26
BARE KNUCKLE ICU DNR SHOULD BE THE DEFAULT @psirides Wed June 15th

DNR Should Be The Default: PRO debate

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

BARE KNUCKLE ICU

BARE KNUCKLE ICUDNR SHOULD BE THE DEFAULT

@psirides

Wed June 15th

56%

I realise this is an impossible task. Giving a talk on DNR at a conference almost wholeheartedly dedicated to resuscitation is like talking about right heart failure at an orthopaedic conference.Define resuscitation: is CPR.

First I will define what I conceive medicine to be. In general terms, it is to do away with the sufferings of the sick, to lessen the violence of their diseases, and to refuse to treat those who are overmastered by their disease, realising that in such cases medicine is powerless.

#Hippocrat400 BC

56%

Video from The Wellcome LibraryA Brief History of CPR

56%A Brief History of CPR

5 Cases

35yr old under GA9yr old post GA80yr old under GA12yr old under GA45yr old in ED

1960

And no brain.

56%

JAMA July 1960James Jude was the cardiac surgeon who first described closed chest massage. He died this year, aged 87. Ironically, he wasnt for CPREvidence drift

Public Perception of CPR

100 in-patients aged 70 years were asked if you had a cardiac arrest, what would happen?Misconceptions Among Elderly Patients, Adams et al 200681% believed they had 50% chance of leaving hospital with no disability

23% believed the chance of no disability was 90%

56%

TV ShowsCountryNo. Episodes ScreenedNo. Cardiac Arrests WitnessedOutcomeCasualty,Cardiac Arrest, MedicsUK6452*25% survivalGreys Anatomy, HouseUS914669.6% ROSC,71.9% survival to hospital dischargeER,Chicago Hope,Rescue 911US976075% ROSC,67% survival to hospital dischargeStar Trek: TNG, DS9 & VoyagerOuter Space5269613% ROSC,9% long-term survival

*48% of patients