PLEA2009 - 26th Conference on Passive and Low Energy Architecture, Quebec City, Canada, 22-24 June 2009
Displacement Ventilation and Passive Cooling Strategies
PAUL CAREW1, BERNARD BEKKER1
1PJCarew Consulting, Cape Town, South Africa
ABSTRACT: The publication of the ASHRAE “System Performance Evaluation and Design Guidelines for Displacement Ventilation” [0] has contributed to the wider acceptance of displacement ventilation (DV) as a ventilation strategy, by offering clear guidelines from an established organisation. A significant advantage of DVis that it lowers the supply air quantities required for cooling compared to conventional mixing ventilation (MV) at the same supply air temperature.This opens up opportunities for the use of passive (non refrigeration-cycle based) cooling sources, which typically are limited in supply air temperature and based on 100% fresh air supply when compared to conventional refrigeration-cycle based sources. This paper quantifies the impacts of using DVin comparison to MV on the peak capacity, size and humidity levels associated with the following passive cooling sources: evaporative cooling, two stage evaporative cooling, thermal stores and air to ground heat exchangers. Ageneric office building in Johannesburg, South Africa, is used as a model. The paper illustratesthe extent to which the use of DVexpands the ability of passive cooling strategies to serve spaces previously considered as having too high a heat load (when calculated using MV system guidelines). The paper however also recognises that passivecooling strategies are unlikely to be widely implemented until design guidelines exist from organizations similar to ASHRAE. Keywords: passive design strategies, displacement ventilation
INTRODUCTION Based on the authors’ experiences as consultants in the built environment, conventional Heating Ventilation and Air Conditioning (HVAC) engineers keep to using clear guidelines and calculations methods provided by established organisations. It is unlikely that unconventional strategies and systems will be incorporated in a project in the absence of such guidelines or methods, unless it is a showcase project with sufficient resources to adequately investigate alternatives.
Displacement ventilation (DV) can be seen as an example of this. While popular in Scandinavia [0], the American Society for Heating, Refrigeration and Air-conditioning Engineers (ASHRAE) only recently released “System Performance Evaluation and Design Guidelines for Displacement Ventilation” [0], which provides generic DV sizing and design guidelines. This publication differs from existing supplier-specific DV design guidelines in that itprovides a simple ten-step guide to design the DV system [0]. While the authors have not found literature that documents the worldwide growth in the number of installed DV systems, since the ASHRAE publication was released they have found HVAC engineers in general to be more receptive to the use of DV for conventional projects.
The aim of this paper is to illustrate the impacts of using DV in comparison tomixing ventilation (MV) on
the peak capacity, size and humidity levels associated with various passive cooling strategies, informed by the ASHRAE DV guidelines. The intention is NOT to provide clear design guidelines for these passive strategies, but merely to demonstrate the implications of these strategies through quantitative analysis.
Through this analysis it is demonstrated that a number of passive cooling strategies, considered impractical for MV applications, can potentially be of benefit in building designs utilising DV.The comparison also highlights the risk of over-design when conventional MV guidelines are used to design cooling sources for DV applications. DISPLACEMENT VS. MIXED VENTILATION DV introduces air at low level and low velocity, and at high supply air temperature (Ts),typically around 18°C,when compared to conventional air conditioning systems which use MV. The air that is slightly cooler than the intended room temperature runs along the floor until it reaches a heat load (Fig. 1). The heat load induces a plume of warmer air that rises due to lower density. This induces stratification in room temperature with the occupied area of the room within comfort conditions and the space near the ceiling at higher temperature conditions. The air near the ceiling is continually exhausted to prevent a build up of warm air into the occupied zone.
Figure 1: Dispgradient relati
When usi14°C - is intlevel, inducinThere shouldroom.
Figure 2: Mdifference rela
Supply
difference inbetween DVDV guidelinerate is calcul
(p TCQV =
ρ
where V is load (kW), specific headesign tempe(°C.)
