View
247
Download
1
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
8/3/2019 C2 SSA Pilot Briefing With Notes
1/26
C2 SSA COI Pilot:
Building Netcentricity in theSpace C2 Weapon System
January 2006
Mrs. Roxanne GroenewoudMajor Mark Schmidt
ESC CC2SG/NGDistribution C. Distribution authorized to US Governmentagencies and their contractors (administrative use, 12 Jan 2006).Refer other requests for this document to CC2SG/NGS.
8/3/2019 C2 SSA Pilot Briefing With Notes
2/26
2
Agenda
Strategic Overview
COI Scope
COI Management
Pilot Goals and Objectives Pilot Options
Pilot Selection
Pilot Acquisition
Metrics Lessons Learned
8/3/2019 C2 SSA Pilot Briefing With Notes
3/26
3
C2 SSA COI Service = C2 SSA Data Model + NCES Security/Discovery/Adapter + NCES Messaging + DoD Metadata Registry
Consumers
Producers/Developers
DDMSDiscovery
Metadata Schemaw/ C2 SSA extensions(XML)
Web Services Info Grid
Advertise
Post
Info Request
Info Delivery
WS Ad
WS P
WS IR
WS ID
DSCS Status DBAuthoritative Source
Web ServiceS D
NCES
Content
Discovery
S D
ServiceAdapter
ServiceAdapter S DS D
UNCLAS
NCES
MessagingD
DoD
Metadata
Registry
NCESServices
ACCESSIBLE
VISIBLE
C2 SSA
UDOP UI
Legacy
SISPUDOP UIDOL Portal /Content
Discovery UI
MetadataRegistry UI
C2 SSAData Model
Schema(XML)
C2 SSASubscription
UI
Developers
UNDERSTANDABLE
S
D
= data flow usesC2 SSA data modelschema
= data flow uses
DDMS Discoverymetadata schema
= uses NCESSecurity forauthorization andPKI
= uses NCESService Discoveryfor web serviceregistry
S
Service Registry
Register & Discover
DSCS
8/3/2019 C2 SSA Pilot Briefing With Notes
4/26
4
Outline
2005 2006
DetermineCOI Scope
Create COI
ManagementStructure
EstablishPilot Goals &
Objectives
Evaluate
PilotOptions
AcquirePilot
SelectPilot
8/3/2019 C2 SSA Pilot Briefing With Notes
5/26
5
C2 Space Situational Awareness Scope
Space
C2
C2 SSA COI
SSA
SSA for C2
8/3/2019 C2 SSA Pilot Briefing With Notes
6/26
6
Outline
2005 2006
DetermineCOI Scope
Create COI
ManagementStructure
EstablishPilot Goals &
Objectives
Evaluate
PilotOptions
AcquirePilot
SelectPilot
8/3/2019 C2 SSA Pilot Briefing With Notes
7/267
C2 SSA COI Structure
Existing Planned
DoD CIO
Service CIOService CIO
Services
Working Group(USSTRATCOMChair)
Service CIOC2 SSA COI Board (O-6)(Maj Gen Shackelford,
AFSPC/DR chair)
C2 SSA COI Forum (FO/GO)(Lt Gen Frank G. Klotz
AFSPC/CV chair)
C2 FCB
Data Mgmt
Working Group(AFSPC/LCO Chair)
Pilot
Working Group(ESC CC2SGChair)
ImplementationWorking Group
(AFSPC &USSTRATCOM
Co-Chair)
Service CIOs
AdditionalWorking Groups
(as required)Additional
Working Groups(as required)
AdditionalWorking Groups
(as required)
8/3/2019 C2 SSA Pilot Briefing With Notes
8/268
C2 SSA COI Management TeamOverall responsibility for groups efforts and COI progress
Provide the action-officer-level administrative dutiesCoordinate issues across COI membership
COI Management Team
Data ManagementWorking Group
Pilot WorkingGroup
Develop COIVocabularies
Identifyauthoritative datasources
Adjudicate SSAdata andmetadatadecisions withstakeholders
ServicesWorking Group
Developprocesses anddemonstrateCOI products(data schema,enterprise
services)
Reduce risk toprogram ofrecord
Facilitateserviceimplementationacross COIspirals
Negotiate andmanageService LevelAgreements(SLAs)
ImplementationWorking Group
Define high level COICapability Roadmap(prioritize data & servicesto be made available)
Define C2-SSA COI joint
operational vision (targetarchitecture)
Synchronize COIproducts with JCIDS,Acquisition, PPBE andMission Areas
8/3/2019 C2 SSA Pilot Briefing With Notes
9/269
Outline
2005 2006
DetermineCOI Scope
Create COI
ManagementStructure
EstablishPilot Goals &Objectives
Evaluate
PilotOptions
AcquirePilot
SelectPilot
8/3/2019 C2 SSA Pilot Briefing With Notes
10/2610
Pilot Goals and Objectives
Select and Design Pilot to:
