1
Volume 159, No. 24 Copyright © 2013 Law Bulletin Publishing Company. All rights reserved. Reprinted with permission from Law Bulletin Publishing Company. CHICAGOLAWBULLETIN.COM MONDAY, FEBRUARY 4, 2013 ® “’ ” ” “’ ” “ … ” ‘‘

Michael LoGiudice, CBIZ Valuation Group - Expert Witness for Companies Suffering Damage from Hurrican Sandy

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Michael LoGiudice, CBIZ Valuation Group - Expert Witness for Companies Suffering Damage from Hurrican Sandy

Volume 159, No. 24

Copyright © 2013 Law Bulletin Publishing Company. All rights reserved. Reprinted with permission from Law Bulletin Publishing Company.

CHICAGOLAWBULLETIN.COM MONDAY, FEBRUARY 4, 2013

®

������� �������� � �������������� ��� �� �� ��� �������

�������� �� � ������ ��

��.% &+ ($� %(�+� *+ � �*%,"(�)�('��+ ($� ��(�&,& *(�+ ��(����/ �4�(*&+ �*%(�*/( &� ����(���$*/�#& �+� ($� �*(?-��� (&+ ��%-*��+/�%�

� �&&1 �&"+(. /*�/"*( !"�#� &�-����� ($� ,") */ '�(�� �#�+/. (&,�. >�7�� 4* *&+ �%( 4&+($ (& ($�&'+�� &� ($� �*(?-��� (&+ ��%*-��+/�% �&� ) &/1*+# �//�%% (& �+� �. +��� ($� )"* �*+# %*(�� /�"%*+#�+ �8-4&+($ �� �.�

“� /� /" �(�� '$�( ($� /&+%(�"/-(*&+ ,�&!�/( '&" � $�2� &&1�� *1�'*($ �+� '*($&"( ($� �� �.�” �&�*"-�*/� %�*�� “�$�+ � ,�&!�/( *% ��-

�.��� .&" $�2� (& �*+�+/� *( �&� � &+#�� ,��*&� &� (*4� �+� /��(�*+/&%(% /&+(*+"� ($�( '&" � $�2�&($��'*%� �*%/&+(*+"�� … *1���+(� &� %(&��#� %,�/� &� !&) %*(�&��*/� %,�/��”

0"%(*+ �� ��*%)��#� � ,��(+�� �(��+%(�*+ < ��$� ��9 '$& &�(�+$*��% �&�*"�*/�� %�*� %&4� �=,��('*(+�%%�% �*%, �. (&& 4"/$ �4&-(*&+ '$�+ ��%/�*)*+# ��4�#�% *+ �/�%��

�"( �&�*"�*/� �2&*�% �&*+# ($�(���*%)��# %�*�� '$*/$ 4�1�% $*4�,,��� 4&�� /���*) ��

“��’% 2��. �2�+ (�4,�����” ��*%-)��# %�*�� “� !"�#� &� � !"�. /�+ (� '$�+ %&4�&+� *% #�((*+# �4&(*&+� �)&"( ($� &,*+*&+� �+� � �&+’( ($*+1($�( $� ,%� �� /&4�% &�� �% 4&��*+��,�+��+(�”

�&�*"�*/� /"���+( . '&�1% �% �+�=,��( '*(+�%% �&� �)&"( +*+� ��'�&�1 /&4,�+*�% ($�( %"������ ��4-�#� �"�*+# �"��*/�+� 3�+�. �%(.���� �� %�*� $� �%%�%%�% ($� ��-%(�"/(*&+ ($��� �*�����+( . ($�+ $��*� ��(�� �"��*/�+� @�(�*+� $*( ($��" � �&�%(�

�+ ($� �%( �&�%(� ($� '*+�/�"%�� 4&�� ��4�#� ($�+ � &&�'�(��% �*�� ��� 4&�� � &&� ��4�#�&//"����� )"%*+�%%�% '&" � $�2��+ ��%*�� (*4� 4�1*+# *+%"��+/�/ �*4%�

“� &( &� ,�&, � ��� �*+�*+# ($�.�&+’( $�2� ($� /&2���#� ($�. ($*+1($�. �*� $�2��” �&�*"�*/� %�*��

�+� '*($ %&4� *+%"��+/� /&4-,�+*�% ��!�/(*+# / �*4% ). )"%*-+�%%�%� ($� %(&�4 $�% #*2�+ �*%� (&� %")%(�+(*� �4&"+( &� *(*#�-(*&+�

“�((&�+�.% ��� #�((*+# *+2& 2��*+ /&2���#� �*%,"(�% 4&�� 5"*/1 .($�+ ($�. %&4�(*4�% '&" ��” $�%�*�� “9�&, � ��� !"%( )�#*++*+# (&��� *?� '$�( /�+ )� �&+� �+� $&'($�. /�+ ��/&2�� �+� #�( 4&+�. �&�*(�”

�*/$�� �� 3(*�#� � � ,��(+�� �(�*/$�� � ��%( < �*���*/$ ��9� %�*��&�*"�*/� %��2�� �% �+ �=,��( '*(-+�%% *+ � /�%� �)&"( �+ *+�"%(�*� ,��1 $� $�+� ���

�&�*"�*/�’% �)* *(. (& ��(*/" �(�$*% ��%���/$ )�+��*(% $*4� 3(*�#� %�*��

“=,��( '*(+�%%�% ��� 2*�'����&4 ($� %(�+�,&*+( &� ($�*� /��-��+(*� %� ($�*� %,��/$ — ($�*� �)* -*(. (& /&44"+*/�(� *+ ($� ��4�#�'&� � �+� )� �) � (& �=, �*+ '$.($� ��4�#�% �=*%(�” $� %�*�� “�(’% �2��. /&4, */�(�� ���� ($�( 4&%(&��*+��. �& 1% �&+’( #�( *+2& 2��*+�”

�����������������

�� ���� ������

��� ������ �� ����

�$�+ (�%(*�.*+# �)&"( ��4-�#� �%%�%%4�+(% *+ %(�(��+� ������ /&"�( /�%�%�

�=,��( '*(+�%% �*/$�� �&�*"�*/����'% &+ ($� �6 .���% $� %,�+( *+($� /&+%(�"/(*&+ �+� 4�+"��/("�-*+# *+�"%(�.�

�+� %*+/� $� )�#�+ �&/"%*+# &+�%%�%%4�+( '&�1 *+ �::A� $�’% $�+-� �� %&4� 4�!&� ,�&!�/(% — *+-/ "�*+# �2� "�(*+# ��4�#� /�"%��). �"��*/�+� @�(�*+� �+� �%(*-4�(*+# ($� ����/(% &� � /&+%(�"/(*&+�� �. &+ � %�( &� �$*/�#& "="�./&+�&4*+*"4%�

�&�*"�*/�� 4�+�#*+# �*��/(&� &����B ;� "�(*&+ ��&", ���� %�*�4"/$ &� $*% ���&�( &+ �+ �%%�%%4�+(#&�% *+(& ��(��4*+*+# $&' ��* .&,���(*&+% — %"/$ �% 4��(*+# ,�.-�& �+� %(���*+# — *4,�/( � )"%*-+�%%’ ,�&�*(�)* *(.�

�*% �=,��*�+/� *+ /&+%(�"/(*&+$� ,% $*4 ,�&2*�� %(�&+#��� 4&��'� -��%���/$�� �%%�%%4�+(%� $�%�*��

“��2*+# )��+ &+ ($� &($�� %*��� �"+���%(�+� ($� *+("*(*&+ $�% (&/&4� �&'+ (& $��� ��/(%� �+� �$�2� (& (�1� C� /&4,�+.’%D #"(��� *+# �+� �%%�%% *( *+ ($� /& � *#$( (& /&4, �(� . �*+� &)!�/(*2���(��”