Howeverportion of toccupied zon
oedis QaQ =
withQdis as tsedentary oc
PLEA2009 - 2
placement ventilive to height
ing MV the cotroduced at hing room air to d be a relatively
Mixing ventilatioative to height sh
air flow raten the calculatio
V and MV becoes. Assuming nated according
)sh
t
TTQ
−
the supply airρ is the air d
at capacity of erature (°C) an
r with DV ththe total roomne using the fol
lloe aQaQ ++
the load betweccupant being s
26th Conference on
lation with indic
ool air - typicaigher velocitiemix with it as y consistent te
on with indicahown as constan
e calculationson of the suppomes apparent no latent coolin
g to the entire r
r rate (m3/s), Qdensity (kgdryaif air (kJ/kgdryand Ts is supply
e flow rate im load that isllowing breakd
exexQa een the head aserved by the
n Passive and Low
cative temperatu
ally around 12 es and at a hig
shown in Fig. mperature in th
ative temperatunt
sA fundamentply air flow rain the ASHRAng, with MV throom load with
…(1)
Qt is total rooir/m3), Cp is thair), Th is rooy air temperatu
is based on ths present in thdown [0]:
…(2)
and the feet ofDV system, Q
HOTTER UNOCCUPIE
ZONE
OCCUPIED
ZONE
WELL-MIXEAIR
w Energy Architec
ure
to gh 2. he
ure
tal ate AE he
h
om he
om ure
he he
f a Qoe
as the equipm(kW) afractiooccupiresultin
hV =
withΔTfeet an
Exexhauswhen close ASHRto calc
TTe =
where
TTs =
from
=fθ
whereTtemperθf is thheat trconvecm2), bo BACKFor theoffice model coolingwithin
Table 1people,
OccuOverExte
TotaLoad Thr
DV sy
ED
D
ED
ture, Quebec City
loads from tment (kW), Qland Qex as the
ons of the reied zone(0.295ng supply air f
phf
dis
CTQρΔ
Thf as the tempnd set at 2°C.
haust air test air temperausing MV. Into the desig
RAE DV guideculate Te for DV
VCQ
Tp
ts ρ+
TT hfh ρ−Δ−
1(
1
+r
p
ACV
αρ
Tf is the florature at the hehe dimensionlansfer coefficictive heat tranoth put forward
KGROUND TOe purpose of thspace in Johan
onto which g strategies canthis office spa
1:Peak cooling 13W/m2for equupants and equiprhead lighting
ernal loads
al loads ds with occupied
ree ventilationystem, as we
, Canada, 22-24 Ju
the occupants,as the load froenvelope loads
espective load5, 0.132 and flow rate is calc
perature differe
emperatureWature (Te) is inn the case of Mgn room temlines supply thV systems:
VCQ
p
tf
ρθ
1)1++
cfα
oor temperatuead or room deless temperatuent of the floor
nsfer coefficiend as 5 by ASH
O MODEL his paper a gennnesburg, Sou
different venn be applied. Tace areshown in
loads of the 1ipment and 10 Wpment Qoe
Ql Qex
Qt (fd zone Qdis
n systems will ell as two M
une 2009
low level ligom the overheas with aoe, al, a
ds that occur 0.185 in [1]
culated as
…(3)
ence between h
When using Dn general highMV the Te sh
mperature, whhe following e
… (4)
… (5)
… (6)
ure (°C), Thesign temperatuure, αr is the rr (W/°C m2) annt of the flooRAE [0].
neric 100m2 oputh Africa, is untilation and
The peak coolinn Table 1.
