8/3/2019 Qualitative Article - Peer Review - L Gray 11-27 (4)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/qualitative-article-peer-review-l-gray-11-27-4 1/7
#:3330,/%%'#$%#%$!#'$#&%
":,9,9;079.0#0;009,.439;0#0,/3$97,9008,32574;0$01#0:,943
,%43,7,
-079&3;0789
6445;('*9¾nf°¾°
½ff%°°°fff°
°½fnf°¾°½f°¯
½fn¯°¾½fn°½fn¯°n
8/3/2019 Qualitative Article - Peer Review - L Gray 11-27 (4)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/qualitative-article-peer-review-l-gray-11-27-4 2/7
%%'#$%#%$!#'$#&%
":,9,9;079.0#0;009,.439;0#0,/3$97,9008,32574;0$01#0:,943
3986:,9,9;0.,8089:/907080,7.07,3/4-807;07,8,8490.4:7803897:.94713/38
17425,8970,/37080,7..,8.43/:.90/9002039,7,0/./703070,550/94,
/0;0452039,70,/3.4:780,990.4000;0%489:/0843209,.43943.070.43/:.90/
94:307./703,3//07;0/1742!0,7843,3/,,07824/0417,/:,700,8041
7085438-95,897080,7.,88.,114/0/,3/5,79.:,7051:3/0./3494574.00/390
.4000;0.4:780%05,79.5,398.438890/411;0.40017082030,784/.4803-,80/
43850.1..7907,1742,74:54189:/03984070706:70/94,9903/,9480208907/0;0452039,
70,/3.,88,8,708:9419078.470843,2,3/,9470397,3.00,29,8706:70/9,9549039,
5,79.5,398,9903/-49901789,3/80.43/80208907/0;0452039,70,/3.,88089,90709,:9-
907080,7.07 ,3/9,9/0243897,9070:,7.,88,9903/,3.0.43889039.425090474392043920
.425094341,88320398,3/ 5,79.5,9070:,75,79.5,9433.,88,.9;90843,70:,7-,88/:73
90178980208907//943,43948089:/03984/0243897,90/,;07,0,-9974:4:9901789
80208907 8.47330907097020434709702043,88320398,3/,8808820398070
.438/070/$9:/0398897:3990.:77.::247473974:9970,90,80070349
.438/070/1473.:84339089:/;0790.4:7804194802089078901443897,9008070
9,:9.4330.93507843,8.02,9,94909-,.74:3/340/0250203931:5897,9008147
:334347/20,33841.431:83803903.08,836:0894384190909/7,3310703.08174290
9098:22,73839083,3//090723325479,3.041,909974:90:80412,73,34908
,3349,93%04,419089:/,894:/089:/03989497,38147290770,/3-0,;478,3/-0.420
80170:,9370,/078
,9,07039,805,7,90/-.,80,3/-/,9,84:7.04/08070/07;0/3/:.9;0,8
5,99073802070/174290;,74:8,8808820398,3/3907;08%080.4/083.:/0/-:9070349290/
6445;(*¾¾f¾¾¯f°¾f¾
n¾°¾"
8/3/2019 Qualitative Article - Peer Review - L Gray 11-27 (4)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/qualitative-article-peer-review-l-gray-11-27-4 3/7
%%'#$%#%$!#'$#&%
94902088:.,8;,:041897,9008,557457,90308841897,90:80,3/:3/0789,3/341897,9008
4/0/4-807;,9438070903,3,0/,.7488901;0.,80894,3807907080,7.6:08943
.42570038;043041905,79.5,398070,-094,3807,4190,8808820396:089438.4770.9
14439080.43/57494.440;070,.41901;089:/03982574;0//7,2,9.,17429070,707
5071472,3.08%441905,79.5,3984,/ -003,-0-003,-094,3807.4770.94397004190
6:0894383901 78957494.40700,.0,.,-094,380770/.4770.939080.43/3490741
9089:/0398498.4770.9,380788.470/9008941,905,79.5,398390178957494.4
2574;0/94330.4770.939080.43/57494.41907.480,3,88419093,4:/31472,943,9
-0.,20,55,7039,89,990,70,84190909070905,79.5,398894550/9493,4:/0702470
419039,3349,70,890070903,-09470202-07039.,2092094,380790,880882039
6:089438%813/38:0890/9,9:8390897,90081,.9,90/.42570038434190909%8
