31
Computer Science and Engineering Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks Kai Li * , Mustafa ̇Ilhan Akbas , Damla Turgut , Salil S. Kanhere * , and Sanjay Jha * * School of Computer Science & Engineering, The University of New South Wales Department of Electrical Engineering & Computer Science, University of Central Florida Monday, 24 March 14

Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Aerial wireless sensor and actor networks are composed of multiple unmanned aerial vehicles. An actor node in the network has the capabilities of both acting on the environment and also performing networking functionalities for sensor nodes. Thus, positioning of actors is critical for the efficient data collection. In this study, we propose an actor positioning strategy, which utilizes a hybrid antenna model that combines the complimentary features of an isotropic omni radio and directional antennas. We present a distributed algorithm for fast neighbor discovery with the hybrid antenna. The omni module of the hybrid antenna is used to form a self organizing network and the directional module is used for reliable data transmission. Extensive simulations show that our protocol improves the packet reception ratio by up to 50% compared to omnidirectional antenna. Moreover, the network reorganization delay is also reduced. The tradeoff between coverage and reorganization delay is also illustrated.

Citation preview

Page 1: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

Computer Science and Engineering

Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

Kai Li*, Mustafa ̇Ilhan Akbas†, Damla Turgut†, Salil S. Kanhere*, and Sanjay Jha*

*School of Computer Science & Engineering,The University of New South Wales

†Department of Electrical Engineering & Computer Science, University of Central Florida

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 2: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Outline

✦ Research Background

✦ Challenges

✦ Flight and Antenna Model

✦ Communications with the Antenna Model

✦ Performance Evaluation

✦ Conclusion

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 3: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks (AWSANs)

✦ Applications~ Fire detection and extinguishing missions.~ Remote sensing for farm monitoring.~ Toxic plume observation or atmospheric sensing.

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 4: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks (AWSANs)

✦ Applications~ Fire detection and extinguishing missions.~ Remote sensing for farm monitoring.~ Toxic plume observation or atmospheric sensing.

Target area

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 5: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks (AWSANs)

✦ Applications~ Fire detection and extinguishing missions.~ Remote sensing for farm monitoring.~ Toxic plume observation or atmospheric sensing.

Various types of sensors like visual, thermal, etc.

Target area

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 6: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Positioning in AWSANs

✦ 2-D positioning strategies become NP-Hard in 3-D space.

✦ For dynamic positioning of the actors in 3-D space with local communication.

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 7: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Positioning in AWSANs

✦ 2-D positioning strategies become NP-Hard in 3-D space.

✦ For dynamic positioning of the actors in 3-D space with local communication.

✦ The previous work: APAWSAN which adopts VSEPR theory was proposed to build a self-configuring dynamic network architecture.

~ Akbas, Mustafa Ilhan, and Damla Turgut. "APAWSAN: Actor positioning for aerial wireless sensor and actor networks." Local Computer Networks (LCN), 2011 IEEE 36th Conference on. IEEE, 2011.

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 8: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Outline

✦ Research Background

✦ Challenges

✦ Flight and Antenna Model

✦ Communications with the Antenna Model

✦ Performance Evaluation

✦ Conclusion

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 9: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Challenges on Communications in AWSANs

✦ For the coverage:

✦ The proposed strategy must provide high connectivity and coverage.

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 10: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Challenges on Communications in AWSANs

✦ For the coverage:

✦ The proposed strategy must provide high connectivity and coverage.

✦ For the communications:

✦ In real-world 3-D scenarios, the positioning strategy is adapted to

~ a quick neighbor discovery during flight in 3-D space

~ varying signal strength which depends on the antenna orientation

~ reorganization requirements in case of topology changes

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 11: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Outline

✦ Research Background

✦ Challenges

✦ Flight and Antenna Model

✦ Communications with the Antenna Model

✦ Performance Evaluation

✦ Conclusion

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 12: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Aerial Positioning Model✦ The positioning strategy preserves 1-hop connectivity between each actor and the sink by using the Valence Shell Electron Pair Repulsion (VSEPR) theory.

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 13: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Aerial Positioning Model✦ The positioning strategy preserves 1-hop connectivity between each actor and the sink by using the Valence Shell Electron Pair Repulsion (VSEPR) theory.

