Upload
helwan
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
1
Volatile Inhalant Dependence and Intoxication among a Sample of
Egyptian Street Children
*Okasha Y.A. , **Abou-Hatab M.F.
*Yaser Amin Khalifa Okasha: Lecturer of Child Health (Clinical Toxicology)
**Maha Fouad Abou-Hatab: Assistant Professor of Child Health (Child & Adolescent Psychiatry)
Kindergarten Education Department; Faculty of Education, Helwan University
Abstract:
One hundred Subject attending drop out units for street children were investigated using: (1)
Short interview sheet for street children,(2) Inhalant Dependence and Intoxication Checklist for
Street children,(3) Inhalant Dependence and Intoxication diagnostic criteria DSM IV (Diagnostic
and Statistical Manual for Mental Disorders-4th edition) (4) urine screen for hippuric acid; a
metabolite of toluene which is the organic solvent found in glue and other commonly used
inhalants and responsible its side effects . The study aims at identification of common
manifestations of volatile inhalants (glue, fuel, and thinner) dependence and intoxication among
a sample of Egyptian street children. Research subjects were using volatile inhalants (100%)
with variable amounts and sometimes in combination with other substances such as: Nicotine
and Hashish (25%) and oral drugs (cough sedatives) (15%). According to DSM IV criteria,
inhalant dependence and intoxication were reported among all research subjects. Dizziness, in-
coordination, lethargy, slurred speech, tremors, blurred vision and euphoria were the commonly
reported signs of intoxication. Street children diagnosed as intoxicated were vulnerable to many
disadvantages. They are using inhalants despite their knowledge of its harmful effects on
physical and psychological wellbeing. There is a great need to develop integrated rehabilitation
medical services directed towards such vulnerable individuals especially detection, detoxification
and mental health services.
Introduction:
Street children constitute a marginalized population in most urban centers of the world. There are
major difficulties in trying to estimate their number and the magnitude of difficulties they
experience. They are not covered by, nor find a place in: the national census, educational or
health data; largely because they are highly mobile and have no fixed address (UNICEF; 1998).
According to rapid situation assessment report 2001 (RSA), there are between 200,000 and
1,000,000 homeless children in Egypt, most of them in the cities of Cairo and Alexandria. Indeed
the RSA team believed that when all children defined as street children are included, their
numbers exceed one million (WFP, UNCF, UNODC; 2001).
WHO estimates that globally, 25% to 90% of street children indulge in substance use of
psychoactive substances of some kind. The word ‘substance’ describes any psychoactive
material which when consumed affects the way people feel, think, see, taste, smell, hear or
behave. A psychoactive substance can be a medicine or an industrial product, such as glue. Some
2
substances are legal such as approved medicines, alcohol and cigarettes, and others are illegal,
such as heroin and cannabis. Each country has its own laws about substances. The percentage of
substance users among street children varies greatly depending on the region, gender and age
(WHO; 2002).
Inhalation of volatile substances for mind alerting is a long-standing problem in developed
world. Research has shown that volatile substances abuse is primarily an adolescent phenomenon
and it gives rise to dose-related effects similar to those of other hypno-sedatives (UNODC, 2004)
In Egypt, None of the Non Governmental Organizations (NGOs) has a current program targeting
substance abuse among street children, at least at the time when the RSA (2001) was carried out.
Although data received indicated that most street children are substance abusers, the problem has
not been directly targeted. Most reception centers do not admit street children who are under the
effect of drugs, and many NGOs do not permit chronic substance abusers to the centers, even if
not under the effect of the drug for fear that they might interrupt their daily programs. On the
other hand there is no detoxification programs carried out in any of the shelters of the NGOs.
Perhaps this is a main reason for a high rate of escape. As for the Social Defense there is no
program as such. Residential care and control of behavior and activities of children seem to be
the only solutions provided (WFP, UNCF, UNODC; 2001).
