201310 springer colombia valle

!"#$%&'"()*$+,-$

!"#$%&'()$*%&'

./0,&1$.234"567$$80"9)$0&$+/':;23<&($8/22"))$=!

+#$,"&-$).)')"/'0.//"'

1'23*%4"&'1567'

").#8")$9#:;3%<=>#$,.//"'

About Jeff…

?>*@%&'

!"#$%&'()$*%&'

A""&'&",$"B"&'

"#$$!%&'$'()!

*&++,#!#-(&-##.&-(!

/#,.'+0&#-0#!

Why publish in English?

!  =(0"1(3<&(3:$:3(>/3>"$&?$3234"5;2)$

!  @/;:4$3($;(0"1(3<&(3:$1"9/03<&($

!  -"A":&9$;(0"1(3<&(3:$2&::3'&13<&()$

!  BA"1)"3)$1")"312,$&99&10/(;<")$

CD   E3(/)21;90$)01/20/1"$

FD   .')01320)$3(4$<0:")$GD   H31>"<(>$0,"$I&/1(3:$JD   K#"2<A"$L1;<(>'

Today’s Presentation

CD   !&/1(3:$)":"2<&($FD   M&A"1$:"N"1)$GD   +""1$1"A;"L$

1#++&'-!2! 1#++&'-!3!

45-,+0.&67!+7.,07,.#!

Section 1

C%,"&.:"'.#)'

!*.D#:'A/.#'

E.#>-3&$F*'

-*&>3*>&"' IMRaD

"  ?4-*&.3*'"  =#*&%)>39%#'" E"*@%)-$$

"  %"->/*-'"  3#)'"  -$-3>--$%#'

G@"'4":$##$#:

G@"'"#)

G@"'<$))/"

C%,"&.:"'.#)'

!*.D#:'A/.#'

E.#>-3&$F*'

-*&>3*>&"' Introduction

O"("13:$;(01&4/2<&($

89"2;P2$3;5)$?$<-'

M/11"(0$)030"$&?$0,"$P":4$

+1&':"5$;($0,"$P":4$

8"2&(4316$;(01&4/2<&($

M/11"(0$)030"$&?$0,"$P":4$

+1&':"5$;($0,"$P":4$

C%,"&.:"'.#)'

!*.D#:'A/.#'

E.#>-3&$F*'

-*&>3*>&"'

Introduction – flow of information

H>#:' 3.#3"&' $-' *@"' /".)$#:' 3.>-"' %I' 3.#3"&'<%&*./$*J' I%&'<"#' .#)'B%<"#;' K"-F$*"' -<%L$#:' F&","#9%#' .#)' 3"--.9%#' F&%:&.<-' .#)' .),.#3"-' $#' ".&/J'

)"*"39%#M'*@"'NOJ".&'->&,$,./'&.*"'I%&' />#:'3.#3"&' $-'%#/J'6PQ'B$*@'3>&&"#*'*@"&.F$"-;'?/*@%>:@' />#:'3.#3"&' $#3$)"#3"'&.*"-'@.,"'&"3"#*/J')"3/$#")' $#'*@"'

+#$*")'!*.*"-M'<%&"'/>#:'3.#3"&'$-'#%B')$.:#%-")'B@"#'3%#-$)"&")'*%:"*@"&'$#'I%&<"&O'.#)'#","&O-<%L"&-'*@.#'$#'3>&&"#*'-<%L"&-;'G@>-M'","#'$I'.//'%I'*@"'

#.9%#./'.#9O-<%L$#:'3.<F.$:#':%./-'.&"'<"*M'/>#:'3.#3"&'B$//'&"<.$#'.'<.R%&'F>4/$3'@"./*@'F&%4/"<'I%&')"3.)"-;'S"B'B.J-'*%'*&".*'%&'F&","#*'/>#:'3.#3"&'

.&"'*@"&"I%&"'#"")");'

2#"'F%*"#9./' *@"&.F">93' *.&:"*' I%&' />#:' 3.#3"&' $-' *@"'T#*' -$:#./$#:'F.*@B.J;'G@"' 3.#%#$3./'T#*' -$:#./$#:'F.*@B.J' $#'<.<<./-' 3%#-$-*-'%I' .' I.<$/J'%I'

-"3&"*")'/$F$)O<%)$U")'T#*'F&%*"$#'/$:.#)-'*@.*'4$#)'*%'.'I.<$/J'%I'VOF.--'*&.#-<"<4&.#"'W&$88/")'XW8)Y'&"3"F*%&-M'.-'&",$"B");'Z#'4&$"IM'$#'*@"'.4-"#3"'%I'

/$:.#)M':/J3%:"#'-J#*@.-"'L$#.-"O7'X[!\7YM'$#'3%<F/"]'B$*@'.]$#'.#)'.)"#%<.*%>-'F%/JF%-$-'3%/$'X?ACYM'3%#-9*>9,"/J'F@%-F@%&J/.*"-'Ô3.*"#$#M'*@"'F&$<.&J'

T#*'-$:#./$#:'"_"3*%&M'*.&:"9#:'$*'I%&'>4$`>$9#.9%#'.#)'F&%*".-%<./')"-*&>39%#;'H$:.#)'4$#)$#:'"#:.:"-'.'F.*@B.J'$#,%/,$#:'K$-@","//")'XK,/Y'*@.*'$#@$4$*-'

[!\7M'.//%B$#:'Ô3.*"#$#'*%'.33><>/.*"'$#'.'@JF%F@%-F@%&J/.*")'I%&<;'G@$-'-*.4$/$8")'I%&<'%I'Ô3.*"#$#'3.#'*&.#-/%3.*"'*%'*@"'#>3/">-M'B@"&"'$*'.39,.*"-'

*.&:"*' :"#"' *&.#-3&$F9%#'4J' 3%<F/"]$#:'B$*@' G' 3"//' I.3*%&' XGCWY' .#)' /J<F@%$)' "#@.#3"&O4$#)$#:' I.3*%&' XH(WY;' Z#' .))$9%#' *%' L"J'<")$.*%&-' %I' "<4&J%#$3'

)","/%F<"#*M'*@"-"'*.&:"*':"#"-'$#3/>)"'3&$93./':&%B*@O&":>/.*%&-'->3@'.-'!"#'.#)'#"#$%&'();''

?4"&&.#*'T#*'-$:#./$#:')>"'*%'<>*.9%#-' $#'*+#,-.&%&'%&'/01')&$,"-')"&":>/.*")':&%B*@' $#'4%*@'I.<$/$./'.#)'#%#O@"&")$*.&J'3%/%&"3*./'3.#3"&-;'a%B","&M'

#%#O-<.//'3"//'/>#:'3.#3"&-'XS!CHCYM'*@"'<%-*'3%<<%#'*JF"'%I'/>#:'3.#3"&M'&.&"/J'@.&4%&'/01'%&'*+#,-.&%&'<>*.9%#-;'b.*@"&M'.4"&&.#*'T#*'.39,$*J'$#'/>#:'

3.#3"&'$-'/$#L")'*%'$#3&".-")'"]F&"--$%#'%I'>F-*&".<'T#*'-$:#./$#:'"_"3*%&-'->3@'.-'K,/'%&')"3&".-")'"]F&"--$%#'%I'T#*'.#*.:%#$-*-'->3@'.-'T#*O$#@$4$*%&J'

I.3*%&'6'XT$IO6Y;''

(_"39,"'F@.&<.3%/%:$3./'$#@$4$*%&-'%I'*@"'T#*'F.*@B.J'@.,"'%#/J'&"3"#*/J'4"3%<"'.,.$/.4/";'!3&""#-'I%&'-<.//O<%/"3>/"'.#*.:%#$-*-'%I'*@"'T#*'F.*@B.J'

I%>#)'*B%'"#8J<"-'*%'4"'L"J'<")$.*%&-'%I'T#*'-$:#./$#:;'G@"-"'.&"'F%/JO?KAO&$4%-"'F%/J<"&.-"' XA?bAY'"#8J<"-M' *.#LJ&.-"' XGS\!Y'6'.#)'GS\!1M'B@$3@'

.c.3@'F%/JO?KAO&$4%-"'XA?bY'%#*%'->4-*&.*"'F&%*"$#-;'G@"$&'&%/"-'$#'&":>/.9#:'*"/%<"&.-"'I>#39%#'.#)'<$*%93'-F$#)/"'I%&<.9%#'.&"'L#%B#M'4>*'*@"$&'&%/"'$#'

A?b-J/.9#:' .]$#' -%' .-' *%'<.$#*.$#' *@"' %F9<./' /","/' I%&' 3.#%#$3./'T#*' -$:#./$#:' @.-' %#/J' &"3"#*/J' 4""#' &"3%:#$8");' G@"' 3%<F%>#)-' $)"#9U")' $#' *@"-"'

-3&""#-M'd?0e7eM'ZTbO6'"]%M'.#)'ZTbO6'"#)%M'.3*'4J'-F"3$U3.//J'$#@$4$9#:'*@"'A?bA'.39,$*J'%I'GS\!6'.#)'GS\!1;'ZTbO"]%'$-'.'-*"&"%$-%<"&'%I'ZTbO6'"#)%'

B$*@'f6gOI%/)'/%B"&'(CN5;'A?bA'$#@$4$9%#'$-'.'*&.3*.4/"'F@.&<.3%/%:$3./'*.&:"*'%&'2%23M'.-'.#*.:%#$-*-'%I'%*@"&'A?bA'@%<%/%:-'"]"&*'.#9#"%F/.-93'&"-F%#-"-'

$#'4&".-*'.#)'%,.&$.#'3.#3"&M'.-'&",$"B");''

G@$-' -*>)J'"]F/%&")' *@"'@JF%*@"-$-' *@.*' $#@$4$9%#'%I'GS\!'4J'F@.&<.3%/%:$3./'%&':"#"93'<".#-'B%>/)' $#@$4$*' />#:'3.#3"&':&%B*@$ %&'2%-43'.#)' %&'2%23' $#'3/$#$3.//JO&"/",.#*'*&.#-:"#$3'<%>-"'<%)"/-'%I'/>#:'3.#3"&'*@.*'B"&"'F&",$%>-/J')","/%F")M'.-'&",$"B");'

O"("13:$;(01&4/2<&($

8"2&(4316$;(01&4/2<&($

B'I"2<A")$h>-3@'"*'./;'hEC'C.#3"&;'1561i'67j'166;'

C%,"&.:"'.#)'

!*.D#:'A/.#'

E.#>-3&$F*'

-*&>3*>&"' Methods

Q&L$;0$L3)$4&("$

O"("13:$5"0,&4)$89"2;P2$0"2,(;R/")$S4;)2/))$2&(01&:)T$

-303$3(3:6);)$U/3(<P23<&($5"0,&4)$

803<)<23:$0")0)$

V,30$L3)$/)"4$

8359:")$&1$931<2;93(0)$E30"1;3:)$

Q&L$;0$L3)$3(3:6W"4$

1,+!897':'+!.#;#<5-!+,!:&+#='!#>6#.&8#-75$!

C%,"&.:"'.#)'

!*.D#:'A/.#'

E.#>-3&$F*'

-*&>3*>&"' Results

CD   =(;<3:$&')"1A3<&($FD   M,31320"1;W3<&($GD   .99:;23<&($

K32,$)/')"2<&($2&11")9&(4)$0&$$'-#!P>/1"$

V,30$6&/$?&/(4*$-'7$L,30$;0$5"3()!

X&>;23:$91")"(03<&($

8/')"2<&()$

Y320/3:$4")21;9<&($

?.#+#-7#!+,+!.#+,$75:'+!#-!,-!'.:#-!$@(&0'!

