Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 1/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
International Guidelines on Trade Indices
Slides based on a presentation by
Ronald Jansen
Trade Statistics Branch
United Nations Statistics Division
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 2/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
International Guidelineson External Trade Indices
International Merchandise Trade Statistics: Concepts and Definitions (Rev 2, 1998)
Guidelines on Price and Quantity Statistics (1977) Strategies for the Measurement of External Trade
Indices (1981) National Practices in compilation of External Trade
indices (2005) XMPI Manual (IMF and others, 2008)
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 3/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
International Guidelineson External Trade Indices
• Main uses of external trade indices:• Government economic policy (monetary policy)• Analysis of country competitiveness (on domestic and
external markets)• Terms of Trade • Measuring inflation risk, forecasting future price trends
(including CPI, PPI)• Exchange rate analysis (pass through into import prices)• Compilation of National Accounts (Deflators)• Specific market analysis
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 4/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
International Recommendation (IMTS, Rev.2,1998)
Paragraph 160 :
Index numbers. Many users need more information than trade values by country or by commodity, and require information on prices and volumes as well. Two kinds of indices may be produced to reflect prices: unit value indices based primarily on customs documents and price indices based on survey data. The relative strengths and weaknesses of those two approaches to index number compilation are described in the United Nations publication Strategies for Price and Quantity Measurement in External Trade. Although price indices are generally preferred, in practice countries may not have the resources available to compile that information.
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 5/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
International Recommendation (IMTS, Rev.2)
Index numbers.
It is recommended that all countries produce and publish volume (quantum) indices and either unit value or price indices for their total imports and exports on a monthly, quarterly and annual basis.
Countries are also encouraged to calculate and publish such indices for the detailed commodity groups at least quarterly
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 6/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
Guidelines on Price and Quantity Statistics
• Deals with all macro-economic indicators
• Published in 1977…
• Provides general guidelines on:
1. Uses of price and quantity statistics
2. Design of price and quantity indices
3. Choice of units of observation
4. Types of index formulae
5. Choice of index formulae and weighting methods
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 7/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
Guidelines on Price and Quantity Statistics
• Export/Import price indices are elements in a broader structure of price indexes described in the System of National Accounts …
• Export/Import priced indices must be adapted to the needs of National Accounts (product classification,…)
• National Accounts aggregates (GDP) may be sensitive to XMPI
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 8/37
International Guidelines on trade indicesSummarized structure of price and quantity indices in the frame of SNA
SUPPLY OF OUTPUT :PRODUCER'S PRICES
Commodities Activities
Gross output Gross outputIntermediate Consumption
Value added Net sector output
Agriculture PPI…
Mining
Manufacturing
Electricity, Gas, water
Construction
Distributive trades
Transport and communications
Finance
Services
USES OF OUTPUT:PURCHASER'S PRICES
Consumption by Households CPI…
Consumption by Government
Consumption by Non-profit institutions
Gross Fixed capital formation
Change in stocks
Exports XPI (SITC)
Imports MPI (SITC)
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 9/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
Guidelines on Price and Quantity StatisticsChoice of units of observation
The choice of units of observation determines what is counted as a change in price and what is counted as a change in quantity.
For instance, if differences are taken into account between cars with small, cars with large engines, sports cars and pick-up trucks, then those differences are reflected as differences in quantity. The price differences are taken between the same type of car.
If cars are not differentiated, then all changes in structure or in quality will be seen as an increase or decrease in the price of a car.
