OpenInsight V2N2-Dialogica p83

7/17/2019 OpenInsight V2N2-Dialogica p83

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/openinsight-v2n2-dialogica-p83 1/31

!"#$%&' ")*+,-' !" ./+*-/ ./+%0+.+& 1- "! 2$',+0+! -% "! 3,-&/)! 1- "! 2$',+0+!4 1- 25 /!6"'

Montserrat Salomón Ferrer

Universidad Panamericana

msalomonf@gmail.com

!"#$ #&'(')* &$+,"' -' .&*./$"#' .*-0#,1' 2$ 3*45 6'7-" ' -'-/8 2$ -'" ,5"/9,1,$51,'" :/$ &$+$-'5 -*" #&'(')*" 2$ ;$5 < 2$='5,$-"> 1*5 $- .&*.?",#* 2$ 1*51,-,'& -*" .&,51,.,*" 2$ -'

)/"#,1,' < -'" 5*1,*5$" 2$ -,($&#'2 $ ,@/'-2'2A B,5'-C$5#$> -'"1&0#,1'" 2$ $"#*" '/#*&$" '- .$5"'C,$5#* .*-0#,1* 2$ 6'7-""$&D5> ' "/ +$8> &$+,"'2'" 1*5 +,"#'" ' /5' C*2,9,1'1,?5 2$ -'

#$*&0' &'7-",'5' :/$ .$&C,#' /5' .&*./$"#' "*1,'- CD" ,@/'E-,#'&,'A

Palabras clave: Rawls, Daniels, Sen, Justicia, Igualdad.

!"#$ &'&() )(*#(+$ ,-". /'+0$1 &-0#2#3'0 2"(-)4 2")-56" #2$#.$577#3#(.3#($8 '$ #2 #$ )(*('0(9 :4 ;(. '.9 <'.#(0$1 +-)=$8$- 2"'2 >5$2#3(1$ &)#.3#&0($8 0#:()24 '.9 (?5'0#24 @'4 :( 3-.A3('0(9B C#.'0048 2"( 3)#2#?5( @'9( 2- /'+0$1 &-0#2#3'0 2"(-)4

:4 2"($( '52"-)$ $"'00 :( )(*#(+(9 2--8 #. 2"( :("'07 -7 '

@-)( (?5'0 $-3#'0 2"(-)4B

Keywords: Rawls, Daniels, Sen, Justice, Equality.

Algunos límites al primer principio de la justicia en la Teoría de la justicia de J. Rawls

!" $%&$'()*" +( ,&-. /"01) () $%&2"21(3(.*( 1" "$&%*"456. 37) 538

$&%*".*( " 1" 951&)&9:" $&1:*54" +(1 )5;1& <<= >. (11" )( %(4&;(. 1")$%(&4'$"45&.() -'3".5*"%5") )'%;5+") *%") 1") ;%".+() ;'(%%") ? )( 1")-"4( 4&3$"*521() 4&. '." $&)*'%" 152(%"1= !" 5.*(.456. () ;"%".*5@"%

1") 152(%*"+() 45'+"+".") )5. +()$%&*(;(% " 1&) ;%'$&) +()9"A&%(45+&)=B(.*%& +( 1" "A"1".4-" +( 4&3(.*"+&%() C'( -" )')45*"+& 1" $'8

2154"456. +( 1" (. DEFDG .& -". 9"1*"+& C'5(.()5.*(.*". 3&A(% )') $&)*'1"+&) -"45" *(%%(.&) 37) 5;'"15*"%5&) (. (14&.*(H*& +( 1" +5)*%52'456. +( %(4'%)&)= I( $"%(4( 41"%& C'( 1" 5.8

*(.456. +(1 "'*&% (%" J')*5954"% 4'"1C'5(% +()A5"456. +( '." +5A5)56.+( %(4'%)&) 5;'"15*"%5" 2")7.+&)( (. 1&) +&) $%5.45$5&) +( 1" J')*545"KL9%= /"01)G DEEMN $=OPDQG " )"2(%N

R%53(% $%5.45$5&N

L"+" $(%)&." -" +( *(.(% '. +(%(4-& 5;'"1

"1 37) (H*(.)& )5)*(3" *&*"1 +( 152(%*"+() 27)54") 4&3$"*521(4&. '. )5)*(3" )5351"% +( 152(%*"+ $"%" *&+&)=

S(;'.+& R%5.45$5&N

!") +()5;'"1+"+() (4&.6354") ? )&45"1()-". +( )(% ()*%'4*'%"+") +( 3".(%" C'( )(". $"%"N

"Q 3"?&% 2(.(9545& +( 1&) 3(.&) "A(.*"J"+&) +( "4'(%+&4&. '. $%5.45$5& +( "-&%%& J')*& ? C'( ()*T

2Q '.5+& " 1&) 4"%;&) ? 1") 9'.45&.() ")(C'521() $"%" *&+&)? (. 4&.+545&.() +( J')*" 5;'"1+"+ +( &$&%*'.5+"+()=

B( ()*( 3&+&G $%(A5" ;"%".*:" +(1 )5)*(3" 37) (H*(.)& $&)521( +( 158 2(%*"+() 27)54") 5;'"1() $"%" *&+&)G 4'"1C'5(% +()5;'"1+"+ (4&.63584" & )&45"1 +(2( ")(;'%"% 1" 5;'"1+"+ +( &$&%*'.5+"+() ? 3"H535@"%(1 .5A(1 +( 25(.() $%53"%5&) +( 1&) ;%'$&) 3(.&) "A(.*"J"+&)= S5.(32"%;&G "'*&%() 4&3& U3"%*?" S(. ? V&%3". B".5(1) 4&.)5+(%".C'( 1" $%&$'()*" C'(+" 4&%*" "1 "."15@"% 1&) 4")&) 1:35*( +( 1" $&2%(@"

? 1" +5)4"$"45+"+=>)*&) 4")&) 1:35*( 1(A".*". 1" $%(;'.*" )&2%( )5 () .(4()"%5& ")(8

;'%"% '. 45(%*& .5A(1 27)54& +( 25(.() $%53"%5&)G 5.41')& " 4&)*" +(

!"#"$%& %!()*+, %,-./$+, 0. !% !"1.&$%0 0. !% ,+/".0%0 -%&% 2). !+,(&)-+, #.*+, %3.*$%4%0+, -).0%* (+5%& 0. )*% !"1.&$%0 .6./$"3% 7*+ ,+!+ 6+&#%!8 9* +$&%, -%!%1&%,: ,. -&.()*$% ," !% &.!%/";* .*$&. !+,

-&"*/"-"+, 0. !% 4),$"/"% 0. <%=!, 7 ,), /+*,./).*/"%, 0",$&"1)$"3%,%,.()&%* !% "()%!0%0 .* !% !"1.&$%0 -%&% $+0+, !+, (&)-+, ,+/"%!.,:"*/!)"0+, !+, -+1&., 7 !+, 0",/%-%/"$%0+,8

9* .,$. $&%1%4+ %*%!"5%&.#+, 1&.3.#.*$. !% -&+-).,$% 0. <%=!, 1),/%*0+ !% /+*/"!"%/";* .*$&. !+, -&"*/"-"+, 0. !% 4),$"/"% 7 !%, *+>/"+*., 0. !"1.&$%0 . "()%!0%08 ?+,$.&"+&#.*$. ,.()"&.#+, !%, /&@$"/%,-&+-).,$%, % .,$% -+,$)&% -+& A.* 7 B%*".!,8 C"*%!#.*$. "*$.*$%&.>#+, .3%!)%& !%, /&@$"/%, -%&% /+*/!)"& ," !% -+,$)&% 0. <%=!, 0.1.: .*

.6./$+: #+0"6"/%&,. + %#-!"%&,. D%/"% )*% -+,$)&% #E, "()%!"$%&"%8

F.+&@% 0. !% 4),$"/"% !" $%&'(

A%1.#+, 2). )*% 0. !%, /&@$"/%, /+#)*., % !% -+,$)&% 0. <%=!, .,2). -%&$. 0. )*% ,+/".0%0 +//"0.*$%! %3%*5%0% 7 2). ,), -+,$)!%0+,D%/.* %()% % !% D+&% 0. "*$.*$%& %-!"/%&!+, % !%, /+#-!.4%, ,"$)%/"+*.,

&.%!., 0. !% #%7+&@% 0. !%, /+#)*"0%0., D)#%*%,8 ?%&% %/.&/%&*+, %.,$. -&+1!.#% 0. !% -).,$% .* -&E/$"/% 0. !% "()%!0%0 .* !% !"1.&$%0:.#-.5%&G -+& 0.!"*.%& 1&.3.#.*$. !% "0.% 0. )*% ,+/".0%0 1".* +&>

0.*%0% .* .! %)$+& 0. !%

9* )*% ,+/".0%0 1".* +&0.*%0% !% .,$&)/$)&% 0. !% #",#% H ,), "*,$"$)/"+*., 7 !%, &.!%/"+*., .*$&. !%, .I-./$%$"3%, 0. !+, (&)>-+, ,+/"%!., 0.,"()%!.,H 0.1.* .,$%& &.("0%, -+& !+, -&"*/"-"+, 0.!% 4),$"/"%8J B. .,$. #+0+: K0%*0+ -+& .,$%1!./"0+ .! #%&/+ 0. !%,

"*,$"$)/"+*., &.2).&"0%, -+& !% !"1.&$%0 "()%! 7 !% 4),$% "()%!0%0 0.+-+&$)*"0%0.,: !%, .I-./$%$"3%, #E, .!.3%0%, 0. 2)".*., .,$E* #.4+&,"$)%0+, ,+* 4),$%, ," 7 ,+!+ ," 6)*/"+*%* /+#+ -%&$. 0. )* .,2).#%2). #.4+&% !%, .I-./$%$"3%, 0. !+, #".#1&+, #.*+, 6%3+&./"0+, 0.!% ,+/".0%0L M<%=!,: JNNOP -8QJR8 S,@: <%=!, -&.$.*0. %,.()&%&: -+&

Parto de ellos y me concentro en las consecuencias que se siguen para los conceptos

de igualdad y libertad.

!" $%&'( $% $)*+,-%& ).!%$ /%,% -'&'0 $'0 1)!&%&%"'0 2( /', +$ '-,'(3)-).%, $%0 &+0).!%$&%&+0 0'1)'4+1'"53)1%0 %$ 6%1+,$%0 &+/+"&+, &+$% 3+7',% &+ $% /'0)1)5" 380 &+09+"-%7'0%: ;% ).!%$&%& +0-8 %0+.!,%&%

/', $%0 3)03%0 $)*+,-%&+0 /%,% -'&'0 $'0 1)!&%&%"'0 2 $% &+0).!%$&%&+0-8 ,+&!1)&% 2 %1'-%&% % $% 9+"-%7% &+$ 3+"'0 <%9',+1)&' +" !"%0!+,-+ &+ =.%"%,4.%"%,> +"-,+ $%0 1$%0+0 0'1)%$+0:

;% /,)"1)/%$ /,+'1!/%1)5" +" +0-+ 1'"-+?-' +0-,)*% +" %0+.!,%,$% ).!%$ 1)!&%&%"@% &+ $%0 /+,0'"%0:A B+ +0-+ 3'&'( 0+ %0+.!,%" -%"-'$'0 &+,+16'0 2 $)*+,-%&+0 1'3' $%0 <!+"-+0 &+$ %!-',,+0/+-' &+ $%0/+,0'"%0: C0-+ /!"-' ,+1)*+ +$ D"<%0)0 2 $% /,)',)&%& +" $% /'0-!,%&+ E%F$0( $% 1!+0-)5" &+ $% &)0-,)*!1)5" &+ ,+1!,0'0 +0( /', -%"-'(

0+1!"&%,)% % $% ,%-)<)1%1)5" &+ $%0 $)*+,-%&+0:G,%1)%0 % $% ',&+"%1)5" H!+ 0+ &+,)9% &+ $'0 /,)"1)/)'0 2 &+ $%

*I0H!+&% /,)3',&)%$ &+ $% ).!%$&%& &+ $% 1)!&%&%"@%( !"% 0'1)+&%& *)+" ',&+"%&% 0+ &+<)"+ 1'3'J

K"% 0'1)+&%& ,+.!$%&% 1'" +<)1)+"1)% /', !"% 1'"1+/1)5"/I*$)1% &+ $% 7!0-)1)%: ;'0 3)+3*,'0 &+ &)16% 0'1)+&%& 0'"2 0+ 1'"0)&+,%" /+,0'"%0 $)*,+0 2 1'" $% 3)03% ).!%$&%&

3',%$L ' 0+% H!+ 1%&% !"' -)+"+ 2 1,++ /'0++, '*7+-)9'0 +)"-+,+0+0 *80)1'0 +" "'3*,+ &+ $'0 H!+ +0 $+.@-)3' +7+,1+,3!-!%0 +?).+"1)%0L % $% 9+M( 1%&% !"' &+ +$$'0 -)+"+ 2 0+ 0%*+

/'0++&', &+$ &+,+16' % ).!%$ ,+0/+-' 2 1'"0)&+,%1)5" +" $%&+-+,3)"%1)5" &+ $'0 /,)"1)/)'0( 0+.I" $'0 H!+ 6% &+ 0+, ',4.%")M%&% $% +0-,!1-!,% *80)1% &+ 0! 0'1)+&%& NOP 2 &%&' H!+0!0 '*7+-)9'0 + )"-+,+0+0 <!"&%3+"-%$+0 +0-8" /,'-+.)&'0 /',$%0 $)*+,-%&+0 %3/%,%&%0 /', +$ /,)3+, /,)"1)/)'( $+ '-',.%"

% D0-+ &)16% /,)',)&%& QE%F$0( RSSTJ USVW:

X'&+3'0 9+, H!+ +$ 1',%M5" &+ $% /,'/!+0-% +0-8 +" +$ ,+1'"'1)43)+"-' &+ $'0 1)!&%&%"'0 +"-,+ 0@( +0 &+1),( $% ).!%$&%& &+ 1)!&%&%"@%(

desde la posición de igual ciudadanía. Esta posición se define por los derechos y li-

oportunidades. Cuando los dos principios se satisfacen, todos son ciudadanos iguales

! #$ %& '($)#'*#$'+& ,# #)-# .#'($('+/+#$-(0 %& .#'+1.('+,&,2 3%'($)+,#.&.)# '+*,&,&$() '($ %() /+)/() ,#.#'4() ! %+5#.-&,#)6 %&)#7+8#$'+&) 9*# 4&'#$ 1&.& .#&%+:&. )* '($'#1'+;$ ,#% 5+#$ #$ )* <+,&

9*#,&$ &)#8*.&,&) &% ,&.%# 1.+(.+,&, &% 1.+$'+1+( ,# +8*&% %+5#.-&,2=& 1.#8*$-& #) )+ #)-& %+5#.-&, &)#8*.&,& #) )*>+'+#$-# 1&.& %& .#&%+:&?'+;$ ,# %&) 1#.)($&)6 ,&,&) %&) ,+>#.#$'+&) 1#./+-+,&) 1(. #% )#8*$,(

1.+$'+1+(6 ( )+ )# 9*#,& /#.&/#$-# #$ *$ $+<#% >(./&%2

@% 1.(5%#/& 9*# +$-#$-&.A ,#%+$#&. #) #% ,# %& ,#/&$,& 1(. *$& %+? 5#.-&, +8*&% ,#% 1.+/#. 1.+$'+1+( ! )* .#%&'+;$ '($ #% #>#'-( ,#% )#?8*$,( 1.+$'+1+(0 %&) ,#)+8*&%,&,#) #$ %() 5+#$#) 1.+/&.+() ! %& ,#)?+8*&%,&, #$ #% #B#.'+'+( #>#'-+<( ,# %& %+5#.-&,2 @)-# 1.(5%#/& 1(,.C&

#71.#)&.)# '($ %& )+8*+#$-# 1.#8*$-&0 D)# 1*#,# -#$#. *$ )+)-#/& 9*# 5*)9*# %& /E7+/& #7-#$)+;$ ,# %+5#.-&,#) +8*&%#) )+$ #7+?8+. .#,*'+. )+8$+>+'&-+<&/#$-# %&) ,+>#.#$'+&) #$ .+9*#:& ! 1(,#.F G#

#)-& >(./& +$-#$-&.A 1($#. & 1.*#5& %() &%'&$'#) ,# %& +8*&% %+5#.-&,,# %& ,# H&I%)2

3*-(.#) '(/( J#$ ! G&$+#%) (5B#-&$ & H&I%) 9*# $( 1&.#'# -#?

