Improving relationships with and working Improving relationships with and working practices of local authorities.practices of local authorities.
Tamra ManninTamra ManninBristol Debt Advice CentreBristol Debt Advice Centre
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre1
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre2
IntroductionIntroduction
BDAC providing free advice 21 years
Increased number of clients with complaints and problems in dealing with council tax & bailiffs
Bailiff Survey over 1 year period
PPIP Project running for 2 years
Which is the Odd one out?Which is the Odd one out?
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre3
Aims of the workshopAims of the workshop
To engage your local authority in meaningful dialogue.
To effect change to obtain a better deal for your clients.
To make your life a bit easier as an advisor.
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre4
Waking up the Graveyard ShiftWaking up the Graveyard Shift
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre5
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre6
How it used to be – Frank makes a How it used to be – Frank makes a call….call….
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre7
Bailiff Survey - Fact findingBailiff Survey - Fact finding
Who’s in charge of the bailiffs?
LA service level agreements for bailiff collection
LA’s internal guidelines for payment arrangements
What LA’s do – what is law and what is local policy?
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre8
Bailiff SurveyBailiff Survey
1 year
Other local agencies fed into project
Included information of over 40 cases
Focus was to examine the experience of people dealing with the council tax department and their bailiffs
Our Key Findings Were :-Our Key Findings Were :-
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre9
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre10
92% did not think the bailiff had been helpful
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre11
68% of the clients identified that they were vulnerable.
100% felt their vulnerability was NOT taken into account.
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre12
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre13
85% said the bailiff did not take their financial circumstances into account.
70% contacted the Local Authority.
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre14
• Only one person reported this to be successful.
• And that was only successful because a benefit appeal had cleared his arrears!
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre15
Some of our recommendations to LASome of our recommendations to LAThe council should use deductions from benefit in preference to bailiffs and where this is not possible they should not send to bailiffs if information held of vulnerability.
The council should inform the customer where to obtain independent advice on their notices and letters.
When approached the council should deal with the council tax payer and not insist they deal with the bailiff company.
The council should not send accounts to more than one bailiff company for collection.
Where an advice centre raises a complaint, the council should acknowledge its responsibility.
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre16
LA FeedbackLA Feedback
We received an Official Response from the Head of the Council Tax Department
The response disputed many of our conclusions and didn’t invite further exploration
This propelled us to look for funding to take this social policy issue further
PuttingPutting Policy Into Practice ProjectPolicy Into Practice Project
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre17
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre18
So then…So then…
Regular meetings with Group Leaders at council tax department
Presentations to council tax staff
Group Leaders met with advice staff at BDAC and other advice agencies
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre19
What were the key issues?What were the key issues?
•Council Tax staff refusing to intervene with cases where bailiffs involved
•Concerns by council tax that existing advice provision would not cope with referrals
•Slow and cumbersome process when dealing with council tax debts.
•A presumption by council tax that clients were “won’t pay” rather than “can’t pay”.
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre20
What was agreed:What was agreed:
•Fast track telephone number
•30 day hold and instruction to bailiff companies to accept affordable repayment arrangements.
•Customers in arrears asked if they would like independent debt advice.
•A specific Council Tax Clinic and direct referral system for appointments.
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre21
Benefits to clientsBenefits to clients
Affordable arrangements in place sooner avoiding higher costs
Reduced requirement to deal with bailiff companies is less stressful for clients
Advice is made available where multiple debts
Accounts are not sent to bailiffs where notes on file that customer is vulnerable
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre22
Benefits to LABenefits to LAMore people maintaining payment arrangements
Fewer accounts where excessive bailiff costs have to be recovered first
Referral system in place for debt advice
Input on working practices from the advice sector
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre23
Benefits to bailiff companiesBenefits to bailiff companies
Payment arrangements set up easier and more likely to be maintained
More likely to be successful in bidding for contracts with local authorities if they can show that they are working collaboratively with advice agencies
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre24
Benefits to Advice centresBenefits to Advice centres
Quicker process for dealing with council tax debts enables us to assist more clients
Less need to compose long complaint letters
No need to complete a financial statement
Setting up affordable arrangements means there is less knock-on effect on other debts
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre25
Bonus benefit! – Corporate Debt PolicyBonus benefit! – Corporate Debt PolicyWider influence – rent, benefits, parking
Simplifying and re-designing customer letters
Every £1 invested in financial capability, affordable credit and an integrated service between LA’s and advice agencies generates £8.40 for local region.
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre26
Frank makes another phone call….Frank makes another phone call….
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre27
Taking it forwardTaking it forward
10/04/23Bristol Debt Advice Centre28
Thanks for listening!Thanks for listening!