eOHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013G-001
COMPLAINANT: KENT LANHAM COUNSEL: CURT HARTMAN, ESQ.3825 MERWIN-TEN MILE RD 3749 FOX POINT COURTCINCINNATI, OH 45245 AMELIA, OH 45102
RESPONDENT: DANNY R. BUBP COUNSEL: DONALD C. BREY, ESQ.307 NORTH MARKET 65 E. STATE ST. STE. 1000WEST UNION, OH 45693 COLUMBUS, OH 43215
DANNY R. BUBP10 APACHE COVELAKE WAYNOKA, OH 45171
DANNY R. BUBP FOR STATE REP. COMMITTEEC/O MARY JEAN CAMPBELL, TREASURER307 NORTH MARKETWEST UNION, OH 45693
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.13(D) (FAILURE TO FILE A COMPLETE AND ACCURATE STATEMENT)§3517.13(O) (IMPROPER USE OF CAMPAIGN FUNDS)§3517.13(R)(2) (PERSONAL EXPENSES)§3517.13(R)(3) (PERSONAL EXPENSES)
OFFICE: STATE REP.
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 6, 2012
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION:
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013G-002
COMPLAINANT: TYRONE K YATES FOR OHIO HOUSE COUNSEL: DONALD MCTIGUE, ESQ.
1624 PULLAN AVE. 545 E. TOWN ST.CINCINNAT, OH 45223 COLUMBUS, OH
43215
RESPONDENT: SELF REFERRAL
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.13(A) (FAILURE TO FILE A COMPLETE AND ACCURATE STATEMENT)
OFFICE: HOUSE OF REPS 33RD DISTRICT
ELECTION: JANUARY 20, 2010
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 4/25/2013 THE COMMISSION CONSOLIDATED CASE NOS. 2011S-209 AND 2013G-002, FOUND A VIOLATION AND IMPOSED A TOTAL FINE OF $250.
06/10/2013 RECEIVED M.O. #21669880 FROM TYRONE YATES IN THE AMOUNT OF $250. FOR PAYMENT OF FINE IN CASE NOS. 2011S-209 AND 2013G-002.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013G-003
COMPLAINANT: JOHN MITCHEL3955 MAPLE GROVE LANEBEAVERCREEK, OH 45440
(937) 4278442
RESPONDENT: COMMITTEE FOR TAX EQUITYSHERMAN BENSON, TREASURER2984 SOUTHFIELD DR.BEAVERCREEK, OH 45434
WILLIAM KUCERA, FINANCE OFFICER COUNSEL: STEPHEN MCHUGH, ESQ.
1368 RESEARCH PARK DR. AMELIA BLANKENSHIP, ESQ.
BEAVERCREEK OH 45432 CO COUNSEL: MARIA ARMSTRONG, ESQ.
MICHAEL CORNELL, CITY MANAGER COUNSEL: SAME1368 RESEARCH PARK DR.BEAVERCREEK OH 45432
VICKI GIAMBRONE, MAYOR COUNSEL: SAME1368 RESEARCH PARK DR.BEAVERCREEK OH 45432
JERRY PETRAK, VICE-MAYOR COUNSEL: SAME1368 RESEARCH PARK DR.BEAVERCREEK OH 45432
BRIAN JARVIS, COUNCIL MEMBER COUNSEL: SAME1368 RESEARCH PARK DR.BEAVERCREEK OH 45432
SCOTT HADLEY, COUNCIL MEMBER COUNSEL: SAME1368 RESEARCH PARK DR.BEAVERCREEK OH 45432
MELISSA LITTERAL, COUNCIL MEMBER COUNSEL: SAME1368 RESEARCH PARK DR.BEAVERCREEK OH 45432
ZACH UPTON, COUNCIL MEMBER COUNSEL: SAME1368 RESEARCH PARK DR.BEAVERCREEK OH 45432
CASE NO. 2013G-003
(CONT’D)
RESPONDENT: DEBORAH WALLACE, COUNCIL MEMBER COUNSEL: SAME(CONT’D) 1368 RESEARCH PARK DR.
BEAVERCREEK OH 45432
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.1011 (ELECTIONEERING COMMUNICATIONS)§9.03 (RESTRICTIONS ON USE OF PUBLIC FUNDS)
OFFICE: INCOME TAX BALLOT INITIATIVE
ELECTION: MAY 7, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 6/20/2013 THE COMMISSION GRANTED THE MOTION TO DISMISS THE COMPLAINT.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013G-004
COMPLAINANT: GLEN P. STEWART 2342 TWIN LEAF COURT
ASHLAND, OH 44805419-289-6255
RESPONDENT: SELF REFERRAL
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.10(D) (LATE FILING OF A DESIGNATION OF TREASURER)
OFFICE: MAYOR OF ASHLAND
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 5, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 5/16/2013 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.10(D) FOR FAILING TO TIMELY FILE A DESIGNATION OF TREASURER FORM BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT IMPOSE A FINE OR REFER THE MATTER FOR FURTHER PROSECUTION.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013D-005
COMPLAINANT: ROBERT LANTMAN 338 HILLCREST DR.
SPRINGBORO, OH 45066937-607-0337
RESPONDENT: CITIZENS FOR RESPONSIBLE SPENDING COUNSEL: JACK CHRISMAN, TREASURER MAURICE THOMPSON3199 DRAKE RD. 208 E STATE STP.O. BOX 1165 COLS., OH 43215LEBANON, OH 45036 340-9817
FAX: 365-9564
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.20 (IMPROPER, INCORRECT OR MISSING DISCLAIMER)
OFFICE: ISSUE 3
ELECTION: MAY 7, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 7/25/2013 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.20 BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT IMPOSE A FINE OR REFER THE MATTER FURTHER PROSECUTION. THE COMMISSION FOUND NO VIOLATION AS TO THE THE OMMISSION OF THE WORDING "PAID FOR BY" PURSUANT TO R.C. §3517.20(A)(13).
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013D-006
COMPLAINANT: KYLE JOSEPH FARMER 216 S. WALNUT ST.