$#. )#$-+,( 1()-*%&. 9*# )(/() %+5.#) ,# ( 1&.& &%8( )+ #$ #>#'-( $(1(,#/() #B#.'#. #>#'-+<&/#$-# #)-& %+5#.-&,2 =& 1.#('*1&'+;$ #)-E#$ -#$#. %+5#.-&,#) !K( ,#.#'4() 9*# )# 9*#,#$ .#,*'+,() & *$&#$*$'+&'+;$ >(./&% ! 9*# $( -#$8&$ *$ '(..#%&-( #$ %& <+,& ,# %&)1#.)($&)2 @$ 1('&) 1&%&5.&)6 D'*E$-( <&%# %& %+5#.-&, )+ $( -#$#/() %&

'&1&'+,&, ,# #B#.'#.%&FL# 1&.#'# 9*# *$ 1*$-( '.*'+&% 1&.& #% 1%&$-#&/+#$-( ,# #)-#

1.(5%#/& #) %& ,+)-+$'+;$ #$-.# %& %+5#.-&, $#8&-+<& ! %& %+5#.-&, 1(?)+-+<&2 M&.& &'%&.&. #)-() -A./+$() &'*,( & N#.%+$ O

6 &*-(. '*!& +$>%*#$'+& #$ H&I%) $( 1*#,# '*#)-+($&.)#2

DM(,#/() 4&5%&. ,# %+5#.-&,#) )+ $( -#$#/() %& '&1&'+,&, #>#'-+<&,# #B#.'#.%&)F

!" $%&'()"* +',")%-" .' ('/%'(' " $". 0('". *' $" -%*" ('.'(-"*" *'%+)'(-'+1%2+ '3)'(+"4 5. *'1%(6 $7. '.8"1%7. 9:' *'&'+ ('.'(-"(.'8"(" $" 78'("1%2+ *'$ %+*%-%*:7 ";'+7. " 1:"$9:%'( %+)'(/'('+1%"4 <7(

7)(7 $"*76 $" $%&'()"* 87.%)%-" .' ('/%'(' " $" ":)7*')'(=%+"1%2+ 8"(""$,76 '. *'1%(6 $" $%&'()"* 9:' :+" 8'(.7+" )%'+' *' ';'(1'( .: 8$"+ *'"11%2+ .%+ 9:' .'" 7&.)"1:$%>"*" 7 ="+';"*" *'.*' '$ '3)'(%7(4 ?=&".

$%&'()"*'. "8"('1'+ 17=7 /%+'. '+ .@ =%.=7.6 8'(7 8:'*'+ 1A71"('+)(' .@ BC/(4 D'($%+6 EFFGH 84IGJ4

5+ '$ 17+)'3)7 *'$ 8('.'+)' )("&";7 =' ,:.)"(@" ('$"1%7+"( $"$%&'()"* +',")%-" 17+ $" %,:"$ $%&'()"* 9:' &:.1" ".',:("( '$ 8(%='(8(%+1%8%7 *' $" ;:.)%1%"4 <7( 7)(7 $"*76 *"*7 9:' $" 87.%&%$%*"* *'

';'(1'( $7. 8$"+'. *' -%*" *'.*' $" ":)78('.1(%81%2+ '.)0 '+1$"-"*" '+'$ .',:+*7 8(%+1%8%76 $7 ('$"1%7+"(K 17+ $" $%&'()"* 87.%)%-"4 L' 8"M('1' 9:' $" $%&'()"* 87.%)%-" +7 8:'*' .'8"("(.' )";"+)'='+)' *' $".17+*%1%7+'. +'1'."(%". 8"(" .: ';'(1%1%74 <7( '.)76 $". 17+.'1:'+1%".*'$ .',:+*7 8(%+1%8%7 N$" *%.)(%&:1%2+ *'$ @+*%1' *' &%'+'. .71%"$'.

8(%="(%7.N 17+$$'-"+ :+ /:'()' ('1$"=7 *' ;:.)%/%1"1%2+ *' 1"(" " $"%,:"$*"* 1%:*"*"+" 8(')'+*%*" 87( O"P$.4

<"(" O"P$.6 $" *%/'('+1%" '.)"(0 '+ $" $%&'()"* Q '$ -"$7( *' $"

$%&'()"*H 87*'=7. ".',:("( $" %,:"$*"* *' $". $%&'()"*'. &0.%1". .%+9:' .'" +'1'."(%7 ".',:("( $" %,:"$*"* *' 17+*%1%7+'. '/'1)%-". 8"("$" 8:'.)" '+ 8(01)%1" *' $7. 8$"+'. *' -%*" $%&('='+)' '$',%*7. 87(

$7. 1%:*"*"+7.4 5. *'1%(6 .7=7. $%&('. *' '$',%( 12=7 -%-%(6 8'(7 +7)'+'=7. ".',:("*" $" 87.%&%$%*"* *' -%-%( '/'1)%-"='+)' 17=7 $7 A'M=7. '$',%*74 R5. '.)7 :+" -%7$"1%2+ *' $" ;:.)%1%"ST

sencillo puesto que su meta es darle prioridad a la libertad para -

demasiado pobre, ignorante o débil para hacer uso de sus derechos, la libertad que és-

tos le confieren no significa nada para él, pero no por ello es aniquilada dicha libertad.

de dar las oportunidades necesarias para el desarrollo de las artes y de las ciencias y de

impedir desigualdades arbitrarias y tácticas políticas, sociales y legales reaccionarias,

no se hace menos estricta porque no vaya dirigida necesariamente a la promoción de

posible que sea valioso tenerla, o al establecimiento de valores que puede que sean

!"# %&'#"( ") "% (")*&+, -,(&*&., &/-%&01 "(*1# %&'#"( +" 0,100&2)"3*"#&,# ") %1 #"1%&410&2) +" )5"(*#1( /"*1(67 8% -5)*, 0%1." -1#191:%( "( ;5" %,( -#&)0&-&,( '5(01) ,#+")1# %1 "(*#50*5#1 '<(&01 +"

%1 (,0&"+1+= +" %1 051% +"-")+") /50>,( ?10*,#"( (,0&,"0,)2/&0,(;5"= 1 %1 %1#@1= +"?&)") %1 -,(&'&%&+1+ +" 100&2) +" %,( &)+&.&+5,(6A" "(*" /,+,= %1 -,'#"41 , %1 +"'&%&+1+ +" 5)1 -"#(,)1 , @#5-, +"

-"#(,)1( B (5 0,)("05")*" +&?&05%*1+ +" 100&2) -,+#C1) 0,)(&+"#1#("5)1 &)*"#.")0&2) "3*"#)1 B= -,# *1)*,= 5)1 ?1%*1 +" %&'"#*1+6 !& "(*,"( 1(C= "% #"0%1/, -,# 1("@5#1# %1( 0,)+&0&,)"( -1#1 "% "D"#0&0&, +" %1%&'"#*1+ ), ("#C1 1%@, *1) +&(*&)*, 1% #"0%1/, -,# %1 %&'"#*1+ /&(/16

E1 -#"@5)*1 "( (& %1( 0,)+&0&,)"( (,0&,"0,)2/&01( -,+#C1) -#"F

(")*1#(" 0,/, ?10*,#"( >"*"#2),/,( ;5" %&/&*") %1 %&'"#*1+ +" %,(>,/'#"(= D5(*&?&01)+, 1(C 5)1 &)*"#.")0&2) /<( &@51%&*1#&1= 0,) (5(0,)("05")*"( #"(*#&00&,)"( 1 %1( %&'"#*1+"(= 0,/, ?,#/1 +" 1("@5#1#%1 &@51%+1+ ")*#" %,( 0&5+1+1),(6

G@51%+1+= #"0,),0&/&")*, B 15*,##"(-"*,H %&'"#*1+ -,(&*&.1 B %&'"#F*1+ )"@1*&.1

I,/, >"/,( .&(*,= ") -"#(-"0*&.1 +" 91:%(= 051%;5&"# +"(.&10&2)+"% *#1*1/&")*, &@51% +"'" ("# .1%&+1+1 +"(+" %1 1-%&010&2) +" %,(-#&)0&-&,( +" %1 D5(*&0&16 8(*" (&(*"/1= 1% ("# 10"-*1+, -,# *,+,( %,(0&5+1+1),(= "( %1 '1(" -1#1 "% #"0,),0&/&")*, #"0C-#,0, B %1( /5*51("3&@")0&1( (,0&1%"(6 E1 '1(" -1#1 %1 &@51%+1+ "(*< ") *")"# 1("@5#1F

+, "% /<( 1/-%&, (&(*"/1 +" +"#"0>,( B %&'"#*1+"( 0,/-1*&'%" -1#1

“El sentido ‘positivo’ de la palabra ‘libertad’ se deriva del deseo por parte del indi-

viduo de ser su propio dueño. Quiero que mi vida y mis decisiones dependan de mí

mismo, y no de fuerzas exteriores, sean éstas del tipo que sean. […] Quiero ser alguien,

ser movido por la naturaleza exterior o por otros hombres como si fuera una cosa, un

medios propios y realizarlos […] Yo me siento libre en la medida en que creo que esto

es verdad y me siento esclavizado en la medida en que me hacen darme cuenta de que

!"#"$ &"$ '()#*#*+"$, -$!. .$ .& /)+!" +" +.0"'(*1&., 2(.+!3*$ !.+0*45"$ .$!* (0)*&#*#6 &*$ #.$(0)*&#*#.$ 73)!" #.& /3(+'(/(" #. #(7.3.+'(*/).#.+ $"/"3!*3$. 5(.+!3*$ .$!8+ #.$!(+*#*$ * 5.9"3*3 &* $(!)*'(:+

#. &*$ /"$('("+.$ (+7.3("3.$ #. &* $"'(.#*#, ;. .$!. 5"#" &* (0)*&#*#.$!< '.+!3*#* .+ &* (0)*&#*# #. '"+$(#.3*'(:+ = +" .+ &* /*3(#*# #.3.')3$"$, >?*$ #.$@(*'("+.$ #.& !3*!*5(.+!" (0)*& !(.+.+ A). $.36 .+

'*#* '*$"6 #.7.+#(#*$ = 9)B0*#*$ (5/*3'(*&5.+!. '"5" $($!.5* #./3(+'(/("$ A). .$ @<&(#" /*3* !"#"$C $. .+!(.+#. A). &* (0)*&#*# .$.+4'(*& .$ &* (0)*&#*# #. '"+$(#.3*'(:+,D EF*G&$6 HIIJK LJMN

O+* @.B *$.0)3*#* .$!* (0)*&#*# /).#.+ /.35(!(3$. #.$(0)*&4#*#.$ .+ .& 3./*3!" #. 3.')3$"$ $(.5/3. = ')*+#" ')5/&*+ '"+ &*

5.9"3* #. &* $(!)*'(:+ #. &"$ 5<$ #.$*@.+!*9*#"$, -$!" 3.$/.!*+#"$(.5/3. $) '*&(#*# #. '()#*#*+"$ #(0+"$ #. .$!(5*'(:+, >2(.+!3*$A). .$!"$ /3(+'(/("$ /.35(!.+ #.$(0)*&#*#.$ * '"+$.').+'(* #. &*$'"+!3(1)'("+.$ A). $. 3.*&(B*+ .+ 1.+.7('(" #. !"#"$6 &* /3..5(+.+4'(* #. &* &(1.3!*# (5/&('* &* (0)*&#*# .+ &*$ 1*$.$ $"'(*&.$ #. &* .$!(4

5*'(:+D EF*G&$6 HIIJK /,LIPN,

?* (0)*&#*#K &(1.3!*# = "/"3!)+(#*#.$

-$!* (0)*&#*# '()#*#*+* .$!< '"5/&.5.+!*#* '"+ &* &&*5*#* (0)*&#*#

#. "/"3!)+(#*#.$, Q"3 5.#(" #. .$!"6 $. 1)$'* 0*3*+!(B*3 &* 5"@(&(4#*# $"'(*&, O+ '()#*#*+" !.+#3R* *''.$" * &*$ 5($5*$ "/"3!)+(#*#.$A). &"$ "!3"$ $(+ (5/"3!*3 $) /3"'.#.+'(* $"'(*&6 /.35(!(8+#"&. *$R5.9"3*3 $) /*3!('(/*'(:+ .+ .& 3./*3!" #. &"$ 1(.+.$ /3(5*3("$,

?* '&*@. /*3* &* (0)*&#*# #. "/"3!)+(#*#.$ .$ 5*+!.+.3 *1(.3!*$

= $(5(&*3.$ &*$ "/'("+.$ #. .#)'*'(:+ #. &"$ '()#*#*+"$ *$R '"5" &*$"/'("+.$ #. .5/&.", -$!" 0*3*+!(B*3R* &* /3./*3*'(:+ #. &"$ 5($5"$= $) '"5/.!(!(@(#*# .+ .& 5.3'*#" &*1"3*& 1*$<+#"$. .+ $)$ '*/*'(4#*#.$ = .$7).3B"C +" .+ .&.5.+!"$ *31(!3*3("$ '"5" &* /3"'.#.+'(*$"'(*&6 .& 08+.3" " &* 3*B*, S .$!. 3.$/.'!"6 $.T*&* F*G&$K >&* 9)$!*(0)*&#*# #. "/"3!)+(#*#.$ $(0+(7('* )+ '"+9)+!" #. (+$!(!)'("+.$ A).

*$.0)3. &* (0)*&#*# #. "/"3!)+(#*#.$ /*3* &* .#)'*'(:+ = &* ')&!)43* #. /.3$"+*$ $(5(&*35.+!. '*/*'(!*#*$6 = 5*+!.+0* &"$ !3*1*9"$

= &"$ .5/&."$ *1(.3!"$ * !"#"$6 $"13. &* 1*$. #. &*$ '*/*'(#*#.$ =

!" $%& "&'(")*%& )+*%,+-$".",/" )"$+01%,+!%& 0%, $+& /+)"+& 2 /)+-+3 4%& 5")/1,",/"&6 78+9$&: ;<<=> 5?@ABC? D&E: 8+9$& $%F)+ (,+ -+&" !"1F(+$!+! ", "$ ,G0$"% &%01+$ 2 5").1/" $+& !1'")",01+& ", $%& +&5"03

/%& .",%& ."!($+)"& 0%.% "$ )"5+)/% !" )"0()&%&? H&/+& !1'")",01+&,% )"5)"&",/+)I, (,+ 0%,!",+ &%01+$ F)+01+& + J(" &" F+)+,/1*+: !"$.1&.% .%!% J(" $+ $1-")/+! -I&10+ 01(!+!+,+: $+ 1F(+$!+! !" %5%)3

/(,1!+!"& 0%.% %501K, 5+)+ ."4%)+) "$ E,!10" !" -1","& &%01+$"& 5)13.+)1%& J(" /",".%&?

L+ 5)1%)1!+! !" $+ $1-")/+!> 5)1.") 5)1,0151%

M%.% N".%& O1&/%: $+ 5%&/()+ )+9$&1+,+ !"&0+,&+ ", !+)$" 5)1%)1!+!+ $+ $1-")/+! 5%) &%-)" 0(+$J(1") 0%&+ ", "$ %)!", &%01+$? H&/% "& +&E:5("&/% J(" 0%,&1!")+ J(" 5)1.")% !"-".%& &") 0+5+0"& !" +&"F()+)3,%& $+ $1-")/+! !" "$"F1) ,("&/)+ 0%,0"501K, !"$ -1", 2 $+& %501%,"&

O1/+$"& J(" 5",&+.%& 5")&"F(1): 2 $("F% !"-".%& 5")&"F(1)$+& "'"03/1O+.",/"? H& !"01): 5+)+ 5%!") &") $1-)"& N+0") +$F% ", 5+)/130($+): 5)1.")% ,"0"&1/+.%& &") $1-)"& !" 5%!") 5)%5%,"),%& 5$+,"&

5")/","01",/"& + "&" FP,")%? H&/+ "& $+ 5)1%)1!+! !" $+& $1-")/+!"& ,"3F+/1O+&: ", "$ &",/1!% !" $1-")/+!"& -I&10+& 2 !")"0N%&: 5%) &%-)" $+&$1-")/+!"& 5%&1/1O+& 2 $+ )"+$1*+01K, 'I0/10+ !" $%& 5)%5K&1/%& "$"F1!%&?

