View
500
Download
1
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
INBOUND15
Growth Through Acquisition
Should you BUY or SELL?
Karl Skutski&
David TobinThe Tobin Group
INBOUND15
45 minutes of Zen…
INBOUND15
…to meditate & do some serious soul-searching
INBOUND15
…about your future
INBOUND15
Where do you hope to be in 5 years?
INBOUND15
Are you getting there fast enough?
INBOUND15
Can you go it alone?
INBOUND15
Can you go it alone?
1. Where is your company in the Inbound Revolution?
2. Are you positioned to buy?
3. Are you a candidate to sell?
4. Hallmarks of a well-run firm
5. What is your business worth?
6. Parting words of wisdom
AGENDA
INBOUND15
Where are you in the Inbound revolution?
INBOUND15
TYPES OF COMPANIES
INBOUND15
1. The small happy “family”
2. Conservative, organic growers
3. Aggressive entrepreneurs
PERSONAS OF BUSINESS OWNERSContentment
Modest growth
Big dollar potential
INBOUND15
1. The small happy “family”
2. Conservative, organic growers
3. Aggressive entrepreneurs
Understand how M&As work…
PERSONAS OF BUSINESS OWNERS
INBOUND15
1. The small happy “family”
2. Conservative, organic “farmers”
3. Aggressive entrepreneurs
Understand how M&As work…
…MAY BE MORE DOABLE THAN YOU THINK!
PERSONAS OF BUSINESS OWNERS
INBOUND15
PROFILE OF INBOUND PROVIDERS2015 HubSpot Partner Benchmark Survey
All Partners Gold + PlatinumAge of firm 2-5 years 2-5 years 2-5 years
Total revenues $100K - $500K $100K - $500K $100K - $500K
Number of full-time employees 2-5 2-5 26+
Annual revenue growth < 10% 21 to 50% 100%
Operating margin 11 to 20% 11 to 20% 11 to 20%
Cash to support expansion < $50,000 < $50,000 $100K - $250K
Average service fees $3K - $5K $5K - $10K $5K - $10K
Percent business = inbound < 25% 75% - 99% 100%
Most Common Responses
INBOUND15
PROFILE OF INBOUND PROVIDERS2015 HubSpot Partner Benchmark Survey
All Partners Gold + PlatinumAge of firm 2-5 years 2-5 years 2-5 years
Total revenues $100K - $500K $100K - $500K $100K - $500K
Number of full-time employees 2-5 2-5 26+
Annual revenue growth < 10% 21 to 50% 100%
Operating margin 11 to 20% 11 to 20% 11 to 20%
Cash to support expansion < $50,000 < $50,000 $100K - $250K
Average service fees $3K - $5K $5K - $10K $5K - $10K
Percent business = inbound < 25% 75% - 99% 100%
Most Common Responses
INBOUND15
PROFILE OF INBOUND PROVIDERS2015 HubSpot Partner Benchmark Survey
All Partners Gold + PlatinumAge of firm 2-5 years 2-5 years 2-5 years
Total revenues $100K - $500K $100K - $500K $1M to $2M
Number of full-time employees 2-5 2-5 26+
Annual revenue growth < 10% 21 to 50% 100%
Operating margin 11 to 20% 11 to 20% 11 to 20%
Cash to support expansion < $50,000 < $50,000 $100K - $250K
Average service fees $3K - $5K $5K - $10K $5K - $10K
Percent business = inbound < 25% 75% - 99% 100%
Most Common Responses
INBOUND15
WHERE THE INDUSTRY IS
INBOUND15
0
500,000
1,000,000
1,500,000
2,000,000
2015 2020
MAS Industry
Projected Growth: Marketing Automation Software (Frost & Sullivan)
INBOUND15
0
500,000
1,000,000
1,500,000
2,000,000
2015 2020
MAS Industry
Projected Growth: Marketing Automation Software (Frost & Sullivan) Typical
Marketing Agency(10% annual growth)
1,600,0001,000,000
INBOUND15
How can you capitalize on the growth of Inbound?
INBOUND15
Can you get to where you want to go alone?