BALTIMORE, OH 43105740-808-2294
RESPONDENT: TIMOTHY ARNOLD1768 BALTIMORE RD. NWLANCASTER, OH 43130740-654-8299
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.20 (NO DISCLAIMER)
OFFICE: LANCASTER CITY COUNCIL
ELECTION: MAY 7, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 7/25/2013 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.20 BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT IMPOSE A FINE OR REFER THE MATTER FOR FURTHER PROSECUTION.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013G-007
COMPLAINANT: GERALDINE BETTIO COUNSEL: WARNER MENDENHALL, ESQ.
4155 OSAGE ST. 190 N. UNION ST. STE. 201
STOW, OH 44224 AKRON, OH 44304330-688-8297 330-535-9160
RESPONDENT: STOW MUNROE FALLS SCHOOL DISTLEVY COMMITTEEWILLIAM S. CHOLER, TREASURER2713 CALAIS DR.STOW, OH 44224330-689-5420
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.10 (STATEMENT OF CONTRIBUTIONS AND EXPENDITURES)§3517.12 (REPORT OF RECEIPTS AND EXPENDITURES ON INITIATIVE AND REFERENDUM PETITIONS)§3517.20 (NO DISCLAIMER)
OFFICE: SCHOOL LEVY
ELECTION: MAY 6, 2012
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 7/25/2013 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.10(A)(3) AND §3517.20 BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT IMPOSE A FINE OR REFER THE MATTER FOR FURTHER PROSECUTION AND DISMISSED ALL MATTERS BROUGHT PURSUANT TO R.C. §3517.12.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013D-008
COMPLAINANT: HAROLD LEWIS1423 TOWN HALL ROADDAYTON, OH 45432937 429-5113
RESPONDENT: MIKE CORNELL, CITY MANAGER COUNSEL: MARIA ARMSTRONG, ESQ.
CITY OF BEAVERCREEK BRICKER & ECKLER1368 RESEARCH PARK DRIVE 100 S THIRD STBEAVERCREEK, OH 45432 COLUMBUS, OH 43215937 427-5510
VICKI GIAMBRONE, MAYOR COUNSEL: SAMECITY OF BEAVERCREEK1368 RESEARCH PARK DRIVEBEAVERCREEK, OH 45432937 427-5510
MIKE THONNERIEUX, PARKS SUPERINTENDENT COUNSEL: SAME
CITY OF BEAVERCREEK1368 RESEARCH PARK DRIVEBEAVERCREEK, OH 45432937 427-5510
STEPHEN MCHUGH, CITY ATTORNEY COUNSEL: SAMECITY OF BEAVERCREEK1368 RESEARCH PARK DRIVEBEAVERCREEK, OH 45432937 427-5510
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.20 (NO DISCLAIMER)
OFFICE: CITY INCOME TAX
ELECTION: MAY 7, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 7/25/2013 THE COMMISSION GRANTED THE MOTION TO DISMISS.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013G-009
COMPLAINANT: ANTHONY J. MEALY328 S. PROFESSOR ST.OBERLIN, OH 44074
RESPONDENT: CHARLES F. PETERSONOBERLIN CITY COUNCILMAN283 MORGAN ST. OBERLIN, OH 44074440-774-4278
LORAIN COUNTY BOARD OF ELECTIONSPAUL R. ADAMS, DIRECTOR1985 N. RIDGE RD. ELORAIN, OH 44055-3344440-326-5901
ALLEGATIONS: 3517.13(O)(2)(CAMPAIGN FUNDS CONVERTED FOR PERSONAL USE – LEGAL FEES) 3517.11(B)(4)(a)(FAILURE TO PROPERLY EXAMINE AND/OR REFER A CANDIDATE FOR POSSIBLE VIOLATIONS OF CAMPAIGN FINANCE STATUTES)
OFFICE: OBERLIN COUNCIL AT LARGE
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 8, 2011
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 8/22/2013 THE COMMISSION FOUND NO VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE COMPLAINT.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013G-010
COMPLAINANT: DANIELLE NICOLE ERB1800 WATERTOWER DR.COLUMBUS, OH 43235614-935-9287
RESPONDENT: JOSEPH DOMINICK ERB4548 BRAITHWAY ST.HILLIARD, OH 43026614-570-1274
ALLEGATIONS: 3517.13(O) (CAMPAIGN FUNDS CONVERTED FOR PERSONAL USE)
OFFICE: HILLIARD CITY COUNCIL
ELECTION:
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 7/17/2014 THE COMMISSION GRANTED THE RESPONDENT'S MOTION TO DISMISS.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013E-011
COMPLAINANT: DON NICOLARD – WARD 2 COUNCILMAN PRESIDENT OF NORTON CITY COUNCIL2816 BROOKFIELD DR.NORTON, OH 44203330-753-4932
RESPONDENT: CITIZENS4NORTON COUNSEL: WARNER MENDENHALLC/O REBECCA VODILKO-AGENT3883 CROYDON ST.NORTON, OH 44203
DENNIS PIERSON, CHAIRMANCITIZENS4NORTON3793 EASTON RD.NORTON, OH 44203330-825-2084
STEVEN FANNIN2811 SHELLHART RD.NORTON, OH 44203330-814-1777
**** Keep Summit County BOE Apprised of the status of this case****
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.10(D) (FAILURE TO FILE A DESIGNATION OF TREASURER)§3517.105(C)(2) (INDEPENDENT EXPENDITURES)§3517.22 (FALSE STATEMENTS)§3599.03 (FAILURE TO FILE A 30-B-1 FORM)
OFFICE: ISSUE #1
ELECTION:
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 5/15/2014 THE COMMISSION ACCEPTED THE COMPLAINANT'S REQUEST TO DISMISS THE MATTER.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013G-012
COMPLAINANT: JOHN A BOYDCUYAHOGA CO. CENTRAL COMMITTEEWARD 6 PRECINCT G2173 E. 84TH ST.CLEVELAND, OH 44103216-319-5693
RESPONDENT: MAMIE J. MITCHELL, COUNCILWOMANCLEVELAND CITY HALL601 LAKESIDE AVE.CLEVELAND, OH 44114
CUYAHOGA CO. BOARD OF ELECTIONS2925 EUCLID AVE.CLEVELAND, OH 44115
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.10(A) (FAILURE TO TIMELY FILE A TRUE AND ITEMIZED STATEMENT)§3517.11 (DUTIES OF BOARD OF ELECTIONS)§3517.11(D) (ISSUANCE OF CERTIFICATE OF NOMINATION)
OFFICE: WARD 6 COUNCIL
ELECTION:
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 8/22/2013 THE COMMISSION FOUND NO VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE COMPLAINT.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013E-013
COMPLAINANT: GEORGE KARL HEISLER233 TRAILS ENDAURORA, OH 44202330-562-8439
RESPONDENT: AURORA RECREATION FOR ISSUE 950 TRAILS ENDAURORA, OH 44202330-562-6131
AURORA RECREATION LLCOHIO ENTITY NUMBER 1606536REGISTERED AGENT: J. HUNTER BANBURY329 GLENGARRY DR.AURORA, OH 44202
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.22(B)(2) (FALSE STATEMENTS)
OFFICE: ISSUE 9
ELECTION:
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 8/22/2013 THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DISMISSED THE MATTER AS THE COMPLAINT WAS FILED BEYOND THE 2-YEAR STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS ESTABLISHED IN R.C. §3517157(A).