L+ 5)1%)1!+! J(" &" $" !+ + $+ $1-")/+! "& /+$ J(" &%$% 5("!" &"))"&/)1,F1!+ + '+O%) !" $+ $1-")/+! .1&.+? H& !"01): $+ $1-")/+! 5("!"$1.1/+)&" &%$% &1 "&/+ $1.1/+01K, 0%,$$"O+ + )"'%)*+) $+& $1-")/+!"& !" $+&%01"!+! ", &( 0%,4(,/% 2: +!".I&: &1 "&" "&/+!% !" 0%&+& "& +0"5/+-$"5+)+ $+ 5")&%,+ 2Q% F)(5% J(" &"+ +'"0/+!% ", &( &1&/".+ !" $1-")/+3

!"& 7M')? 8+9$&: ;<<=> @R;C?H&/+ ,%).+ !" 5)1%)1!+! &(5%," J(": +,/" $+ 5%&1-1$1!+! !" O")

$+& $1-")/+!"& !"$ 0%,4(,/% &%01+$ !1&.1,(1!+&: $%& 01(!+!+,%&: !%/+3!%& !" (, &",/1!% 2 !"&"% !" $+ 4(&/101+: +0"5/+)I, $+ $1.1/+01K, !"&(& $1-")/+!"& ", -(&0+ !" (, ."4%) &1&/".+ J(": + $+ $+)F+: )"!1/(+)I", -","'101% !" /%!%&?

!"#$%&$& &( )*)+,#-.&$&(/ 0 (% *+.-1.*.) &( &.2(+(-1.$3 /("#-&)*+.-1.*.)

4-$ 5(6 (/,$7%(1.&) (% /./,(8$ ."#$% &( %.7(+,$&(/9 %$ )+"$-.6$1.:-/)1.$% ;$ &( ,+$,$+ 1)- %$ <#/,.1.$ (- (% +(*$+,) &( %)/ +(1#+/)/ 0 )*)+=,#-.&$&(/> ?- (% *+.-1.*.) &( &.2(+(-1.$ 0 %$ &./,+.7#1.:- &( %)/ 7.(=

-(/ /)1.$%(/ *+.8$+.)/ ,$87.@- (-1)-,+$8)/ #- )+&(- &( *+.)+.&$&>A-,(/ B#( 1#$%B#.(+ &./,+.7#1.:- &( 7.(-(/9 /( ,.(-( B#( $/("#+$+ %$."#$%&$& &( )*)+,#-.&$&(/> ?/,) (/ $/C9 1)8) 0$ /( &.<)9 *$+$ $/("#=+$+ %$ 8)5.%.&$& /)1.$% 1)- 7$/( (- 1+.,(+.)/ -) $+7.,+$+.)/ 0 -) 2$5)=+(1(+ #- (/,$&) &( 7.(-(/,$+ &(-,+) &( #- /./,(8$ (/,D,.1) 0 1$+(-,(

&( %.7(+,$& E12+> F$G%/9 HIIJ3 KLHM>N$ -)+8$ B#( /( (/,$7%(1( (- 1#$-,) $ %)/ +(1#+/)/ 0 %$ )*)+,#=

-.&$& (/ B#( 1#$%B#.(+ &(/."#$%&$& (- )*)+,#-.&$& 2$5)+(61$ ) $#=8(-,( %$/ )*)+,#-.&$&(/ &( %)/ "+#*)/ 8(-)/ 2$5)+(1.&)/> ?/,) (/9/( *#(&( $1(*,$+ %$ &(/."#$%&$& (- (% $11(/) $ 2#(-,(/ &( .-"+(/)9 *)+

(<(8*%)9 /.(8*+( 0 1#$-&) (/,$ &.2(+(-1.$ +(&.,O( (- #-$ /.,#$1.:-8(<)+ *$+$ %$/ 1%$/(/ 1)- 8$0)+(/ &(/5(-,$<$/>

4-) &( %)/ *+.-1.*$%(/ 2$1,)+(/ B#( $0#&$- $ %)"+$+ %$ <#/,.1.$

(- %$ /)1.(&$& (/ (% 5$%)+ B#( &$ (% *+.-1.*.) &( &.2(+(-1.$ $ %$ 1)8=*(-/$1.:-> P( 1)-,(8*%$ %$ -(1(/.&$& &( 1)8*(-/$+ %)/ (2(1,)/ &(&(/."#$%&$&(/ $+7.,+$+.$/ B#( 1)8*+(-&(- 2$1,)+(/ &( -$1.8.(-,) 0

&),(/ -$,#+$%(/> ?/,( (/ #- /./,(8$ B#( 7#/1$ -.5(%$+ (% 1$8*) &( <#(") 7#/1$-&) #-$ ."#$%&$& +($% &( )*)+,#-.&$&(/> N$/ &(/5(-,$<$/*+)*.$/ &(% (-,)+-) (- (% B#( /( -$1( 0 %$/ &),(/ B#( -$,#+$%8(-,(/( ,.(-(- *#(&(- $2(1,$+ (% &(/$++)%%) &( #- 1#.&$&$-) *)+ +$6)-(/2#(+$ &( /# 1)-,+)%> N)/ *+.-1.*.)/ &( %$ <#/,.1.$ 7#/1$- (5.,$+ (/,(

,.*) &( 5(-,$<$/ .-8(+(1.&$/ *)+ %) B#( /( $*)0$+D 8$0)+8(-,( $%)/ "+#*)/ B#( ,(-"$- #-$ *)/.1.:- 8D/ &@7.% *)+ ,(-(+ 8(-)+(/1$*$1.&$&(/ ) *)+ *+)5(-.+ &( #-$ *)/.1.:- /)1.$% &(/2$5)+$7%(> P(=Q$%$ F$G%/3 R(% *+.-1.*.) &( &.2(+(-1.$ &$ $%"O- 5$%)+ $ %$/ 1)-/.=&(+$1.)-(/ *$+,.1#%$+.6$&$/ *)+ (% *+.-1.*.) &( 1)8*(-/$1.:-> ?/,(*+.-1.*.) $2.+8$ B#( %$/ &(/."#$%&$&(/ .-8(+(1.&$/ +(B#.(+(- #-$

1)8*(-/$1.:-S 0 &$&) B#( %$/ &(/."#$%&$&(/ &( -$1.8.(-,) 0 &( &)=,(/ -$,#+$%(/ /)- .-8(+(1.&$/9 ;$7+D- &( /(+ 1)8*(-/$&$/ &( $%"O-

8)&)> A/C9 (% *+.-1.*.) /)/,.(-( B#( 1)- )7<(,) &( ,+$,$+ ."#$%8(-,(

! #$%!& '!& ()*&$+!& , %) (*$($*-.$+!* /+! !/#0+#.-! .1/!'%!% %)$($*#/+.%!%)&2 '! &$-.)%!% #)+%*3 4/) %!* 5!,$* !#)+-.6+ ! 4/.)+)&#.)+)+ 5)+$& %$+)& +!#/*!')& , ! 4/.)+)& 7!+ +!-.%$ )+ '!& ($&.-.$8

+)& &$-.!')& 5)+$& 9!:$*!;')&< =>!?'&2 @AABC @DEFG H$%)5$& :)* 4/))' (*.+-.(.$ %) %.9)*)+-.! !(/+#! ! 5)I$*!* '! &.#/!-.6+ %) '$& 53&%)&9!:$*)-.%$& )+ /+! &$-.)%!% %!%!G J! -/)&#.6+ -'!:) )&#!*3 )+ %)8

9.+.* -/3')& &$+ '!& ($&.-.$+)& 53& %)&:)+#!I$&!& , -65$ &) %!*3 )&#!K5!,$* !#)+-.6+< ! '!& +)-)&.%!%)& %) '!& ()*&$+!& 4/) '!& -$5($+81!+G L+ )&#) (/+#$ ($%*M! %.*.5.*&) '! -/)&#.6+ %) -65$ ($+%)*! '!#)$*M! %) >!?'& '!& %.9)*)+-.!& +!#/*!')& )+#*) '!& ()*&$+!&G H$* '$(*$+#$2 ;!&#) %)-.* 4/) 7!&#! )' 5$5)+#$ )' (*.+-.(.$ %) %.9)*)+-.!

(!*)-) !(/+#!* ! &.#/!-.$+)& &$-.!')& %) %)&:)+#!I! ;!&!%!& )+ '!&-!(!-.%!%)& :!'.$&!& )+ )' 5)*-!%$ '!;$*!'2 )+ '! )&-!'! &$-.!' , )+)+#$*+$& -/'#/*!')& , )%/-!#.:$&2 , +$ #!+#$ ! '! -!(!-.%!% .+#)*+! %)'$& &/I)#$& .+%.:.%/!')&G

N+! :)O 4/) #)+)5$& '!& 'M+)!& ;3&.-!& %) '! $*1!+.O!-.6+ %) '! )&8#*/-#/*! &$-.!' ($%)5$& (*)1/+#!*+$& -65$ )& 4/) '$& %$& (*.+-.8(.$& *)&/'#!+ -$5(!#.;')&G P. )' (*.5)* (*.+-.(.$ ;/&-! !&)1/*!* '!

'.;)*#!% .1/!' !+#)& 4/) -/!'4/.)* -$&! , )' &)1/+%$ (*.+-.(.$ ()*85.#) %)&.1/!'%!%)&2 Q-65$ )& 4/) %.-7!& %.&(!*.%!%)& +$ !9)-#)+ '!.1/!'%!% *)4/)*.%! ($* )' (*.5)* (*.+-.(.$R

P/($+.)+%$ 4/)2 %) !-/)*%$ -$+ )' $*%)+ %) (*.$*.%!% (*$(/)&8#$ ($* '$& (*.+-.(.$&2 -$+#!5$& -$+ /+! &$-.)%!% )+ %$+%) '!& '.8

;)*#!%)& ;3&.-!& , '!& $($*#/+.%!%)& )&#3+ %.&($+.;')& ! #$%$& '$&-./%!%!+$& )+ 9$*5! .1/!'2 '!& %.9)*)+-.!& 4/) ($%)5$& )+-$+#*!*&) -)+#*!*3+ )+ '! *)(!*#.-.6+ %) '$& $#*$& ;.)+)& &$-.!')& (*.5!*.$&GS.-7!& %)&.1/!'%!%)& &) -$+&.%)*!+ :)+#!I$&!& (!*! '$& 1*/($& 5)+$&!9$*#/+!%$&G KT$%$& '$& ;.)+)& &$-.!')& (*.5!*.$& U'.;)*#!%2 .1/!'%!%%) $($*#/+.%!%)&2 *)+#!2 *.4/)O!2 , '!& ;!&)& %) *)&()#$ 5/#/$U2 7!+

%) &)* %.&#*.;/.%$& %) /+ 5$%$ .1/!'2 ! 5)+$& 4/) /+! %.&#*.;/-.6+%)&.1/!' %) /+$ $ %) #$%$& )&#$& ;.)+)& *)%/+%) )+ ;)+)9.-.$ %) '$&

5)+$& !:)+#!I!%$&< =>!?'&2 @AABC (GVW@FG

!" $%&'()*" &+ +, &+*" -,.&%&)/," $&%0,*,-" $1% 21+ $%,)/,$,1+ -&2" 3(+*,/," )1 %&+(2*" ()" 0&%0" &) 2"+ 2,4&%*"-&+ 45+,/"+ 6(& +& -&7

4&) "+&'(%"% -&+-& &2 $%,0&% $%,)/,$,18 9)" /"%&)/," ,0$1%*")*& -&

%&/(%+1+ &/1):0,/1+ $1-%;" -&%,<"% &) ()" 2,0,*"/,:) ,0$1%*")*&-& 2"+ 1$/,1)&+ <,*"2&+ -& 21+ /,(-"-")1+8 =+*1 ,0$&-,%;" 6(& %&"72,>"%") 2"+ 0&*"+ 6(& 2,4%&0&)*& ?") &2&',-1 $"%" +( <,-"8 @A:01

$(&-& /1)/,2,"%+& &+*& /2"%1 ,0$&-,0&)*1 " 2" 2,4&%*"- /1) 2" $%&7*&)+,:) -&2 $%,0&% $%,)/,$,1 6(& ")*&$1)& 2" 2,4&%*"- "2 %&$"%*1 -&21+ 4,&)&+ &/1):0,/1+B @C&)&01+ -&%&/?1+ D 2,4&%*"-&+ +, )1 +101+/"$"/&+ -& $1)&%21+ &) $%5/*,/"B

E"%" F"G2+ )1 ?"D /1)*%"-,//,:) ,)*&%)" &)*%& &2 3(&'1 -& 21+

$%,)/,$,1+ $(&+*1 6(& )1 +& %&.,&%&) "2 0,+01 "+$&/*1 -& 2" 2,4&%*"-HI=) 1/"+,1)&+ +& &+*,0"%5 /101 ()" -& 2"+ %&+*%,//,1)&+ -&.,),*1%,"+-& 2" 2,4&%*"- " 2" ,)/"$"/,-"- -& "$%1<&/?"%+& -& 21+ $%1$,1+ -&%&7/?1+ ( 1$1%*(),-"-&+ /101 %&+(2*"-1 -& 2" $14%&>" D 2" ,')1%")/,"DJ &) '&)&%"2J -& 2" /"%&)/," -& 0&-,1+8 K,) &04"%'1J 0")*&)-%L

6(& &+*"+ /1+"+ ".&/*") &2 <"21% -& 2" 2,4&%*"-J &2 <"21% 6(& *,&)&)$"%" 21+ ,)-,<,-(1+ 21+ -&%&/?1+ -&.,),-1+ $1% &2 $%,0&% $%,)/,$,1MNF"G2+J OPPQH OPRS8 =)/1)*%"01+ "6(; 2" /2"<& $"%" %&/1)/,2,"% 21+

-1+ $%,)/,$,1+8 !" ."2*" -& 0&-,1+ $"%" %&"2,>"% 21+ .,)&+ $%1$(&+*1+$1% 2" 2,4&%*"- ".&/*" "2 <"21% -& 2" 2,4&%*"- D )1 " 2" 2,4&%*"- 0,+0"8=2 $%,0&% $%,)/,$,1 "+&'(%" 2" 2,4&%*"- D 2"+ /1)+&/(&)/,"+ -& 2" "$2,7

/"/,:) -&2 +&'()-1 $%,)/,$,1J 2" -&+,'("2-"- &) 4,&)&+ D %&/(%+1+J +&%&.,&%& "2 <"21% 6(& 2& -"01+ " 2" 2,4&%*"-8 =) 1*%1+ *L%0,)1+J &2 6(&D1 )1 $(&-" %&"2,>"% "2'1 $1% ."2*" -& %&/(%+1+ &/1):0,/1+ )1 6(,&%&-&/,% 6(& D1 )1 +&" 2,4%& -& ?"/&%218 9)" /1+" &+ )1 *&)&% -&%&/?1 ""2'1 D 1*%" /1+" &+ )1 $1-&% .5/*,/"0&)*& %&"2,>"%218

T 0")&%" -& &3&0$21J "2'(,&) 6(& )1 $(&-& $"%*,/,$"% &) ()"/"%%&%" -& OUU 0&*%1+ $2")1+ $1% ?"4&% )"/,-1 +,) $,&%)"+8 K( $"%7*,/,$"/,:) )1 &+*5 2,0,*"-" $1% ()" ."2*" -& -&%&/?1 1 2,4&%*"-J +,)1$1% ()" /1)-,/,:) 6(& 2& ,0$,-& &2 &3&%/,/,1 &.&/*,<1 -& ()" "/*,7<,-"-8 !" 2,4&%*"- &V,+*& "()6(& 21+ 0&-,1+ $"%" 22&<"%2" " /"41 )1+& <&%,.,6(&)8 =+*& /"+1 )1 /"2,.,/"%;" /101 ()" ,)3(+*,/," +1/,"2 "2

),<&2 -& 2"+ 2,4&%*"-&+ D )1 $1-%;"01+ /(2$"% " 21+ 1%'"),>"-1%&+ -&2&<&)*1 -& &+*"% %&+*%,)',&)-1 2" 2,4&%*"- " &+*" $&%+1)" -"-1 6(& +(

".&/*"/,:) &+*5 .(&%" -& +( &+.&%" -& ,).2(&)/,"8 IT+;J 2" 2,4&%*"- D

!" $%"&' (! "% ")*!'+%( ,! -%'%-+!').%/ -&0& ,)12!3 "% ")*!'+%( !,+4'!5'!,!/+%(% 0!()%/+! !" ,),+!0% -&05"!+& (! "%, ")*!'+%(!, (! "%)12%"(%( -)2(%(%/%6 0)!/+'%, 72! !" $%"&' (! "% ")*!'+%( 5%'% "%,

5!',&/%, 8 "&, 1'25&, (!5!/(! (! ,2 -%5%-)(%( 5%'% 5'&0&$!' ,2,9)/!, (!/+'& (!" 0%'-& (!9)/)(& 5&' !" ,),+!0%: ;% ")*!'+%( !/ +%/+&")*!'+%( !72)+%+)$% !, "% 0),0% 5%'% +&(&,< /& ,! 5'!,!/+% "% -2!,=

+)>/ (! -&05!/,%' 5&' +!/!' 0!/&,: ?)/ !0*%'1&6 !" $%"&' (! "%")*!'+%( /& !, !" 0),0& 5%'% +&(&,: @"12/&, +)!/!/ 04, %2+&')(%(8 04, ')72!.%6 8 5&' +%/+& 04, 0!()&, 5%'% %"-%/.%' ,2, &*A!+)$&,BCD%E",6 FGGH3 FGIJ:

;%, ")*!'+%(!, *4,)-%, (! "% )12%"(%( -)2(%(%/% !,+4/ 1%'%/+).%(%,

52!,+& 72! ,&/ )/(!5!/()!/+!, % "&, %''!1"&, !-&/>0)-&, !/+'! "&,1'25&, ,&-)%"!,: K,+&, %''!1"&, !,+4/6 %(!04,6 '!1)(&, 5&' "&, 5')/-)=5)&, (! "% A2,+)-)%6 5&' "& 72! 5&(!0&, (!-)' 72! !,+4/ -&/+!05"%(&,!/ "% !,+'2-+2'% *4,)-% 8 '!(2/(%/ !/ !" *!/!9)-)& (! "&, 04, (!,5'&=+!1)(&,: @,L "%, -&,%,6 /& M%8 2/% !N)1!/-)% (! -&05!/,%-)>/ (!,(! !"