C%,"&.:"'.#)'

!*.D#:'A/.#'

E.#>-3&$F*'

-*&>3*>&"' Discussion

8/55316$&?$P(4;(>)$

%":"A3(2"$&?$P(4;(>)$

=59:;23<&()$?&1$$0,"$P":4$

C%,"&.:"'.#)'

!*.D#:'A/.#'

E.#>-3&$F*'

-*&>3*>&"'

' ' ' '?--"--<"#*'%I'$)"#9*J')","/%F<"#*'./&".)J'$#'.)%/"-3"#3"'$-'$<F%&*.#*'*%'-*>)J')","/%F<"#*./'F.*@-'$#':"#"&./'.#)'*%'"#.4/"',./$)'3%#3/>-$%#-'

.4%>*'-F"3$U3'F.*@%/%:$3./'&$-L-k'G@"'!B$--O["&<.#O?<"&$3.#'`>"-9%##.$&"'/5(/'F&%,$)"-'.'&"/$.4/"'.#)',./$)'.--"--<"#*'%I'*@"'3%<F/"]'3%#-*&>3*'

lF.*@%/%:JO&"/.*")'$)"#9*J'$#*":&.9%#',-;'$)"#9*J')$_>-$%#m'$#'.)%/"-3"#*-'4J'$#*":&.9#:')$_"&"#*'*@"%&"93./'.FF&%.3@"-'.#)'.'&".-%#.4/"'-*&>3*>&"'

%I'L#%B#'->43%#-*&>3*-;'0./$)'.--"--<"#*'*%%/-'<>-*'./-%'<""*'*@"'&"`>$&"<"#*-'%I'$#*"&#.9%#./'>-.4$/$*J'$#'3&%--O3>/*>&./'-*>)$"-'X";:;'.-')"-3&$4")'4J'

*@"' Z#*"&#.9%#./'G"-*'C%<<$--$%#YM' *%'<%)"/')$_"&"#*'F@"#%*JF"-' $#')$_"&"#*' 3>/*>&"-'.#)' *%'"#.4/"',./$)' 3%<F.&$-%#-'%I' $)"#9*J')","/%F<"#*' $#'

)$_"&"#*'-%3$"9"-'4J'F&%,$)$#:'*&>"'"`>$,./"#3"'$#'3%#*"#*'%I'*@"'.--"--<"#*'*%%/;'

' ' ' ' ' G@"'!F.#$-@' 3>/*>&"O.).F*")' *&.#-/.9%#'%I'/5(/' -@%B")':%%)'F-J3@%<"*&$3'F&%F"&9"-' $#' *@"'E"]$3.#' -.<F/"M'B$*@' -$<$/.&'F.c"&#-' $#' &"->/*-'

3%<F.&")'*%'*@"'%&$:$#./',"&-$%#;'T"'3%#3/>)"'*@.*'.//'3%#-*&>3*-'.#)'->43%#-*&>3*-'3%#*.$#")'$#'*@"'?ZK?'<%)"/'*%'3%#-9*>*"'l$)"#9*J')","/%F<"#*m'

@.)'4""#'->33"--I>//J'*&.#-F%-")'$#*%'*@"'l!F.#$-@O-F".L$#:'3>/*>&"m'B$*@':%%)'3%#*"#*'"`>$,./"#3";''

' ' ' ' 'C%<F.&")'*%'*@"'["&<.#'$*"<-'%I'/5(/M'*@"'!F.#$-@'$*"<-'-""<")'*%'4"'l".-$"&'*%'.#-B"&'$#'.'-J<F*%<.93'B.JmM'$;";'*%'-.J'lJ"-m'3%)")'*%B.&)-'

$)"#9*J')$_>-$%#'$#'*@"'E"]$3.#'-3@%%/'-.<F/";'T@$/"'$#'*@"'["&<.#'-.<F/"M'*@"'<".#'F"&3"#*.:"'%I'-J<F*%<.93'.#-B"&-'XF$Y'B.-'75Q'.#)'15'%I'*@"'

Nn'$*"<-'-@%B")'.'F"&3"#*.:"'4"/%B'65QM'$#'*@"'E"]$3.#'-.<F/"'*@"'<".#'F$'B.-'g5Q'.#)'%#/J'7'$*"<-'-@%B")'.#'"]*&"<"',./>"'I%&'l)$D3>/*J'*%'4"'

.#-B"&")'B$*@'J"-m'B$*@'.'F$'4"/%B'65Q;'G@$-'<".#-'*@.*'*@"'$*"<-'B"&"'$#':"#"&./'<%&"')$D3>/*'*%'.#-B"&'B$*@'lJ"-m'$#'*@"'["&<.#',"&-$%#'*@.#'$#'

*@"'E"]$3.#',"&-$%#'%I'/5(/;'G@>-M'-3%&"')$_"&"#3"-'4"*B""#'E"]$3.#'.#)'["&<.#'.)%/"-3"#*-'3.##%*'4"' $#*"&F&"*")')$&"3*/J'.-')$_"&"#*' /","/-'%I'

$)"#9*J')$_>-$%#'4"3.>-"'-3%&"'"`>$,./"#3"'3.##%*'4"'.--><");'G@"&"I%&"M'F%F>/.9%#'#%&<-M'";:;'GO,./>"-'"]*&.3*")'I&%<'&"F&"-"#*.9,"'F%F>/.9%#-M'

@.,"'*%'4"'>-")'I%&',./$)'3%<F.&$-%#-'%I'-.<F/"-'3%#3"&#$#:'*@"$&'l/","/-'%I'$)"#9*J')","/%F<"#*m;''

' ' ' ' '?//'!F.#$-@'?ZK?'$*"<-'<.*3@")'*@"'3&$*"&$%#'I%&'$*"<'4$.-'.#)'F&%,")'*%'4"'l.:"'.#)':"#)"&'I.$&m'$#'*@"'E"]$3.#'-*>)J;'G@$-'.:&""-'B"//'B$*@'*@"'

&"->/*-' $#' *@"'["&<.#' -*>)J;' G@"' 3/.--$3./' "].<F/"' I%&' "]F/.$#$#:' l$*"<' I.$&#"--m' $-' *@"' l-%33"&' $*"<mj' $*'B%>/)'4"'>#I.$&' *%' R>):"' *@"' I&"`>"#3J'%I'

:"#"&./'F@J-$3./'.39,$*J'4J'.-L$#:'la%B'%o"#')%'J%>'F/.J'-%33"&m'4"3.>-"':$&/-'>->.//J')%'#%*'/$L"'*@$-':.<"'.-'<>3@'.-'4%J-')%;'[$&/-'B%>/)'F&%4.4/J'

-.J'l#","&m'<%&"'%o"#M'.#)'*@"&"I%&"'B%>/)'4"' R>):")'I./-"/J'.-'lF@J-$3.//J' $#.39,"m' $#'3%#*&.-*' *%' *@"'4%J-;'?-'.//'?ZK?' $*"<-'3.#'4"'&":.&)")'.-'

:"#)"&'.#)'.:"'I.$&M')$_"&"#3"-'%#'*@"'-3%&"'/","/'4"*B""#':"#)"&'.#)'.:"':&%>F-'3.#'4"'$#*"&F&"*")'.-'*&>"')","/%F<"#*./')$_"&"#3"-;''

'''''?'/$<$*.9%#'%I'*@"'-*>)J'$-'*@"'/.3L'%I'F-J3@$.*&$3')$-%&)"&'.--"--<"#*'$#'*@"'-3@%%/'-.<F/";'h.-")'%#'"F$)"<$%/%:$3./'-*>)$"-M'B"'.--><")'*@.*'>F'*%'

6NO15Q'%I'*@$-'&"F&"-"#*.9,"'-.<F/"'%I'.)%/"-3"#*-'<.J'"]@$4$*'<$#%&'*%'<.R%&'-$:#-'%I'<"#*./'F&%4/"<-;'a%B","&M'B$*@%>*'"#&$3@<"#*'B$*@'.'3/$#$3./'

->4-.<F/"' )$-F/.J$#:' "]*&"<"&' /","/-' %I' $)"#9*J' )$_>-$%#M' *@"' @"*"&%:"#"$*J' %I' *@"' -.<F/"' I%&' ",./>.9#:' *@"' 4.-$3' F-J3@%<"*&$3' F&%F"&9"-' %I' *@"'

!F.#$-@'/5(/' $-'#%*'%F9<./;'!$<$/.&/JM'.'*&>"'3/$#$3./'-.<F/"'%I'F.9"#*-'B$*@')"U#")')$.:#%-"-'B%>/)'4"'<%&"'$#I%&<.9,"'I%&'3%<F.&$#:'*@"$&'?ZK?'

-3%&"-'B$*@'*@%-"'%I'*@"'-3@%%/'-.<F/"'$#'%&)"&'*%'",./>.*"'3&$*"&$%#',./$)$*J;'G%'"]*&.3*'F%F>/.9%#'#%&<-'I%&'E"]$3%M'.'&"F&"-"#*.9,"'-.<F/"'B$*@'.'

@$:@"&'F.&93$F.9%#'&.*"'$-'#"")")'B$*@'.)"`>.*"'-.<F/"'-$8"'$#'*@"')$_"&"#*'*.&:"*")':&%>F-'I%&':"#)"&'.#)'.:";''

' ' ' ' 'G@"'!F.#$-@',"&-$%#'%I'/5(/'-@%B")':%%)'F-J3@%<"*&$3'F&%F"&9"-'$#'E"]$3%'.#)'3.#'4"'>-")'*%'.--"--'*@"'3%#-*&>3*'lF.*@%/%:JO&"/.*")'$)"#9*J'

$#*":&.9%#',-;')$_>-$%#m'B$*@'&"/$.4$/$*JM',./$)$*JM'.#)'3%#*"#*'"`>$,./"#3"'$#'3%<F.&$-%#'B$*@'*@"'%&$:$#./'?ZK?'`>"-9%##.$&";'G@$-'U#)$#:'->FF%&*-'*@"'

3&%--O3>/*>&./':"#"&./$8.4$/$*J'%I'*@"'>#)"&/J$#:'3%#3"F*'.#)'3%#U&<-'*@"'$<F%&*.#3"'%I'3>/*>&"O-F"3$U3'*"-*'.).F9%#'$#'.))$9%#'*%'/$*"&./'*&.#-/.9%#'%I'

*@"'`>"-9%##.$&";'S","&*@"/"--M'-%<"'$*"<-'-@%>/)'4"'$<F&%,");'G@"&"I%&"M'*@"'*"-*',"&-$%#'%I'l/5(/'!F.#$-@'p'E"]$3%m'-@%>/)'4"'I>&*@"&'.).F*")'.#)'

-@%>/)'4"'*"-*")'$#'.'<%&"'@"*"&%:"#"%>-'F%F>/.9%#;''

\.--$#'"*'./;'C@$/)'?)%/"-3'A-J3@$.*&J'E"#*'a"./*@'1567i'Vj1N;'

Discussion – flow of information

h.3L:&%>#)'

M&(2:/);&($

+1&':"5$

b"/",.#3"'

+1"A;&/)$)0/4;")$

X;5;03<&()$

Z<F/$3.9%#-' =59:;23<&()$M&(2:/);&($

Y/0/1"$4;1"2<&()$

C%,"&.:"'.#)'

!*.D#:'A/.#'

E.#>-3&$F*'

-*&>3*>&"' Linking your ideas

O"("13:$'32Z>1&/(4$

B'I"2<A")$

E"0,&4&:&>6$

%")/:0)$3(4$P>/1")$

8/55316$&?$P(4;(>)$

=59:;23<&()$?&1$0,"$P":4$

%":"A3(2"$&?$P(4;(>)$

[(&L:"4>"$>39)$

A-$50#!$@(&058#-7#!+,+!&:#5+!#-!+,!&-B#+C(50&@-!

M/11"(0$)030"$&?$0,"$P":4$=(01&4/2<&($

E"0,&4)$

%")/:0)$

-;)2/));&($

D%+7.507+!

Section 2

?4-*&.3*-' Important points

Y;1)0$;591"));&($&?$6&/1$939"1$

=59&103(2"$&?$6&/1$1")/:0)$

\3:;4;06$&?$6&/1$2&(2:/);&()$

%":"A3(2"$&?$$6&/1$3;5)$

!/4>"$6&/1$L1;<(>$)06:"$

+1&'3':6$&(:6$9310$0,30$L;::$'"$1"34$

C%,"&.:"'.#)'

!*.D#:'A/.#'

E.#>-3&$F*'

-*&>3*>&"' Sections of an abstract

.;5)$

@32Z>1&/(4$

E"0,&4)$

%")/:0)$

M&(2:/);&($

V,6$0,"$)0/46$L3)$4&("$SF]^T$

_&/1$,69&0,");)$SC]^T$

H"2,(;R/")$SC]^T$

E&)0$;59&103(0$P(4;(>)$SJ]^T$

M&(2:/);&(`;59:;23<&()$SF]^T$

"'-0&+#!+,885.)!'E!)',.!.#+#5.0F!

?4-*&.3*-' Unstructured abstract

2>&' >#)"&-*.#)$#:' %I' *@"'<"3@.#$-<-' 4J'B@$3@' )>3*-' .#)' /%4>/"-' )","/%F' $-' )"&$,")' I&%<'

<%)"/' %&:.#$-<-' .#)' *@&""O)$<"#-$%#./' X7KY' 3"//' 3>/*>&"' <%)"/-' B@"&"$#' <.<<./$.#'

"F$*@"/$./' 3"//-' >#)"&:%'<%&F@%:"#"-$-' *%' I%&<'<>/93"//>/.&' -F@"&"-'B$*@' .' @%//%B' 3"#*&./'

/><"#;' a%B","&M' *@"'<"3@.#%F@J-$3./' F&%F"&9"-' .--%3$.*")'B$*@' "F$*@"/$./'<%&F@%:"#"-$-'

.&"'F%%&/J'>#)"&-*%%);'T"'F"&I%&<")'<>/9)$<"#-$%#./'/$,"O3"//'$<.:$#:'.#./J-$-'*%'*&.3L'*@"'

<%&F@%:"#"93' F&%3"--' -*.&9#:' I&%<' .' -$#:/"' 3"//' *%' *@"' )","/%F<"#*' %I' .' <>/93"//>/.&M'

-F@"&$3./' -*&>3*>&"' 3%<F%-")' %I' F%/.&$8")' "F$*@"/$./' 3"//-' ->&&%>#)$#:' .' @%//%B' /><"#;'T"'

&"F%&*' *@.*' $#'.))$9%#' *%'.39,"/J'<.$#*.$#$#:'.F$3%4.-./'F%/.&$*JM' *@"'-*&>3*>&"-'>#)"&B"#*'

&%*.9%#./'<%9%#-'.*'&.*"-'%I'6Np15'q<=@'.#)'*@"'-*&>3*>&"-'&%*.*")'7P5r'","&J'g'@')>&$#:'

*@"'".&/J'[email protected]"'%I'<%&F@%:"#"-$-;'b%*.9%#./'<%9%#'B.-' $#)"F"#)"#*'%I'*@"'3"//'3J3/"M'4>*'

