Valuation & Financial Opinions Dispute Advisory & Forensic Services
Redemption Approach to Leveraged ESOP Transactions
Scott D. Levine, CPA/ABV, CFA, ASA Managing Director Stout Risius Ross, Inc.
Peter H. Briggs Managing Director Shareholder Strategies, Inc.
Valuation & Financial Opinions Dispute Advisory & Forensic Services 2
CLASSIC LEVERAGED ESOP
BANK
Front-end Loan Principal + InterestPayments
COMPANY
Principal + InterestPayments
Interior Loan Contributions
Stock STOCK-ESOP HOLDERS
Cash
Valuation & Financial Opinions Dispute Advisory & Forensic Services 3
SELLER-FINANCED ESOPLoan Thru Company
COMPANY P+I
LoanShareholderDistributions Contributions
Loan
Stock STOCK-ESOP HOLDERS
Principal and InterestPayments Cash
Valuation & Financial Opinions Dispute Advisory & Forensic Services 4
Illustration Assume FMV of Company Stock is a total of $10,000,000 1,000,000 Shares Outstanding Purchase price equals FMV and is $10.00 per share ESOP purchases 100% of the stock for $10.0 million Purchase is entirely funded with debt Assume seller note for $10.0 million to the Company This seller note is 10 years, level principal, $1.0 million per year A back-to-back loan from the Company to the ESOP for $10.0 million The “Inside” loan from the Company to the ESOP is 15 years, level principal The 15-year ESOP loan provides cash flow savings to the Company by virtue of
the tax-deductibility of principal payments on the ESOP loan These tax savings result in a post-deal value of $1.5 million or $1.50 per share Note that the ESOP is the buyer. This would be required for the Section 1042 Tax-
Free Rollover
Valuation & Financial Opinions Dispute Advisory & Forensic Services 5
Recovery in Value as Debt Repaid After just one year, $1.0 million of seller debt should be
repaid. This alone should cause value (all else equal) to
recover to $2.5 million or $2.50 per share. This represents a 67% growth in the price per share in year 1.
Valuation & Financial Opinions Dispute Advisory & Forensic Services 6
DOL’s “Dollar for Dollar” Position
The DOL does not like the Post-Deal drop in Value They are troubled that the asset being purchased by
the ESOP is immediately less than the ESOP paid for it
Valuation & Financial Opinions Dispute Advisory & Forensic Services 7
Dole v. Farnum DOL files lawsuit in 1990 against independent ESOP Trustee 1985 ESOP transaction at Wardwell Braiding Machine Company ESOP purchased 80% of the Company, largely funded with debt from Fleet DOL alleges that Trustee paid more than Adequate Consideration because
the appraisal did not take into account the necessary future debt service to Fleet
Therefore, the ESOP loan was not an Exempt Loan Therefore, it was alleged to be a Prohibited Transaction Huge outcry among the business, labor and ESOP community DOL withdraws suit later that same year Note that ESOPs were specifically intended by Congress to be not only an employee benefit but also to be used as a tool of corporate finance. They were intended to borrow money. That is the whole point behind the exempt loan rules.
Valuation & Financial Opinions Dispute Advisory & Forensic Services 8
What Is The Typical ESOP Candidate?
