10
GRAMMAR & LOGIC: AN UNHOLY MARRIAGE From “Language” (1933) By L. Bloomfield

GRAMMAR & LOGIC: AN UNHOLY MARRIAGE

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Bloomfield's early warnings on the historical disease of the study of language

Citation preview

Page 1: GRAMMAR & LOGIC: AN UNHOLY MARRIAGE

GRAMMAR & LOGIC: AN UNHOLY MARRIAGE

From “Language” (1933)

By L. Bloomfield

Page 2: GRAMMAR & LOGIC: AN UNHOLY MARRIAGE

THE IDEAL LANGUAGE BIAS

Page 3: GRAMMAR & LOGIC: AN UNHOLY MARRIAGE

THE IDEAL LANGUAGE BIAS

Page 4: GRAMMAR & LOGIC: AN UNHOLY MARRIAGE

PRESCRIPTIVE/DESCRIPTIVE FALLACY

Page 5: GRAMMAR & LOGIC: AN UNHOLY MARRIAGE

PRESCRIPTIVE/DESCRIPTIVE FALLACY:GOOD OR BAD POPULAR MYTH

Page 6: GRAMMAR & LOGIC: AN UNHOLY MARRIAGE

PRIMACY OF SPEECH VS STATUS

Page 7: GRAMMAR & LOGIC: AN UNHOLY MARRIAGE

PRIMACY OF SPEECH VS STATUS

Page 8: GRAMMAR & LOGIC: AN UNHOLY MARRIAGE

SPEECH IS ALIVE – IT CHANGES.

WRITING IS A FOSSIL - IT RESISTS CHANGE.

Page 9: GRAMMAR & LOGIC: AN UNHOLY MARRIAGE

UNIVERSAL GRAMMAR: ANCIENT MYTH

Fila 1 Fila 2 Fila 3 Fila 40

2

4

6

8

10

12

Columna 1

Columna 2

Columna 3

Page 10: GRAMMAR & LOGIC: AN UNHOLY MARRIAGE

SCIENTIFIC INDUCTION VS INTELLECTUAL SPECULATION