Upload
venturespec
View
197
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Implications of 4G Deployments Presentation representing the MEF Metro Ethernet Forum MPLS World Congress Ethernet Wholesale Summit Paris 2010
Citation preview
1
Implications of 4G Deployments MEF Workshop – Carrier Ethernet for Mobile Backhaul A presentation for “Ethernet Wholesale Summit 2010”
January 2010
Presented by Javier E. Gonzalez
MEF Representative
2
Market Analysis, Scale and Trends
– Current trends in backhaul deployments – Growth drivers and challenges worldwide – Packet-based backhaul cost advantage analysis – Implications of 4G (WiMAX, LTE) deployments
3
Market Analysis, Scale and Trends
– Packet-based backhaul cost advantage analysis – Implications of 4G deployments
• Backhaul market drivers + What’s driving 4G ? • Economics of 4G Networks • Carrier Ethernet for 4G solutions
4
Packet-based backhaul cost advantage analysis The Carrier Ethernet Backhaul Economic Driver
TDM backhaul for 4G is costly and unreliable • Monthly TDM cost per tower for 10Mbps ~ $20K.
4G builds are capital intensive • Fiber and microwave costs require significant
investment ($20-$50K per tower) • Existing tree topologies are cost-inefficient • Leased services can balance the CAPEX load
5
Implications of LTE Deployments Backhaul Market Drivers
Increased bursty data traffic and streaming video • User Interface Improvements • Additional cell sites, devices, and increased b/w (10-100x) • Wildly varying traffic patterns Rapid deployment is a must • First to market captures market share (WiMax has a 2-3 yr.
lead over LTE) • Rapid construction requires multiple strategies for backhaul
deployment (self-build, lease)
6
Economics of 4G networks
Mobile backhaul is a COST issue!
Carrier Ethernet Backhaul Bends the Curve.
7
Keys to Profitable Ethernet Services
• Bandwidth Control – Flexible, granular service definitions
• Scalability – Wide area coverage with simple, repeatable service
tagging
• Flexible Interworking – Cost optimize the right technologies in the right place
• Resilience – Robust service protection, high availability
• Manageability – Clear diagnostics, service level agreement
• Low Touch Operations – Time to service = time to revenue with lower OpEx
Raise Revenues
With Differentiated
Services
Improve Service
Margins via Lowered
Costs
Profitability!
8
Carrier Ethernet for 4G Operators need Ethernet for:
– Greenfield WiMax deployments • Opportunities limited today but increasing • All eyes on successful deployments (Clearwire/Xohm)
– ATM 3G Leapfrogs • Developing world operators slow to adopt 3G technology
– Wireline Wholesalers • May have separate PWE3 requirements (e.g. ATT, BT)
– 4G deployments (2-3 yrs from now) • Evolution to LTE from GSM/UMTS family à 88% of market • Key is to commence now during transition from TDM to Packet
• Ethernet + T1/E1 – Combined Ethernet + T1/E1 (ATM & TDM) over Ethernet backhaul – Represent roughly 80-90% of today’s MWB
9
4G (WiMAX) Transport Requirements
– Stable, redundant architecture – Comprehensive management/provisioning system – Optimized network utilization – Scalability in MAC addresses, customers, sites – Point-to-point and multipoint service models – Microwave friendly – Flexible “Best Practices” design – MPLS / PBB-TE / VLAN (QinQ)
10
4G (WiMAX) Transport Challenges • Operators require a solution that provides:
– Scalability: Scalable MACs & customers • Directly at tower site - no MAC learning network between towers
– Reliability: Redundancy & rapid restoration • Dedicated Primary & Back-up tunnels from each tower with rapid
restoration – Predictable QoS: Strict Priority settings
• Committed & Excess Information Rates per service – Bandwidth Utilization: Efficient use of network resources
• Bandwidth engineering, no automatic path disabling for loop prevention (STP)
– Simplified Provisioning: Reduce complexity • Provisioning wizards with GUI interface for service creation
– Management: Comprehensive OAM capabilities • Service assurance, Fault-Config-Performance Mgmt (802.1ag, 802.3ah, Y.
1731) – Cost Effective: Economies of Scale of Carrier Ethernet
• Advantages of a Layer-2 Carrier Ethernet architecture • Minimize costly Layer-3 devices at head-end.
11
Carrier Ethernet OAM
Customer Domain
Provider Domain
Operator Domain Operator Domain
Eth Access MPLS Access
Customer CustomerService Provider
MPLS Domain MPLS Domain
PW/MPLS OAM
Service OAM
MEPMIP
Operator Domain
MPLS Core
Network OAM
IEEE 802.1ag CFM Connectivity Fault Management
Operations, Administration, and Maintenance offering enables service providers to use cost-effective Ethernet networks as the means to reliably deliver high-bandwidth, profitable, retail and wholesale services.
