Update of NTG Re-Organization
Colonel Marv MakulowichCanadian Army
10 May 2011
Directorate of Army Training
Direction de l’instruction de l’Armée de Terre
22
ACO Strategic PlanningACO Strategic PlanningACT Strategic PlanningACT Strategic Planning
Boards and WGsBoards and WGs(NTG, NPETN…)(NTG, NPETN…)
IMS, MCIMS, MC, , NationsNations
Management Management PlansPlans
Bi-SC Bi-SC CoordCoord
ACT ETEE Supporting PlansACT ETEE Supporting Plans ACO ETEE Supporting PlansACO ETEE Supporting Plans
SG ETEE conducts checks, provides additional D&G as requiredSG ETEE conducts checks, provides additional D&G as requiredFeedback provided to IMS and SACEURFeedback provided to IMS and SACEUR
NATO HQ,NATO HQ,Nations,Nations,
Other InputsOther Inputs
NMA SPOs,NMA SPOs,PPolol/Mil /Mil
GuidanceGuidance
SACEUR’s SACEUR’s Annual Annual
Guidence Guidence on ETEEon ETEE
NATO Training Organization
NATO UNCLASSIFIED
Military Committee Military Committee JSB/LSB/MSBJSB/LSB/MSB
SACTSACT
Steering Group Steering Group (SGNTG)(SGNTG)
Executive Working Group Executive Working Group (EWGNTG)(EWGNTG)
NTG /Pol NTG /Pol SectionSection
NSANSA
Bi SCBi SCSG ETEESG ETEE
MPBMPB
TEPTEPSACT SACT WGWG
SHAPE SHAPE WGWG
Bi-SC ETEEP WG
SHAPESHAPE
MCMC
NTG/Pol NTG/Pol SectionSection
DCOS JFT DCOS JFT CHAIRCHAIR
DCOS JFT DCOS JFT CHAIRCHAIR
MTECMTEC NITECNITECNTECNTEC
NTG Service Task Groups + NTG Service Task Groups + NTG Task GroupsNTG Task Groups
Standardization: Standardization: STANAGsSTANAGs
NTG within ETEE System
NTEC: NTEC: MTEPMTEP
NITEC: NITEC: ITEPITEP
SG ETEE: SG ETEE: SAGE + Action PlansSAGE + Action Plans
NTG Service Task Groups + NTG Task Groups NTG Service Task Groups + NTG Task Groups to perform to perform
the the NTG Program of Work (POW)NTG Program of Work (POW)
NPETN: NPETN: Enable ETEE events and activitiesEnable ETEE events and activities
NATO-Partner Education and NATO-Partner Education and Training Network (NPETN)Training Network (NPETN)
BackgroundBackground
• National input into NTG TORs summer/fall 2010• ASG Nuremburg Oct 2011• NTGSG – Brussells Oct 2010• Interim EWGNTG Jan 2011 Brussells• NTG/NTEC/NTEP – Talinn – Feb 2011• First EWGNTG Paris Mar 2011
•
How should the How should the new NTG organization work?new NTG organization work?
ACTACT
SGNTGSGNTGto steerto steer
CM: CM: DCOS JFT HQ SACTDCOS JFT HQ SACTCo-CM: Co-CM: national Co-CMnational Co-CM
MCJSBMCJSB
EWGNTGEWGNTGto execute/to execute/coordinatecoordinate
NTGSTGs + NTGTGsNTGSTGs + NTGTGsto perform POW to perform POW
CM:CM: Branch Head EPAE HQ SACT Branch Head EPAE HQ SACTCo-CM: Co-CM: national Co-CMnational Co-CM
CM:CM: NATO Staff Officer NATO Staff OfficerCo-CM:Co-CM: national Co-CM national Co-CM
CM:CM: NATO Staff Officer NATO Staff OfficerCo-CM:Co-CM: national Co-CM national Co-CM
CM:CM: NATO Staff Officer NATO Staff OfficerCo-CM:Co-CM: national Co-CM national Co-CM
1st STEERING GROUP NTG MEETING 2011Tallinn/ESTONIA, 10-11 February 2011
1. NTG Annual Report achievements past year
2. NTG mandatesstatus old mandates new mandates requirements
3.NATO Individual Training & Education Conference (NITEC)
NATO Training & Exercise Conference (NTEC)NATO & Partners’ Education and Training Network (NPETN)
Feedback/Input Training Synchronization Conference
4.NATO Education, Training, Exercise and Evaluation (ETEE)
issues, shortfalls & requirementsSAGE, JALLC reports, SWGI etc.
