Upload
studiesfree
View
362
Download
1
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Citation preview
FCBARCELONA
A vision of the football industry and the case of the
FC Barcelona
February 2006
http://migre.me/eohac
Page 2
http://migre.me/eohac
The football industry: The last 10 years
Current challenges
FCB Revolution 2003-2005
The next decade
INDEX
http://migre.me/eohac
Page 3
http://migre.me/eohac
THE INDUSTRY IN THE LAST 10 YEARS
Extraordinary growth. Between 10% and 25% annually…- Stadium development- Broadcasting deregulation- Marketing revenue
… and a major change in the business model…- From clubs as organizers of local events (like a circus) to global
entertainment companies (like Walt Disney)
… that could “break” the industry in two segments: big global clubs and smaller local ones
- The change benefits big clubs that can capture the growth and become global franchises and powerful brands
http://migre.me/eohac
Page 4
http://migre.me/eohac
CLUBS REVENUE GROWTH
Extraordinary growth... With lessons learned and challenges ahead.
Extraordinary growth... With lessons learned and challenges ahead.
Chelsea +17% +28%
R.Madrid +13% +20%
FCBARCELONA +16% +30%
22
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
1992/3 1993/4 1994/5 1995/6 1996/7 1997/98 1998/99 1999/00 2000/01 2001/02 2002/03 2003/4
Tottenham +12% +4%
CAGR 03-0598-05Million €
Realstatedeal New
owner
22 24 2936
48
6577 81
100 96 98104
129135
169180
210
25
234251
246
259
6268
49
25
8775
119
169
208
123139
110
85
58
116
164
276
236
193
152
138
116
€
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
1992/3 1993/4 1994/5 1995/6 1996/7 1997/98 1998/99 1999/00 2000/01 2001/02 2002/03 2003/4 2004/5
73
121118
217
143
90
134
221
M.United (Est.) +9% -1%
http://migre.me/eohac
Page 5
http://migre.me/eohac
SOURCES OF REVENUE: 6 BIGGEST CLUBS · 2004/05
72,2 55,1
82,2
124,0
62,8
71,782,0
138,0124,4
88,0
79,0
102,583,7
63,7
66,1
57,9
22,838,1
Marketing Media Matchday
Million €
(42%)
(29%)
(29%)
(38%)
(37%)
(25%)
(16%)
(59%)
(25%)
(10%)
(54%)
(36%)
(23%)
(32%)
(45%)
(32%)
(38%)
(30%)
Machester Utd. Chelsea FC AC Milan Juventus R. Madrid FC Barcelona
246
221234 229
275,7
208
http://migre.me/eohac
Page 6
http://migre.me/eohac
COSTS
Source: ladbrokes.com, 01.08.05Source: eurobet.com, 01.08.05As in all other professional sports, managing player’s compensation is the major cost challenge.
As in all other professional sports, managing player’s compensation is the major cost challenge.
Player salaries are the highest costs
G-14 recommends that salaries have to be between 55% and 70% of revenues
Salaries have increased spectacularly in the last 5 years... But are now more stable
Amortizations depend on transfer prices, that had its highest in the season 2001-02
Operational costs have to be tightly controlled in a professional manner
Player salaries
Transfer amortization
Operational costs
http://migre.me/eohac
Page 7
http://migre.me/eohac
PROFIT & LOSS: 6 BIGGEST CLUBS · 2004/05
221234
276
208
34
-13
18
246229
-9 -24
Million €
OPERATION REVENUES
OPERATION EXPENSES
OPERATION PROFIT/LOSS
TOTAL PROFIT/LOSS(1)
(1) Operation profit/loss +/- financial +/- extraordinary results.
Machester Utd.
221
230
-9
-207
234
N.A.
N.A.
N.A.
