Upload
department-of-communication-science-university-of-amsterdam
View
1.114
Download
1
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure asnetwork of users and news items
Damian Trilling
University of AmsterdamDepartment of Communication Science
Amsterdam School of Communication [email protected]
DGPUK FG Methoden23-09-2016
1 Common assumptions. . . and why they are wrong
2 Toward new theories of news flows
3 News exposure as network of users and news itemsA modelImplementation
4 Conclusion
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
Common assumptions
We do as if these assumptions would still hold . . .(have they ever?)
“People use a fixed set of newsoutlets”
“People can name these outlets”“People use these outlets with aconstant frequency”“The content of the outlets isstatic”
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
Common assumptions
We do as if these assumptions would still hold . . .(have they ever?)
“People use a fixed set of newsoutlets”
“People can name these outlets”
“People use these outlets with aconstant frequency”“The content of the outlets isstatic”
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
Common assumptions
We do as if these assumptions would still hold . . .(have they ever?)
“People use a fixed set of newsoutlets”“People can name these outlets”
“People use these outlets with aconstant frequency”
“The content of the outlets isstatic”
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
Common assumptions
We do as if these assumptions would still hold . . .(have they ever?)
“People use a fixed set of newsoutlets”“People can name these outlets”“People use these outlets with aconstant frequency”
“The content of the outlets isstatic”
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
Common assumptions
We do as if these assumptions would still hold . . .(have they ever?)
“If we know content of the outletand frequency of use, we can inferto which content people areexposed”
“Outlets are a meaningful categoryto categorize distinct content”“Content produced by one outlet isdelivered via one channel”
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
Common assumptions
We do as if these assumptions would still hold . . .(have they ever?)
“If we know content of the outletand frequency of use, we can inferto which content people areexposed”
“Outlets are a meaningful categoryto categorize distinct content”
“Content produced by one outlet isdelivered via one channel”
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
Common assumptions
We do as if these assumptions would still hold . . .(have they ever?)
“If we know content of the outletand frequency of use, we can inferto which content people areexposed”“Outlets are a meaningful categoryto categorize distinct content”
“Content produced by one outlet isdelivered via one channel”
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
. . . and why they are wrong
But they are wrong.
• News providers spread their content via different channels:website, apps, social media, . . .
• Large share (typically 33%–50%) of website traffic comes vialinks on social media
• tailored, personalized, targeted content
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
Toward new theories of news flows
Transmission of societally relevant information
• before: few distinct channels, largely the same for everyone• now: also social network sites, personalized media, . . .• complicating factor: citizens influence the news diffusionprocess by sharing articles (feedback loops)
⇒ news products get unbundled
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
Toward new theories of news flows
Transmission of societally relevant information
• before: few distinct channels, largely the same for everyone• now: also social network sites, personalized media, . . .• complicating factor: citizens influence the news diffusionprocess by sharing articles (feedback loops)
⇒ news products get unbundled
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
Unbundling of news
• single news item instead of collection of items bundled in, e.g.a newspaper
examples
• aggregators (Google News)• pay-per-article (Blendle)
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
Unbundling of news
• single news item instead of collection of items bundled in, e.g.a newspaper
examples
• aggregators (Google News)• pay-per-article (Blendle)
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
This renders questions like “Did you watch the news yesterday?”pointless and makes it necessary to shift perspectives towards theindividual news item.
solid-state entity of news has become liquid.
(see also Bauman, 2007).
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
Consequences of liquid news
Revisting theories• distinction between mass communication and (mediated)personal communication cannot be upheld Perloff2015
• the question “who sets the media agenda?” has become “illstructured” Russell Neuman e.a., 2014, because traditional and socialmedia interact and resonate Deuze, 2008
Re-integrating old theories• Two-step-flow• apply news value theory to news sharing
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
Thorson & Wells: Curated news flows
• tracking data from Facebook app• combined with survey data
⇒ one example of how to tackle mesaurement of liquid news: Howcan we measure who has been exposed to which news item?Thorson, K., & Wells, C. (2016). Curated flows: A framework for mapping media exposure in the digitalage. Communication Theory, 26, 309–328. doi:10.1111/comt.12087
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
A model
Basics
A network approach• nodes of different types• edges of different types
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
A model
Conceptualization
Nodes
• news item: node with a number of properties:• timestamp• news values• medium• topic• . . .
