Using Accreditation to Using Accreditation to Promote DiversityPromote Diversity
Presented October 20, 2006Presented October 20, 2006AAC & U Conference on Inclusive ExcellenceAAC & U Conference on Inclusive Excellence
Ralph A. Wolff, President and Executive DirectorRalph A. Wolff, President and Executive DirectorAccrediting Commission for Senior Colleges and Universities Accrediting Commission for Senior Colleges and Universities
Western Association of Schools & CollegesWestern Association of Schools & Colleges
AAC & U October 2006AAC & U October 2006 22
What Are Our Core What Are Our Core Attitudes About:Attitudes About:
Diversity?Diversity?Accreditation?Accreditation?
AAC & U October 2006AAC & U October 2006 33
Where is Your Institution?Where is Your Institution?
Burden or Opportunity?Burden or Opportunity?
On a scale of 1- 4, where is your On a scale of 1- 4, where is your institution?institution?– 1= State of denial1= State of denial– 2= Willing only to deal with conflicts as 2= Willing only to deal with conflicts as
they arisethey arise– 3= Some data but little engagement3= Some data but little engagement– 4= Initiates dialogue and generates data 4= Initiates dialogue and generates data
out of deep commitment to serve all with out of deep commitment to serve all with excellenceexcellence
AAC & U October 2006AAC & U October 2006 44
The Biggest Obstacle to The Biggest Obstacle to Achieving Diversity Is The Achieving Diversity Is The
Belief It Already ExistsBelief It Already Exists
John Slaughter, PresidentJohn Slaughter, PresidentOccidental CollegeOccidental College
AAC & U October 2006AAC & U October 2006 55
Institutional ContextInstitutional Context
Proposition 209/legislation/court cases in Proposition 209/legislation/court cases in California, Texas, Washington, MichiganCalifornia, Texas, Washington, Michigan
Frequent lawsuits challenging diversity, Frequent lawsuits challenging diversity, speech codes, codes of conduct, etc.speech codes, codes of conduct, etc.
Horowitz amendmentHorowitz amendment
Surveys portraying how “liberal” professors Surveys portraying how “liberal” professors areare
Unwillingness to declare ethnic statusUnwillingness to declare ethnic status
AAC & U October 2006AAC & U October 2006 66
National Policy ContextNational Policy Context
““Leaky pipeline” – who gets inLeaky pipeline” – who gets in
Graduation rates – who gets outGraduation rates – who gets out
What happens when they are in What happens when they are in college? Are students learning college? Are students learning anything?anything?– NAAL surveyNAAL survey– Survey of college seniorsSurvey of college seniors– PISA studiesPISA studies
AAC & U October 2006AAC & U October 2006 77
Accreditation ReformAccreditation Reform
Revised standards in all regionsRevised standards in all regions
Period of major reformPeriod of major reform
Openness to institutional innovationOpenness to institutional innovation
Ability to use accreditation process to Ability to use accreditation process to focus on key institutional issuesfocus on key institutional issues
Institutional “themes” get sustained Institutional “themes” get sustained attentionattention
AAC & U October 2006AAC & U October 2006 88
Key Areas of ReformKey Areas of Reform
Focus on learning outcomes Focus on learning outcomes
New self-evaluation and visit modelsNew self-evaluation and visit models
Emphasis on a “culture of evidence” Emphasis on a “culture of evidence” and “organizational learning”and “organizational learning”
Shift to a value adding processShift to a value adding process
Accreditation as an agent of changeAccreditation as an agent of change
AAC & U October 2006AAC & U October 2006 99
Accreditation Standards on Accreditation Standards on Diversity – HLC/NCADiversity – HLC/NCA
In its mission documents, the organization recognizes the diversity of its learners, other constituencies, and the greatersociety it serves.
● In its mission documents, the organization addresses diversity within the community values and common purposes it considers fundamental to its mission.
● The mission documents present the organization’s function in a multicultural society.
● The mission documents affirm the organization’s commitment to honor the dignity and worth of individuals.
● The organization’s required codes of belief or expected behavior are congruent with its mission.
● The mission documents provide a basis for the organization’s basic strategies to address diversity.
AAC & U October 2006AAC & U October 2006 1010
HLC/NCA HLC/NCA
Core Component - 4c The organization assesses the usefulness of its curricula to students who will live and work in a global, diverse, and technological society.
Examples of Evidence ● Regular academic program reviews include attention to currency and
relevance of courses and programs.● In keeping with its mission, learning goals and outcomes include
skills and professional competence essential to a diverse workforce.● Learning outcomes document that graduates have gained the skills
and knowledge they need to function in diverse, local, national, and global societies.
AAC & U October 2006AAC & U October 2006 1111
MSA - CHEMSA - CHEConsistent with the institution’s mission, administration selection processes should give appropriate consideration to diversity in areas such as age, race, ethnicity, and gender. The administrative staff should work effectively as a team and work cooperatively with other constituencies of the institution.
