Programme on 5 Nov 09

          8.30am – 9.30am - Registration of teams.

          9.30am – 10.30am - Mass briefing & ground rules

          10.30am – 12.00pm – Preliminary Round (submit 1 page proposals)

          12.00pm – 1.30pm – Lunch (catered) + selection of finalist teams (teams that don’t qualify can leave if they want or stay on for the rest of the day)

          1.30pm – 3.15pm – Final Round: A maximum of 13 Finalist teams to prepare short presentation of their Solution (see page 2 of competition form). Teams can visit the library or surf wirelessly (please bring own laptops and use own Wireless.SG accounts).

          3.30pm - 3.45pm – Arrival of GOH

          3.35pm -4.15pm – Presentation by Finalist teams (2 minutes per team; judges may pose clarifying questions)

          4.15pm –4.30 pm – Teabreak (catered) & tabulation of scores

          4.30pm -4.40pm - Closing speech by GOH

          4.45pm – 5.00pm - Prize presentation

Programme on 5 Nov 09

Examples of ‘Stupid’ Questions

And research material uncovered by our librarians supporting the ideas &

solutions generated…

(B) - Association

What if sports attire is made by NASA?

How can aircraft maintenance be done like F1 pit-stop?

What if sneakers are sold through vending machines?

Red Bull London offices

What if working environment is like a What if working environment is like a Recreation Club?Recreation Club?

How can balloons catch pirates?

Creating Stupid Questions:Using the ASQ cards

“What if a SCHOOL is like a RESORT?”

Subject + Association

Association

DeconstructedAttributes

(Yellow card) + (Blue card)

Step 1: Form stupid questions

1. Pick a theme that ties in with the issue or problem that needs to be solved. For the Competition, it will be the 3 themes: Climate change, Clean energy & garden city.

2. Create several stupid questions using 3-5 different sets of Yellow + Blue Cards the ASQ cards to generate possibilities.

3. Write each Stupid Question on a post-it note

4. Begin each Stupid Question with: What if…

Step 1: Form stupid questions

2. Create several stupid questions using 3-5 different sets of Yellow + Blue Cards the ASQ cards to generate possibilities. Example:

“What if a SCHOOL is like a RESORT?”

1. Select one Stupid Question from your list of 5

2. Combine attributes from the Yellow + Blue cards to create Features, e.g. Free & Easy + CurriculumRoom Service + TeachersSeaside + ClassroomsBuffet + Timetable

3. Write a brief description for each Feature, for the benefit of the judges. Try to make sense of each Feature. You can play with different meanings of each word, or swop the placement of the words.

Step 2: Combine attributes

2. Combine attributes from the Yellow + Blue cards to create Features, e.g.

Step 2: Combine attributes

Curriculum + Free & Easy

=

“A flexible curriculum for pupils…”

A School Retreat

Room Service + Teachers

Free & Easy +

Curriculum

Seaside +

Classrooms

Buffet + Timetable

“How can a SCHOOL be like a RESORT?”

Combine the 4 Features into a holistic idea that addresses your Stupid Question:

Step 3: Generate solution

• Check: Have you decided if your Solution is a Product / Service / Framework / Process / Policy etc? Please indicate by checking the relevant box in the form. Try to avoid creating a super solution that encompasses everything.

• Check: Does your Solution incorporate all 4 Features?

• Check: Does your Solution address the theme you selected?

Step 3: Generate solution

1. List the tangible & intangible benefits of your Solution

2. Describe the possible issues or challenges in implementing your new Product, Service, Framework or Process, and ways to overcome them

3. What is the estimated cost of implementing your Solution (in Singapore dollars)? Please give a break down of the major cost components, e.g. “Manpower = $20,000”. While this will have no bearing on the scoring by judges, it will force the team to think about the feasibility of its solution.

Step 4: Defending your Solution(for Finalists)

Judging Criteria (1)

Preliminary Round (morning)

Equal weightage for all 4 criteria. Rating on a 5-point scale of 1 (lowest) to 5 (highest):

• Relevance – solution addresses the selected theme

• Creativity – solution is creative and out-of-the-box

• Originality – solution is unique and not common knowledge

• Feasibility – solution is easy to implement and is affordable

This round will be evaluated by NLB’s ASQ facilitators.

Final Round (afternoon)

Weightage of each criterion in parantheses. Rating on a 5-point scale of 1 (lowest) to 5 (highest):

• Relevant & Feasible (25%) – solution addresses the selected theme & is easy to implement or produce or offer as a service

• Creativity & Originality (30%) – solution is unique & out-of-the-box

• Rigor (30%) – solution is well thought out and watertight, and research is evident

• Quality of presentation (15%)

This round will be evaluated by a panel of judges

Judging Criteria (2)

1. Familiarise the team with the use of the ASQ cards. Those used in the competition will have different words & designs, and will be smaller in size, they are used in the same way.

2. Read up on the 3 themes: Climate Change, Clean Energy & Garden City. The yellow Subject cards will focus on aspects of these themes.

3. Stay healthy to minimise chance of falling sick on 5 November.

Preparing your team

Resources are parked at:Resources are parked at:http://blogs.nlb.gov.sg/asqmhttp://blogs.nlb.gov.sg/asqm

Enquiries? Contact me at:Enquiries? Contact me at:

damien_wang@nlb.gov.sgdamien_wang@nlb.gov.sg