JanetAmos,March2016 1
Tisplan Questionnaire Analysis of Results The TisPlan questionnaire was distributed personally by a team of community volunteers to every household in the Neighbourhood Area of Tisbury and West Tisbury during October 2015.
This was a successful consultation generating a good evidence base for future Neighbourhood Planning decision-making. Although the printing costs were relatively expensive compared with an online survey and the door-to-door collection was time consuming, nevertheless it was clearly the right decision in terms of the methodology adopted. Questionnaire feedback re the age of respondents and the stated requirement for IT and computing courses, indicates that an on-line questionnaire most probably would not have realised such a positive and significant response rate.
There were 671 responses which represented a 47% response rate and statistically is a sufficient response for valid findings.
Over one third of the respondents provided comments and feedback. Again this is statistically significant and indicative of an extremely engaged, informed and interested community with strong opinions. There are clear mandates for action and decision-making. There is an expectation that the information will be shared with those who can influence outcomes. It is important that the NP Steering Group and the Parish councils show how these responses have influenced thinking and future decision making: eg
• The importance of the availability of parking • The lack of interest in the provision of cycle racks and facilities for the use of bicycles • The importance of housing design which should not be left to developers to dictate to the
community
Some elements of the questionnaire generated a huge weight of opinion from the community which will provide good evidence for the development of plan policies and objectives.
NB All reference to ‘Tisbury’ in the following text is shorthand for ‘Tisbury and West Tisbury Neighbourhood Plan Area.’
JanetAmos,March2016 2
Results of the questionnaire
Question 1 Numbers of residents per household by age group
101 97
148
182
358368
108
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
Ages0-11 Ages12-18 Ages19-35 Ages36-50 Ages51-65 Ages66-80�Ages81+
Totalnum
berrepo
rted
ineachcategory-Allho
useh
olds
Q1-Howmanypeopleliveinyourhouseholdperagegroup?
JanetAmos,March2016 3
Question 2. Length of Residency
Lessthan1year;5%
1-5years;19%
6-10years;14%
11-24years;23%
25+years;39%
Q2 How long have you lived in the Neighbourhood Area?
JanetAmos,March2016 4
Question 3. Why do people live in Tisbury and West Tisbury?
Question 4. Future needs for types of housing accommodation
320
242
309 320
126 125
92
173143
60
221
38 37
117
44
85
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Num
ber o
f res
pons
es
Q3 What brought you to live here?
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
Lowcoststarterhom
e
Shared
owne
rship
Affo
rdablere
nted
-ho
using
Affo
rdablere
nted
-bu
sine
ss
Busine
ss/Com
mercialspace
ReOrem
enta
ccom
mod
aOon
-inde
pend
ent
ReOrem
enta
ccom
mod
aOon
-assisted
living
Smalleraccommod
aOon
Largeraccom
mod
aOon
Manufacturingspace/w
orksho
p
Q4Likelyaccommoda@onrequirementsby2026
Ranking5-verylikely
Ranking4
Ranking3
Ranking2
Ranking1-notatalllikely
JanetAmos,March2016 5
16%
8%
17%
3%4%17%
13%
13%
6% 3%
Q4Likelyaccommoda@onrequirementsby2026AnalysisofRank5-verylikely Lowcoststarterhome
Sharedownership
Affordablerented-housing
Affordablerented-business
Business/Commercialspace
ReOrementaccommodaOon-independent
ReOrementaccommodaOon-assistedliving
SmalleraccommodaOon
LargeraccommodaOon
Manufacturingspace/workshop
JanetAmos,March2016 6
Question 5. Where should new homes be built by 2026?
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
Onbrownfieldsites
Inthehamlets Convertexis@ngcommercial
Ongreenfieldsites Plotsoflandbetweenexis@ng
buildings
Convertredundantagriculturalbuildings
Whereshouldnewhomesbebuiltby2026?
Ranking5-mostpreferred
Ranking4
Ranking3
Ranking2
Ranking1-leastpreferred
50%
5%
13%
2%
11%
19%
Q5Whereshouldnewhomesbebuiltby2026?Ranking5-Mostpreferred
Onbrownfieldsites
Inthehamlets
Convertexis@ngcommercial
Ongreenfieldsites
Plotsoflandbetweenexis@ngbuildings
Convertredundantagriculturalbuildings
JanetAmos,March2016 7
Question 6. There are 5 known Brownfield Sites – how would you like to see these sites used if they come forward for re-development?
