Upload
ohm-advisors
View
77
Download
1
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
OHM-ADVISORS.COM
Quantifying Climate Change for Stormwater & Wastewater
Systems
Gregory P. Kacvinsky, P.E.OHM Advisors
APWA Michigan Annual ConferenceMay 21, 2015
ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Climate is what you expect;
weather is what you get
Edward Lorenz
Mathematician and Meteorologist
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
• Long design life of infrastructure
• Increasing precipitation already
observed across the Midwest
• Climate models predict
continued increases in both
average and extreme rainfall
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Why is this important?
• We state that the ‘design life’ is 50
years, BUT:
• Detroit, MI: Average age of Detroit Water
and Sewerage pipes is 80 years• Minnesota: One third of state’s sewers are
older than 50 years• Philadelphia, PA: Average age of sewers is
100 years, with some pipes as old as 190
years• New Jersey: Average age of sewers is 70
years
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
How Long will it Last?
• Infrastructure built in
the 1950s:
• Simplified methods• Few (if any) rainfall statistics
to rely on (pre-TP-40)• Less knowledge of flood
potential (pre-FIRM era)
• We are still living with this
infrastructure
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
How Long will it Last?
• Rehabilitating sewers increases life
expectancy, BUT:
• Pipe lining typically results in a smaller effective
diameter• Rehabilitated pipe can have a reduced flow
capacity
• We should assume that the pipe we
design will be in service 80-100 years
from now.
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
How Long will it Last?
Climate models (forward-looking)
Rainfall statistics (rear-looking)
Modeling – how does all this impact utility sizing?
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Predicted Changes in Annual Average Precipitation
• 1986-2005 data compared to 2081-2100 multi-model mean
• 10-20% increase in Great Lakes Region
• IPCC Summary for Policy Makers
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Predicted Changes in Annual Average Precipitation
• 1986-2005 data compared to 2081-2100 multi-model mean
• 10-20% increase in Great Lakes Region
• IPCC Summary for Policy Makers
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
• National Climate
Assessment, US Global
Change Research Program
• 1971-2000 versus 2041-
2070 with continued
emissions scenario
• Michigan existing average
is about 32.2” per year, so
increase in range of 2.4” to
4.0” means 7% to 12%
more rain predicted
Predicted Changes in Annual Average Precipitation
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
• National Climate
Assessment, US Global
Change Research Program
• 1971-2000 versus 2041-
2070 with continued
emissions scenario
• Michigan existing average
is about 32.2” per year, so
increase in range of 2.4” to
4.0” means 7% to 12%
more rain predicted
Predicted Changes in Annual Average Precipitation
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
• National Climate
Assessment, US Global
Change Research Program
• “Heavy” rains defined as top
2% largest rainfall events of
each year
• 1971-2000 vs 2041-2070
with continued emissions
scenario
• Projections indicate heavy
rains will occur more
frequently
Predicted Changes in Heavy Rain Events
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
• National Climate
Assessment, US Global
Change Research Program
• “Heavy” rains defined as top
2% largest rainfall events of
each year
• 1971-2000 vs 2041-2070
with continued emissions
scenario
• Projections indicate heavy
rains will occur more
frequently
Predicted Changes in Heavy Rain Events
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Bottom Line:
In Michigan, we should be prepared for
more rain: heavy rains should become
more frequent and rainfall intensities
should increase by 10-20%.