According to the pilot study made by researchers prior to conduction of the current research,
there are still no direct services for substance abuse (identification or management) available in
major governmental and non-governmental organizations (GOs & NGOs) targeting street
children in great Cairo.
Aim of the work:
The present study aims at identification of common medical, toxicological, and psychological
manifestations of volatile inhalant dependence and intoxication among a sample of Egyptian
street children.
Subjects and method:
Subjects:
One hundred subject attending drop out units for street children in Helwan, Cairo, Egypt, were
investigated after their legal guardian consent. Inclusion criteria include: cooperative subjects,
attending drop out unit with a positive history of inhalant abuse (glue, fuel, and thinner) within
the last 6 hours, with a positive history of chronic inhalant use and positive detection of hippuric
acid in urine (a metabolite of toluene which is the organic solvent found in glue and other
commonly used inhalants and responsible its side effects), within the last 12 months and
fulfilling assessment at the same day (20 subjects were excluded as they did not show up).
3
Procedures:
Tools:
I. Short interview sheet for street children (made by researchers).
II. Inhalant Dependence and Intoxication Checklist for Street children (made by
researchers).
III. Inhalant Dependence and Intoxication Criteria (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual for
Mental Disorders-4th edition-DSM IV).
IV. Hippuric acid (a metabolite of toluene) detection in urine by visibile absorption
spectrophotometry at 410nm wave length (NIOSH manual, method 8003, 1994).
I- Short interview sheet for street children:
Interview sheet made by researchers for the purpose of the study.It is designed for rapid
collection of important data as regard Personal and family information of the child. Personal
information include: Name, age, sex, education and grade, occupation, duration and frequency of
drop in service use. Family information includes data of mother, father, siblings, other caregivers
(e.g. grandfather, grandmother…etc) as regard: name, age, education, occupation and relation
with the child.
II-Inhalant Dependence and Intoxication Checklist for Street:
It is a self report DSM IV based scale scored Yes/No. A total result is calculated for each subject.
Both the interview sheet and the Inhalant Dependence and Intoxication Checklist for Street
children were judged before there practical use. Items accepted by more than 75% of the judges
were included in the final assessment form.
III-DSM IV criteria for Inhalant Dependence and Intoxication.
A. DSM IV criteria for Inhalant Dependence:
According to DSM IV, subjects should positively experience 3 out of the following:
1. Tolerance as defined by either a or b :(a)A need for markedly increased amounts of the
substance to achieve intoxication or desired effect, (b)Markedly diminished effect with
continued use of the same amount of the substance.
2. Withdrawal as manifested by either a or b: (a) criteria for withdrawal from the
substance, (b) the same or a closely related substance is taken to relieve or avoid
withdrawal symptoms.
3. The substance is often taken in larger amounts or over longer period than was intended.
4. There is persistent desire or unsuccessful efforts to cut down or control substance use.
4
5. A great deal of time is spent in activities necessary to obtain the substance, use the
substance or recover from its effects.
6. Important social, occupational or recreational activities are given up or reduced because
of substance use.
7. The substance use is continued despite knowledge of having a persistent or recurrent
physical or psychological problem that is likely to have been caused or exacerbated by
the substance.
B. DSM IV criteria for Inhalant Intoxication:
According to DSM IV, diagnostic criteria for inhalant intoxication include 3 major items, as well
as the at least 2 of the signs that develop during or shortly after inhalant use or exposure. They
are as follows:
I. Recent intentional use or short-term, high-dose exposure to volatile inhalants.
II. Clinically significant maladaptive behavioral or psychological changes (e.g. belligerence,
assaultiveness, apathy, impaired judgment, impaired social or occupational functioning)
that developed during or shortly after use of or exposure to volatile inhalants.
