99
ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY Antiquities authority and the application of advanced (digital) technologies: presentation of case studies Raanan Kislev, Head of Conservation Department, Israel Authority of Antiquity The Eleventh Annual Jerusalem Conference on the Digitisation of Cultural Heritage - 2014

I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Antiquities authority and the application of

advanced (digital) technologies: presentation

of case studies

Raanan Kislev, Head of Conservation Department, Israel Authority of AntiquityThe Eleventh Annual Jerusalem Conference on the Digitisation of Cultural Heritage - 2014

Page 2: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Page 3: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

The ancient synagogue in Qazrin

Page 4: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

The Church of St. John in Old Acre

Page 5: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

The Church of St. John in OLd Acre

Page 6: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

The Church of St. John in Old Acre

Page 7: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Page 8: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Page 9: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

The Church of St. John in Old Acre

Page 10: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Page 11: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Page 12: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

The Israel Antiquities Authority has expanded the role of the Conservation

Department (Minhal Shimur). This initiative is an outgrowth of the IAA’s

role in safeguarding the cultural assets and built heritage in Israel. The

IAA will act to strengthen the status of the Conservation Department as

the leading professional body that acts to formulate expert standards and

to promote supervision of the conservation processes, professional

training and the assimilation of conservation education.

Bet She‘arim Ben Gurion Airport Zefat

Page 13: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

The Conservation Department will advance the preservation of the

cultural heritage in Israel from a national point of view that encompasses

the totality of its values. This heritage is a mosaic of cultures that have

existed in the region from the dawn of humanity until the present. It is

shared by many communities and therefore a high degree of sensitivity is

required in the treatment of it.

Tel Dan Caesarea

Migdal TzedekJerusalem

Bet She’an

Page 14: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

The Conservation Department will formulate a policy for the treatment

of the cultural heritage assets in Israel basing it on the Antiquities Law,

professional ethics and the accepted conservation principles in the

world. This policy will make it possible to direct the bodies that are

involved in conservation activity in Israel – public authorities, site

managers, researchers, documenters, planners, conservators and

educators – in assimilating a high degree of professional standards.

Tel Yoqne‘am The Pisan Harbor, Old Acre

Page 15: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

The Conservation Department manifests the IAA’s obligation to

establish a body that will lead the way in the field of conservation in

Israel, as an integral part of the responsibility of the state to the

cultural heritage in its territory.

City of David in Jerusalem

Migdal Ha-‘Emeq

Lohamey Ha-Geta’ot

Nebi Samwil

Page 16: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Conservation and development of the Caeserea site. Planning,

preservation, restoration and development of the bathhouse

and great yard from the Roman and Byzantine periods.

Page 17: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Before and after

Page 18: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Conservation of the Hospitaller Compound for touristic

development and presentation for the public

Before and after

Page 19: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Conservation and development of the Hospitaller visitors’ center in Old Acre

Page 20: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Conservation and stabilization of the Western Wall

complex in the Old City of Jerusalem

Page 21: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Before and after

Page 22: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Mapping in a 3D laser scanning methodJerusalem Old City Walls - 3D Mapping

Page 23: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Project of Preservation and Rehabilitation of the

Jerusalem Old City Walls

Page 24: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Conservation and rehabilitation of the Old City walls of Jerusalem

Page 25: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Conservation and rehabilitation of the Old City walls of Jerusalem

Page 26: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Conservation and rehabilitation of Zion Gate, the Old City walls of Jerusalem

Before and After

Page 27: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Damascus Gate - Before and After Treatment 2010-2011

Page 28: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

The city wall, The Tower of David - 3D measure

Page 29: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

The city wall, The Tower of David - 3D measure

Page 30: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Conservation and rehabilitation of the Old City walls of Jerusalem

Page 31: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

The Citadel's Outer Wall - 1920

Page 32: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

The Citadel's Outer Wall - 2007

Page 33: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

The Citadel's Outer Wall - 2010

Page 34: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Conservation and stabilization at the Western Wall compound in the Old

City of Jerusalem

Page 35: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

The Western Wall - 3D Mapping

Page 36: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Conservation, stabilization of the Western Wall - Survey cards

Page 37: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Data collection - Damage Identification, Mapping risk areas

Page 38: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Conservation, stabilization and the removal of hazards in the Western Wall

Page 39: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Examination of the Southeast corner of the

Temple Mount, Jerusalem.