Provide Military Utility & Operational Leave-Behind
Reduce Risk for COI (define & exercise processes)
Intentionally tackle social / political issues
Depend on DISAs Discovery & Security Services
Derived Constraint Use SIPRNET
Deliver Capability in 12 months
Integrate existing tech rather than develop new tech
Derived Constraint No new contracts
Be Funded
Derived Constraint Use/support program of record
8/3/2019 C2 SSA Pilot Briefing With Notes
11/2611
Outline
2005 2006
DetermineCOI Scope
Create COI
ManagementStructure
EstablishPilot Goals &Objectives
Evaluate
PilotOptions
AcquirePilot
SelectPilot
8/3/2019 C2 SSA Pilot Briefing With Notes
12/2612
Pilot Evaluation Process
Describe characteristics of good Pilot to the Community
Solicit / Identify Pilot Candidates to be evaluated
Reviewed Joint SSA Team recommendations
Asked for Army, Navy, Marines & AF inputs
Tailor Selection Process Evaluation Criteria
Weighting of Criteria (Decision = Weigh Equally)
Preliminary Scoping (costs; plans; schedule; COI
commitments, manpower, funds)
8/3/2019 C2 SSA Pilot Briefing With Notes
13/2613
Evaluation Criteria
Operator
Acquisition
COI
Perspectives: Evaluation Criteria:
- WHAT IS OPS UTILITY (or VALUE) PROVIDED BY PILOT ?- JOINTNESS (ARMY, NAVY, MARINES, AF) ?- DOES PILOT BUILD ON JSSAT RECOMMENDATIONS ?- DOES PILOT BUILD ON AFSPCS HPT USE CASES ?- DOES PILOT PROVIDE FOUNDATION FOR REST OF THIS COI ?
- WHAT ARE THE RISKS AND DEPENDANCIES ?- IS THERE A CONTRACT VEHICLE ALREADY AVAILABLE ?- ARE FUNDS ADEQUATE FOR 12 MONTH SCHEDULE ?- IS PILOT SCOPED TO BE SUCCESSFUL IN 12 MONTHS ?- IS THERE AN OPS DELIVERY THAT PILOT CAN MIGRATE WITH ?
- DOES PILOT HELP ESTABLISH GOOD COI PROCESSES ?- DOES PILOT FOCUS ON EXTERNALLY SHARED DATA ?- DOES PILOT CREATE AN AUTHORITATIVE VOCABULARY FOR THE COI ?- DO AGREED UPON BUSINESS RULES EXIST ?- DOES PILOT ACTUALLY DEMONSTRATE NET-CENTRIC CAPABILITY ?
Exercise processes across multiple boundaries
8/3/2019 C2 SSA Pilot Briefing With Notes
14/2614
Outline
2005 2006
DetermineCOI Scope
Create COI
ManagementStructure
EstablishPilot Goals &Objectives
Evaluate
PilotOptions
AcquirePilot
SelectPilot
8/3/2019 C2 SSA Pilot Briefing With Notes
15/2615
Recommended Pilot to C2 SSA COI Forum & obtained finalapproval
AFSPC/CV approved two operational threads during C2-SSA COIGeneral Officer Forum, 26 Jul 05
Defense Satellite Communication System (DSCS) Thread (Joint
with Army): Automate link status data exchange (M2M) Satellite communications status available near real-time to all
Global Positioning System Thread: Create service to alert operators to satellite changes Improve target location and GPS weapon accuracy
Provide Risk Reduction for Space C2 Weapon System Gain experience with use of Core Enterprise Services
Security, discovery and messaging Exercise net-centric service oriented approach
OSD/NII provided resources to assist the Pilot effort
Pilot Selected
8/3/2019 C2 SSA Pilot Briefing With Notes
16/2616
Outline
2005 2006
DetermineCOI Scope
Create COI
ManagementStructure
EstablishPilot Goals &Objectives
Evaluate
PilotOptions
AcquirePilot
SelectPilot
8/3/2019 C2 SSA Pilot Briefing With Notes
17/2617
COIs
COI Pilot Acquisition Pathfinder
GovernanceRqmts. System Engineering
Security Service Level Agreements
Metrics
Risk ReductionPrototype Delivery Data Schema
NCES interoperability
HeadquartersPolicy andProcedures
COI
Space C2 WSProgram of
Record
DeliverOperationalCapability
Acquire
Pilot
Data Schema
Architecture
Roadmap
COIsCOIs
OSD
A i i i Ch ll S i C ifi i
8/3/2019 C2 SSA Pilot Briefing With Notes
18/2618
Acquisition Challenge -- Security Certificationand Accreditation
SystemDevelopment(continuous)
SystemOperation
(continuous)
SSAADocument(periodic)
SystemChange
CertificationAnalysis(periodic)
Mismatched processes
Inherent bottleneck
Risk
How can IA be built-induring development?
