39
We use the power of the law to support grassroots groups working for environmental justice in the Western Great Lakes region

Cafo webinar

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Webinar on the environmental effects of factory farming in Wisconsin

Citation preview

Page 1: Cafo webinar

We use the power of the law to support grassroots groups working for environmental justice in the Western Great Lakes region

Page 3: Cafo webinar

"Conservation must have continuity of purpose and policy, and freedom from interference by political control or manipulation.”

For almost 70 years, Wisconsin’s Secretary was appointed by the seven citizen members of the Natural Resources Board. The idea of an independent conservation agency was originally established by Aldo Leopold in1927.

Page 4: Cafo webinar

Governor Tommy Thompson ended the 70-year history of an independent DNR and abolished the Public Intervenor Office in 1995

Melissa Scanlan, MEA’s founder, while still in law school, became determined to restore access to legal and technical services to the people of Wisconsin

Page 5: Cafo webinar

Governor Jim Doyle, Democrat vetoes bill to free the DNR from political pressure, even though he campaigned on returning the selection of DNR Secretary to citizen board 2009

Page 6: Cafo webinar
Page 7: Cafo webinar
Page 8: Cafo webinar

Citizens have taken on the costs and burdens of protecting public

health while special interest politics diminishes the autonomy and resources available to DNR

professional staff

Page 9: Cafo webinar

Industrial Livestock Facilities, or CAFOs, are NOT farms

ConcentratedAnimalFeedingOperation

Page 11: Cafo webinar

Industry, DNR & DATCP pushing aerial manure spraying Citizens led two local bans of the practice inRosendale, Fond du Lac Co.Johnstown, Rock Co.

Most Citizens assume their government protects their

health

Page 12: Cafo webinar

“According to a report published by the National Association of Local Boards of Health animal manure contains 160 pathogens that are capable of causing disease or infection in animals or humans, affecting the respiratory and digestive systems, muscles and skin with chills and fever, itching and rashes, fatigue and weakness, nausea and vomiting, diarrhea and dehydration, headache, abdominal pain and cramping and other debilitating symptoms and illnesses.”

American Lung Association letter to DNR, DATCP & DHS

Page 13: Cafo webinar

Livestock Facility Siting Law Governor Jim Doyle signed into law in 2003

Virtually eliminates local control of where CAFOs can be built

A local government must enact a siting ordinance to even gain access to the uniform state standards of the Siting Law and may not pass more stringent conditions

1)Location of livestock structures2)Odor and air emissions3)Nutrient Management4)Waste storage facilities5)Runoff management

Page 14: Cafo webinar

Citizens across Wisconsin opposed the loss of local control, but industrial ag special interests clogged elected officials ears with

money

Page 15: Cafo webinar

http://www.cdc.gov/nceh/ehs/docs/understanding_cafos_nalboh.pdf

CAFO manure contains a variety of potential contaminants. It can contain plant nutrients such as nitrogen and phosphorus, pathogens such as E. coli, growth hormones, antibiotics, chemicals used as additives to the manure or to clean equipment, animal blood, silage leachate from corn feed, or copper sulfate used in footbaths for cows.

Excerpt from CDC Study

Page 16: Cafo webinar

http://www.unmc.edu/rural/documents/cafo-report.pdf

Nebraska Center for Rural Health Research

Page 17: Cafo webinar

The highest concentration of CAFO dairies in the world is in counties around Green Bay

Central Sands area targeted for new CAFOs

The two most inappropriate places in WI to dump untreated animal waste

Page 18: Cafo webinar

The carrying capacity of land in the areas of Wisconsin where drinking water is most at risk are the places where the most untreated animal waste is being land spread

Page 19: Cafo webinar

Citizens Speak Out at public hearing on “Golden Sands” a proposed industrial dairy in the Town of Saratoga, Wood Countyhttp://www.protectwoodcounty.org/

New and Expanding CAFOs threaten many communities across Wisconsin

The Central Sands and counties around Green Bay have the highest concentrations of industrial livestock operations

Page 20: Cafo webinar

Central Sands Region, and area suffering from over-irrigation, is under threat from proposals for what would be the largest CAFOs in Wisconsin

Page 21: Cafo webinar

Massive quantities of untreated, liquid animal waste is spread on KARST topography,

characterized by thin soils over fractured bedrock

Page 22: Cafo webinar

Gordon Stevenson, retired DNR Chief on Non-Point Runoff

“Industrial dairies in Wisconsin create as much waste as the human populations of Tokyo and Mexico City”

“there is little to no meaningful regulation of the impact of CAFOs on public health or the environment”

Page 23: Cafo webinar

February 5, 2014 http://www.gao.gov/assets/660/659496.pdfGAO Recommends Clean Water Act Regulate Farm Discharges

A Government Accountability Office (GAO) report released Jan. 13 states that the total maximum daily load (TMDL) program would be more effective if the Clean Water Act included mandatory pollution controls for agriculture. Based on historical funding and restoration rates, GAO points out that the time required to address water quality impairments associated with

nonpoint source pollution would be greater than 1,000 years.

http://stormwater.wef.org/2014/02/gao-report-recommends-clean-water-act-regulate-farm-discharges/

Page 24: Cafo webinar

One CAFO dairy produces as much as 100 million gallons of animal waste each year. The untreated waste is then spread on fields.

One dairy cow produces the waste of 18 humans. Kewaunee County has 16 CAFOs

Page 25: Cafo webinar

Citizen Scientists in Kewaunee County have taken on the task of monitoring pollution when their government can’t or won’t do.

Photo of water samples upstream and downstream from a factory farm

Page 26: Cafo webinar

Where does all the manure go?

Over 50% of tested wells in theTown of Lincoln in Kewaunee County are unsafe for human consumption

Page 27: Cafo webinar

Lynda Cochart is one of the courageous citizens fighting for clean water. Her family has farmed Kewaunee County for 5 generations

Lynda and her neighbors waited two years for a hearing to challenge the issuance of a permit that allowed a CAFO to double in size even though area wells are already polluted

Page 28: Cafo webinar

The Treml family almost lost their daughter when she was exposed to Ecoli from their well

in Lincoln Township in 2004

Page 29: Cafo webinar
Page 31: Cafo webinar

Lynn Henning is a farmer and citizen leader fighting CAFOs in Michigan for many years. She’s lost significant lung capacity from exposure to harmful air pollutants while monitoring CAFOs.

Every aspect of daily life is impacted by families living near CAFOs

What can I do?

Page 32: Cafo webinar
Page 33: Cafo webinar

Oppose Groundwater Privatization Bills AB679 & SB302This proposed law tells DNR they can’t use sound science when managing our groundwater

Page 35: Cafo webinar

CitizenVoicesMatter

Page 36: Cafo webinar
Page 37: Cafo webinar

Stand with your neighborsVote with your Fork Buy Local, Sustainably Produced

Page 38: Cafo webinar

Ordinary people play an important role in protecting the rights of future

generations to clean air, land and water. We are motivated by love of

family– not special interests or dark money.

Page 39: Cafo webinar

www.midwestadvocates.org

@MidwestAdvocate

/MidwestEnvironmentalAdvocates