Page 40: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Southeast corner of the Temple Mount - 3D Mapping

Page 41: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Facade of the south wall, and a mapping of contour lines in relation to

the plane of the wall

Page 42: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Facade of the south wall, and a mapping of contour lines in relation to

the plane of the wall

Page 43: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Facade of the south wall, mapping of contour lines on picture

Page 44: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Historic picture of the southeast corner from 1864

Page 45: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Facade of the south wall, mapping of contour lines on Historic picture

Page 46: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Conservation and development of the Templar tunnel for public visitation in Old

Acre

Page 47: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Templar tunnel for public visitation in Old Acre - 3D Mapping

Page 48: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Database of archeological sites on the basis

of a geographic information system (GIS)

Beit Shean, destruction subsequent to the Earthquake of 749 A.D

Page 49: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

• Tool for decision-making

• Management tool based on

knowledge

• Possible priorities for action

• A tool to raise the awareness

• Guidelines for risk preparedness

Risk map objectives

Page 50: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Risk Evaluation – Engineering and physical state

Page 51: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Mapping Selected sites

BaniasHunin

Beth She'an

Kakun

Caesarea

Tiberias

Page 52: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Risk Evaluation – Engineering and physical state

Page 53: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Critical

Low

High

Medium

Risk Assessment results of Archaeological Sites

Page 54: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

תחזוקת אתרי הדרום

Maintenance of southern sites - on the basis of a geographic

information system (GIS)

Page 55: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Maintenance of southern sites - focus on site with development

potential and high risk level

Page 56: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Maintenance of southern sites - focus on site with development potential and

high risk level, The Citadel in Ashdod and The painted tombs in Ashkelon

AshkelonAshdod

Page 57: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Meron.

Gush Halav. Ein Nashut

.The ancient Galilean synagogues on the basis of a geographic information

system (GIS)

Page 58: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

This tool is used for making decisions about the manner of intervention at each

and every site based on an evaluation of all aspects

Conservation and stabilization of the

ancient synagogue of Ein Nashut

Page 59: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Conservation and stabilization of the ancient synagogue of Meron

Page 60: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Conservation and stabilization of the ancient synagogue of Gush Halav

Page 61: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Research of historical buildings with the

assistance of innovative techniques and

modern technologies

David's Tomb, Jerusalem - Survey

Page 62: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

David's Tomb - documentation

Page 63: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

David's Tomb - stages of construction

Page 64: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

David's Tomb - Conservation plan

Page 65: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Conservation and rehabilitation David's Tomb

Page 66: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Conservation and rehabilitation David's Tomb

Page 67: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Conservation and rehabilitation David's Tomb

Page 68: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Conservation and rehabilitation David's Tomb

Page 69: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Natural frequency analysis: principal calculated mode of

vibrations and corresponding mass participation factors

Numerical models

Page 70: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

David's Tomb - Proposed interventions, Tie rods

Page 71: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

The International Conservation Center Old Acre - analysis

Page 72: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Historical (Archival) research on the building or site Building Typology

Page 73: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Physical Evaluation (Diagnosis) of the building or site

Non destructive diagnosis

Sonic

Tests

Dynamic

Identification

Page 74: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Modal analysis of the structure

Page 75: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Modal analysis of the structure

Page 76: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Seismic assessment of the “typical” building of Old Acre

Page 77: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Seismic assessment of the “typical” building of Old Acre

Page 78: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Flat Jack test - definition of the mechanical characteristics of

the investigated masonry

Page 79: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Flat Jack test - definition of the mechanical characteristics of the

investigated masonry

Page 80: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Examination of adding extra storey on “typical” building

Page 81: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Examination of adding extra storey on “typical” building

Page 82: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

The Tower of David, Jerusalem - Monitoring system

Page 83: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

The Tower of David, Jerusalem - Static system

Page 84: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

The Tower of David, Jerusalem - Dynamic system

Page 85: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

The Tower of David, Jerusalem – Automated data processing

Page 86: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

ROLE OF MONITORING

• INVESTIGATION PHASE

• INTERVENTION PHASE

• EVALUATION PHASE

• MAINTENANCE PHASE

Page 87: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Restoration by 3D simulations

Conservation and development of Tel Batash

Page 88: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Illustration of the gate in Tel Batash

Page 89: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Illustration of the gate in Tel Batash

Page 90: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Conservation and development of the Ophel walls, stages of construction

Page 91: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Conservation and development of the Ophel walls

Page 92: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Conservation and development of the Ophel walls

Page 93: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Beth She'an

Page 94: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Beth She'an – “She'an Nights”

Page 95: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Beth She'an – “She'an Nights”

Page 96: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Illustration of the Hospitaller Compound, Old Acre

Page 97: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Illustration of the Hospitaller Compound, Old Acre

Page 98: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Modal of the Hospitaller Compound, Old Acre

Page 99: I2 raanan kislev_antiquitiesauthorityconservation-min

ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY

Conservation Department IAA

THANK YOU FOR YOUR KIND ATTENTION!