5. Most pressing capability needs in NATO NATO summits
6. training standardization issues & requirements &
Training STANAG portfolio MCJSB/NSA
7. nations’ requests all
8. review TOR NTG + NTG Order of Business MC 238/4 (regular updates)
9. approval of NTG mandates and NTG Program of Work NTG POW
“To have” on NTG Standard Agenda
Three options:1.Keep the WG and task it as TGNTG with a mandate to perform a specific task.
2.Move the WG to another NATO organization or subordinate or merge it with another existing NATO structure/board/group where synergies are at hand.
3.Disband the WG because of a missing requirements or NTG mandate.
Transition of former NTG WGs iaw MC 238/4
• 6 x NTGTGsMandates until 2011-12• IT&ED Task Group• PRT TRG Task Group• TEPSO Task Group• LOAC TRG Task Group• NUO TRG Task Group
Financial Sub Group
(FSG) under MCJSB)
Environmental Training WG (ETWG under EPWG)
CBRN NTGTG (MC/CNAD merger on CBRN)
Interim mandate until 31 DEC 11
• 3 x NTG STGs(ARSTG, NASTG, AFSTG )
Transition proposal for NTG
Change to TGs
Training Simulation WG(under NMSG/MORS)
International Special Training Centre WG (ISTCWG)
Aircrew Human Factors WG (AHFWG)
Civil Military Licenses WG (CMLWG)
Remove from NTG Move/merge
Going fromNTG in 2010
99
New StructureNTG in 2011
1010
ACTACT
SGNTGSGNTG to steerto steerCM: DCOS JFT HQ SACTCM: DCOS JFT HQ SACTCo-CM: national Co-CM: national
EWGNTGEWGNTG to execute/coordinateto execute/coordinateCM: Branch Head EPAE HQ SACTCM: Branch Head EPAE HQ SACTCo-CM: national Co-CM: national
3 NTGSTGs + 3 NTGSTGs + xx NTGTGs???xx NTGTGs??? to perform mandates to perform mandates CM: NATO Staff OfficerCM: NATO Staff OfficerCo-CM: national Co-CM: national
NTG in 2012
Main changesMain changes
• No permanent WG structureNo permanent WG structure • TGs limited in scopeTGs limited in scope • Remarkable reduction in the Remarkable reduction in the number of WGs/TGsnumber of WGs/TGs
• Formal link with NSA establishedFormal link with NSA established
• All levels chaired by NATO staff All levels chaired by NATO staff officers (subject owner from NATO)officers (subject owner from NATO)
NATO UNCLASSIFIEDNATO UNCLASSIFIED1212
MC/WG MMC/WG M
• SGNTGSGNTG- Senior body within NTG provides direction and Senior body within NTG provides direction and guidance to EWGNTG and co-ordinate with guidance to EWGNTG and co-ordinate with MCJSB.MCJSB.- Decide on specific Task Group and their mandate.Decide on specific Task Group and their mandate.(to direct continuation of current SG work or to (to direct continuation of current SG work or to discontinue TG work not longer required)discontinue TG work not longer required) - Comprised of national training representatives Comprised of national training representatives from MOD level (ETEE decision makers).from MOD level (ETEE decision makers).
- CM: DCOS JFT, HQ SACTCM: DCOS JFT, HQ SACT
- DCM: National Representative (period of 2 years)DCM: National Representative (period of 2 years)
NATO UNCLASSIFIEDNATO UNCLASSIFIED1313
MC/WG MMC/WG M
• EWGNTGEWGNTG- Executive body provides permanent network for Executive body provides permanent network for consultation and NTG project approval. consultation and NTG project approval. - Identifies standardisation projects and assigns this Identifies standardisation projects and assigns this task to NTGTG.task to NTGTG.
- CM: Branch Head ACT ETE Policy Analysis and CM: Branch Head ACT ETE Policy Analysis and Education BranchEducation Branch
- DCM: National Representative (period of 2 years)DCM: National Representative (period of 2 years)
- Co-Chair and Standardization Secretary from NSA: Co-Chair and Standardization Secretary from NSA: for standardization issuesfor standardization issues
NATO UNCLASSIFIEDNATO UNCLASSIFIED1414
MC/WG MMC/WG M
• NTGTGNTGTG- Specific Projects with limited scope.Specific Projects with limited scope.- Comprised of national and NATO SMEs.Comprised of national and NATO SMEs.- Provides flexible use of national and NATOProvides flexible use of national and NATO resources.resources.