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013E-014
COMPLAINANT: DOMENIC L. CAMPANA6523 LIBERTY BELL DR.BROOK PARK, OH 44142216-267-0785
LINBELL LEWIS JR.6561 WEST VANCEY DR.BROOK PARK, OH 44142216-534-8569
RESPONDENT: THOMAS J. COYNE JR. COUNSEL: DONALD MCTIGUE, ESQ.23589 WOODHILL DR.BROOK PARK, OH 44142216-509-7873
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.21(B)(1) (FALSE STATEMENTS)
OFFICE: BROOK PARK MAYOR
ELECTION:
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 9/26/2013 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.21(B)(1) BY CLEAR AND CONVINCING EVIDENCE BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT REFER THE MATTER FOR FURTHER PROSECUTION.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013G-015
COMPLAINANT: TECUMSEH LOCAL SCHOOLS LEVY COMMITTEEDANNY KOTTMYER2733 QUAIL RIDGE DRIVENEW CARLISLE, OH 45344937 620-2975
RESPONDENT: LARRY HALL10555 NEW CARLISLE PIKENEW CARLISLE, OH 45344
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.10 (FAILURE TO FILE A PAC)3517.10 (FAILURE TO FILE THE REQUIRED CAMPAIGN FINANCE REPORTS)
OFFICE: TECUMSEH LOCAL SCHOOLS LEVY
ELECTION: AUGUST 6, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 10/31/2013 THE COMMISSION FOUND NO VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.10.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013G-016
COMPLAINANT: JASON HARTMEDIA TRACKERS OHIO 4485 KRIGGSBY BLVDHILLIARD, OH 43026614 [email protected]
RESPONDENT: WE ARE OHIO (PAC REGISTRATION #BI1491) COUNSEL: MCTIGUE545 E TOWN ST COREY COLOMBOCOLUMBUS, OH 43215 545 E TOWN STWEBSITE: http://facebook.comWeAreOhio COLS., OH 43215
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.10(B)(4), AND (5) (FAILURE TO FILE A COMPLETE AND ACCURATE CAMPAIGN FINANCE REPORT)
OFFICE:
ELECTION: 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 12/5/2013 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT IMPOSE A FINE OR REFER THE MATTER FOR FURTHER PROSECUTION.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013G-017
COMPLAINANT: MATTHEW BORGES CHAIRMAN, OHIO REPUBLI CAN PARTY211 S FIFTH STCOLUMBUS, OH 43215614 228-2481
RESPONDENT: EDWARD FITZGERALDCUYAHOGA COUNTY EXECUTIVE1219 ONTARIO STCLEVELAND, OH 44113
FRIENDS OF FITZGERALD COMMITTEEJEFFREY RUPERT, TREASURER 340 E FULTON STCOLUMBUS, OH 43215
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.13(A)(1) (FAILURE TO FILE A COMPLETE AND ACCURATE CAMPAIGN FINANCE REPORTS)§3517.10 and §3517.13 (ACCEPTING AN ILLEGAL CONTRIBUTION)
OFFICE: OHIO GOVERNOR
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 5, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 10/31/2013 THE COMPLAINT WAS WITHDRAWN BY THE COMPLAINANT.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013G-018PAGE 1 OF 2
COMPLAINANT: GERALD L. SILVERA 2203 LEE BLVD.EAST CLEVELAND, OH [email protected]
RESPONDENT: GARY NORTON JR.2120 NEWBURY DR.EAST CLEVELAND, OH [email protected]
FRIENDS OF GARY NORTONERIC SCOTT NORTON, TREASURER 8115 WADE PARK #4CLEVELAND, OH 44103216-791-5914
FRIENDS OF GARY NORTONSHALOM NORTON, TREASURER2120 NEWBURY DR.EAST CLEVELAND, OH 44112216-397-1121
FRIENDS OF GARY NORTONMICHAEL SMEDLEY, TREASURER16000 TERRACE RD. #1705EAST CLEVELAND, OH [email protected]
CUYAHOGA CO. BOARD OF ELECTIONSC/O PAT MCDONALD, DIRECTOR2925 EUCLID AVE.CLEVELAND, OH 44115216-443-6411
CASE NO: 2013G-018PAGE 2 OF 2
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.08 (MATTERS NOT CONSIDERED CONTRIBUTION OR EXPENDITURE)§3517.081 (CAMPAIGN COMMITTEE; DESIGNATION OF TREASURER; FILING STATEMENTS)§3517.092 (SOLICITATIONS FROM PUBLIC EMPLOYEES)§3517.10 (TIMES FOR FILING STATEMENT OF CONTRIBUTIONS AND EXPENDITURES; CONTENTS; APPOINTMENT OF TREASURER)§3517.11 (PROCEDURES RELATING TO REPORTS OF CONTRIBUTIONS AND EXPENDITURES)§3517.13 (FAILURE TO FILE A COMPLETE AND ACCURATE STATEMENT)
OFFICE: EAST CLEVELAND MAYOR
ELECTION:
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 11/14/2013 THE COMMISSION DISMISSED THE MATTER.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013E-019
COMPLAINANT: KENNETH P MASICH389 E PARK AVEBARBERTON, OH 44203
RESPONDENT: ZACH MILKOVICH COUNSEL:DONALD MCTIGUE, ESQ.PEOPLE FOR MILKOVICH210 17TH ST NWBARBERTON, OH 44203 330 810-2007
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.21(B)(1), AND (10) (FALSE STATEMENT)
OFFICE: BARBERTON MUNICIPAL CLERK OF COURT
ELECTION: SEPTEMBER 10, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 10/31/2013 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §351721(B)(1) BY CLEAR AND CONVINCING EVIDENCE AGAINST PEOPLE FOR MILKOVICH BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT REFER THE MATTER FOR FURTHER PROSECUTION. THE COMMISSION THEN FOUND NO VIOLATION AGAINST THE CANDIDATE ZACH MILKOVICH.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013G-020
