central administrative tribunal

1 OA 404/2017

CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL AHMEDABAD BENCH, AHMEDABAD.

O.A.No.404/2017

Ahmedabad, this the 22d day of February, 2018

Coram :

Hon’ble Dr. K.B.Suresh, Member (J)

Hon’ble Shri K.N.Shrivastava, Member (A)

1. Chandragupt Singh Rathore, Aged 36 years

Working as Inspector of Central Excise,

S/o Late Shri Rajendra Singh Rathore,

Residing at : Flat No. 5, Pramukh Residency,

Hira Kiran Apartment,

Halar Road, Valsad

2 Yogesh Kumar Razak, Aged – 31 years

Working as Inspector of Central Excise

S/o Sh. Ratan Prakash Verma

Residing at : 28, Vastav Park,

Roffel College Road, Nr. Janseva Hospital,

Vapi Town, Disit. Valsad

3 Rakesh Kumar, Aged – 35 years


S/o Sh. Sunil Kumar Singh

Residing at : F. No.A1-601,

Pramukh Oracle, Dungar Falia,

Near Dabhel Check Post,

Vapi

4 Avinash Rawat, Aged – 32 years


S/o Sh. Dharm Singh Rawat

Residing at : Viola-605, Park City,

Opposite Yogi Hospital, Kilwani Naka,

Silvassa

5. Arjun Singh, Aged – 35 years


S/o Sh. Lakshman Singh

Residing at : F. No.C-1/206,

2 OA 404/2017

Yogi Hills, Basera Road,

Amli, Silvassa

6. Kaushal Kishore, Aged 38 years


S/o Shri NaveenKumar Gupta,

Residing at : B 302, Shree Ganesh App.,

Krishna Colony, Muktanand Marg,

Challa, Vapi

7. Naveen Kumar, Aged 33 years


Son of Shri Ayodhya Prasad

Residing at : Flat No.105,

Anmol Apartment, Behind Mahesh Bhawan,

Muktanand Marg, Challa, Vapi

8. Prem Prakash Meena, Aged 33 years


Son of Shri Ram Kishan Meena

Residing at : F. No.A-806, Subham tower-3,

Vapi-Daman Road, Challa, Vapi

9. Suresh Chand Meena, Aged 33 years


Son of Shri Ramesh Chand Meena

Residing at : I-604, Pramukh Residency,

Challa, Vapi

10. Mahendra Kumar Meena, Aged 37 years


Son of Shri Hari Narayan Meena

Residing at : F. No.C-706, Subham Tower-3,


11. Sandeep Kumar, Aged 37 years


Son of Shri Danendra P.D. Singh

Residing at : A-607, Arihant Enclave,

Near Jan Seva Hospital, Vapi

12. Amit Kumar Meena, Aged 32 years


Son of Shri Umedi Lal Meena

Residing at : F. No.A-106, Shivalik Heights,

Swaminarayan Road, Challa, Vapi

3 OA 404/2017

13. Sajid Hussain, Aged 36 years


S/o Shri Moajjam Hussain

Residing at : F. No.B-407, Nity Park,

Customs Road, Challa, Vapi

14. Dheeraj Kumar, Aged 36 years


S/o Shri Jai Prakash Chandak

F. No.A1-204, Pramukh Oracle,

Dungar Falia, Near Dabhal Check Post,

Vapi

15. Gopesh Kumar, Aged 33 years


S/o Shri Shashi Bhushan Prasad Yadav

Residing at : 803, B1, Pramukh Oracle,

Daman Road, Challa, Vapi

16. Munna Kumar, Aged 36 years


S/o Shri Chandradeo Singh

Residing at : B2/503, Pramukh Oracle,

Daman Road, Challa, Vapi

17. Ved Prakash Meena, Aged 29 years


S/o Shri Ratan Singh Meena

Residing at : C-407, Shubham Tower-3,


18. Shri Manoj Kumar Meena, Aged 34 years


S/o Shri Mathura Prasad Meena

Residing at : Pramukh Residency,

Flat No. 401-A, Challa, ,

Vapi-Daman Road,Vapi