00m2 space (7W/m2 for lighting
2 k1 k4 k
for MV) 7 ks (for DV) 1.4
now be consiMV systems, o
ghts and ad lights aex as the
in the ). The
head and
DV the her than hould be hile the quations
is the ure (°C), radiative nd αcfthe or (W/°C
pen plan used as a
passive ng loads
W/m2 for g) kW kW kW
kW 462kW
idered: a one that
supplies air system (MVtemperature air flow rate now be calcu
Table 2: Resusystems with ventilation (M
Mode Ts (°C) Th/Te (V (m3/% ofMV% ofMV
From Tab
for DVislessthough both temperature. similar, but Msource than D
The compintroduced bpaper will eselection ofpassive desigJohannesburgwide diurnatemperature chosen as thepaper. Typic
Figure 3:Dry [0,0] IMPACT OON PASSIVThe applicafunction of cactivity in thequipment/decost. What thintroducing tsuitability. Tcooling stratfollowing sttwo stage, temperatures
PLEA2009 - 2
at the same Vht) and the ot
(MVlt). Using into the room
ulated, as show
lting air flow fro% relative to lo
MVlt and MVht) MV14
(°C) 26 s) 0.59Vlt 100Vht 37%
ble 2 it is clears than half thventilation syThe airflow
MVlttypically DV in order to
parison in Tabby using DV inexplore how thf passive coogn strategies arg climate baseal temperaturefor much of the context for thal office hours
and wet bulb
OF DISPLAVE COOLINGability of pasclimate, comfohe space, interesign implicathis paper puts the cooling intoThe impact is tegies, and wtrategies: evapthermal storag
s and air to gro
dry bulb temp
26th Conference on
high temperatther at a mucEq. 1 to 3, the
m for each of thwn in Table 2.
om MV (low andow (and high te
Vlt MVht 22 26
9 1.61 % 273%
% 100%
r that the air flhat required ystems have t
rates for DVrequire a mucobtain the low
ble 2 highlightsnstead of MVhese efficienci
oling strategiere potentially a
ed on Fig. 3, we range and he year.This cihe simulations s were assumed
temperatures f
CEMENT VG STRATEGIssive cooling ort expectationrnal loading otions – often rforward is tha
o the space alsquite specific
will now be eporative coolinge based on und heat excha
w
n Passive and Low
ture as the Dch lower suppe required supphese systems ca
d high Ts) and Demperature mixin
DV 22 26/31 0.74 125% 46%
ow rate requirefor MVht, evehe same supp
V and MVlt ach larger coolinw Ts.
s the efficienci.The rest of thies impact on s.A number applicable in th
which indicateslow wet bu
ity was therefopresented in th
d.
for Johannesbur
VENTILATIOES strategies is
ns related to thof the space anrelating back at the method o impacts on thto each passiv
explored for thng – single an
night time aangers.
wet bulb temp
w Energy Architec
DV ply ply an
DV ng
ed en
ply are ng
ies his
a of he s a ulb ore his
rg.
ON
a he nd to of he ve he nd air
Evchangestreamand noenergyair andrelativ
Thevaportempercooledwet bevapor
s TT =
Figureyear ba
Figureevaporaline)[0,
Altsuitablrepresein Fig.absoluimpact
Figurecoolingroom athe dayindicaticompon
Threlativspace. relatedflow, t
%
ture, Quebec City
vaporative cooe of phase o
m/volume to coon-evaporatingy required. Thid residual wate humidity of t
e minimum rative coolingrature (Twb) of
d a part of the bulb temperatrative cooling e
( devapdb TT −η
e 4 provides thased on eq. 7 a
4: Cumulative ative cooling (0]
though evaporle, the comfoent the actual l 5, evaporative
ute and relativts on comfort.
5:Psychrometrg process with 1air conditions wy, and (right) thing the sensibnent (1b to 2)
e increase in e to the amoThe amount o
d to the supply the lower the ab
2-stage evaporative
cooling
, Canada, 22-24 Ju
oling Evaporaof the water ol down the ai
g water is useds results in a teter, and an incthe air.
temperature g is expressef the air. In realway between
ture and thisefficiency (heva
)wbdb TT −
he probability and on annual c
distributed freq(1st line) and e
rative cooling ort expectationlimitations to the cooling resulve humidity
ric chartsshowin1 as the outdoor
with increasing ahe 2-stage evapble(1a to 1b)
humidity in thount of vapourof vapour enter
air flow. Therbsolute amoun
e
Ts
une 2009
ative cooling ucontained in
ir. Energy fromd to supply themperature drocrease in abso
achievableed by the wlity the air canthe dry bulb (s is known ap), assumed as
…(7)
of Ts throughclimatic data [4
quency of Ts forevaporative coo
might be climns and roomhis strategy. Alts in an increaof the space
ng(left) the evar, 2 the supplyaabsolute humidiporative cooling
as well as a
he space overr being addedring a space is refore the lowent of vapour int
single stagevaporativ
cooling
uses the an air
m the air he latent op in the lute and
through wet bulb n only be Tdb) and as the
s 80%.