COMPLAINANT: DONALD R. CULP1021 KIRKWALL CTMIAMISBURG, OH 45342937-671-0881
RESPONDENT: DEBORAH PRESTONMIAMI TOWNSHIP TRUSTEE2172 PARKWYN DR.MIAMISBURG, OH 45342937-866-8044937-673-3312
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.10(A) AND (D)(4) (TIMES FOR FILING STATEMENT OF CONTRIBUTIONS AND EXPENDITURES; CONTENTS; AOOIUBTNEBT IF TREASURER)§3517.13(G)(1) (CONCEALMENT OR MISREPRESENTATION)
OFFICE: MIAMI TOWNSHIP TRUSTEE
ELECTION:
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION:
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013D-021
COMPLAINANT: KENNETH R. WATKINS6667 CLIFFSIDE DR.VERMILION, OH 44089440-541-7365
RESPONDENT: JEAN ANDERSON3240 EDGEWATER DR.VERMILION, OH 44089440-213-3058
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.20 (IMPROPER OR MISSING DISCLAIMER)
OFFICE: VERMILION MAYOR
ELECTION:
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 10/31/2013 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.20 AND IMPOSED A FINE OF $500 BUT DID NOT REFER THE MATTER FOR FURTHER PROSECUTION.
12/23/2013 THE COMMISSION RECEIVED CHECK # 5011 IN THE AMOUNT OF $500 FROM JEAN A ANDERSON FOR PAYMENT OF THE FINE IMPOSED.
CASE CLOSED
Send copy of disposition to Karen Cornelius via email to [email protected]
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013E-022
COMPLAINANT: GEORGE C GEORGEFF261 SOUTH HAMILTON ROADCOLUMBUS, OH 43213614 231-3131
RESPONDENT: RYAN DEMRO598 WICKHAM WAYGAHANNA, OH 43230216 288-8092
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.20(A)(NO DISCLAIMER)§3517.21(B)(9) (FALSE STATEMENT)
OFFICE: GAHANNA MAYOR
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 5, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 12/5/2013 THE COMMISSION CONSOLIDATED CASE NOS. 2013E-022 AND 2013D-036. THE COMMISSION FOUND NO VIOLATION IN CASE NO. 2013E-022. THE COMMISSION THEN FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.20(A) AGAINST CITIZENS FOR DEMRO, AS SUBSTITUTED FOR MR. DEMRO INDIVIDUALLY, IN CASE NO. 2013D-036 AND IMPOSED A FINE OF $100.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013D-023
COMPLAINANT: BRIAN COOK5190 WORLEY RD.TIPP CITY, OH 45371(W) 937-669-4822(C) 937-609-6285
RESPONDENT: PATRICK HALE260 S. GARBER DR.TIPP CITY, OH 45371
PATRICK HALE264 S. GARBER DR.TIPP CITY, OH 45371
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.20(A)(NO DISCLAIMER)
OFFICE: TIPP CITY COUNCIL
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 5, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 11/14/2013 THE MATTER WAS WITHDRAWN BY THE COMPLAINANT.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013E-024
COMPLAINANT: KEVIN M KENNEDYCITY OF NORTH OLMSTED MAYOR6049 BARTON RDNORTH OLMSTED, OH 44070
RESPONDENT: THOMAS O’GRADY6328 HASTINGS DRNORTH OLMSTED, OH 44070
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.21(FALSE STATEMENT)
OFFICE: NORTH OLMSTED MAYOR
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 5, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 10/31/2013 THE MATTER WAS DECLARED AN ADMINISTRATIVE DISMISSAL AS THE COMMISSION WAS UNABLE TO REACH A MAJORITY VOTE.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013E-025PAGE 1 OF 2
COMPLAINANT: GEORGE KEYSER147 AIRPORT RD. SECARROLLTON, OH 44615
RESPONDENT: CARROLLTON EXEMPTED VILLAGE SCHOOL DIST. COUNSEL: DR. DAVID QUATTROCHI, SUPERINTENDENT MELISSA R
HOEFFEL252 THIRD ST. NE ROETZEL &
ANNDRESS LPACARROLLTON, OH 44615 155 E BROAD ST
12TH FLOORCOLS., OH 43215
ROSE SECK136 GALLO RD. NWCARROLLTON, OH 44615
HELEN SKINNER126 WOOD RD. SECARROLLTON, OH 44615
BONNIE LITTLE3035 ARROW RD. NWCARROLLTON, OH 44615
MICHAEL POZDERAC160 WEDGEWOOD LANECARROLLTON, OH 44615
WENDY GOTCHALL1203 KENSINGTON RD. NECARROLLTON, OH 44615
CARROLLTON SCHOOLS CAMPAIGN COMMITTEESONYA EDDY, TREASURER107 JOSH LANECARROLLTON, OH 44615
CARROLLTON SCHOOLS CAMPAIGN COMMITTEECHRISTOPHER SHEPHERD, DEPUTY TREASURER1045 TRUMP RD. NWCARROLLTON, OH 44615
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.105 (INDEPENDENT EXPENDITURES)§3517.22(B)(2) (FALSE STATEMENTS)§3517.20 (IMPROPER DISCLAIMER)
CASE NO. 2013E-025PAGE 2 OF 2
OFFICE: SCHOOL LEVY
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 5, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION 10/17/2013 THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL FOUND THAT THERE WAS NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.22(B)(2) AND §3517.105 AS ALLEGED IN THE COMPLAINT. IN ADDITION, THE COMMISSION DISMISSED THE SUPERINTENDENT AND THE INDIVIDUAL MEMBERS OF THE CARROLLTON EXEMPTED VILLAGE SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARD OF EDUCATION. THE PANEL DID FIND THAT THERE WAS PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AS ALLEGED IN THE COMPLAINT CONCERNING R.C. §3517.20. THAT PORTION OF THE COMPLAINT WILL BE HEARD BY THE FULL COMMISSION ON NOVEMBER 4, 2013.
