Upload
paul-maharg
View
923
Download
2
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
sensus communis: experiential learning and the
law school curriculum
Paul Maharg
Northumbria Law School
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 2
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 3
Glasgow
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 4
presentation structure
Francis Hutcheson sensus communis: a genealogical sketch Dewey & the Laboratory School Law schools & experiential learning Law schools & curriculum
Slides @ http://www.slideshare.net/paulmaharg
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 5
‘Occasionally Law … tries to be like children outside the School. Law is sometimes caught playing “Let’s pretend” games – let’s pretend we are an advocate or let’s pretend we are interviewing a client. Law sometimes forgets that it is not there to pretend anything anymore. It is in School to be a pupil and do the things that other pupils do.’
Bradney, A. (2010). End of Term Report. The Reporter: The Newsletter of the Society of Legal Scholars, 40, 2010, 1.
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 6
US Airways Flight 1549…
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 8
what difference can legal education make?
Legal education has a weak socialising affect, much weaker than the centripetal power of the job market.
A. Sherr, A., Webb, J. (1989). Law students, the external market, and socialisation: do we make them turn to the City? Journal of Law and Society 16, 2, 225.
Legal subjects studied affect career ambitions, but had a neutral, short term or negative impact on the public service orientation of law students.
Boon, A. (2005). From public service to service industry: the impact of socialisation and work on the motivation and values of lawyers. International Journal of the Legal Profession, 12, 2, 229-260.
A study on socio-economic & ethnic diversity in Scotland found similar results.
Anderson, S., Maharg, P., Murray, L. (2003) Minority and Social Diversity in Legal Education, Scottish Government Official Publication.
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 9
Francis Hutcheson(1694-1746)
Professor of Moral Philosophy, University of Glasgow (1730-46)
An Inquiry into the Original of our Ideas of Beauty and Virtue (1725).
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 10
‘[T]he old Notions of natural Affections, and kind Instincts; the Sensus communis, the Decorum, and Honestum, are almost banished out of our Books of Morals; we must never hear of them in any of our Lectures for fear of Innate Ideas; all must be Interest and some selfish View.’
Francis Hutcheson, Collected Works, 7 vols, facsimile edition prepared by Bernhard Fabian. Hildesheim: Olms, 1969-90. Vol VII, 475
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 11
sensus communis as virtuous spiral
1. Translation by Aquinas for a phrase in Aristotle’s De Anima, where it is used to describe the cognitive activity of the mind to engage in discriminating relationships between particulars and universal – in effect, a meta-sense.
Schaeffer, J.D. (1990). Sensus Communis: Vico, Rhetoric and the Limits of Relativism. Durham, North Carolina, Duke University Press.
2. In the Stoic tradition, for example Seneca’s De Beneficiis, it refers more to the manners and sense of decorum that belong to a society or community – in the 18th century revival of Stoic literature Shaftesbury’s Sensus Communis: An Essay on the Freedom of Wit and Humour is an example.
For Hutcheson: 1 creates 2. 2 influences 1. Moral theory is lived practice
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 12
law as reason?
‘Law is the dictate of reason, determining every rational being to that which is congruous and convenient for the nature and condition thereof.’
James Dalrymple, Viscount Stair, The Institutions of the Law of Scotland. 1681, reprinted 1981. Edited D.M. Walker, University Presses of Edinburgh & Glasgow, I, I, I.
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 13
William Hazlitt
‘Natural disinterestedness of the human mind’
ie it is our sympathetic imagination that influences our relations with others, not reason or self-interest:
‘The imagination, by means of which alone I can anticipate future objects, or be interested in them, must carry me out of myself into the feelings of others by one and the same process by which I am thrown forward as it were into my future being, and interested in it. I could not love myself, if I were not capable of loving others. Self-love, used in this sense, is in its fundamental principle the same with disinterested benevolence.’
Hazlitt, W. (1805). An Essay on the Principles of Human Action: Being an Argument in Favour of the Natural Disinterestedness of the Human Mind. Gainesville: Scholars’ Facsimiles & Reprints, 1969.
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 15
John Dewey(1859-1952)
‘A democracy is more than a form of government; it is primarily a mode of associated living, of conjointcommunicated activity.’
Democracy and Education(1916)
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 16
Standard classroom c.1908. Would you like to learn about measurement and volume this way?
Thanks to Mike Sharples,http://tinyurl.com/6bzdgx
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 17
…or this way? (Dewey’s Laboratory School, U. of Chicago, 1901)
http://tinyurl.com/6onvjp
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 18
Would you like to learn about history and town planning this way?
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 19
… or by building a table-top town for a social life history project? (Dewey’s Lab School)
http://tinyurl.com/59c93q
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 20
two origins of contemporary learning theory
‘One cannot understand the history of education in the United States in the twentieth century unless one realizes that Edward L. Thorndike won and John Dewey lost.’ Lageman, E.C. (1989) The plural worlds of educational research, History of
Education Quarterly, 29(2), 185-214
E.L. Thorndike John Dewey
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 21
E.L. Thorndike John Dewey1. Educational psychologist Philosopher & educationalist
2. Theoretician & experimentalist Theoretician and practical implementer
3. Explored the dyadic relationship between mind & the world
Interested in the arc between experience & the world
4. Adopted as precursor of a behaviourist approach to learning: assessment-led; laws of effect, recency, repetition
Pragmatist approach to learning: prior experience, ways of contextual knowing; democracy & education
5. Emphasised teaching strategies
Emphasised learning ecologies
6. Followed by: Watson, Skinner, Gagné; outcomes, competence & instructional design (ID) movements.
Followed by: Bruner, Kilpatrick, standards movement, Constructivist tradition.
