View
114
Download
1
Category
Preview:
DESCRIPTION
Citation preview
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
1 Of 39
English and Cultural Studies Communication Studies Women’s Studies 35 Stirling Highway Crawley WA 6009 Telephone + 61 8 6488 2101 Facsimile + 61 8 6488 1030
ESSAY & EXERCISE COVER SHEET
UNIT:
STUDENT No:
STUDENT'S SURNAME: GIVEN NAME:
TUTOR'S NAME:
ASSIGNMENT No. & QUESTION No.:
DUE DATE: OFFICE USE ONLY DATE RECEIVED:
ALL STUDENTS MUST READ AND SIGN THE FOLLOWING STATEMENT BEFORE AN ESSAY WILL BE ACCEPTED FOR SUBMISSION:
“I am aware of the Faculty policy relating to academic misconduct (www.faculty.arts.uwa.edu.au/enrolled_students/policies/plagiarism) I certify that this work is my own, complies with the relevant guidelines, and uses an approved form of referencing throughout. I acknowledge that the work may be electronically scanned for detection of plagiarism. I have taken a backup copy / computer copy / photocopy of this essay prior to submission.”
Signed ........................................................................... Date ..............................................................
Marker’s Comments:
COMM3001
20910329
BAGARIB SITI AISYAH BINTE SAAD
ROB COVER
Research Report
16 Sept 2012
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
Implications of foreign labour trends and immigration policies on
employment practices and job satisfaction in Singapore
Surname: Bagarib
First name: Siti Aisyah
Student ID: 20910329
Word-count of Research Report: 5,300
2 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
Executive Summary
In order to remain economically competitive, Singapore's relaxed foreign labour policy has resulted
in a large number of foreign workers entering the job market. This study analyzes the effect of the
massive inflow of migrant/transient workers into Singapore on Singapore's labour market. This
study also sought to examine Singaporeans' perspectives on the foreign talent policy and job
satisfaction. Through quantitative and qualitative research, the relationship between the
government's policy on foreign talents and on Singaporean employees' job satisfaction is studied.
The former affects the wages and hiring practices and the latter affects the motivation of
employees and productivity outputs.
A public survey of 45 Singaporean respondents and an interview with 2 respondents were
conducted to establish their perceptions of today’s employment policy. The results found that
discourse on employment policy issues is heavily dominated by economics, and that Singaporeans
prioritize their economic well-being over any demographic changes in the country. This suggests
that government rhetoric’s focus on economic justifications for employment and immigration
policies has prevented a more holistic consideration of policy issues. The findings of this project
contribute to understanding of citizens’ outlook and can be of use in formulating more effective
government policy and also workplace policy.
Keywords: transient workers, Foreign Talent Policy, employee job satisfaction,
3 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
Implications of foreign labour trends and immigration policies on
employment practices and job satisfaction in Singapore
Surname: Bagarib
First name: Siti Aisyah
Student ID: 20910329
University of Western Australia
Word-count of Research Report: 5,300
4 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
Acknowledgements
This research project would not have been possible without the support of many people.
The author wishes to express her gratitude to her lecturer, Prof. Rob Cover who was abundantly
helpful, patient and offered invaluable assistance, support and guidance. Special thanks also to
Bhavani for tutoring sharing the literature and invaluable assistance.
5 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
Table of ContentsExecutive Summary..............................................................................................................................3Acknowledgements..............................................................................................................................5Introduction..........................................................................................................................................7
Hypotheses.......................................................................................................................................8Methodology....................................................................................................................................8
Labour in Singapore.............................................................................................................................9Labour Trends..................................................................................................................................9Fair Employment Practices in Singapore ......................................................................................10
Singapore's Foreign Talent Policy .....................................................................................................111. Economic Factors......................................................................................................................12
Types of Work Passes ..............................................................................................................122. Political Factors.........................................................................................................................133. Social Factors.............................................................................................................................14
Employee Satisfaction........................................................................................................................18Study: Reasons employers hire non-Singaporeans...................................................................18
Employee Satisfaction Survey............................................................................................................19Profile of Respondents...................................................................................................................19Survey Duration.............................................................................................................................20Method of Delivery........................................................................................................................20Survey Results: Stage 1.................................................................................................................20Survery results: Stage 2.................................................................................................................22
Employee Satisfaction Interview........................................................................................................26Profile of Respondents...................................................................................................................26Method of Delivery........................................................................................................................27Interview Results...........................................................................................................................27
Stealing Jobs............................................................................................................................27 Job Satisfaction........................................................................................................................28 Work-life Balance....................................................................................................................28 Relevant Skills.........................................................................................................................28 Knowledge-based Economy....................................................................................................29
Conclusion..........................................................................................................................................31References..........................................................................................................................................33
6 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
IntroductionConcerns over fair opportunities for Singaporeans emerged as the top issue for the first time in
2011 . There is increasing dissatisfaction among Singaporeans on the employment policies in
Singapore, which is largely attributed to Singapore's relaxed foreign labour policies. Discussions at
the Singapore Institute of International Affairs (SIIA) also concluded that Singapore's dependence
on foreign labour is currently the highest among East Asian economies (Yeo Aiqi 2011). Tripartite
Alliance for Fair Employment Practices (TAFEP), a fair employment watchdog, states in it's annual
reports that the number of complaints received in 2011 was more than double of that of the
previous year. Nationality was one of the top three types of complaints, stating that employers
prefer foreigners over locals.