11/14/2013 THE MATTER WAS WITHDRAWN BY THE COMPLAINANT.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013E-026
COMPLAINANT: MICHAEL J. SHAPIRO, ESQ.23240 CHAGRIN BLVD. STE. 450BEACHWOOD, OH 44122216-831-3737(F) 216-831/[email protected]
RESPONDENT: MERLE S. GORDEN, MAYORMERLE S. GORDEN ELECTION COMMITTEEC/O TERRY SILVER, TREASURER23621 HALBURTON RD.BEACHWOOD, OH 44122
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.21(B)(10) (FALSE STATEMENT)§3599.03 (FAILURE TO FILE A 30-B-1 FORM)
OFFICE: BEACHWOOD CITY MAYOR
ELECTION:
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 10/17/2013 THE PROBABLE CAUSE FOUND NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE COMPLAINT.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013E-027
COMPLAINANT: SARAH M. JOBE25 DEVON CT.SPRINGBORO, OH [email protected]
RESPONDENT: KOLTON VAUGHN544 HAMPSTEAD CT.DAYTON, OH 45458
DAVID BITNER85 FAIRWAY DR.SPRINGBORO, OH 45066
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.21(B)(1) (FALSE STATEMENT)
OFFICE: SPRINGBORO BOARD OF EDUCATION
ELECTION:
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 11/4/2013 THE MATTER WAS WITHDRAWN BY THE COMPLAINANT.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013E-028
COMPLAINANT: SUE MAYBERRY439 HIGH ST. NECANAL FULTON, OH 44614330-854-9756 PAUL BAGOCIUS451 CHERRY ST. EASTCANAL FULTON, OH 44614330-854-4645
EARL MINKS627 S. CANAL ST.CANAL FULTON, OH 44614309-208-0187
RESPONDENT: SEAN CRANEY842 MEADOW VIEW DR. NWCANAL FULTON, OH 44614330-854-9494
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.21 (FALSE STATEMENT)
OFFICE: CANAL FULTON CITY COUNCIL
ELECTION: 11/5/2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 11/4/2013 THE MATTER WAS WITHDRAWN BY THE COMPLAINANT.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013D-029COMPLAINANT: GEORGE KEYSER
147 AIRPORT RD. SECARROLLTON, OH 44615
MICHELL DAY3407 LUNAR RD. NECARROLLTON, OH 44615
RESPONDENT: CARROLLTON EXEMPTED VILLAGE SCHOOL DIST. COUNSEL:DR. DAVID QUATTROCHI, SUPERINTENDENT MELISSA R HOEFFEL252 THIRD ST. NE ROETZEL & ANNDRESS LPACARROLLTON, OH 44615 155 E BROAD ST
12TH FLOORCOLS., OH 43215
ROSE SECK136 GALLO RD. NWCARROLLTON, OH 44615
HELEN SKINNER126 WOOD RD. SECARROLLTON, OH 44615
BONNIE LITTLE3035 ARROW RD. NWCARROLLTON, OH 44615
MICHAEL POZDERAC160 WEDGEWOOD LANECARROLLTON, OH 44615
WENDY GOTCHALL1203 KENSINGTON RD. NECARROLLTON, OH 44615
ALLEGATIONS: §3315.07(C)(1) (PROHIBITION OF SCHOOLS USING FUNDS ON BALLOT ISSUE)§3517.20 (NO DISCLAIMER)
OFFICE: SCHOOL LEVY
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 5, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 11/14/2013 THE COMMISSION DISMISSED ALL INDIVIDUAL BOARD MEMBERS NAMED IN THE COMPLAINT. THE COMMISSION THEN FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.20 AGAINST CARROLTON EXEMPTED VILLAGE SCHOOL DISTRICT AND IMPOSED A FINE OF $100.