19%
14%
19%14%
10%
3%
6%
6%
1%0%0%
0%0%0%
2%
1%
0%
1% 0%0%0%0%0%0%
3%
Q6UseofSta@onWorks Housing
Commercial
Parking
Mixed
Affordable
Elderlycare
Employment
Noanswer
Bridgeovertrack
Starterhomes
Tunnel
College
Supermarket
Industrial
SecondplaVorm
Flats
Allotments
Retail
Unsuitable
Wildlife
Community
Childcare
Youthclub
Medical/Clinic
Anything
JanetAmos,March2016 8
27%
7%
14%
6%
14%
12%
4%
9%
0%0% 0%0%
0%
0%0%
1%0%
1%
1%0%
3%
0%0%
0%0%
Q6OldMagistrates'Court Housing
Commercial
Parking
Mixed
Affordable
Elderlycare
Employment
Noanswer
Bridgeovertrack
Starterhomes
Tunnel
College
Supermarket
Industrial
SecondplaVorm
Flats
Allotments
Retail
Unsuitable
Wildlife
Community
Childcare
Youthclub
Medical/Clinic
Anything
32%
3%
14%6%
14%
13%
1%6%
0%0%0%0%0%0%0%1%
0% 1%
6%
1% 2%0%0%0%0%Q6LandadjacenttoTrellisHouse Housing
Commercial
Parking
Mixed
Affordable
Elderlycare
Employment
Noanswer
Bridgeovertrack
Starterhomes
Tunnel
College
Supermarket
Industrial
SecondplaVorm
Flats
Allotments
Retail
Unsuitable
Wildlife
Community
Childcare
Youthclub
Medical/Clinic
Anything
JanetAmos,March2016 9
49%
9%2%
10%
13%
2% 3%
5%
0%0%0%
0%
0%
0%
0% 0%0%0%
5%
1% 0%0%0%0%0%
Q6WiltsCouncilhighwaysdepot Housing
Commercial
Parking
Mixed
Affordable
Elderlycare
Employment
Noanswer
Bridgeovertrack
Starterhomes
Tunnel
College
Supermarket
Industrial
SecondplaVorm
Flats
Allotments
Retail
Unsuitable
Wildlife
Community
Childcare
Youthclub
Medical/Clinic
Anything
46%
8%1%
11%
12%
3%
2%3%
0%0%0%0%0%0%0%
0%
0%
0%
8%4%
0%0%0%0%0%
Q6Disusedquarry-Tuckingmill Housing
Commercial
Parking
Mixed
Affordable
Elderlycare
Employment
Noanswer
Bridgeovertrack
Starterhomes
Tunnel
College
Supermarket
Industrial
SecondplaVorm
Flats
Allotments
Retail
Unsuitable
Wildlife
Community
Childcare
Youthclub
Medical/Clinic
Anything
JanetAmos,March2016 10
Q7 and Q8 Significant ‘Green’ Spaces in the neighbourhood area.
Question 9 Greenfield sites that have already been proposed as potential development sites – are you in favour of the development of these sites for housing?
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
Q7Howimportantisitthattheseareasareprotectedfromdetrimentaldevelopment?
Ranking5-VeryimportantRanking4
Ranking3
Ranking2
Ranking1-leastimportant
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
NorthofVicarageRoad
Tuckingstones SouthoftheAvenue
ChurchillEstate Tuckingfold,HindonLane
Q9AreyouinfavourofthedevelopmentoftheseGreenfieldsitesforhousing? Ranking5-
Stronglyinfavour
Ranking4
Ranking3
Ranking2
Ranking1-Stronglyagainst
JanetAmos,March2016 11
12%
8%
18%
8%
54%
NorthofVicarageRoad
Ranking5-Stronglyinfavour
Ranking4
Ranking3
Ranking2
Ranking1-Stronglyagainst
13%
7%
13%
6%
61%
SouthoftheAvenue
20%
13%
29%
7%
31%
Tuckingstones
19%
13%
23%8%
37%
Tuckingfold,HindonLane17%
10%
22%8%
43%
ChurchillEstate
JanetAmos,March2016 12
Question10 Is there anywhere else in the neighbourhood area where development would be appropriate?
This was a free-form question inviting respondents to put forward any other sites which had not yet been proposed. The results have not yet been fully analysed, but several small sites have been proposed for consideration.
JanetAmos,March2016 13
Question 11 How important is it that the parish councils should be consulted
re planning issues?
82%
10%
6%
0%2%
Howimportantisitthatparishcouncilsareconsultedinformallybeforeplanningapplica@onsaresubmibed?