19. Ashok Kumar Meena, Aged 36 years


S/o Shri Narayan Lal Meena

Residing at : I-605, Pramukh Residency,

Daman Road, Chala,

Vapi

20. Rakesh Prasad, Aged 36 years


4 OA 404/2017

S/o Shri Sitaram Prasad,

Residing at : B2/702, Pramukh Greens,

Chala, Vapi

21. Manish Kumar Nougriya, Aged 36 years


S/o Shri Prahlad Prasad Nougriya,

Residing at : F. No.C-1/303, Yogi Hills,

Basera Road, Amli, Silvassa

22. Prem Prakash Dencherwal, Aged 32 years


S/o Shri Jagdish Prasad Meena

Resinding at : B-503, Ishan Apartment,

Vashi falia, Halar, Valsad

23. Arun Kumar, Aged 35 years


S/o Shri Som Prakash Agarwal

Residing at : E-202, Krutik, Nakshtra Heights,

B/h Gorwa Workshop,

Gorwa, Vadodara

24. Om Prakash Meena, Aged 32 years


S/o Shri Jasram Meena

Residing at : Plot No. 142,

Ward No. 7B, Gurukul,

Gandhidham, Gujarat

25. Rakesh Kumar Jajoria, Aged – 31 years


s/o Shri Banshidhar Jajoria

Residing at : Q. No. 122, Type-3,

Central Revenue Colony, Vadodara

26. Vikas Shukla, Aged – 36 years


S/o Shri P.N. Shukla



27. Amit Kumar Mishra, Aged – 31 years


S/o Shri Akhilesh Mishra

Residing at : 21, Tulsidham Society,

High Tension Road, Subhanpura, Vadodara

5 OA 404/2017

28. Prameshwar Pramanik, Aged – 36 years


S/o Shri Tewari Pramanik

Residing at : 98, Kanha Residency, Nr. St. Basil School,

Opp. Voltamp, Maneja, Vadodara

29. Sarvesh Kumar Singh, Aged – 37 years


S/o Lt. Shri Ram Ishwar Singh



30. Kanwaljit Singh, Aged – 39 years


S/o Lt. Shri Harjit Singh

Residing at : Q. No.111, Type-3,


31. Akhilesh Kumar Gupta, Aged – 31 years


S/o Shri P.L. Gupta

Residing at : 504, K, Tower, Gunatit Residency,

Near Gotri Pond, B/h Gayatri Nagar Watertank,

Gotri, Vadodara

32. Yogesh Damachya, Aged – 30 years


S/o Shri Jamna Lal Meena



33. Deepak Kumar, Aged – 36 years


S/o Late Shri mahesh Mishra

Residing at : E-203, Earth Acropolis-3,

Vasna- Bhayali Road, Behind- Bright Day School,

Vadodara-390012

34. Sandeep, Aged – 33 years


S/o Shri Ramnivas


Central Revenue Colony,

Race Course, Vadodara

35. Vinod Kumar, Aged – 36 years

6 OA 404/2017


S/o Late Gokhula Prasad Singh



Race Course, Vadodara

36. Abhishek Shrivastawa, Aged – 36 Years


S/o Shri Harendra Prasad,

Residing at : Flat No. 203, White House Apartment,

Street No. 3, Navanagar Wada,

Junagadh – 362001

37. Vikash Kumar Srivastava, Aged – 39 years


S/o Shri D.N. Prasad,

Residing at : C-501, Samarpan Heights,

Jahangirpura Ugat Canal Road, Surat – 395005

38. Rahul Kumar, Aged – 35 Years


S/o Shri Navin Mohan Prasad,

Residing at : C/1-12, BSNL Colony, Ghod Dod Road,

Surat – 395007

39. Vikas Gupta, Aged – 36 years


S/o Shri Vijay Kumar Gupta,

Residing at : Flat No. A2/204, Smeet Residency,

Near Mathura Nagari, Palanpur Gam, Surat.

40. Amresh Ranjan, Aged 37 years


S/o Shri Upendra Prasad Bharti,

Residing at : House No. 401, Sterling Heights,

Ugat Canal Road, Jahangirabad, Surat.