B.-'4/%3L")'4J' /%--' %I' *@"' "F$*@"/$./' F%/.&$*J' F&%*"$#-' !3&$44/"' %&' A.&)7M' %&' 4J' $#@$4$9%#'%I'

)J#"$#O4.-")'<$3&%*>4>/"'<%*%&-;' Z#*"&"-9#:/JM'#%#"'%I'*@"'-*&>3*>&"-')"&$,")'I&%<'@><.#'

3.#3"&' >#)"&B"#*' &%*.9%#./' <%9%#;' T"' I%>#)' .' )$&"3*' &"/.9%#-@$F' 4"*B""#' &%*.9%#./'

<%9%#'.#)'.--"<4/J'%I'"#)%:"#%>-'4.-"<"#*'<"<4&.#"'<.*&$]'.&%>#)'*@"'7K'-*&>3*>&"-M'

.#)'*@.*'-*&>3*>&"-'*@.*'I.$/")'*%'&%*.*"'B"&"')"I"39,"'$#'B".,$#:'"]%:"#%>-'/.<$#$#'<.*&$];'

K$--%/>9%#' %I' 4.-"<"#*' <"<4&.#"' .&%>#)' <.*>&"M' #%#&%*.9#:' .3$#$' &"-*%&")' &%*.9%#./'

<%,"<"#*' .#)' *@"' .4$/$*J' *%' .--"<4/"' "]%:"#%>-' /.<$#$#;' G@>-M' 3%%&)$#.*")' &%*.9%#./'

<%,"<"#*' $-'.'>#$`>"'<"3@.#%F@J-$3./'F&%3"--'%4-"&,")')>&$#:'#%&<./'7K'<%&F@%:"#"-$-'

*@.*'&":>/.*"-'/.<$#$#'<.*&$]'.--"<4/J'.#)'$-'/%-*'$#'3.#3"&O)"&$,")'"F$*@"/$./'3"//-;'

T.#:'"*'./;'AS?!;'1567i'665j'6P7 6Pn;'

?4-*&.3*-' Unstructured abstract

M&(2:/);&($G@>-M'3%%&)$#.*")'&%*.9%#./'<%,"<"#*' $-'.'>#$`>"'<"3@.#%F@J-$3./'F&%3"--'%4-"&,")')>&$#:'#%&<./'

7K'<%&F@%:"#"-$-'*@.*'&":>/.*"-'/.<$#$#'<.*&$]'.--"<4/J'.#)'$-'/%-*'$#'3.#3"&O)"&$,")'"F$*@"/$./'3"//-;'

%")/:0)$

T"' &"F%&*' *@.*' $#' .))$9%#' *%' .39,"/J' <.$#*.$#$#:' .F$3%4.-./' F%/.&$*JM' *@"' -*&>3*>&"-' >#)"&B"#*'

&%*.9%#./'<%9%#-'.*'&.*"-'%I'6Np15'q<=@'.#)'*@"'-*&>3*>&"-'&%*.*")'7P5r'","&J'g'@')>&$#:'*@"'".&/J'

[email protected]"'%I'<%&F@%:"#"-$-;'b%*.9%#./'<%9%#'B.-'$#)"F"#)"#*'%I'*@"'3"//'3J3/"M'4>*'B.-'4/%3L")'4J'/%--'

%I' *@"' "F$*@"/$./' F%/.&$*J' F&%*"$#-' !3&$44/"' %&' A.&)7M' %&' 4J' $#@$4$9%#' %I' )J#"$#O4.-")' <$3&%*>4>/"'

<%*%&-;'Z#*"&"-9#:/JM'#%#"'%I'*@"'-*&>3*>&"-')"&$,")'I&%<'@><.#'3.#3"&'>#)"&B"#*'&%*.9%#./'<%9%#;'

T"' I%>#)' .' )$&"3*' &"/.9%#-@$F' 4"*B""#' &%*.9%#./' <%9%#' .#)' .--"<4/J' %I' "#)%:"#%>-' 4.-"<"#*'

<"<4&.#"'<.*&$]'.&%>#)'*@"'7K'-*&>3*>&"-M'.#)'*@.*'-*&>3*>&"-'*@.*'I.$/")'*%'&%*.*"'B"&"')"I"39,"'$#'

B".,$#:' "]%:"#%>-' /.<$#$#' <.*&$];' K$--%/>9%#' %I' 4.-"<"#*' <"<4&.#"' .&%>#)'<.*>&"M' #%#&%*.9#:'

.3$#$'&"-*%&")'&%*.9%#./'<%,"<"#*'.#)'*@"'.4$/$*J'*%'.--"<4/"'"]%:"#%>-'/.<$#$#;'

E"0,&4)$T"'F"&I%&<")'<>/9)$<"#-$%#./' /$,"O3"//' $<.:$#:'.#./J-$-'*%'*&.3L'*@"'<%&F@%:"#"93'F&%3"--'-*.&9#:'

I&%<' .' -$#:/"' 3"//' *%' *@"' )","/%F<"#*' %I' .' <>/93"//>/.&M' -F@"&$3./' -*&>3*>&"' 3%<F%-")' %I' F%/.&$8")'

"F$*@"/$./'3"//-'->&&%>#)$#:'.'@%//%B'/><"#;''

@32Z>1&/(4$2>&' >#)"&-*.#)$#:' %I' *@"' <"3@.#$-<-' 4J' B@$3@' )>3*-' .#)' /%4>/"-' )","/%F' $-' )"&$,")' I&%<' <%)"/'

%&:.#$-<-'.#)'*@&""O)$<"#-$%#./'X7KY'3"//'3>/*>&"'<%)"/-'B@"&"$#'<.<<./$.#'"F$*@"/$./'3"//-'>#)"&:%'

<%&F@%:"#"-$-' *%' I%&<' <>/93"//>/.&' -F@"&"-' B$*@' .' @%//%B' 3"#*&./' /><"#;' a%B","&M' *@"'

<"3@.#%F@J-$3./'F&%F"&9"-'.--%3$.*")'B$*@'"F$*@"/$./'<%&F@%:"#"-$-'.&"'F%%&/J'>#)"&-*%%);''

T.#:'"*'./;'AS?!;'1567i'665j'6P7 6Pn;'

K)21;'3$)/$1")"a3$$"($)"22;&(")$

?4-*&.3*-' Writing your abstract

T"' &"F%&*' *@.*' $#' .))$9%#' *%' .39,"/J' <.$#*.$#$#:' .F$3%4.-./' F%/.&$*JM' *@"' -*&>3*>&"-'

>#)"&B"#*'&%*.9%#./'<%9%#-'.*'&.*"-'%I'6Np15'q<=@'.#)'*@"'-*&>3*>&"-'&%*.*")'7P5r'

","&J'g'@')>&$#:'*@"'".&/J'[email protected]"'%I'<%&F@%:"#"-$-;'b%*.9%#./'<%9%#'B.-'$#)"F"#)"#*'

%I' *@"'3"//'3J3/"M'4>*'B.-'4/%3L")'4J' /%--'%I' *@"'"F$*@"/$./'F%/.&$*J'F&%*"$#-'!3&$44/"'%&'

A.&)7M'%&'4J' $#@$4$9%#'%I')J#"$#O4.-")'<$3&%*>4>/"'<%*%&-;' Z#*"&"-9#:/JM'#%#"'%I' *@"'

-*&>3*>&"-')"&$,")'I&%<'@><.#'3.#3"&'>#)"&B"#*'&%*.9%#./'<%9%#;'T"'I%>#)'.')$&"3*'

&"/.9%#-@$F' 4"*B""#' &%*.9%#./' <%9%#' .#)' .--"<4/J' %I' "#)%:"#%>-' 4.-"<"#*'

<"<4&.#"'<.*&$]' .&%>#)' *@"' 7K' -*&>3*>&"-M' .#)' *@.*' -*&>3*>&"-' *@.*' I.$/")' *%' &%*.*"'

B"&"' )"I"39,"' $#' B".,$#:' "]%:"#%>-' /.<$#$#' <.*&$];' K$--%/>9%#' %I' 4.-"<"#*'

<"<4&.#"' .&%>#)' <.*>&"M' #%#&%*.9#:' .3$#$' &"-*%&")' &%*.9%#./' <%,"<"#*' .#)' *@"'

.4$/$*J'*%'.--"<4/"'"]%:"#%>-'/.<$#$#;'

V1;0"$0,"$1")/:0)$)"2<&($P1)0$

T.#:'"*'./;'AS?!;'1567i'665j'6P7 6Pn;'

G'+!.#+,$75:'+!+'-!$'+!:#+0,%.&8&#-7'+!8H+!&86'.75-7#+!


2>&'>#)"&-*.#)$#:'%I' *@"'<"3@.#$-<-'4J'B@$3@')>3*-' .#)' /%4>/"-' )","/%F' $-' )"&$,")'

I&%<' <%)"/' %&:.#$-<-' .#)' *@&""O)$<"#-$%#./' X7KY' 3"//' 3>/*>&"' <%)"/-' B@"&"$#'

<.<<./$.#'"F$*@"/$./'3"//-'>#)"&:%'<%&F@%:"#"-$-'*%'I%&<'<>/93"//>/.&'-F@"&"-'B$*@'.'

@%//%B' 3"#*&./' /><"#;' a%B","&M' *@"' <"3@.#%F@J-$3./' F&%F"&9"-' .--%3$.*")' B$*@'

"F$*@"/$./'<%&F@%:"#"-$-'.&"'F%%&/J'>#)"&-*%%);''

V1;0"$0,"$'32Z>1&/(4$)"2<&($)"2&(4$

T.#:'"*'./;'AS?!;'1567i'665j'6P7 6Pn;'

G'+!5-7#0#:#-7#+!#>6$&05-!6'.!I,9!+,!#+7,:&'!:#%#!F50#.+#'

+1&':"5$


T"'F"&I%&<")'<>/9)$<"#-$%#./' /$,"O3"//' $<.:$#:' .#./J-$-' *%' *&.3L' *@"'<%&F@%:"#"93'

F&%3"--' -*.&9#:' I&%<' .' -$#:/"' 3"//' *%' *@"' )","/%F<"#*' %I' .' <>/93"//>/.&M' -F@"&$3./'

-*&>3*>&"'3%<F%-")'%I'F%/.&$8")'"F$*@"/$./'3"//-'->&&%>#)$#:'.'@%//%B'/><"#;''

V1;0"$0,"$5"0,&4)$)"2<&($0,;14$

T.#:'"*'./;'AS?!;'1567i'665j'6P7 6Pn;'

G'+!897':'+!+'-!$5+!790-&05+!(#-#.5$#+!


G@>-M' 3%%&)$#.*")' &%*.9%#./' <%,"<"#*' $-' .' >#$`>"' <"3@.#%F@J-$3./' F&%3"--'

%4-"&,")')>&$#:'#%&<./'7K'<%&F@%:"#"-$-' *@.*' &":>/.*"-' /.<$#$#'<.*&$]' .--"<4/J'

.#)'$-'/%-*'$#'3.#3"&O)"&$,")'"F$*@"/$./'3"//-;'

V1;0"$0,"$2&(2:/);&($)"2<&($:3)0$

Q&L"A"1*$ 0,"$ 5"2,3(&9,6);23:$ 91&9"1<")$ 3))&2;30"4$ L;0,$"9;0,":;3:$5&19,&>"(");)$31"$9&&1:6$/(4"1)0&&4D$

T.#:'"*'./;'AS?!;'1567i'665j'6P7 6Pn;'

G5!0'-0$,+&@-!:#%#!5%'.:5.!#$!6.'%$#85!