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 10/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
Guidelines on Price and Quantity StatisticsTypes of index formulae
1. Laspeyres
2. Paasche
3. Fisher
4. Relation Price and Quantum Indexes
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 11/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
∑PitQi0
∑Pi0Qi0
i=1
n
n
i=1
PL=
Guidelines on Price and Quantity StatisticsTypes of index formulae
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 12/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
Guidelines on Price and Quantity StatisticsChoice of index formulae and weighting methods
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 13/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
Strategies for the Measurement of External Trade Indices
1. Source of data
2. Limitations of unit values and survey prices
3. Major problems of pricing
4. Types of index-number formulae
5. Strategies for compiling index numbers
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 14/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
Strategies for the Measurement of External Trade IndicesSource of data (part I)
1. Customs records- Data useful for indices:
a) Commodity codesb) Trading partner codesc) Customs procedure codesd) Quantity unit codese) Mode of Transportation codef) Identification of importer/exporter
- Almost exhaustive coverage, but :- Greater scrutiny generally applied on imports- Commodity classification often more detailed on imports- Access to detailed transactions not always possible
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 15/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
Strategies for the Measurement of External Trade IndicesSource of data (part I)
2. Export and Import – price surveysa) List of importers/exporters : Business associations, business
Registers, Customsb) Sampling Design:
Draw sample from the list of enterprisesDiscuss with each firm the particular items to be selected for pricing
c) Survey taking
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 16/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
Strategies for the Measurement of External Trade IndicesLimitations of unit values and survey prices (part II)
1. Main problem of unit values: heterogeneity
a) Different products in same item
Other problem : quantity measurement (definition, customs controls)
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 17/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
Strategies for the Measurement of External Trade IndicesLimitations of unit values and survey prices (part II)
1. Main problem of unit values: heterogeneity
Example of refrigerators (page 15)
Period q p v q p v q p v q p v
Initial 5 1 5 3 2 6 2 3 6 10 1,7 17Current 2 2 4 3 4 12 5 6 30 10 4,6 46
small Medium Large All sizes
Overstatement of price increase by unit value of 36%
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 18/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
Strategies for the Measurement of External Trade IndicesLimitations of unit values and survey prices (part II)
2. Main problems of price surveys:
a) Cost
b) Choice of product varieties to be priced
c) If items too specific, they may change quickly
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 19/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
Strategies for the Measurement of External Trade IndicesMajor problems of pricing (valuation) – (Part III)
1. Quality Changes
2. Unique Goods
3. Seasonal Goods
4. Transfer pricing
5. Prices CIF or FOB
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 20/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
Strategies for the Measurement of External Trade IndicesSome tentative solutions – (Part V)
1. Measuring Unit value bias- through examination of distribution of unit values within each category of the classification, consultation with enterprises,…
2. Refining Unit values-use of all possible data available in Customs records: partner country, size of transaction, mode of transport, identity of importer/exporter, tariff classification
3. Combining sources of data : “The overall measurement of price changes in external trade could be improved by combining the Customs-based data with information drawn from a variety
of sources” (direct surveys, domestic producer prices,…)
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 21/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
Strategies for the Measurement of External Trade IndicesStrategies for compiling index numbers (part VI)
1. Limited Budgeta) Unit Value Indexes – detailed Customs data – selection
of “stable” items - data screening
2. Average Budgeta) Unit Value Indexes – sophisticated data editing
b) Commodity specialists – possible use of a variety of sources to fill the gaps
3. Large Budgeta) sophisticated Unit Values and Price surveys (dual or
combined strategy)
b) Commodity specialists
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 22/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
National Practices in compilation of External Trade indices
Questionnaire (8 questions, conducted in 1999-2002, 77 respondents)
a) Index number series producedb) Source of Informationc) Index calculation methodsd) Limitations of indicese) Release datesf) Revision Policyg) Disseminationh) Compiling agency
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 23/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
National Practices in compilation of External Trade indicesResults: Index number series produced
Unit Value index only - 75%Price Index only - 17%Both UV and Price - 8%
SITC - 45%HS - 19%BEC - 16%ISIC - 20%
Annual only - 16%Annual and Quarterly - 34%Annual, Quarterly, Monthly - 50%
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 24/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 25/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
National Practices in compilation of External Trade indicesResults: Problems encountered
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 26/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
National Practices in compilation of External Trade indicesResults: ESCWA countries
Respondents: Egypt, Jordan, Kuwait, Oman, Qatar, Syria, TurkeyEgypt – Annual; Unit Value (Paasche), Quantum (Laspeyres); CAPMASJordan – Monthly, quarterly and annual; Price (Laspeyres); HS and BEC; Customs
records; DOSKuwait – Annual; Unit Value (Paasche), Quantum (Laspeyres); Customs records, oil
authority, Kuwait airlines; CSOOman – Annual; Unit Value (Laspeyres); SITC section; Customs records; Ministry
of National EconomyQatar – Annual; Unit Value (Fisher), Quantum (Fisher); Customs records; Planning
CouncilSyria – Annual; Unit Value and Quantum (Laspeyres and Paasche); SITC section
and division; Customs records; CBS