This paper describes and analyzes Singapore foreign labour trends and how Singapore's
immigration policies affect local employment practices and job satisfaction of Singaporeans. It
examines the economic, political and social shifts that the government has to consider in
formulating policies related to the employment structure. It then analyzes more deeply the current
employment practices in Singapore and how these policies affect job satisfaction among
Singaporeans. It also discusses the challenges ahead for Singapore in it's plight to stay
economically competitive. Finally proposes ways in which the challenges might be overcome.
The significance of this report is to improve public understanding of the role and significance of
having foreigners in Singapore's labour pool. Secondly, it serves to increase awareness of the
current employment issues in Singapore. This report also contributes in improving existing
literature on employment policies in Singapore.
7 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
Hypotheses
1) Actual hiring practices conflicts with fair employment policies.
2) Current labour trends and employment practices are inevitable in order for Singapore to
continue striving economically.
Methodology
This study was conducted in three stages: Firstly, literature reviews was done on the economic,
political and social factors that may affect labour policies in Singapore; Secondly, quantitative
research methods involving a public survey was deployed to study Singaporean employees' level of
job satisfaction. Qualitative research involving individual interviews was also conducted to give
more insights on the topic. Two Singaporeans were interviewed. One of them is a working student
in Australia, giving his personal insights one how Singapore and Australia differ. The second
interviewee works at an IT MNC, giving insights on hiring practices of foreigners in that
organization. The qualitative research method enables a deeper understanding of the issue already
studied using the quantitative methodology (Berg 1998).
8 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
Labour in Singapore
Labour Trends
An ASEAN Community is aimed to be established amongst ASEAN member countries by 2015. A
single market offers many advantages and influences regional labour trends. The community will
narrow developmental gaps between ASEAN countries by increasing integration within the region,
allowing each member country to maximize productivity, individual development potential and
competitiveness while offering security, stability, prosperity and social progress. However success
in achieving these goal would depend on how well governments, employers and workers can work
together to collectively pursue their progress.
Singapore relies on human resources as the engine of economic growth as its small country size
does not produce any natural resources. The demand for foreign labour arises from short-term
needs of the business cycle and the long-term needs of economic growth and restructuring. In
1998, employment of foreign workers increased rapidly and accounted over 20% of the workforce
(Chia 2001). The trend then seem to be towards low-skilled foreign labour. Subsequently Singapore
realized that their dependence on low-skilled foreign workers does not contribute in improving the
profile of it's workforce. Singapore's labour and immigration framework was then amended
towards developing a Knowledge-based Economy (KBE) and designed to attract higher-skilled,
higher-qualified foreign workers to enhance the national workforce (Ministry of Manpower 1999).
Powell and Snellman (2004) defines a knowledge-based economy as “production and services
based on knowledge-intensive activities that contribute to an accelerated pace of technical and
scientific advance, as well as rapid obsolesce”.
9 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
The increment of the national labour force with foreign labour remains one out of six key elements
in Singapore's future economic plans and policies as outlined in the county's Manpower 21 Report.
However dependence on low-skilled workers such as those in construction, manufacturing and
domestic helpers are reduced and hired on transient basis to increase labour flexibility, whereby
intake is increased and reduced according to economic expansion or contraction.
Fair Employment Practices in Singapore
The Tripartite Alliance for Fair Employment Practices (TAFEP) works in partnership with the
government and unions to promote and facilitate the adoption of the adoption of fair, responsible
and merit-based employment practices among employers, employees and the general public.
TAFEP also provides advisory services and training workshops to help organizations implement fair
employment practices. Tripartite Guidelines on Fair Employment Practices asserts that while
foreigners play a valuable role in enhancing the workforce, Singaporeans must remain the core of
the workforce. Highlighting one of the six principles of Fair Employment Practices from their
handbook, to provide employees with equal opportunity to be considered for training and
development is one of the key themes of this report.
In Singapore, three legislatives regulate the management and deployment of foreign labour. They
are the Immigration Act, Employment of Foreign Workers' Act and the Penal Code. The
Immigration Act are law enforcement guidelines pertaining to immigration violations and
discretion towards both employers and illegal migrant workers. The Employment of Foreign
Workers' Act issues employment passes, work permits and regulates the foreign levy system. The
Penal Code penalizes abuse or non-payment or workers (Kaur 2006). Prison sentences and caning
have controlled migrant workers from overstaying and unauthorized entry.
10 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
Singapore's Foreign Talent Policy
By examining Singapore's unique backdrop, government, and immigration and employment
policies, we will be able to better understand how its finanscape and ideoscape has been affected.
The term immigrant worker in Singapore is separated into foreign workers and foreign talents.
