Getting Early Estimates Right, DrupalCon Chicago 2011

Getting Early Estimates RightJakob Persson

Introducing me

www.nodeone.seSTOCKHOLM | GOTHENBURG | COPENHAGEN

Lead Drupal Solutions Architect

Co-Founder of NodeOne

Worked with Drupal since 2005

[email protected]

http://www.twitter.com/realsolipsist

http://drupal.org/user/37564

http://www.nodeone.se

http://www.nodeone.se

mailto:[email protected]






Introducing

Some of NodeOne’s team and clients

Scandinavia’s largest Drupal services provider

Employs 39 people

Offices in Sweden and Denmark

What we do at NodeOne, apart from...

card games...

Hi, I’m Dries!*

www.drupalcardgame.com

* No he’s not really Dries, but you knew that already.

http://www.drupalcardgame.com






Druplicons wielding nun-chuks...

Druplicon Road Trip – “Showdown in Paris” (YouTube)

Drupal rock stars...

“The Kitten Killers” Live at DrupalCon Copenhagen (photo by Dries)

Pilot studies

Design and usability

Development

Hosting and scalability

Training

Consulting

Early estimating“There’s no point in being exact about something if you don’t even know what you’re talking about.”

— John von Neumann

frustrated!

frustrated!

bored...

frustrated!

bored...

uncertain?!

What is an early estimate?

“Estimation is the calculated approximation of a result which is usable even if input data may be incomplete or uncertain.”

Source: Wikipedia

Useless!

http

://w

ww

.sxc

.hu/

phot

o/12

5985

0

http://www.sxc.hu/photo/1259850


Useless!

Project X

≠ Project ?Project Y

http

://w

ww

.sxc

.hu/

phot

o/12

5985

0



Early estimates vs in-project estimates

Early In-project

Target Feature User story

Purpose Decide on investment Planning

Accuracy Low to medium High

Method Expert Team

Effort and accuracy

Acc

urac

y

Effort

100%

Adapted from “Agile Estimating and Planning”, Cohn 2008

Early estimates

• Can be made in relatively short time

• Generates estimates that aren’t based on random guesses or chance

• Lets you use your experience as a yardstick and reference

How early estimates are made

“Divide et impera”, how’s that for a

strategy?

# Title Estimate DoE Solution

1

2

3

4

A spreadsheet

A Drupal-devoted developer

– and possibly also –

Dick Olsson, kick-ass Drupal developer at NodeOne

The method

Timebox your estimation work

Analyze the requirements

Make initial guesstimate

Extract features and write proposed solutions

Estimate features

Take uncertainty and errors into account

Compare with guesstimate

Tim

ebox

Analy

ze re

quire

men

tsIn

itial

gues

stim

ate

Extr

act f

eatu

res

Estim

ate

feat

ures

Unc

erta

inty

and

err

ors

Com

pare

with

gue

sstim

ate

TIMEBOX ESTIMATION WORK

From: [email protected]: YouSubject: Link directory on Drupal

Hey,

We're looking into moving our site awesomecoolwebsites.com to drupal and wonderhow much it would cost. We would like to get rid of the proprietary software weuse and have more flexibility. Drupal seems to be the best choice for us.

Our site is a link directory where people with awesomely cool sites can postlinks to their sites. The directory is divided into categories and people canpay for premium exposure. We also have something called "link of the day" whichcosts $50 and puts a link to your site on the front page.

The site has a blog where we post updates and business articles on a regularbasis. This blog is written by several people and they can only be able to edittheir own blog posts. Though they should be able to add other users who can edittheir posts so that they can cooperate on a post.

We're not planning on migrating content but we're offshoring the work and allold links will be added manually. We want to tag content too and we think it'sbest to migrate manually and do the tagging at the same time.

It's important that it's super easy to post new links and comment on blog posts.when you add a link you get a user account. Unless you have one already.Also, administrators must be able to approve links posted. Admins should get anemail when links are added so they can go and check.We want captcha so that automated postings are prevented.

