Practice Education Advocacy Research
OUR MIX TAPE UNDERSTANDING THE EXPERIENCE OF SCHEMAS, ATTACHMENT AND PAIN DR KAREN T. HALLAM SENIOR RESEARCH FELLOW RESEARCH MANAGER, YSAS HONORARY FELLOW THE UNIVERSITY OF MELBOURNE HONORARY FELLOW VICTORIA UNIVERSITY
Practice Education Advocacy Research
TODAYS WORKSHOP
Take a hitchikers tour through Part 1. Foundations of therapeutic styles Attachment Schemas Formulation approaches Part 2. Application of theory to a case study with in depth discussion of formulation and therapy approach
Practice Education Advocacy Research
TRIGGER WARNING
This workshop necessarily discusses the experiences of people who have experienced abuse, have engaged in suicidal behaviour and have witnessed family violence and suicide. Please keep this in mind when considering the right workshop for you. If the content raises immediate concerns for you I am happy to debrief at the end of the workshop, if you are engaged with a therapist or health care team I also encourage you to discuss with them at your next opportunity. Thank you Karen
Practice Education Advocacy Research
WHAT MAKES A SKILLED THERAPIST? Background factors Interpersonal skills Emotional Intelligence Affect regulation Context Therapeutic
orientation
Therapeutic skills and techniques
Therapeutic Approach
Eg schemas, mindfulness etc
Practice Education Advocacy Research
THERAPEUTIC ORIENTATION
Psychoanalytic/ Psychodynamic
Humanistic Existential
Cognitive therapies
Practice Education Advocacy Research
THERAPEUTIC APPROACH
The method you learn to do things within and outside of your own orientation. Often learned from where you study and work Continue to develop and expand over time Should be formulation based (must combine both of the following) Nomothetic
– Formulation based on general laws/rules – Typical of DSM diagnoses (if you have … it wil look like…)
Idiographic
– What might work for … – Takes into account complexity of the individual – Our experience and needs vary between people
Practice Education Advocacy Research
THERAPEUTIC TECHNIQUES
Nuts and bolts of what you might do in any one session Well practiced and shared in the most effective way for the person based on formulation
Practice Education Advocacy Research
FOCUSING ON THERAPEUTIC APPROACH… WHAT IMPACT DOES EARLY EXPERIENCE HAVE?
Practice Education Advocacy Research
ATTACHMENT
Many animals (including humans) have an instinct to have a stable and safe attachment with the primary caregiver Caregiver is ideally a secure base from which to venture and explore environment
Ideally a tension between preserving familiarity and novelty seeking When caregiver not tuned in with child/ abuses child/ abandons child may lead to insecure attachment formation While they begin in childhood, they are adaptable (but tough to change) over time
Practice Education Advocacy Research
ATTACHMENT STYLES
Secure: Comfortable displaying interest and affection. Comfortable being alone and independent. Can identify and assert their boundaries. Loyal, sacrificing, able to accept rejection and trust/be trusted (50% population) Secure attachment is developed in childhood by infants who regularly get their needs met, as well as receive ample quantities of love and affection Anxious (Preoccupied): Often nervous and stressed about their relationships, requiring constant assurance. Being alone is difficult and they struggle to trust people. They can irrational, sporadic, and overly-emotional when feeling threatened and complain that potential/current relationships are cold and unresponsive Anxious attachment strategies are developed in childhood by infants who receive love and care with unpredictable sufficiency.
Practice Education Advocacy Research
ATTACHMENT STYLES
Avoidant (Dismissive): Extremely independent, self-directed, and often uncomfortable with intimacy. They struggle with commitment and the feeling of suffocation . They both yearn for but fear intimacy, hence pushing people away (often pre-emptively), they may construct their lives in such a way that they don’t need others Developed in childhood by infants who only get some of their needs met while the rest are neglected (for instance, he/she gets fed regularly, but not held enough). Anxious-Avoidant (Fearful): Struggle with both avoidance and anxious styles. Fear intimacy and connection, distrust others and lash out at people who try to get close to them, often attract abusive others (shit magnet) Anxious-avoidant types develop from abusive or terribly negligent childhoods.