M&(2:/);&($

=59:;23<&()$


G@>-M' 3%%&)$#.*")' &%*.9%#./' <%,"<"#*' $-' .' >#$`>"' <"3@.#%F@J-$3./' F&%3"--' %4-"&,")' )>&$#:'

#%&<./' 7K' <%&F@%:"#"-$-' *@.*' &":>/.*"-' /.<$#$#' <.*&$]' .--"<4/J' .#)' $-' /%-*' $#' 3.#3"&O)"&$,")'

"F$*@"/$./'3"//-;'

T"' &"F%&*' *@.*' $#' .))$9%#' *%' .39,"/J' <.$#*.$#$#:' .F$3%4.-./' F%/.&$*JM' *@"' -*&>3*>&"-' >#)"&B"#*'

&%*.9%#./'<%9%#-'.*'&.*"-'%I'6Np15'q<=@'.#)'*@"'-*&>3*>&"-'&%*.*")'7P5r'","&J'g'@')>&$#:'*@"'".&/J'

[email protected]"'%I'<%&F@%:"#"-$-;'b%*.9%#./'<%9%#'B.-' $#)"F"#)"#*'%I'*@"'3"//'3J3/"M'4>*'B.-'4/%3L")'4J'

/%--'%I'*@"'"F$*@"/$./'F%/.&$*J'F&%*"$#-'!3&$44/"'%&'A.&)7M'%&'4J'$#@$4$9%#'%I')J#"$#O4.-")'<$3&%*>4>/"'

<%*%&-;' Z#*"&"-9#:/JM' #%#"' %I' *@"' -*&>3*>&"-' )"&$,")' I&%<' @><.#' 3.#3"&' >#)"&B"#*' &%*.9%#./'

<%9%#;'T"' I%>#)' .' )$&"3*' &"/.9%#-@$F' 4"*B""#' &%*.9%#./' <%9%#' .#)' .--"<4/J' %I' "#)%:"#%>-'

4.-"<"#*'<"<4&.#"'<.*&$]'.&%>#)'*@"'7K'-*&>3*>&"-M'.#)'*@.*'-*&>3*>&"-'*@.*'I.$/")'*%'&%*.*"'B"&"'

)"I"39,"'$#'B".,$#:'"]%:"#%>-'/.<$#$#'<.*&$];'K$--%/>9%#'%I'4.-"<"#*'<"<4&.#"'.&%>#)'<.*>&"M'

#%#&%*.9#:'.3$#$'&"-*%&")'&%*.9%#./'<%,"<"#*'.#)'*@"'.4$/$*J'*%'.--"<4/"'"]%:"#%>-'/.<$#$#;'

T"' F"&I%&<")' <>/9)$<"#-$%#./' /$,"O3"//' $<.:$#:' .#./J-$-' *%' *&.3L' *@"' <%&F@%:"#"93' F&%3"--'

-*.&9#:' I&%<' .' -$#:/"' 3"//' *%' *@"' )","/%F<"#*' %I' .'<>/93"//>/.&M' -F@"&$3./' -*&>3*>&"' 3%<F%-")' %I'

F%/.&$8")'"F$*@"/$./'3"//-'->&&%>#)$#:'.'@%//%B'/><"#;''

2>&'>#)"&-*.#)$#:'%I' *@"'<"3@.#$-<-'4J'B@$3@')>3*-' .#)' /%4>/"-')","/%F' $-')"&$,")' I&%<'<%)"/'

%&:.#$-<-' .#)' *@&""O)$<"#-$%#./' X7KY' 3"//' 3>/*>&"' <%)"/-' B@"&"$#' <.<<./$.#' "F$*@"/$./' 3"//-'

>#)"&:%'<%&F@%:"#"-$-' *%' I%&<'<>/93"//>/.&' -F@"&"-'B$*@' .' @%//%B' 3"#*&./' /><"#;' a%B","&M' *@"'

<"3@.#%F@J-$3./'F&%F"&9"-'.--%3$.*")'B$*@'"F$*@"/$./'<%&F@%:"#"-$-'.&"'F%%&/J'>#)"&-*%%);''

T.#:'"*'./;'AS?!;'1567i'665j'6P7 6Pn;'


2>&'>#)"&-*.#)$#:'%I' *@"'<"3@.#$-<-'4J'B@$3@')>3*-' .#)' /%4>/"-')","/%F' $-')"&$,")' I&%<'<%)"/'

%&:.#$-<-' .#)' *@&""O)$<"#-$%#./' X7KY' 3"//' 3>/*>&"' <%)"/-' B@"&"$#' <.<<./$.#' "F$*@"/$./' 3"//-'

>#)"&:%'<%&F@%:"#"-$-' *%' I%&<'<>/93"//>/.&' -F@"&"-'B$*@' .' @%//%B' 3"#*&./' /><"#;' a%B","&M' *@"'

<"3@.#%F@J-$3./' F&%F"&9"-' .--%3$.*")' B$*@' "F$*@"/$./' <%&F@%:"#"-$-' .&"' F%%&/J' >#)"&-*%%);'T"'

F"&I%&<")'<>/9)$<"#-$%#./' /$,"O3"//' $<.:$#:' .#./J-$-' *%' *&.3L' *@"'<%&F@%:"#"93'F&%3"--' -*.&9#:'

I&%<'.'-$#:/"'3"//' *%' *@"')","/%F<"#*'%I'.'<>/93"//>/.&M' -F@"&$3./' -*&>3*>&"'3%<F%-")'%I'F%/.&$8")'

"F$*@"/$./' 3"//-' ->&&%>#)$#:' .' @%//%B' /><"#;' T"' &"F%&*' *@.*' $#' .))$9%#' *%' .39,"/J' <.$#*.$#$#:'

.F$3%4.-./' F%/.&$*JM' *@"' -*&>3*>&"-' >#)"&B"#*' &%*.9%#./'<%9%#-' .*' &.*"-' %I' 6Np15' q<=@' .#)' *@"'

-*&>3*>&"-'&%*.*")'7P5r'","&J'g'@')>&$#:'*@"'".&/J'[email protected]"'%I'<%&F@%:"#"-$-;'b%*.9%#./'<%9%#'B.-'

$#)"F"#)"#*'%I'*@"'3"//'3J3/"M'4>*'B.-'4/%3L")'4J'/%--'%I'*@"'"F$*@"/$./'F%/.&$*J'F&%*"$#-'!3&$44/"'%&'

A.&)7M' %&' 4J' $#@$4$9%#' %I' )J#"$#O4.-")'<$3&%*>4>/"'<%*%&-;' Z#*"&"-9#:/JM' #%#"' %I' *@"' -*&>3*>&"-'

)"&$,")'I&%<'@><.#'3.#3"&'>#)"&B"#*'&%*.9%#./'<%9%#;'T"'I%>#)'.')$&"3*'&"/.9%#-@$F'4"*B""#'

&%*.9%#./' <%9%#' .#)' .--"<4/J' %I' "#)%:"#%>-' 4.-"<"#*' <"<4&.#"' <.*&$]' .&%>#)' *@"' 7K'

-*&>3*>&"-M' .#)' *@.*' -*&>3*>&"-' *@.*' I.$/")' *%' &%*.*"'B"&"' )"I"39,"' $#'B".,$#:' "]%:"#%>-' /.<$#$#'

<.*&$];' K$--%/>9%#' %I' 4.-"<"#*' <"<4&.#"' .&%>#)' <.*>&"M' #%#&%*.9#:' .3$#$' &"-*%&")' &%*.9%#./'

<%,"<"#*'.#)'*@"'.4$/$*J'*%'.--"<4/"'"]%:"#%>-'/.<$#$#;'G@>-M'3%%&)$#.*")'&%*.9%#./'<%,"<"#*'$-'

.'>#$`>"'<"3@.#%F@J-$3./'F&%3"--'%4-"&,")')>&$#:'#%&<./'7K'<%&F@%:"#"-$-'*@.*'&":>/.*"-'/.<$#$#'

<.*&$]'.--"<4/J'.#)'$-'/%-*'$#'3.#3"&O)"&$,")'"F$*@"/$./'3"//-;'M&(2:/);&()$

%")/:0)$

E"0,&4)$

@32Z>1&/(4$

T.#:'"*'./;'AS?!;'1567i'665j'6P7 6Pn;'

?4-*&.3*-'

=59&103(0$9&;(0)$

8/5531;W"$Z"6$P(4;(>$M&(03;()$Z"6L&14)$X"))$0,3($F]$L&14)$

.A&;4$

U/")<&()$.''1"A;3<&()$

bc"Ld$&1$b(&A":d$

Effective titles

A$!J7,$'!:#%#!+#.!0'-0&+'!)!.#+,8&.!+,!F5$$5K('+!0$5B#!

*5.(#7!7F#!<',.-5$!

Section 3

C>-*%<"&'!"&,$3"'G.&:"*'*@"'R%>&#./'

C@/%&%F@J//'$-'F&"-"#*'$#'<.#J'F/.#*'%&:.#-M'$#3/>)$#:'$<<.*>&"'

I&>$*'B@"&"'$*'$-'>->.//J')":&.)")')>&$#:'&$F"#$#:;'E.*>&"':&""#'

L$B$I&>$*' X/#6&%7%,' 7.$%#%38,Y' .&"' .#' "]3"F9%#M' B$*@' @$:@'3%#3"#*&.9%#-' %I' 3@/%&%F@J//' &"<.$#$#:' $#' *@"' I&>$*' s"-@;' Z#'

:%/)Os"-@")' L$B$I&>$*' X/9' #:%&.&8%8YM' 3@/%&%F@J//' $-' )":&.)")' *%'3%/%>&/"--' 3.*.4%/$*"-' >F%#' I&>$*' &$F"#$#:M' /".,$#:' J"//%B'

3.&%*"#%$)-',$-$4/";'T"'@.,"' $)"#9U")'3.#)$).*"':"#"-' I%&' *@"'

3%#*&%/'%I'3@/%&%F@J//')":&.).9%#k'

A$/L$#:*%#'"*'./;'A/.#*.;'1561i'17Pj'6P6Nt6P1n;'

H,"$2&(01&:$&?$2,:&1&9,6::$:"A":)$;($530/1;(>$Z;L;?1/;0$@1&34$;(0"1")0$

@1&34$;(0"1")0$

Broad focused journal

?$5-75!

C>-*%<"&'!"&,$3"'G.&:"*'*@"'R%>&#./'

G&.)$9%#./'B"")'<.#.:"<"#*M'->3@'.-'9//.:"'.#)'$&&$:.9%#M'@.-'/")'

*%' .#' "#@.#3")' <.$#*"#.#3"' %I' B"*/.#)' F/.#*' -F"3$"-' $#' I.//%B'

F.))J'U"/)-;'b"3"#*'@"&4$3$)"'>-.:"'.#)'$<F&%,"<"#*-' $#' $&&$:.9%#'

.#)' )&.$#.:"' -J-*"<-' @%B","&' @.,"' 3.>-")' @.4$*.*' /%--' %I' *@"-"'

-F"3$"-M'"-F"3$.//J'$#'U"/)-'%#'%F"#'/%B/.#)-k'

K#"20)$&?$<::3>"$3(4$;11;>3<&($&($0,"$&22/11"(2"$3(4$")03':;),5"(0$&?$(3<A"$L"0:3(4$9:3(0$)9"2;")$;($?3::&L$93446$P":4)$

Narrow focused journal

?5::)!5-:!L57#.!M#B#$'68#-7!

G.L.#%-"'"*'./;'A.))J'T.*"&'(#,$&%#;'1567i'66j'6tg;'

N#)O'.:+!E.'8!7F#!D&8+!5-:!10'6#!

AP#0CB#!O.&C-(!

Section 4

(_"39,"'T&$9#:' High readability

_&/1$1"34"1$),&/:4e$

f(4"1)03(4$6&/1$:&>;2$;55"4;30":6$

c&0$,3A"$0&$1"34$):&L:6$

B(:6$,3A"$0&$1"34$&(2"$

(_"39,"'T&$9#:' 1. Short sentences

Q#5:&-(!'-0#R!J^$&?$1"34"1)$23($/(4"1)03(4$3$FghL&14$)"(0"(2"$gi^$&?$1"34"1)$23($/(4"1)03(4$3$CghL&14$)"(0"(2"$

A$##"&'.#)'A$##"&'X6eenY'13!!;&%#,63&'<=%$$8'

f<:;2"$)j:&$/(3$;4"3$9&1$&132;&($CikF]$93:3'13)$

(_"39,"'T&$9#:' Short sentences

ST!O'.:+!

H,"$ :31>")0$ 2&593(6*$ 3$ M&:&5';3($ 2&19&13<&($ ?&/(4"4$ ;($ClCm$&/0);4"$&?$@&>30n$'6$E;>/":$Q"1(n(4"W*$L3)$2&();4"1"4$0&$ '"$ 3$ 5&4":$ ;($ 0,"$ 4"A":&95"(0$ &?$ 5&4"1($ "59:&6""$2&(4;<&()$'6$"2&(&5;)0)D$


ST!O'.:+!

H,"$ :31>")0$ 2&593(6*$ 3$ M&:&5';3($ 2&19&13<&($ ?&/(4"4$ ;($ClCm$&/0);4"$&?$@&>30n$'6$E;>/":$Q"1(n(4"W*$L3)$2&();4"1"4$0&$ '"$ 3$ 5&4":$ ;($ 0,"$ 4"A":&95"(0$ &?$ 5&4"1($ "59:&6""$2&(4;<&()$'6$"2&(&5;)0)D$


K2&(&5;)0)$ 2&();4"1"4$ 0,"$ :31>")0$ 2&593(6$ 0&$'"$ 3$5&4":$ ;($0,"$ 4"A":&95"(0$ &?$ 5&4"1($ "59:&6""$ 2&(4;<&()D$ H,;)$2&593(6$ L3)$ 3$ M&:&5';3($ 2&19&13<&($ ?&/(4"4$ ;($ ClCm$&/0);4"$&?$@&>30n$'6$E;>/":$Q"1(n(4"WD$

2U!O'.:+!

2V!O'.:+!W-#!&:#5!6#.!+#-7#-0#!

(_"39,"'T&$9#:' 2. Active voice

8"(0"(2")$L1;N"($;($0,"$32<A"$A&;2"$31"7$

+&86$#! :&.#07! 0$#5.! #5+)!7'!.#5:!

H,"$5"2,3(;)5)$1">/:3<(>$0/5&1$>1&L0,$L"1"$;(A")<>30"4D$

?5++&B#!

V"$;(A")<>30"4$0,"$5"2,3(;)5)$1">/:3<(>$0/5&1$>1&L0,D$D0CB#!

XC$&0#!$5!B'K!50CB5!65.5!+#.!8H+!:&.#07'+!

