49
These constant changes

These constant changes

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

A critical view on the evolution of the judge program and it's documents

Citation preview

Page 1: These constant changes

These constant changes

Page 2: These constant changes

What we’re going to discuss:

• Debate

• What are the IPG & MTR• A Walk down memory lane• The evolution of the Judge Program

Page 3: These constant changes
Page 4: These constant changes

What is the MTR?

• The Rules on how to run Magic Tournaments

Page 5: These constant changes

What is the IPG?• Magic™ Infraction Procedure Guide:

(AKA Penalty Guidelines)

• Name of the Infraction• Penalty• Definition• Examples• Philosophy• Additional Remedy

Page 6: These constant changes

2012… 2011… 2010… 2009… 2008… 2007… 2006… 2005… 2004… 2003… 2002 … 2001… 2000…

Page 9: These constant changes
Page 10: These constant changes
Page 11: These constant changes
Page 12: These constant changes
Page 13: These constant changes
Page 14: These constant changes
Page 15: These constant changes
Page 16: These constant changes
Page 18: These constant changes
Page 19: These constant changes
Page 20: These constant changes
Page 22: These constant changes

2005

Page 23: These constant changes

February 1, 2007 Complete rewrite of Penalty Guide

Page 25: These constant changes
Page 26: These constant changes
Page 27: These constant changes
Page 29: These constant changes
Page 30: These constant changes
Page 31: These constant changes
Page 32: These constant changes
Page 33: These constant changes
Page 34: These constant changes
Page 35: These constant changes

Time for the main event!

Page 36: These constant changes
Page 37: These constant changes
Page 38: These constant changes
Page 39: These constant changes

1998

May 2, 2014

2007 - June 20, 2010

Page 40: These constant changes

Feb 2007

Later that year

March 2012

Page 41: These constant changes
Page 42: These constant changes

1998

2012

May2014

Page 43: These constant changes
Page 44: These constant changes

GPE— Incorrect Representation

GPE— Failure to Reveal

Unsporting Conduct — severe

Etc’

Page 45: These constant changes

Missed TriggersUntil 2007 - Procedural Error—Major

2007 – Missed Trigger

Page 46: These constant changes
Page 47: These constant changes
Page 48: These constant changes
Page 49: These constant changes

Missed Triggers