Practice Education Advocacy Research
HOW ATTACHMENTS PLAY OUT
Practice Education Advocacy Research
LIKE SANDS THROUGH THE HOURGLASS…
Six years of age
25 years of age
40 years of age
Practice Education Advocacy Research
IF THEY ARE SO STABLE, WHY DID THEY CHANGE?
When I was 25, I showed up to begin a long course of psychodynamically oriented psychotherapy… At the beginning of the session my therapist asked me “How can I help?” I replied “I’m that Simon and Garfunkle song”
25 years of age
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PKY-smJ6aBQ
Practice Education Advocacy Research
HOW ABOUT YOU?
Practice Education Advocacy Research
WHAT ARE THE ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES OF YOUR OWN ATTACHMENT STYLE?
The role of the therapist is to provide a secure basis for person To establish and experience a securely attached relationship
To provide a secure base to venture from to undertake behavioural challenges etc (motivating, nurturing etc)
To provide a person to return to following exploration to discuss/
synthesise and prevent distortion (reflective space) • Secure therapist works well with all clients as provide a secure base • Avoidant therapist works well with secure, avoidant but less well with anxious • Anxious therapist works well with secure clients but struggles with anxious clients and wont
retain avoidant clients
Practice Education Advocacy Research
HOW DO WE RELATE ATTACHMENTS AND SCHEMAS?
Over time children learn to predict and respond to the behaviours of attachment figures and modify their own response
These are internal working models (eg parentified child) Jeffrey Young has proposed these become early maladaptive schemas Early maladaptive schemas are broad, pervasive themes or patterns Comprised of memories, emotions, thoughts (cognitions) and bodily sensations Regarding ourselves and our relationship with others. Throughout life we may reinforce and elaborate these themes
Practice Education Advocacy Research
EARLY MALADAPTIVE SCHEMAS
EMS
Form core of our
sense of self
Rigid beliefs and
feelings
Triggered by events
Drive behaviour
Vary throughout life and in intensity
Rigid beliefs and
feelings
Outside our awareness
Resistant to change
Self perpetuating
Impact how we see situations and
events
Practice Education Advocacy Research
ORIGINS OF SCHEMAS
It is argued that four main types of events in childhood develop early maladaptive schemas (check out the similarities with attachment theory) 1. Toxic Frustration
– Refers to an absence of healthy, loving and nurturing experiences
2. Traumatization and victimization
• Consists of specific traumatic or abusive experiences
3. Too much of a good thing • Where parents/ superiors/ guardians do not set realistic limits are
overprotective or over involved
4. Selective internalization or identification with significant others • Internalization of aspects of parents or other important adults thinking
or behaviour
Practice Education Advocacy Research
DOMAINS AND SCHEMAS
Domain Schema
Disconnection and rejection Abusive, traumatic childhoods, unstable family life, rejection and humiliation, feel different or lacking in some way, long periods of insecurity and inconsistent parenting
Mistrust/Abuse Abandonment/Instability Emotional Deprivation Defectiveness/Shame Social Isolation/alienation
Impaired autonomy and performance Often over protected and controlled as children or neglected and ignored, undermined and made to feel incompetent or encouraged to be dependent on another
Dependence/Incompetence Vulnerability to harm Enmeshment Failure
Impaired limits Internal sense of control under developed, difficulty respecting the rights of others, un-boundaried family, children did not have structure and rules
Entitlement Insufficient Self Control
Other directedness Experienced conditional love, family overly concerned with appearances, parents focused on own needs
Subjugation Self-Sacrifice Approval Seeking
Over-vigilance and inhibition Strict parental control to gain compliance, ever watchful, frightened of overly severe punishment for expressing feelings
Negativity/Pessimism Emotional Inhibition Unrelenting Standards Hypercriticalness Punitiveness
Practice Education Advocacy Research
HOW WE COPE WITH SCHEMAS (COPING STYLES) We all respond differently to experiences That is why in a family experiencing violence, one child might become aggressive, another may become passive which puts them at higher risk of being a victim again while the other become rebellious and defiant This is partly because we have different temperaments at birth and partly because of the social context that each child finds themselves in These coping styles are normal and helpful in assisting the child to cope with complex contexts and problems. We also continue with these coping styles into adult life when thy are no longer helpful and may begin to impact on our self concept, relationships and how we cope with what the world sends our way