Foreign workers refer to low-skilled workers who largely work in construction, manufacturing or
domestic service sectors. Foreign talent refers to foreigners with specialized skills or good paper
qualifications. The foreign talent policy came about as Singapore heads towards a knowledge-
based economy. Over the years, the PAP Government have used the term foreign talent loosely,
broadly, and interchangeably to formulate 'foreign talent policies'. Often, the term 'foreign talent'
in foreign talent policies lacked definition and includes foreign workers, fresh foreign graduates
and just normal foreign workers. There seems to be certain disconnect with the foreign talent
policies as they contradict the rationale of filling in the shortage of skills in Singapore's talent pool,
such as in healthcare. For example in 2007, The Ministry of Manpower announced a new initiative
called Work Holiday Programme (WHP) to attract foreign talents to work in Singapore. The
initiative was open for 2000 students and university graduates between the ages of 17-30 from
Australia, France, Germany, Hong Kong, Japan, New Zealand, the UK and US. The WHP pass is valid
for 6 months. However there were no restrictions made on the type of work allowed or minimum
salary requirements (Ministry of Manpower 2007).
For the purpose of this research project, the term foreign talents refers to skilled and semi-skilled
people who have come to Singapore in order to work or study. These are people who have not
11 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
spent the large part of their lives in Singapore. The term foreign talents excludes low-income job
sectors in construction and domestic maids.
1. Economic Factors
Singapore ranked second in 2012's Global Statistical Report. The report ranks 142 countries based
on the Global Competitive Index of the Geneva-based World Economic Forum (WEF) (McArthur
and Sachs 2002), which measures how effective the policies, institutions and factors that affect
economic prosperity are being utilized (World Economic Forum, 2012). Singapore, because of it's
and population size, has always relied on migrant workers to boost it's economic growth since it's
founding in 1819. The British free-trade policy attracted migrants to carry out trade in Singapore
and it's main economic pillar was entrêpot trade. Many also came to work at plantations (Trocki
2001). Migration was brought into focus again in 1980s and the influx of foreign workers in
Singapore continued to increase. In 2011, of the 1.46 million non-resident population (National
Population and Talent Division 2012), 720000 were working foreign talent, excluding Permanent
Residents and the ones in construction and domestic workers, (MOM 2011).
The influx of immigrants has supplied it's labour market with diverse and sufficient manpower to
compete globally and has continued to benefit Singapore economically. Singapore's success in
attracting Foreign Direct investment (FDI) can also be attributed to attractive investment incentives
and low tax rates (Rajan, 2004). To ensure high productivity outputs, job market and wages have to
be kept competitive. New work passes were also introduced to support the influx.
Types of Work Passes
Employment Pass: (1) P—pass: aimed at professional, managerial, knowledge workers
12 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
(2) Q—pass: aimed at skilled workers with a minimum 5 years work
experience. Not subject to levies. Allowed to bring family and apply
for residency or citizenship.
(3) Personalized Employment Pass: aimed at skilled independent
migrant workers such as foreign students from higher learning
institutions in Singapore.
S—pass: aimed at foreign workers with starting pay of S$1800 per month such as degree or
diploma holders in a technical field. Subject to employment quotas and levies. Disallowed
from bringing family along.
Work Permit: or R—pass, aimed at semi-skilled or low-skilled workers. Subject to
employment quotas and levies. Disallowed from bringing family along.
2. Political Factors
The People's Action Party (PAP) has been the dominant ruling party in Singapore Since its
independence. The PAP has been criticized for it's authoritative governance, building on the
Leninist model, which believes that politics should be handled by a small elite group. Lee Kwan
Yew, the founding political leader of Singapore created policies based on Confucian or 'Asian
values'. The Confucian value system have rigorously been used in promoting moral and social
values and legitimizing the authoritative governance and interests of the state (Chua 1995). An
instance of this is the government’s emphasis on placing society above self such as encouraging
women to take on more economically productive role, increasing the retirement age and is also
used to justify not being a welfare state to ensure the young to look after their old (Kuah 1990).
13 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
3. Social Factors
Singapore faces a vicious cycle of an ageing population, declining birthrates, shrinking workforce.
Ageing Populations
The proportion of Singapore residents aged 45 years and above expanded over time.
Mortality rates means people live longer. Singapore can't sustain an aging yet shrinking
population.
Chart 1: Age Pyramid of Resident Population
Population Trends 2011 Department of Statistics Singapore
Declining Birth Rates
It is common for developed countries to have a total fertility rate (TFR) below the
replacement level of 2.1. However, Singapore currently has a TFR severely below
replacement level. Singapore is ranked last on the list of an Independent US Government
Agency (Central Intelligence Agency 2012).
14 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
There is a continued decline in births of almost 5% across all ethnic groups since 2009
(Singapore Department of Statistics 2011). Malays producing more babies still. However the
overall decline has continued to drop from a 2.1 replacement rate in 1975 to just 1.2 in
2012 (National Population and Talent Division 2012)
Table1: Total Fertility Rates (TFR)
Year Total Chinese Malays Indians
2000
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
1.60
1.26
1.28
1.29
1.28
1.22
1.15
1.43
1.10
1.11
1.14
1.14
1.08
1.02
2.54
2.03
2.02
1.94
1.91
1.82
1.65
1.59
1.29
1.27
1.25
1.19
1.14
1.13per 1,000 Population Trends 2011 Department of Statistics Singapore
The decline in births is also attributed to residents postponing marriages, declining
marriage rates and also not having as many children as before. There was a steady decline
in registered marriages in Singapore since 2003, with divorce rates rising (Singapore
Department of Statistics 2011). Most Singaporeans are choosing to get married at a later
age around 30-34.