INBOUND15
2 Are you positioned to buy?
INBOUND15
WHY BUYERS BUY?1. Increase REVENUE and/or PROFITABILITY
2. Strengthen MANAGEMENT team (including potential successors)
3. Add COMPLEMENTARY TALENT & capabilities (technical, strategic, branding, PR/content, etc.)
4. Gain access to seller’s CLIENTS
5. Expand GEOGRAPHIC footprint
6. Position the company to be MONETIZED
INBOUND15
DO YOU HAVE WHAT IT TAKES TO BE A PLAYER?
1. Clear VISION of the how an acquisition might enhance your business (are you buying talent, capabilities, managers/successors, revenue, cash flow?)
2. An UNDERSTANDING of the M&A process & a good team of advisors
3. TOP-LINE REVENUES of > $1 million or approximately 3x value of the target firm
4. Access to CASH to fund 20% to 35% of the purchase price upfront
5. Consistent CASH FLOW, ideally 15% to 20% of Adjusted Gross Income, to fund debt service and grow your business
INBOUND15
Should you acquire anunder-performing company
OR
a profitable, growing firm?
INBOUND15
POTENTIAL DEAL ELEMENTS TO ACQUIREPROFITABLE, GROWING FIRMS1. CASH (20% to 40% of the deal value)
2. GUARANTEED DEFERRED PAYMENTS
3. EARN-OUT PAYMENTS that offer the opportunity for increased value
4. EQUITY in the larger enterprise
5. PHANTOM STOCK PLAN
6. EMPLOYMENT CONTRACT
INBOUND15
PHANTOM STOCK PLANS
1. CONTRACT to pay benefits upon certain triggering events; i.e., the sale of the company
2. You custom DESIGN the plan elements
3. Can include a VESTING schedule
4. Can base the payouts on APPRECIATED value
5. NOT REAL EQUITY so you are not required to share financial information or buy back shares
6. Ownership is not DILUTED
INBOUND15
SAMPLE DEALS
INBOUND15
SAMPLE CASE #1 Buyer: Inbound marketing agency Seller: Inbound marketing agency Seller’s revenue: $1,400,000 Seller’s EBITDA: Negative $75,000
DEAL TERMS:
1. Down payment of $100,000
2. Commissions of 20% of AGI in excess of $900,000 for two years
3. Six-month consulting contract of $75,000 for seller
INBOUND15
SAMPLE CASE #2 Buyer: Inbound marketing agency Seller: Web development & digital marketing Seller’s revenue: $700,000 Seller’s EBITDA: $53,300
DEAL TERMS:
1. Down payment of $50,000
2. Deferred payments of $60,000 per year with earn out safeguards
3. Phantom units in Phantom Stock Plan
4. Employment contact for owner
INBOUND15
SAMPLE CASE #3 Buyer: Integrated marketing agency Seller: Design firm Seller’s revenue: $1,700,000 Seller’s EBITDA: $168,000
DEAL TERMS:
1. Down payment of $300,000
2. Commissions of 15% of AGI above $1,100,000 for a four-year period
3. Employment contracts for two principals
INBOUND15
3 Are you a candidate to sell?
INBOUND15
WHY SELLERS SELL?THE SELLER’S MOTIVATION
INBOUND15
WHY SELLERS SELL?THE NOT-SO-GOOD REASONS
INBOUND15
WHY SELLERS SELL?THE NOT-SO-GOOD REASONS
1. Unable to achieve PERSONAL FINANCIAL GOALS on own
2. Burdened with DEBT
3. SALARY lower than Fair Market
4. NO GROWTH
5. LOSS of big account(s)
6. No BENEFITS or 401K
INBOUND15
WHY SELLERS SELL?THE NOT-SO-GOOD REASONS
1. Unable to achieve PERSONAL FINANCIAL GOALS on own
2. Burdened with DEBT
3. SALARY lower than Fair Market
4. NO GROWTH
5. LOSS of big account(s)
6. No BENEFITS or 401K
DISTRESSED BUSINESS ? =
OPPORTUNITY FOR BUYER
INBOUND15
WHY SELLERS SELL?THE NOT-SO-GOOD REASONS
1. Unable to achieve PERSONAL FINANCIAL GOALS on own
2. Burdened with DEBT
3. SALARY lower than Fair Market
4. NO GROWTH
5. LOSS of big account(s)
6. No BENEFITS or 401K
DISTRESSED BUSINESS ? =
OPPORTUNITY FOR BUYER&
STILL COULD BE A GOOD DEAL FOR SELLER !