Practice Education Advocacy Research
SCHEMA COPING
Schema modes describe the schemas that are triggered at any one point in time In essence a schema is considered a trait A schema mode represents a state
Practice Education Advocacy Research
SCHEMA MODES
The schema or schemas currently activated or shown in our behaviour Often easier to work with in sessions than individual schemas Four main mode types • Child Mode • Dysfunctional Coping Mode • Parent Mode • Healthy Adult Mode
Practice Education Advocacy Research
CHILD MODES
Associated with intense negative emotions such as rage, sadness and abandonment Resemble the concept of the ‘inner child’ Might include
Vulnerable child Angry child Impulsive child Lonely child
Practice Education Advocacy Research
DYSFUNCTIONAL COPING MODES
Avoidance Modes Detached Protector (deaden inside) Detached self soother (eg drugs and alcohol, food, sex) Angry protector (wall of anger to push others away)
Surrender Modes
Compliant mode (gives in) Overcompensation modes
Self eggrandizer Bully/Attacker Manipulator Predator Over controller
Practice Education Advocacy Research
DYSFUNCTIONAL PARENT MODE
A highly emotional mode Considered internalisations of dysfunctional parental responses to the child In dysfunctional parent modes, people keep putting pressure on themselves or hating themselves Might include
Punitive critical parent Demanding parent
Practice Education Advocacy Research
HEALTHY ADULT MODE
Mode of the healthy adult and happy child In this mode, people can view their life and themselves in a realistic way They are able to fulfil their age appropriate obligations and care for their wellbeing and needs
The happy child in this mode is able to experience fun, joy, and play (we can let go and be happy but also be an adult)
SLIDE HEADING
Practice Education Advocacy Research
Unlike you guys last year, most people don’t want to sit down and fill in a questionnaire And some people who fill in the questionnaire don’t feel confident or comfortable being honest in it So how do we find out what’s going on for the person in front of you? We have three typical approaches
Co-development of schema profile Thinking about it on our own when the YP is not around Supervision and reflection from sessions
So how do we know what someone’s schemas are?
SLIDE HEADING
Practice Education Advocacy Research
First, use your own experience of the young person How do they make you feel Do you get frustrated, hopeless, angry, sad etc Do you feel yourself trying to do things for them Do you find yourself encouraging them to try things Or do you find yourself trying to stop them doing things that are unhelpful
Irving Yalom Use your own feelings as precious and valuable information. If a client bores you for example, then they may likely bore others as well. Use that. Say to the client, “I notice I have been feeling disconnected from you, somewhat distanced…is your feeling similar?…let’s try and understand what is happening.”
Identifying schemas in supervision
SLIDE HEADING
Practice Education Advocacy Research
Pull out the schema tables by Young Simply circle the ones that jump out for a specific client
Identifying schemas yourself
EMS Surrender Avoidance Overcompensation
Abandonment / Instability
Chooses partners who cannot make a commitment/unfaithful and remain in relationship
Avoids intimate relationships. May drink, overeat etc. when alone to avoid schema
Clings to and smothers partner, jealous of time with partner and may push partner away
Abuse/ mistrust
Selects abusive partners and stays in abusive relationships
Avoids trusting anyone or becoming vulnerable in any way
Uses and abuses others (“get them before they get me”)
Emotional Deprivation
Selects emotionally depriving partners and does not ask for needs to be met
Avoids intimate relationships altogether
Emotionally demanding with partners and friends
Defectiveness shame
Selects critical and rejecting friends and partner. Puts self down
Avoids expressing true thoughts and feelings and letting others close
Criticises and rejects others while seeming to be perfect
Social Isolation
At social gatherings focuses exclusively on differences from others rather than similarities
Avoids social situations and groups
Becomes a chamelion to fit into groups
Dependence/ Incompetence
Asks significant others to make decisions “”what do YOU think I should do?”