41. Neha Goel, Aged – 31 years


Daughter of Shri Arun Kumar Goel,

Residing at : A-403, Stuti Arista, Palanpur,

Surat – 395005

42. Ankur Sinha, Aged – 35 years


S/o Satyendra Prasad Sinha,

Residing at : A-301, Stuti Arista, Palanpur,

7 OA 404/2017

Surat – 395009

43. Ujjawal Kumar, Aged 34 years


S/o Shri Uday Nath Prasad,

Residing at : A-1/101, Sai Milan Residency,

Palanpur Gam, Surat

44. Chander Deo Bharti, Aged 36 years


S/o Shri Sadanand Mehta,

Residing at : Vaishnodevi Township,

Near B.R. Park Society, Jahangirpura, Surat.

45. Gopal Lal, Aged – 39 years


S/o Shri Nathu Lal,

Residing at : 17, Tirupati Balaji Society,

Opp. Bhoomi Complex, Adajan, Surat – 395009

46. Narendra Kumar, Aged – 30 years


S/o Shri Gopi Ram,

Residing at : E-304, Shreepad Ethics, B/h Raj World

Shopping Centre, Palanpor gam, Surat 395009

47. Rajesh Bhati, Aged : 39 years


s/o Shri Ram Chandra Bhati

Residing at : R-404, Vaishnodevi Township,

Near B.R. Park Society, Jahangirpura, Surat.

48. Avinash Kumar, Aged 36 years


S/o Shri Pramod Kumar Verma,

Residing at : A-604, Shree Raj Residency,

Nr. Parshuram Garden, Adajan, Surat.

49. Sanjay Kumar, Aged -45 years


S/o Shri Ramashish Choudhary,

Residing at : F-101, Smeet Residency, T.P. 09,

Palanpur Gam, Surat.

50. Vijay Parashar, Aged 39 years


S/o Shri Suresh Chandra Sharma,

8 OA 404/2017

Residing at : C-801, Shree Sai Residency,

Near Parshuram Garden, Adajan,

Surat – 395009

51. Aditya Pande, Aged 32 years

Working as Inspector of Central excise,

S/o Late Shri Jagdish Chandra Pande,

Residing at A-102, Sainath Plaza,

Rajesh Tower Road, Gotri, Vadodara.

52. Jaya Pandey, Aged 33 years


Daughter of Shri Dinesh Chandra Pandey,

Residing at A-102, Sainath Plaza,

Rajesh Tower Road, Gotri, Vadodara.

53. Subodh Kumar, Aged 41 years


S/o Shri Kameshwar Prasad Singh,

Residing at : Qtr.No. 303/Type-III,

Central Revenue Colony, Race Course Circle,

Vadodara.

54. Vinay Kumar Soni, Aged 38 years


S/o Shri Purushottam Das Soni,

Residing at : House No. 05, Neelkanth Bunglows,

Plot No. 248/249, Ward 10A, Gurukul Area,

Gandhidham (Kutch), Gujarat

55. Pradeep Meena, Aged 31 years


S/o Shri Ramroop Meena,

Residing at : S4, Mansi Flat, Plot No. 118-119,

Ward 7B, Gurukul, Gandhidham (kutch)

Gujarat

56. Badram Meena, Aged 38 years


S/o Shri Ranjeet Meena,

Residing at : S4, Mansi Flat, Plot No. 118-119,

Ward 7B, Gurukul, Gandhidham (kutch)

Gujarat

57. Shilpi Pathak, Aged 35 years


D/o Shri Brajesh Narayan,

9 OA 404/2017

Residing at : Type 3/112, Central Revenue Colony,

Race Course Circle, Vadodara

58. Sheo Shankar Kumar, Aged 35 years


S/o. Shri Surajmal Prasad

Residing at Flat No.101A, Sankalp Flats

Near Munni Dairy, Airport Road, Bhavnagar.

59. Siddhartha Tiwari, Aged 30 Years


S/o Shri Jainath Prasad Tiwari

Residing at: B-2/704, Nakshatra Platinum,

Palanpur Gam Road, Surat-395009.

60. Sarikakumari A. K. Singh, Aged 35 Years


D/o Shri A. K. Singh

Residing at: E-102, Jasan Residency,

Chanakyapuri, Near Sama Road,

Vadodara.

61. Dhiraj Kumar Jha, Aged 34 Years

Working as Preventive Officer,

S/o Shri Late Vishwanath Jha

Residing at: 105/Type-III


Race Course, Vadodara.

62. Gaurav Srivastava, Aged 40 Years

Working as Preventive Officer

S/o. Shri Ramprakash Srivastava

Residing at : H.N.-11, Shiv |Township,

Mundra Gandhidham road, Mundra.