(_"39,"'T&$9#:' Active voice is preferred

l+-"'*@"'50CB#!B'&0#!B@"#'$*'$-'/"--'B%&)J'.#)'<%&"'

)$&"3*'*@.#'*@"'F.--$,"m;'X7&)'");M'F:;'g1Y'

l+-"'*@"'50CB#!B'&0#!&.*@"&'*@.#'*@"'F.--$,"',%$3"km;''BBB;.F.-*J/";%&:=/".&#=I.`-="_"39,"O,"&4O>-";.-F]'

l?-'.'<.c"&'%I'-*J/"M'F.--$,"',%$3"'$-'*JF$3.//JM'4>*'#%*'

./B.J-M'$#I"&$%&'*%'50CB#!B'&0#m;'X6N*@'");M'F:;'6VVY'

lZ#':"#"&./M'.>*@%&-'-@%>/)'>-"'*@"'50CB#!B'&0#km;'X65*@'");M'F:;'715Y'

D"1!17)$#!Y,&:#!

D?D!17)$#!!

"F&05('!17)$#!Y,&:#!

D4D!45-,5$!'E!17)$#!

(_"39,"'T&$9#:' 3. Stress position

G'+!$#07'.#+!+#!0#-7.5-!#-!#$!Z-5$!:#!$5!'.50&'-!65.5!&:#-CZ05.!$'!I,#!#+!&86'.75-7#!

CD   _&/$4")"1A"$3$13;)"*$'/0$0,"$'/4>"0$;)$<>,0D$

V,;2,$)"(0"(2"$)/>>")0)$0,30$6&/$$O&$$$>"0$3$13;)"o$

FD   H,"$'/4>"0$;)$<>,0*$'/0$6&/$4")"1A"$3$13;)"D$

@cFj==B&$9#:3"#*"&;>#3;")>=@.#)%>*-=s%B='

(_"39,"'T&$9#:' Stress position

H,"$'/4>"0$;)$<>,0*$'/0$6&/$4")"1A"$3$13;)"D$_&/1$)3:316$

L;::$;(21"3)"$30$0,"$'">;((;(>$&?$("p0$6"31D$

X3$9&);2;j($4"$0"();j($4"'"$;(01&4/2;1$$":$0"53$4"$:3$);>/;"(0"$&132;&$

@cFj==B&$9#:3"#*"&;>#3;")>=@.#)%>*-=s%B='

801"))$9&);<&($ H&9;2$9&);<&($

G5!6'+&0&@-!:#$!7#85!&:#-CZ05!:#!I,9!7.575!$5!'.50&@-!

(_"39,"'T&$9#:' 4. Topic position

*F#! 65C#-7! L"(0$ 0&$ 0,"$ ,&)9;03:$ 0&$ )""$ 3$(5+7.'#-7#.'$'(&+7D$*F#! :'07'.! 0,"($ 9"1?&15"4$ 3$ )"1;")$&?$ :&5(-'+C0! 7#+7+D$ *F#! .#+,$7+! ),&L"4$ 0,"$ 93<"(0$)/#"1"4$ ?1&5$ 3$ %507#.&5$! &-E#0C'-D! D-C%&'C0+! L"1"$91")21;'"4$ 0&$ 01"30$ 0,"$ ;(?"2<&($ '"?&1"$ 0,"$ 93<"(0$4"A":&9"4$3($,$0#.D$$

$)". $)".$)".$)".

G%F$3'/$#L

-"#*"#3"

FDi$<5")$5&1"$2&55&($;($K(>:;),$0,3($;($893(;),$

!$<F-%#'uE;'u'!"3%#)'H.#:'T&$*;'1555i'ej'1e7p75e;'

(_"39,"'T&$9#:'

X/(>$ 23(2"1$ ;)$ 0,"$ :"34;(>$ 23/)"$ &?$ 23(2"1$ 5&103:;06$ ?&1$5"($ 3(4$ L&5"(D$ -")9;0"$ )5&Z;(>$ 91"A"(<&($ 3(4$2"))3<&($91&>135)e$ec"L$L36)$ 0&$ 01"30$&1$91"A"(0$ :/(>$23(2"1$31"$0,"1"?&1"$(""4"4D$

B("$9&0"(<3:$0,"139"/<2$031>"0$?&1$:/(>$23(2"1$;)$0,"$V(0$);>(3:;(>$930,L36D$H,"$23(&(;23:$V(0$);>(3:;(>$930,L36$;($53553:)$2&();)0)$&?$3e$

h>-3@'"*'./;'hEC'C.#3"&;'1561i'67j'166;'

H&9;2$)"(0"(2"$

H&9;2$)"(0"(2"$

801"))$)"(0"(2"$

f<:;2"$:3$9&);2;&($4"$$0"();j($6$0"53$$"($)/$")21;0&$4"$53("13$:j>;23$3:$91")"(031$:3$;(?&1532;j($

Manuscript structure

Thank you!

LLLD"43(W"4;<(>D2&5$

Any questions?

Y&::&L$/)$&($HL;N"1$q!&/1(3:.4A;)&1'

X;Z"$/)$&($Y32"'&&Z$?32"'&&ZD2&5`!&/1(3:.4A;)&1'

-&L(:&34$3(4$?/10,"1$1"34;(>$"43(W"4;<(>D2&5`/(;A3::"$

Thank you!

LLLD"43(W"4;<(>D2&5$

Any questions?

Y&::&L$/)$&($HL;N"1$q!&/1(3:.4A;)&1'

X;Z"$/)$&($Y32"'&&Z$?32"'&&ZD2&5`!&/1(3:.4A;)&1'

-&L(:&34$3(4$?/10,"1$1"34;(>$"43(W"4;<(>D2&5Ì3A"1;3(3$

!"#$%&'"()*$+,-$

!"#$%&'()$*%&'

./0,&1$.234"567$$80"9)$0&$+/':;23<&($8/22"))$==!

+#$,"&-$).)')"/'0.//"'

1'23*%4"&'1567'

").#8")$9#:;3%<=>#$,.//"'

!"#$%&'"()*$+,-$

!"#$%&'()$*%&'

./0,&1$.234"567$$80"9)$0&$+/':;23<&($8/22"))$==!

A%#9U3$.'+#$,"&-$).)'u.,"&$.#.'

g'23*%4"&'1567'

").#8")$9#:;3%<=R.,"&$.#.'

CD   E3(/)21;90$)01/20/1"$

FD   .')01320)$3(4$<0:")$GD   H31>"<(>$0,"$I&/1(3:$JD   K#"2<A"$L1;<(>'

Today’s Presentation

CD   !&/1(3:$)":"2<&($FD   M&A"1$:"N"1)$GD   +""1$1"A;"L$

1#++&'-!2! 1#++&'-!3!

Edanz survey results – Primary difficulty during manuscript preparation

&'v'777'F>4/$-@")'#%#O#.9,"'(#:/$-@'.>*@%&-'

C@%%-$#:'.'

R%>&#./'

(]F&"--$#:'*@%>:@*-'

3/".&/J'$#'(#:/$-@'

+#)"&-*.#)$#:'*@"'

.>*@%&':>$)"/$#"-'

W%&<.w#:'.33%&)$#:'

*%'*@"':>$)"/$#"-'

CCr$

gl$

gG$

mG$

GiDJ^$

FGDg^$

FCDl^$

CrDl^$

X&)$3/0&1")$<"("($4;P2/:034")$9313$":">;1$:3)$1"A;)03)$6$2&591"(4"1$:3)$4;1"201;2")$4"$:3)$$1"A;)03)$

[',.-5$!+#$#0C'-!

Section 1

u%>&#./'-"/"39%#'Tenga en cuenta los diferentes

factores de cada revista

.;5)$s$)2&9"$ %"34"1),;9$

B9"($322"))$ =(4"p;(>$

LF&0F!E507'.!&+!8'+7!&86'.75-7!7'!)',\!

+/':;23<&($?1"R/"(26$

=59320$?320&1$

]5.&#+!%)!Z#$:!

u%>&#./'-"/"39%#' Choosing a target journal

^'-#+758#-7#!#B5$,#!$5!&86'.75-0&5!!:#!+,!&-B#+C(50&@-!

8;>(;P23(2"$ .;5)$3(4$82&9"$=59320$

u%>&#./'-"/"39%#'

c"L$P(4;(>)$

Evaluating significance: Novelty

E"4;/5$0&$,;>,$;59320$

X&L$0&$5"4;/5$;59320$

=(21"5"(03:$34A3(2")$

M&(2"90/3:$34A3(2")$

_`,#!75-!-,#B'+!+'-!7,+!.#+,$75:'+\!

u%>&#./'-"/"39%#' Evaluating significance: Relevance

_`,9!75-!.#$#B5-7#+!+'-!+,+!.#+,$75:'+!!#-!+,!0586'!,!'7.'+!0586'+\!

+&9/:3<&($)9"2;P2o$%")01;20"4$0&$>"&>139,;23:$:&23<&(o$Q&L$2&55&($;)$0,"$4;)"3)"o$

E"4;23:$

%":"A3(0$0&$'/);("))$&1$531Z"<(>o$Q3A"$;59320$&($>&A"1(5"(0$9&:;26o$

+)62,&:&>6$

Q&L$'1&34:6$399:;23':"$;)$0,"$4");>(o$$=)$;0$2&)0h"#"2<A"o$

K(>;(""1;(>$

u%>&#./'-"/"39%#'Evaluating significance:

Importance

.1"3$&?$9&9/:31$399"3:

80"5$2"::)*$<))/"$"(>;(""1;(>*$>:&'3:$L315;(>*$31<P2;3:$;(0"::;>"(2"

=59&103(0$1"3:hL&1:4$399:;23<&()

%;2"$1");)03(0$0&$,;>,$)3:0$2&(4;<&()*$),1;59$1");)03(0$0&$;(?"2<&(

_`,9!75-!&86'.75-7#+!+'-!$5+!56$&050&'-#+!!!#-!#$!8,-:'!.#5$\!

u%>&#./'-"/"39%#' Journal Selector

=()"10$6&/1$91&9&)"4$3')01320$

A$![',.-5$!1#$#07'.!5),:5!5!#$#(&.!!$5!6,%$&050&'-!8H+!5:#0,5:5!

u%>&#./'-"/"39%#' Journal Selector

%"2&55"(4"4$I&/1(3:)$

Y;:0"1$'67$=59320$?320&1$

+/':;),;(>$?1"R/"(26$B9"($322"))$

u%>&#./'-"/"39%#' Journal Selector 8"53(<2$5302,;(>$0"15)$

!&/1(3:)$=Y*$.;5)$s$82&9"*$$3(4$Y1"R/"(26$

8;5;:31$9/':;),"4$31<2:")$

Q3A"$0,"6$9/':;),"4$);5;:31$31<2:")$.#0#-7$)o$Q3A"$6&/$0&7#:$)&5"$&?$0,")"$31<2:")o$

u%>&#./'-"/"39%#' Visit journal websites

u%>&#./'-"/"39%#' For Springer journals

u%>&#./'-"/"39%#'Tips to identify the most

suitable journal

!'

=4"(<?6$0,"$;(0"1")0)$&?$0,"$<',.-5$!#:&7'.!

=4"(<?6$0,"$;(0"1")0)$&?$0,"$

.#5:#.+!

•  K4;0&1;3:)$•  %"A;"L$31<2:")$•  89"2;3:$;))/")$

•  E&)0$A;"L"4$•  E&)0$2;0"4$

a:#-CZ05!$'+!&-7#.#+#+!:#$!#:&7'.!:#!$5!.#B&+75!)!:#!$'+!$#07'.#+!#-!05:5!6,%$&050&'-!

u%>&#./'-"/"39%#' Author guidelines

bcUTT!O'.:+d!

a86'.75-7!6'&-7+!

.1<2:"$)01/20/1"$

V&14$:;5;0)$

%"?"1"(2")$

u%>&#./'-"/"39%#'Author guidelines –

article structure

+1"9313<&($&?$E3(/)21;90)$

@">;()$&($93>"$l$S&?$CgT$

H;0:"$93>"*$3')01320$["6L&14)$0&$$:&&Z$?&1o$

V,30$6&/$),&/:4$'"$:&&Z;(>$?&1$

•  .1<2:"$069"$)9"2;P2)$•  H;0:"$93>"$;(?&153<&($•  .')01320*$>139,;23:$3')01320*$

Z"6L&14)*$3(4$,;>,:;>,0)$•  E3;($0"p0$)"2<&()$•  %"?"1"(2")$•  Y;>/1")$3(4$Y;>/1"$X">"(4)$


word limits

L'.:!$&8&7+!85)!566$)!7'e!

•  H;0:")$•  %/((;(>$<0:")$•  Q;>,:;>,0)$•  .')01320)$•  E3;($0"p0$•  Y;>/1"$:">"(4)$


references

=(h0"p0$2;03<&()$\3(2&/A"1$7$x6y'%&'6'

Q31A3147$XS.<"M'J".&Y'

%"?"1"(2"$:;)0$\3(2&/A"1$7$S><"&$3./'

Q31A3147$?/[email protected]"93./'

"'B#.!$#f#.+!