IETF RFC 5357 TWAMP Two-Way Active Measurement Protocol
Layer 2 SLA Monitoring & Metrics: Delay, Jitter, Frame Loss ITU-T Y.1731 Ethernet OAM
Enhanced troubleshooting, rapid network discovery IEEE 802.3ah EFM
Service Heartbeats, End-to-End & Hop-by-Hop fault detection
Layer 3 SLA Monitoring & Metrics: Delay, Jitter
• SLA Assurance • Rapid Fault Isolation • Minimized Downtime
12
Key drivers for Carrier Ethernet Solutions Ethernet is Carrier Class & Cost Less
– Universally accepted that Ethernet is less expensive and ubiquitous technology – By 2008, 89% of providers believed that Carrier Ethernet is mature enough for
“carrier class” deployments – Solid Ethernet OAM features that provide a comfort factor for providers (SDH like
characteristics) – Connection oriented Ethernet (COE) solutions provide deterministic & resilient
services (VLANs, PBB-TE, etc..)
Enterprises & Providers want Ethernet – Reported growth in the Ethernet services revenue ($14.9B in 2008 to $19.9B in 2011) – Service Providers have lowered the price per bit for Ethernet services, making it
more attractive than legacy services (TDM, ATM, etc…) Ethernet is integral to Network Transition
– Ethernet is the key component to many NGN packet network transformations – COE is well-placed to replace legacy SDH applications – Evolution of 40G and 100G are being driven by data centre applications and are
complimentary to Optical networks
Source: Infonetics Research
13
Advantages of Carrier Ethernet
Advantage Benefits Cost-
Effective Ø Capex: Ethernet Economics Ø Opex: Provisioning, Fault Resolution, Network
Engineering
Simple Ø Flexible network topologies Ø Avoids L3 routing complexity Ø Transparent regarding IPv4, IPv6, IPSec
Secure Ø No network-layer attacks Ø No misconfigured Access Control Lists (ACLs) Ø Inherent security of L2 EVCs
Carrier-Class
Ø Resilient Ø Ethernet OAM Ø Deterministic “SONET/SDH-like” Ø Convergence with business and residential traffic
14
… further challenges Packet bandwidth consumption continues to grow….
But revenue growth is slowing
2004 2006 2008 2010
10%
20%
30%
41%
3% 7%
13% 13%
-5% -3% -1% 4%
Broadband
Wireless
Wireline
**
** Sources: Yankee Group and Pyramid Research
15
IP-Ethernet Mobile Backhaul: Preparing for LTE
February 9 MEF Workshop - Carrier Ethernet for Mobile Backhaul Tuesday, 0915-1000 - Market Analysis, Scale, and Trends
Presented by
Michael Howard Co-founder and Principal Analyst, Carrier and Data Center Networking
Infonetics Research
16 Copyright © 2009 Infonetics Research, Inc.
16
Today’s Speaker
Michael Howard Principal Analyst and Co-founder
17 Copyright © 2009 Infonetics Research, Inc.
17
• Social changes under way, unabated mobile subscriber growth will prompt 95% of operators to migrate to LTE
• …Creating mobile backhaul challenges – Mobile subs and their bandwidth grow strongly; ARPU cannot
– Data and video traffic growing fast
– Multiple operators at cell site; transport provider wants single backhaul
– WiMAX, LTE coming; need to prepare for IP/Ethernet backhaul
• Operators must go to packet backhaul • Operators need OAM&P and service assurance now • Conclusions and Q&A
Agenda
18 Copyright © 2009 Infonetics Research, Inc.
18
Social changes underway…
• Social phenomena: consumer, business – Connected, competitive world
• Anytime, anywhere connections • More bandwidth, mobile broadband • Confluence of fixed/mobile, wireless/wireline
– Video inserted into most applications, so traffic never stops growing
19 Copyright © 2009 Infonetics Research, Inc.
19
…Causing unabated mobile subscriber growth
Source: Fixed and Mobile Subscribers Annual Worldwide Market Forecasts, March 2008
5.2
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
Bill
ions
CY06 CY07 CY08 CY09 CY10 CY11
Worldwide Mobile Subscribers
20 Copyright © 2009 Infonetics Research, Inc.
20
Backhaul connections are growing quickly
• Connections and bandwidth per connection drive equipment spending; adding 100,000s of new connections per year
• Mobile operators pay incremental charges for 2x to 10x bandwidth – Ethernet options solve costs—but need service assurance, OAM&P tools
Source: Mobile Backhaul Equipment, Installed Base, and Services, May 2009
0
1,000
2,000
3,000
4,000
5,000
6,000
Con
nect
ions
(K)
CY07 CY08 CY09 CY10 CY11 CY12 CY13
Worldwide Mobile Backhaul ConnectionsL Installed vs New
Installed connectionsNew connections
21 Copyright © 2009 Infonetics Research, Inc.
21
…And data dramatically increases traffic load
Operators rolling out increased capacities via EDGE, EV-DO, HSPA, WiMAX, then LTE
0
10
20
30
40TB
Oct-06 Jan-07 Apr-07 Jul-07 Oct-07 Jan-08 Apr-08 Jul-08 Oct-08 Jan-09 Apr-09 Jul-09
JRA 09 .0 9.2 00 9
0
10
20
30
40TB
Oct-06 Jan-07 Apr-07 Jul-07 Oct-07 Jan-08 Apr-08 Jul-08 Oct-08 Jan-09 Apr-09 Jul-09