1/29/2014 THE COMMISSION RECEIVED CHECK # 069075 IN THE AMOUNT OF $100 FROM CARROLLTON EX. VILLAGE SCHOOL DIST. FOR PAYMENT OF THE FINE IMPOSED.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013E-030
COMPLAINANT: CATHY ANSPACH427 OLD 122LEBANON, OH 45036513 850-3355
RESPONDENT: DALE LAMB COUNSEL: DONALD MCTIGUE, ESQ.7830 BUNNELL HILL ROADSPRINGBORO, OH [email protected]
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.21(B) (FALSE STATEMENT)
OFFICE: CLEARCREEK TOWNSHIP TRUSTEE
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 5, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 10/24/2013 THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THAT THERE WAS NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE COMPLAINT.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013E-031
COMPLAINANT: JOHN BIECHELE3914 GALLOWAY ROADSANDUSKY, OH 44870419 625-8408
RESPONDENT: KEVIN ASHER 601 WILLIAMS STHURON, OH 44938
NANCY BULEA326 WEXFORD DRHURON, OH 44839
ERIC MUEHLHAUSER606 ONEIDA PLACEHURON, OH 44839WWW.SAVEHURONSHOOLS.COM
COMMITTEE TO ELECT ASHER, BULEA AND MUEHLHAUSERMIKE TANN, TREASURER 229 CENTER STHURON, OH 44839
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.21(B)(3) (FALSE STATEMENT)
OFFICE: HURON SCHOOL BOARD
ELECTION: 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 10/24/2013 THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THAT THERE WAS NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE COMPLAINT.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013E-032
COMPLAINANT: THEODORE J WEBB1979 TIMBER CREEK DRIVE ECORTLAND, OH 44410330 638-2955
CELL: 330 540-1551
RESPONDENT: DONALD P. URCHEK COUNSEL: H. Gilson Blair3900 LAKESHORE DR DeHaven & Blair, Ltd.CORTLAND, OH 44410 154 N. Park Ave.330 638-5325 Warren, OH 44481
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.21(B)(10) (FALSE STATEMENT)
OFFICE: BAZETTA TOWNSHIP TRUSTEES
ELECTION: 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 11/4/2013 THE COMMISSION FOUND NO VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.21(B)(10).
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013D-033
COMPLAINANT: JANICE K STEELE 208 ST RT 58SULLIVAN, OH 44880419 736-2145
RESPONDENT: SUZANNE FAYAK593 TWP RD 150SULLIVAN, OH 44880440 225-9064
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.20(A) (NO DISCLAIMER)
OFFICE: SULLIVAN TOWNSHIP TRUSTEE
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 5, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 12/5/2013 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.20(A) AS TO THE YARD SIGNS BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT IMPOSE A FINE OR REFER THE MATTER OR REFER THE MATTER FOR FURTHER PROSECUTION. THE COMMISSION THEN FOUND NO VIOLATION AS TO THE ALLEGATIONS REGARDING THE POST CARD.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013D-034
COMPLAINANT: DONALD R CULP1021 KIRKWALL CTMIAMISBURG, OH 45342 937 671-0881
RESPONDENT: ANDREW PAPANEK3430 OLD LANTERN CTMIAMISBURG, OH 45342
NICHOLAS SEITZ3401 MYNA LANEMIAMISBURG, OH 45342
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.20(A)(2)AND (13) (INCORRECT DISCLAIMER) §3517.10(D) (1)(FAILURE TO FILE A DESIGNATION OF TREASURER)§3517.081 (FAILURE TO FILE A DESIGNATION OF TREASURER)
OFFICE: MONTGOMERY COUNTY MIAMI TOWNSHIP TRUSTEE
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 5, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 12/5/2013 THE COMMISSION ACCEPTED THE COMPLAINANT’S REQUEST TO DISMISS THE COMPLAINT.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013E-035
COMPLAINANT: JOE MCABEE3677 SYLVIA DR.FAIRFIELD TWP, OH 45011
RESPONDENT: MARK SUTTON COUNSEL: BRETT RENZENBRINKKEEP SUTTON TRUSTEE COMMITTEE STRAUSS, TROY CO LPAMARK SUTTON, TREASURER 150 E 4THST 6417 GLENMONT DR. FOURTH FLOORFAIRFIELD TWP, OH 45011 CINTI., OH 45202
STEVE MORGAN2784 TYLERSVILLE RD.HAMILTON, OH 45015
REELECT STEVE MORGAN FAIRFIELD TWP TRUSTEEMICHELLE A. HURLEY, DEPUTY TREASURER2538 SHAFER KNOLL CT.HAMILTON, OH 45011
KEEP TRUSTEES MORGAN AND SUTTON COMMITTEEDONNA IRVIN, TREASURER3484 HAMILTON-MIDDLETOWN RD.HAMILTON, OH 45011
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.10(D)(1) (FAILURE TO FILE A DESIGNATION OF TREASURER)§3517.20(A)(2) (IMPROPER, INCOMPLETE OR MISSING DISCLAIMER)§3517.21(B)(8) (FALSE STATEMENTS)
OFFICE: FAIRFIELD TOWNSHIP TRUSTEE
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 5, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 11/4/2013 THE COMMISSION FOUND NO VIOLATION AGAINST KEEP TRUSTEES MORGAN AND SUTTON COMMITTEE AND DONNA IRVIN. THE COMMISSION THEN FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.20 AGAINST ALL OTHER PARTIES NAMED BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT IMPOSE A FINE OR REFER THE MATTER FOR FURTHER PROSECUTION.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013D-036
COMPLAINANT: GEORGE C GEORGEFF261 SOUTH HAMILTON ROADCOLUMBUS, OH 43213614 231-3131
RESPONDENT: RYAN DEMRO598 WICKHAM WAYGAHANNA, OH 43230216 288-8092
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.20(A)(NO DISCLAIMER)
OFFICE: GAHANNA MAYOR
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 5, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 12/5/2013 THE COMMISSION CONSOLIDATED CASE NOS. 2013E-022 AND 2013D-036. THE COMMISSION FOUND NO VIOLATION IN CASE NO. 2013E-022. THE COMMISSION THEN FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.20(A) AGAINST CITIZENS FOR DEMRO IN CASE NO. 2013D-036 AND IMPOSED A FINE OF $100.