52/+& (! $),+% (! "% ")*!'+%( %2/72! ,L M%8 2/% !N)1!/-)% (! 0!A&'%'!" !,+%(& (! "%, 5!',&/%, 8 1'25&, (!,9%$&'!-)(&, 5&' "%, ()9!'!/-)%,!/ '!-2',&,: K,+%, ()9!'!/-)%, 5!'0)+!/ 2/% (),5%')(%( !/ "% 9%-)")(%(

-&/ "% 72! ,! %"-%/.%/ "&, &*A!+)$&, 5'&52!,+&,6 5!'& "% ")*!'+%( (!5"%/+!%',! % ,L 0),0&, !,+&, &*A!+)$&, /& ,! $! %9!-+%(%: @,L6 "% !,=+'2-+2'% *4,)-% *2,-% "% A2,+)-)% ,&-)%" 5&' 0!()& (!" A2!1& !/+'! "&,

(&, 5')/-)5)&,6 %" 0%N)0).%' "%, ")*!'+%(!, 8 '!-2',&, -&/,)(!'%/(& %"&, 1'25&, (!,%$!/+%A%(&, -&0& ,2 52/+& (! 0)'%:

K/ !,+! %5%'+%(& 0! 5'&5&/1& 0&,+'%' 72! "% 5'&52!,+% (! D%E",(!A% (! "%(& %"12/&, !"!0!/+&, 72! ,&/ )05&'+%/+!, % "% M&'% (!5&/(!'%' "% '!"%-)>/ !/+'! "% ")*!'+%( 8 "% )12%"(%( !/ 2/% ,&-)!(%(:O%'% !,+& ,!12)'P "% -'L+)-% 72! "! M%-! @0%'+8% ?!/ !/ '!"%-)>/ %"2,& (! "&, *)!/!, ,&-)%"!, 5')0%')&, -&0& 0P+&(& 5%'% 0!()' "%,

(!,)12%"(%(!, !/+'! "%, 5!',&/%, 8 "&, 1'25&, ,&-)%"!,:;&, *)!/!, ,&-)%"!, 5')0%')&,6 -&0& 8% ,! ()A&6 )/-"28!/ -)!'=

+& +)5& (! ")*!'+%(!,6 5&(!'!,6 &5&'+2/)(%(!,6 )/1'!,&6 ')72!.% 8 !"

!"#$%%&'(&#$) +'#! &' ,! -!.&%! %!/,'0!.! 1& !#&.1&% ! ,!' .&2&'01!31&' 1& ,$' 20"1!1!.$') 4$. &, 5.102& 1& 60&.&' ($1&-$' -&10% '0 ".!(&%'$.! ("&1& 2"6%0% '"' .&2&'01!1&' $ .$)

7!%! '0-(,0802!% &, (%$6,&-! 1& -&10% ,!' .&2&'01!1&' 1& ,$' 20"31!1!.$'9 :!/,' !'"-& ;"& #$1! ,! <&.#& &' #$#!,-&.#& 8".20$.!, ! ,$,!%<$ 1& ".! =01! 1& 1"%!20>. &'#?.1!%) @! A0(>#&'0' &,0-0.! ,! &.3

8&%-&1!19 10'2!(!201!19 ,! =&B&C D -"&%#& (%&-!#"%! 2$-$ 8"&.#&'1& 1&'0<"!,1!1) E'59 '& ("&1& #&.&% ". 2%0#&%0$ -?' $ -&.$' 80B$ &.2"!.#$ !, .0=&, 1& 60&.&' '$20!,&' (%0-!%0$' .&2&'!%0$' (!%! 2"6%0% ,!'.&2&'01!1&' 1& ".! (&%'$.!) +'#! &F2,"'0>. ,! A!2& '$6%& ,! 6!'& 1& ;"&,$' 60&.&' 2$-$ ,! '!,"1 '$. .!#"%!,&' D .$ '$20!,&') G& &'#& -$1$9 ,!

&'#%"2#"%! '$20!, .$ #0&.& .!1! ;"& =&% 2$. '" 10'#%06"20>.H

I"($.<!-$'9 102& :!/,'9 ;"& ,! &'#%"2#"%! 6?'02! 1& ,! '$320&1!1 10'#%06"D& 20&%#$' 60&.&' (%0-!%0$'9 &'#$ &'9 2$'!' ;"&'& (%&'"-& ;"& #$1$ '&% %!20$.!, 1&'&!) +'#$' 60&.&' #0&.&.

.$%-!,-&.#& ". "'$9 '&! 2"!, 8"&%& &, (,!. %!20$.!, 1& =01!1& ".! (&%'$.!) +. <%!20! ! ,! '0-(,0201!1 '"($.<!-$' ;"&,$' (%0.20(!,&' 60&.&' (%0-!%0$' ! 10'($'020>. 1& ,! '$20&1!1

'$. 1&%&2A$'9 ,06&%#!1&'9 $($%#".01!1&'9 0.<%&'$ D %0;"&C!JKL M#%$' 60&.&' (%0-!%0$' #!,&' 2$-$ ,! '!,"1 D &, =0<$%9 ,!0.#&,0<&.20! D ,! 0-!<0.!20>.9 '$. 60&.&' .!#"%!,&'N !".;"&

'" ($'&'0>. '& =&! 0.8,"01! ($% ,! &'#%"2#"%! 6?'02!9 .$ &'#?.10%&2#!-&.#& 6!B$ '" 2$.#%$, O:!/,'9 PQQRH SQT)

+, (%$6,&-! 2$. &'#! '0-(,0802!20>. -&#$1$,><02! &' ;"& .$ 2$.32"&%1! 2$. ,!' 2$.1020$.&' %&!,&' 1& ,!' '$20&1!1&') E1&-?'9 -&

(!%&2& 2,!%$ ;"& ,! '$20&1!1 .$ #0&.& 2$.#%$, '$6%& ,!' ,0-0#!.#&'.!#"%!,&' ;"& #&.<!. ,$' 20"1!1!.$'9 (&%$ '5 2%&$ ;"& ".! '$20&1!1

60&. $%1&.!1! 1&6&%5! #%!#!% 1& %&2"(&%!%9 &. ,! -&101! 1& ,$ ($'03 6,&9 ,!' 8".20$.&' .!#"%!,&' 1& ,$' 0.10=01"$' (!%! (&%-0#0%,&' &.#%!%&. &, '0'#&-! 1& 2$$(&%!20>. '$20!, 2$-$ 20"1!1!.$' 0<"!,&')R @$ !.3

ral de las personas. Parece que algunos tipos de discapacidad mental podrían poner

en entredicho la capacidad de autonomía de los enfermos. Como sabemos, el pater-

nalismo en Rawls se considera una situación temporal. En los casos en los que la dis-

!"#$%# '%( ))"*+ + ,"'(+# -." /"0"1%( #"23+4+# )+ !"%#5+6 ,%# '% ("##",#"("'!+!$*+ /") "(!+/% /" 2%(+( +) -." '%( "'7#"'!+1%( +) $'!"'!+#%#/"'+# .'+ (%2$"/+/ 8.(!+1"'!"6 % 1%/$7$2+#)+ ,+#+ -." ,."/+ ))"9

*+#(" + )+ ,#:2!$2+;<+ 1"/$2$=' /" )+( /"($>.+)/+/"( ,%# 1"/$% /") ,#%,."(!% 5'9/$2" !$"'" ") /"7"2!% /" 0+(+#(" "' #"2.#(%( ?)$0"#!+/"(6 ,%/"#"(6

#$-."4+6 "!2@!"#+?; A) >#+' ,#%0)"1+ "( -." )+ "'7"#1"/+/ B /$(2+9,+2$/+/ ?B +)>.'+( 7%#1+( /" ,%0#"4+? ,#%*%2+' -." )+( ,"#(%'+('% ,."/+' 2%'*"#!$# "(%( #"2.#(%( "' ") /"(+##%))% ,"#(%'+) B (%2$+)'"2"(+#$% ,+#+ ,#%1%*"# (.( 7$'"( "' )+ (%2$"/+/; A) 5'/$2" /" 0$"9'"( (%2$+)"( ,#$1+#$%( 0+(+/% "' #"2.#(%( -."/+ 2%#!% + )+ 3%#+ /"

"'7#"'!+# )%( #"!%( /" )+ )$0"#!+/ ,%($!$*+; A(!" 1%/")% /" 1"/$# )+($'"-.$/+/"( '% +,%B+ + )%( 2$./+/+'%( "' )+ !+#"+ /" )%>#+# (.( ,)+'"(/" .'+ *$/+ +.!='%1+ B ,)"'+;

C"' +#>.1"'!+ -." ") "##%# "( 2"'!#+#(" "' )%( #"2.#(%( "' ).>+#/" )+( 2+,+2$/+/"( % )$0"#!+/ ,%($!$*+ ,+#+ #"+)$4+# ") ,)+' /" *$/+

,"#(%'+); C$ '% 0.(2+1%( .' 2#$!"#$% /" 1"/$2$=' -." (" 0+(" "' )+2+,+2$/+/ $'!"#'+ /" )+( ,"#(%'+( /" #"+)$4+# (. ,)+' /" *$/+6 /"8+#"91%( ,+(+# /"($>.+)/+/"( -." (%' $'8.(!+( ,%# ("# +#0$!#+#$+(; <% -."

C"' ,#%,%'/#: "( .' 2+10$% #+/$2+) "' )+ !"%#5+ /" )+ 8.(!$2$+ +) 7.'9/+1"'!+#)+ "' )+ !"%#5+ /" )+( 2+,+2$/+/"(; D 2%'!$'.+2$='6 ("E+)+#@.'+ /" )+( ,#$'2$,+)"( 2#5!$2+( /" C"' +) "'7%-." 0+(+/% "' #"2.#(%(

/" F+G)(6 ,"#% '% +3%'/+#@ "' )+ !"%#5+ /" )+( 2+,+2$/+/"(;

C"'H 1$'.(*+)5+6 0$"'"( ,#$1+#$%( B 2+,+2$/+/"(

I+#+ C"'6 +(.1$# /"'!#% /" .'+ !"%#5+ /" )+ 8.(!$2$+ -." !%/+( )+(

,"#(%'+( (%' !%!+)1"'!" 7.'2$%'+)"( + )% )+#>% /" (.( *$/+( B -." '%

personas. Sin embargo, este problema no parece preocupar demasiado a Rawls, pues-

ya, brevemente, la de los niños, en relación con el paternalismo. El problema de los que

han perdido su capacidad, temporalmente, a causa de una desgracia, un accidente o

una tensión intelectual, puede ser considerado de modo similar. Pero los que se ven

privados más o menos permanentemente, de personalidad moral, pueden presentar

!"#$%"&'( &*"%!"( +%"&,!*%,( "( ,-.' /%%",-0 1,&"#!,2-"&"#!" "(3'&4# "#3'#!%,%#'( $5, , $5, 3'# 3,('( "# $'#$" -,( #"3"(/$,$"( $"-,( +"%('#,( (" $/(+,%,# +'% "(!" !/+' $" 3/%3*#(!,#3/,(0 6"($" -, ,#7

!/.8"$,$ "( 3'&4# "#3'#!%,%#'( 3'# +%"9/(/'#"( ('3/,-"( "(+"3/,-"(,#!" -'( ":"3!'( $" -, &*"%!" +%"&,!*%, 3'&' "( "- 3,(' $" -,( 9/*$,(' -'( ;*<%:,#'(0 6"- &/(&' &'$'= (,2"&'( $" /##*&"%,2-"( 3,('(

$" +"%('#,( &,%./#,$,( +'%>*" (*( :,&/-/,( #' +*"$"# 3,%.,% 3'#-'( ,-!'( 3'(!'( $" (*( $/(3,+,3/$,$"( &"#!,-"( ' :5(/3,(0

?/ >*"%"&'( 2*(3,% -, @*(!/3/, "# *#, ('3/"$,$ !"#"&'( >*" +-,#7!",% -'( !<%&/#'( $" '!%, &,#"%,0 1, "#:"%&"$,$= -, $/(3,+,3/$,$=-, +'2%"A,= -, %,A, B "- .<#"%' ('# :,3!'%"( >*" +*"$"# %"+%"("#!,%

$"(9"#!,@,( ,%2/!%,%/,( B= +'% !,#!'= ("% /#@*(!,( C3:%0 6,#/"-(= DEEFGDHIJ0 K(!" !/+' $" :,3!'%"( +%'9'3,# >*"= ,4# 3'# "- #/9"- $" 2/"#"(('3/,-"( +%/&,%/'( 3'&+%"#$/$' +'% -'( +%/#3/+/'( %,L-(/,#'(= -,(+"%('#,( (" 9",# /#3,+,3/!,$,( +,%, 3'#9"%!/% "(!'( 2/"#"( "# 3,+,73/$,$"(0 1' ,#!"%/'% ."#"%,%5, $/:"%"#3/,( >*" #' +'$"&'( +"%&/!/%

"# *# "(>*"&, >*" 2*(>*" -, @*(!/3/,0M'&' ;"&'( 9/(!'= +,%, N,L-( -, @*(!/3/, (" -'.%, ,(".*%,#$' -,(

-/2"%!,$"( B $/(!%/2*B"#$' -'( 2/"#"( +,%, -, &"@'%, $" 3'#$/3/'#"(

$" -,( +"%('#,( ' .%*+'( 3'# &"#'( 9"#!,@,( "# -, ('3/"$,$0 O#,+,%!" 3"#!%,- $" "(!" "(>*"&, "( -, 3'%%"3!, /$"#!/:/3,3/P# $"- .%*+'>*" '3*+, -, +"'% +'(/3/P# "# -, ('3/"$,$= "(!" .%*+' ("%Q *# 3"#!%'

,-%"$"$'% $"- 3*,- ./%,%Q# -'( 2"#":/3/'( +-,#!",$'( +'% -, !"'%5, $"-, @*(!/3/,0 1, &"$/3/P# $" >*/<# "(!Q &"@'% (/!*,$'= (" -'.%,= +'%!,#!'= ,- +'#$"%,% "- #/9"- $"- 5#$/3" $" -'( 2/"#"( ('3/,-"( +%/&,%/'(G, &,B'% 5#$/3"= &"@'% +'(/3/P# ('3/,-0

K(!" 3%/!"%/' $" &"$/3/P# :*#3/'#,%5, (/ "(!*9/<%,&'( !%,!,#$'