An institution demonstrates integrity through the manner in which it specifies its goals, selects and retains its faculty, admits students, establishes curricula, determines programs of research, pursues its fields of service, demonstrates sensitivity to equity and diversity issues, allocates its resources, serves the public interest, and provides for the success of its students.
AAC & U October 2006AAC & U October 2006 1212
MSA (cont.)MSA (cont.)
Faculty selection processes should give appropriate consideration to the value of faculty diversity, consistent with institutional mission, in areas such as age, race, ethnicity, and gender.
An institution demonstrates integrity through the manner in which it specifies its goals, selects and retains its faculty, admits students, establishes curricula, determines programs of research, pursues its fields of service, demonstrates sensitivity to equity and diversity issues, allocates its resources, serves the public interest, and provides for the success of its students.
AAC & U October 2006AAC & U October 2006 1313
New England (NEASC)New England (NEASC)
The institution ensures equal employment opportunity consistent with legal requirements and any other dimensions of its own choosing; compatible with its mission and purposes, it addresses its own goals for the achievement of diversity of race, gender, and ethnicity. In providing services, in accordance with its mission and purposes, the institution adheres to both the spirit and intent of equal opportunity and its own goals for diversity.
AAC & U October 2006AAC & U October 2006 1414
WASC – Senior College WASC – Senior College CommissionCommission
Consistent with its purposes and Consistent with its purposes and character, the institution demonstrates character, the institution demonstrates an appropriate response to the an appropriate response to the increasing diversity in society through increasing diversity in society through its policies, its educational and co-its policies, its educational and co-curricular programs, and its curricular programs, and its administrative and organizational administrative and organizational practices.practices.
AAC & U October 2006AAC & U October 2006 1515
WASC – Sr.WASC – Sr.
Baccalaureate programs engage students in an Baccalaureate programs engage students in an integrated course of study of sufficient breadth and integrated course of study of sufficient breadth and depth to prepare them for work, citizenship, and a depth to prepare them for work, citizenship, and a fulfilling life. These programs also ensure the fulfilling life. These programs also ensure the development of core learning abilities and development of core learning abilities and competencies including, but not limited to, college-competencies including, but not limited to, college-level written and oral communication; college-level level written and oral communication; college-level quantitative skills; information literacy; and the habit quantitative skills; information literacy; and the habit of critical analysis of data and argument. In addition, of critical analysis of data and argument. In addition, baccalaureate programs actively foster an baccalaureate programs actively foster an understanding of diversity; civic responsibility; the understanding of diversity; civic responsibility; the ability to work with others; and the capability to ability to work with others; and the capability to engage in lifelong learning.engage in lifelong learning.
AAC & U October 2006AAC & U October 2006 1616
WASC Statement on DiversityWASC Statement on Diversity
Recognizes the comprehensive and Recognizes the comprehensive and multidimensional character of diversity multidimensional character of diversity issuesissues
Based on key assumption that diversity Based on key assumption that diversity is an integral element of excellenceis an integral element of excellence
Goes beyond representation to address Goes beyond representation to address respect for all students, campus respect for all students, campus climate, and educational programsclimate, and educational programs
AAC & U October 2006AAC & U October 2006 1717
Making Diversity a Key Focus of Making Diversity a Key Focus of AccreditationAccreditation
Hooks:Hooks:– MissionMission– Retention/graduation ratesRetention/graduation rates– Educational outcomesEducational outcomes– Assessment activities (including of diversity)Assessment activities (including of diversity)– Faculty recruitment and developmentFaculty recruitment and development– Faculty and staff developmentFaculty and staff development– Campus climateCampus climate– Program reviewProgram review– Resource allocationsResource allocations– Others?Others?
AAC & U October 2006AAC & U October 2006 1818
ExamplesExamples
California State University, East BayCalifornia State University, East BaySan Jose State UniversitySan Jose State UniversityUCLAUCLAUniversity of California, BerkeleyUniversity of California, BerkeleyChapman UniversityChapman UniversityLoyola Marymount UniversityLoyola Marymount UniversityMount Saint Mary’s CollegeMount Saint Mary’s CollegeBiola UniversityBiola University
AAC & U October 2006AAC & U October 2006 1919
Key ConsiderationsKey Considerations
Need to disaggregateNeed to disaggregate
Test assumptionsTest assumptions
Create a comprehensive approachCreate a comprehensive approach
Go for long term over episodicGo for long term over episodic
Find key advocatesFind key advocates
Embed diversity issues within other topicsEmbed diversity issues within other topics
AAC & U October 2006AAC & U October 2006 2020
““We are the ones we have We are the ones we have been waiting for.”been waiting for.”
Hopi eldersHopi elders
AAC & U October 2006AAC & U October 2006 2121
For Additional Information or For Additional Information or CommentsComments
Please contact Ralph Wolff Please contact Ralph Wolff [email protected]@wascsenior.org