The government has been trying to encourage Singaporeans to have more babies by
increasing benefits. These benefits include baby bonus cash incentive of up to S$6,000, tax
rebate, paid maternity leave and child-related leave (National Population and Talent
15 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
Division 2012). However, there are other factors that contribute to the declining birthrates
such as work stress, overtime, expensive education and people are staying in school longer
in order to get better qualifications for better jobs are all interlinked factors that (Ramesh,
2011).
Overcrowding
Singapore's population has increased from 3.04 million to 5.18 million within the past
decade. It's population density of 7,257 persons per/km² places it in the top three highest
in the world (Department of Statistics 2012).
Low Wages and Income Gap
High immigration rate increases competition with the resident population for jobs,
inadvertently lowering wages and increasing the income gap for Singaporeans. The income
gap between it's rich and poor is one of the widest in the world (Wah 2012). Mr Manu
Bhaskaran, senior research fellow at the Singapore Prespectives 2012 Conference,
expressed that the rising influx of foreign workers “almost certainly impacted wage growth
at parts of the income distribution and thereby worsened inequality” (Wah 2012). While
higher income groups saw their income grow annually the lower income groups suffered
income recession. The foreign labour policy aggravated the circumstances of the dislocated
lower-income wage earners. Business owners and employers benefit because they increase
profit by cutting labour cost.
16 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
Government has introduced these measures to counter problems:
Amidst increasing dissatisfaction from Singaporeans regarding effectiveness of foreign
employment and immigration policies, political leaders have continued to defend the
foreign talent policies as a matter of economic necessity. Nevertheless, the government has
responded to public pressure and will moderate demand for foreign manpower. Singapore's
Ministry of Manpower has had to alter the inflow of foreigners into the workforce. The bar
was raised for foreign workers wishing to attain Singapore work Visa. Measures such as
increased qualifying salaries, tightened educational qualifications and Dependency Ratio
Ceilings (DRC) for employment pass workers, has resulted in a 30% rejection of foreign work
pass applications in the first 7 months of 2012. This is an increase from the 26% total
rejected applications in 2011 (Ministry of Manpower 2012).
The NPTD is also seeking feedback from the public on tackling marriage, parenthood,
immigration and integration issues (National Population and Talent Division 2012).
17 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
Employee Satisfaction
Employee satisfaction is commonly measured by anonymous employee satisfaction surveys
administered to gauge employee satisfaction. The common facets of job satisfaction are
satisfaction with salary, promotion opportunities, relations with co-workers and supervisors and
the work itself (Smith, Kendall, & Hulin, 1969). Employee attitudes is positively associated with
organizational ethics and financial performance (Koh and El'fred). Employees would be more
committed to an organization that satisfiy their needs (Steers 1977).
Study: Reasons employers hire non-Singaporeans
A survey done by JobStreet revealed that Singaporean employers prefer to hire non-
Singaporeans because of their flexibility. Of the 200 employers surveyed, 40% said their
main reason for hiring foreigners was because they are less particular with regards to time,
job scope and location of workplace. This is the reason business owners like Wei Chan, who
is the owner of a bakery, hires the maximum quota of foreigners that Singapore Labour law
allows. 20% of employers surveyed also said that they thought foreigners were more skilled
in certain areas of expertise. However, the vice president of Conrad and Ottess Private
Asset Management Limited, a private asset management firm, responded that if other
factors such qualifications, experience and attitude are taken into consideration, preference
would be in favour of Singaporeans (Choo 2012).
18 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
Employee Satisfaction Survey
The employment satisfaction survey provides an preliminary examination on job satisfaction of
Singaporean employees. The purpose of the survey is to determine the existing levels and factors
affecting job satisfaction among Singaporeans. In light of recent increased dissatisfaction and
complains lodged by employees, it is worth taking a look into the issue to find out the underlying
causes.
In Stage 1 of the survey, respondents were asked to rate work attributes that are important to
them. They were asked to choose as many attributes as they found applicable from a list of 10 pre-
listed attributes. Attributes listed in the questionnaire were mostly selected based on a 2011 Work
Happiness Indicator Report done by JobsCentral. A total of 2,384 working adults participated in the
2011 Work Happiness Indicator Report, therefore results regarding the work attributes that are
important is highly significant (JobsCentral 2011). The list of desirable work attributes used in this
survey are advancement opportunities, appreciation of work done, bonus, challenge, interesting
work, job security, medical benefits, positive impact to society, good relations with colleagues,
salary, work recognition, work-life balance.
In Stage 2, a series of questions and statements was presented and respondents were asked to rate
items answered on a 5-point answer scale.
Profile of Respondents
45 anonymous respondents was needed for the survey. Respondents had to be Singaporean
citizens with some working experience. A minimum working experience criteria of three months is
19 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
sufficient for this research as an average duration of temporary employment as well as 'probation
period' before a confirmed employment in Singapore is three months. Respondents were not
informed of the study hypotheses.
Survey Duration
The survey was conducted from 16th August 2012 for over a period of 3 weeks.
Method of Delivery
The survey was conducted online.