3'# /#$/9/$*'( ("&"@,#!"( "#!%" (50 K( $"3/%= (/ !'$,( -,( +"%('#,(3*"#!,# 3'# &Q( ' &"#'( -,( &/(&,( 3,+,3/$,$"(0 R(5= -,( 9"#!,@,(' $"(9"#!,@,( 3'# -,( >*" 3*"#!,# +'$%5,# %"$*3/%(" , -'( &"$/'(>*" !/"#"# , (* ,-3,#3"0 1, $/:"%"#3/, "#!%" ,."#!"( (/&/-,%"( "(= +'%!,#!'= 3*,#!/!,!/9, "# %":"%"#3/, , *#, &/(&, -/(!, $" 2/"#"( >*" ('#%"+,%!/$'( "#!%" "--'( $" &,#"%, >*" (" &"@'%" -, (/!*,3/P# $"- &"7

#'( :,9'%"3/$' (".4# "(, &/(&, -/(!, $" 2/"#"(0S,(Q#$'#'( "# -, ;/+P!"(/( $" !%,2,@' $" N,L-(= "(!" 3%/!"7

%/' %"(*-!, ":"3!/9' B ("#3/--' $" ,+-/3,%0 ?/= +'% -, B, &"#3/'#,$,

!"#$%"&"'('")* #,-./.%)0"'(1 -./.! %.! "*/"2"/3.! !.* !(*.!1 *"*034*. /"&,5"56 /, %.! .-5.! ,* 3*( &.5#( -(% 73, (%-,5, ,% '5"-,5". /,/,-,''")* /, %(! 2,*-(8(! !.'"(%,!9 :% $5.;%,#( ,!-6 ,* 73, <(= '.*4

/"'".*,! $5,!,*-,! ,* %( 2"/( <3#(*( 73, (%-,5(* -(*-. %( &3*'")* /,%(! $,5!.*(! <(!-( ,% $3*-. ,* ,% 73, 3* '5"-,5". ,>-,5*.1 ;(!(/. ,*%.! ;",*,! !.'"(%,! 73, !, -,*0(* ( #(*.1 *. !,56 ,&,'-"2. $(5( #,/"5%( $.!"'")* !.'"(%9 ?* '(!. $(5(/"0#6-"'. ,! ,% /, %(! /"!'($('"/(/,!&@!"'(! . #,*-(%,!9

A(5( B,*1 3* 2,5/(/,5. '5"-,5". /, #,/"'")* /, 2,*-(8(! -",*, 73,-.#(5 ,* '3,*-( %(! '(5('-,5@!-"'(! $,5!.*(%,! = *. !.%. %.! 5,'35!.!!.'"(%,! $5"#(5".! '.* %.! 73, '3,*-(9 C5(-(*/. /, #,/"5 (#;(! 5,(4

%"/(/,! $./5@(#.! ,!-"#(5 %( !"-3('")* /, ,!( $,5!.*( /,*-5. /, %( 8,45(573@( !.'"(%1 ,! /,'"51 !3 '($('"/(/ $(5( $5.#.2,5 !3! $%(*,! 2"-(%,!= %(! 2,5/(/,5(! *,',!"/(/,! 73, 5,73",5, '3;5"59 DE,;,#.! ,>(#"*(5%( '($('"/(/ 0%.;(% 73, -",*, '3(%73",5 $,5!.*( $(5( %%,2(5 3*( 2"/('.#. ,%%( /,!,( %%,2(5%(1 = ,!-. 5,73",5, 73, !, $5,!-, (-,*'")* ( !3! '(45('-,5@!-"'(! $,5!.*(%,! F"*'%3=,*/. !3! /"!'($('"/(/,!1 !" %(! <(=G1 (!@'.#. !3! "*05,!.! = .-5.! 5,'35!.!1 =( 73, (#;.! $3,/,* "*&%3,*'"(5!3! '($('"/(/,! ('-3(%,!H FB,*1 IJJKL IG9 M!-, ,! 3* ,*&.73, 73, -5(-(

/, $5.-,0,5 %( 2,5/(/,5( $.!";"%"/(/ /, %%,2(5 ( '(;. %.! $%(*,! 2"-(4%,! /, %(! $,5!.*(!9 B, -5(-( /, 3*( $5,.'3$('")* $.5 %( ,&,'-"2"/(//, %( %";,5-(/ $.!"-"2(9 N( %%(#(/( ( ,>(#"*(5 %(! '(5('-,5@!-"'(! /,%.! '"3/(/(*.! ,! 3* "*-,*-. $.5 (-,*/,5 %(! /"&,5,*'"(! $,5!.*(%,!,*-5, %( 0,*-, $(5( %.05(5 3* 5,$(5-. /, ;",*,! !.'"(%,! $5"#(5".!73, 5,(%#,*-, (=3/, ( %.! #6! *,',!"-(/.! ( 5,(%"O(5!, ,* "03(%/(//, '"5'3*!-(*'"(!9 B" 73,5,#.! -5(-(5 ( %.! <.#;5,! '.#. "03(%,! =/(5%,! "03(% ,!$('". $(5( 5,(%"O(5 !3 %";,5-(/1 -,*,#.! 73, '.*!"/,4

5(5%.! ,* !3! /"&,5,*'"(!9 :* ,!-, !,*-"/.1 (% -5(-(5 ( %.! <.#;5,! ,*!3! /"&,5,*'"(! $,5!.*(%,!1 %( -,.5@( /, P(Q%! !, 73,/( '.5-(9

:% '(!. /, %( /"!'($('"/(/1 '.#. /"8,1 ,! $(5(/"0#6-"'. ( %( <.5(/, $%(*-,(5 '5"-,5".! /"!-5";3-"2.! ,* 3*( !.'",/(/9 :! 3* '(!. 73,$.*, ( $53,;( ( %( 83!-"'"( #"!#(9 B" $(5-"#.! /, %( "03(%/(/ /, %.!'"3/(/(*.! = /, %(! %";,5-(/,! ;6!"'(! 73, -./.! /,;,* 0.O(51 ,! "#4$.5-(*-, (*(%"O(5 %(! %"#"-('".*,! 73, ,!-, -"$. /, '.*/"'".*,! %,!"#$.*,* ( ,!-(! $,5!.*(!9 E"'<(! %"#"-(*-,! #,5#(* !3 %";,5-(/1$5.2.'(*/. 3*( /"!$(5"/(/ 73, 2".%(5@( %.! $5"*'"$".! /, %( 83!-"'"(9

!"#$%&' &) *+ &,-)#"+" ., *,& ).-*/0# #. #* &)&1#$+ "# -,,2#3+-)4. 3#5-623,-+' 1+$2,-, #&1+36+ 3#&2#1+.", &/ )7/+*"+" #. 1+.1, -)/"+"+.,&8

9+3+ "#$,&13+3 -4$, *+& -+3+-1#36&1)-+& 2#3&,.+*#& 2/#"#. +:#-5

1+3 #* -3)1#3), ;+&+", #. #* .)<#* "# *,& ;)#.#& &,-)+*#& 23)$+3),& #.*,& ")&-+2+-)1+",&' =#. ,-/2+ *,& -,.-#21,& "# $)./&<+*6+ "# 7+.+.5-)+ 0 $)./&<+*6+ "# -,.<#3&)4.8 >+ $)./&<+*6+ "# 7+.+.-)+ &# 3#:)#3#

+ *+& ,2-),.#& "# #$2*#, 0 + *,& ).73#&,& "#3)<+",& "#* $)&$,8 ?@.+2#3&,.+ ")&-+2+-)1+"+ 2/#"# 1#.#3 $+0,3#& "):)-/*1+"#& 2+3+ ,;1#.#3/. #$2*#, , 2+3+ 3#1#.#3*,' , 2/#"# 3#-);)3 $#.,3 -,$2#.&+-)4.2,3 &/ 13+;+A, BCD /.+ 2#3&,.+ ")&-+2+-)1+"+ 2/#"# 1#.#3 &#3)+&"#&<#.1+A+& #. 1E3$).,& "# &/& ).73#&,& 0 3)F/#G+&H I=#.' JKKLM NO8

P,"+<6+ #. $/-Q+& &,-)#"+"#& -,$, *+ ./#&13+ ., #& -,$R. <#3 +2#3&,.+& ")&-+2+-)1+"+& ).1#73+"+& +* $/.", *+;,3+*8 S&1, 2/#"# "#5

;#3&# + $/-Q+& <+3)+;*#& -,$, *+ :+*1+ "# /.+ -/*1/3+ :+<,3+;*# + &/).1#73+-)4. , *+ :+*1+ "# ).:3+#&13/-1/3+ 0 -3#+1)<)"+" 2+3+ +"+21+3 *,&$#"),& *+;,3+*#& + *+& -,.")-),.#& "# #&1+& 2#3&,.+&8 S&1+ :+**+ &,-)+*

., &,*, +:#-1+ + *,& ")&-+2+-)1+",& 0 + &/& :+$)*)+& &)., + *+ $)&$+&,-)#"+" F/# "#A+ "# ,;1#.#3 *+ +2,31+-)4. F/# #&1+& 2#3&,.+& 2,5"36+. "+3 &) &# ).<)31)#3+ #. *+& $,"):)-+-),.#& .#-#&+3)+& 1+.1, 2+3+

&/ -+2+-)1+-)4. -,$, 2+3+ &/ #$2*#,89#3, E&1+ #& &,*, *+ 2/.1+ "#* )-#;#37 "#* 23,;*#$+ "# *+ ")&-+2+5

-)"+"8 >+ $)./&<+*6+ "# -,.<#3&)4. +73+<+ #* 23,;*#$+8 ?9+3+ 3#+*)G+3

*+& $)&$+& +-1)<)"+"#& F/# /.+ 2#3&,.+ &). ")&-+2+-)"+"' /.+ 2#3&,.+-,. ")&-+2+-)"+" :6&)-+ 2/#"# .#-#&)1+3 "# $+0,3#& ).73#&,& F/# /.+2#3&,.+ &). ")&-+2+-)"+" BCD >+ $)./&<+*6+ "# -,.<#3&)4. &# 3#:)#3#+ *+ "#&<#.1+A+ F/# /.+ 2#3&,.+ -,. ")&-+2+-)"+" 1)#.# +* -,.<#31)3 &/").#3, #. ;/#. <)<)3H I=#.' JKKLM NO8 >,& 7+&1,& "# /. ")&-+2+-)1+", &#

")&2+3+. 2/#&1, F/# 2+3+ -/+*F/)#3 +-1)<)"+" .#-#&)1+3% $%& #&:/#3G,0 3#-/3&,& F/# /.+ 2#3&,.+ &). #&1+ -,.")-)4.8 !&)&1#.-)+ 2#3$+.#.1#'$#")-+$#.1,&' 2341#&)&' +"+21+-),.#& + *+ ).:3+#&13/-1/3+ "#* Q,7+3 ,"#* -#.13, "# 13+;+A,' #1-8 ! #&1# 1)2, "# 2#3&,.+& *#& 3#&/*1+ $/-Q,$%& -,$2*#A, *,73+3 *, F/# =#. **+$+ #* ;/#. <)<)3' *, F/# 3#&/*1+ /.+")&2+3)"+" F/# "#;#36+ &#3 +1#.")"+ 2,3 *+ 1#,36+ "# *+ A/&1)-)+8

>+& 2#3&,.+& ")&-+2+-)1+"+& ., &,*, -,.&)7/#. $#.,& 0 2#,3#&13+;+A,&' &)., F/# 1+$;)E. &/:3#. *+ $)./&<+*6+ "# -,.<#3&)4.8 S&1,

F/)#3# "#-)3 F/#' +/.F/# .,& +&#7/3#$,& F/# ,;1#.7+. *+ 23,2,3-)4.

!" $%"&"' '()%*+"' ,-%.*-%(' )(--"',(&!%"&/" * '0 ,('%)%1& '()%*+ !"*)0"-!( *+ )-%/"-%( -*2+'%*&(3 "++*' ,(!-4& 5*)"- .0)5( ."&(' )(&"'/(' -")0-'(' 60" 0&* ,"-'(&* '%& "'/* +%.%/*&/"7

8 9"& +" ,-"()0,* 60" +* !"/"-.%&*)%1& !" +(' :-0,(' ."&(' ;*<=(-")%!('3 ( +* ."!%)%1& !" +* ,($-">*3 '" +%.%/" ( '" )"&/-" !".*'%*!("& 0& )-%/"-%( !" %&:-"'('7 ?' 0& ;*)/(- !"/"-.%&*&/"3 ,"-( &( "' "+

@&%)(7 8+ )(&'%!"-*- +* .%&0'=*+A* !" )(&="-'%1& ,(!".(' )(.,-"&!"-"+ "--(- "& "'/* ."/(!(+(:A*7 B* !%')*,*)%!*! ,0"!" 5*)"- 60" 0&*,"-'(&* )(& 0& $0"& &%="+ !" %&:-"'(' &( +(:-" +* '0;%)%"&/" +%$"-/*!,*-* =%=%- $%"& C);-7 9"&3 DEEFG HI7 ?' "+ .%'.( /%,( !" )-A/%)* 60" '"5*)" * +(' ,-(:-*.*' !" *'%'/"&)%* '()%*+ 60" $*'*& +* -",*-/%)%1& !"

*J0!* :0$"-&*."&/*+ "& "+ A&!%)" !" %&:-"'( ,(- ;*.%+%*3 '%& %.,(-/*-'% 5*J *+:@& .%".$-( '"="-*."&/" "&;"-.( ( !%')*,*)%/*!(7 K(!-A*!*-'" "+ )*'( !" 60" "L%'/*& !(' ;*.%+%*'3 0&* !" +*' )0*+"' &( )*+%;%)*,*-* "+ *,(J( :0$"-&*."&/*+3 ,0"'/( 60" "'/4 ,(- '($-" +* )*&/%!*!!" %&:-"'(' -"60"-%!*3 J (/-* 60" "'/4 ,(- !"$*M( !" "'* +A&"* J )*+%;%)*

,*-* "+ ,-(:-*.*7 ?+ ,-($+".* "' 60" +* ,-%."-* ;*.%+%* )0"&/* )(& 0&5%M( !%')*,*)%/*!( ,(- +( 60"3 "& -"+*)%1& * '0 ,(!"- !" )(&="-'%1& !"+(' %&:-"'(' "& )*+%!*! !" =%!*3 "'/4 ,"(- '%/0*!* 60" +* ;*.%+%* '*&* 60"

=%=" ,(- !"$*M( !"+ %&:-"'( -"60"-%!( ,*-* +* *'%'/"&)%* J 60"3 ,(- /*&</(3 -")%$" "+ %&)"&/%=( ")(&1.%)(7 8'A3 N'% %:&(-*.(' +* .%&0'=*+A* !")(&="-'%1& )(.( ."!%!* !" ,($-">* $*'*!* "& +(' %&:-"'('3 '" /%"&" "+

";")/( !" !%'/(-'%(&*- "&(-."."&/" "+ &%="+ !" ,($-">* !" +*' ;*.%+%*')(& 0&( ( .4' .%".$-(' !%')*,*)%/*!('O C9"&3 DEEFG FI7

P/-( ;*)/(- * )(&'%!"-*- "' 60" +*' !"'="&/*M*' 60" ,-"'"&/* +* !%'<)*,*)%!*!3 %:&(-*!*' "& +* .*J(-A* !" +(' '%'/".*' !" M0'/%)%*3 )(&++"=*&0&* .%&0'=*+A* !" )(&="-'%1& /*.$%Q& !" +*' (,(-/0&%!*!"' J '"-=%)%('

'()%*+"'7 R0)5*' !" +*' %&'/%/0)%(&"' 60" $-%&!*& *,(J(3 */"&)%1& J;(-.*)%1& * +(' )%0!*!*&(' '(& *,-(=")5*!*' !%',*-."&/" ,(- +*' ,"-<'(&*' !%')*,*)%/*!*'7 ?M".,+(' )+*-(' '(& "+ )*.,( !" +* "!0)*)%1& J!" +* '*+0!7 K"&'".(' "& !(' =*-%*$+"' @&%)*."&/"G +* *))"'%$%+%!*! J"+ *,-(=")5*.%"&/(7 9*$".(' 60" *+:0&*' !%';0&)%(&"' .(!%;%)*& +*.(=%+%!*! !" +*' ,"-'(&*'3 "'/( +%.%/* '0 ,*-/%)%,*)%1& "& +(' ,-(:-*<

.*' *&/"' ."&)%(&*!('7 K(- (/-( +*!(3 !%')*,*)%!*!"' '"&'(-%*+"' (

."&/*+"' %.,%!"& "+ !"'*--(++( %&/":-*+ !" +(' *+0.&(' )(&!"&4&!(+('

*+ -">*:(7 ?'/*' '%/0*)%(&"' )%"--*& "+ )A-)0+( =%)%('( !" +* .%&0'=*+A*

!" $%&%&'(% ) !" '*&+",-(.&/ 0" "-1% 2*,3%4 "5 6"'6* !" &* '*&-(!",%,5%- !(2","&'(%- "&1," 5%- 7",-*&%- '*3* "& "5 '%-* !" 5% !(-'%7%'(!%!4,"75('% ) %$,%+% 5%- (&89-1('(%- "& 59$%, !" 2*3"&1%, 5% 89-1('(%/

:& "5 '%-* '*&',"1* !" 5% 1"*,;% !" 5% 89-1('(% !" <%=5-4 5*- >("?&"- 7,(3%,(*- -*& 5*- 3"!(*- 7%,% 5*$,%, 5*- *>8"1(+*- +(1%5"- !" 5*-(&!(+(!9*-/ @9&A9" 5*- >("&"- 7,(3%,(*- &* -" ,"!9B'%& %5 (&$,"-*4

1%3>(C& 5%- 5(>",1%!"-4 5*- 7*!","- ) 5%- >%-"- 7%,% "5 %91*,,"-7"1*-92,"& 9&% 3",3% "& "5 '%-* !" 5*- !(-'%7%'(1%!*-/ :- '5%,* A9" 5%-5(3(1%'(*&"- 2;-('%- ) 3"&1%5"- %2"'1%,D& 5%- 5(>",1%!"- ) 5%- *7*,19&(?!%!"- !" "-1%- 7",-*&%- ) A9" "-1* 1"&!,D 9&% '*&-"'9"&'(% &"$%1(+%"& -9 %91*'*&'"7'(.&/ 0%!* 5* %&1",(*,4 ,"-951% 9&% (&89-1('(% '"&?