III. Two (or more) of the following symptoms, developing during, or shortly after, inhalant
use or exposure:
1. Dizziness
2. Nystagmus
3. In coordination
4. Slurred speech
5. Unsteady gait
6. Lethargy
7. Depressed reflexes
8. Psychomotor retardation
9. Tremor
10. Generalized muscle weakness
11. Blurred vision or diplopia
12. Stupor or coma
13. euphoria
IV. The symptoms are not due to general medical condition and are not better accounted for
by another mental disorder (Need more detailed investigations and was excluded as part
of diagnoses).
5
Method:
Descriptive analysis of the data collected was used for more identification of the phenomena of
inhalant dependence and intoxication among research subjects.
Results:
One hundred subjects, aged 9-17 years were investigated. They started inhalants abuse from the
age of 7 to the age of 12. Eighty percent were school dropout (from early school grades: 1st - 5
th
primary) and 20% were illiterate. They stated using inhalants for a duration range 2-7
years.100% were inhalant users as proved by positive detection of hippuric acid in their urine
samples, 60% reported using inhalants alone and 40% in combination. 25% were inhalant users
in combination with nicotine and hashish and 15%with oral drugs (Table-1).
According to DSM IV Volatile Inhalants Dependence and Intoxication were reported among all
research subjects (100%). Tolerance (with physiological dependence) was also reported among
all research subjects (100%).As all subjects under consideration experienced a need for markedly
increased amounts of the substance to achieve intoxication or desired effect (100%) as well as
markedly diminished effect of the substance with continued use of the same amount (Table-2).
Ninety percent of research subjects use the same substance (glue) or a closely related substance
(fuel, thinner) to relieve or avoid withdrawal symptoms (Table-2).
Inhalants were often taken in larger amounts or over longer period than intended among (72%)
of research subjects. The substance is often taken in larger amounts than was intended among
(54%) and was used for longer period among (18%) of subjects under consideration (Table-2).
Unsuccessful efforts to cut down or control substance use was reported only among (20%) of
research subjects. On the other hand, none of them reported that there was a great deal of time
spent to obtain inhalants although use and recovery may take some time (40%). Social,
occupational malfunction were reported among all of them in different forms (100%). They were
using inhalants despite recurrent exposure to physical and mental problems because of the use of
the substance (100%) (Table-2) .
Maladaptive changes and symptoms characteristic of inhalant intoxication that developed during
or shortly after glue sniffing commonly reported were: Dizziness, in-coordination, lethargy,
slurred speech, tremors, blurred vision and euphoria (Table-3).
Discussion:
Inhalant abuse is a major public health problem that has been associated with numerous acute
and chronic medical problems. Inhalants are defined as volatile organic substances, found in
common household and commercial products that are easily accessible, inexpensive, and legally
6
obtained. Inhalants have been labeled as gateway drugs. Significant social, economic, and
medical consequences are associated with their use (Meadows and Varghese, 1996).
Although early reports have linked inhalant abuse to poor school adjustment, with high truancy
and dropout rates, increased criminal activity, and an elevated incidence of psychopathology
(Oetting and Webb 1988). The problem of early childhood substance use is out of organized
Governmental Organizations (GOs) and Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs) services.
Almost none of the major NGOs working with street children in Egypt have a current organized
program directly targeting the issue of substance use and detoxication.
However volatile substances (e.g. fuel, paint, Kolla….) were classified as inhalants if they were
used for the purpose of being intoxicated ( American Psychiatric Association;1994). All of the
research subjects were inhalant users for many reasons especially reaching euphoric mood,
headedness, pain and cold relief, and induction of sleep. 60% of them were using inhalants alone
and 40% in combination.
Research subjects with an average age 14.5 were using inhalants for a duration range 2-7 years.
They started substance use from the age of 7 to the age of 12. According to Mith Samlah/Friends
survey (2001); multi-drug use continued to increase sharply as older boys (over 16 years) are the
ones using the most different substances with a significant increase in the use of 3 and more
different drugs. However, a slight increase in the use of other substances as well as younger
children involvement, seem to indicate that children are always experimenting new substances. It
is, therefore, possible that substance use will continue to increase and community is increasingly
facing problems and disturbances from young boys under influence.
