35
We use the power of the law to support grassroots groups working for environmental justice in the Western Great Lakes region

March webinar frac_sand

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

In this discussion of frac sand mining in Wisconsin, Kim Wright, Executive Director of Midwest Environmental Advocates, Inc., examines environmental and public health issues.

Citation preview

Page 1: March webinar frac_sand

We use the power of the law to support grassroots groups working for environmental justice in the Western Great Lakes region

Page 3: March webinar frac_sand

Frac Sand Mining in Western WisconsinLandscape-scale destruction unchecked

Page 5: March webinar frac_sand

Campaign contributions increased over 1200% from 2007-2012

The number of frac sand operations grew at a similar rate

Page 6: March webinar frac_sand
Page 7: March webinar frac_sand

Every part of the process causes problems for local communities

Page 8: March webinar frac_sand

Industrial activities are regulated with old laws designed for gravel pits

Stormwater controls are under a general permit with no technical standards appropriate for the scale of frac sand operations

Page 9: March webinar frac_sand

http://www.wateronline.com/doc/do-wisconsin-s-frac-sand-mines-endanger-groundwater-0001

“Washing” the sand to isolate the marketable size and grade uses lots of clean water, from high capacity wells.

Area residents have had trouble with the quality & quantity of well water

Page 10: March webinar frac_sand

Preferred Sands processing facility in Blair uses thousands of gallons of water per minute

http://www.wisconsinwatch.org/2013/03/03/impacts-of-frac-sand-mines/

Page 11: March webinar frac_sand

http://dnr.wi.gov/topic/mines/documents/silicasandminingfinal.pdf

DNR Natural Resources Board (NRB) directed staff to study the rapidly expanding frac sand industry in 2010. The link below is to the report finished in 2012 that called for cumulative impact studies if the number of mines and processing facilities continued to grow. There were less than 10 frac sand operations then, now there are over 150 with many more in the permitting process.

The legislature changed state law to prohibit citizens from challenging high capacity wells with sound science.

Page 12: March webinar frac_sand

“Conservation must have continuity of purpose and policy and freedom from interference by political control or manipulation.” Aldo Leopold 1927

The Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources secretary was appointed by a citizen board for 70 years. The independence and scientific autonomy of the DNR has continually eroded sine the secretary became a gubernatorial appointee in 1995.

Page 13: March webinar frac_sand
Page 14: March webinar frac_sand

Campaign contributions increased over 1200% from 2007-2012

The number of frac sand operations grew at a similar rate

Page 15: March webinar frac_sand
Page 16: March webinar frac_sand

Local Governments and citizens have a critical rolein providing meaningful conditions to protect

Public Health and the Environment

Page 17: March webinar frac_sand
Page 18: March webinar frac_sand

Green Bay Press Gazzette, March 3, 2014

Page 19: March webinar frac_sand
Page 20: March webinar frac_sand

The costs and burdens of protecting public health and the environment are primarily on the backs of citizen advocates.as the WI-DNR is increasingly starved for resources and choked by politics and special interest money.

Page 21: March webinar frac_sand

“Environmental laws don’t enforce themselves, somebody has to step up, and that somebody is us.”

Arlen ChristensonPublic Intervenor Board

Founding Board President of MEA

Page 22: March webinar frac_sand

MEA is providing legal services to families in Trempealeau County challenging air permits issued by the DNR.

Page 23: March webinar frac_sand
Page 24: March webinar frac_sand
Page 25: March webinar frac_sand
Page 26: March webinar frac_sand

Respirable Crystalline Silica Dust has sharp edges and gets lodged deep in the lungs and has been proven to cause silicosis, cancer and other serious health problems

These tiny particles are a waste product of frac sand mining and little is done to control or contain it Smooth, round sand is used in fracking

Page 27: March webinar frac_sand

Health surveillance for those exposed to respirable crystalline silica (RCS)Your work involves dusts that can cause lung diseases. Although it arises in obviously dusty environments RCS dust is invisibly fine. It is breathed in through the nose and mouth and can stay in the lungs for many years. It can cause irreversible lung damage before any symptoms develop. The illness it causes may continue to worsen even after exposure stops.

Silicosis Silicosis is a major disease risk from RCS dust. It causes small hard nodules of scar tissue to develop in the lungs that are seen on a chest X-ray. Silicosis usually takes some years to develop. There is also an acute form of silicosis that occurs at very high exposures. This can start within a short time and can kill within a few months of first exposure. The main symptoms are cough and difficulty in breathing. Workers with silicosis are at increased risk of tuberculosis and lung cancer and may also develop kidney disease and arthritis (and related diseases).

Page 28: March webinar frac_sand
Page 29: March webinar frac_sand

Many homes and public buildings wouldn’t pass OSHA standards for air quality, putting the public at great risk,

yet their own government fails to act.

Page 30: March webinar frac_sand

NIOSH Policy StatementRespiratory Protection Recommendations for Airborne Exposures to Crystalline SilicaThe following describes the NIOSH policy for respiratory protection against airborne exposures to crystalline silica. RecommendationNIOSH recommends the use of half-face piece particulate respirators with N95 or better filters for airborne exposures to crystalline silica at concentrations less than or equal to 0.5 mg/m3. The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) also specifies the use of at least a 95-rated filter efficiency [29 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) 1910.134]. The recommendation for a 95-rated filter efficiency reflects the improved filter efficiency of N95 filters over the earlier dust and mist (DM) filters. A comprehensive respirator program must be instituted prior to the use of 42 CFR 84 respirators. The requirements for a comprehensive respirator program may be found in the OSHA respiratory protection standard (29 CFR 1910.134).

http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2008-140/pdfs/2008-140.pdf

Page 31: March webinar frac_sand

Homes and schools are surrounded by frac sand operations

Public Health is at risk from unchecked industrial activities

Page 32: March webinar frac_sand
Page 33: March webinar frac_sand
Page 34: March webinar frac_sand
Page 35: March webinar frac_sand

www.midwestadvocates.org

@MidwestAdvocate

/MidwestEnvironmentalAdvocates