1,%,-" E&('%3"&1" "& 5% !(-1,(>9'(.& !" 5*- >("&"- 7,(3%,(*- '*3*9& (&!('%!*, !" 5% +"&1%8% (&!(+(!9%5/ FG(& !9!%4 5% %375(%'(.& !"5"&2*A9" (&2*,3%'(*&%5 !"-!" "5 (&$,"-* 6%'(% 5*- >("&"- 7,(3%,(*-&* "- 7*, -; -*5* %!"'9%!* 7%,% 1,%1%, 5%- +%,(%'(*&"- ,"5"+%&1"- "&5% ,"5%'(.& "&1," 5*- ,"'9,-*- ) 5%- '%7%'(!%!"-/ H% 7*>5%'(.& '*&

!(-'%7%'(!%!"- 3"&1%5"- * 2;-('%- 79"!"& -", 39'6* 3D- 7,(+%!% "&1C,3(&*- !" 5* A9" 79"!"& 6%'", %E& '*& 5%- 3(-3%- '%&1(!%!"- !"

>("&"- 7,(3%,(*-4 (&'59)"&!* I!","'6*-4 5(>",1%!"- ) *7*,19&(!%!"-4

(&$,"-*- ) ,(A9"B%4 ) 5% >%-" -*'(%5 !"5 %91*?,"-7"1*JK LG"&4 MNNOP QR/G( !"2(&(3*- 5% !(-1,(>9'(.& !" '9%5A9(", >("& 7,(3%,(* '*& (&!"?

7"&!"&'(% !" 5%- '%,%'1",;-1('%- 7",-*&%5"- !" 5*- (&!(+(!9*-4 3"&*-?

7,"'(%3*- 2%'1*,"- '*3* 5% 3(&9-+%5;% !" '*&+",-(.&/ H% 7*-(>(5(!%!!" 9&% 7",-*&% 7%,% "8",'", 5(>",1%!"-4 %7,*+"'6%, *7*,19&(!%!"-* 7,*3*+", -9- 2(&"- 7%,1('95%,"- ,"-7*&!"4 "& $,%& 3"!(!%4 % 5%-'%7%'(!%!"- A9" 1"&$% ) "5 &(+"5 29&'(*&%5 A9" 6%)%& %5'%&B%!*/ H*-2%'1*,"- 3",%3"&1" "S1",&*- &* %5'%&B%& % 7*&!",%, 5%- !(2","&'(%-

A9" "& "-1" '%37* 1("&"& 5*- (&!(+(!9*- ) A9"4 "& E51(3% (&-1%&'(%4!"2(&"& "5 3%,$"& !" %''(.& A9" -" 1("&"/

G($9("&!* "5 %,$93"&1*4 5*- 7,(&'(7(*- !" 5% 89-1('(% !" <%=5- 2%?55%& %5 &* (&'*,7*,%, 5%- !(2","&'(%- "&1," 5%- 7",-*&%- "& '9%&1* % 5*-2%'1*,"- (&1",&*- A9" %2"'1%& 5% +%5*,%'(.& !" -9 7*-('(.& "& 5% -*'("?!%!/ G( A9(-(C,%3*- &(+"5%, 5%- '(,'9&-1%&'(%- ,"%53"&1"4 1"&!,;%3*-

A9" !(-7*&", !" 39'6% 3D- %)9!% -*'(%5 7%,% "-1*- $,97*- A9"4 %9&?A9" 79"!% &* ,"25"8%,-" "& 7,(3",% (&-1%&'(% !" %'9",!* '*& -9 &(+"5

!" >("&"- -*'(%5"- 7,(3%,(*-4 1("&"& "& -; 9&% !"-+"&1%8% '*&-1(191(+%

!"# %#& '(#)*' #+ %' ,#'%-.')-/+ 0# &" 1%'+ 0# 2-0'3 45- %' #2'%"')-/+ 0#%' 6"&*-)-' 0-&*,-7"*-2' +8& ,#!"-#,# *89', +8*' 0# %'& 818,*"+-0'0#&,#'%#& 0# "+ -+0-2-0"8 1',' %' 7:&!"#0' 0# &"& 876#*-28&; #+*8+)#& +8

#& '0#)"'08 )8+)#+*,', %' '*#+)-/+ #+ %8& -+<,#&8&; 8 #+ %8& 7-#+#&1,-9',-8&; 8 &8%8 ' %8& 1%')#,#& = 0#&#8&3 >'& 2#,0'0#,'& )'1')-0'0#&0# "+' 1#,&8+' 0#7#+; 0-,#)*' 8 -+0-,#)*'9#+*#; &#, )8+*'7-%-.'0'&

)8+ %'& 0#&2#+*'6'& = 1,87%#9'& 0# "+ -+0-2-0"83? @5#+; ABBCD 13EF>' 1,#8)"1')-/+ )#+*,'% 0# G'H%& #,' %8<,', "+' &8)-#0'0 8,I

0#+'0' !"# <','+*-.',' %' -<"'%0'0 #+ %'& %-7#,*'0#& = !"# 0-&*,-7"I=#,' %8& 7-#+#& 0# *'% 9'+#,' !"# &# '18=',' ' %8& <,"18& 9#+8&('28,#)-08&3 J% "&', "+ ),-*#,-8 #K*#,+8 ' %'& 1#,&8+'& 1',' 9#0-, %'

2#+*'6' &8)-'%; #% '"*8, 0#6' ("#,' 0# 6"#<8 (')*8,#& 0#*#,9-+'+*#&1',' %' ,#'%-.')-/+ 0# %'& %-7#,*'0#& @)(,3 5#+; ABBCD LF =; 18, *'+*8;%' -<"'%0'0 )-"0'0'+'3 >'& #+(#,9#0'0#& = 0-&)'1')-0'0#& +8 1"#0#+!"#0', ("#,' 0# %' )8+&-0#,')-/+ 0# %' 6"&*-)-'3

M'+-#%& = %' #K*#+&-/+ 0# %' *#8,N' ,'H%&-'+'D %' O<"'%0'0 0# P18,I*"+-0'0

>' ),N*-)' 1,#&#+*'0' ' G'H%& #+ *8,+8 ' %' #K)%"&-/+ 0# (')*8,#&

)898 %' #+(#,9#0'0 0# %'& )8+&-0#,')-8+#& 0# %' 6"&*-)-' #& ,#*89'I0' 18, M'+-#%& '"+!"# #+ (8,9' 0-&*-+*'3 Q',' #&*# '"*8,; '% -<"'% !"#1',' 5#+; +8 #& 2R%-0' %' &-91%-(-)')-/+ 9#*808%/<-)' 18, %'& )8+&#I)"#+)-'& -+0#&#'7%#& !"# *,'# ' %' ,#'%-.')-/+ 0# %' 6"&*-)-'3 J 1#&',0# %8& #(#)*8& 18&-*-28& !"# *,'# %' *#8,N' '% ,#0-&*,-7"-, %8& 7-#+#&

&-#91,# ' ('28, 0# %8& 9R& 0#&1,8*#<-08&; #% &-&*#9' ('%%' ' %' S8,'0# )891#+&', 18, )8+*-+<#+)-'& )898 %' 0-&)'1')-0'03 T&*# *-18 0#(')*8,#&; )898 =' 9#+)-8+U; 1,80")#+ 0#&2#+*'6'& -918,*'+*#& !"#-91-0#+ ' %'& 1#,&8+'& 0#&#91#V',&# #(#)*-2'9#+*# #+ &8)-#0'03W898 ,#&"%*'08 *#+#98& ' <,"18& -+6"&*'9#+*# 0#&1,8*#<-08& ="+' ('%%' #+ %' #&*,")*",' 0# ,#)-1,8)-0'0 &8)-'% X*'+*8 0# %' &8)-#0'0

S')-' %8& 0-&)'1')-*'08& )898 ' %' -+2#,&'X3>' &-*"')-/+ 0# %8& 0-&)'1')-*'08& #+ #&*# #&)#+',-8 &# *8,+' ':+

9R& <,'2# &- )8+&-0#,'98& %'& #&)'&'& 1,87'7-%-0'0#& 0# &'%-, 0#%

!"#!$%& ()!)&*& +, %- .)/$*(-%"- +, 0-/-/!)- 1 %- .)/$*(-%"- +, !&/2(,#*)3/4 5% 6-#,!,#7 ,*8, *)*8,.-7 -% /& !&.6,/*-# %-* %).)8-!)&/,* +,%+)*!-6-!)8-+&7 #,6%)!-#"- %-* +,*)0$-%+-+,* *&!)-%,* 1 !&/+,/-#"- - ,*8,

0#$6& - $/- *)8$-!)3/ +,*(,/8-9&*-4 :5 6,*-# +, %- .)8)0-!)3/7 -;$,2%%&* !&/ %&* 8-%,/8&* 1 <-=)%)+-+,* .>* (-%)&*-* ,/ ,% .,#!-+& -!-=-#>/6#&=-=%,.,/8, ,/ %&* 0#$6&* .,9&# !&%&!-+&* 1 %&* 6,#+,+&#,* ,/ %-

%&8,#"- 6#&=-=%,.,/8, 8,#.)/-#>/ ,/8#, %&* +, %&* 0#$6&* 6,&# !&%&2!-+&*4 ?% 6#)/!)6)& +, +)@,#,/!)- *, ;$,+- !&#8& !&.& A6#)/!)6)& +,#,6-#-!)3/B ;$, -6$/8- - !&.6,/*-# - %- 0,/8, 6&# 8&+-* %-* !&/8)/20,/!)-* *&!)-%,* 1 /-8$#-%,* ;$, 6#&+$!,/ +,*(,/8-9-* !&.6,8)8)(-*C/& /)(,%- 6&# !&.6%,8& ,% !-.6& +, 9$,0&D EF-/),%*7 GHHIJ GKLM4

?*8- 6#,&!$6-!)3/ %%,(- - F-/),%* - 6#&6&/,# $/- ("- )/8,#.,+)-,/8#, %& 6%-/8,-+& 6&# N-O%* 1 6&# P,/4 P)/ -=-/+&/-# %- =-*, +, %-8,&#"- +, %- 9$*8)!)- #-O%*)-/-7 F-/),%* =$*!- #,*6&/+,# - %-* &=9,!)&2/,* +, P,/ 1 !$.6%)# %-* +,.-/+-* 6&# %-* /,!,*)+-+,* +, *-%$+Q +,%-* 6,#*&/-*4

?% !&/!,68& !,/8#-% *,#> ,% +, &6&#8$/)+-+7 $/& +, %&* =),/,*6#).-#)&* 6#&6$,*8&* 6&# N-O%*4 R&# ,*8, .,+)& =$*!- #,*-%8-# %-)0$-%+-+ +, &6&#8$/)+-+ 1 !&/!)%)-# %- %)=,#8-+ 1 %- )0$-%+-+ ,/ $/-

6&*8$#- #-O%*)-/-C ,* +,!)#7 6#,8,/+, +-#%, *-%)+- - %- #,-%)S-!)3/ +, %-%)=,#8-+ 6&*)8)(- 1 - %- )0$-%+-+ !)$+-+-/- -% !&/*)+,#-# %-* &6!)&/,*#,-%,* ;$, 8),/,/ $/- 6,#*&/- +,/8#& +, %- *&!),+-+ 1 -*,0$#-# *$

!&.6,8)8)()+-+ ,/ $/ !-.6& /)(,%-+& +, 9$,0&4R-#- 6&+,# -*,0$#-# %- )0$-%+-+ +, &6&#8$/)+-+ ,* /,!,*-#)& ;$,

%-* 6,#*&/-* 6-#8-/ +, $/- =-*, !&.T/4 ?*8- =-*, *,#> ,% A@$/!)&/-2.),/8& /&#.-%B4 U&.& 6$,+, (,#*,7 ,% !&/!,68& +, *-%$+ +,% -$8&#0)#- ,/ 8&#/& - %-* &6,#-!)&/,* 8"6)!-* +,% *,# <$.-/&7 !$-%;$),# +)*2

.)/$!)3/ ,/ ,%%-* 6&+#"- !&/*)+,#-#*, $/- +,*(,/8-9- ;$, -@,!8-#"- %-

hace para buscar una acepción general del término. “To defend Rawls’s index of pri-

mary social goods, we must show how it can meet all important citizens’ needs, inclu-

ding health needs. Suppose we view health as the absence of disease, and suppose we

member of a species. In the case of people, of course, our various cognitive and emotio-

nal functions are crucial, since normal functioning must permit us to pursue our goals

!"#$%&$& &( )*)+,#-!&$&. /0$ 1%$2( *$+$ (3,(-&(+ %$ 2!4!5- &( 6$7%4(4,8 (- %$ !9*)+,$-,( +(%$1!5- (-,+( %$ :#-1!5- -)+9$% ; %$ )*)+,#-!<&$&= #-) &( %)4 >!(-(4 4)1!$%(4 *+!9$+!)4. 0$4 &(42!$1!)-(4 &(% :#-<

1!)-$9!(-,) -)+9$%= !-1%#!&$ %$ 9#(+,( ,(9*+$-$= +(&#1(- (% +$-")&( )*)+,#-!&$& $>!(+,) $ %)4 !-&!2!&#)4 1)- (% 1#$% (%%)4 *)&+?$-1)-4,+#!+ ) *(+4("#!+ 4#4 @*%$-(4 &( 2!&$AB CD$-!(%4= EFFGH EIJK.

D( (4,$ :)+9$= 4!- 4(*$+$+-)4 &( %)4 *+!-1!*!)4 &( %$ L#4,!1!$+$7%4!$-)4= *)&(9)4 L#4,!:!1$+ #-$ 9$;)+ *+),(11!5- &( %$ )*)+,#<-!&$& &( +($%!M$+ %)4 *%$-(4 &( 2!&$ &( %)4 1!#&$&$-)4. 0$ 4$%#& 4(+8#-$ 2?$ -(1(4$+!$ *$+$ *+(4(+2$+ (% :#-1!)-$9!(-,) -)+9$% &( %$4*(+4)-$4 ; (4,)= $#-$&) $ %$ L#4,$ &!4,+!>#1!5- &( %)4 ),+)4 >!(-(4

*+!9$+!)4= 4( ,+$&#1( (- %$ 1)-&!1!5- &( *)4!>!%!&$& &( %$ !"#$%&$&&( )*)+,#-!&$&.