�&�*"�*/�� 7�� %,�+( 4&%( &� $*%/����� '&�1*+# �% ($� /$*�� �*-+�+/*� &��*/�� �&� 0� � �'���%�&+%(�"/(*&+ �&� *+ ��+�%�&�

�"���+( .� �&�*"�*/� $�+� �% �%-%�%%4�+(% *+ ����% *+/ "�*+# 4�+-"��/("�*+#� /&+%(�"/(*&+� $&%,*(� -*(.� '$& �%� � �*%(�*)"(*&+ �+� ��-(�* %� �%�

�*($ �2��. �%%�%%4�+(� �&�*"-�*/� ��(��4*+�% $&' ��/$ ��/(&� &�($� ��4�#�% &"( *+�� *+ � �'%"*(�� �(�% (& ($� )"%*+�%%�

“� (�1� ($� ��/(% ��&4 ($� /�%��+� /&+%(�"/( � 4&�� &� '$�('&" � $�2� $�,,�+�� )"( �&� ($�($*+#% ($�( ��� )�*+# � �#�� *+ ($�/�%��” $� %�*��

�"�*+# $*% (*4� �% � ����&�*"�*/� &�(�+ '&�1�� '*($ �(-(&�+�.% '$* � %�((*+# ", /&+%(�"/-(*&+ ,�&!�/(%� ��5"�+( .� ($�.'&" � �%1 $*4 �&� $*% &,*+*&+ &+��4�#� /�%�% ($�. '��� $�+� *+#�$� %�*��

�2�� ($� .���%� $� %�*�� $� #���-"� . )�#�+ �&*+# �%% /&+%(�"/(*&+'&�1 �+� %,�+( 4&�� (*4� &+ ��4-�#� /�%�%�

“�% � '&" � ,�&2*�� ($�&�*�%� &+�($*+# '&" � ��� (& �+&($��� �+� �'�% $*��� &+ 2��*&"% /�%�%�” $�%�*��

����% �(��� �&�*"�*/� (�%(*�*�� �%�+ �=,��( '*(+�%% *+ �"��*/�+�@�(�*+� /�%�% ��(�� � ��*�+� — '$&'�% � �� &� � ��%(-�&&� /$�*+ ($�(&'+�� ��%(�"��+(% ��4�#�� ). ($�%(&�4 — �%1�� �&� $*% $� ,�

�&�*"�*/� '&�1�� '*($ /&4,�-+*�% (& ��(��4*+� ($�*� /&%(% (&��)"* � �+� $&' &+# /&+%(�"/(*&+'&" � (�1� (& /&4, �(��

�"( &+� &� ($� 4&%( *4,&�(�+(($*+#% (& ��(��4*+�� $� %�*�� '�%$&' 4"/$ )"%*+�%% ($� �+(*(. &%(�% � ��%" ( &� ($� $"��*/�+��

�&�*"�*/� $� ,�� �%%�%% �)&"( >�)* *&+ *+ ��4�#�%� $� %�*�� �+���/$ %(&�4 ��4�#� /�%� (&&1 )�-('��+ +*+� (& �8 4&+($% (& /&4-, �(��

“� '�% �&'+ ($��� ($��� '��1%��(�� �"��*/�+� @�(�*+� $*(� �+� ���4�4)�� $�2*+# (& #& ($�&"#$4* *(��. /$�/1 ,&*+(%�” $� %�*�� “&�($� +�=( ('& .���%� � 4��� &+� (&('& (�*,% � 4&+($ �&'+ (& ��'�� ��+% &� ($� �" � �&�%(�”

�"�*+# � /�%� �%( 4&+($ '$����&�*"�*/� ��(��4*+�� ($� *4,�/(&� � /&+%(�"/(*&+ �� �.� $� %,�+( ��

������ �������

������ ���������

“�������� � ��

�� ���� ���� ����� ���������� ��� ��� ��� � �� ������� ��� � ��� ���� �� ������’����� ����� �������� �� … ”

‘‘