63. Ravi Kumar Gupta, Aged 34 Years


S/o Shri Ram Lal Gupta

Residing at: 7, Manoratham Bunglow, Nr. Dahej Bypass,

Shravan Chokadi, Bharuch-392001.

64. Mukesh Kumar Jha, Aged 37 Years


S/o Shri Ganesh Jha

Residing at: A-2/97, Om Bunglows,

Laxmipura-Godba Road,

10 OA 404/2017

Vadodara 390 016.

65. Praveen Kumar Mishra, Aged 33 Years


S/o Shri Subhash Mishra,

Residing at: Plot No.: 252, Gurukul,

Gandhidham-370201

66. Pankaj Kumar Singh Gautam, Aged 37 Years


S/o Shri Gauri Shankar Singh

Residing at: D-804, Stuti Arista,

Nr. New L. P. Savani School,

Palanpur, Surat

67. Rajeev Kapoor, Aged 36 Years


S/o Shri Jai Prakash Mehta,

Residing at: C-61, Vishwanath Township,

Near-Tulsidham Sabji Market, Bharuch-392001.

68. Abhishek Shukla, Aged 41 Years


S/o Shri Tirth Ram Shukla




69. Ratnakar Jha, Aged 38 Years


S/o Shri Babu Lal Jha

Residing at: 202/ New Alkapuri Residency

Gotri-Sevasi Road, Vadodara.

70. Sneha Sanjay Handa, Aged 32 Years


D/o Late Jamuna Prasad

Residing at: K-402, Sterling Heights, Ugat Canal Road,

Palanpur, Surat

71. Chitendra Singh Chahar, Aged 38 Years


S/o Shri Suraj Bhan Chahar

Residing at: D-202, Brahma Residency

New Alkapuri, Gotri, Vadodara.

72. Amit Kumar Mishra, Aged 34 Years

11 OA 404/2017


S/o Shri Krishna Kant Mishra,

Residing at: Flat No.: 5, Balaji Enclave,

Plot No.: 1, Sector-2,

Near IFFCO,Gandhidham-370203

73. Aditya Kumar, Aged 32 Years


S/o Shri Jalim Prasad Gupta

Residing at: J-402, Sterling Heights,

Ugat Canal Road,

Palanpur, Surat

74 Harindra Kumar Yadav, Aged 35 Years


S/o Shri Rajaram Yadav

Residing at: J-402, Sterling Heights,

Ugat Canal Road,

Palanpur, Surat

75. Kamruzzma Ansari, Aged 35 Years


S/o Shri Mehmood Hussain Ansari




76. Ram Singh, Aged 37 Years


S/o Shri Ganpat Ram,

Residing at: D-303, Stuti Arista,

Nr. New L. P. Savani School,

Palanpur, Surat

77. Rahul Sihag, Aged 35 Years


S/o Shri Shivpal Singh Sihag

Residing at: 404, Nakshtra Height,

Nr. Jamnotri Party Plot,

Sama-Savali Road, Vadodara

78. Anand Jaiswal, Aged 30 Years


S/o Shri Durga Prasad Jaiswal

Residing at: 202, Rajhans Campus,

Pal-Hazira Road, Surat

12 OA 404/2017

79. Amarjit Kumar, Aged 34 Years

Working as Intelligence Officer,

S/o Shri Rajkumar Prasad

Residing at: F/301, Shridhar Residency,

B/h. Sun Pharma R.& D, Vadodara.

80. Rajeshwer Prakash Gupta, Aged 43 Years


S/o Shri Sharda Prasad Gupta

Residing at: J-302, Vaishnodevi Township,

Jahangirpura, Surat-395009.

81. Mukesh Kumar, Aged 34 Years


S/o Shri Manbodh Kumar,

Residing at: Flat No.: 8, Balaji Enclave,

Plot No.: 1, Sector-2,

Near IFFCO,Gandhidham-370203

82. Hariom, Aged 34 Years


S/o Shri Rakshpal

Residing at: H-303, Sterling Heights, Ugat Canal Road,

Palanpur, Surat

83. Manoj Kumar Yadav, Aged 34 Years


S/o Shri Anant Prasad Singh

Residing at: Plot No.: 141, Tenament No.: 4,

Ward-7B,Gurukul, Gandhidham

84 Devendra Singh, Aged 30 Years


S/o Shri Bannedan Ujjawal

Residing at: Near Gurukul School, Gandhidham

85. Manohar Kumar, Aged 37 Years


S/o Shri Ram Narayan Shah

Residing at: House No.: 10, Shiv Township,

Mundra-Gandhidham Road, Mundra.