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 22
signature pedagogies (Lee Shulman)
Sullivan, W.M., Colby, A., Wegner, J.W., Bond, L., Shulman, L.S. (2007) Educating Lawyers. Preparation for the Profession of Law, Jossey-Bass, p. 24
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 23
transforming the pedagogy…?
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 24
A specific form of problem-based learning. At least seven distinguishing elements –
active learning through performance in authentic transactions involving reflection in & on learning, deep collaborative learning, and
holistic or process learning, with relevant professional assessment that includes ethical standards
– that can have a significant effect on learning when used in simulations of professional practice.
transactional learning
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 25
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 26
personal injury negotiation project
Administration: 272 students, 68 firms, 8 anonymous information sources – PI
mentors 68 document sets, 34 transactions Each scenario has embedded variables, called from a document
server, making it similar, but also unique in critical ways students have 12 weeks to achieve settlement introductory & feedback lectures discussion forums FAQs & transaction guideline flowcharts voluntary face-to-face surgeries with a PI solicitor
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 27
PI project: assessment criteria
We require from each student firm a body of evidence consisting of:
fact-finding – from information sources in the virtual community) professional legal research – using WestLaw + paperworld
sources formation of negotiation strategy – extending range of Foundation
Course learning performance of strategy – correspondence + optional f2f meeting,
recorded
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 28
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 29
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 30
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 31
PI project: (some of) what students learned
extended team working real legal fact-finding real legal research process thinking in the project setting out negotiation strategies in the context of (un)known information writing to specific audiences handling project alongside other work commitments structuring the argument of a case from start to finish keeping cool in face-to-face negotiations more effective delegation keeping files taking notes on the process...
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 32
PI project: what students would have done differently…
‘In tackling this project I think that our group made two main mistakes. The first mistake we made was in approaching the task as law students as opposed to Lawyers. By this I mean we tried to find the answer and work our way back. Immediately we were thinking about claims and quantum and blame. I don't think we actually initiated a claim until a week before the final settlement. I think the phrase "like a bull in a china shop" would aptly describe the way we approached the problem. […] Our group knew what area of law and tests to apply yet we ended up often being ahead of ourselves and having to back-pedal
The second mistake we made was estimating how long it would take to gather information. We started our project quite late on and began to run out of time towards the end. None of us appreciated the length of time it would take to gather information and on top of this we would often have to write two or three letters to the same person as the initial letter would not ask the right question.’
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 33
PI project: what students would have done differently…
‘At the beginning we thought we perhaps lost sight of the fact that we had a client whom we had a duty to advise and inform. On reflection we should have issued terms of engagement and advised the client better in monetary terms what the likely outcome was going to be.’
‘[…] unlike other group projects I was involved in at undergraduate level I feel that I derived genuine benefit from this exercise in several ways:1. reinforcing letter-writing, negotiation, time-management and IT skills2. conducting legal research into issues of quantum3. working effectively in a group as a group - not delegating tasks at the first
meeting and then putting together pieces of work at the second meeting.’
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 34
curriculum: tempo & complexity
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 35
curriculum: tempo & complexity
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 36
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 37
three-level thinking…
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 38
Curriculum is multiple distributed technologies and practices. Eg timetables, course teams, notepads, learning spaces, forms of knowledge transmission, discussion, computers, forms of discourse, writing – all existing in time spans.
Some technologies are ancient (lectura, glossa), some new (SIMPLE, standardised clients, mobile phones)
Success in learning means:
1. for staff, the need to compose and orchestrate the curriculum.
2. for students, the tools, support & spaces to manage their own curriculum
curriculum is technology
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 39
OER software: SIMPLE
See http://simplecommunity.org Aims – Be collaborative: staff, students, different institutions, different
professions Be international – in our increasingly globalized jurisdictions we
need to enable our students to work with others Research our practice Integrate with other forms of simulation,
eg standardized clients Organize like Mozilla
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 40
OER in simulation resources: Simshare
See http://www.simshare.org.ukAims: Collate simulation resources which are repurposed as open
educational content Create guidelines for future publication of simulation projects Help staff to use simulation more widely and effectively through
staff development. Create methodologies that will help staff to see more clearly how
simulation OER can be interpreted.
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 41
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 42
my profile
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 43
OER ethics resources
See www.teachinglegalethics.org
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 44
Two book series:
1. Emerging Legal Education Book Series, Ashgate Publishing, editors Paul Maharg, Caroline Maughan, Elizabeth Mertz.
2. Digital Games and Learning Book Series, Continuum Publishing, editors Sara de Freitas & Paul Maharg.
research & publication…
Professor Paul Maharg Northumbria Law School 46
Slides @
http://www.slideshare.net/paulmaharg
Discussion @
http://zeugma.typepad.com