Specification Calculations Wallace Library Redesign for Usability Compiled by students in Design...

Specification Calculations

Wallace Library Redesign for Usability

Compiled by students in Design Project Management Spring 2013

Individual- Leisure: Number of CouchesDirection Units Marginal Value Target Value

↓ Couches 1.5 0

There are currently 3 couches on the first floor of the library. Our assumption was a 50/50 split between academic and

leisure use.

In an effort to give spaces an ‘identity’ – and allow students to know the purpose

of the space – the number couches should decrease because it doesn’t make

sense to have furniture that can seat multiple people in an individual area.

Providing group-like seating in an individual area may result in group use.

Individual- Leisure: Number of ChairsDirection Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ Chairs 9.5 13

There are currently 19 soft chairs on the first floor of the library. Our assumption was a 50/50 split between academic

and leisure use.

Target increase of 30% from the current level

Individual- Leisure: Number of TablesDirection Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ Tables 5.5 10

There are currently 11 coffee/small tables on the first floor of the library.

Our assumption was a 50/50 split between academic and leisure use.

Target to have 75% of leisure chairs with a table. From previous slide target

number of chairs is 13 ( 75% of 13 is about 10)

Individual- Leisure: Number of OutletsDirection Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ Outlets 4 5

Current Outlet Observations

Permanent & Accessible

Permanent & Not Accessible

Available with Power-strips

Total

Idea Factory 22 66 4 92

Circulation 23 14 20 57

Private Workspace 6 0 0 6

Computer Area 18 28 10 56

Assumed Idea Factory, Circulation, and Private spaces are currently used for leisure, which provides at total of 51 permanent & accessible outlets. Data collected shows 41 % of observed patrons in these areas were working individually ( ~ 21 outlets)

Assuming an 80% of patrons are using the library for academic purposes and 20% are leisure users: marginal outlets for leisure users is 20% of 21 = 4.2 (rounded down to 4)

Individual- Leisure: Number of OutletsDirection Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ Outlets 4 5

Assumed Idea Factory, Circulation, and Private spaces are currently used for leisure. Data collected shows the maximum needed observed outlets for all of these areas as 57. Data collected shows 41 % of observed patrons in these areas were working individually ( ~ 24 outlets)

Assuming an 80% of patrons are using the library for academic purposes and 20% are leisure users:

target outlets for leisure users is 20% of 24 = 4.8(rounded up to 5)

Individual-Academic: Number of Workstations & Seats

Direction Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ Workstations 13 20

↑ Seats 13 20

Assumed Circulation, Idea Factory, and Private Workspace are currently used for individual-academic work. Data collected shows 25% of observed patrons in these areas were working individually. Currently there are 101 seats in these areas.

Assuming 1 seat = 1.5 workstations (due to the area students occupy with books and notes while doing hw) that is about 17 current workstations in these areas

Assuming an 80% of patrons are using the library for academic purposes and 20% are leisure users:

marginal workstations for academic users is 80% of 17 = 13.6(rounded down to 13)

Individual-Academic: Number of Workstations & Seats

Assumed Circulation, Idea Factory, and Private Workspace are currently used for individual-academic work. Data collected shows 25% of observed patrons in these areas were working individually. If the maximums observed occurred simultaneously there is potential for 148 patrons in these areas at one time. That is 37 workstations.

Assuming an 80% of patrons are using the library for academic purposes and 20% are leisure users:

target workstations for academic users is 80% of 37 = 29.6 (rounded up to 30)

** Target workstation styles are for

individuals, so the 1.5 weighting is not applied here**

Direction Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ Workstations 13 20

↑ Seats 13 20

Individual-Academic: Percentage of ‘soft’ seats at Workstations

Direction Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ % 48 100

Marginal value represents the current state of the first floor:

Chairs

Number with Cushioned Seats 53

Total 110

Cushioned Percentage 48%

Ideally, to provide comfortable workspace seating all chairs

would have ‘soft’ seats

Individual-Academic: Distance between Workstations

Direction Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ Feet 3 6

Minimum ADA requirement Doubled the ADA requirement to allow for easy two-way traffic

Individual-Academic: Sound LevelDirection Units Marginal Value Target Value

↓ dbA 80 40

Online research suggests a typical office environment falls into this range

A loud office environment can reach 80 dbA while a quiet office environment is around 40 dbA

Our target it at the low end of this sound range, since the quiet atmosphere may be more conducive to academic work

Source: http://home.earthlink.net/~dnitzer/4HaasEaton/Decibel.html

Individual- Academic: Number of OutletsDirection Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ Outlets 16 19