INBOUND15
WHY SELLERS SELL?OKAY REASONS
1. Be part of a GROWING ENTERPRISE
2. EQUITY opportunity with larger enterprise
3. Play on a BIGGER FIELD
4. EXIT plan
5. Greater LIFE BALANCE
6. Be RELIEVED of management and administrative responsibilities
INBOUND15
WHAT BUYERS DESIRE1. Net after-tax CASH FLOW
2. CONFIDENCE cash flow will persist
3. SYNERGISTIC savings
4. LEVERAGE opportunities
5. Ability to INCREASE VALUE
6. Fit with their STRATEGIC PLANS
INBOUND15
PREPARING YOUR BUSINESS FOR A SALE1. Paint a PICTURE of what your company can be or do2. Create a MARKET3. Seek buyers that can leverage your resources and realize SYNERGISTIC savings4. Address key DEPENDENCIES & VULNERABILITIES5. Demonstrate stability and CONSISTENT CASH FLOW6. Get your financial RECORDS IN ORDER7. LOCK IN key employees8. Confront potential “DEAL KILLERS”9. Have a realistic expectation of your FIRM’S VALUE
INBOUND15
Key Value DriversWhat buyers look for…and sellers should flaunt!
Factors that impact the multiple or company risk factor in VALUATIONS1. Consistent cash flow > 15% to 20% 7. Diversity/longevity of accounts
2. Strength of senior management team 8. Sales trends/growth potential
3. Limited dependence on owner(s) 9. Lack of debt/long-term obligations
4. “Golden handcuffs” for key people 10. Financial controls and reporting systems
5. Market niches/specialty services 11. Reputation & goodwill
6. Systematic approach to new business 12. Technology/digital capabilities
INBOUND15
Key Value DriversWhat buyers look for…and sellers should flaunt!
Factors that impact the multiple or company risk factor in VALUATIONS1. Consistent cash flow > 15% to 20% 7. Diversity/longevity of accounts
2. Strength of senior management team 8. Sales trends/growth potential
3. Limited dependence on owner(s) 9. Lack of debt/long-term obligations
4. “Golden handcuffs” for key people 10. Financial controls and reporting systems
5. Market niches/specialty services 11. Reputation & goodwill
6. Systematic approach to new business 12. Technology/digital capabilities
INBOUND15
Key Value DriversWhat buyers look for…and sellers should flaunt!
Factors that impact the multiple or company risk factor in VALUATIONS1. Consistent cash flow > 15% to 20% 7. Diversity/longevity of accounts
2. Strength of senior management team 8. Sales trends/growth potential
3. Limited dependence on owner(s) 9. Lack of debt/long-term obligations
4. “Golden handcuffs” for key people 10. Financial controls and reporting systems
5. Market niches/specialty services 11. Reputation & goodwill
6. Systematic approach to new business 12. Technology/digital capabilities
INBOUND15
4 Hallmarks of a well-run firm
INBOUND15
Key Financial Ratios & MetricsTTG client database of 100+ marketing agencies between $500K to $5 million
Factor Average Top
Revenues per FTENet income as % of AGI after FMS 10% 35%
Labor costs as a % of AGI 65% 55%
Staff utilization rates (non-mgt.) 70% 95%
Average hourly billing rates $90 $175
Owner’s discretionary income $90,000 $350,000+
Billable to non/low-billable FTE ratio 1:5 1:25
INBOUND15
Key Financial Ratios & MetricsTTG client database of 100+ marketing agencies between $500K to $5 million
Factor Average Top
Revenues per FTE $100,000Net income as % of AGI after FMS 10% 35%
Labor costs as a % of AGI 65% 55%