hout the 4].
r 2-stage oling (2nd
matically loading
As shown se in the , which
aporative and 3 the ty during g process adiabatic
r time is d to the
directly er the air troduced
ge ve
into the spaspace duringlower inflow
Figure 6: Fan
This mea(and therefoproject mighcooling utilisMV. In otherather than wbe met (morealternatively for the same
Two-stagevaporative component tbulb tempercooling, as sh
11 adbdb TT =
from which
1bdbS TT −=wherehsensis t
This senprovided bycooling, usinOther stratege.g. passing before apply
The resullower temperin duration iused (Fig. 4)
This influserved by thioccupants asindicated in F
PLEA2009 - 2
ace, slowing thg the day. Fig
w of humidity fo
n driven evapora
ans that the core also cost)ht be met thrsing DV, wherr words, using
with MV meane cooling for tha lower increaroom load.
ge evapocooling add
to the cooling prature before hown in Figs. 5
( 1adsensdb T−η
( 1bdbevap T −−ηtaken to be 90%
nsible pre-cooy water that ing residual wagies can also beair through aning an evapora
lt impacts in trature to the spin the year tha based on a ma
uences the sizeis strategy and
s less humidityFig. 9.
26th Conference on
he build up og. 8 indicatesor DV compare
tive cooling
comfort and c) requirementsrough the usere it might havg evaporative cns that a highehe same humidase in humidity
rative cods a sensibprocess, whichapplying dir
5 and 7:
)1awbdb T−
)1bwbT− % and hevap 80%
oling componeis cooled thouater from the ee used for sensn air-to-groundative cooling co
two ways; air ipace and/or theat evaporativeaximum Ts of 2
e of the room d the comfort c is being added
n Passive and Low
f vapour of ths a significanted to MV.
cooling capacis of a specif of evaporativ
ve failed utilisincooling with Der room load cadity increase), y can be realise
oolingTwo-stagble pre-coolinh lowers the wrect evaporativ
…(8)
…(9)
% [0]
ent is typicalugh evaporativevaporative paible pre-coolin
d heat exchangomponent.
is delivered atere is an increa cooling can b22°C.
load that can bconditions of thd to the space
w Energy Architec
he tly
ity fic ve ng
DV an or ed
ge ng
wet ve
lly ve
art. ng, ger
t a ase be
be he as
Figure equipm
Figure for singspace wdifferen
Diuventilaknowntemperbuilt ube usethe forcooledmechaintroduintroduconstrumateripossib
Th
store temperof 22°Cbetwee
ture, Quebec City
7: Diagram iment
8: Air flow rategle(Evap) and with a peak totance between DV
urnal range ation and expon passive coolinratures to flush
up during the ped in the introdrm of a packedd down at nightanical ventilatiouced through uction into thucted by incorpals, includingly phase chang
e climatic limstrategy is thrature drops toC, and a minien the store
, Canada, 22-24 Ju
indicating 2-sta
es(V) and humid2-stage (2S) ev
al cooling load V and MV.
and thermased thermal mng strategy. It uh the structure previous day. Tduction of a red bed, as showt by flushing won. During the this bed,which
he space. Theporating a variceramic balls
ge materials.
mitation of thehe number of a usable temp
imum temperamaterial and
une 2009
age evaporative
dity inflow (g) ovvaporative cooliof 70W/m2 indic
al store Nigmass is a relativ
uses low nightof the building
The same princemote thermal
wn in Fig 9. Thwith outside air
day outside aih cools the aie packed bediety of thermals and tiles, ro
e packed bed f days that thperature. Basedture difference
the supply
e cooling
ver a day ing for a cated the
ht time vely well t time air g of heat ciple can
store in is bed is through
ir is then ir before
can be l storage
ocks and
thermal he night d on a Ts e of 3°C air, the
duration that10. It is cle24h00 and 0year.