02/11/2014 RECEIVED CHECK #1053 IN THE AMOUNT OF $100 FROM CITIZENS FOR DEMRO FOR PAYMENT OF FINE
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013E-037
COMPLAINANT: DAVID H. LANDONFIRST VICE CHAIRMAN AND ACTING CHAIRMANMONTGOMERY CO. EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE2700 E. RIVER RD.DAYTON, OH 45439937 241-9807
RESPONDENT: ANDREW PAPANEK3430 OLD LANTERN CT.MIAMISBURG, OH 45342
NICHOLAS SEITZ3401 MYNA LANEMIAMISBURG, OH 45342
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.21(8)(10) (FALSE STATEMENTS)
OFFICE: MIAMI TOWNSHIP TRUSTEE
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 5, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 10/31/2013 THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THAT THERE WAS NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE COMPLAINT.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013E-038
COMPLAINANT: CHARLES E. WALDER9240 MUSIC ST.NOVELTY, OH 44072216-554-1094
RESPONDENT: KENNETH M. ARMSTRONG15175 DEEPWOOD LN.NOVELTY, OH 44072440-247-5127
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.22(B)(2) (FALSE STATEMENTS)
OFFICE: RUSSELL TOWNSHIP TRUSTEE
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 5, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 10/31/2013 THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THAT THERE WAS NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE COMPLAINT.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013E-039
COMPLAINANT: JON SNYDER515 EVERHARD RD. SWN. CANTON, OH 44709330-497-2470(C) 330-612-3986
RESPONDENT: HILLARY MUELLER1334 WILKSHIRE CIRCLE SWN. CANTON, OH 44720330-904-9107
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.21(B)(9) & (10) (FALSE STATEMENTS)
OFFICE: NORTH CANTON CITY COUNCIL
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 5, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 11/4/2013 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.21(B)(9) & (10) BY CLEAR AND CONVINCING EVIDENCE BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT REFER THE MATTER FOR FURTHER PROSECUTION.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013E-040
COMPLAINANT: LINBELL LEWIS JR.6561 W. VANCEY DR.BROOK PARK, OH 44142216-534-8569
RESPONDENT: DANNY V. COLONNA COUNSEL: JEFF RUPPERT, ESQ.17948 SHELDON RD.BROOK PARK, OH 44142216-362-7755
FRIENDS TO ELECT COLONNA COMMITTEE COUNSEL: SAMEKIMBERLY KINNEAR, TREASURER13453 CRESTWAY DR.BROOK PARK, OH 44142216-265-3097
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.21(B)(10) (FALSE STATEMENT)
OFFICE: BROOK PARK MAYOR
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 5, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 10/31/2013 THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THAT THERE WAS NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE COMPLAINT.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013E-041
COMPLAINANT: MARCIA KIESLING315 BONNETT ST. SWN. CANTON, OH 44720330-284-3334
RESPONDENT: JAMIE MCCLEASTER710 PIERCE AVE. NWN. CANTON, OH 44720330-526-6960
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.21(B)(9) & (10) (FALSE STATEMENTS)
OFFICE: N. CANTON COUNCIL-AT-LARGE
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 5, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 11/4/2013 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.21(B)(9) & (10) BY CLEAR AND CONVINCING EVIDENCE BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT REFER THE MATTER FOR FURTHER PROSECUTION.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013D-042
COMPLAINANT: RODNEY RHODEN11033 BAYS RDCYGNET, OH 43413
HOME: 419 619-0933 CELL: 419 655-2363
RESPONDENT: DONALD ZIEGLER9113 EMERSONWAYNE, OH 43466
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.20 (NO DISCLAIMER)
OFFICE: PORTAGE TWP TRUSTEE
ELECTION:
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 12/5/2013 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.20 BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT IMPOSE A FINE OR REFER THE MATTER FOR FURTHER PROSECUTION.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013D-043
COMPLAINANT: ED DAVILA333 ERIE ST SOUTH #325MASSILLON, OH 44648330 412-2605
RESPONDENT: PAUL MANSON COUNSEL: PERICLES G. STERGIOS, ESQ.350 STARBROOK ST NW 2859 AARONWOOD AVE. NEMASSILLON, OH 44647 SUITE 102330 832-7817 MASSILLON, OH 44646-2371
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.20 (NO DISCLAIMER)
OFFICE: MASSILLON COUNCIL AT LARGE
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 5, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 12/5/2013 THE COMMISSION FOUND NO VIOLATION OF §3517.20.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013D-044
COMPLAINANT: ART SAUERWEIN1723 SERENITY HILL LN.HAMILTON, OH 45013513-615-8400
RESPONDENT: FRED STITSINGER1285 MORMAN RD.HAMILTON, OH 45013513-205-5670
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.20 (NO DISCLAIMER)
OFFICE: HANOVER TOWNSHIP TRUSTEE
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 5, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 12/19/2013 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.20 BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT IMPOSE A FINE OR REFER THE MATTER FOR FURTHER PROSECUTION.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013E-045
COMPLAINANT: JAMES G. NUZNOFF727 DEERWOOD DR.TALLMADGE, OH [email protected]
RESPONDENT: JAMES M. DONOVAN496 HELENA DR.TALLMADGE, OH 44278
ROBERT D. MAGUIRE1068 LEDGEBROOK DR.TALLMADGE, OH 44278
KIM RAY378 CHERYL DR.TALLMADGE, OH 44278
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.20 (NO DISCLAIMER)§3517.21(B)(10) (FALSE STATEMENTS)
OFFICE: TALLMADGE COUNCIL-AT-LARGE