Survey Results: Stage 1
The first few questions in the survey questionnaire was to ensure that response eligibility criteria
were met. Those sampled were 17-49 years old inclusive, as typical work age fall in this age group.
Almost all of the respondents (87%) were in their twenties. At 17, a typical Singaporean would
have graduated secondary school with an O-level or A-level certificate. This proved to be accurate
as all the survey respondents held a formal educational qualification of some type: 15% held N-
level or O-level passes, 49% held diploma qualifications, and 29% held university degrees. 7% had
done their masters.
Table 2: Demographic profile of survey respondentsVariable Percentage
Age17-20 years21-29 years30-39 years
4%87%7%
20 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
40-49 years 2%
EducationN-levels/ O-levelsDiplomaDegreeMasters
15%49%29%
The major findings of the survey are as follows. The interview data reveal that salary plays the
most important role for Singaporean employees. Having a job that is interesting came as second
most important attribute, work recognition and bonus were rated equally in third place. Task
significance (Hackman and Oldham 1975), otherwise known in this survey as “positive impact to
society”, is the degree to which the job impacts external environment or the immediate
organization was ranked important by only 15 respondents. Job challenge was ranked the least
important.
Chart 2: Job Attributes Important to Singaporean Workers
Although the monetary aspect is widely believed to be a leading factor in job satisfaction, intrinsic
psychological rewards provides job satisfaction too (Timmreck, 2001). As derived from the survey,
21 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
results show that employees placed about the same weightage on having a job that interests them
(85%) with salary (91%). This demonstrates that job engagement is important to Singaporeans as it
makes tasks more fulfilling and enjoyable. However, of 1000 Singaporean employees surveyed in
Towers Watson's 2012 Global Workforce Study, 72% we found to be less engaged in their work
(Towers Watson 2012).
Survery results: Stage 2
Respondents were asked to rate their response to a series of questions and statements on a 5-
point answer scale which is: very dissatisfied, dissatisfied, neither dissatisfied nor satisfied,
satisfied and very satisfied. The first set of questions is regarding the level of satisfaction of work-
related facets. Chart 3 below excludes 'neither dissatisfied nor satisfied' responses because it does
not contribute to the analysis. However it was important to have 'neither dissatisfied nor satisfied'
option in the questionnaire so as to avoid inaccurate results by compelling respondents to choose
a positive or negative response to statements they have a neutral stance on.
A set of 9 questions beginning with “How satisfied are you with:” was asked in regards to; (1) their
salary; (2) job training; (3) recognition they get for their work; (4) overall job security; (5) the
professional growth from tasks are assigned to them; (6) the working environment; (7) working
practices; (8)employee benefits; and (9)employment hiring practices in Singapore?
22 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
Chart 3: Job Satisfaction Survey
In general, responses regarding workplace satisfaction is positive (60%). Singaporeans seem to be
most satisfied with their current working environments. The only two questions that received
higher dissatisfied responses than satisfied ones is regarding salary and professional growth. 58%
responded that they were not satisfied with the salary they receive.
From this set of questions, salary is again highlighted as the factor that employees are most
dissatisfied with. This might inter-relate with the results in the first survey where respondents'
answer reflects on what they desire in future jobs.
23 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
52% did not think that the tasks assigned to them at work contributed to their professional growth,
16% responded that they are very dissatisfied. When asked about satisfaction of hiring practises in
Singapore only 51% responded positively, with 11% being very dissatisfied.
In the second set of questions, respondents were asked whether they agreed that (1) Their
education in Singapore gives leverage over foreign talents working in Singapore; (2) Their
workplace hires foreign talents; (3) The company they work for care about it's employees; (4)
Employers prefer foreign talents over its indigenous worker; (5) There is ample opportunity to get a
job promotion; and (6) Foreign talents and Singapore's indigenous workers are provided with equal
career opportunities.
Chart 4: Opinion Survey
24 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
Regarding promotion, 27 respondents did not have opinions on being promoted (60%). Education
and age range can provide an explanation to this. Almost 90% of the respondents were relatively
young, below 30 years old, and usually not at an age where they have decided to make the current
job their career.
Working with foreign talents are common in the workplace, however a staggering 84% believe that
the education in Singapore does not give them any advantage over foreign employees. This is a
worrying figure as Singapore prides itself for having top-notch education syllabus but that
knowledge provides no application leverage in future work-life.
25 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
Employee Satisfaction Interview
Qualitative research enables a deeper understanding of the issue already studied using the
quantitative methodology (Berg 1998). The interview questions consisted of how respondents
view the foreign talent policy in Singapore; the efficiency of foreign talents in affecting
competitiveness and economic growth; Singaporean work attitudes and whether there is an
association between the job happiness and the foreign talent policy.
Profile of Respondents
Three interviewees were selected for the interview stage. Respondents had to meet the same
criteria as in the survey. Respondents had to be Singaporean citizens with work experience. One
male and female were interviewed. Both were diploma holders pursuing a university degree. There
is a bias towards Singaporeans with higher education for this interview. This bias is useful as
higher-educated individuals are generally more aware of current affair issues and can provide a
better insight on the issue at large.