N4,( *$4) O#(&$ L#4,!:!1$&) ,$9>!P- &(4&( %$ (%(11!5- &( %)4*+!-1!*!)4 (- %$ *)4!1!5- )+!"!-$%. 0)4 $"(-,(4 (-1$+"$&)4 &( Q$1(+(4,$ ,$+($ O#(++?$- *+(4(+2$+ %$ )*)+,#-!&$& &( +($%!M$+ 4#4 *%$-(4 &(

2!&$ $ %) %$+") &(% ,!(9*). 0$ (-:(+9(&$& ; %$ &!41$*$1!&$& *#(&(-*+(4(-,$+4( (- 1#$%O#!(+ 9)9(-,)= *)+ %) O#( (4 *%$#4!>%( O#( 4(,)9$+$- 9(&!&$4 *$+$ *+),("(+ %$ 4$%#& $ %) %$+") &( %$ 2!&$ Q#9$-$

C1:+. D$-!(%4= EFFGH EIRK. N4,) !-1%#!+?$ #- 4!4,(9$ 1)9*+(-4!2) &(4$%#&H *+(2(-1!5-= ,+$,$9!(-,)= +(Q$>!%!,$1!5- ; +($&$*,$1!5-. D(%9!49) 9)&)= 1)9*+(-&(+?$ %$4 8+($4 &(,(+9!-$-,(4 &( %$ 4$%#& ,$%(4

1)9) %$ (&#1$1!5-= %)4 (-,)+-)4 %$>)+$%(4= %$ (1)%)"?$= (,1.0$4 !-4,!,#1!)-(4 &!4(S$&$4 >$L) (4,$ *(+4*(1,!2$ >#41$+8- *+)<

,("(+ ;T) +(4,$>%(1(+ (% :#-1!)-$9!(-,) -)+9$% &( ,)&$ %$ *)>%$<1!5-. D( (4,$ :)+9$ *)&(9)4 1)-4(+2$+ %$ (4,+#1,#+$ *+)*#(4,$ *)+6$7%4 ; (3,(-&(+%$ Q$4,$ &$+ +(4*#(4,$ $ %$4 *+()1#*$1!)-(4 &( U(-.

V)-4(+2$+?$9)4 (% 4("#-&) *+!-1!*!) 4)%) O#( %) $*%!1$+?$9)4 &(:)+9$ O#( *#(&$ 1#>+!+ (% 1)-1(*,) &( W"#$%&$& &( X*)+,#-!&$&1)-4!&(+$-&) %$ $9*%!$1!5- Q(1Q$ $% :#-1!)-$9!(-,) -)+9$% &( %)41!#&$&$-)4.

N- (% 1$4) 1)-1+(,) &( %$ &!41$*$1!&$& *$4$ $%") 4!9!%$+. Y-$&!41$*$1!&$& &!:!(+( &( %) O#( 1)9Z-9(-,( %%$9$9)4 (-:(+9(&$&

(- O#( ,!(-&( $ 4(+ #-$ 1)-&!1!5- (4,$>%( &( *P+&!&$ &(% :#-1!)<-$9!(-,) -)+9$%. N4,$ 1)-&!1!5-= 1)9) $*#-,5 U(-= $:(1,$ $% 1!#<

&$&$-) *+):#-&$9(-,( ; %( !9*!&( +($%!M$+ 4#4 $1,!2!&$&(4 1)- %$

!"!#$%&%'(' '!*!('(+ ,-%*#(.(#%'('!*/ 01! .1!'!2 *!3 !2$!2'%'(*#454 #42'%#%42!* 56'%#(* %2#13(78!* (8!9('(* '!8 "12#%42(5%!2$42435(8/ 3!01%!3!2 :(#454'4 3(;42(78!< ( #(3=4 '! 8( *4#%!'('/ $(2$4

!2 !8 $3(7(94 #454 !2 #1(801%!3 4$34 81=(3/ .(3( #3!(3 12 (57%!2$! !2!8 01! !8 3(2=4 '! 4.43$12%'(' '! 12( .!3*42( #42 '%*#(.(#%'('!*!*$6 3(;42(78!5!2$! .34$!=%'4> ?-(2%!8*/ @AABC @DEF+

G(* .!3*42(* 01! *1"3!2 '! (8=12( '%*#(.(#%'(' &!2 8%5%$('4 *13(2=4 2435(8 '! 4.43$12%'('!* ( #(1*( '! *1 #42'%#%H2 '! *(81'+I*$4 8!* %5.%'! !"!#$1(3 12( #42&!3*%H2 ('!#1('( '! 84* 7%!2!* !#4J2H5%#4* K *4#%(8!* 01! $%!2!2 ( *1 (8#(2#!+ L(3( 345.!3 !*$( $!2'!2J#%( 2!=($%&(/ 8( *4#%!'(' '!7! ('(.$(3 84* *!3&%#%4* ( 8( #4512%'(' K

84* #(5.4* 8(743(8!* .(3( 01! *!(2 (##!*%78!* ( !*$(* .!3*42(*+ I*$(!* 8( M2%#( 5(2!3( '! N(#!384* 3!(85!2$! #45.!$%$%&4* K '! %2$!=3(3J84* !2 8( *%2!3=%( #%1'('(2(+

O42 8( !P$!2*%H2 (2$!3%43/ -(2%!8* 84=3( 12( .34.1!*$( 3(Q8*%(2(5R* ($!2$( ( 8(* '%"!3!2#%(* .!3*42(8!* K !2"4#('( ( 8(* #(.(#%'('!*

3!(8!* '! 8(* .!3*42(*/ 4 8%7!3$(' .4*%$%&(/ .(3( (8#(2;(3 *1* "%2!*.34.1!*$4*+ I*$! (#!3#(5%!2$4 7(*('4 !2 2%&!8(3 !8 #(5.4 '! 91!=4.(3( 84* #%1'('(24* (*!=13(2'4 (*S 8( %=1(8'(' '! 4.43$12%'('/ 84=3(

12( "1!2$! !"!#$%&( '! (1$433!*.!$4 K 8%7!3$('+I*$( 54'%"%#(#%H2 24 3!*18$( !P$3(T( ( 8( 5%*5( $!43S( '! U(Q8*

.43 8( .3%43%'(' 01! 68 5%*54 '( ( 8( 4.43$12%'(' .43 *473! !8 .3%2J

#%.%4 '! '%"!3!2#%(+ -! !*$! 54'4/ .!2*(2'4 !2 !*$( .3%43%'('/ 84*.3%2#%.%4* 3!'1#%3S(2 8(* '%"!3!2#%(* *%=2%"%#($%&(* .(3( 8( 4.43$12%J'('+ I*4 24* *1=%!3! 01! *% U(Q8* 24 !P#81K!3( #42#%!2$!5!2$! 8(*#42'%#%42!* '! *(81' (8 %2$!3%43 '!8 !*.!#$34 '! 8( 91*$%#%(/ !*$( !PJ$!2*%H2 .4'3S( 24 *!3 (9!2( ( 84* .3%2#%.%4* 5%*54*+ V%2 !57(3=4/ *%

24 *! 8! '( 5R* .!*4 ( 8( 4.43$12%'(' 01! (8 %2=3!*4/ .4'3S(2 '(3J*! %2$!3#(57%4* 01! ("!#$!2 8( *(81' '! 84* #%1'('(24* .43 *!2$%3*!478%=('4* ( 71*#(3 12 5(K43 %2=3!*4+ I8 .3478!5( !* 01!/ #454 K( *!#45!2$H/ 12 '!#3!#%5%!2$4 !2 8( 4.43$12%'('/ (1201! *!( .(3( (*!J=13(3 12 5(K43 2%&!8 '! 7%!2!* .3%5(3%4*/ 24 *%!5.3! !*$R (#45.(JT('4 #42 8( %=1(8'(' #%1'('(2(+ ,V% 12 %2=3!*4 '!*%=1(8 .34'1#! 12(

5!943( =847(8 !2 !8 S2'%#! WK 24 *48(5!2$! 12 5!943 %2=3!*4W *!3S(3(#%42(8 .(3( 84* .(#$(2$!* (#!.$(3 '%#N( '!*%=1(8'('+ L!34 #1(2'4

!8 (15!2$4 '! 84* %2=3!*4* 24 *! 3!"8!9( !2 !8 3!*$4 '!8 S2'%#! WK(

!"# %&' (&! ")"*+&! '"!,(+#-+"! "- &%&'+,-./#/ /#/#! (#! /"!.0,#(1/#/"! "- !#(,/ & 2# !"# %&' (&! ")"*+&! '"!,(+#-+"! /"( 3#(&' /" (&!/"'"*4&! /" %#'+.*.%#*.5- %&(6+.*# 7/.*4& .-*'"8"-+& -& /"9"'6# !"'

#*"%+#/& -. *&8& ,- .-0'"!& '#*.&-#( -. *&8& #(0& :,!+.).*#/& %&'"( %'.-*.%.& /" /.)"'"-*.#; <- +#("! *#!&!= (# /"!.0,#(/#/ "- "( .-0'"1!& "!+> #!&*.#/# *&- /"!.0,#(/#/"! '"(#+.3#! .8%&'+#-+"! %,"!+& ?,"

8.-#- (#! -"*"!./#/"! @2# !"# /" !#(,/ & /" %#'+.*.%#*.5- %&(6+.*#A/" (&! *.,/#/#-&!; B#C(! !" %'"&*,%# %&' (#! /"!.0,#(/#/"! '"(#+.3#!*,#-/& %&-"- "- '."!0& (#! *#%#*./#/"! /" (.9"'+#/ " .0,#(/#/ /" (&!*.,/#/#-&! DE#-."(!= FGGHI FJF1FJHK;

<- !,8#= (# %'&%,"!+# /" E#-."(! ),-*.&-# %#'# *"''#' ,- 0'#-

)#(+#-+" "- (# +"&'6# /" (# :,!+.*.# /" B#C(!I (# /.!+'.9,*.5- /" (&! 9."-"! '"(#*.&-#/&! *&- (# !#(,/; L# %'.&'./#/ /" (# .0,#(/#/ /"&%&'+,-./#/ &'."-+#/# # %'&+"0"' "( ),-*.&-#8."-+& -&'8#( /" (#!%"'!&-#! 9,!*# #!"0,'#' ,- +'#+& "- .0,#(/#/ 2 '"*.%'&*./#/ "-+'"(&! *.,/#/#-&! #( 8.!8& +."8%& ?," ("! %"'8.+" ,- 8#2&' *#8%&

/" #**.5- %#'# %'&8&3"' !,! %(#-"! /" 3./#; M&- "!+# 8&/.).*#*.5-!" (&0'# '"*&-*.(.#' (# .0,#(/#/ 2 (# (.9"'+#/ /"-+'& /" ,-# +"&'6#'#C(!.#-#;

L# .-+"-*.5- /"( %'"!"-+" +'#9#:& "'# 8&!+'#' (# /.).*,(+#/ %#'# '"1*&-*.(.#' (# %'"+"-!.5- /"( %'.8"' %'.-*.%.& /" (# :,!+.*.# /" B#C(!

7#?,"( ?," /"8#-/# .0,#(/#/ "- (#! (.9"'+#/"! 9>!.*#!7 *&- (#! *&-1!"*,"-*.#! /"( !"0,-/& %'.-*.%.& 7,- '"%#'+& /"!.0,#( /" (&! 9."-"!

!&*.#("! %'.8#'.&! *&- (# 8"+# /" #2,/#' # (&! %"&' !.+,#/&! "- (# "!1*#(# !&*.#(7; M&8& 3.8&!= ,-# /.)"'"-*.# "- (&! 9."-"! !&*.#("! %'.18#'.&! %,"/" '"!,(+#' "- ,- /"*'"*.8."-+& !.0-.).*#+.3& /"( ":"'*.*.&/" (#! (.9"'+#/"! 9>!.*#!= 4#*."-/& .-*&8%#+.9("! #89&! %'.-*.%.&!;

N-+" "!+" %'&9("8# !" -&! %'"!"-+#- /&! &%*.&-"!I #K #9#-/&-#'(# +"&'6# /" (# :,!+.*.# /" B#C(! %&' -& !"' /" ,+.(./#/ # (# 4&'# /" (#

%,"!+# "- %'>*+.*# 2 9K 8&/.).*#' (# +"&'6# %#'# '")&'O#' (&! #!%"*+&!%"'+"-"*."-+"! # (# (.9"'+#/ %&!.+.3# /" (&! *.,/#/#-&!; P" .-+"-1

+#/& !&!+"-"' (# !"0,-/#; L# %'.8"'# &%*.5- !.0," (# %'&%,"!+# /"

!" $%&'(" )% !"* +","+-)")%* )% .%/0 .-/ )1)" %* 1/" ,'&,1%*$" "2(/" !" '"3!*-"/"4 ,%'& 5"*" *1* +'-$%'-& )% 61*$-+-" %/ !" '%"!-7"+-8/ )%!"* +","+-)")%* )% !"* ,%'*&/"* 9 /& %/ 1/ (/)-+% )% 5-%/%* *&+-"!%*

,'-:"'-&*0 ;*$" ,&*$1'" ,'%*%/$" *1* ,'&,-"* )-2-+1!$")%* $"!%* +&:&21/)":%/$"' 2-!&*82-+":%/$% !"* +","+-)")%* 9 )%2-/-' "!<=/ !-*$")& 9,'-&'-)") %/$'% !"* :-*:"*0 >&' !& "/$%'-&'4 :% ,"'%+% :?* %2%+$-@&

&,$"' ,&' %A$%/)%' !" ,'&,1%*$" )% B"3!* C"*$" "!+"/7"' !"* &56%+-&D/%* )% .%/0

E" &,+-8/ F1% ,'&,&/% G"/-%!* 2!19% /"$1'"!:%/$% )% !" -/$%/D+-8/ ,'-:%'" )% !&* ,'-/+-,-&* )% !" 61*$-+-"0 ;* :?* %A,!(+-$" %/ $"/D$& F1% *% +%/$'" %/ !"* )-2%'%/+-"* ,%'*&/"!%* )% !&* +-1)")"/&*4 +&*"

F1% B"3!* /& C"+%4 9 51*+" 1/ %/2&F1% :?* +"'<")& C"+-" %! %6%'+-+-&)% !" !-5%'$") ,&*-$-@"0 H% ,"'%+% F1% %* 1/" &,+-8/ :?* %+&/8:-+"9 ,'?+$-+" ,"'" '%*&!@%' !"* &56%+-&/%* ,!"/$%")"* ,&' !" $%&'(" )% !"*+","+-)")%*0 .-/ %:5"'<&4 $%/%:&* F1% '%+&/&+%' "!<1/&* ,1/$&*,%/)-%/$%*0 B"3!* ,'&,&/% *1 ,'-/+-,-& )% )-2%'%/+-" ,%/*"/)& %/

F1% !"* -/*$-$1+-&/%* F1% *% &')%/%/ +&/ I! -'?/4 ,&+& " ,&+&4 +%D''"/)& !"* )-2%'%/+-"* %/$'% !"* ,%'*&/"*0 ;/ %*$% *-*$%:"4 *%<=/ %*$"$%&'("4 !"* )%*-<1"!)")%* %A+%*-@"* J"F1%!!"* F1% ":%/"7"/ !" -<1"!D

)") 9 !" !-5%'$") )% !&* +-1)")"/&*J /& $%/)'?/ !1<"'0 KG%5%:&*&5*%'@"' $":5-I/ F1% %! ,'-/+-,-& )% )-2%'%/+-" /& *&!& *1,&/% %!21/+-&/":-%/$& )% &$'&* ,'-/+-,-&*4 *-/& $":5-I/ 1/" +-%'$" $%&'("

)% !"* -/*$-$1+-&/%* *&+-"!%* LMN *% 5"*" %/ !" -)%" )% F1% %/ 1/"%+&/&:(" +&:,%$-$-@" O+&/ & *-/ ,'&,-%)") ,'-@")"P4 +&/ 1/ *-*$%D:" "5-%'$& )% +!"*%*4 !"* )%*-<1"!)")%* %A+%*-@"* /& *%'?/ !" '%<!"QOB"3!*4 RSSTU RTVP0