86. Rohan Arora, Aged 30 Years


S/o Shri Nandlal Arora

Residing at: C-101, Nandanvan-3, Nr. Nandini Apartment,

Vesu-Abhva Road, Vesu, Surat-395007.

13 OA 404/2017

87. Rajeev Guggal, Aged 32 Years


S/o Shri Ved Prakash

Residing at: A-303, Sanghat Residency,

Nr. Aagam Shopping World,

Vesu, Surat-395007.

88. Ravindra Kumar, Aged 36 years


S/o Shri Kailash Singh,

Residing at : A-102, Stuti Apartment,

Nr. Maheswari Bhawan, Muktanand marg,

Chala Vapi

89. Abhishek Mishra, Aged 33 years


S/o Shri Ramroop Mishra,

Residing at : A-1/304, Pramukh Oracle,

Nr. Daman Gate, Chala, Vapi

90. Anita Meena, Aged 31 years


Daughter of Shri Kailash Chandra Meena,

Residing at : 12, Sajni Row House,

B/h Shivalik Heights,

Swaminarayan Gurukul Road,

Chala, Vapi

91. Uma Nath Choudhary, Aged 36 years,


S/o Shri Shreedeo Chaudhary

Residing at : K-301, Sun Residency,

Daman Road, Chala, Vapi

92. Sandip Kumar, Aged 35 years


S/o Shri Ramchandra Singh,

Residing at : H-204, Sun Residency,

Daman Road, Chala, Vapi

93. Hans Ram Meena, Aged 27 years


S/o Shri Madan Lal Meena

Residing at : D-903, Pramukh Sahaj,

Muktanand Marg, Chala, Vapi

14 OA 404/2017

94. Praveen Kumar Meena, Aged 31 years


S/o Shri Kunjilal Meena

Residing at : D-803, Pramukh Sahaj,

Muktanand Marg, Chala, Vapi

95. Goutam Govinda, Aged 34 Years


S/o Shri Akhil Anand Pandey

Residing at: D-304, Stuti Icon,

Palanpur Gam Road, Surat-395009

96. Rajesh Kumar, Aged 42 years,

Working as Intelligence Officer,

S/o Late Shri Gopal Shah

Residing at: 201, Gunatit Residency,

Nr. Gayatri School, Gotri, Vadodara.

97. Praveen Kumar


S/o Shri Bhagwat Prasad

Residing at: Tenament-1, Plot No.197, Ward-10A,

Gurukul, Gadhidham.

98. Jay Prakash Singh, Aged 323 years,


S/o Shri Ram Chandra Singh

Residing at: Plot No.9/A, Samarpan Society,

Street No.1, Raiya Road,

Rajkot. 360 007. ………………………………………..…... Applicants

(By Advocate : Shri Prithu Parimal )

Versus

1. Union of India,

(Through the Revenue Secretary,

Government of India,

Ministry of Finance,

Department of Revenue,

North Block,

New Delhi – 110 001.)

2. The Chairman,

Central Board of Excise & Customs,

North Block,

New Delhi 110 001.

15 OA 404/2017

3. Chief Commissioner,

Central Excise, Customs & Service Tax,

Vadodara Zone,

2nd

Floor, Central Excise Building,

Race Course Circle,

Vadodara – 390 007.