Figure 9: Pac
Figure 10: Dcooling strateg
The feasithe cost and the storage efficiency omedium and Hollmuller eshould causeprofile, as shthey suggestevery 100m3
amplitude coutput is relused:
Figure 11: Ththermal store shift in phase. for a cost-efof the input aairflow relati
PLEA2009 - 2
t the strategy isear that the a05h00 is lower
ked bed thermal
DVIEW indicategy is applicable
ibility of the stsize of packecapacity of
of the heat tthe air, and the
et al. [0] notee a 180° phasehown in Fig 11t a packed be3/h air flow rahange (transmlated to the th
he input and outpover time, illusBased on [0].
ffective materiaamplitude is arionship, the siz
26th Conference on
s applicable is ambient temper than 19°C fo
l store
es duration thain Johannesburg
trategy is furthed bed, which f the thermaltransfer betwee air flow rate es that ideallye shift in the d1. For such a 1ed volume of ate. They furthmission) of thhermal storage
tput temperaturetrating the effec
al like gravel tround 50%. Usze of a 180° ph
n Passive and Low
indicated in Ferature betweeor 98.5% of th
at the night timg.
her influenced bis a function
l material, theen the storagthrough the be
y a packed beaily temperatu180° phase shiroughly1m3 f
her note that thhe phase-shifte
material that
es of a packed bct of a 180 degr
the transmissiosing the volumhase shift packe
w Energy Architec
Fig en he
me
by of he ge ed. ed
ure ft,
for he ed is
bed ree
on me-
ed
bed foto a be
Usireduceimpactthe spathe authe strthe spathe lowtherefo
AirexchanThe firutilisesand ththan 3variatiphase,thermatemperstrategstoragethe pipthe pipto the togethe
Figure
Figure
Thcooling
ture, Quebec City
r DV can be roed of 58m3 for M
ing DV rathees the requiredting on both mace that the st
uthors’ experienrategy unfeasibace available. wer air flow raore energy con
r to ground hngers consist orst one, seasons thedifference
he ground temm.Fig. 14indicon in the soil as the depth
al storage (Figrature in a w
gy described e medium beiping. Compareping for daily t
surface, and er.
12: Seasonal gr
13: Daily groun
e climatic appg strategy is
, Canada, 22-24 Ju
oughly estimatMVht.
er than MV tsize of the pac
material costs tore takes up. nce, the commble, due to theAn additional
ate is the reducsumption.
heat exchangeof two distinctnal ground soue between the
mperature at decates how the temperature dincreases.The
g. 13), uses theway similar to
in the previoing the groundd to seasonal gthermal storagethe piping run
round source coo
nd source cooling
plicability of thsimilar to t
une 2009
ted at 27m3, co
therefore signcked bed thermand more impThis last impa
mon factor thae high cost of l benefit derivction in fan po
ersAir to groutly different sturce cooling (Fe ambient temepths typicallyamplitude of
decreases, and second stratege lower night
o the thermal ous section, wd immediatelyground source e can be locatens are typicall
oling
g.
he daily groundthat described
ompared
nificantly mal store, portantly act is, in at makes f making ved from ower and
und heat rategies. Fig. 12),
mperature y greater seasonal shifts in
gy, daily time air storage
with the y around
cooling, ed nearer ly closer
d source d in the
previous seapplicability demonstratedhours that tdepends on diameter andrate. Fig. 15of this stratdepending oshown for an
Figure 14: Atemperature a
Figure 15: Pethe exchangerof 5 m/s, pipe
Using theal. [0] to estthe simulateassumptions requires rourequiring rou
The abovthe volume athe pipe lentechnical anadditional betherefore ene
CONCLUSIDV significaserve a roomsame Ts. Thpassive cooli
PLEA2009 - 2
ection on thof the season
d in Figs. 14 anthis strategy i
a variety of d length of the illustrates howegy can be u
on the length on air velocity o
Annual air temat 3m, based on [
ercentage of offr is below maximdiameter of 0.38
e methodologytimate the lenged Johannesbas in Fig. 15,
ughly 80m ofughly 170m.