A closely held corporation (C or S corporation) One or more owners nearing retirement Company needs tax favored capital In closely-held company, generally no (or limited) family
involvement in business History of profitability Comfort with the concept of employee ownership Stable employee population Successor management in place or in the wings Available corporate credit Focus on organic growth
Valuation & Financial Opinions Dispute Advisory & Forensic Services 9
REDEMPTION APPROACH
STOCK-HOLDERS
Sell Stock to Company Note Principal + InterestPayments
COMPANY
Principal + InterestPayments
Sells Treas. Stock to ESOP Contributionsand Distrib's
ESOP
Valuation & Financial Opinions Dispute Advisory & Forensic Services 10
Advantages of Redemption Approach
Avoids the Post-deal drop in value issue Reduces contribution levels to service ESOP debt and can
therefore avoid Section 404 problems (limits on Plan contributions)
Safer from a Fiduciary standpoint – ESOP might purchase its stock at a price that is somewhat lower than even the post-debt value
Valuation & Financial Opinions Dispute Advisory & Forensic Services 11
Disadvantages of Redemption Approach
Cannot elect tax-free Section 1042 rollover. ESOP must be the buyer in that case
Valuation & Financial Opinions Dispute Advisory & Forensic Services 12
Redemption Transaction Redemption Transaction Illustration
In U.S. DollarsLow High
Guideline Company Method 11,000$ 14,000$ Discounted Cash Flow Method 10,000 13,000
Concluded Enterprise Value 10,500$ 13,500$
Less: Interest-Bearing Debt (2,000) (2,000) Add: Cash and Cash Equivalents 1,000 1,000 Total Adjustments to Enterprise Value (1,000) (1,000)
Fair Market Value of Equity (Rounded) 9,500$ 12,500$
Redemption Price
ESOP Purchase
Indicated Range of Value
$10,000
$2,500
Valuation & Financial Opinions Dispute Advisory & Forensic Services 13
Post-Transaction Value Post-Transaction Fair Market Value of Common Stock
In U.S. DollarsPost-Transaction
Implied Enterprise Value (Rounded) 10,500$ 13,500$
Add: Cash and Cash Equivalents 1,000 1,000 Less: Existing Debt (2,000) (2,000) Less: Senior Subordinated Term (7,000) (7,000) Less: Subordinated Seller Notes (3,000) (3,000) Add: Present Value of ESOP Debt Tax Benefit 1,000 1,000 Total Adjustments to Enterprise Value (10,000) (10,000)
Marketable, Controlling-Interest Value of Equity 500$ 3,500$
Less: Discount for Limited Marketability 5.0% (25) (175)
Fair Market Value of Equity (Rounded) 500$ 3,300$
Divided by: Common Shares Outstanding 100.0 100.0
Estimated Post-Transaction Fair Market Value Per Share of Common Stock 5.00$ 33.00$
Per Share Strike Price of Warrants
Indicated Value
$10.00
Valuation & Financial Opinions Dispute Advisory & Forensic Services 14
What is a Warrant?
A warrant is a security similar to a stock option that entitles a holder to buy the underlying stock of the issuing company at a fixed exercise price for a specified period of time. A warrant is frequently attached to bonds allowing the issuer (ESOP company) to pay a lower interest rate and can also be used to enhance the yield of the bond.
Valuation & Financial Opinions Dispute Advisory & Forensic Services 15
Why Are Warrants Used in ESOP Transactions?
With less access to capital from more traditional financing sources seller financing is often used as an alternative form of capital to help finance an ESOP Transaction
Almost always utilized in highly leveraged deals The ESOP transaction creates significant leverage and a lower
interest rate combined with warrants reduces an ESOP company’s cash obligations post-transaction
Sellers will pay taxes at ordinary income levels for the interest earned on their seller notes but can pay the long-term capital gains tax rate on the appreciation of warrants.
Valuation & Financial Opinions Dispute Advisory & Forensic Services 16
Overview of Seller Debt and Warrant Position
$3 million of seller debt Interest rate of 5% and warrant equal to 20% of stock
post-transaction Targeted IRR – 15%
Valuation & Financial Opinions Dispute Advisory & Forensic Services 17
IRR Calculation
In U.S. Dollars
12/31/2013 12/31/2014 12/31/2015 12/31/2016 12/31/2017 12/31/2018 12/31/2019 12/31/2020 12/31/2021
Initial Outlay (3,000)$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$
Interest Payments [a] 0 150 150 150 150 120 90 60 30 Principal Payments 0 0 0 0 600 600 600 600 600
Payment for Warrants 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3,400
Total Debt Cash Flows (3,000)$ 150$ 150$ 150$ 750$ 720$ 690$ 660$ 4,030$
Internal Rate of Return 15.0%
[a] Based on cash interest of 5.00% per annum. Interest calculation is based on annual payments.
Calculation of IRR of Subordinated Term Notes
For the Year Ending
Valuation & Financial Opinions Dispute Advisory & Forensic Services 18
Items for ESOP Team to Consider Regarding Warrant Position Cash flow considerations (interest rate v. warrant position) Strike price for warrant What is a reasonable IRR? What is reasonable ownership dilution (also consider other equity
holders)?
Valuation & Financial Opinions Dispute Advisory & Forensic Services 19
Questions?
Valuation & Financial Opinions Dispute Advisory & Forensic Services 20
Contact Information
Scott D. Levine, CPA/ABV, CFA, ASA Managing Director
Stout Risius Ross, Inc. 8180 Greensboro Drive, Suite 600
McLean, VA 22102 (703) 848-4944
Peter H. Briggs Managing Director
Shareholder Strategies, Inc. P.O. Box 158
Charlottesville, VA 22902 (434) 984-0474