Table 3: Profile of interview respondents
Respondent Gender Age Education
Ismail Male 25 Diploma
Aggy Female 24 Diploma & Degree
undergraduate
26 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
Method of Delivery
Interviews were done face-to-face. Interviewees were ensured of anonymity. Each person
interviewed were asked different sets of questions based on their different backgrounds.
Interview Results
Ismail has been living in Melbourne, Australia for two years. He is there to further his
studies and at the same time works to support himself. The interview gives insights of how
it is like to be a foreign worker in Australia. The second interviewee,Aggy, has worked at a
major IT MNC in Singapore for two years. She is currently working while pursuing her
degree. She gives her account on the hiring practices at her workplace.
Stealing Jobs
When Ismail was asked if his Australian colleagues has shown adversity towards foreign workers or
if he feels that he is stealing their jobs, he replied that he has never encountered racism or
xenophobia at the workplace. As for stealing jobs from Australians, he responded that the
minimum wage system ensures that workers are paid fairly and not shorthanded. The minimum
wage applies to both the locals and foreign workers thus Australians do not face problems with
foreign talents lowering or compromising wages for the locals.
“The unemployed here also receive money from welfare every month. In Singapore if
you are unemployed, you're on your own. Not only do Singaporeans have to
compete with foreigners on jobs, they also have to compete with them for housing.
It's almost as if there is no incentive of being a citizen and a foreigner, so maybe
27 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
that’s why Singaporeans are more unhappy with the presence of foreign talents.”
Job Satisfaction
Asked whether Ismail thought Melbourne is a better place to work as compared to Singapore?
“Personally, I would say yes. The work culture here is different. My employers here
constantly give out rewards for good work. You won't have to wait till mid or end-
year to be appraised and I feel more appreciated than when I was working in
Singapore. Wages are more attractive here than in Singapore.
Work-life Balance
When asked about work-life balance, he mentions about the plight of middle class in Singapore,
which is where most Singaporeans belong to.
“At the end of the day, work is work. You have to earn a living. No matter where
you choose to work and live, there are always pros and cons. In Singapore, the
government is more proactive in developing policies rather than reactive to
citizen's feedback. Transport, healthcare and services are more efficient. It is
relatively safer to walk around at night in Singapore. However, the middle-class
workers, are generally overworked, underpaid and under-appreciated. In
Melbourne the transport system and services are not as efficient and cost of living
is high. However, salaries are better, the government is more reactive to public
feedback and most importantly there is a better work-life balance.”
Relevant Skills
PAP's liberal pro-foreigner policies can partly be blamed for causing decline in productivity in 2012
28 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
because recruiters face challenges in finding the right manpower(Grosse 2012). The criteria
needed to apply for work visa in Singapore is too low thus does not target what the market needs.
Having a more selective requirement criteria would be beneficial. Ismail revealed that unlike PR
application in Singapore, application criteria for Permanent Residence in Australia is more
stringent. It includes an English language proficiency test, having a job listed in the Skilled
Occupancy List, acquiring enough years of job experience and necessary qualifications and
character requirements (Department of Immigration and Citizenship). Unlike in Singapore where
there is no minimum residency period for Singapore PRs. According to a Straits Times report,
Chinese national Zhang Yuanyuan, obtained her Singapore PR within 2 months of application
(Straits Times 2010). Neither do applicants need to pass an English proficiency test. This poses
problems in communication and efficiency especially in service and sales sectors. English is the
unifying language of business, government and education, although there are 4 four official
languages in Singapore, (Chia 2011).
Knowledge-based Economy
There was skepticism when asked whether the foreign talent policy helping Singapore move into a
successful Knowledge-based economy. Aggy described her experience with the multinational
corporation that she works at.
“There was a sudden influx of foreign talents from India, Myanmar and Philippines
hired by the company last year. This year, most of them have gone and there are a
lot of vacant cubicles in the office. Foreign workers are dispensable, they are
always the first to go. Though the dismissed foreign workers were from a different
department, the company has now started to dismiss Singaporeans too. Most of
29 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
the jobs are being outsourced to India. I have had to train them myself and I
wouldn't say they are more skilled or capable or productive than Singaporean
workers. They work longer hours and it costs less to hire them.
It's very worrying that companies value Singapore labour for its low costs rather
than the skills of the workers. The government has emphasized on upgrading skills
and education but the workers themselves are not being valued that way. I do not
blame these companies for their search for cheaper labour, but I think it is the job
of the government to implement policies that help protect its citizens, not exploit
them.”
An analysis made by the Economic Strategies Committee in 2010 in Monetary Authority of
Singapore's annual report predicts that a lower productivity growth and a lower labour force
growth per annum supported by much higher quality of labour, produces higher quality growth in
10 years. In detail:
“The expected labour productivity growth rate of between 2% and 3% p.a.,
combined with the projection of an average 1-2% p.a. labour force growth by the
Economic Strategies Committee, produces a medium-term potential GDP growth
rate of 3-5% p.a. for the Singapore economy over 2010 – 2019.” (Monetary
Authority of Singapore 2010)
30 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
Conclusion
The presence of foreign labour in Singapore is important and beneficial to the economy. It plays a
role in increasing size of the national workforce, increasing the output capacity and thus improving
it's economic growth. However, economic benefits should be weighed against social costs that now
has become very prominent in Singapore. High-income foreign talents benefit most from the
Foreign Talent Policies and higher-income Singaporean may not be affected by it's disadvantages.