4. Vyas Sanjaykumar J.

Working as Superintendent

in Chief Commissioner Office,

GST Bhavan,

Near Polytechnic Ambavadi,

Amhedabad – 380015

5. Varia Jashvant R.


in Vadodara Audit Commissionrate,

Central Excise Building,

Subhanpura, Vadodara 390023

6. Patel Hirenkumar J.


in Vadodara II - GST Commissionrate,



7. Joshi Tejash Arvindkumar



GST Bhavan,


Ahmedabad – 380015

8. Vyas Deepak R.



GST Bhavan,



9. Shaikh Khurshid S.


in Vadodara I - GST Commissionrate,


Race course Circle, Vadodara 390007

16 OA 404/2017

10. Joshi Tapas R.



GST Bhavan,



11. Patel Bharatkumar Ravindrabhai





12. Shaikh Abdulwahid N.


in Chief Commissioner Office Vadodara,



13. Raj Narendra P.





14. Chauhan Manishkumar Pramodbhai





15 Gohel Paresh V.



GST Bhavan,



16. Bhalsod Uttam R.



GST Bhavan,



17. Dolia Vivek G.

17 OA 404/2017





18 Desai Jigneshkumar J.


in Audit Surat Commissionrate,

GST Bhavan, Magnnus 4th Floor,

Althan Bhimrad Canal Road,

Althan, Surat 395017

19. Patil Rajnanda D.

(Smt. Rajnanda k. Mohite)





20. Patel Deepakkumar M.





21. Dharaiya Sanjay Natvarlal



GST Bhavan,



22. Raj Mustak Allauddin





23. Ratna Hemantsinh H.



GST Bhavan,



24. Mujaria Pritiben A.


18 OA 404/2017

in Surat - GST Commissionrate,

New Central Excise Building,

Opp Gandhi Baug,

Chowk Bazaar, Surat 395001

25. Atul Bhagwanjibhai Sejpal



GST Bhavan,



26. Shaikh Zakirhusain M.





27. Devarukhkar Bimal Vinod



GST Bhavan,



28. Vyas Chetan H.



GST Bhavan,



29. Malcolm Dadi Bhathena


in Audit Surat Commissionrate,

GST Bhavan, Magnnus 4th Floor,

Althan Bhimrad Canal Road,

Althan, Surat 395017

30. Mehta Janak Rashmikant




Opp Gandhi Baug,


31. Ms. Jani Yogita K.

19 OA 404/2017



GST Bhavan,



32. Bhandodkar Jagrutiben Khandubhai

(Smt. Jagruti Bharatkumar Patel)





33. Chauhan Dipak Mohanlal



GST Bhavan,



34. Shaikh Mohd. Amin M.


in C.C.O Vadodara,



35. Ms. Joshi Manisha P.



GST Bhavan,



36. Panchal Chandrakant M.



GST Bhavan,



37. Patel Ilyas Musamohamed





38. Pandya Ratnesh R.

20 OA 404/2017





39. Malhotra Manish J.



GST Bhavan,



40. Patel Ketan Govindbhai



GST Bhavan,



41. Patel Rakesh J.





42. Gosar Tarun M.


in C.C.O Vadodara,



43. Mevati Idris Abdul





44. Dhruv Rakesh Bhupatray



GST Bhavan,



45. Soni Ketan J.



21 OA 404/2017

GST Bhavan,



46. Parmar Sureshkumar B.





47. Chauhan Sanjeev C.





48. Ajay Kanti Ghosh


in C.C.O Vadodara,



49. Hunter Robert W.



GST Bhavan,



50. Shukla Sanjay Rahidev



GST Bhavan,



51. Smt. Shah Deepa Pratik





52. Raees Khan A . Maulvi



GST Bhavan,


22 OA 404/2017


53. Smt.Jyotsnaben N Khandhani



GST Bhavan,



54. Ms. Nimje Nanda A.



GST Bhavan,



55. Ms.Pattani Geetaben C.



GST Bhavan,



56. Chaudhary Anilkumar Gulsingh


in C.C.O Vadodara,



57.Smt.Patel NaynaBenB.

(Smt. Gamit Naynaben M.)





58. Mehta Chandresh M.



GST Bhavan,



59. Ghag Rohit Kalyanrao




23 OA 404/2017


60. Popat Pravinkumar Chunilal



GST Bhavan,



61. Shah Gopesh Mahendralal





62. Kum.Gozia Jalil

(Mrs.Gozia Abdul Rahim)





63. Smt. Shiny Saji





64. Kum.Hema s. Namboodiri

(Smt. Hema k. Namboodiri)





65. Bhagoshya Rajendra H



GST Bhavan,



66. Kum.Kuruvareth Suma T.

(Smt. Suma Vinu Philips)




24 OA 404/2017


67 .Kum.Elizabeth J

(Mrs.Elizabeth B.Mampilly)