Ranking5-Veryimportant
Ranking4
Ranking3
Ranking2
Ranking1-Notatallimportant
JanetAmos,March2016 14
Question12 Design of new buildings and their preferred features
21%
3%
3%
17%
21%
1%
8%
8%
11%
7%
Whatlook/featuresshouldnewbuildingshave?Ranking5-mostimportant
InkeepingwithnearbybuildingsSpaceforworkingfromhomeInnova@vedesigns
FeaturestoreduceenergycostsParkingspace
Lectodeveloper
Recrea@onareaforchildrenWalkingdistancetoshops/ameni@esOutsidespace
Garage
JanetAmos,March2016 15
Question13. What is the occupation of the household’s main earner?
Question14. How far away from home does the main earner work?
11213 8 10 9 14 2
1121622
2 7 3
49
6 2
158
1 119
231
217
1211511
10
50
100
150
200
250
Agr
icul
ture
A
rchi
tect
A
rt &
cra
ft Av
iatio
n C
ivil
Ser
vice
C
leric
al
Con
stru
ctio
n C
ounc
il E
ngin
eerin
g E
stat
e Fi
nanc
e H
ealth
care
In
sura
nce
Jour
nalis
m/
Pub
lishi
ng
Lega
l M
anag
emen
t M
ilita
ry
Mus
ic
Not
giv
en
Par
t-tim
e R
elig
ion
Ret
ail
Ret
ired
Sci
ence
S
elf-
Stu
dent
Te
achi
ng
Tech
nolo
gy
Tran
spor
t U
nem
ploy
ed
Num
ber o
f Res
pons
es
What is the occupation of the main earner?
24%
15%
30%
31%
Howfarfromhomedoesthemainearnerwork?
Athome
<5miles
6-20miles
>20miles
JanetAmos,March2016 16
Question 15. Modes of travel to work
Question16. What would persuade respondents to use alternative forms of transport?
10%
3%1%
55%
4%
23%
2%2%
Howdoesthemainearnertraveltowork?
Walk
Cycle
Motorbike
Car/Van
Carshare
Train
Bus
Other
6%
14%
31%
8%
10%
31%
Whatwouldpersuadeyoutomakemoreuseofalterna@veformsoftransport?
Ranking5-Mostlikely
Vehiclesharingschemes
Improvedfootpaths
Improvedcoordina@onofbuses/trains
Provisionofmorecycleracks
Electriccarchargingpoints
LatertrainsfromSal/Ldn
JanetAmos,March2016 17
Questions 17, 19a & 20 Future job opportunities, local skills base and training
4%9%
14%
4%
5%
7%
4%5%2%5%
6%
4%
4%
3%
9%
4%
9%
Whatfuturejobopportuni@eswouldberelevanttoyou?Ranking5-Mostpreferred Agriculturalworking
Training,educaOon,skills,apprenOceshipsHealthandmedicalservicesLeisureindustry
Hospitality
Internet
Manufacturing
Professionalservices
Self-employment
HorOcultural
RuraltradesandcraYs
Sport-related
Music/performingarts
TouristaccommodaOon
Caringservices
Buildingtrades
Retail
JanetAmos,March2016 18
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
Num
ber o
f res
pons
es
Q 19a What courses would you like to attend / see provided at the new Campus?
JanetAmos,March2016 19
Questions18 and 19 Business and Commercial requirements
6%3%
6%
25%60%
Q19Business/CommercialPremisesRanking5-Verylikely/important
Requirenewbusinesspremises
MakeuseofbusinessincubaOon
OffernewjobsinTisbury
ProximitytorailwaystaOon
Availabilityofhighspeedbroadband
JanetAmos,March2016 20
Question 21 Community Priorities for the use of CIL (Community Infrastructure Levy) monies
1%1% 5%4%
13%
6%
6%
3%1%
6%4%9%
6%
8%
3%
9%
7%
8%
WhatprojectsshouldCILmoniesfund?Ranking5-Mostimportant
Communitybicyclescheme
Morecycleracks
Communitytransport
Improveflooddefences
Provisionoffreecarparking
EnergyefficiencyforcommunitybuildingsRenewableenergyini@a@ves
PicnicsitesbyRiverNadder
Touristinforma@oncentre
GrantsforimprovementstocommunitybuildingsEnhancelocalstreetenvironmentConserveandmanagegreenspacesImproveplayparksandrecrea@ongroundsFurtherimprovementstoswimmingpoolPurchaseland/propertyforcommunityinvestmentSupportfacili@esforlocalcommunitygroupsCon@nuedprovisionofpublicconveniencesImprovefootpathsandrightsofway