The high saturation of middle to lower-skilled foreigners in the job market compromises wages for
Singaporeans. Majority of Singaporeans are in the middle-income group. They and the lower-
income Singaporeans are most affected by depressing wages.
From the survey done, job salary is the most important factor chosen that affect Singaporean's
attitude towards the job. However this is not the only factor that is important. Being engaged in
the work that they do is also important to them. Almost half of the respondents expressed that
they did not think that the tasks they are assigned contributes to their professional growth. It can
be deduced that majority of diploma and young degree holders in Singapore are being underpaid
or hired for jobs where they are undervalued and not utilized fully for their skills.
When there is demand, there will be supply. More higher-skill requirement jobs have to be created
to truly move Singapore into a knowledge-based economy. While most locals do not have a
problem working with foreigners, there needs to be more screening in place to bring in more
specific and qualified foreign talents to augment the indigenous workforce. A minimum-wage
system should also be implemented to ensure that employers don’t cut back on pay, and that
31 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
middle and and lower-income workers do not drift further back resulting in an even bigger income
gap.
From the hypothesis that was set out in the beginning of this study, it can be concluded that:
1. Actual hiring practices conflict with fair employment policies in terms of tendency to
employ workers based on lower labour cost rather than purely by merit. However this is
not actually against the law as long as employers keep hiring foreign labour within the
quota set by Singapore labour laws.
2. Singapore can continue to strive economically if it chooses to cut down on low-cost labour
and focus on providing high skill jobs and hiring quality workers. Economic growth would
move at a slower pace for the first ten years, but the benefits are are more rewarding after
that.
32 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
ReferencesKoh, H.C. & El'fred, H.Y.B. 2004, "Organisational ethics and employee satisfaction and
commitment", Management Decision, vol. 42, no. 5, pp. 677-693.
Smith, P. C., Kendall, L. M., & Hulin, C. L. (1969). The measurement of satisfaction in work and
retirement. Chicago: Rand McNally.
Steers, R. M. (1977) 'Antecedents and Outcomes of Organizational Commitment.' Administrative
Science Quarterly. 22, pp. 46-56.
Berg, B.L. (1998) Qualitative Research Methods for the Social Sciences, 3rd ed. Boston, MA: Allyn &
Bacon.
JobsCentral (2011) '2011 Work Happiness Indicator Report'. Available at:
http://jobscentral.com.sg/survey/happiness_survey/2011 (accessed 15 September 2012).
Towers Watson (2012) 2012 Global Workforce Study. Available at:
http://www.towerswatson.com/assets/pdf/7564/TowersWatson-GWS-At-a-Glance-NA-2012-
25644.pdf (accessed 15 September 2012).
Hackman J.R. and Oldham G.R (1975) 'Development of the Job Diagnostic Survey.' Journal of
Applied Psychology. 60 (1975), pp. 159–170.
33 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
Timmreck, T.R. (2001) 'Managing motivation and deleping job satisfaction in the health care work
environment.' The Health Care Manager. 20 (1) (2001), pp. 42–59.
Yeo Aiqi (2011) 'Foreign Labour Policy Discussed at the SIIA.' Business Times Singapore, 11 October
2011. Available at: http://siiaonline.org/?q=blog/foreign-labour-policy-discussed-siia-business-
times-channel-newsasia-11-october-2011 (accessed 10 September 2012).
Kaur, A. (2006) Order (and disorder) at the border: Mobility, international labour migration and
border controls in Southeast Asia. In A. Kaur & I. Metcalfe (Eds.), Mobility, labour migration and
border controls in Asia , pp. 23–25. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Ministry of Manpower (1999) Manpower 21: Vision of Talent Capital. Singapore: Ministry of
Manpower.
Chia Siow Yue (2001). 'Singapore: Towards a Knowledge-based Economy' pp. 169-208 in Seiichi
Masuyama, Donna Vandenbrink, Chia Siew Yue, eds., Industrial Restructuring in East Asia: Towards
the 21st century. Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asia Studies.
Chia Siow Yue (2011). 'Foreign Labour in Singapore: Trend, Policies, Impacts, and Challenges',
Singapore Institute of Internal Affairs October 2011. Available at:
http://dirp4.pids.gov.ph/ris/dps/pidsdps1124.pdf(accessed 10 September 2012).
McArthur, J. W. and J. D. Sachs. (2002) 'The Growth Competitiveness Index: Measuring
34 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
Technological Advancement and the Stages of Development.' In: The Global Competitiveness
Report 2001–2002. New York: Oxford University Press for the World Economic Forum.
Schwab, K. (2012) 'The Global Competitive Report 2012-2013.' World Economic Forum. Available
at: http://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_GlobalCompetitivenessReport_2012-13.pdf (accessed
15 September 2012).
Trocki, C. A. (2001), 'Development of Labour Organisation in Singapore, 1800-1960.' Australian
Journal of Politics & History, 47: 115–129. Available at
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com.ezproxy.library.uwa.edu.au/doi/10.1111/1467-8497.00222/pdf
(accessed 15 September 2012).