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 27/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
Export Import Price Index (XMPI) Manual - 2008
• Draft Manual available on the IMF website:
http://www.imf.org/external/np/sta/tegeipi/index.htm
• Draft written in coordination with ILO, IMF, ECE, OECD, World Bank, Eurostat, and UNSD
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 28/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
Export Import Price Index (XMPI) Manual - 2008
ForewordPrefaceReader's guide1. A summary of XMPI methodology2. Unit value indices3. Background, purpose, and uses of
export and import price indices4. Valuation, timing, coverage, and
classification5. Data sources6. Sampling issues in price collection7. Price collection8. Treatment of quality change9. Item substitution, sample space, and
new goods10. An overview of export and import
price index calculation 11. The treatment of specific products12. Errors and bias in the export and
import price indices
13. Organization and management14. Publication, dissemination, and user
relations15. The system of price statistics16. Index number theory17. Axiomatic and stochastic approach18. Economic approach19. Transfer prices20. Price indices using an artificial data
set21. Elementary indices22. Quality change and hedonics23. Treatment of seasonal productsGlossaryBibliography
Background
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 29/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
Export Import Price Index (XMPI) Manual - 2008
ForewordPrefaceReader's guide1. A summary of XMPI methodology2. Unit value indices3. Background, purpose, and uses of
export and import price indices4. Valuation, timing, coverage, and
classification5. Data sources6. Sampling issues in price collection7. Price collection8. Treatment of quality change9. Item substitution, sample space, and
new goods10. An overview of export and import
price index calculation 11. The treatment of specific products12. Errors and bias in the export and
import price indices
13. Organization and management14. Publication, dissemination, and user
relations15. The system of price statistics16. Index number theory17. Axiomatic and stochastic approach18. Economic approach19. Transfer prices20. Price indices using an artificial data
set21. Elementary indices22. Quality change and hedonics23. Treatment of seasonal productsGlossaryBibliography
Practice of compilation
Practice of compilation
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 30/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
Export Import Price Index (XMPI) Manual - 2008ForewordPrefaceReader's guide1. A summary of XMPI methodology2. Unit value indices3. Background, purpose, and uses of
export and import price indices4. Valuation, timing, coverage, and
classification5. Data sources6. Sampling issues in price collection7. Price collection8. Treatment of quality change9. Item substitution, sample space, and
new goods10. An overview of export and import
price index calculation 11. The treatment of specific products12. Errors and bias in the export and
import price indices
13. Organization and management14. Publication, dissemination, and user
relations15. The system of price statistics16. Index number theory17. Axiomatic and stochastic approach18. Economic approach19. Transfer prices20. Price indices using an artificial data
set21. Elementary indices22. Quality change and hedonics23. Treatment of seasonal productsGlossaryBibliography
Theoreticalaspects
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 31/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
Export Import Price Index (XMPI) Manual – 2008Summary – 100 pages
1. Uses of XMPIs2. Unit value indices and price indices3. Basic index number formulas and economic approach4. Elementary Price indices5. Concepts, Scope and Classifications6. Source data: Customs and Surveys7. Adjusting Prices for Quality Change8. Weights9. Publication and Dissemination
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 32/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
Export Import Price Index (XMPI) Manual – 2008Unit Value and Price Indices
Unit Values Indices and their potential bias:• Unit value are suitable for the aggregation of price changes of
homogeneous items• Mains advantages of unit value indices are their coverage and
relatively low resource cost• Some unit value changes are highly volatile• For heterogeneous items, bias arises from compositional changes in
exported /imported goods• Changes in quality are not taken in account• Problematic measurement of quantities by Customs• Unit value indices rely to a large extent on outlier detection and
deletion• Outliers detection routines may remove some of the signal as well
as the noise
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 33/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
Export Import Price Index (XMPI) Manual – 2008Unit Value and Price Indices
Strategic options:
• A move to price indices based on establishment surveys has resource consequences
• The Manual advises that countries using unit value indices undertake a staged progressive adoption of hybrid indices with, overtime, increasing proportions of unit value indices being substituted by establishment-based survey data
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 34/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
Export Import Price Index (XMPI) Manual – 2008Concepts : Valuation, Coverage and Classifications (chapter 4)
• Coverage : linked to the SNA 1993 definition
• Time of recording : Change of ownership
• Commodity classification : HS, SITC, BEC, CPC…
• Valuation:
• Unit value indices : CIF / FOB value
• Surveys: basic price for exports, purchaser price for imports (but in practice: deflators should be consistent with nominal values of imports/exports…)
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 35/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
Export Import Price Index (XMPI) Manual – 2008Data Sources
1. Customs Records
2. Enterprise Surveys• Concepts are close to those used in other price surveys (Production
Price Index)
• Sampling must be used for both the establishments surveyed and the commodities exported or imported
• Samples must be unbiased and cost-effective
• Data can be collected by various means: postal survey, personal interview, telephone interview, Internet data provision
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 36/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
Export Import Price Index (XMPI) Manual – 2008Data Sources (chapter 5)
Training on calculation of External trade indices for statisticians in ESCWA countries- 14-16 December 2009 - Beirut 37/37
International Guidelines on trade indices
Export Import Price Index (XMPI) Manual – 2008Summary – Appendix 1.1 : Basic Steps in XMPI Development