ve estimation air flow rate rengths requirednd financial feenefit is a relatiergy consumpti
IONS antly lowers thm heat load, whis reduction iming strategies in
26th Conference on
ermal stores.nal ground sond 15.The percs applicable ifactors, inclu
e exchanger, aw the percenta
up to 100% aof the exchangf 5m/s and a de
mperature and [0]
fice hours (6h tomum Ts of the loa8m, and depth of
y described by gth of exchan
burg office, w, results in thef pipes, com
illustrates thatequired, it signid and thereforeasibility of thive reduction iion.
he required supwhen comparempacts the fean projects in a
n Passive and Low
The climatource cooling centage of offiin Johannesbuuding the deptand the air floage applicabili
at a Ts of 22°Cger, in this caepth of 3m.
expected groun
o 18h) that Toutad, for air velocf 3m. Based on [
Mihalakakouger required fwith the same following: D
mpared to MV
t, as DV loweificantly reducre increases thhe strategy. Ain fan power an
pply air flow ed to MV at thasibility of usinvarious ways:
w Energy Architec
tic is ce
urg th, ow ity C,
ase
nd
of ity
[0]
et for me DV Vht
ers ces he
An nd
to he ng
Evabeing i
2-sevaporconvencoolingby DVMV mto com
Thewith thprovid
Airreduce
Thassisterequireestimaand ca(with ecoolingwould HVACcoolingengineassist strateg
REFE1. CheEvaluatVentila2. Svdisplac3. GrapNationaEngine4. Inteweatherhttp://wdata3.c5. IWAfrom PAfrica6. Hollstoragephase-s7. Kusuthermalof Stan8. Mihpipes cEnergy
ture, Quebec City
aporative coolintroduced into
stage evaporarative coolingntional evaporg component.
V in the lower smaking the stratmfort levels.
ermal storagehe main impac
ding the space f
r to ground heed dramatically
e publication ed in determined for DV:siated using MValculations of texception of eg) still depend
typically noC engineers. Eg, which are en
eers refer to ingreatly with g
gies beyond env
ERENCES n, Q. and Gliction and De
ation. ASHRAEvensson, A.G.Lement ventilatio
ph produced usinal Renewable ering Inc. using
ernational Weatr data
www.eere.energyfm, last visited
AC Two stage evPROTEK CC, B
lmuller et al.(2e technique forshifting, PLEA, Guda, I. and Achel diffusivity at se
ndards, Building alakakou, G. et
cooling potentialy
, Canada, 22-24 Ju
ling – significo the space due
ative cooling–g introduces rative coolingThis advantag
supply air flowtegy applicable
e – the storagct being the refor the store.
eat exchangersy.
of the ASHning with conignificantly loV calculations.the various pasevaporative ands on non-stanot be consideEstablishing gndorsed by orgn confidenceegaining furthervironmentally
ksman, L. (200esign Guidelin
L. (1989). Non systems. ASHng DView Versio
Energy LabIWEC weather
ther for Energyfile
y.gov/buildings/eon 22nd May 200vaporative cooli
Box 1943, Halfw
006) - A new rpassive coolingGeneva, 6-8 Sepenbach, P. (1965elected stations iResearch Div., Wal, Parametric
l for passive co
une 2009
cantly less hume to the lower a
– intrinsically less humidit
g due to the ge is further am
w required come to more proj
e volume is reduction in the
s – the pipe l
HRAE Guidelinfidence the flower than pr. However, thssive coolingst
nd 2 stage evandardised methered by convguidelines for ganisations that.g. ASHRAEr penetration extreme projec
03) System Perfnes for Disp
Nordic experienHRAE Trans. 95(
on 1.09 developboratory and file y Calculations
sourced energyplus/cfm/08 ing units producway House 168
ventilation andg of buildings:ptember 2006 5), Earth temperin USA, NationaWashington D.Cprediction of th
ooling applicatio
midity is air flow.
2-stage ty than sensible mplified
mpared to ects due
reduced, e cost of
length is
ines has low rate eviously
he sizing trategies
aporative hods that ventional
passive t HVAC
E, would of these cts.
formance placement
nces of (2).
ped by the Mistaya
(IWEC) from
/weather_
ct manual 85, South
d thermal thermal
ature and al Bureau
C. he buried ons, Solar