Staff utilization rates (non-mgt.) 70% 95%
Average hourly billing rates $90 $175
Owner’s discretionary income $90,000 $350,000+
Billable to non/low-billable FTE ratio 1:5 1:25
INBOUND15
Key Financial Ratios & MetricsTTG client database of 100+ marketing agencies between $500K to $5 million
Factor Average Top
Revenues per FTE $100,000 $250,000Net income as % of AGI after FMS 10% 35%
Labor costs as a % of AGI 65% 55%
Staff utilization rates (non-mgt.) 70% 95%
Average hourly billing rates $90 $175
Owner’s discretionary income $90,000 $350,000+
Billable to non/low-billable FTE ratio 1:5 1:25
INBOUND15
Key Financial Ratios & MetricsTTG client database of 100+ marketing agencies between $500K to $5 million
Factor Average Top
Revenues per FTE $100,000 $250,000Net income as % AGI after FMS
Labor costs as a % of AGI 65% 55%
Staff utilization rates (non-mgt.) 70% 95%
Average hourly billing rates $90 $175
Owner’s discretionary income $90,000 $350,000+
Billable to non/low-billable FTE ratio 1:5 1:25
INBOUND15
Key Financial Ratios & MetricsTTG client database of 100+ marketing agencies between $500K to $5 million
Factor Average Top
Revenues per FTE $100,000 $250,000Net income as % AGI after FMS 10%
Labor costs as a % of AGI 65% 55%
Staff utilization rates (non-mgt.) 70% 95%
Average hourly billing rates $90 $175
Owner’s discretionary income $90,000 $350,000+
Billable to non/low-billable FTE ratio 1:5 1:25
INBOUND15
Key Financial Ratios & MetricsTTG client database of 100+ marketing agencies between $500K to $5 million
Factor Average Top
Revenues per FTE $100,000 $250,000Net income as % AGI after FMS 10% 35%
Labor costs as a % of AGI 65% 55%
Staff utilization rates (non-mgt.) 70% 95%
Average hourly billing rates $90 $175
Owner’s discretionary income $90,000 $350,000+
Billable to non/low-billable FTE ratio 1:5 1:25
INBOUND15
Key Financial Ratios & MetricsTTG client database of 100+ marketing agencies between $500K to $5 million
Factor Average Top
Revenues per FTE $100,000 $250,000Net income as % AGI after FMS 10% 35%
Labor costs as a % of AGI
Staff utilization rates (non-mgt.) 70% 95%
Average hourly billing rates $90 $175
Owner’s discretionary income $90,000 $350,000+
Billable to non/low-billable FTE ratio 1:5 1:25
INBOUND15
Key Financial Ratios & MetricsTTG client database of 100+ marketing agencies between $500K to $5 million
Factor Average Top
Revenues per FTE $100,000 $250,000Net income as % AGI after FMS 10% 35%
Labor costs as a % of AGI 65%
Staff utilization rates (non-mgt.) 70% 95%
Average hourly billing rates $90 $175
Owner’s discretionary income $90,000 $350,000+
Billable to non/low-billable FTE ratio 1:5 1:25
INBOUND15
Key Financial Ratios & MetricsTTG client database of 100+ marketing agencies between $500K to $5 million
Factor Average Top
Revenues per FTE $100,000 $250,000Net income as % AGI after FMS 10% 35%
Labor costs as a % of AGI 65% 55%
Staff utilization rates (non-mgt.) 70% 95%
Average hourly billing rates $90 $175
Owner’s discretionary income $90,000 $350,000+
Billable to non/low-billable FTE ratio 1:5 1:25
INBOUND15
Key Financial Ratios & MetricsTTG client database of 100+ marketing agencies between $500K to $5 million
Factor Average Top
Revenues per FTE $100,000 $250,000Net income as % AGI after FMS 10% 35%
Labor costs as a % of AGI 65% 55%
Staff utilization rates (non-mgt.)