Ministry of Manpower. 2007. Work Holiday Pass - Before you apply. Available at:
http://www.mom.gov.sg/foreign-manpower/passes-visas/work-holiday-programme/before-you-
apply/Pages/default.aspx (accessed 10 September 2012).
Ministry of Manpower (2011). Foreign Workforce Numbers as at Dec 2011.
http://www.mom.gov.sg/statistics-
publications/others/statistics/Pages/ForeignWorkforceNumbers.aspx (accessed 10 September
2012).
Ministry of Manpower (2012). Further Moderating Demand for Foreign Manpower. Press release
17 February 2012. Available at:
35 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
http://www.mom.gov.sg/newsroom/Pages/PressReleasesDetail.aspx?listid=409 . (accessed 14
September 2012).
Ramesh, S. (2011) 'MM Lee weighs in on Singapore's record-low fertility rate.' Channel NewsAsia,
18 January 2011. Available at:
http://www.channelnewsasia.com/stories/singaporelocalnews/view/1105496/1/.html (accessed
15 September 2012).
Rajan, R.S. (2004) 'Measures to Attract FDI: Investment Promotion, Incentives and Policy
Intervention', Economic and Political Weekly, 3 January 2004. Available at:
http://www.spp.nus.edu.sg/ips/docs/pub/pa_kishen_Measures%20to%20Attract%20FDI.pdf
(accessed 15 September 2012).
Powell, W. and Snellman, K. (2004) 'The Knowledge Economy', Annu. Rev. Sociol 2004 (30) pp.199-
220. Available at http://www.stanford.edu/group/song/papers/powell_snellman.pdf/ (accessed 15
September 2012).
Tripartite Alliance for Fair Employment Practices (TAEFP) (2012) Tripartite Guidelines on Fair
Employment Practices. http://www.fairemployment.sg/assets/files/Publications/Publication%20-
%20Tripartite%20Guidelines%20on%20FEP%20English%20(as%20of%20290612).pdf (accessed 15
September 2012).
36 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
Kuah, K. (1990) 'Confucian Ideology and Social Engineering in Singapore', Journal of Contemporary
Asia, 20:3, pp. 371-383. Available at: http://pao.chadwyck.co.uk/PDF/1347773763562.pdf
(accessed 15 September 2012).
Department of Immigration and Citizenship. 'Coming to Australia'
http://www.immi.gov.au/immigration/coming-to-australia/ (accessed 15 September 2012).
Monetary Authority of Singapore (2010) Annual Report 2009/2010, p 20. Available at:
http://www.mas.gov.sg/annual_reports/annual20092010/pdf/MASAnnual
%20Report_2010.pdf (accessed 15 September 2012).
Central Intelligence Agency (2009) The World Factbook, Washington, DC. Available at:
https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/index.html (accessed 15
September 2012).
Choo, D. (2012) 'Employers’ No.1 Reason for Hiring Foreigners is Job Flexibility: JobStreet
Survey', Yahoo News, 4 September 2012. Available at: http://sg.news.yahoo.com/employers
%E2%80%99-no-1-reason-for-hiring-foreigners-is-job-flexibility--survey.html (accessed 15
September 2012).
National Population and Talent Division (2012) 'Our Population, Our Future: Issues Paper',
Government of Singapore, July 2012. Available at:
https://www.nptd.gov.sg/content/NPTD/home/_jcr_content/par_content/download_0/file.res
37 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
/Issues%20Paper%20-%20Our%20Population%20Our%20Future.pdf (accessed 15
September 2012).
Department of Statistics (2012) 'Yearbook of Statistics Singapore 2012', Department of Statistics,
Singapore. Availabile at: http://www.singstat.gov.sg/pubn/reference/yos12/yos2012a.pdf
(accessed 15 September 2012).
National Population and Talent Division (2012) 'Our Population, Our Future: Public
Engagement on Population Challenges', Government of Singapore, July 2012. Available at:
http://www.population.sg/ (accessed 15 September 2012).
Wah, T. M. (2012) 'Singapore's Rising Income Inequality and a Strategy to Address It', 29, 2,
pp. 128-145, EconLit with Full Text, EBSCOhost, viewed 13 September 2012.
Tan, M (2012) 'Foreign Talent Policy Had Effect on Income Gap', The Straits Times, 17
January 2012. Available at:
http://www.spp.nus.edu.sg/ips/docs/media/yr2012/p2012/ST_Foreign%20talent
%20policy%20had%20effect%20on%20income%20gap_170112.pdf (accessed 15
September 2012).
Grosse, S. (2012) “Singapore's Q1 unemployment up slightly, job vacancies fall”, Channel
NewsAsia, 15 June 2012. Available at:
38 Of 39
COMM3001 Case Studies in Communication Siti Aisyah Bagarib 20910329
http://www.channelnewsasia.com/stories/singaporelocalnews/view/1207742/1/.html
(accessed 15 September 2012).
Straits Times (2010) “Singapore PR took part in parade”, Straits Times, 5 june 2010.
Chua Beng Huat and Tan Joo Ean (1995) 'Singapore: New Configuration of a Socially
Stratisfied Culture', Working Paper No. 127, Department of Sociology, National University
of Singapore.
39 Of 39
Recommended