Avoids taking on new challenges such as travel, studies
Becomes so independent they cant rely on asking for help
Vulnerability to harm
Obsessively reads about catastrophes and follows bad news, worries they will happen to them
Avoids going places that do not seem totally safe
Acts recklessly without regard to danger
EMS Surrender Avoidance Overcompensation
Enmeshment
Tells parent everything, even as adult, always lives with partner
Avoids intimacy, stays independent
Tries to become opposite of significant other
Failure Does tasks in a half hearted or haphazard manner
Avoids work challenges completely or procrastinates
Becomes an overachiever by ceaselessly driving self
Entitlement
Bullies others into getting own way
Avoids situations where they are average or not superior
Attends excessively to the needs of others
Insufficient self control
Gives up easily on routine tasks
Avoids employment or accepting responsibilities
Becomes overly self controlled or self disciplines
Subjugation
Lets others control situations and make choices
Avoids situations that might involve giving or taking
Gives as little as possible to others
Self sacrifice
Gives a lot to others and asks for nothing in return
Avoids situations involving giving or taking
Gives as little as possible to others
Emotional Inhibition
Maintains a calm and unemotional demeanour
Avoids situations in which people discuss or express feelings
Awkwardly tries to be the life of the party, even if it feels forced
Unrelenting Standards
Spends large amounts of time trying to be perfect
Avoids or procrastinates in situations and tasks in which performance will be judged
Does not care about standards, can be careless
SLIDE HEADING
Practice Education Advocacy Research
Lynchpin hypothesis approach
Co-development of a schema profile
SLIDE HEADING
Practice Education Advocacy Research
Lynchpin hypothesis approach
Co-development of a schema profile
An empty vessel to be
used
Pathetic A limp body
Suicidal
Sexual object
Alone Ruined
Broken/used
Afraid
Disposable
Less than
Schemas we identified • Mistrust/Abuse • Defectiveness • Vulnerability to harm
SLIDE HEADING
Practice Education Advocacy Research
Now we have identified the attachment concerns, early maladaptive schemas, coping styles and perhaps some schema modes we need to begin therapy Phases Establishment of rapport, trust and working alliance Agreeing on the need for integration of schema modes/ a change
(and moving away from some) Learning to safely activate schemas Engaging in activities specifically targeting
Child mode (experiential work) Dysfunctional coping styles (CBT and exposure style work) Dysfunctional parent mode (limited reparenting)/ safe attachment Nurturance of the healthy adult mode (celebration of joy, sharing of sadness etc)
Approaching schema work
SLIDE HEADING
Practice Education Advocacy Research
Like a controlled explosion This should ONLY be done by a skilled schema therapist
ACTIVATING THE SCHEMAS
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dx0IMHco81I
SLIDE HEADING
Practice Education Advocacy Research
That’s (most of) the theory done, next I put it all into practice by sharing with you one of my own formulation based therapies with a young client with a severe mood disorder Lets have a cup of teaJ
After the break
Practice Education Advocacy Research
OUR MIX TAPE UNDERSTANDING THE EXPERIENCE OF SCHEMAS, ATTACHMENT AND PAIN – PART 2 DR KAREN T. HALLAM SENIOR RESEARCH FELLOW RESEARCH MANAGER, YSAS HONORARY FELLOW THE UNIVERSITY OF MELBOURNE HONORARY FELLOW VICTORIA UNIVERSITY
Practice Education Advocacy Research
EXISTENTIALISM IN THERAPEUTIC CONTEXTS
My therapeutic orientation is largely existential/humanistic This approach posits the question how shall I live?” This is constructed day to day by our beliefs and actions
– Self construct (who and what we are) – World construct (how we see world)
This self and world construct allows us to put meaning into our lives that may otherwise be unanchored
Psychoanalytic /Psychodynamic
Humanistic Existential
Cognitive therapies
Practice Education Advocacy Research
FOUR PILLARS OF EXISTENTIAL PSYCHOTHERAPY Mortality Greatest fear may not be death but extinction and the extinguishing of our identity and place
Isolation/Connection On a fundamental level we mostly need to belong. With connections we ‘live on’ and are memorialised or remembered even if we die Meaning Making sense, coherence or order out of our existence and having a purpose or goal to strive for Erikson (1963) would say that meaning in adolescence is developed through a focus on
– Forming intimate relationships
– Establishing a stable sense of self (identity) – Being creative and productive
Freedom When we separate from others our personal control increases but at the cost of connection. We may give up freedom by partnering or finding a group. Captivity is a genuine fear for many
Practice Education Advocacy Research
EXISTENTIAL PSYCHOTHERAPY
The purpose is to help clients become aware of their existence to the degree that they are aware of their full potential and choose how they act The core of this approach puts the relationship between the therapist and client as central,
– fellow travellers – exploring relationship, society, self concept etc – non judgemental
Central belief “It is the relationship that heals”
Practice Education Advocacy Research
THE EXISTENTIAL VACUUM
If meaning is what we desire, then meaninglessness is a hole, an emptiness, in our lives Whenever you have a vacuum, things rush in to fill it We attempt to fill our existential vacuums with “stuff” eg eating beyond all necessity, sex for the sake of the high or feeling alone, power, busy-ness, conformity, conventionality Or alternatively, we fill the vacuum with anger and hatred and spend our days attempting to destroy what we think has hurt/is hurting us.