Average hourly billing rates $90 $175
Owner’s discretionary income $90,000 $350,000+
Billable to non/low-billable FTE ratio 1:5 1:25
INBOUND15
Key Financial Ratios & MetricsTTG client database of 100+ marketing agencies between $500K to $5 million
Factor Average Top
Revenues per FTE $100,000 $250,000Net income as % AGI after FMS 10% 35%Labor costs as a % of AGI 65% 55%
Staff utilization rates (non-mgt.) 70%
Average hourly billing rates $90 $175
Owner’s discretionary income $90,000 $350,000+
Billable to non/low-billable FTE ratio 1:5 1:25
INBOUND15
Key Financial Ratios & MetricsTTG client database of 100+ marketing agencies between $500K to $5 million
Factor Average Top
Revenues per FTE $100,000 $250,000Net income as % AGI after FMS 10% 35%
Labor costs as a % of AGI 65% 55%
Staff utilization rates (non-mgt.) 70% 95%
Average hourly billing rates $90 $175
Owner’s discretionary income $90,000 $350,000+
Billable to non/low-billable FTE ratio 1:5 1:25
INBOUND15
Key Financial Ratios & MetricsTTG client database of 100+ marketing agencies between $500K to $5 million
Factor Average Top
Revenues per FTE $100,000 $250,000Net income as % AGI after FMS 10% 35%
Labor costs as a % of AGI 65% 55%
Staff utilization rates (non-mgt.) 70% 95%
Average hourly billing rates
Owner’s discretionary income $90,000 $350,000+
Billable to non/low-billable FTE ratio 1:5 1:25
INBOUND15
Key Financial Ratios & MetricsTTG client database of 100+ marketing agencies between $500K to $5 million
Factor Average Top
Revenues per FTE $100,000 $250,000Net income as % AGI after FMS 10% 35%
Labor costs as a % of AGI 65% 55%
Staff utilization rates (non-mgt.) 70% 95%
Average hourly billing rates $90
Owner’s discretionary income $90,000 $350,000+
Billable to non/low-billable FTE ratio 1:5 1:25
INBOUND15
Key Financial Ratios & MetricsTTG client database of 100+ marketing agencies between $500K to $5 million
Factor Average Top
Revenues per FTE $100,000 $250,000Net income as % AGI after FMS 10% 35%
Labor costs as a % of AGI 65% 55%
Staff utilization rates (non-mgt.) 70% 95%
Average hourly billing rates $90 $250
Owner’s discretionary income $90,000 $350,000+
Billable to non/low-billable FTE ratio 1:5 1:25
INBOUND15
Key Financial Ratios & MetricsTTG client database of 100+ marketing agencies between $500K to $5 million
Factor Average Top
Revenues per FTE $100,000 $250,000Net income as % AGI after FMS 10% 35%
Labor costs as a % of AGI 65% 55%
Staff utilization rates (non-mgt.) 70% 95%
Average hourly billing rates $90 $250
Owner’s discretionary income
Billable to non/low-billable FTE ratio 1:5 1:25
INBOUND15
Key Financial Ratios & MetricsTTG client database of 100+ marketing agencies between $500K to $5 million
Factor Average Top
Revenues per FTE $100,000 $250,000Net income as % AGI after FMS 10% 35%
Labor costs as a % of AGI 65% 55%
Staff utilization rates (non-mgt.) 70% 95%
Average hourly billing rates $90 $250
Owner’s discretionary income $90,000
Billable to non/low-billable FTE ratio 1:5 1:25
INBOUND15
Key Financial Ratios & MetricsTTG client database of 100+ marketing agencies between $500K to $5 million
Factor Average Top
Revenues per FTE $100,000 $250,000Net income as % AGI after FMS 10% 35%
Labor costs as a % of AGI 65% 55%
Staff utilization rates (non-mgt.) 70% 95%
Average hourly billing rates $90 $250
Owner’s discretionary income $90,000 $350,000+
Billable to non/low-billable FTE ratio 1:5 1:25
INBOUND15
Key Financial Ratios & MetricsTTG client database of 100+ marketing agencies between $500K to $5 million
Factor Average Top
Revenues per FTE $100,000 $250,000Net income as % AGI after FMS 10% 35%
Labor costs as a % of AGI 65% 55%
Staff utilization rates (non-mgt.) 70% 95%
Average hourly billing rates $90 $250
Owner’s discretionary income $90,000 $350,000+
Billable to low-billable FTE ratio
INBOUND15
Key Financial Ratios & MetricsTTG client database of 100+ marketing agencies between $500K to $5 million
Factor Average Top
Revenues per FTE $100,000 $250,000Net income as % AGI after FMS 10% 35%
Labor costs as a % of AGI 65% 55%
Staff utilization rates (non-mgt.) 70% 95%
Average hourly billing rates $90 $250
Owner’s discretionary income $90,000 $350,000+
Billable to low-billable FTE ratio 1:5
INBOUND15
Key Financial Ratios & MetricsTTG client database of 100+ marketing agencies between $500K to $5 million