The relationship between the use of solvents and other drugs is a complex one. Although a
possibility can be linked, research is unable to answer if the use of solvents leads to abuse of
more potent addictive drugs in the future or not (Ginzler etal 2003). However research subjects
reported the use of the same inhalants in an increasing amount and the use of other oral drugs or
addictive substances to decrease negative effects or relief symptoms especially aches.
Evidence of recent intake of the substance can be obtained from history, physical examination
and toxicological analysis of body fluids (urine-blood).However it is accessible to obtain rapid
history and do physical examination at drop out units although some individuals seem
uncooperative. On the other hand toxicological analysis was reported not to be easily available at
drop out units because of refusal of street children to offer blood samples easily. On the other
hand, direct assay for inhalants is rarely used clinically and is generally not a part of routine
screening for drugs of abuse (American Psychiatric Association; 1994).
Acute intoxication from inhalation primarily affects the CNS, causing euphoria, dizziness,
confusion, CNS depression, headache, vertigo, hallucinations, seizures, ataxia, tinnitus, optic
neuropathy, peripheral neuropathy, stupor, and coma (Martin, 2006). According to American
Psychiatric Association (1994), intoxication symptoms include disturbance of: perception,
7
wakefulness, attention, thinking, judgment, psychomotor and interpersonal behavior. Impairment
in cognitions or mood is the most common symptoms associated with toxic substances. Although
hallucinations, delusions or seizures can result, symptoms usually disappear when individual is
no longer exposed to the substance but resolution of symptoms may take weeks or months and
may require treatment. Many of such symptoms were reported among research subjects
especially Dizziness, in-coordination, lethargy, slurred speech, tremors, blurred vision and
euphoria.
The majority of short term effects of inhalants reported by the responding children in Nepal were
hallucinations. Various experiences such as illusions of seeing actors, seeing money, being able
to talk with gods and the like were the most popular immediate experiences accounted by street
children after glue sniffing (Abinash etal, 2002).
Substance intoxication is mostly involved by dose, duration, chronicity of dosing, personal
variability , personal tolerance for the substance, period of time since the last dose and the
expectations of the person as to the substance’s effects and the environment or setting in which
the substance was taken (American Psychiatric Association-1994).Small doses can rapidly lead
to euphoria and other disturbances of behavior similar to those caused by ethanol(alcohol) and
may also induce delusions and hallucinations(UNODC,2004).
Both dose and duration of use of inhalants and other substances used with them in combination
were variable among research subjects.90% of research subjects were using inhalants and other
drugs for the last 2 years almost on daily basis. Most commonly inhalants are used in group
setting using and increasing the dose according to street circumstances and targeting euphoric
mood and headedness.
Information gathered from the key informant interviews, documented a very unsatisfactory
knowledge and awareness of issues related to street children, and more importantly the
understanding of solvent abuse among this extremely high-risk group. An overall lack of clarity
was observed regarding detoxification of solvent abuse in the existing drug treatment facilities,
compounded by absolutely no rehabilitation program for these children (UNODC, 2004)
Further research should encounter the role of antioxidant therapy or supplementation in children
with inhalant abuse considering the possible consequences of oxidative damage and lipid
peroxidation, including the risk of severe damage to various tissues and organs such as bone
marrow, liver, kidney, brain, and heart (Ruþen etal, 2003).
Conclusion and Recommendations:
Research subjects using inhalants, diagnosed as inhalant dependent and intoxicated according to
DSM IV. They were inhalant users alone or in combination. Regardless their negative effects on
their physical and mental wellbeing they were continuously using such substances. Dizziness,
hallucinations (especially visual hallucinations) in-coordination, lethargy, slurred speech,
8
tremors, blurred vision and euphoria were the commonly experienced symptoms of volatile
inhalant intoxication. There is a great need to develop integrated rehabilitation medical services
within drop out units for street children including mental health and detoxification services.