GST Bhavan,



68. Malhotra Amit P.



GST Bhavan,



69. Limaye D. R.




Race course Circle,

Vadodara 390007

70. Shyamsunder K.



GST Bhavan,



71. Kum.Menon K.Sujatha

(Smt.S.J.Nair)



GST Bhavan,



72. Nair K.C. Sanjeevkumar



GST Bhavan,



73. Smt. Sussen Verghese

25 OA 404/2017




Opp Gandhi Baug,


74. Mudaliar A. K.



GST Bhavan,



75. Dave Jitendra



GST Bhavan,



76. Smt.Nair Rita R.



GST Bhavan,



77. Ajay Shah A



GST Bhavan,



78. Dangi Nikunj Navnitlal



GST Bhavan,



79. Smt. Sarvaiya Dimple Bharat




Race course Circle,Vadodara 390007

26 OA 404/2017

80. Galiyal Rajbhai Kalubhai



GST Bhavan,



81. Solanki Govindbhai Keshavbhai



GST Bhavan,



82.Kum.Kumbhare Nanda M

(Smt. Nanda A. Petkar)



GST Bhavan,



83.Shete Rekha M.(Smt. Rekha B. Nainvale)



GST Bhavan,



84. Ohlan Rajeshkumar Bhupsingh



GST Bhavan,



85. Shaikh Hasam Dawood



GST Bhavan,



86. Smt.Jayshree Venu




27 OA 404/2017


87. Smt. Meena Vinita S.


in C.C.O Vadodara,



88. Patel Amaratbhai Ukadbhai





89. Patel Sureshbhai Ramjibhai





90. Sonkusare Sanjay R.



GST Bhavan,



91.Ms. Sonkusare Chanda M.

(Smt.Chanda Kosthi)



GST Bhavan,



92. Kumbhare Bhupendra R.



GST Bhavan,



93. Kharbikar Bhaskar R.



GST Bhavan,


28 OA 404/2017


94. Rathod Arpeshkumar R.



GST Bhavan,



95. Nagpurkar Bharatkumar M.



GST Bhavan,



96. Rathod Prakashkumar L.



GST Bhavan,



97. More Madhvi R.

(Mrs. Madhvi S Kashikar)





98. Baria Jitendrakumar Kevalsingh





99. Pabari Dinesh Bhagwanjibhai



GST Bhavan,



100.Pithodia Sheetal D.

(Smt. Sheetal P. Parmar)



29 OA 404/2017

GST Bhavan,



101.Ruparelia K.K.

(Smt.Krishna Manish Shah)



GST Bhavan,



102. Shah Bijal Satishbhai





103. Ansari Rafiuddin N.



GST Bhavan,



104. Maddiptla Srinivas




Subhanpura,Vadodara 390023

105. Jani Sanjiv Ashwinbhai



GST Bhavan,



106. Bhayani Yogesh P.



GST Bhavan,



107. Jivrajani Pareshkumar P.


30 OA 404/2017


GST Bhavan,



108. Parvadia Chirag Babulal



GST Bhavan,



109. Purohit Praful Ratilal



GST Bhavan,



110. Jani Dilipkumar Navnitray



GST Bhavan,



111. Riska Yogeshkumar Kankrai



GST Bhavan,



112. Smt.Aiyar Amba A.



GST Bhavan,



113. Pithadia Jitendra Harilal



GST Bhavan,



31 OA 404/2017

114. Ms.John Pretha M.

(Smt.Preetha Altaf Khirani)



GST Bhavan,



115. Mehta Bhavesh R.



GST Bhavan,



116. Vaghela Prakash J.



GST Bhavan,



117. Kamdar Manish Pranlal



GST Bhavan,



118. Somaiya Divyesh Vrajlal



GST Bhavan,



119. Somaiya Nilesh N.



GST Bhavan,



120. Joshi Divyesh Mahendrabhai



GST Bhavan,

32 OA 404/2017



121. Nagrecha Jeetendra S.



GST Bhavan,



122. Dharmesh Navin Chandra Kamani



GST Bhavan,



123. Panchamatia Prakash G.



GST Bhavan,



124. Sheth Sandipkumar L.



GST Bhavan,



125. Parekh Nehal Pramodbhai



GST Bhavan,



126. Swadia Sameep Pravinkumar



GST Bhavan,



127. Rathod Harkishan Kantilal


33 OA 404/2017


GST Bhavan,



128. Hardipsingh Jadeja



GST Bhavan,



129. D'cruz Thersia Antony

(Mrs. Theresia Jacob)





130. Smt. Pearl Charles



GST Bhavan,



131.Aryadevi N.N.