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 14: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Aerial Positioning Algorithm

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 15: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Aerial Positioning Algorithm

✦ Assume spherical transmission and reception ranges with identical RSSI and loss rates at every communication angle.

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 16: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Aerial Positioning Algorithm

✦ Assume spherical transmission and reception ranges with identical RSSI and loss rates at every communication angle.

Not true in real AWSAN!

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 17: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Hybrid Antenna Model

~ Li, Kai, et al. "Reliable communications in aerial sensor networks by using a hybrid antenna." Local Computer Networks (LCN), 2012 IEEE 37th Conference on. IEEE, 2012.

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 18: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Hybrid Antenna Model✦ O-BESPAR antenna model leverages the complementary properties of omnidirectional and directional antennas.

✦ Omni module: 360 degrees coverage.

✦ Directional module: non-interference transmissions.

~ Li, Kai, et al. "Reliable communications in aerial sensor networks by using a hybrid antenna." Local Computer Networks (LCN), 2012 IEEE 37th Conference on. IEEE, 2012.

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 19: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Outline

✦ Research Background

✦ Challenges

✦ Flight and Antenna Model

✦ Communications with the Antenna Model

✦ Performance Evaluation

✦ Conclusion

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 20: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Communication and Rearrangement Protocols

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 21: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Communication and Rearrangement Protocols

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 22: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Outline

✦ Research Background

✦ Challenges

✦ Flight and Antenna Model

✦ Communications with the Antenna Model

✦ Performance Evaluation

✦ Conclusion

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 23: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Simulation Configurations✦ 30 UAVs in the simulation, 2 ~ 8 actors and 1 sink.

✦ The target area size is 1000m×1000m. The simulation time is set to 15 minutes and the flying speed of actor and sink is 1 m/s.

✦ Each UAV includes a queue of 50 packets. Five beacons per second are sent out by the actor to search for the sink.

✦ Performance metrics: ~ packet reception ratio (PRR)

~ actors’ reorganization delay

✦ RSSI are evaluated to show the efficiency of the algorithm.

✦ The relationship between RSSI and coverage.

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 24: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

PRR in Different Geometries

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 840

45

50

55

60

Number of actor UAVsPR

R a

t Sin

k U

AV(

%)

Actor1Actor2Actor3Actor4Actor5Actor6Actor7Actor8

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 895

96

97

98

99

100

Number of actor UAVs

PRR

at S

ink

UA

V(%

)

Actor1Actor2Actor3Actor4Actor5Actor6Actor7Actor8

Omnidirectional antenna

O-BESPAR antenna

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 25: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Reorganization Time Delay

2 3 4 5 6 7 8

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

Number of actor UAVs

Tim

e (s

ec)

O−BESPAR AntennaOmni Antenna

✦ Reorganization: The actor-sink link is prone to failure due to flying path dynamics and interference. Then the sink repositions actors and updates the geometry for a better coverage.

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 26: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Antenna Orientation and Coverage✦ Orientation of omni antenna module causes poor RSSI which decreases PRR at some positions.

✦ The loss of beacon messages increases reorganization time delay of UAVs.

8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 −80

−70

−60

−50

−40

−30

−20

−10

0

The number of actor UAVs

RSS

I(dbm

)

Actor No.8Actor No.7Actor No.6Actor No.5Actor No.4Actor No.3Actor No.2Actor No.1

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 27: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Coverage Values of Geometry Flight✦ When the actors fly closer to the sink, the coverage of network is changed.

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 28: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Outline

✦ Research Background

✦ Challenges

✦ Flight and Antenna Model

✦ Communications with the Antenna Model

✦ Performance Evaluation

✦ Conclusion

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 29: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Conclusion✦ This work

~ Apply the actor positioning strategy to real-world scenarios by utilizing hybrid antenna (O-BESPAR).

~ Use VSEPR theory to form the geometries of UAVs.

~ Propose communication and rearrangement protocols.

~ Evaluate the positioning strategy with antenna model by packet reception rate and actors’ reorganization delay.

~ Discuss the effect of antenna orientation on the coverage.

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 30: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Thank You!

Kai LiPhD student

Email: [email protected]

Monday, 24 March 14

Page 31: Reliable Positioning with Hybrid Antenna Model for Aerial Wireless Sensor and Actor Networks

School of Computer Science and Engineering

Blank Page

Monday, 24 March 14