229
243
-13
-3
276
300
-24
+2
208
190
+18
+37
246
212
+34
+15
Chelsea FC AC Milan Juventus R. Madrid FC Barcelona
http://migre.me/eohac
Page 8
http://migre.me/eohac
STRONG RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN SALARIES PAIDAND SUCCESS ON THE PITCH…
Relative Salaries
Ranking
0,25
0,5
1
2
4
Rotherham United
Reading
Preston
Plymouth
Arsenal
Aston Villa
Barnsley
Birmingham City
Bolton Wanderers
Brentford
Bristol Rovers
Bury
Derby
Leeds
Leicester
Liverpool
Manchester United
Newcastle
Scunthorpe United
Sheffield United
Sheffield Wednesday
Shrewsbury
Southampton
Southend
Tottenham
Wrexham
R2 = 0,94
1 320,50,25
RELATIONSHIP SALARIES - SUCCESS
(UK 1990-1999; LOGARITMIC
SCALE)
Best players, paid at market price will win championships
Source: S. Szymanski & T, kuypers, Deloitte, Estim&Co.
http://migre.me/eohac
Page 9
http://migre.me/eohac
… BEST PLAYERS CAN ONLY BE PAID BY THE BIGGEST CLUBS
Source: ladbrokes.com, 01.08.05Source: eurobet.com, 01.08.05
Club size matters.Club size matters.
Source: Szymanski, Deloitte & Touche FIT, Estin & Co.
RELATIONSHIP SALARIES - REVENUES
(UK 1990-1999; BASE 100
LOGARITMIC SCALE)
Salaries (% of revenues)
Revenues
(average1990-1999)
RotherhamReading
Preston
Plymouth
ArsenalAston Villa
BarnsleyBirmingham
Blackburn Rovers
Bolton Wanderers
Brentford
Burnley
Bury
Cambridge
Coventry
Derby
Everton
Huddersfield
Leeds
Leicester
Liverpool
Manchester United
Newcastle
Oldham
Peterborough
ScunthorpeSheffield United
Sheffield Wednesday
Southampton
Southend
Tottenham
WBA
West Ham
Wrexham
40%
60%
80%
100%
12,5 25 50 100 200 400
30%
50%
70%
90%
Safe zone salaries are
less than 55% of revenues
http://migre.me/eohac
Page 10
http://migre.me/eohac
The football industry: The last 10 years
Current challenges
FCB Revolution 2003-2005
The next decade
INDEX
http://migre.me/eohac
Page 11
http://migre.me/eohac
CURRENT CHALLENGES
“Product management”: Players and team performance
Revenue growth and globalization
Cost control and value chain management
Industry organization and regulation
http://migre.me/eohac
Page 12
http://migre.me/eohac
CURRENT CHALLENGES
“Product management”: Players and team performance
Revenue growth and globalization
Cost control and value chain management
Industry organization and regulation
Balance of TEAM PERFORMANCE vs. STAR PLAYERS- Chelsea / Liverpool vs. Real Madrid
Balance of RESULTS vs. ATTRACTIVENESS OF PLAY- Chelsea vs. FC Barcelona
MANAGEMENT OF TRANSFER MARKET- Less star players in the market (“Not for sale”)- Commercial value vs. Sporting Value- Best and worst practices
Example: Recent transfers of 20 million or more in Spain Ronaldinho, Eto’o, Deco (FC Barcelona) Beckham, Samuel, Woodgate, Robinho, Ramos, Baptista
(R.Madrid) YOUTH TALENT DEVELOPMENT
- High investment in schools and youth teams- Fierce competition to hire young players
http://migre.me/eohac
Page 13
http://migre.me/eohac
CURRENT CHALLENGES
“Product management”: Players and team performance
Revenue growth and globalization
Cost control and value chain management
Industry organization and regulation
Development of new sources of growth beyond Europe. Globalization of Brands- Markets
Asia, US…- Business model
Tours, schools, clubs- Content of the brand, positioning
“The theater of dreams” (MANUTD), “the galactics” (Madrid), “more than a club” (FCBARCELONA)
The role of players- Execution
Infrastructure, management, control, communication…