B"3!* ,"'%+% *1,&/%' F1% !"* )-2%'%/+-"* %A$'%:"* " !"* F1% "!1D

)%/ *1* +'($-+&* /& *% )"'?/ )% C%+C& %/ 1/" *&+-%)") &')%/")" ,&'!&* ,'-/+-,-&* )% !" 61*$-+-"0 H% ,"'%+% F1% %*$":&* "F1( "/$% 1/"-)%"!-7"+-8/ )% !"* +&/)-+-&/%* *&+-"!%* 9 F1% %*$? +&/*-)%'")& %! C%D+C& )% F1% C"+% 2"!$" 1/ :(/-:& )% 5-%/%* ,'-:"'-&* ,"'" F1% !"$%&'(" $%/<" %2%+$& ,%'& F1% /& *% ",'%+-" %/ $&)" *1 -:,&'$"/+-" !&*%2%+$&* F1% $-%/% !" )-*$"/+-" F1% C"9 %/$'% !"* )-*$-/$"* ,&*-+-&/%*

*&+-"!%*0E"* )-2%'%/+-"* %/ !"* !-5%'$")%* +-1)")"/"*4 %/ !&* ,&)%'%*4 %/

!"* &,&'$1/-)")%* % -/+!1*& %/ %! "1$&+&/+%,$& /& )%,%/)%/ $"/$&

!" $%"&'() $*+", !" -)&"&*.$ !" /*"$"& -(*01(*)& 2)0) !" ,1& (",132*)$"& !" !"&*4%1,!1! "$ ,1 &)2*"!1! "$ ,1 5%" +*+*0)&6 71(1 819,&"&'1& !*:"("$2*1& '"$!"(;$ 1 "5%*,*/(1(&" 2)$ ", -1&) !", '*"0-) -"()

2(") 5%" "&') $) 2)(("&-)$!" 1 ,1 &*'%12*.$ !" 0%2<1& &)2*"!1!"&=2)0) ,1 $%"&'(1= "$ ,1 5%" ,1& !*:"("$2*1& &)$ '1,"& 5%" ,1& *$&'*'%2*)3$"& ("!%-,*21$ ,1& *$>%&'*2*1& 4"$"(12*.$ '(1& 4"$"(12*.$6

?$ &%01= $) 0" -1("2" 5%" ,1 '")(@1 !" 819,& "$ &@ 0*&01 "&'A"5%*+)21!1= 2(") 5%" "&'; *!"1,*B1!1 C 5%"= "$ ,1 01C)(@1 !" ,1& &)32*"!1!"& 12'%1,"&= &"(@1 0;& -(;2'*21 %$1 +"(&*.$ 5%" 1'"$!*"(1 ,1& !*3:"("$2*1& -"(&)$1,"& C ,1 ("2)$2*,*12*.$ !" ,1 *4%1,!1! 2)$ ,1 ,*/"('1!!"&!" ,1 -"(&-"2'*+1 !" ,1 ,*/"('1! -)&*'*+16 D1 2)$&"2%"$2*1 !" "&')

&"(@1 %$1 *$+"(&*.$ 0;& :%"('" "$ ,1& *$&'*'%2*)$"& 5%" &1,+14%1(!1$,1 *4%1,!1! !" )-)('%$*!1! "$ ,1 &)2*"!1!6

E" -1("2" 5%" "&') $) +*),"$'1 ,1 '")(@1 !" 819,&= C1 5%" A,0*&0) 1/(" ,1 -%"('1 1 %$1 ,*0*'12*.$ !" ,1& ,*/"('1!"& /;&*21& "$2)$!*2*)$"& "F2"-2*)$1,"&G 2%1$!) ,1 &1'*&:122*.$ !" ,1& $"2"&*!13

!"& 01'"(*1,"& /;&*21& $) <1 2%0-,*!)6 H$'"& !" "&'" 0)0"$') $)-)!(@10)& 2)$'1( 2)$ ,1& /1&"& -1(1 %$1 &)2*"!1! /*"$ )(!"$1!1=2)0) -("'"$!" ", 1%')(= -)( ,) 5%" ,1& 0)!*:*212*)$"& -,1$'"1!1&

'"$!(@1$ 5%" ,,"+1(&" 1 21/) I2:(6 819,&= JKKLG MKNO6 P?$ 2%1,5%*"(21&)= -1(1 12"-'1( ,1 )(!"$12*.$ ,"F*2)4(;:*21 !" ,)& !)& -(*$2*-*)&=$) "&'10)& )/,*41!)& 1 $"41( 5%" ,1 -)&*/*,*!1! !" &"( !" ,1& ,*/"(3

'1!"& /;&*21& !"-"$!1 !" ,1& 2*(2%$&'1$2*1&6 Q*$ "0/1(4)= !"/"0)&1&"4%(1($)& !" 5%" ", 2%(&) -)( &"4%*( <12*1 ", 210/*) &"1 '1, 5%" 1,1 -)&'(" &" -%"!1$ 1,21$B1 ,1& 2)$!*2*)$"& &)2*1,"& "$ 5%" C1 $) &"

>%&'*:*5%" ,1 ("&'(*22*.$ !" "&'1& ,*/"('1!"&R I2:(6 819,&= JKKLG STTO6?$ %$1 &)2*"!1! !"&*4%1,= %$ 210*$) 0">)( &"(@1 !1(," -(*)(*!1! 1 ,1

*4%1,!1! !" )-)('%$*!1! -1(1 *$2"$'*+1( ,1 /U&5%"!1 !" ,)& -,1$"& !"+*!1 C ("&"(+1( ", -1'"($1,*&0) -1(1 &"+"()& 21&)& !" !*&21-12*!1!6

819,& >%B41 ", &*&'"01 &)2*1, !"&!" ,1 *4%1,!1! "$ ,1& ,*/"('1!"& C,)& $*+","& !" /*"$"& -(*01(*)&= "$ 2)$2("') ", *$4("&) C ,1 (*5%"B16Q*$ "0/1(4)= A, 0*&0) 1!0*'" )'()& :12')("& 5%" -%"!"$ ,,"41( 12)$&'*'%*( -)&*2*)$"& !" 1((1$5%" -1(1 ,)& >%*2*)& &)/(" ,1 >%&'*2*16

V%1$!) '"$"0)& %$ 21&) "$ ", 5%" ,)& !"("2<)& /;&*2)& !" %$1 -"(3&)$1 &" +"$ !*&0*$%*!)& -)( 1,4%$1 21(12'"(@&'*21 $1'%(1, = 2)0)

"$ ", 21&) !" ,1 (1B1 ) ", 4A$"()= 819,& -1("2" !*&-%"&') 1 1!0*'*(

!"#$ &'()*&*+( &',' -($ .'"*&*+( "'&*$/ )! "-0' .$1$ &'("*)!1$1 /$")!"2!(#$3$" 4-! .')15$ &'(#!(!1 06 $"56 "!1 '73!#' )! /$ 1!)*"#1*7-&*+()!/ "!8-()' .1*(&*.*' )! /$ 3-"#*&*$9 :"*6 .'1 !3!,./'6 !;*"#!( )!<

1!&='" 7>"*&'" )!"*8-$/!" ?-()$)'" !( &$1$&#!15"#*&$" ($#-1$/!" ?*3$"6!"#$" )!"*8-$/)$)!" )!#!1,*($1>( .'"*&*'(!" .!1#*(!(#!"@ A$)' 4-!!"#$" &$1$&#!15"#*&$" (' .-!)!( "!1 ,')*?*&$)$"6 /$" .'"*&*'(!" 4-!

)!?*(!( &'(#$1>( &',' /-8$1!" *(*&*$/!" !( /$ !"#1-&#-1$ 7>"*&$@ B$")*"#*(&*'(!" 7$"$)$" !( !/ "!;' "'( )! !"#! #*.'6 $"5 &',' /$" 4-!)!.!()!( )! /$ 1$C$ 0 /$ &-/#-1$D EF$G/"6 HIIJ9 HKHL@

M! .$1!&! 4-! .')15$,'" 3-C8$1 $/8-('" &$"'" )! )*"&$.$&*)$)&',' .'"*&*'(!" )! $11$(4-! .$1$ /$ )*"#1*7-&*+( )! /$ '.'1#-(*)$)

0 )! /'" 7*!(!" .1*,$1*'"@ N"5 .')15$,'" *(&/-*1 $/8-($ //$,$)$ $/$ 3-"#*&*$ .$1$ /'" *,.!)*,!(#'" ?*3'" 4-! #!(8$ -($ .!1"'($ )$)$"- &'()*&*+( )! "$/-)@ O"#! #*.' )! !"#1-&#-1$ "'&*$/ 0$ /$ 2!,'"*,./!,!(#$)$ !( $/8-('" /-8$1!" &'( /'" .1'81$,$" .$1$ $.'0' $)*"&$.$&*#$)'" 4-! $7$1&$( #$(#' /$ .1!2!(&*+(6 /$ $#!(&*+( 0 !/ $/*2*'

)! /$ &'()*&*+(6 &',' /$ 1!*("!1&*+( "'&*$/ 1!4-!1*)$ .'1 /$ 3-"#*&*$@P!( $.'0$ /$ *)!$ )! 4-! (' *,.'1#$ !/ #*.' - '1*8!( )! /$" )!"<

*8-$/)$)!" !( /$" &$.$&*)$)!"6 0$ 4-! !( #$(#' ?$&#'1!" $17*#1$1*'"

"'( .-(#'" $ &'11!8*1 .'1 /$ 3-"#*&*$@ O"#! .-(#' 1!"-/#$ &'(#1'2!1<#*)' .'14-! (' !"#> &/$1$ /$ ?'1,$ !( /$ 4-! )!7!15$,'" !2$/-$1 /$"&$.$&*)$)!" 0 !/ (*2!/ )! )!"$11'//' ' )! *,.!)*,!(#' 4-! #!(8$(

E&?1@ A$(*!/"6 QKKR9 QJIL@S P!( )!3$ !"#! .-(#' #$( $7*!1#' 4-! "-<.!1$ /$" ?1'(#!1$" )! /$ )*"&$.$&*)$) 0 /$ !(?!1,!)$)@ T'( !"#'6 1!<"-/#$ .1'7/!,>#*&' ,!)*1 4-*U( !"#> !( -($ .'"#-1$ )! )!"2!(#$3$&-$()' (' =$0 -($ /*"#$ )!?*(*)$ )! &$.$&*)$)!" (* )!/ (*2!/ 4-! U"#$")!7!( $/&$(C$1 .$1$ &'("*)!1$1"! $&!.#$7/!" 0 3-"#$"@ V$1!&!15$ 4-!

!/ &'("!("' !" /$ W(*&$ ?'1,$ )! /'81$1 )!?*(*1 4-*U( !" !/ ,!('"$?'1#-($)'@

O( &$,7*'6 "* X$/ ,')' )! A$(*!/"X ('" 7$"$,'" !( !/ &'(<&!.#' )! *8-$/)$) )! '.'1#-(*)$)6 #!(!,'" -($ 7$"! &',.$1$#*2$

en una aparente contradicción: “If worth of liberty is not included among the goods

indexed, then Rawls appears to be authorizing a trade-off between it and the primary

social goods which are indexed, since he claims that the lesser worth of liberty of the

!"# %&%'()*+, -+ !%(+ .% /+ 01#()')+ #%23+ 4)*%/+2 %/ '+!56 .% 01%765+2+ /+ 01#(+ '6!5%(%4')+ %4(2% /6# ')1.+.+46#, 84 %/ '+#6 '64'2%(6.% /+ #+/1.9 #% (2+(+23+ .% /672+2 %/ !+:62 +'%2'+!)%4(6 56#);/% +

+/76 '646').6< %/ &14')64+!)%4(6 462!+/ .% /6# #%2%# =1!+46#, -+#'+5+').+.%# %4(2+4 + 01%76 '64 14 2%&%2%4(% '6!>49 /+ #+/1. '6!6'64.)')?4 .% 56#);)/).+. .%/ .%#+226//6,

8#(+ 56#(12+ !% 5+2%'% !"# '%2'+4+ + /6 @1% %4 /+ 52"'()'+ /6A72+23+ 14+ 2%'64')/)+')?4 %4(2% )71+/.+. : /+ /);%2(+., -+ 56#(12+ .%B+C/#9 //%*+.+ .% (+/ !6.6 @1% 51%.+ %*)(+2 /+ 56;2%D+ : +(%4.%2/+# .%!+4.+# .% #+/1.9 /672+23+9 %4 %&%'(69 2%.1')2 /+# .%#)71+/.+.%##6')+/%# '64 %/ 5+#6 .%/ ()%!56,

E2%69 #)4 %!;+2769 @1% /+# .6# '23()'+# 52)4')5+/%# +@13 52%#%4A(+.+# .%;%4 #%2 5+2(% &14.+!%4(+/ .% 14+ (%623+ .% /+ 01#()')+, -6#

;)%4%# #6')+/%# 52)!+2)6# 46 ;+#(+4 5+2+ %/ +56:6 .% /6# 72156# !"#.%#526(%7).6#, F62 6(26 /+.69 !% 5+2%'% '%4(2+/ @1% 14+ #6')%.+.'64#).%2% /+ 6562(14).+. '6!6 14+ .% /+# 52)4')5+/%# /);%2(+.%# +

526(%7%2, G4+ &62!+ .% =+'%2/6 %# %/%*+4.6 %/ /17+2 .%/ .%2%'=6 +/+ #+/1. .%4(26 .% /+# /);%2(+.%# ;"#)'+# :9 '64#%'1%4(%!%4(%9 +(%4A.)%4.6 /+# .%!+4.+# .% 01#()')+ .% /6# 72156# 5%62 #)(1+.6# + %#(%

2%#5%'(69 %# .%')29 #+()#&+')%4.6 /+# 4%'%#).+.%# .% H71+/.+. .% 6562A(14).+. .% /6# %4&%2!6# : .)#'+5+')(+.6#,

!"!#"$%&'()'

!"#$%&' %) "##$% &'()*(+ ,-*'./'%

*+&%"$,

' &) "#$#% 0123'- 4*56)78 '.( 9.623'- :;)7< ;= 4*56)78> 6. !"#$%&' !#)*+, ?+ @'-*=;).*'+ A7'.=;)( 9.*B6)C*78 D)6CC%

*+&%"$,' E% FGGH% 0I'J-C?C @;KL-6M 1N'-*7')*'.*CK> 6. O)66K'.+ A'K36- P6(%Q% E6J R;)S+ @'K5)*(N6 9.*B6)C*78 D)6CC%

#+-$,' .) "##T% + &UM*V;+ O;.(; (6 @3-73)' 1V;.WK*V'%

,"&' ,K')78'% FGGX% 0Y*CV'L'V*('( 8 Z3C7*V*'%> ['.V; &3.(*'- 6. <77L\]]-'7*.'K6)*V'%(L*%;)N]"A1E,&,I^R,_Y`A@,D,@`Y,YRZ9A^`@`,aGG"%(;V

OpenInsight V2N2-Dialogica p83

Documents

Immunochemische Charakterisierung des p83/100 …bibd.uni-giessen.de/gdoc/2001/uni/d010051.pdf · Immunochemische Charakterisierung des p83/100-Antigens von Borrelia burgdorferi Inaugural-Dissertation

[Architecture eBook] Arquitectonics 6 - Alvar Aalto Una Arquitectura Dialogica (Spa)

[Architecture eBook] Arquitectonics 6 - Alvar Aalto. Una Arquitectura Dialogica (Spa)

KALLEY K-LED32HDZD_chassis_tp.vst59.p83-65w18.pdf

Tertulia Literaria Dialogica-Cat-CONFAPEA

construccion dialogica

04 Amir p83-106.indd

de la critica dialogica

Staff Papers Series - AgEcon Searchageconsearch.umn.edu/bitstream/13541/1/p83-05.pdf · P83-5 Staff Papers Series February1983. MINNESOTA’SECONOMICGROWTH IN RECESSIONAND RECOVERY:

Expo Sic Ion - Etica Dialogica - Adela Cortina Y Jesus Conill

alvar aalto. una arquitectura dialogica (spa)-arquitectonics 6.pdf

L’interpretazione dialogica in ambito sanitario: analisi

How Open is OpenInsight? Connecting our Database to Other Technologies

OpenInsight and U2 Databases. What is OI for U2?

Gli elementi chiave della pratica dialogica

Normativ P83-81

Arquitectonics 6 - Alvar Aalto - Una Arquitectura Dialogica

Educazione dialogica nell’era di internet · Educazione dialogica nell’era di internet Rupert Wegerif Padova luglio 2015 ReteDialogues

De La Dialectica a La Dialogica

314-954 OpenInsight 9.4 Upgrade Guide 9.4... · 2013-03-22 · 23 Section IV: Setting your OIPI version ... 954 ty . Title: Microsoft Word - 314-954 OpenInsight 9.4 Upgrade Guide.docx