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 5, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 11/4/2013 THE COMMISSION DISMISSED JAMES DONOVAN FROM THE MATTER. THE COMMISSION THEN FOUND A VIOLATION AGAINST ROBERT MAGUIRE BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT IMPOSE A FINE OR REFER THE MATTER FOR FURTHER PROSECUTION.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013G-046
COMPLAINANT: KARL SALMON2135 SHERBORNE LANEPOWELL, OH 43065614-844-3834
RESPONDENT: TOM MITCHELL4426 METLER CT.POWELL, OH 43065614-917-9053
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.10(D) (FAILURE TO INCLUDE NAME OF CANDIDATE IN COMMITTEE NAME)
OFFICE: LIBERTY TOWNSHIP TRUSTEE
ELECTION: NOVEMBER 5, 2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 12/19/2013 THE COMMISSION FOUND A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.10 BUT FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN DID NOT IMPOSE A FINE OR REFER THE MATTER FOR FURTHER PROSECUTION.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013E-047
COMPLAINANT: SARAH M. JOBE25 DEVON CT.SPRINGBORO, OH [email protected]
RESPONDENT: KOLTON VAUGHN544 HAMPSTEAD CT.DAYTON, OH 45458
DAVID BITNER85 FAIRWAY DR.SPRINGBORO, OH 45066
JIM RIGANO8786 WILDWOOD PLACESPRINGBORO, OH 45066
DAVID PETRONI25 DREW COURTSPRINGBORO, OH 45066
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.22 (FALSE STATEMENTS)
OFFICE: SPRINGBORO BOARD OF EDUCATION
ELECTION: 11/5/2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 11/14/2013 THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THAT THERE WAS NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE COMPLAINT.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013E-048
COMPLAINANT: JIM REED1080 STONE RD.XENIA, OH 45385937-750-5145
RESPONDENT: THE CITIZENS SEEKING TRUTH COUNSEL: DAVID P SUICH, ESQAND HONESTY IN XENIA TWP GOV’T MCNAMEE & MCNAMEE, PLLC/O DAVID BLACK 2625 COMMONS BLVD1166 DAYTON XENIA RD. BEAVERCREEK, OH 45431XENIA, OH 45385937-429-2961
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.21(B)(10) (FALSE STATEMENTS)
OFFICE:
ELECTION: 11/5/2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 3/13/2014 THE COMMISSION DISMISSED THE MATTER.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013E-049
COMPLAINANT: JOHN T. PLECNIK2890 BISHOP RD.WILLOUGHBY HILLS, OH 44092440-382-9978
RESPONDENT: RAYMOND C. SOMICH2941 LEGEND LN.WILLOUGHBY HILLS, OH 44092440-567-8316
ANDREW JOSEPH ZAWATSKI28914 EDDY RD.WILLOUGHBY HILLS, OH 44092
GLORIA JEAN MAJESKI2717 GRAYLOCK DR.WILLOUGHBY HILLS, OH 44094440-951-0776
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.10(D) (LATE FILING A DESIGNATION OF TREASURER)§3517.20 (FAILURE TO INCLUDE DISCLAIMER)§3517.21 (FALSE STATEMENTS)
OFFICE:
ELECTION: 11/5/2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 11/14/2013 PRIOR TO THE COMMISSION TAKING THE MATTER UNDER CONSIDERATION, THE COMPLAINANT SUBMITTED TO THE COMMISSION A REQUEST TO WITHDRAW THE COMPLAINT. PURSUANT TO R.C. §3517.157(B), A MATTER MAY BE WITHDRAWN WITHOUT FURTHER ACTION OF THE COMMISSION AT ANY TIME PRIOR TO THE COMMISSION TAKING THE MATTER UNDER CONSIDERATION. THEREFORE, THE COMMISSION ALLOWED THE MATTER TO BE WITHDRAWN WITHOUT ANY FURTHER ACTION.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013E-050
COMPLAINANT: DEBBIE TARANTO COUNSEL: JAMES BOWNAS, ESQ188 STONE BEND DR.POWELL, OH [email protected]
RESPONDENT: LISA KNAPP228 HIDEAWAY COURTPOWELL, OH 43065614-425-1549
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.21(10) (FALSE STATEMENTS)
OFFICE: ORANGE TOWNSHIP TRUSTEE
ELECTION:
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 11/14/2013 THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THAT THERE WAS NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE COMPLAINT.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013E-051
COMPLAINANT: SHIRLEY HACKETT-AUSTIN6736 STOLL LANESILVERTON, OH 45236513-984-6736
MARK QUARRY7032 EAST AVE.SILVERTON, OH 45236513-675-5368
FRANK SYLVESTER6316 ELWYNNE CIRCLESILVERTON, OH 45236513-891-7852
RESPONDENT: SHIRLEY A. JASON6612 STOLL LANESILVERTON, OH 45236513-793-6612
NOLAN JASON6612 STOLL LANESILVERTON, OH 45236
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.21 (FALSE STATEMENTS)
OFFICE:
ELECTION: 11/5/2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 12/5/2013 THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL DETERMINED THAT THERE WAS NO PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION AND DISMISSED THE COMPLAINT.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013E-052
COMPLAINANT: KENNETH CLAYPOOLE10221 GLOUCESTER RD.STREETSBORO, OH 44241330-571-5778
RESPONDENT: EMERYLDE BRADLEY10070 N. DELMONTE BLVD.STREETSBORO, OH 44241513-793-6612
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.21(B) (FALSE STATEMENTS)
OFFICE: STREETSBORO CITY COUNCIL
ELECTION: 11/5/2013
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 12/5/2013 THE PROBABLE CAUSE PANEL FOUND THAT THERE WAS PROBABLE CAUSE OF A VIOLATION OF R.C. §3517.21(B)(10) AS ALLEGED IN THE COMPLAINT. THIS MATTER WILL BE SCHEDULED FOR HEARING BEFORE THE FULL COMMISSION AT A DATE TO BE DETERMINED BY THE COMMISSION STAFF.
4/24/2014 THE COMMISSION ACCEPTED THE COMPLAINANT'S REQUEST TO DISMISS THE MATTER.
OHIO ELECTIONS COMMISSIONCASE SUMMARY SHEET
CASE NO. 2013G-053
COMPLAINANT: FRIENDS OF ERIC FINGERHUT COUNSEL: DONALD MCTIGUE, ESQ. 84 NORTH ARDMORE COREY COLOMBO, ESQ.
BEXLEY, OH 45209 545 E. TOWN ST.COLUMBUS, OH 43215
RESPONDENT: SELF REFERRAL
ALLEGATIONS: §3517.13(D) (FAILURE TO FILE A COMPLETE AND ACCURATE STATEMENT)
OFFICE: OHIO SENATE
ELECTION: JANUARY 20, 2010
PRIORS:
DISPOSITION: 12/5/2013 THE COMMISSION CONSOLIDATED CASE NOS. 2011S-202, 2012S-063 AND 2013G-053, FOUND A VIOLATION, IMPOSED A FINE OF $200 AND DECLARED THE COMMITTEE TERMINATED.
1/22/2014 THE COMMISSION RECEIVED CHECK #3354 IN THE AMOUNT OF $200 FROM ERIC D FINGERHUT FOR PAYMENT OF THE FINE IMPOSED.
CASE CLOSED