Table (1): Socio-demographic data and substances used: characteristics among research
subjects
Age range 9-17 Mean:14.5
Items number %
*Educational background
-Dropped out school
-Never been to school
80
20
80%
20%
*Characteristics of Substances used
-Inhalants
-Inhalants alone(glue)
-Inhalants in combination(fuel, thinner)
-Inhalants in combination with nicotine and hashish
-Inhalants in combination with oral drugs(cough sedatives)
100
60
40
25
15
100%
60%
40%
25%
15%
Table (2): Inhalant dependence according to DSM IV among research subjects
DSM IV criteria-Inhalant Dependence number %
1-Tolerance
1-1 A need for markedly increased amounts of the substance to
achieve intoxication or desired effect
100 100%
1-2 Markedly diminished effect with continued use of the same
amount of the substance.
100 100%
2-Withdrwal 90 90%
2-1 Criteria for withdrawal from the substance 0 0%
2-2 The same or a closely related substance is taken to relieve or
avoid withdrawal symptoms.
90 90%
3-Larger amount/longer time of use 72 72%
3-1 The substance is often taken in larger amounts than was
intended.
54 54%
3-2 The substance is often taken over longer period than was
intended.
18 18%
4-Unsuccessful efforts to control volatile inhalant use 20 20%
5-A great deal of time is spent in activities necessary to obtain the
substance, use the substance or recover from its effects.
40 40%
5-1 Great time spent to obtain volatile inhalants 0 0%
5-2 Great time spent in use/recovery from volatile inhalant effects 40 40%
6-Social, occupational malfunction 100 100%
7-The substance use is continued despite knowledge of having a
persistent or recurrent physical or psychological problem that is
likely to have been caused or exacerbated by the substance.
100 100%
9
Table (3): Inhalant intoxication according to DSM IV among research subjects
DSM IV criteria-Inhalant Intoxication number %
A-Recent intentional use of volatile inhalants 100 100%
B-Maladaptive changes after use of volatile inhalants 100 100%
C-Two or more Signs of volatile inhalant use 100 100%
D-The symptoms are not due to general medical or mental problem Need more
detailed
investigations
References:
1. Abinash R., Keshab P., Pooja S., Sumnima T.(2002):Glue sniffing among street children
in Kathmandu Valley. Child workers in Nepal(CWIN).Indreni offset press. Anamnagar,
Kathmandu.
2. Abou-Hatab M.F. (2004): Street Children: Children at risk for Psycho-social
Disadvantages. Current Psychiatry; March 2004.
3. American Psychiatric Association (A.P.A) (1994): Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of
Mental Disorders-4th edition (DSM IV). Washington DC.
4. Ginzler JA, Cochran BN etal (2003): Sequential progression of substance use among
homeless youth: An empirical investigation of the gateway theory. Substance use misuse.
Feb-May 38(3-6):725-58.
5. Martin K.A. (2006): Toluene Toxicity. http://emedicine.medscape.com-article-
818939/overview.
6. Lee XP, Kumazawa T, Sato K, et al.(1998) Determination of solvent thinner components
in human body fluids by capillary gas chromatography with trapping at low oven
temperature for headspace samples. Analyst;123: 147-150.
7. Meadows R, Verghese A. (1996): Medical complications of glue sniffing. South Med J;
89:455-462.
8. Mith Samlah/Friends survey (2001): Substance use among street children in Phnom
Penh. Drug program Supported by the European Community (EC).