Practice Education Advocacy Research
FIRSTS…
Client Client who made me cry Client who scared or hurt me Client who suicided Client who recovered, survived and thrived Client who I let really matter to me, pushed me, tested me and really needed me. In turn, the client who turned me into the therapist I am today
Practice Education Advocacy Research
ATTACHMENT WORK APPROACH Recognise her ambivalence Leverage off my own experience of this style Recognise past history with ‘all the rest’ and that I cannot be another ‘all the rest’ Follow her lead Recognise based on attachment, schemas and interpersonal style that her attempting boundary pushing, transgressions is unlikely Don’t push Be honest as hell, be a fellow traveller
Practice Education Advocacy Research
BEING PRESENT… THE HERE AND NOW
The importance of using the here and now is based upon assumptions of the importance of interpersonal relationships and the idea of therapy as a social microcosm. Our interpersonal environment influences us and our self image is formulated to a large degree based upon what we perceive important figures in our lives appraise us to be. The interpersonal problems of the person will manifest themselves in the here-and-now of the therapy relationship. The use of the here and now is my most important therapeutic skill and tool
Practice Education Advocacy Research
ESTABLISHMENT
Practice Education Advocacy Research
WE ALSO TALKED ABOUT ME Based on my formulation and chosen approach I knew that connection and a caring and steady attachment figure was what she needed. We could build skills on that. I took a fellow traveller approach She asked me if I had an ambivalent attachment style too
I answered She asked me if I had a hard life
I answered She asked me what gave me hope in my own life
I answered, one of my answers was helping her She asked me if we might have been friends if we met in different circumstances
I said no… because she wouldn’t have let me , she didn’t really have friends. But if I had seen her as I did in sessions, we would definitely have been friends
She asked me how to let people in
We began the next phase of therapy
Practice Education Advocacy Research
HOW DID I DECIDE WHAT TO DISCLOSE
I was led by my therapeutic approach (Yalom) And the formulation I give what the person needs, no more, no less Its always about what they need to hear, not what I want to say Its never about superficial connection • Deliberate (a planned choice) • Measured (only what is needed) • Discussed (in supervision)
Here and now
Fellow Travellers
Personal
Practice Education Advocacy Research
RE-ESTABLISHING CONNECTION Difficult to access wounded or angry child schema modes to express distress Better success with challenging and understanding schema surrender, over compensation and avoidance
Behavioural challenges (e.g hw it felt talking to me, small experiments with workmates etc) Scaffolding trust (together, workmates, brother, selected friends)
Sam had strong skills in using CBT in challenging her negative parent modes
E.g. Even if it were true, what would be the worst thing that would happen? Schema focused work (we talked, catharsis of unexpressed sadness and anger)
First around mum Then around dad
But fundamental assumption… it is the relationship that heals
Practice Education Advocacy Research
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME AND ALLOWING ME TO SHARE SAMS STORY
If you wanted to contact me you can reach me at [email protected] Or by phone on 0409-250-147 K