- CM: NATO Staff OfficerCM: NATO Staff Officer
- DCM: National Representative (period of 2 years)DCM: National Representative (period of 2 years)
NATO UNCLASSIFIED RELEASABLE TO EU/PfP/MD/ICI/AFGHANISTAN/AUSTRALIA/JAPAN/NEW ZEALAND/PAKISTAN/SOUTH KOREA
NATO UNCLASSIFIED RELEASABLE TO EU/PfP/MD/ICI/AFGHANISTAN/AUSTRALIA/JAPAN/NEW ZEALAND/PAKISTAN/SOUTH KOREA
NTGSTGs Mandates
Developed according to MC 0238/4 approved 05 Nov 2010:
“…Service Task Groups will receive tasking by the EWGNTG….” (para 5.c.)
NATO UNCLASSIFIED RELEASABLE TO EU/PfP/MD/ICI/AFGHANISTAN/AUSTRALIA/JAPAN/NEW ZEALAND/PAKISTAN/SOUTH KOREA
NATO UNCLASSIFIED RELEASABLE TO EU/PfP/MD/ICI/AFGHANISTAN/AUSTRALIA/JAPAN/NEW ZEALAND/PAKISTAN/SOUTH KOREA
NTGSTGs Mandates
- 1 Mandate for the 3 Service Task Groups: Air Force Service Task Group Army Service Task Group Naval Service Task Group
- Mandate approved at the SGNTG Meeting
NATO UNCLASSIFIED RELEASABLE TO EU/PfP/MD/ICI/AFGHANISTAN/AUSTRALIA/JAPAN/NEW ZEALAND/PAKISTAN/SOUTH KOREA
NATO UNCLASSIFIED RELEASABLE TO EU/PfP/MD/ICI/AFGHANISTAN/AUSTRALIA/JAPAN/NEW ZEALAND/PAKISTAN/SOUTH KOREA
NTGSTGs MandatesSERVICE TASK GROUPS (AFSTG – ARSTG - NASTG)
- Chairman: NATO Staff Officer: AFSTG: Air CCs (TBC) ARSTG: Component Commander / JFC (TBC) NASTG: Maritime CCs (TBC)
AT THIS STAGE NO NATO CM HAS BEEN IDENTIFIEDAn official letter from ACT to ACO will be sent soon.
- Co-Chairman: elected amongst the national representatives at the Spring meeting
NATO UNCLASSIFIED RELEASABLE TO EU/PfP/MD/ICI/AFGHANISTAN/AUSTRALIA/JAPAN/NEW ZEALAND/PAKISTAN/SOUTH KOREA
NATO UNCLASSIFIED RELEASABLE TO EU/PfP/MD/ICI/AFGHANISTAN/AUSTRALIA/JAPAN/NEW ZEALAND/PAKISTAN/SOUTH KOREA
NTGSTGs Mandates
AUTHORITY
The AFSTG, ARSTG and NASTG:
-Operate under the authority of MC 0238/4;-Present project proposals to the EWGNTG;-Receive tasking by the EWGNTG;-No WGs/TGs subordinated.
NATO UNCLASSIFIED RELEASABLE TO EU/PfP/MD/ICI/AFGHANISTAN/AUSTRALIA/JAPAN/NEW ZEALAND/PAKISTAN/SOUTH KOREA
NATO UNCLASSIFIED RELEASABLE TO EU/PfP/MD/ICI/AFGHANISTAN/AUSTRALIA/JAPAN/NEW ZEALAND/PAKISTAN/SOUTH KOREA
NTGSTGs Mandates
AIM
The AFSTG, ARSTG and NASTG, in the field of air, land and maritime ETEE, are established to improve the coordination and standardization of ETEE in order to enhance interoperability among Alliance forces, and additionally between the forces of partners.
NATO UNCLASSIFIED RELEASABLE TO EU/PfP/MD/ICI/AFGHANISTAN/AUSTRALIA/JAPAN/NEW ZEALAND/PAKISTAN/SOUTH KOREA
NATO UNCLASSIFIED RELEASABLE TO EU/PfP/MD/ICI/AFGHANISTAN/AUSTRALIA/JAPAN/NEW ZEALAND/PAKISTAN/SOUTH KOREA
NTGSTGs Mandates
AIM
The AFSTG, ARSTG and NASTG act as a multinational group of air, land and maritime ETEE experts, responsible for NTG air, land and maritime ETEE aspects.