Predicted Changes in Precipitation
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Observed Changes in Very Heavy Precipitation
• National Climate
Assessment
• “Very Heavy” rains
defined as top 1% of
all observed daily
events (1958 to
2012)
• Big storms have
gotten more intense
over the past 50
years
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Recent Rainfall Statistics
• Technical Paper 40 – Published in 1961• Length of record: Ranged from 14-48 years• Most recent data: 1958• 57 years out of date
• Bulletin 71 – Published in 1992• Length of record: up to 87 years (60 years in Michigan)• Most recent data: late 1980s• 25-30 years out of date
• NOAA Atlas 14 – Published in 2013 (for Michigan)• Length of record: Ranged from 30 to over 119 years• Most recent data: 2012
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Recent Rainfall Statistics
• NOAA Atlas 14
• Denser grid of
observations than
previous studies
• Significant
differences
compared to
previous studies
(especially for less
frequent storms)Source: NOAA Atlas 14, Volume 8 (2013)
Percent difference between NOAA Atlas 14 and TP40
for the 100-yr 24-hr rainfall
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Recent Rainfall Statistics
• NOAA Atlas 14
• Denser grid of
observations than
previous studies
• Significant
differences
compared to
previous studies
(especially for less
frequent storms)Source: NOAA Atlas 14, Volume 8 (2013)
Percent difference between NOAA Atlas 14 and TP40
for the 100-yr 24-hr rainfall
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
100-yr 24-hr
100-yr 3-hr
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
↑ 24%
↑ 38%
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
NO
AA
Atl
as
14
TP
40
Bu
lleti
n 7
1
LEGEND
10-yr 2-hr
100-yr 3-hr
↑ 26%
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
1.6
1.7
1.8
1.9
2.0
2.1 ↑ 14%
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
NO
AA
Atl
as
14
TP
40
Bu
lleti
n 7
1
LEGEND
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
1.6
1.7
1.8
1.9
2.0
10-yr 2-hr
100-yr 3-hr
↑ 40%
↑ 11%
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
NO
AA
Atl
as
14
TP
40
Bu
lleti
n 7
1
LEGEND
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
1.7
1.8
1.9
2.0
2.1
10-yr 2-hr
100-yr 3-hr
↑ 22%
↑ 11%
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
NO
AA
Atl
as
14
TP
40
Bu
lleti
n 7
1
LEGEND
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Comparing Statistics
• August 11-12, 2014
• Catastrophic rainfall event in
Metro Detroit
• Local press coverage
categorized this as a 500-yr
storm in some locations
• However, using recent
statistics shows us it wasn’t
as rare as we thought
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Comparing Statistics
CityPeak 3-hour rainfall (in.) TP 40 Bulletin 71 NOAA Atlas 14
Garden City 2.89 63 >100 28Exceedance Interval
Detroit (west fringe) 3.21 >100 >100 48 25-yr to 50-yr
Romulus 2.84 56 >100 28 50-yr to 75-yr
Westland 2.91 66 >100 29 75-yr to 100-yr
Royal Oak 4.26 >500* >500* 275 >100 yr* Extrapolated
August 11-12, 2014 Rainfall Event
Exceedance Interval (years)
Key
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Comparing Statistics
CityPeak 6-hour rainfall (in.) TP 40 Bulletin 71 NOAA Atlas 14
Garden City 3.49 79 >100 37Exceedance Interval
Detroit (west fringe) 3.59 91 >100 43 25-yr to 50-yr
Romulus 3.65 98 >100 48 50-yr to 75-yr
Westland 3.49 79 >100 36 75-yr to 100-yr
Royal Oak 4.79 >500* >500* 200 >100 yr* Extrapolated
Exceedance Interval (years)
Key
August 11-12, 2014 Rainfall Event
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Comparing Statistics
CityPeak 12-hour rainfall (in.) TP 40 Bulletin 71 NOAA Atlas 14
Garden City 3.91 68 >100 30Exceedance Interval
Detroit (west fringe) 4.24 93 >100 36 25-yr to 50-yr
Romulus 4.03 77 >100 28 50-yr to 75-yr
Westland 3.94 70 >100 23 75-yr to 100-yr
Royal Oak 5.08 >500* >500* 167 >100 yr* Extrapolated
August 11-12, 2014 Rainfall Event
Exceedance Interval (years)
Key
• Flow rates and pipe sizes dependent on selection of climate
data
• Climate data based on past statistics only and are not
forward-looking
• Need new tools to address future climate patterns
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Uncertainty in Design
?
• Several Independent Methods:
Updating Rainfall Statistics (national AND local
data, if available)
EPA Stormwater Calculator
Confidence Intervals
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Tools for Addressing Climate Trends
• 1949-2012 Detroit City Airport Rainfall Data
• Compared peak annual rainfall totals (1949-2012) against
more recent subset (1990-2012)
• Results showed a recent increase in peak rainfall depths,
which tends to reflect NOAA Atlas 14 findings
• 7.4% increase for 10 year, 24 hour storm
• 10.2% increase for 10 year, 1 hour storm
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Updating Rainfall Statistics
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Updating Rainfall Statistics
7.4% increase for 10-yr, 24-hr
storm
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
EPA Stormwater Calculator
http://www2.epa.gov/water-research/national-stormwater-calculator
Estimates annual
amount of
rainwater &
frequency of
runoff from a
specific site based
on local soil
conditions, land
cover, and historic
rainfall records.