Section 2

C%,"&.:"'.#)'

!*.D#:'A/.#'C%,"&'/"c"&-'

.')013207$Y;1)0$;591"));&($?&1$1"34"1)$

X3)$23103)$4"$91")"(032;j($)&($:3$91;5"13$;591");j($9313$":$"4;0&1$4"$/(3$1"A;)03$

8;>(;P23(2"$%":"A3(2"$

X"A":$&?$K(>:;),$=(0"1")<(>$0&$0,";1$1"34"1)o$

V,6$6&/1$L&1Z$;)$;59&103(0t$

C%,"&.:"'.#)'

!*.D#:'A/.#'C%,"&'/"c"&-' Building your cover letter

E.&3'H$FF<.#M'EK'

()$*%&O$#OC@$"I'

>4.,8-'1,&#.4'?.8.,4#:',&7'@4.,-!.&-'

7'!"F*"<4"&'1567'

K".&'K&'H$FF<.#M'

A/".-"' U#)' "#3/%-")' %>&' <.#>-3&$F*' "#9*/")' l(,./>.9%#' %I' *@"'

[/.-:%B'F&%:#%-93'-3%&"'$#'F.9"#*-'>#)"&:%$#:'3>&.9,"'&"-"39%#'

I%&'4&".-*'3.#3"&' /$,"&'<"*.-*.-"-Mm'B@$3@'B"'B%>/)' /$L"'*%'->4<$*'

I%&'F>4/$3.9%#'.-'.#'2&$:$#./'?&93/"'$#'>4.,8-'1,&#.4'?.8.,4#:',&7'

@4.,-!.&-;''

u%>&#./'")$*%&z-'#.<"'

E3(/)21;90$<0:"$

+/':;23<&($069"$

a-:&I,#!#$!J7,$'!:#!+,!#+0.&7'!)!C6'!:#!6,%$&050&@-!

C%,"&.:"'.#)'


G@"' [/.-:%B' F&%:#%-93' -3%&"' X[A!Y' $-' %I' ,./>"' I%&' .' ,.&$"*J' %I'

*><%>&-;' !","&./' -*>)$"-' @.,"' $#,"-9:.*")' *@"' F&%:#%-93' ,./>"' %I'

*@"' [A!' $#' F.9"#*-' B$*@' <"*.-*.93' 4&".-*' 3.#3"&M' 4>*' I"B' -*>)$"-'

@.,"' F"&I%&<")' ->3@' .#' $#,"-9:.9%#' I%&' F.9"#*-' >#)"&:%$#:' /$,"&'

&"-"39%#' I%&' /$,"&'<"*.-*.-"-;' W>&*@"&<%&"M' *@"&"' .&"' 3>&&"#*/J' #%'

-*>)$"-'*@.*'@.,"'"].<$#")'*@"'F&%:#%-93',./>"'%I'*@"'<%)$U")'[A!'

X<[A!Y' $#' *@"-"'F.9"#*-;'G@"'F&"-"#*' -*>)J'",./>.*")' *@"'<[A!' $#'

*"&<-' %I' $*-' F&%:#%-93' ,./>"' I%&' F%-*%F"&.9,"' )".*@' $#' F.9"#*-'

>#)"&:%$#:'/$,"&'&"-"39%#'I%&'4&".-*'3.#3"&'/$,"&'<"*.-*.-"-;'

Kp9:;R/"$9&1$R/u$)/$;(A")<>32;j($4"'"1;3$4"$,32"1)"$

!  ",..#-7!-*.*"'%I'*@"'U"/)'!  ?.'%$#8'&"-".&3@"&-'.&"'I.3$#:'

C%,"&.:"'.#)'


G@"' [/.-:%B' F&%:#%-93' -3%&"' X[A!Y' $-' %I' ,./>"' I%&' .' ,.&$"*J' %I'

*><%>&-;' !","&./' -*>)$"-' @.,"' $#,"-9:.*")' *@"' F&%:#%-93' ,./>"' %I'

*@"' [A!' $#' F.9"#*-' B$*@' <"*.-*.93' 4&".-*' 3.#3"&M' 4>*' I"B' -*>)$"-'

@.,"' F"&I%&<")' ->3@' .#' $#,"-9:.9%#' I%&' F.9"#*-' >#)"&:%$#:' /$,"&'

&"-"39%#' I%&' /$,"&'<"*.-*.-"-;' W>&*@"&<%&"M' *@"&"' .&"' 3>&&"#*/J' #%'

-*>)$"-'*@.*'@.,"'"].<$#")'*@"'F&%:#%-93',./>"'%I'*@"'<%)$U")'[A!'

X<[A!Y' $#' *@"-"'F.9"#*-;'G@"'F&"-"#*' -*>)J'",./>.*")' *@"'<[A!' $#'

*"&<-' %I' $*-' F&%:#%-93' ,./>"' I%&' F%-*%F"&.9,"' )".*@' $#' F.9"#*-'

>#)"&:%$#:'/$,"&'&"-"39%#'I%&'4&".-*'3.#3"&'/$,"&'<"*.-*.-"-;'

Kp9:;R/"$9&1$R/u$)/$;(A")<>32;j($4"'"1;3$4"$,32"1)"$

!  ",..#-7!-*.*"'%I'*@"'U"/)'!  ?.'%$#8'&"-".&3@"&-'.&"'I.3$#:'

=(01&4/2<&($

+1&':"5$

B'I"2<A")$

C%,"&.:"'.#)'


%")/53$)/)$2&(2:/);&(")$2:3A"$

!  g.&#;)')"-3&$4"'J%>&'<"*@%)%/%:J'

!  1,885.&K#'J%>&'L"J'U#)$#:-'

?' *%*./' %I' 76n' F.9"#*-' B$*@' 4&".-*' 3.#3"&' /$,"&' <"*.-*.-"-' B@%'

>#)"&B"#*'@"F.*"3*%<J'%,"&'.'6NOJ".&'F"&$%)'B"&"'$#3/>)")'$#'*@$-'

-*>)J;' G@"' <[A!' B.-' 3./3>/.*")' 4.-")' %#' *@"' /","/-' %I' CO&".39,"'

F&%*"$#' .#)' ./4><$#M' .#)' *@"' )$-".-"OI&""' ->&,$,./' .#)' 3.#3"&O

-F"3$U3' ->&,$,./' &.*"-' B"&"' ",./>.*")' $#' &"/.9%#' *%' *@"' <[A!;'

2,"&.//M'*@"'&"->/*-'-@%B")'.'-$:#$U3.#*'.--%3$.9%#'4"*B""#'3.#3"&O

-F"3$U3' ->&,$,./' .#)' *@"'<[A!' .#)' 3.&3$#%"<4&J%#$3' .#9:"#' /","/M'

.#)'.'@$:@"&'<[A!'B.-'.--%3$.*")'B$*@' $#3&".-")'.::&"--$,"#"--'%I'

/$,"&'&"3>&&"#3"'.#)'F%%&"&'->&,$,./'$#'*@"-"'F.9"#*-;'

C%,"&.:"'.#)'


?' *%*./' %I' 76n' F.9"#*-' B$*@' 4&".-*' 3.#3"&' /$,"&' <"*.-*.-"-' B@%'

>#)"&B"#*'@"F.*"3*%<J'%,"&'.'6NOJ".&'F"&$%)'B"&"'$#3/>)")'$#'*@$-'

-*>)J;' G@"' <[A!' B.-' 3./3>/.*")' 4.-")' %#' *@"' /","/-' %I' CO&".39,"'

F&%*"$#' .#)' ./4><$#M' .#)' *@"' )$-".-"OI&""' ->&,$,./' .#)' 3.#3"&O

-F"3$U3' ->&,$,./' &.*"-' B"&"' ",./>.*")' $#' &"/.9%#' *%' *@"' <[A!;'

2,"&.//M'*@"'&"->/*-'-@%B")'.'-$:#$U3.#*'.--%3$.9%#'4"*B""#'3.#3"&O

-F"3$U3' ->&,$,./' .#)' *@"'<[A!' .#)' 3.&3$#%"<4&J%#$3' .#9:"#' /","/M'

.#)'.'@$:@"&'<[A!'B.-'.--%3$.*")'B$*@' $#3&".-")'.::&"--$,"#"--'%I'

/$,"&'&"3>&&"#3"'.#)'F%%&"&'->&,$,./'$#'*@"-"'F.9"#*-;'

!  g.&#;)')"-3&$4"'J%>&'<"*@%)%/%:J'

!  1,885.&K#'J%>&'L"J'U#)$#:-'

E"0,&4)$

["6$1")/:0)$

%")/53$)/)$2&(2:/);&(")$2:3A"$

C%,"&.:"'.#)'


G@$-'-*>)J'$-'*@"'U&-*'*%')"<%#-*&.*"'*@.*'*@"'F&"%F"&.9,"'<[A!M'.'

-$<F/"' 3/$#$3./' *%%/M' $-' .' >-"I>/' F&%:#%-93' I.3*%&' I%&' F%-*%F"&.9,"'

->&,$,./' $#'4&".-*'3.#3"&'F.9"#*-'>#)"&:%$#:'3>&.9,"'&"-"39%#'I%&'

/$,"&' <"*.-*.-"-;' G@$-' $#I%&<.9%#' $-' $<<")$.*"/J' 3/$#$3.//J'

.FF/$3.4/"' I%&' ->&:"%#-' .#)' <")$3./' %#3%/%:$-*-' *&".9#:' ->3@'

F.9"#*-;'?-'.'F&"<$"&'R%>&#./'3%,"&$#:'4&".-*'3.#3"&'*&".*<"#*M'B"'

4"/$","' *@.*'>4.,8-' 1,&#.4' ?.8.,4#:' ,&7' @4.,-!.&-' $-' *@"' F"&I"3*'F/.{%&<'I&%<'B@$3@'*%'-@.&"'%>&'&"->/*-'B$*@'.//' *@%-"'3%#3"&#")'

B$*@'4&".-*'3.#3"&;'

Kp9:;R/"$9&1$R/u$)/$")21;0&$)"1v3$;(0"1")3(0"$9313$:&)$:"20&1")$4"$/(3$1"A;)03$

C%,"&.:"'.#)'


G@$-'-*>)J'$-'*@"'U&-*'*%')"<%#-*&.*"'*@.*'*@"'F&"%F"&.9,"'<[A!M'.'

-$<F/"' 3/$#$3./' *%%/M' $-' .' >-"I>/' F&%:#%-93' I.3*%&' I%&' F%-*%F"&.9,"'

->&,$,./' $#'4&".-*'3.#3"&'F.9"#*-'>#)"&:%$#:'3>&.9,"'&"-"39%#'I%&'

/$,"&' <"*.-*.-"-;' G@$-' $#I%&<.9%#' $-' $<<")$.*"/J' 3/$#$3.//J'

.FF/$3.4/"' I%&' ->&:"%#-' .#)' <")$3./' %#3%/%:$-*-' *&".9#:' ->3@'

F.9"#*-;'?-'.'F&"<$"&'R%>&#./'3%,"&$#:'4&".-*'3.#3"&'*&".*<"#*M'B"'

4"/$","' *@.*'>4.,8-' 1,&#.4' ?.8.,4#:' ,&7' @4.,-!.&-' $-' *@"' F"&I"3*'F/.{%&<'I&%<'B@$3@'*%'-@.&"'%>&'&"->/*-'B$*@'.//' *@%-"'3%#3"&#")'

B$*@'4&".-*'3.#3"&;'

Kp9:;R/"$9&1$R/u$)/$")21;0&$)"1v3$;(0"1")3(0"$9313$:&)$:"20&1")$4"$/(3$1"A;)03$

M&(2:/);&($

%":"A3(2"$

C%,"&.:"'.#)'


G@$-'-*>)J'$-'*@"'U&-*'*%')"<%#-*&.*"'*@.*'*@"'F&"%F"&.9,"'<[A!M'.'

-$<F/"' 3/$#$3./' *%%/M' $-' .' >-"I>/' F&%:#%-93' I.3*%&' I%&' F%-*%F"&.9,"'

->&,$,./' $#'4&".-*'3.#3"&'F.9"#*-'>#)"&:%$#:'3>&.9,"'&"-"39%#'I%&'

/$,"&' <"*.-*.-"-;' G@$-' $#I%&<.9%#' $-' $<<")$.*"/J' 3/$#$3.//J'

.FF/$3.4/"' I%&' ->&:"%#-' .#)' <")$3./' %#3%/%:$-*-' *&".9#:' ->3@'

F.9"#*-;'?-'.'F&"<$"&'R%>&#./'3%,"&$#:'4&".-*'3.#3"&'*&".*<"#*M'B"'

4"/$","' *@.*'>4.,8-' 1,&#.4' ?.8.,4#:' ,&7' @4.,-!.&-' $-' *@"' F"&I"3*'F/.{%&<'I&%<'B@$3@'*%'-@.&"'%>&'&"->/*-'B$*@'.//' *@%-"'3%#3"&#")'

B$*@'4&".-*'3.#3"&;'

f)"$93:3'13)$2:3A"$3$931<1$4"$:&)$&'I"<A&)$6$$":$3:23(2"$"($)/$23103$4"$91")"(032;j($

N#)O'.:+!E.'8!7F#!D&8+!5-:!10'6#!