When you buy a premium link you pay with credit card, we have a processor forthis and drupal needs to integrate with them. It's important that users feelsuper safe when submitting links. For this reason the whole submit process mustbe over secure connection.

We plan on launching the new drupalized site in the next six months.

Looking forward to your quote.

Sincerely,

JohnWebsite Manager

ANALYZE THE REQUIREMENTS



Hey,









Sincerely,

JohnWebsite Manager

ANALYZE THE REQUIREMENTS

Check out the sample

requirements for the

link directory site at:

http://bit.ly/drupalestimating

http://bit.ly/drupalestimate











































































MAKE INITIAL GUESSTIMATE

“BETWEEN THUMB AND INDEX FINGER”

EXTRACT FEATURES AND WRITE SOLUTIONS


Hey,









Sincerely,

JohnWebsite Manager




The sample requirements for the link directory website can also be found on the web:

http://bit.ly/estimate

http://bit.ly/estimate

Requirements

Feature A

Feature B

Feature C

Feature D

Feature E

Feature F

are broken down into

2

10

1

20

5

1

FeatureDefinition of a

A conceptually and contextually discrete piece of the final deliverables with an estimated proposed solution

FeatureDefinition of a

Link directory sample requirements:





Hey,









Sincerely,

JohnWebsite Manager




Hey,









Sincerely,

JohnWebsite Manager

“Our site is a link directory where people with awesomely cool sites can post links to their sites”




Hey,









Sincerely,

JohnWebsite Manager

“Our site is a link directory where people with awesomely cool sites can post links to their sites”

1 Nodetype: Link




Hey,









Sincerely,

JohnWebsite Manager

“Also, administrators must be able to approve links posted. Admins should get an email when links are added so they can go and check.”

1 Nodetype: Link




Hey,









Sincerely,

JohnWebsite Manager

“Also, administrators must be able to approve links posted. Admins should get an email when links are added so they can go and check.”

2Users add links which are unpublished before approved

3 Administrators are notified when links are added

4 Administrators can view and approve links

1 Nodetype: Link



14 Featured link on the front page A view displaying a single node of type “Featured”

1 Nodetype: Link

2 Users add links which are unpublished before approved



# Description Proposed solution

1 Nodetype: Link Create a node type called link and use the Link module for the link field.

2Users add links which are unpublished before approved

Use Flag and Rules modules to create a workflow. The workflow sets a newly created Link node as unpublished.


Workflow created with Rules, it sends an email to the webmaster once a link node is created.


A list of unpublished nodes of type “link”, created using the Views module.

-30%

-30%

Code less

Use the UI instead

Do this

By: h

ttp:

//ww

w.s

xc.h

u/pr

ofile

/age

ntos

eis

Enjoy a safe upgrade path

http

://w

ww

.flic

kr.c

om/p

hoto

s/jn

s001

/295

8140

977/

Future-proof your website

Get this

http://www.sxc.hu/profile/agentoseis

http://www.sxc.hu/profile/agentoseis

http://www.flickr.com/photos/jns001/2958140977/






http://bit.ly/estimationsheet3

Estimation sheet with sample requirements

http://bit.ly/estimationsheet


http://bit.ly/estimationtemplate3

Estimation Sheet Template



2 Users add links which are unpublished before approved 2 5


Number

Description

Estimate

Degree of Experience

Proposed Solution

2 Users add links which are unpublished before approved

2 5Use Flag and Rules modules to create a workflow. The workflow sets a newly created Link node as unpublished.

Number

Description

Estimate

Degree of Experience

Proposed Solution

ESTIMATING FEATURES

•Development

•Writing automated tests

• Configuration

• Testing

• Fixing bugs

•Deploying to staging server

Estimating using a scale

• Scale of fixed number of hours

• Only use numbers from the scale.