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
EPA Stormwater Calculator: Climate Change Options
http://www2.epa.gov/water-research/national-stormwater-calculator
• Scenarios:
Hot/Dry
Median Change
Warm/Wet
• Time Period:
Near Term
(2020-2049)
Far Term
(2045-2074)
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
EPA Stormwater Calculator: Ann Arbor Example
http://www2.epa.gov/water-research/national-stormwater-calculator
Applying
Rainfall
generated
to a
Sanitary
Sewer
Analysis
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
EPA Stormwater Calculator: Ann Arbor Example
• Far Term (2045-2074) was selected because design life is >50
years
• Warm/Wet scenario was selected to be conservative
• Predicted percent change in monthly rainfall data were extracted
from the tool
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
EPA Stormwater Calculator: Ann Arbor Example
Perform frequency analysis
using hydrologic
model output
based on past rainfall data to get
existing design flow
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
EPA Stormwater Calculator: Ann Arbor Example
Rainfall data adjusted for
climate change based on predicted
monthly % change
Ran adjusted rain through
model
10% increase in future design
flow
10% increase for 25-yr flow
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
EPA Stormwater Calculator: Ann Arbor Example
• Consider 10% increase in peak flow at WWTP to account
for future climate change (2045-2074).
• Technical Oversight and Advisory Group (TOAG) quote:
…TOAG Members indicated that the
recommendation to increase the 25 year Design
Event flow rate by 10% is reasonable since this is
a mid-range value which falls near the center of
the climate change forecast models showing
“best case” and “worst case” future conditions…
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Novi Study
10-year flow = 22.5 cfs based on
running all 64 years (1949-2012) of rainfall through
model
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Novi Study
22.5 cfs = 10-year flow based on
running 1949-2012 rain data through
model
24.1 cfs = 10-year flow based on
running 2000-2012 rain data through
model
7% increase based on recent
trends
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Novi Study
22.5 cfs = 10-year flow based on
running 1949-2012 rain data through
model
7% increase based on recent
trends
26.5 cfs = 10-year flow based on adding
10% for future climate change
predictions
10% increase based on future climate change
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Novi Study
How does this impact pipe size?
22.5 cfs: 30-inch sewer
26.5 cfs: 36-inch sewer
18% increase in flows, due to both rear-looking statistics and forward-looking climate models
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Novi Study
30-inch sewer will be ok TODAY, but will surcharge above surface elevation (SSO) if statistics and
climate projections hold
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Stormwater FootprintNOAA Atlas 14 rainfall statistics
show a large increase in the 100-yr 24-hr storm. In some
parts of Michigan, it has gone up 20%-25%
• Using confidence intervals (in NOAA Atlas 14 data) may be a reasonable way to address future climate variability:
• Example: (NW Oakland County)
• 100-yr 24-hr rainfall = 5.45 inches
• Climate models put the likely range closer to 6.0-6.5 inches (second half of 21st Century)
• How will this impact developability?
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Stormwater Footprint
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Confidence Intervals
• 90% probability of observing a value within the range
• Climate models predict an increase in future precipitation values so use a value towards the upper bound of the confidence interval
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
NOAA Atlas 14 Confidence Intervals
http://www.nws.noaa.gov/oh/hdsc/index.html
• Frequency estimates for Detroit, MI
• 90% confidence intervals given
• Lower bounds are 13.3% lower than average
• Upper bounds are 20% higher than average
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
NOAA Atlas 14 Confidence Intervals
http://www.nws.noaa.gov/oh/hdsc/index.html
• Frequency estimates for Detroit, MI
• 90% confidence intervals given
• Lower bounds are 13.3% lower than average
• Upper bounds are 20% higher than average
• Recent statistics indicate rainfall depths for design storms have been increasing in Michigan
• Climate models project further increases in rainfall depth for future storms
• Tools are available to estimate future rainfall increases and develop future design flows for different parts of the state
• Using these tools for SE Michigan communities indicated future design flows should be increased ~10%-20% above existing
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Conclusions
• In most cases, this translates to an increase of one pipe size:
• 12-inch to 15-inch
• 30-inch to 36-inch
• Etc.
• When replacing storm or sanitary sewers, consider this change
• Also consider that the pipe may be lined in the future (design for reduced future diameter)
OHM-ADVISORS.COM ARCHITECTS. ENGINEERS. PLANNERS.
Conclusions