Current Outlet Observations

Permanent & Accessible

Permanent & Not Accessible

Available with Power-strips

Total

Idea Factory 22 66 4 92

Circulation 23 14 20 57

Private Workspace 6 0 0 6

Computer Area 18 28 10 56

Assumed Idea Factory, Circulation, and Private spaces are currently used for leisure, which provides at total of 51 permanent & accessible outlets. Data collected shows 41 % of observed patrons in these areas were working individually ( ~ 21 outlets)

Assuming an 80% of patrons are using the library for academic purposes and 20% are leisure users: marginal outlets for leisure users is 80% of 21 = 16.8 (rounded down to 16)

Individual- Academic: Number of OutletsDirection Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ Outlets 16 19

Assumed Idea Factory, Circulation, and Private spaces are currently used for leisure. Data collected shows the maximum needed observed outlets for all of these areas as 57. Data collected shows 41% of observed patrons in these areas were working individually ( ~ 23.3 outlets)

Assuming an 80% of patrons are using the library for academic purposes and 20% are leisure users:

target outlets for academic users is 80% of 23.3 = 18.6(rounded up to 19)

Group-Leisure: Number of CouchesDirection Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ Couches 1.5 4

There are currently 3 couches on the first floor of the library. Our assumption was a 50/50 split between academic and

leisure use.

Increase by 30% from total number of current couches

Target = 3 + 30%

(Recommended to have 0 couches for individual leisure use)

Group-Leisure: Number of ChairsDirection Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ Chairs 9.5 13

There are currently 19 soft chairs on the first floor of the library. Our assumption was a 50/50 split between academic

and leisure use.

Target increase of 30% from the current level

Group-Leisure: Number of TablesDirection Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ Tables 5.5 11

There are currently 11 coffee/small tables on the first floor of the library.

Our assumption was a 50/50 split between academic and leisure use.

Target to have a table for each couch and then 50%

of the leisure chairs

Couch count = 4Chair count = 13

Tables = (4) + (50% of 13)

Group- Leisure: Number of OutletsDirection Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ Outlets 6 7

Current Outlet Observations

Permanent & Accessible

Permanent & Not Accessible

Available with Power-strips

Total

Idea Factory 22 66 4 92

Circulation 23 14 20 57

Private Workspace 6 0 0 6

Computer Area 18 28 10 56

Assumed Idea Factory, Circulation, and Private spaces are currently used for leisure, which provides at total of 51 permanent & accessible outlets. Data collected shows 60% of observed patrons in these areas were working individually (~31 outlets)

Assuming an 80% of patrons are using the library for academic purposes and 20% are leisure users: marginal outlets for leisure users is 20% of 31 = 6.2 (rounded down to 6)

Group- Leisure: Number of OutletsDirection Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ Outlets 6 7

Assumed Idea Factory, Circulation, and Private spaces are currently used for leisure. Data collected shows the maximum needed observed outlets for all of these areas as 57. Data collected shows 60% of observed patrons in these areas were working individually ( ~ 34 outlets)

Assuming an 80% of patrons are using the library for academic purposes and 20% are leisure users:

target outlets for leisure users is 20% of 34 = 6.8(rounded up to 7)

Group-Academic: Number of OutletsDirection Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ Outlets 24 28

Current Outlet Observations

Permanent & Accessible

Permanent & Not Accessible

Available with Power-strips

Total

Idea Factory 22 66 4 92

Circulation 23 14 20 57

Private Workspace 6 0 0 6

Computer Area 18 28 10 56

Assumed Idea Factory, Circulation, and Private spaces are currently used for leisure, which provides at total of 51 permanent & accessible outlets. Data collected shows 60% of observed patrons in these areas were working individually (~31 outlets)

Assuming an 80% of patrons are using the library for academic purposes and 20% are leisure users: marginal outlets for leisure users is 80% of 31 = 24.8 (rounded down to 24)

Group-Academic: Number of OutletsDirection Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ Outlets 24 28

Assumed Idea Factory, Circulation, and Private spaces are currently used for leisure. Data collected shows the maximum needed observed outlets for all of these areas as 57. Data collected shows 60% of observed patrons in these areas were working individually ( ~ 34 outlets)

Assuming an 80% of patrons are using the library for academic purposes and 20% are leisure users:

target outlets for academic users is 80% of 34 = 27.2(rounded up to 28)

Group-Academic: Number of WorkstationsDirection Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ Workstations 18 23

Assumed Circulation and Idea Factory are currently used for group-academic work. Data collected shows 34% of observed patrons in these areas were working individually. Currently there are 101 seats in these areas.