• Always round up

1 2 4 8 16

1 2 4 8 16Popular scale

1 2 4 8 16Popular scale

1 2 5Scale I use





~ 3 hours (ideally)



~ 3 hours (ideally)

2 5



~ 3 hours (ideally)

2 552

3 Administrators are notified when links are added 5


1 2 5Scale I use

Factor 0.1

10 20Factor 10

Factor 1

1 2 5

Factor 0.1

10 20Factor 10

Factor 1

1 2 5

Factor 0.1

10 20Factor 10

Factor 1

Changing settings or setting configuration

Co-authors for articles 0.2 Add a user reference field to Article node type

1 2 5

Factor 0.1

10 20Factor 10

Factor 1


Building functionality using Drupal’s user interface


List of most popular user profiles based on number of guestbook entries 1

A view listing Profile nodes and sorts it based on the number of comments each has

1 2 5

Factor 0.1

10 20Factor 10

Factor 1


Building functionality using Drupal’s user interface

Developing new modules or themes


List of most popular user profiles based on number of guestbook entries 1

A view listing Profile nodes and sorts it based on the number of comments each has

Integrate user accounts with mailing list service provider 10

Write a module that POSTs the user’s email address to the provider’s REST API when the user registers.

50+

Estimating goo

http

://w

ww

.sxc

.hu/

phot

o/71

6594



TAKING UNCERTAINTY AND ERRORS INTO ACCOUNT

The cone of uncertainty

1.0x1.25x

0.8x0.67x

0.5x

0.25x

1.5x

2x

4x

Resolution of decisions in the course of a project

Estimate error


1.0x1.25x

0.8x0.67x

0.5x

0.25x

1.5x

2x

4x


1.0x1.25x

0.8x0.67x

0.5x

0.25x

1.5x

2x

4x

Rough idea0.25x - 4x


1.0x1.25x

0.8x0.67x

0.5x

0.25x

1.5x

2x

4x

Rough idea0.25x - 4x

User Interface Design Complete0.8x - 1.25x


1.0x1.25x

0.8x0.67x

0.5x

0.25x

1.5x

2x

4x


1.0x1.25x

0.8x0.67x

0.5x

0.25x

1.5x

2x

4x


1.0x1.25x

0.8x0.67x

0.5x

0.25x

1.5x

2x

4x

Logg utBli medlem Engagera digNyheter Aktiviteter Career Service Partners Reversen Om oss

Sök

Annonsera | Kontakta oss | In English

Maria Jakobsson | Min profil

Fritid, utbildning & framtidVi stoltserar idag med drygt 2 200 medlemmar och är därmed en av Uppsalas största studentföreningar. Vi intresserar oss för allt som rör fritid, framtid och studier för studenter med ekonomianknytning i Uppsala och jobbar ständigt för att på ett professionellt sätt utveckla både utbildningen och studiernas förankring till arbetslivet. Läs mer om oss

Bli medlem

"Detta är varför jag tycket du skall engagera dig!"

NAMN NAMNSSON, ORDF

KOMMANDE AKTIVITETER

Alla Fritid Framtid Studier

12/12 Luciabalen med grodornas aftonRestaurang Lantis, 17.45 - 01.00





Fler aktiviteter...

Meningsfull och rolig tillvaro vid sidan av studierna genom fester och events, sport, spel- och filmkvällar med mera

Täta kontakter och nära relationer med näringslivet genom föreläsningar, besök, casetävlingar, jobbannonser och informella möten

Bevakar och förbättrar utbildningen genom utvärdering och påverkan i nära samarbete med studenterna och universitet

SENASTE NYTT Fritid Framtid Studier

På ekonomikum just nu: KontaktdagarnaDen 2:a och 3:e februari är det äntligen dags för årets mest efterlängtade mässa med 60 företag och organisationer som kommer till Uppsala för att träffa dig! Kontaktdagarna är ett ypperligt tillfälle att knyta nya kontakter med intressanta företag och hämta inspiration på föreläsningar som hålls av inflytelserika personer. Mässan öppnar klockan 10 på onsdag den 2 februari. Var med redan från start!