4-807;,943.4774-47,90/9013/3841,90,89842049077080,7.0784,;084:9943897:.9
89:/03983:83209,.439;0897,900894,/3.4257003843,73070,3/07
%74:90:80413907;0893,4:/57494.4831472,4-807;,9438,3//4.:2039,3,8890
14434:9.4208413897:.943070:3.4;070/3.70,80/340/04170,/3897,9008,-994
:8090897,90088:..0881:94.,304;07,70,/3-0,;47,3/:3/0789,3/34190897,9008
;,:0#0,/3-0,;47.,30/8:-89,39,147,1;05,79.5,398%74:90793,4:/
57494.489070;0,0/24;020391742;07-,8./0.,7,9;0340/041897,900894/00507
574.0/:7,,3/.43/943,340/0..47/39490/,9,9089:/039803,3.0/340/0,40/
90294-0.420247080170:,90/70,/078//943,905,79.5,3987054790/9,99014:3/
90280;08:8390897,90083/0503/0390370,/3-49,.,/02.,3/4:9418.449098,3
4190205,30/9850342034398420/070041,894382039,819089:330/90280;08
6445;('*¾¾¯¯f
¾¯½°n°½n°f¯½̄ °
¯f¾¯¯f¯n°n¾"
8/3/2019 Qualitative Article - Peer Review - L Gray 11-27 (4)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/qualitative-article-peer-review-l-gray-11-27-4 4/7
%%'#$%#%$!#'$#&%
039070,0/90070:83897,900894:95742593%0.42-3,9434190804:9.4208
8002894,;0.4397-:90/949089:/0398,-99480170:,90070,/3
3,88
%070,7080;07,455479:39081471:79077080,7.708:9317429889:/78941,89:/08.4:/
-0.43/:.90/43906:,941209,.439;070,/3897,903897:.943,990002039,7390720/,90
,3/80.43/,70;08410/:.,9438494:/-0390708939480090708:9841980,.97080,7.
9,33897:.94748349907080,7.07,3/904-807;0731,.990;,/9419889:/2,,;0
5488--003.42574280/.438/073901,.99,9907080,7.07,3/4-807;07,8,84903897:.94741
90/0;0452039,70,/3.,88%8%01,.99,9907080,7.07,8,84903897:.947.4:/03/9801
94:3/4.:20390/-,88,708:989:/0884:/-0.43/:.90/970:,70/:.,94390,.0784,;0
-00397,30/390,70,41209,.439;070,/3897,90080,7080,7.07 48,8497,30/ -:9
807;0843,8907080,7.07,3/4-807;07419089:/-:9349,8903897:.947 !70;4:87080,7.848
9,9903,-99497,381070,730/897,9008,85,:0/.400907,.89:/0398%857080398,34907
455479:391471:7907,3/6:,399,9;07080,7.940,2304908089:/039897,381079070,730/
897,90089470,/3,.9;908-043/9070,/37420
4943//9089:/0398:8041897,9008,3/.42570038433.70,80-:990:80419080
897,9008.,30/9074;07,70,/3-0,;47#080,7.8489,989:/03984,709,:9-
3897:.94784,70$9:/083/.,909,94:724892,73,0/89:/039870.0;083897:.9439,98349
,/06:,90-,80/37080,7.3479,:9-3897:.94784:3/0789,3/70,/39047,0
%025.,9438,709,9.400813/930.088,7.422994738:..0881:3897:.94784,;0,
8974314:3/,9433.:7703970,/3904708-0.,:8098950413897:.943,3//,9,.40.9439,08,
70,9/0,41.,701:5,333.42292039,3/0507980!708804..0;398
57080398831.,39.,030894.400.:77.::2/0;0452039%44;07.4209080.,0308
6445;('*f°¾
¾°°°¾n°¾f¾f¾f
¾°"
6445;('*D¾¾¯¯f
¾½fff½ff°¾
f°f¾¾
6445;('*¾¾¾°°n°
°°¾f¾¾f¯°f°f¾°f"
6445;('*¾¯f¾
¾¾°°n"
6445;('*¾¾¾°°n°"
8/3/2019 Qualitative Article - Peer Review - L Gray 11-27 (4)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/qualitative-article-peer-review-l-gray-11-27-4 5/7
%%'#$%#%$!#'$#&%
.40089/0;0452039,70,/35747,2829-03019-411073574108843,/0;0452039
455479:390843.:7703970,/39047,3/50/,494907/0;0452039,3897:.9478
#010703.08
742009,.43943.439;0897,903897:.943,3/70,/33,/:9907,. #0;0
41/:90,733,3/907,.