9. NIOSH Manual of Analytical Methods (NMAM), Fourth Edition, 8/15/94:method 8003.
10. Oetting E.R, Webb J.(1988): Social and psychological factors underlying inhalant abuse.
Epidemiology of Inhalant Abuse: An Update. Crider RA, Rouse BA (eds). NIDA
research monograph series no. 85, DHHS publication ADM 88-1577. Washington, DC,
Department of Health and Human Services, 1988, pp 172-203
11. Ruþen D, Tümer T, Cemal A, S. Ümit S, Ahmet A ,Metin D, Erdal G(2003):Antioxidant
enzymes and lipid peroxidation in adolescents with inhalant abuse .The Turkish Journal
of Pediatrics; 45: 43-45
12. UNICEF (1998): Children at Risk: United Nations, New York 1998.
10
13. UNODC (2004): Solvent abuse among street children in Pakistan. United Nations system
in Pakistan - Islamabad.
14. WFP, UNCF, UNODC (2001): World Food Program [WFP], United Nations Children’s
Fund [UNCF], United Nations Office for Drug Control and Crime Prevention [UNODC]:
Rapid situation assessment (RSA) report: The situation of street children in Cairo and
Alexandria, including the children’s drug abuse and health/nutritional status-Cairo.
15. World Health Organization-WHO (2000) Report “Module I”: A profile of street children:
Working with street children: Street children intervention. World Health Organization-
Mental Health Determinants and populations, Department of Mental Health and
Substance Dependence Geneva, Switzerland.
16. World Health Organization-WHO (2002) Report “Module 3”: Understanding Substance
Use among Street Children. A Training Package on Substance Use, Sexual and
Reproductive Health including HIV/AIDS and STDs. World Health Organization -
Division of Mental Health: Evidence and Research, Department of Mental Health and
Substance Dependence Geneva, Switzerland.
االعتماد والسمية للمواد الطيارة لدى عينة من أطفال الشوارع المصريين
مها فؤاد عبد اللطيف أبوحطب** ,ياسر أمين خليفة عكاشة *
(ى لألطفالالطب النفس)ستاذ مساعد صحة الطفلأ**-(السموم االكلينيكية)مدرس صحة الطفل*
جامعة حلوان-كلية التربية-رياض األطفالقسم
تهدف هذه الدراسة الوصفية الى معرفة الخصائص المميزة لالعتماد والسمية للمواد الطيارة لدى عينة من
طفل من االطفال المترددين على مراكز االستقبال الخاصة 011تم دراسة وقد.أطفال الشوارع فى مصر
(ناعداد الباحثي(ألطفال الشوارع استمارة المقابلة المختصرة(0): باستخدام كل منبأطفال الشوارع
لمحكات التشخيصية الخاصة باالعتماد ا (3)،(اعداد الباحثين)ألطفال الشوارع والسميةقائمة االعتماد (2)،
مسح لعينات البول الكتشاف حمض (4) ، (الدليل التشخيصى االحصائى الرابع) والسمية للمواد الطيارة
لوين و هو المذيب العضوي المسستخدم في هذه المواد منتجات االيض لمركب التو هو أحد الذي الهيبيوريك
" بكميات متفاوتة وأحيانا%(011)مستخدمة من قبل جميع األطفال عينة الدراسة الموادهذه وكانت . الطيارة
طفال جميع األ استوفى وقد %(.02)والعقاقير %(22)حشيش والسجائريتم االستخدام مع مواد أخرى مثل ال
للدليل التشخيصى " تبعالكل من االعتماد والسمية للمواد الطيارة التشخيصيهلمحكات اعينة الدراسة
عدم -الدوخة:وكان من أهم أعراض السمية للمواد الطيارة التى توصلت اليها الدراسة.االحصائى الرابع
ارتفاع الحالة -الرؤية الغير واضحة-ارتجاف االطراف-الكالم الغيرواضح-النعاس-الحركىالتناسق
يخبرون العديد من همأن هؤالء األطفال يستخدمون المواد الطيارة مع أن" وقد كان واضحا.المزاجية
ل متضمنة وقد بات من المؤكد ضرورة اقامة خدمة طبية متكاملة لهؤالء األطفا.المشكالت الصحية والنفسية
.خدمات الصحة النفسية وعالج التسمم