Detta är en puffSveriges bästa nollning är i full gång i Uppsala och du hittar den här. > Läs mer

Detta är en puffSveriges bästa nollning är i full gång i Uppsala och du hittar den här. > Läs mer

Chaotic development

Requirements that weren’t investigated very well

Chaotic development


Poor coding practices cause extensive bug fixing

Chaotic development



Inexperienced personnel

Chaotic development




Incomplete or unskilled project planning

Chaotic development





Abandoning planning under pressure

Chaotic development






Developer gold-plating

Chaotic development






Developer gold-plating

Lack of automated source code control

Chaotic development

Overlooked activities

Overlooked activities

Migration of data

Producing help or documentation

Deployment

Working with a third party

Integrating third party systems

Overlooked expectations

Performance

Stability

Security

Usability

“You never have to fear that estimates created by developers will be too pessimistic, because developers will always generate a too-optimistic schedule.”

– Chris Peters, Microsoft Vice President

Unfounded optimism

Off-the-cuff estimation

Off-the-cuff estimation

Assume for clarity

Make an assumption and communicate it:

“I’m not sure what you mean by ‘integrated user bookmark blogging’ so I assume you mean this, and that’s what I’ve estimated.”

Avoid uncertain solutions

Avoid uncertain solutionsBase solutions on wireframes and mockups or comps if available.


Proposing well-tested solutions you have used before.



Researching solutions by googling, reading articles and blog posts.




Prototyping solutions in Drupal.




Prototyping solutions in Drupal.

Avoiding solutions that require integration with unknown third-party solutions.

Factoring in solution uncertainty

Degrees of experience

You have done the exact same thing in other projects.

Someone else at your company has done it in other projects.

You have read about it a way to solve it.

You can think of a solution that seems reasonable/possible.

You have no idea how to implement a solution.

Degrees of experience

5 You have done the exact same thing in other projects.

4Someone else at your company has done it in other

projects.

3 You have read about it a way to solve it.

2You can think of a solution that seems reasonable/

possible.

1 You have no idea how to implement a solution.

# Description Est Degree of Exp. Proposed solution

1 Nodetype: Link 1 5Create a node type called link and use the Link module for the link field.

2 Users add links which are unpublished before approved 2 4


3 Administrators are notified when links are added 5 3


4 Administrators can view and approve links 2 5


Degrees of experienceDeg. Description

5 You have done the exact same thing in other projects.

4 Someone else at your company has done it in other projects.

3 You have read about it a way to solve it.

2 You can think of a solution that seems reasonable/possible.

1 You have no idea how to implement a solution.

Degree of experienceDeg. Description Uncertainty factor

5You have done the exact same thing in other projects.

4Someone else at your company has done it in other projects.

3You have read about it a way to solve it.

2You can think of a solution that seems reasonable/possible.

1You have no idea how to implement a solution.































RESEARCH IT!







1.0x1.25x

0.8x0.67x

0.5x

0.25x

1.5x

2x

4x



0.8x - 1.25x


0.67x - 1.5x


0.5x - 2x


0.25x - 4x


-

# Description Est Degree of Exp. Range Low High Proposed solution

1 Nodetype: Link 1 5 1 × 0.8 = 0.81 × 1.25 = 1.25 0.8 1.25 Create a node type called link and use

the Link module for the link field.