Process certification
A i iti Ch ll S i L l
8/3/2019 C2 SSA Pilot Briefing With Notes
19/26
19
DataProducer
SIPR
SISPServer
Acquisition Challenge -- Service LevelAgreements
Acquisition:Ops. Requirements
ResponsibilitiesInteroperabilityDevelopment
OwnershipFundingTesting
OperationalPerformance:
FrequencyQuality
Accuracy
TimingAvailability
DataFlow
DataConsumer
High Risk Government Responsibility
A i iti Ch ll DISA d
8/3/2019 C2 SSA Pilot Briefing With Notes
20/26
20
Acquisition Challenge -- DISA andInteroperability
Pilot is dependent on DISA NCES services
Accessing services for development from .com
Connecting non-operational with operational systems
Balancing federated v. enterprise security solutions
Interoperability standards / policy between: Data producers and consumers
How to define the interface?
Metadata schema
Security Service
Messaging
8/3/2019 C2 SSA Pilot Briefing With Notes
21/26
21
Metrics for OSD/NII
Evaluate Initial and incremental costs of interfaces
Rational: Provide a quantitative indicator of the cost of net-centricity Compare cost (time + $) of point-point v. net-centric interface development Assess variability in the development costs for future interfaces
Changes / Impacts to Space C2 Weapon System Rational: How did the pilot influence and reduce the risk for future development Document changes to the SISP program. Including roadmap, costs, systems
engineering process, security and test processes attributable to the COI pilot
Service Usage Rational: Understand who is using what service and how often Create an automated log of users and activity Eventually measure unanticipated user activity
Capability Assessment Rational: Assess if pilot provided capabilities are useful to the targeted users Assess the planned capability to be delivered. Did capability meets
expectations? Was additional capability derived? Compare the planned v.actual capability.
8/3/2019 C2 SSA Pilot Briefing With Notes
22/26
22
Some Lessons Learned
Net-Centric information sharing approach not wellunderstood
High learning curve with NCES Core Enterprise Services
Meetings with OSD/NII and DISA of great help
Difficult to articulate & test Net-Centric requirements Performance requirements [SLAs]
Combining operational systems with non-operationalcapabilities (e.g., NCES)
Security requirements when combining systems atdifference mission assurance levels
High level endorsement is key in joint environment
8/3/2019 C2 SSA Pilot Briefing With Notes
23/26
23
Synopsis
Off and running building joint processes
8/3/2019 C2 SSA Pilot Briefing With Notes
24/26
24
Pilot Working Group Points of Contact
Maj Mark Schmidt
Pilot Working Group Chair ESC CC2SG/NG
Mark.Schmidt@cisf.af.mil
719-556-9469
Capt Neil Soliman
Engineer and GPS Domain Expert
ESC CC2SG/NG
Neil.Soliman@cisf.af.mil
719-556-2058
Ms. Mary Pulvermacher
Technical Lead
MITRE
pulver@mitre.org
719-572-8241
Pilot Working Group
8/3/2019 C2 SSA Pilot Briefing With Notes
25/26
25
C2 SSA COI Collaboration Portal
1. To get an AF Knowledge Now Account
Https://afkm.wpafb.af.mil/ASPs/Users/login.asp?filter=ct
2. Direct link to C2 SSA Portal
https://afkm.wpafb.af.mil/ASPs/COP/ClosedCoP.asp?filter=oo-ot-sp-03
8/3/2019 C2 SSA Pilot Briefing With Notes
26/26
26
Back- Up: C2 SSA COI Pilot Responsibilities
DSCSClosed
Network
SATCOM Server Node
Firewall
Security LayerSecurity
Layer
AccessDSCS Data
Get DSCSData
SatelliteStatus Web
Page
SIPRNET
GPS MissionControl Station
2 SOPS
SBMCS-MCSInterface
NavAccData
NavAccPrediction
Web Service
NavAcc AlertService
SISP 1.0 Server
DSCSData
Other SIPRNETUsers
Browser Only
SIPRNET
SIPRNET
SISP Users
SISPClient
SIPRNETXML
DMWG
Army
SISP 1.0
Pilot Addition
GPS StatusService
SIPRNET
PredictionRepository
AlertProfiles
GPS StatusWebsite (NANU)
SIPRNETSIPRNET
SBMCS-NANUInterface
XML
C2 SSA ServerSISP Prototype
DSCS Thread
GPS NavAcc Thread
Recommended