NATO UNCLASSIFIED RELEASABLE TO EU/PfP/MD/ICI/AFGHANISTAN/AUSTRALIA/JAPAN/NEW ZEALAND/PAKISTAN/SOUTH KOREA
NATO UNCLASSIFIED RELEASABLE TO EU/PfP/MD/ICI/AFGHANISTAN/AUSTRALIA/JAPAN/NEW ZEALAND/PAKISTAN/SOUTH KOREA
NTGSTGs MandatesORGANISATION
The Service TGs are comprised of:a.CM: a NATO Staff Officer with responsibilities in the particular topic area, who reports directly to the CM EWGNTG.b. Co-CM: elected amongst the national representatives. Subject to the duration of the project work, the Co-CM is normally elected for a period of 2 years.c. NATO and national (including partner) SMEs as required.d. When required, appropriate representation from NSA to ensure compliance with AAP-3.
NATO UNCLASSIFIED RELEASABLE TO EU/PfP/MD/ICI/AFGHANISTAN/AUSTRALIA/JAPAN/NEW ZEALAND/PAKISTAN/SOUTH KOREA
NATO UNCLASSIFIED RELEASABLE TO EU/PfP/MD/ICI/AFGHANISTAN/AUSTRALIA/JAPAN/NEW ZEALAND/PAKISTAN/SOUTH KOREA
NTGSTGs MandatesCHAIRMANSHIP AND SECRETARY
CHAIRMAN Co-CHAIRMAN
AFSTG
Air CCs nations
ARSTG
Component Commander / JFC
nations
NASTG
Maritime CCs nationsThe Chairmanship provides the Secretary of the STG.
NATO UNCLASSIFIED RELEASABLE TO EU/PfP/MD/ICI/AFGHANISTAN/AUSTRALIA/JAPAN/NEW ZEALAND/PAKISTAN/SOUTH KOREA
NATO UNCLASSIFIED RELEASABLE TO EU/PfP/MD/ICI/AFGHANISTAN/AUSTRALIA/JAPAN/NEW ZEALAND/PAKISTAN/SOUTH KOREA
NTGSTGs Mandates
REPORT
The AFSTG, ARSTG and NASTG have to submit the Annual Report to the EWGNTG in a written form by the end of October of each year.The AFSTG, ARSTG and NASTG CMs report to the CM EWGNTG through the submission of minutes (Record of Proceedings) after each meeting, proposals for new TGs and making proposals for new mandates.
Proposed NTG Order of Business
NTGTGsNTGTGs
APR-JUNAPR-JUN JUL-SEPJUL-SEP OCT-DECOCT-DECJAN-MARJAN-MAR
REPORTING PROCESSREPORTING PROCESSDIRECTIVE & GUIDANCE PROCESSDIRECTIVE & GUIDANCE PROCESS
NTGSTGsNTGSTGs
ad-hocad-hoc
ETEE ETEE shortfalls&shortfalls&requirements requirements (SAGE, LL)(SAGE, LL)
D&GD&GREPREP
REPREP
EWGNTGEWGNTG
SGNTG SGNTG MeetingMeeting
Inputs SGNTGInputs SGNTG
NTEC+NITEC NTEC+NITEC +NPETN +NPETN
NTG annual NTG annual reportreport
standardization standardization issues (NSA)issues (NSA)
POWPOW
AFSTGAFSTG
EWGNTGEWGNTG
NTGTGsNTGTGs NTGSTGsNTGSTGs
ad-hocad-hoc
ad-hocad-hoc
ARSTGARSTG
NASTGNASTG ad-hocad-hoc
nations’ nations’ requestsrequests
WORKING PROCESSWORKING PROCESS WORKING PROCESSWORKING PROCESS
Agenda or Agenda or Read-AheadRead-Ahead
NATO: NATO: capabilities capabilities
AFSTGAFSTG ARSTGARSTG
NASTGNASTG
EWGNTGEWGNTG (ad –hoc, if required)(ad –hoc, if required)
SACT/SGNTGSACT/SGNTG
NTG Mandates NTG Mandates & proposals& proposals