C%,"&.:"'.#)'


T"'3%#U&<'*@.*'*@$-'<.#>-3&$F*'@.-'#%*'4""#'F>4/$-@")'"/-"B@"&"'

.#)'$-'#%*'>#)"&'3%#-$)"&.9%#'4J'.#%*@"&'R%>&#./;'?//'.>*@%&-'@.,"'

.FF&%,")' *@"' <.#>-3&$F*M' $#3/>)$#:' .>*@%&-@$F' .#)' %&)"&' %I'

.>*@%&-@$FM' .#)' .:&""'B$*@' ->4<$--$%#' *%'>4.,8-' 1,&#.4' ?.8.,4#:',&7' @4.,-!.&-;' G@$-' -*>)J'B.-' I>#)")' 4J' *@"'E$#$-*&J' %I' a"./*@M'

H.4%>&' .#)'T"/I.&";' G@"' .>*@%&-' @.,"' #%' 3%#s$3*-' %I' $#*"&"-*' *%'

)"3/.&";'

Kp9&(>3$1")9&()3';:;434$:">3:$)&'1"$u<23$4"$:3$;(A")<>32;j($6$:3$9/':;232;j($

!  -;)2:3;5"1)$1":30"4$0&$6,%$&05C'-!#7F&0+!!  8&/12")$&?$h,-:&-(!!  "'-;&07+!'E!&-7#.#+7!

C%,"&.:"'.#)'


T"'3%#U&<'*@.*'*@$-'<.#>-3&$F*'@.-'#%*'4""#'F>4/$-@")'"/-"B@"&"'

.#)'$-'#%*'>#)"&'3%#-$)"&.9%#'4J'.#%*@"&'R%>&#./;'?//'.>*@%&-'@.,"'

.FF&%,")' *@"' <.#>-3&$F*M' $#3/>)$#:' .>*@%&-@$F' .#)' %&)"&' %I'

.>*@%&-@$FM' .#)' .:&""'B$*@' ->4<$--$%#' *%'>4.,8-' 1,&#.4' ?.8.,4#:',&7' @4.,-!.&-;' G@$-' -*>)J'B.-' I>#)")' 4J' *@"'E$#$-*&J' %I' a"./*@M'

H.4%>&' .#)'T"/I.&";' G@"' .>*@%&-' @.,"' #%' 3%#s$3*-' %I' $#*"&"-*' *%'

)"3/.&";'

Kp9&(>3$1")9&()3';:;434$:">3:$)&'1"$u<23$4"$:3$;(A")<>32;j($6$:3$9/':;232;j($

!  -;)2:3;5"1)$1":30"4$0&$6,%$&05C'-!#7F&0+!!  8&/12")$&?$h,-:&-(!!  "'-;&07+!'E!&-7#.#+7!

Y/(4;(>$

K0,;2)$

M&(w;20)$&?$;(0"1")0$

C%,"&.:"'.#)'


T"'B%>/)'/$L"'*%'&"3%<<"#)'*@"'I%//%B$#:'&",$"B"&-'*%'",./>.*"'

%>&'<.#>-3&$F*j''

6;  b",$"B"&'6'.#)'3%#*.3*'$#I%&<.9%#'

1;  b",$"B"&'1'.#)'3%#*.3*'$#I%&<.9%#'

7;  b",$"B"&'7'.#)'3%#*.3*'$#I%&<.9%#'

g;  b",$"B"&'g'.#)'3%#*.3*'$#I%&<.9%#'

A/".-"'.))&"--'.//'3%&&"-F%#)"#3"'*%j'

!  b"3%<<"#)")'&",$"B"&-'

!  ?>*@%&z-'3%#*.3*'$#I%&<.9%#'

B0,"1$;59&103(0$;(?&153<&(7$

C%,"&.:"'.#)'


T"'B%>/)'/$L"'*%'&"3%<<"#)'*@"'I%//%B$#:'&",$"B"&-'*%'",./>.*"'

%>&'<.#>-3&$F*j''

6;  b",$"B"&'6'.#)'3%#*.3*'$#I%&<.9%#'

1;  b",$"B"&'1'.#)'3%#*.3*'$#I%&<.9%#'

7;  b",$"B"&'7'.#)'3%#*.3*'$#I%&<.9%#'

g;  b",$"B"&'g'.#)'3%#*.3*'$#I%&<.9%#'

A/".-"'.))&"--'.//'3%&&"-F%#)"#3"'*%j'

%"2&5;"(4"$1"A;)&1")$9313$)/$53(/)01;0&$

B0,"1$;59&103(0$;(?&153<&(7$

!  b"3%<<"#)")'&",$"B"&-'

!  ?>*@%&z-'3%#*.3*'$#I%&<.9%#'

C%,"&.:"'.#)'

!*.D#:'A/.#'

E.#>-3&$F*'

-*&>3*>&"' A good cover letter E.&3'H$FF<.#M'EK'

()$*%&O$#OC@$"I'

>4.,8-'1,&#.4'?.8.,4#:',&7'@4.,-!.&-'

7'!"F*"<4"&'1567'

K".&'K&'H$FF<.#M'

A/".-"' U#)' "#3/%-")' %>&'<.#>-3&$F*' "#9*/")' l(,./>.9%#' %I' *@"' [/.-:%B' F&%:#%-93' -3%&"' $#' F.9"#*-' >#)"&:%$#:' 3>&.9,"' &"-"39%#' I%&' 4&".-*' 3.#3"&' /$,"&'<"*.-*.-"-Mm' B@$3@'B"'B%>/)' /$L"' *%' ->4<$*' I%&'

F>4/$3.9%#'.-'.#'2&$:$#./'?&93/"'$#'>4.,8-'1,&#.4'?.8.,4#:',&7'@4.,-!.&-;';''

G@"'[/.-:%B'F&%:#%-93'-3%&"'X[A!Y'$-'%I',./>"'I%&'.',.&$"*J'%I'*><%>&-;'!","&./'-*>)$"-'@.,"'$#,"-9:.*")'*@"'F&%:#%-93',./>"'%I'*@"'[A!'$#'F.9"#*-'B$*@'<"*.-*.93'4&".-*'3.#3"&M'4>*'I"B'-*>)$"-'@.,"'F"&I%&<")'

->3@'.#' $#,"-9:.9%#' I%&'F.9"#*-'>#)"&:%$#:' /$,"&' &"-"39%#' I%&' /$,"&'<"*.-*.-"-;' W>&*@"&<%&"M' *@"&"'.&"' 3>&&"#*/J'#%' -*>)$"-' *@.*'@.,"'"].<$#")' *@"'F&%:#%-93',./>"'%I' *@"'<%)$U")'[A!' X<[A!Y' $#' *@"-"'

F.9"#*-;'G@"'F&"-"#*'-*>)J'",./>.*")'*@"'<[A!'$#'*"&<-'%I'$*-'F&%:#%-93',./>"'I%&'F%-*%F"&.9,"')".*@'$#'F.9"#*-'>#)"&:%$#:'/$,"&'&"-"39%#'I%&'4&".-*'3.#3"&'/$,"&'<"*.-*.-"-;'

?'*%*./'%I'76n'F.9"#*-'B$*@'4&".-*'3.#3"&'/$,"&'<"*.-*.-"-'B@%'>#)"&B"#*'@"F.*"3*%<J'%,"&'.'6NOJ".&'F"&$%)'B"&"'$#3/>)")'$#'*@$-'-*>)J;'G@"'<[A!'B.-'3./3>/.*")'4.-")'%#'*@"'/","/-'%I'CO&".39,"'F&%*"$#'.#)'

./4><$#M'.#)' *@"')$-".-"OI&""' ->&,$,./'.#)'3.#3"&O-F"3$U3' ->&,$,./' &.*"-'B"&"'",./>.*")' $#' &"/.9%#' *%' *@"'<[A!;'A&%:#%-93' -$:#$U3.#3"'B.-' &"*&%-F"39,"/J'.#./J8")'4J'>#$,.&$.*"'.#)'<>/9,.&$.*"'.#./J-"-;'

2,"&.//M'*@"'&"->/*-'-@%B")'.'-$:#$U3.#*'.--%3$.9%#'4"*B""#'3.#3"&O-F"3$U3'->&,$,./'.#)'*@"'<[A!'.#)'3.&3$#%"<4&J%#$3'.#9:"#'/","/M'.#)'.'@$:@"&'<[A!'B.-'.--%3$.*")'B$*@'$#3&".-")'.::&"--$,"#"--'%I'/$,"&'

&"3>&&"#3"'.#)'F%%&"&'->&,$,./'$#'*@"-"'F.9"#*-;'

G@$-'-*>)J'$-'*@"'U&-*'*%')"<%#-*&.*"'*@.*'*@"'F&"%F"&.9,"'<[A!M'.'-$<F/"'3/$#$3./'*%%/M' $-'.'>-"I>/'F&%:#%-93'I.3*%&'I%&'F%-*%F"&.9,"'->&,$,./' $#'4&".-*'3.#3"&'F.9"#*-'>#)"&:%$#:'3>&.9,"'&"-"39%#'I%&' /$,"&'

<"*.-*.-"-;'G@$-'$#I%&<.9%#'$-'$<<")$.*"/J'3/$#$3.//J'.FF/$3.4/"'I%&'->&:"%#-'.#)'<")$3./'%#3%/%:$-*-'*&".9#:'->3@'F.9"#*-;'?-'.'F&"<$"&'R%>&#./'3%,"&$#:'4&".-*'3.#3"&'*&".*<"#*M'B"'4"/$","'*@.*'>4.,8-'1,&#.4'?.8.,4#:',&7'@4.,-!.&-'$-'*@"'F"&I"3*'F/.{%&<'I&%<'B@$3@'*%'-@.&"'%>&'&"->/*-'B$*@'.//'*@%-"'3%#3"&#")'B$*@'4&".-*'3.#3"&;'

T"'3%#U&<'*@.*'*@$-'<.#>-3&$F*'@.-'#%*'4""#'F>4/$-@")'"/-"B@"&"'.#)'$-'#%*'>#)"&'3%#-$)"&.9%#'4J'.#%*@"&'R%>&#./;'?//'.>*@%&-'@.,"'.FF&%,")'*@"'<.#>-3&$F*M'$#3/>)$#:'.>*@%&-@$F'.#)'%&)"&'%I'.>*@%&-@$FM'

.#)'.:&""'B$*@'->4<$--$%#'*%'>4.,8-'1,&#.4'?.8.,4#:',&7'@4.,-!.&-;'G@$-'-*>)J'B.-'I>#)")'4J'*@"'E$#$-*&J'%I'a"./*@M'H.4%>&'.#)'T"/I.&";'G@"'.>*@%&-'@.,"'#%'3%#s$3*-'%I'$#*"&"-*'*%')"3/.&";'

T"'B%>/)'/$L"'*%'&"3%<<"#)'*@"'I%//%B$#:'&",$"B"&-'*%'",./>.*"'%>&'<.#>-3&$F*j''

b",$"B"&'6'.#)'3%#*.3*'$#I%&<.9%#'

b",$"B"&'1'.#)'3%#*.3*'$#I%&<.9%#'

b",$"B"&'7'.#)'3%#*.3*'$#I%&<.9%#'

b",$"B"&'g'.#)'3%#*.3*'$#I%&<.9%#'

A/".-"'.))&"--'.//'3%&&"-F%#)"#3"'*%j'

T"'/%%L'I%&B.&)'*%'@".&$#:'I&%<'J%>'.*'J%>&'".&/$"-*'3%#,"#$"#3";'

|%>&-'-$#3"&"/JM'

E3(/)21;90$;(?&153<&($

@32Z>1&/(4$

["6$P(4;(>)$

%":"A3(2"$

-;)2:3;5"1)$

%"2&55"(4"4$1"A;"L"1)$

C%,"&.:"'.#)'

!*.D#:'A/.#'C%,"&'/"c"&-'

Recommending reviewers

lT@"#' ->4<$w#:' J%>&' F.F"&M' J%>' <>-*' F&%,$)"' *@"'

#.<"-M' .D/$.9%#-M' .#)' ,./$)' "O<.$/' .))&"--"-' %I' U,"' XNY'

&",$"B"&-;' ZI' J%>' )%' #%*' )%' -%M' J%>&' F.F"&' B$//' 4"'

&"*>&#")M'>#&",$"B");m'

l?>*@%&-' .&"' &"`>"-*")' *%' F&%,$)"' *@"' #.<"-' .#)' I>//'

.))&"--"-'X$#3/>)$#:'"O<.$/'.))&"--Y'%I'>F'*%'I%>&'F%*"#9./'

&"I"&""-km'

]#.&ZI,#!$5+!:&.#07.&0#+!:#!$5!.#B&+75!65.5!:#7#.8&-5.!0,H-7'+!.#B&+'.#+!+#!.#0'8&#-:5-!

C%,"&.:"'.#)'

!*.D#:'A/.#'C%,"&'/"c"&-'

Recommending reviewers

V,"1"$0&$P(4$0,"5o$

Y1&5$6&/1$1"34;(>`1"?"1"(2")*$("0L&1Z;(>$30$2&(?"1"(2")$

Q&L$)"(;&1o$ .;5$?&1$5;4h:"A":$1")"312,"1)$

V,&$0&$3A&;4o$M&::3'&130&1)$S93)0$i$6"31)T*$

1")"312,"1)$?1&5$)35"$;()<0/<&($

a-7#.-5C'-5$!$&+7e$$C$&1$F$?1&5$.);3*$C$&1$F$?1&5$K/1&9"*$3(4$C$&1$F$?1&5$0,"$.5"1;23)$

Q#0'8&#-:#!&-B#+C(5:'.#+!:#!-&B#$!!8#:&'!:#!:&E#.#-7#+!65i+#+!

?##.!Q#B&#O!