http://migre.me/eohac
Page 14
http://migre.me/eohac
CURRENT CHALLENGES
“Product management”: Players and team performance
Revenue growth and globalization
Cost control and value chain management
Industry organization and regulation
Players compensation- Fixed salaries and bonuses
Transfer prices Agents New owners
- Inflation, market disturbances
http://migre.me/eohac
Page 15
http://migre.me/eohac
CURRENT CHALLENGES
“Product management”: Players and team performance
Revenue growth and globalization
Cost control and value chain management
Industry organization and regulation
FIFA / UEFA / National Associations / Leagues / G-14 / Clubs Calendar, release of international players, revenue
distribution… The “Charleroi Case”
http://migre.me/eohac
Page 16
http://migre.me/eohac
The football industry: The last 10 years
Current challenges
FCB Revolution 2003-2005
The next decade
INDEX
http://migre.me/eohac
Page 17
http://migre.me/eohac
THE STARTING POINT AND THE STRATEGIC ALTERNATIVES
STRATEGIC ALTERNATIVE 1 EVOLUTION
SEASON 2002 / 2003
Revenues of 123M- Number 12th in global ranking
Losses of 73m
Debt of 186m
Team is 6th in the Spanish Championship
Drastic reduction of expenses
Very moderate investment for 2/3 years
Less economic risk but higher market and sporting risk
STRATEGIC ALTERNATIVE 2REVOLUTION: “THE VIRTUOS CIRCLE”
High investment in the team to generate immediate results and revenues
Fast expenses reduction. 0 losses year 1
Accelerate / investment and business plan in year 2 to get results faster
Higher financial risk but less market and sporting risk
http://migre.me/eohac
Page 18
http://migre.me/eohac
THE ACCELERATED “VIRTUOS CIRCLE”
123
240
208
169
139
110
203
191
163
123
2000/1 2001/2 2002/3 2003/4 2004/5 2005/6
Million €Revenues
Reality
June 2003Business plan
http://migre.me/eohac
Page 19
http://migre.me/eohac
EXTRAORDINARY GROWTH… IN ALL ASPECTS
TOTAL REVENUES WEB TRAFFIC TRIPPLED 30,000 NEW MEMBERS
TV REVENUES +30% GLOBAL TV VIEWERSHIP
7,3 4,5 4,1 0,4
25,3 34,347,6
69,3
42,6
67,2
81,1
87,7
37,3
50,5
61,7
68,5
10,9
12,7
13,4
14,3
02/03 03/04 04/05 05/06
+23%
169,2
207,9
Member-ships
Stadium
Media
Marketing
Others
+47%
+8%
+11%
+7%
+16% 240,2
-90%
+39%
+21%
+22%
+6%
-9%
105000
135.000
50000
75000
100000
125000
150000
jun-03 jan-06
67.200
87.700
0
50.000
100.000
02-03 04-05
‘000 page views ‘000 unique visitors
members
‘000 €
0
5.000
10.000
15.000
20.000
25.000
sep-
03 nov
gen-
04 mar
mai ju
l
sep
nov-
04
ene-
05
mar
-05
may
-05
jul-0
5
0
200
400
600
800
1.000
1.200
1.400
1.600
23%
77%
SpainRest of world
FCB – Madrid is viewed by120 million people
+37%
+33%
+58%
+35%
+16%
-44%
http://migre.me/eohac
Page 20
http://migre.me/eohac
MANAGING COSTS…
109,3
85,295,6
123,1
240,2
207,9
169,2
123,4
0
50
100
150
200
250
2002 / 2003 2003 / 2004 2004 / 2005 2005 / 2006
0%
50%
100%
88%
50%46%
51%
RevenuesSalaries (football + other sports)Salaries / Revenues
70%
55%
Maximumrecommended
Optimal
EVOLUTION OF PLAYER COSTS
FIXED
64%
INDIVIDUALBONUS
18%
TEAMBONUS
18%
SALARY STRUCTURE
http://migre.me/eohac
Page 21
http://migre.me/eohac
… AND OBTAINING PROFITS
8775
85
119 110
139123
169
208
240
6
-15 -14
10
-38 -45-72
6,718 19
96/97 97/98 98/99 99/00 00/01 01/02 02/03 03/04 04/0505/06
(estimated)
Revenues
Profit / Loss
The Club consolidates its revenue growth with a cost structure that produces profits in a sustainable way.
