Upload
niall-watts
View
147
Download
1
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Seírbhísí TF UCDUCD IT Services
Measures of Learning Style in the Evaluation of Blogs as Reflective Learning Tools
Niall Watts
Educational Technology Officer
ELSIN, Billund, June 2013
Research Background
• Working as an Educational Technologist
– Open University student
– Hype about new technologies
– Reflection and Collaboration
– Quality of educational research
– Methods criticism – student evaluations
Aims of Research
• Investigate blogging as a tool for learning
– Cycle of Experiential Learning (Kolb)
• Active (doing) or Reflective (watching)
• Individual (thinking) or Collaborative (feeling)
– Blogs promote reflective learning?
Why Blog?
• Storytelling
• Improve writing & media skills
• Opportunity to engage and reflect
• Simple technology
Research Participants
“Unrestrained by class rules”
No assessment
Lecturer well-known blogger
What is Reflection (Reflective Learning)?
• Reflection describes the processes where learners explore their experiences to gain a better understanding and appreciation of their learning (Boud, 1985).
• Many students find reflective learning difficult and initially resist it… Properly implemented blogs can help bring about reflective learning (Bartlett-Bragg, 2003).
Kolb’s Cycle of Experiential Learning
Kolb’s Learning Styles
• Preferred learning style
• Teaching to match style
• Not fixed Approach Emotional Response Active Experimentation
AE - Doing
Reflective Observation
RO - Watching
Concrete Experience
CE - Feeling
Accommodating (CE/AE) Diverging (CE/RO)
Abstract Conceptualisation AC - Thinking
Converging (AE/AC) Assimilating (RO/AC)
Kolb’s Learning Styles
• Based on Kolb’s Experiential Learning Theory– Accommodating: intuition, people– Assimilating: logic, theory– Converging: practice, technology– Diverging: imaginative, group work
Which would you expect to:
Be reflective/collaborative ?
Use hypermedia?
Reflection
• Assimilating
• Diverging
Collaboration
• Accommodating
• Diverging
Kolb Cycle Modified for Blogging
• Dron– ‘Reflective Observations’ on ‘Concrete Experience ‘– Comments – Theorise to explain reflective observations– Test theory in ‘Active Experimentation’
Methodology – KLSI 3.1
• Quantitative - standardised
• Literature
• Reflection, Hypermedia, Blogging
• Benefits
• Free
• Short (12x4)
• Bias
Methods – Learning Style
• Student Consent
• Ranked themselves on 12 questions– Students calculated own Learning Style– Results plotted on graph– Discussion
• Reliability & validity• Critiques
Results – Learning Style
Converging Learning Style dominant among bloggers:– Four keenest bloggers – One non-blogger
N=10
Methods – Text Analysis
• Blog posts coded for reflection using heuristics (Hatton & Smith)
• Risk of subjectivity
• Writing categorised as reflective (or not):
– “In one class we were asked how much time do we spend actually away from technology. I for one know that I can spend 5 hours online and most of that the tv is also on (I like to multi task) and that doesn't even include college. I don't think I can remember a week where I haven't been online every day at some time or another. I am away to a hotel for weekend and I know my laptop will be with me, not to mention my mobile with wifi function”.
Results – Blog Analysis
• One third of posts reflective
• One third of comments reflective
• 1 comment for 3 posts suggests collaboration
BLOG POSTS COMMENTS MADE RECEIVED
Total
Total Refl. Total Refl. Total Refl.
6 92 33 31 12 69 14
Converging Learning Style
• 4 Bloggers with Converging LS – 75% of all posts– 81% of reflective posts– 100% reflective comments (made & received)
– All “Somewhat reflective”– 2 Mature– 2 Male. 2 Female.
Methods – Triangulation
• Kember’s Questionnaire on Reflection– Agree/disagree 16 questions on their learning- Most students highly or somewhat reflective- All bloggers highly or somewhat reflective
• Blogging habits questionnaire (10 questions)– Do you enjoy blogging?– Does it help you to learn?– Do you/read comment on your classmates blogs?
Conclusions
• Bloggers reflective & collaborative learners
• Unexpected Result – Converging Learning Style– Not associated with Reflection or Collaboration– Skills with Hypermedia (Kolb)– Practical, hands-on
• Privacy?
• Matched perceptions– Sample bias?– Students existing community– Teaching & learning practices– Lecturer well-known blogger