Section 3

A""&'b",$"B'

Improves your manuscript

Y#7!&-B'$B#:!$#'*@"''

F""&'&",$"B'F&%3"--'

X3$1"A;);j($9&1$931")$")$/($91&2")&$$9&);<A&$R/"$5"I&131n$)/$53(/)2;0&$

A""&'b",$"B' What reviewers are looking for

H,"$)2;"(2"$

H,"$53(/)21;90$

!  %":"A3(0$,69&0,");)$!  O&&4$"p9"1;5"(03:$4");>($!  .991&91;30"$5"0,&4&:&>6$!  O&&4$4303$3(3:6);)$!  \3:;4$2&(2:/);&()$

!  X&>;23:$w&L$&?$;(?&153<&($!  E3(/)21;90$)01/20/1"$3(4$?&153x(>$!  .991&91;30"$1"?"1"(2")$!  Q;>,$1"343';:;06$

A""&'b",$"B'

%")9&()"$:"N"1$

%")9&(43$2:3135"(0"$3$2343$$2&5"(031;&$4"$)/)$1"A;)&1")$

A5+)$0&$)""$2,3(>")$

%"?"1$0&$:;("$3(4$93>"$(/5'"1)$

f)"$3$4;#"1"(0$2&:&1$?&(0$

Q;>,:;>,0$0,"$0"p0$

Revision

A""&'b",$"B'

Writing a response letter

E.&3'H$FF<.#M'EK'

()$*%&O$#OC@$"I'

>4.,8-'1,&#.4'?.8.,4#:',&7'@4.,-!.&-'

7'!"F*"<4"&'1567'

K".&'K&'H$FF<.#M'

b"j'b"->4<$--$%#'%I'<.#>-3&$F*'&"I"&"#3"'S%;'Tu!O5VONV7e'

A/".-"'U#)'.c.3@")'.'&",$-")',"&-$%#'%I'%>&'<.#>-3&$F*'%&$:$#.//J'"#9*/")'l(,./>.9%#'%I'*@"'[/.-:%B'F&%:#%-93'

-3%&"'$#'F.9"#*-'>#)"&:%$#:'3>&.9,"'&"-"39%#'I%&'4&".-*'3.#3"&'/$,"&'<"*.-*.-"-Mm'B@$3@'B"'B%>/)'/$L"'*%'&"->4<$*'

I%&'3%#-$)"&.9%#'I%&'F>4/$3.9%#'$#'*@"'>4.,8-'1,&#.4'?.8.,4#:',&7'@4.,-!.&-9'

G@"'&",$"B"&z-'3%<<"#*-'B"&"'@$:@/J'$#-$:@{>/'.#)'"#.4/")'>-'*%':&".*/J'$<F&%,"'*@"'`>./$*J'%I'%>&'<.#>-3&$F*;'Z#'

*@"'I%//%B$#:'F.:"-'.&"'%>&'F%$#*O4JOF%$#*'&"-F%#-"-'*%'".3@'%I'*@"'3%<<"#*-;'

b",$-$%#-'$#'*@"'<.#>-3&$F*'.&"'-@%B#'.-'>#)"&/$#")'*"]*;'Z#'.33%&).#3"'B$*@'*@"'U&-*'3%<<"#*M'*@"'9*/"'@.-'4""#'

&",$-")'.#)'*@"'"#9&"'<.#>-3&$F*'@.-'>#)"&:%#"'->4-*.#9./'(#:/$-@'")$9#:;''

T"'@%F"'*@.*'*@"'&",$-$%#-'$#'*@"'<.#>-3&$F*'.#)'%>&'.33%<F.#J$#:'&"-F%#-"-'B$//'4"'->D3$"#*'*%'<.L"'%>&'

<.#>-3&$F*'->$*.4/"'I%&'F>4/$3.9%#'$#'*@"'>4.,8-'1,&#.4'?.8.,4#:',&7'@4.,-!.&-;'

.441"))$"4;0&1$9"1)&(3::6$

E3(/)21;90$=-$(/5'"1$

H,3(Z$1"A;"L"1)$

Q;>,:;>,0$53I&1$2,3(>")$

A""&'b",$"B'

Agreeing with reviewers

Q#B&#O#.!"'88#-7e! 5&'"3;4',&,$"8%8'3A'-:.'7,-,'"3;':,2.'#:38.&'-3' ;8.' ,' 83!.B:,-' 3C8#;4.' DE&F' A;&#63&' G4.F4.88%3&H9' ' 5&' !"'3I%&%3&J','8%!I$.'K,;88%,&'A;&#63&'B3;$7':,2.'8;L#.79'M34.32.4J'-:.' 4.8;$-8' B3;$7' C.' !34.' %&8-4;#62.' ,&7' .,8%.4' -3' #3!I,4.' -3'I4.2%3;8'4.8;$-89'

%")9&()"7' T"' .:&""' B$*@' *@"' &",$"B"&z-' .--"--<"#*' %I' *@"'

.#./J-$-;'2>&'*.$/%&")'I>#39%#M'$#'$*-'3>&&"#*'I%&<M'<.L"-'$*')$D3>/*'

*%' *"//' *@.*' *@$-' <".->&"<"#*' 3%#-9*>*"-' .' -$:#$U3.#*'

$<F&%,"<"#*' %,"&' F&",$%>-/J' &"F%&*")' ,./>"-;' T"' )"-3&$4"' %>&'

#"B'.#./J-$-'>-$#:'.'[.>--$.#'Uw#:'I>#39%#'$#'%>&'&",$-")'b"->/*-'

-"39%#'XA.:"'PM'H$#"-'61p6nY;'

A""&'b",$"B'

Q#B&#O#.!"'88#-7e! 5&'"3;4',&,$"8%8'3A'-:.'7,-,'"3;':,2.'#:38.&'-3' ;8.' ,' 83!.B:,-' 3C8#;4.' DE&F' A;&#63&' G4.F4.88%3&H9' ' 5&' !"'3I%&%3&J','8%!I$.'K,;88%,&'A;&#63&'B3;$7':,2.'8;L#.79'M34.32.4J'-:.' 4.8;$-8' B3;$7' C.' !34.' %&8-4;#62.' ,&7' .,8%.4' -3' #3!I,4.' -3'I4.2%3;8'4.8;$-89'

%")9&()"7' T"' .:&""' B$*@' *@"' &",$"B"&z-' .--"--<"#*' %I' *@"'

.#./J-$-;'2>&'*.$/%&")'I>#39%#M'$#'$*-'3>&&"#*'I%&<M'<.L"-'$*')$D3>/*'

*%' *"//' *@.*' *@$-' <".->&"<"#*' 3%#-9*>*"-' .' -$:#$U3.#*'

$<F&%,"<"#*' %,"&' F&",$%>-/J' &"F%&*")' ,./>"-;' T"' )"-3&$4"' %>&'

#"B'.#./J-$-'>-$#:'.'[.>--$.#'Uw#:'I>#39%#'$#'%>&'&",$-")'b"->/*-'

-"39%#'XA.:"'PM'H$#"-'61p6nY;'

Agreeing with reviewers

.>1""5"(0$

%"A;);&()$X&23<&($

A""&'b",$"B'

Disagreeing with reviewers

Q#B&#O#.!"'88#-7e!5&'"3;4',&,$"8%8'3A'-:.'7,-,'"3;':,2.'#:38.&'-3' ;8.' ,' 83!.B:,-' 3C8#;4.' DE&F' A;&#63&' G4.F4.88%3&H9' ' 5&' !"'3I%&%3&J' ,' 8%!I$.' K,;88%,&' A;&#63&' B3;$7' :,2.' 8;L#.79'M34.32.4J' -:.' 4.8;$-8' B3;$7' C.' !34.' %&8-4;#62.' ,&7' .,8%.4' -3'#3!I,4.'-3'I4.2%3;8'4.8;$-89'

%")9&()"7' ?/*@%>:@' .' -$<F/"' [.>--$.#' U*' B%>/)' I.3$/$*.*"'

3%<F.&$-%#'B$*@'*@"'&"->/*-'%I'%*@"&'-*>)$"-M'%>&'*.$/%&")'I>#39%#'

.//%B-' I%&' *@"' .#./J-$-' %I' *@"' ).*.' $#' *"&<-' %I' *@"' !<$*@'<%)"/'

x!<$*@' "*' ./;M' 6eeny;' T"' @.,"' #%B' "]F/.$#")' *@"' >-"' %I' *@$-'

I>#39%#' .#)' *@"' !<$*@' <%)"/' $#' %>&' &",$-")' K$-3>--$%#' -"39%#'

XA.:"'61M'H$#"-'1pPY;'

A""&'b",$"B'

Q#B&#O#.!"'88#-7e!5&'"3;4',&,$"8%8'3A'-:.'7,-,'"3;':,2.'#:38.&'-3' ;8.' ,' 83!.B:,-' 3C8#;4.' DE&F' A;&#63&' G4.F4.88%3&H9' ' 5&' !"'3I%&%3&J' ,' 8%!I$.' K,;88%,&' A;&#63&' B3;$7' :,2.' 8;L#.79'M34.32.4J' -:.' 4.8;$-8' B3;$7' C.' !34.' %&8-4;#62.' ,&7' .,8%.4' -3'#3!I,4.'-3'I4.2%3;8'4.8;$-89'

%")9&()"7' ?/*@%>:@' .' -$<F/"' [.>--$.#' U*' B%>/)' I.3$/$*.*"'

3%<F.&$-%#'B$*@'*@"'&"->/*-'%I'%*@"&'-*>)$"-M'%>&'*.$/%&")'I>#39%#'

.//%B-' I%&' *@"' .#./J-$-' %I' *@"' ).*.' $#' *"&<-' %I' *@"' !<$*@'<%)"/'

x!<$*@' "*' ./;M' 6eeny;' T"' @.,"' #%B' "]F/.$#")' *@"' >-"' %I' *@$-'

I>#39%#' .#)' *@"' !<$*@' <%)"/' $#' %>&' &",$-")' K$-3>--$%#' -"39%#'

XA.:"'61M'H$#"-'1pPY;'

Disagreeing with reviewers

%"A;);&()$

X&23<&($

KA;4"(2"$

A""&'b",$"B'

Q#B&#O#.!0'88#-7N'@:.',;-:348'$33=.7'A34'I3$"!34I:%8!8'%&'-:.'I43!3-.4' 4.F%3&'3A' -:.'F.&.O' :3B.2.4J' -:."'7%7&P-' .2,$;,-.' -:.';&-4,&8$,-.7' 4.F%3&89' @:,-' %8' 3&.' 3A' !"' #3&#.4&8' ,C3;-' -:%8'!.-:373$3F"9'

“Hidden” questions

Q#6F.5+#:! I,#+C'-N' Q:"' 7%7&R-' -:.' ,;-:348' .2,$;,-.'I3$"!34I:%8!8'%&'-:.';&-4,&8$,-.7'4.F%3&8'3A'-:.'F.&.S'

A""&'b",$"B'



%")9&()"j' Z#' *@$-' -*>)JM' B"' )"3$)")' *%' I%3>-' %#' *@"' F&%<%*"&'

&":$%#'%I'*@$-':"#"'4"3.>-"'F&",$%>-'-*>)$"-'x|.R$<.'"*'./;M'1565i'

u.3L-%#' "*' ./;M' 1566y' @.,"' -@%B#' *@.*' $*-' *&.#-3&$F9%#' B.-'

F.&93>/.&/J' ._"3*");' G@$-' @.-' #%B' 4""#' 3/.&$U")' $#' *@"'

K$-3>--$%#'-"39%#'%I'%>&'<.#>-3&$F*'XA.:"'6PM'H$#"'1gp1nY;'

A""&'b",$"B'



%")9&()"j' Z#' *@$-' -*>)JM' B"' )"3$)")' *%' I%3>-' %#' *@"' F&%<%*"&'

&":$%#'%I'*@$-':"#"'4"3.>-"'F&",$%>-'-*>)$"-'x|.R$<.'"*'./;M'1565i'

u.3L-%#' "*' ./;M' 1566y' @.,"' -@%B#' *@.*' $*-' *&.#-3&$F9%#' B.-'

F.&93>/.&/J' ._"3*");' G@$-' @.-' #%B' 4""#' 3/.&$U")' $#' *@"'

K$-3>--$%#'-"39%#'%I'%>&'<.#>-3&$F*'XA.:"'6PM'H$#"'1gp1nY;'

%"A;);&()$

X&23<&($

KA;4"(2"$

Summary 1#++&'-!2!

!  X&>;23::6$91")"(<(>$;(?&153<&($;($6&/1$53(/)21;90$! V1;<(>$"#"2<A"$3')01320)$3(4$<0:")$!  H31>"<(>$'1&34$A"1)/)$(311&L$?&2/)"4$I&/1(3:)$!  M:"31:6$2&55/(;23<(>$6&/1$;4"3)$;($K(>:;),$

1#++&'-!3!

!  M,&&);(>$0,"$5&)0$)/;03':"$I&/1(3:$!  M&55/(;23<(>$L;0,$I&/1(3:$"4;0&1)$!  c3A;>3<(>$9""1$1"A;"L$

Thank you!

LLLD"43(W"4;<(>D2&5$

Any questions?

Y&::&L$/)$&($HL;N"1$q!&/1(3:.4A;)&1'

-&L(:&34$3(4$?/10,"1$1"34;(>$"43(W"4;<(>D2&5`/(;A3::"$

X;Z"$/)$&($Y32"'&&Z$?32"'&&ZD2&5`!&/1(3:.4A;)&1'

Travel

201310 springer colombia valle