The Club consolidates its revenue growth with a cost structure that produces profits in a sustainable way.
http://migre.me/eohac
Page 22
http://migre.me/eohac
Revenues of 123M Number 12th in global ranking
Losses of 73m
Debt of 186m
Team is 6th in the Spanish League
240m revenues
Among 5 highest in the ranking
Profit 19m
Debt of 150m
Team won Spanish Championship 2004/2005
THE TRANSFORMATION
WE WERE IN 2002 / 2003
- Valdés- Puyol- Gabri- Xavi- Jorquera- Motta- Iniesta- Navarro- Saviola
- Kluivert- Overmars- Mendieta- Anderson- Christanval- Rochemback- Riquelme- Sorin- Bonano- Enke- Geovani- Dani- Frank de Boer
WE ARE IN 2005 / 2006
- Valdés- Puyol- Gabri- Xavi- Oleguer- Jorquera- Motta- Iniesta- Messi- Ruben- Saviola
- Ronaldinho- Eto’o- Deco- Edmilson- Giuly- Belleti- Gio- Márquez- Silvinho- Maxi- Larsson- V.Bommel- Ezquerro- Damià
Net investment in
players
98m
Profit + amortizations
99m
Real state investment
38m
Real state sold
28m
The club achieved its transformation self-financingits growth.
The club achieved its transformation self-financingits growth.
http://migre.me/eohac
Page 23
http://migre.me/eohac
The football industry: The last 10 years
Current challenges
FCB Revolution 2003-2005
The next decade
INDEX
http://migre.me/eohac
Page 24
http://migre.me/eohac
THE NEXT DECADE WILL BE ABOUT…
Globalization Development of Asia and US markets Soccer global ubiquity thru “media play”
(TV, IP-TV, web, mobiles, ...) Top clubs positioned as global brands
(media, international leagues, tours, ...) Star players as global icons / characters
Clubs and players will promote proximity to the fans - Schools, Tours, Humanitarian actions
Soccer will continue to be the most popular collective sport to be played
… whilebeing closer
to people
Furtherglobalizationand growth…
http://migre.me/eohac
Page 25
http://migre.me/eohac
KEY SUCCESS FACTORS FOR CLUBS OVER NEXT YEARS?
CLUBS KEY SUCCESS FACTORS OVER THE NEXT DECADE
Attractive game
Sportingsuccess
Governance & management
Club’s cityimage
Fan baseattraction
Globalaudience
Players’image
Financial size& strength
SOCIAL &
COMMERCIAL
FACTORS
MA
NA
GE
RIA
L
FAC
TOR
S
SPORTING FACTORS
In a globalized world few,
clubs will be competing for
a global market
http://migre.me/eohac
Page 26
http://migre.me/eohac
FCBARCELONA IS ALREADY WELL POSITIONED TO BE ONE OF THE LEADING CLUBS IN THE NEXT DECADE
Ronaldinho as main global icon - Deco, Eto’o, Marquez and Messi follow suit
7 distinct nationalities. 3 continents represented
Global TV coverage of Champions League
Room for improvement of “La Liga” TV coverage
BarçaTV growing international penetration
Vast coverage on web and print media
#1 club in members and fan base within the young segment
Most attended games in international tours
Identification with key players
“Fashion” and “tourism” strong statements
City that stands for peace, civism and solidarity
Already in the top 6 clubs in revenue size, and growing
Democratic election system to Board guarantees good governance
Management achieved excellent results in last 2 years
57 main trophies Current Liga champion Ronaldinho, Eto’o, Deco and Messi
accumulating individual prizes last 2 years
Unique offensive and spectacular game recognized worldwide
Young and talented player squad guarantees pitch entertainment over next years
Attractive game
Sportingsuccess
Governance & management
Club’s cityimage
Fan baseattraction
Globalaudience
Players’image
Financial size& strength
4
4
4
3
4
3
3
3