,7307#0,3/07!09,.4394338070/,3/:3,38070/6:089438 /:.,943,
!8.4489
,890$09,.439;070,/3897,9008.,32574;080170:,943 4:73,41400
#0,/3,3/0,733
!0,7843!,,07%03897:.9434170,/3.425700384343902547,7
/:.,943,!8.44
6445;('*9°¾½fn°
¾
8/3/2019 Qualitative Article - Peer Review - L Gray 11-27 (4)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/qualitative-article-peer-review-l-gray-11-27-4 6/7
%%'#$%#%$!#'$#&%
!708804.$:223:5,9.42570038433897:.943.4:/-03
4.!70880/842570038433897:.94355047:147/!7088
9@-D@; D@@I@IJD@IJ@-
9@@,
D,, @@
9½¾
¾
9½¾
¾nff°n°n¾°
9½¾¾
°
9½¾
¾¾°nf
-¾n¾¾°
½½¾¾
°n¯½
¾n½°
9fn½f°¾$f¯½
@
¾n½°
½fn½f°¾$¾f¯½
°n°¾f¯½
¾n°
¾n½°
½fn½f°¾¾f¯½
f°¾f¯½¾n°
½n¾
nn½f
¾n½°
½fn½f°¾¾f¯½
f°¾f¯½
¾n°
f°
¾n½°
¾f¯½-¯°°
¾f¯½°
½n¾
°n¯½
¾fn¾°
¾fn¾°
n¯°
°nf¾
¾¾f°
f½½½f¾°
¾fn¾°
n¯°f
°fn°°
¾¾f°
f½½½f¾°
¾fn¾°
n¯°
-¾fn¾°
°nf°n¯½
ffn°
°f¾¾
,ff
nn°f°
f°f¾¾°nf
f°½f°
,ff
nn°f°f¾¾
°nff°
¾¯f½f°
,ff
nn°f°
f°f°f
°nf
-¯ff
nn°f°
f°f¾¾°nf
°n¯½
¾¾ @n¾ °fn¾ ¯fn¾ nff°¯ °n¯½
8/3/2019 Qualitative Article - Peer Review - L Gray 11-27 (4)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/qualitative-article-peer-review-l-gray-11-27-4 7/7
%%'#$%#%$!#'$#&%
°¾¯¯f°
¾¾
¾
¾¯¯f
¾¾¾
¾¯¯f
¾¾¾
°
n¾°¾¾
¾
-
¾fn
9¾¯½
n°¾
¾fn
9¾f
n°¾
¾fn
n°¾
¾fnf
°nf
°n°¾¾°
°°¾
°n¯½
¾n¾¾°
¾fn
°n¯½
If$f
½¾¾
¯½
n°n¾¾n¾¾°
f$f
½¾¾
°n¾f°°f
n°¾¯¾
f¾½n¾
f$f
½¾¾
If$f
½¾¾°
°¾
f¾½n¾
f$f
½¾¾¯¾¾°
°n¯½
f$f
½¾¾
¾n¾¾°
°n¯½
°f
°¾$n¾¯
°¾$n¾¯
f¾°fn
¾fn
¾nff
°f
°n°°
¾½½½°°
°n°
¾¯f¾½½¾
½°°
½°°°
°¾½½°n¯½
¯½nf°¾
¯½
n°n¾¾n¾¾°
¯½nf°¾
¾fn°½fnn
°¾¯½nf°¾
½fnn
D°nf¯½nf°¾
½fnn
-n°°n°
°¾fn
f°½fnn
°n¯½
J@-$@
J°9
¾½°
¾°ff°
f¯¯fnf¾
J
¯ff
9¾f½½n°¾¾°
°f¾
¯°¾°nf°n
f¯¯ff°
9
°¯¾
-
,f°¾9
f¯¯ff°
¾°°n¾n
f¾f¾9
¾
°n¯½
@@ $
9,,-@
½½f¾½°¾n°¾
9¾nf°¾f¾½f°¾½fn°°n½f°°°¾°n
,f°¾°°n¾n¯°f°°nn¾
f¾°°nf¾¾°n¾°f¾f°¾½¾fn
½f¾fnf½°f¾¯¯ffn@¾¯¯ff°f°f¾¾f½n°½f¾
9°fn°n¾¾¯¯ff°f°f¾¾°¾
°fn¯¯°¾½°¯f½