Assuming 1 seat = 1.5 workstations (due to the area students occupy with books and notes while doing hw) that is about 23 current workstations in these areas

Assuming an 80% of patrons are using the library for academic purposes and 20% are leisure users:

marginal workstations for academic users is 80% of 23 = 18.4(rounded down to 18)

Group-Academic: Number of WorkstationsDirection Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ Workstations 18 23

Assumed Circulation and Idea Factory are currently used for group-academic work. Data collected shows 34% of observed patrons in these areas were working in groups of 2 or more people. If the maximums observed occurred simultaneously there is potential for 125 patrons in these areas at one time. 34% of 125 is about 42 workstations.

Assuming 1 seat = 1.5 workstations (due to the area students occupy with books and notes while doing hw) that is about 35 workstations.

Assuming an 80% of patrons are using the library for academic purposes and 20% are leisure users:

Target workstations for academic users is 80% of 35 = 22.4 (rounded up to 23)

Group-Academic: Number of SeatsDirection Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ Seats 27 34

Assumed Circulation and Idea Factory are currently used for group-academic work. Data collected shows 34% of observed patrons in these areas were working individually. Currently there are 101 seats in these areas.

34% of 101 seats is about 34 seats.

Assuming an 80% of patrons are using the library for academic purposes and 20% are leisure users:

marginal seats for academic users is 80% of 34 = 27.2(rounded down to 27)

Group-Academic: Number of SeatsDirection Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ Seats 27 34

Assumed Circulation and Idea Factory are currently used for group-academic work. Data collected shows 34% of observed patrons in these areas were working in groups of 2 or more people. If the maximums observed occurred simultaneously there is potential for 125 patrons in these areas at one time. 34% of 125 is about 42 workstations.

Assuming an 80% of patrons are using the library for academic purposes and 20% are leisure users:

Target workstations for academic users is 80% of 35 = 33.6(rounded up to 34)

Group-Academic: Percentage of ‘soft’ seats at Workstations

Direction Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ % 48 100

Marginal value represents the current state of the first floor:

Chairs

Number with Cushioned Seats 53

Total 110

Cushioned Percentage 48%

Ideally, to provide comfortable workspace seating all chairs

would have ‘soft’ seats

Group-Academic: Distance between Workstations

Direction Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ Feet 3 6

Minimum ADA requirement Doubled the ADA requirement to allow for easy two-way traffic

Group-Academic: Sound LevelDirection Units Marginal Value Target Value

↓ dbA 80 40

Online research suggests a typical office environment falls into this range

A loud office environment can reach 80 dbA while a quiet office environment is around 40 dbA

Our target it at the low end of this sound range, since the quiet atmosphere may be more conducive to academic work

Source: http://home.earthlink.net/~dnitzer/4HaasEaton/Decibel.html

Computer Area: Number of ComputersDirection Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ Computers 36 52

Currently there are 36 computer workstations on the first floor

If the library were to see the maximums observed at the same time

Computer Area: Number of OutletsDirection Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ Outlets 38 55

Out of the 36 available computers, our observational data shows a maximum of 2 people using devices requiring an outlet (2/36 = 5%)

Outlets = # of computers + 5%

Target Outlets = target # of computers + 5%

Computer Area: Number of SeatsDirection Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ Chairs 36 52

Currently there are 36 computer workstations on the first floor If the library were to see

the maximums observed at the same time

General 1st Floor: Percentage of Movable Furniture

Direction Units Marginal Value Target Value

↑ % 47 75

Marginal value represents the current state of the first floor:

Chairs Tables Overall

Number that move freely 98 3 101

Total 171 47 217Movable

Percentage 57% 7% 47%

Realistically, 100% of the furniture does not need to be mobile

In order to satisfy the customer need to reconfigure the space, a

large percentage of furniture need to be mobile

75% was chosen, does that seem reasonable?

General 1st Floor: Number of Blockages to Natural Light

Direction Units Marginal Value Target Value

↓ Blocked Windows 1 0

Currently the Publishing Studio blocks one large window in the Idea Factory, which is limiting the amount of natural light in the space

The proposed layout moves the publishing studio away from the window to better utilize the natural lighting for group workspaces

General 1st Floor: Forms of Customer Use

Metric Units Marginal Target

Contains area for group collaboration Y/N Y Y

Contains area for private work Y/N Y Y

Contains presentation space Y/N Y Y

Contains social space Y/N Y Y

Contains space for ITS Y/N Y Y

Contains space for The Writing Center Y/N Y Y

Contains space for The Publishing Studio Y/N Y Y