Factor Average Top
Revenues per FTE $100,000 $250,000Net income as % AGI after FMS 10% 35%
Labor costs as a % of AGI 65% 55%
Staff utilization rates (non-mgt.) 70% 95%
Average hourly billing rates $90 $250
Owner’s discretionary income $90,000 $350,000+
Billable to low-billable FTE ratio 1:5 1:25
INBOUND15
5 What is your business worth?
#INBOUND15
“1.5 times AGI”
“21% Cap Rate”
“6 times EBITDA”
“Book Value”
INBOUND15
THE PERILS OF VALUATIONS
INBOUND15
(general blank slide)
INBOUND15
(general blank slide)
INBOUND15
(general blank slide)
$ 0
BOOK VALUE METHOD
INBOUND15
(general blank slide)
CAPITALIZATION OF HISTORIC EARNINGS METHOD
INBOUND15
(general blank slide)
DISCOUNTED FUTURE CASH FLOW METHOD
$ 2,889,296
INBOUND15
THE HUSBAND’SCERTIFIED VALUATION ANALYST:
$0.00
INBOUND15
THE HUSBAND’SCERTIFIED VALUATION ANALYST:
$0.00
THE WIFE’SCERTIFIED VALUATION ANALYST:
$4,000,000
INBOUND15
COMMON VALUATION METHODS FOR AGENCIES1. Multiple of EBITDA (Earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, & amortization)
2. Capitalization of historic earnings
3. Discounted future cash flow
4. Percentage Adjusted Gross Income
INBOUND15
Some Problems with the EBITDA Approach
• PRETAX estimates of cash flow
• Does not take THE FUTURE into consideration
• Often results in UNREALISTIC VALUESthat future cash flow may not support
• Certified Valuation Analysts (CVAs) frown upon the approach
EBITDA Is 'BS' EarningsForbes, November 13, 2014
“Beware of geeks bearing formulas.”– Warren Buffett
Buffett’s long-time business partner, Charlie Munger, expressed Berkshire Hathaway’s position on this particular formula best: “I think that, every time you see the word EBITDA, you should substitute the word ‘bullshit’ earnings.”
INBOUND15
Making Common Sense Out of Valuations• Historic numbers don’t lie…high EBITDA or CAP RATE will drive higher value
• Valuations provide a BASE LINE FOR NEGOTIATIONS
• CAP RATE may be more realistic than multiple of EBITDA
• If buyers and sellers can agree on upside potential, DISCOUNTED FUTURE CASH FLOW should be considered
• MULTIPLES are highly SUBJECTIVE
• Potential FINANCIAL SYNERGIES should be factored in
#INBOUND15
The ultimate definition of FAIR VALUE
What a willing buyer and willing seller agree to when neither are under undue pressure to buy or sell.
#INBOUND15
Cash FlowDrives the Deal Value!
MANAGE for 20% or more!
INBOUND15
6 Parting words
#INBOUND15
1. Do some soul-searching
2. Know thy value
3. Consider the possibilities
#INBOUND15
4. Learn, learn, learn
5. Get thy business act together
6. Don’t try this at home
#INBOUND15
GO FOR IT!
#INBOUND15
GO FOR IT!You deserve the
rewards of being an entrepreneur!
#INBOUND15
Free E-Book
www.thetobingroup.com
#INBOUND15
Karl SkutskiDavid Tobin
Pittsburgh & LA
412-418-1231
dtobin@thetobingroup.com
Recommended