2 Users add links which are unpublished before approved 2 4 2 × 0.67 = 1.34

2 × 1.5 = 3 1.34 3


3 Administrators are notified when links are added 5 3 5 × 0.5 = 2.5

5 × 2 = 10 2.5 10


4 Administrators can view and approve links 2 5 2 × 0.8 = 1.6

2 × 1.25 = 2.5 1.6 2.5






2 × 1.5 = 3 1.34 3



5 × 2 = 10 2.5 10



2 × 1.25 = 2.5 1.6 2.5






2 × 1.5 = 3 1.34 3



5 × 2 = 10 2.5 10



2 × 1.25 = 2.5 1.6 2.5






2 × 1.5 = 3 1.34 3



5 × 2 = 10 2.5 10



2 × 1.25 = 2.5 1.6 2.5


# Description Est Degree of

Range Low High Proposed solution




2 × 1.5 = 3 1.34 3



5 × 2 = 10 2.5 10


191 147 271

Summing up estimates






2 × 1.5 = 3 1.34 3



5 × 2 = 10 2.5 10


191 147 271

Summary of ideal estimates







2 × 1.5 = 3 1.34 3



5 × 2 = 10 2.5 10


191 147 271

Sum range high








2 × 1.5 = 3 1.34 3



5 × 2 = 10 2.5 10


191 147 271

Sum range high

Sum range low



Low uncertainty

Low0.8x

Idealestimate

High1.25x

Symmetrical uncertainty

Low High0.25x 4x

Idealestimate

High uncertainty


Asymmetrical uncertainty

Low High1x 4x

Idealestimate

Or: it can only get worse!

PessimisticPessimisticPessimisticPessimistic OptimisticOptimisticOptimistic

SymmetricalSymmetrical AsymmetricalAsymmetrical SymmetricalSymmetrical AsymmetricalAsymmetrical

1 0.17 6 1 6 0.67 1.5 1 1.5

2 0.25 4 1 4 0.71 1.4 1 1.4

3 0.5 2 1 2 0.77 1.3 1 1.3

4 0.67 1.5 1 1.5 0.83 1.2 1 1.2

5 0.8 1.25 1 1.25 0.91 1.1 1 1.1



1 0.17 6 1 6 0.67 1.5 1 1.5

2 0.25 4 1 4 0.71 1.4 1 1.4

3 0.5 2 1 2 0.77 1.3 1 1.3

4 0.67 1.5 1 1.5 0.83 1.2 1 1.2

5 0.8 1.25 1 1.25 0.91 1.1 1 1.1



1 0.17 6 1 6 0.67 1.5 1 1.5

2 0.25 4 1 4 0.71 1.4 1 1.4

3 0.5 2 1 2 0.77 1.3 1 1.3

4 0.67 1.5 1 1.5 0.83 1.2 1 1.2

5 0.8 1.25 1 1.25 0.91 1.1 1 1.1



1 0.17 6 1 6 0.67 1.5 1 1.5

2 0.25 4 1 4 0.71 1.4 1 1.4

3 0.5 2 1 2 0.77 1.3 1 1.3

4 0.67 1.5 1 1.5 0.83 1.2 1 1.2

5 0.8 1.25 1 1.25 0.91 1.1 1 1.1




1 0.17 6 1 6 0.67 1.5 1 1.5

2 0.25 4 1 4 0.71 1.4 1 1.4

3 0.5 2 1 2 0.77 1.3 1 1.3

4 0.67 1.5 1 1.5 0.83 1.2 1 1.2

5 0.8 1.25 1 1.25 0.91 1.1 1 1.1

Asymmetrical uncertainty

Use the UncertaintyFactors tab in your sheet to set factors and symmetry

Copy the above values into the APPLIED columns to

work with asymmetrical uncertainty

It's easy to estimate what you know.

It's hard to estimate what you know you don't know.

It's very hard to estimate things that you don't know you don't know.

In the end

Overhead time

Administration and project management 1.25x

Testing 1.15x

COMPARE WITH GUESSTIMATE

??? hours

Start big, reduce later

Awareness of time

Culture

If unsure, ask an expert

Recommended reading

What did you think?Locate this session on the DCC website:http://go.nodeone.se/estimates

Click the “Take the Survey” link.

Contact [email protected]









Technology

Getting Early Estimates Right, DrupalCon Chicago 2011