(Smt.Aryadevi A. Namboodiri)





132. Pandya Paresh Mansukhlal



GST Bhavan,



133. Lohia Rizvan Abdulkadar



GST Bhavan,



34 OA 404/2017

134. Ashara Yagnesh Prafulbhai



GST Bhavan,



135. Dave Rahul J.



GST Bhavan,



136. Jasani Hemal



GST Bhavan,



137. Palan Vipul Jayantilal



GST Bhavan,



138. Bhanshali Dipesh Hematlal



GST Bhavan,



139.Sarvana Raj M.



GST Bhavan,



140 Rana Bhagirathsinh Surendrasinh



GST Bhavan,


35 OA 404/2017


141. Gohel Dharmendra A.



GST Bhavan,



142. Kundalia Nimish Rameshbhai



GST Bhavan,



143. Chotaliya Vijay Maganlal





144. Trivedi Piyushkumar S.



GST Bhavan,



145. Badrakiya Hitesh Amritlal.



GST Bhavan,



146. Narolkar Nimesh Sharadchandra


in C.C.O Vadodara,



147. Dave Hemang Bhadreshkumar



GST Bhavan,


36 OA 404/2017


148. Bhatt Amishkumar Narottam



GST Bhavan,



149. Menon Sunil K.



GST Bhavan,



150. MS. Nair Deepa N.

(Smt. Deepa A. Shah)



GST Bhavan,



151. Iyer Prasad A.K.


in C.C.O Vadodara,



152. Barai Jyesh Hasmukhrai


in C.C.O Vadodara,



153. Kanjani Dharmendra Bassarmai


in C.C.O Vadodara,



154 Mishra Vivek Pradipkumar


in C.C.O Vadodara,



37 OA 404/2017

155. Parmar Ashokkumar Babukumar


in C.C.O Vadodara,



156. Doria Bipinchandra N.


in C.C.O Vadodara,



157. Surti Lata D.

(Smt. Rathod Lata R.)


in C.C.O Vadodara,



158. Parmar Tusharkumar M.


in C.C.O Vadodara,



159. Chavda Shaileshbhai Kanjibhai


in C.C.O Vadodara,



160. Makwana Bharatkumar M.


in C.C.O Vadodara,


Race course Circle,

Vadodara 390007

161. Makwana Paresh I.


in C.C.O Vadodara,


Race course Circle,

Vadodara 390007

162. Solanki Baldevbhai Kalabhai

38 OA 404/2017


in C.C.O Vadodara,


Race course Circle,

Vadodara 390007

163. Mrs. Vasantaben Ishvarlal Parmar


in C.C.O Vadodara,


Race course Circle,

Vadodara 390007………………………………. Respondents

(By Advocate : Prachi Upadhyay )

O R D E R (ORAL)

Per : Hon’ble Dr. K.B. Suresh, Member (J)

We have heard the matter today.

2. It appears that all the OAs are covered by the decision passed in the

OA No.169/2018 decided on 15.1.2018 by the Principal Bench, New

Delhi.

3. Therefore, after having explained the matter, we have gone through

the aforesaid order dated 15.1.2018 at para-4 passed in OA No.169/2018

by Principal Bench, New Delhi. It reads as follows :

“In view of the above, this OA is disposed of at the admission stage

without going into the merits of the controversy with a direction to the

respondents to examine the case of the applicants in the light of the

judgment passed in OA No.3405/2014 and pass appropriate order in

accordance with law within a period of two months from the date of

receipt of a copy of this order.”

4. We also adopt the same order. Therefore, the case of the applicant

shall be looked into a fresh in the light of the judgment passed in OA

No.3405/2014 of the Principal Bench and as stated in the order mentioned

39 OA 404/2017

above within a period of two months from the date of receipt of a copy of

this order. In the interregnum, no other orders may be issued.

5. The OA stands disposed of with the above direction. No costs.

(K.N.Shrivastava) (K.B.Suresh) Member (A) Member(J)

nk

Documents

central administrative tribunal