We were pioneers: early applications of dwn simulations_2

By Piero Belforte, July 2010

PrefaceIn the early 70s CSELT Labs (Turin,Italy) developed the

first digital switches deployed in the Italian network.

The Switching Techniques lab, headed by Piero Belforte, had the mission of developing a modular technologyfor fast prototyping of high-speed digital systems

A CAD methodology for prediction of high-speedinterconnects behavior was strongly needed…

The environment (1) IBM’s ASTAP circuit simulation program was only

available on mainframe computers.

ASTAP was very slow and inaccurate dealing withtrasmission line and propagation effects.

Accurate models of ICs I/O ports were not available.

The environment (2) The expression “Signal Integrity” didn’t exist.

The IBIS models of Ics were not yet invented.

The S-parameter concept was only used in the Microwave field in the frequency domain.

The Eye-Diagram representation of digital signals wasonly used in the Transmission System domain.

The environment (3) HP launches the first desktop calculators (9800

series).

Tek 7S12 TDR unit has already a 25 ps risetimecapability.

HP introduces the HPIB instrumentation control bus.

DSP techniques were already known but never

applied to circuit simulation.

Hp 9800 Series technologyhttp://www.hpmuseum.org/tech98xx.htm

8MHz 16-bit processor.

Microcode stored in bipolar ROM (7 ICs were used to supply 256 28 bit words.)

Firmware stored in 4K bit ROM chips organized as 512 8 bit words.

Intel 1103 1K bit PMOS dynamic RAM ICs.

16-character LED display

Philips cassette magnetic-tape cartridge drive

HPL algebraic programming language

HPIB bus card for instrument control

The TEK 7S12 TDR/Sampler Unit(25ps rise time)

THE WINNING IDEAS1) Apply DSP (Digital Signal Processing) techniques

to circuit simulation.

2) Use Wave variables instead of classical voltage and currents tomodel propagation effects.

3) Use TDR as Time-domain S-parameter extractor from actualdevices .

4) Integrate Modelling & Simulation Environments using a Desktop calculator for both controlling instruments and runnigsimulations.

5) Extensive use of PRBS sequences as stimulus and EYE-DIAGRAMS to evaluate signal prameters ( eye opening, jitter, Noise margins).

Piero (left) and his colleague Giancarlo (right) with the HP9821 desktop calculator used for the first versions of the simulator (circa 1974)

Published paper showing the Digital Wave DSP algorithms usedfor modelling and simulation of high-speed interconnects

Cellular topology (N transmission-line cells) interconnection structure modelled by the DWN program

Digital Network model of the cellularinterconnection structure

DWN Simulation Program features

The whole DWN algorithm for the modular structurerequired about 250 lines of HPL code and was written byUgo Colonnelli.

The output waveforms were plotted on a HP 9862A plotter driven by the calculator.

The accuracy and speed performance was much better thanIBM’s ASTAP circuit analysis program running on a mainframe computer .

Layout of a microstrip test circuit used for

validation of simulator’s results (TDR response)

Plot of simulated (s) and measured (m) one-port TDR

responses of the test circuit (1975)

Simulation (s) vs measure (m) of a 220 Mbit/s MECL III pcb interconnect (1975) using a PRBS stimulus

ECL multi-drop backplane bus

Simulated and measured Eye-diagrams of the multi-

drop bus carrying a 100Mbit/s PRBS stream (1975)

Early HPIB automatic bench for modelling active and passive device based on Tek 7S12 TDR (1974)

Automatic I/O model extraction from biasedTDR measures (S-parameters) of IC ports

THICK-FILM HIGH-SPEED HYBRID CIRCUIT

Thin-film hybrid clock driver designedfor 500Mhz clock distribution

MEASUREMENT SETUPS FOR TDR I/OCHARACTERIZATIONS OF HYBRID CLOCK DRIVERS

BIASED TDR INPUT RESPONSES

BIASED TDR OUTPUT RESPONSES

TEST BOARD FOR TDR CHARACTERIZATION

DWN simulations of 250Mhz clock waveforms ofthe hybrid clock driver at various fan outs

250 Mbit/s module designed using the DWN methodology (1974)

Backplane twisted pair interconnectsamong high-speed modules

COLLECTION of hybrid circuits designed and characterized using DWN (1973-1975)

Interconnect optimization for a high-speed (.5 Gbps) MCM using simulated eye diagrams (1975)

.5 Gbps MCM module fully designed by means of DWN modelling and simulations (1975)

Low-cost high-speed module for fast prototyping of digitalsystems fully optimized by DWN (1978)

EYE-DIAGRAM PARAMETERS FOR INTERCONNECT PARAMETERS EVALUATION

TDR Characterization of the connector

TLM model of the connector (DWN simulation)

SETTING OF INTER-MODULE BACKPLANE INTERCONNECT RULES BY SIMULATION

INTER-MODULE CLOCK INTERCONNECT PARAMETERS VS FREQUENCY (From DWN SIMs)

High-speed prototype of a digitalswitch built up using .5Gps modules

TEST SETUP OF A HIGH-SPEED DIGITAL SUBSYSTEM PROTOTYPE

WEB LINKS (1) http://it.linkedin.com/in/pierobelforte

http://www.slideshare.net/pierobelforte

http://sites.google.com/site/pierobelforte/Home/piero-s-papers-1

http://www.linkedin.com/groups?mostPopular=&gid=2673743

http://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&pid=sites&srcid=ZGVmYXVsdGRvbWFpbnxwaWVyb2JlbGZvcnRlZG9jfGd4OjMwNzY5MjUzZjM1ZTJjNzQ

WEB LINKS (2) http://www.hp9825.com/html/hpib1.html

http://www.hp9825.com/html/hp_9810_20_30.html

http://www.hpmuseum.org/hp9820.htm