18

Click here to load reader

Is one better than two

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Is one better than two

Alfredo Tifi

ITT Divini, San Severino Marche (MC)

[email protected]

ICCE – ECRICE - ROME July19° 2012

Page 2: Is one better than two

So, it is one better than

two?Less lab time has stimulated reflections:

1. What the laboratory is for? Beyond fun

2. Talk & Reflect more on past experiments

vs claiming for "next episodes"

3. Relevance for the syllabus

4. Adapting the syllabus to lab concreteness

5. More emphasis on evidences from

everyday life plus class demonstrations

Page 3: Is one better than two

1/6 adaptable IBSE principles

Any important chemical concept should be referable to experimental evidence

Atoms emitting light

Atoms having nuclei

Ions having charges

http://rcl.physik.uni-kl.de/

Page 4: Is one better than two

2/6 adaptable IBSE principles

few meaningful experiments acting as milestones in the syllabus, e.g.:

combustion of magnesiumflame testdistillation of Coca Coladiffusion of potassium permanganatereaction Zinc plus Iodine...

Page 5: Is one better than two

3/6 adaptable IBSE principles

Language first: talk in advance about instruments, tasks, prepare the imaginery

preview certain phenomena

use background dictionary

elicit focus questions, investigations

ask to plan the experiment

compare different plannings

Page 6: Is one better than two

4/6 adaptable IBSE principles

Prepare everything in advance: your students have 30 minutes to do the experiment.

So they can't waste time to make the queue at the balance to weigh, to search for materials, to prepare solutions or to accomplish lengthy filtering or evaporation tasks.

Page 7: Is one better than two

5/6 adaptable IBSE principles

Things to scaffold: • reporting, • discussing • testing

the experiment and related contents through in-school and out-of-school web2 environment permit extended interactions, as in Google Apps www.divini.net/chimica/

Page 8: Is one better than two

6/6 adaptable IBSE principles

Continue to scaffold and practice the use of concepts, repeating simulated experiments and descriptions and reviewing past experiments,

Accepting that the students won't master those concepts, won't be autonomous problem-solver.

Page 9: Is one better than two

An example of IBSE syllabus Diary

at: https://sites.google.com/a/divini.org/classe-1e-chimica/home/attivita

1. Sep. 21. Evaporating

DI-water & tap water

2. Oct.5-26. Measuring

mass & volume

3. Nov. 5-7 Mixing subs

Investigation

Volume units,

absolute/relative

error, sig. figs.

density, atoms

distributions in solids,

liquids and gases

Property, chem/phys

transfs. Substance

ACTIVITY CONCEPTS

Page 10: Is one better than two

4. Nov. 25, 28 Mg

combustion

5. Dec. 5 Zinc + Iodine

6. Dec. 19 Decompos.

of Zinc iodide

7. Dec. 19-Jan. 26

forming/separating

mix. Cu/CuSO4

Chemical combination,

elementary and

compound

substances

Atomic weight ratio,

composition ratio,

formula.

Decomposition,

element vs elemental

substance.

identity of a substance

homo/heterog.

mixture

Page 11: Is one better than two

8. Jan. 23-30 Solubility

of salts in water/NaCl

30%

9. Feb. 27 Diffusion

(KMnO4, HCl-NH3)

brownian motion,

soccer ball pressure,

T-shirt air drying.

Solubility, saturated

solution, causes of

different solubilities

Molecular motion

Temperature

Dynamic models of

solution formation

and evaporation.

Chemical reaction as

molecule collisions

Page 12: Is one better than two

more on pressure,

other insights on kinetic

model (qualitative)

investigating real atoms

plus challenging models

10. Mar 2 - 9. Weigh the

pressure of air with a

syringe, Boyle law

with syringe plus

body balance,

hampered straw

sucking

11. Mar 12-19.

Rutherford

experiment

rcl.physik.uni-kl.de/

Page 13: Is one better than two

12. Mar. 26. Light from

atoms (light from

gases H, He &

emission spectra)

13. Apr. 2, 4. Flame test

as problem solving:

which element atoms

are responsible for

the observed

colours?

Electromagnetic wawes

wawelenght & frequency

Planck equation:

frequency/energy

relation, photons.

Symbols & formulas

spectral lines and likeness

of electronic structures of

same elements.

Bohr model, levels &

electronic transitions

Page 14: Is one better than two

14. Apr. 16. Game:

"How the atom

works" http://www.mhhe.com/physsci/ast

ronomy/applets/Bohr/frame.html

15. Apr. 18, 20, 23; May

2, 4. Game: "Build an

Atom"http://phet.colorado.edu/en/simulation

/build-an-atom

Bohr model, levels &

electronic transitions

Planck equation:

wavelenght/frequency/

energy,photons, spectra.

Nucleons, Isotopes, Z, N, A,

noble gas element, octet,

charged atoms (ions) +

ionisation energy,

dimension, core/valence

shell model, periodic

trend, atomic weight

Page 15: Is one better than two

16. May 7. Investigate:

a) "recognize alkali

metal atoms“

b) "calculate masses of

LiCl, NaCl, KCl".

17. May 14,

Investigate:

"Differences in Li, Na

reacting in water"

PTE Group-family

equal number of different

atoms

Ions, ionic solid,

ion volume or radius

chemical reaction

equation.

Core effective charge,

valence electrons, atomic

radius, Ionisation

energy.

Page 16: Is one better than two

18. May 21. Investigate:

"Halogen tug of war"

19. May 25. Atom

mass/number

calculations

PTE Group-family

oxidation-reduction

electron-affinity

chemical reaction equation.

Octet

Core effective charge,

valence electrons, atomic

radius. Electron config.

Periodic trends.

Formula weight, relative

atomic weight ratios;

balancing ionic compound

formulas.

Page 17: Is one better than two

20. May 28 - June 7.

Demos: oxidations of

elemental

substances (Ca, Mg,

Fe, Cu, C, S) in

water, HCl, air.

End of Year

...

To be contd. in 2012-13

Periodic Table: metals,

nonmetals, semimetals.

electron configurations,

ions; ionic bond, covalent

bond, metal bond;

formulas of ionic

compounds, Lewis

notation; covalent

molecules and

formulas; octet rule;

redox reactions.

All that was less than any

textbook proposes.

Page 18: Is one better than two

Thank you very muchfor your attention

A l f r e d o T i f i

Website to access the diaries

www.divini.net/chimica

Email address

[email protected]