• user: node with a number of properties• age• gender• . . .
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
A model
Conceptualization
Nodes
• news item: node with a number of properties:• timestamp• news values• medium• topic• . . .
• user: node with a number of properties• age• gender• . . .
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
A model
Conceptualization
Edges
• news item ↔ news item• is_similar
• user → news item• has_read
Other conceptualizations possible, e.g. taking into accounttimestamps to explicitly model chains of link sharing)
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
A model
Conceptualization
Edges
• news item ↔ news item• is_similar
• user → news item• has_read
Other conceptualizations possible, e.g. taking into accounttimestamps to explicitly model chains of link sharing)
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
A model
Conceptualization
Edges
• news item ↔ news item• is_similar
• user → news item• has_read
Other conceptualizations possible, e.g. taking into accounttimestamps to explicitly model chains of link sharing)
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
A model
News exposure as network of users and news items
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
is (
near
ly)
iden
tica
l
News item 5
News item 4
News item 3
News item 2
topic = economy
source = ANP
date = 06-12-2015
frames = [human interest, conflict]
reads
reads
A
B
C
reads
reads
... ... ...
medium = nu.nl
medium = nrc.nl
age = 59
gender = M
age = 27
gender =F
News item 1 age = 59
gender = M
... ... ...readsis (nearly) identical
is (
near
ly)
iden
tica
l
News item 5
News item 4
News item 3
News item 2
topic = economy
source = ANP
date = 06-12-2015
frames = [human interest, conflict]
reads
reads
A
B
C
reads
reads
... ... ...
medium = nu.nl
medium = nrc.nl
age = 59
gender = M
age = 27
gender =F
News item 1 age = 59
gender = M
... ... ...readsis (nearly) identical
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
A model
Advantages
• It allows to predict which item a given person is exposed to –irrespective of the channel.
• However, if one is interested in the channel instead, one couldalso predict the channel.
• If the news items are time-stamped, one can also investigatehow information spreads in the news environment.
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
Implementation
Implementation
Data collection
• Collect info about user nodes with surveys• Use tracking for news nodes (user-news-edges)
Enriching the dataset
• cosine similarity, Levenshtein distance to determine (nearly)intical article
• automated content analysis to determine properties of articles
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
Implementation
Implementation
Data collection
• Collect info about user nodes with surveys• Use tracking for news nodes (user-news-edges)
Enriching the dataset
• cosine similarity, Levenshtein distance to determine (nearly)intical article
• automated content analysis to determine properties of articles
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Again, different conceptualizations would be possible
• outlets as additional nodes• directed edges for news flows (“originates_from”)• . . .
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
Implementation
Storing, accessing, and analyzing the data
• graph database• specific, derived datasets for each RQ at hand• e.g., collapsing nearly-identical articles, aggregating, . . .
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
Conclusion
• “outlet” becomes less and less a meaningful category• unbundling of news items• measure exposure to specific items• conceptualize (and store, analyze) as network of users anditems
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
Linking this to what we heard yesterday
• intentional vs non-intentional use: surveys are bad inmeasuring the latter
• Harsh’s conceptualization of overlap: outlets as nodes, doubleusage as edge weight
• avoids problems of site-centric measurements (Claes’ & Peter’spresentation and paper)
• and of course, this is one thing that I’ll do with the trackingdata Judith talked about
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling
Common assumptions Toward new theories of news flows Network of users and news items Conclusion
Questions?
[email protected]@damian0604
www.damiantrilling.net
www.personalised-communication.net
Conceptualizing and measuring news exposure as network of users and news items Damian Trilling