JRA 09 .0 9.2 00 9
Live network KPI dataOperators: 9 Europe, 4 APAC, 6 Americas
Average Y-Y growth over 500%
Total HSDPA Traffic per DaySource: Nokia Siemens Networks
22 Copyright © 2009 Infonetics Research, Inc.
22
3 stages of IP/Ethernet backhaul for LTE
• IP/Ethernet backhaul solves ARPU-traffic disconnect today and backhaul problem for HSPA today…and LTE tomorrow
2G BTS
3G NodeB
E1/T1
RNC
BSCPDH
Backhaul
2G BTS
3G NodeB
E1/T1
RNC
BSCHybrid/Dual
Backhaul
2G BTS3G NodeB
RNC
BSCAll
IP/Ethernet
Ethernet
EthernetInternetGateway
LTE eNodeB
2G BTS
3G NodeB
E1/T1E1/T1
RNC
BSCPDH
BackhaulPDH
Backhaul
2G BTS
3G NodeB
E1/T1E1/T1
RNC
BSCHybrid/Dual
BackhaulHybrid/Dual
Backhaul
2G BTS3G NodeB
RNC
BSCAll
IP/EthernetAll
IP/Ethernet
Ethernet
EthernetInternetGateway
LTE eNodeB
23 Copyright © 2009 Infonetics Research, Inc.
23
Operators already moving to IP/Ethernet backhaul
40%
80%
100%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Perc
ent o
f Res
pond
ents
2008 or before By 2009 By 2010
Year Deployed
• From Infonetics’ August 2009 IP/Ethernet in Mobile Backhaul Networks: Global Service Provider Survey
• OAM&P and service assurance tools needed • Major investments in staffing/operations, procedures changes
– Rich IP/Ethernet options very complex compared to TDM circuits
24 Copyright © 2009 Infonetics Research, Inc.
24
Many triggers for IP/Ethernet backhaul before LTE
• From the same Infonetics service provider survey
• LTE is the final, absolute time to move to IP/Ethernet backhaul
47%
93%
80%
80%
73%
60%
47%
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
Support iPhone or othersmartphones
Deploy HSPA
Need to lower backhaul costs
Deploy HSPA+
Deploy IP base station or basestation
with Ethernet connection
Deploy IP IuB (R6)
Deploy LTE
Even
ts
Percent of Respondents Rating 6 or 7
25 Copyright © 2009 Infonetics Research, Inc.
25
Costs drive operators to IP/Ethernet backhaul
• Ethernet offers huge drop in cost per bit of bandwidth that almost matches the 2x to 10x traffic increases HSPA delivers
• IP/Ethernet naturally fit WiMAX and LTE as well Source: Mobile Backhaul Equipment, Installed Base, and Services, May 2009
$0
$5,000
$10,000
$15,000
$20,000
$25,000
$30,000
$35,000
$40,000
$45,000
$50,000
CY08 CY09 CY10 CY11 CY12 CY13
Calendar Year
Annu
al B
ackh
aul C
harg
es p
er C
onne
ctio
n
PDH and ATM over PDH New wireline Mobile Backhaul
…or move to Ethernet
Stay on TDM
Mobile Backhaul Equipment and ServicesBiannual Worldwide and Regional Market Size and Forecasts
26 Copyright © 2009 Infonetics Research, Inc.
26
Worldwide Mobile Backhaul New Connections (by Technology)
-300
-150
0
150
300
450
600
750
900
CY05 CY06 CY07 CY08 CY09 CY10 CY11
Conn
ectio
ns (K
)
Ethernet microwave Ethernet copper and fiber Other
PDH/SDH microwave SONET/SDH ATM over PDH
PDH
Ethernet backhaul—connections of choice
• De-commissioning legacy (no more hybrid): use Ethernet backhaul to carry voice, data, and video traffic for 2G, 3G, WiMAX, and LTE – New 1588v2 solves clock synch problem
Source: Mobile Backhaul Equipment, Installed Base, and Services, October 2008
Ethernet
27 Copyright © 2009 Infonetics Research, Inc.
27
IP/Ethernet backhaul before LTE and for LTE • Backhaul costs are the principal driver, due to
traffic growth
• Operators are making the investment to move to the eventual IP/Ethernet backhaul networks
• IP/Ethernet backhaul – Solves ARPU-traffic disconnect today
– Solves backhaul problem for HSPA today
– …and LTE tomorrow
28
Thank You
Michael Howard Co-founder and Principal Analyst, Carrier and Data Center Networks
Infonetics Research +1 408.583.3351
[email protected] www.infonetics.com
29
Accelerating Worldwide Adoption of Carrier-class Ethernet Networks and Services
For more information regarding joining the MEF: Visit: www.metroethernetforum.org Email us at: [email protected] Call us at: +1 310 258 8032 (California, USA)
For in-depth presentations of Carrier Ethernet for business, Ethernet services, technical overview, certification program etc., visit: www.metroethernetforum.org/presentations
31
BACKUP