8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 1/27
1
Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners:
Voices of International Educators
Ian M. Henderson
Framingham State Uniersit!
8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 2/27
"
Introduction
#hen consulting the literature concerning the conce$t of differentiated instruction
for left-handed children% seeral themes &ecome readil! a$$arent: the inherited cultural
mores a&out handedness colored a &ul' of the research during the "(th centur!% much
of this $rior research )as called into *uestion and reassessed &eginning in the 1++(,s%
and onl! er! recentl! hae the im$lications concerning $edagog! &een addressed.
Ho)eer% seeral themes are clear from )hat data does eist left-handedness is an
in&orn genetic condition )hich alters the )a! the &rain functions and $rocesses ne)
information% there is a clear need for differentiated instruction for left-handed learners
and there is limited research% training or a)areness of the $henomenon in the realm of
education.
Review of the Literature on Left-handed Learners
/he )eighted negatie im$lications of things associated )ith the left hand hold
true glo&all!% &ut $articularl! so in the )estern tradition. 0umerous researchers
illuminate the et!mological im$lications )ith eam$les such as the )ord left%2 )hich
deries from the 3nglo Saon )ord l!ft2 meaning 4)ea', or 4&ro'en, 5#en6e "((78. /his
inherited influence dominated research u$ through the end of the "(th centur!. Denn!
5"((98 concluded that left-handedness )as seen &! most earl! researchers as a mar'er
for other $athologies li'e grou$s )ith a histor! of alcoholism% autism% criminalit!%
de$ression% homoseualit!% immune diseases% $s!chosis% and schi6o$hrenia to mention
8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 3/27
&ut a fe)2 5$. ;98. <arallels can &e dra)n )ith other research during this $eriod such
as lin's &et)een criminalit! and the $oor% mista'ing correlation )ith causation. Een
through the 1+9(,s it )as still &eing argued that the origins of left-handedness )ere due
fetal or infant head trauma and )as therefore a t!$e of neurological disa&ilit! 5=ohnston
"((+8. 3s late as 1+>;% dismissing mounting genetic eidence% ?arlson 51+>;8 argued
that is )as mostl! due to enironmental factors and &elieed ta'ing $recautions )ith
infants could determine their lateral $reference.
@ne researcher in $articular sered as a transition for much of the earlier findings
and more modern attitudes Dr. Stanle! ?oren. /hrough do6ens of studies he sho)ed
that left-handers )ere more $rone to a host of negatie effects including accidents%
&ehaioral issues and een shorter life s$ans 5?oren 1+>+% ?oren 1++1% ?oren 1++>8.
3round the same time a gro)ing &od! of )or' )as forming to challenge or com$letel!
oerturn some of these conclusions. Most im$ortantl!% =ohnston 5"((+8 tells us the
conclusion of these studies demonstrated conclusiel! that handedness could not &e
attri&uted to child health at &irth% famil! com$osition% income% or other enironmental
factors and that )orld)ide the incidence has held stead! at 1(A of the $o$ulation.
Besides the causatie element% Eaton 51++C8 ruled out other oerloo'ed
aria&les and found that it )as im$ossi&le to lin' maturational lag to handedness.
3nnett 51++8 demolished the reduced longeit! theor! &! demonstrating the
decreased num&er of lefties among the elderl! )as due to the )ides$read $ractice of
conerting children at an earl! age to )rite )ith their right hands% )hich had diminished
oer time.
8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 4/27
7
0onetheless% some findings )ere reaffirmed )hile other ne) discoeries seemed
to &e in direct contradiction )ith each other. Lefties )ere found to &e dis$ro$ortionatel!
re$resented in a ariet! of disorders such as d!sleia% autism% schi6o$hrenia%
h!$eractiit! and asthma% 5rouios 1+++% Hauc' "((1% Schiffman "((;% Dee$-So&osla!
"(1(% romm!das "((8. 3t the same time% numerous studies such as Ben&o) 51+>C8
sho)ed a higher incidence of left-handers among the etremel! intellectuall!
$recocious and gifted children2 5Denn!% "((9% $. ;98. Li'e)ise% other researchers
found a dis$ro$ortionate num&er of left-handers among musicians% artists% architects
and mathematicians 5=ohnston "((+% Beratis "(18. Een ?oren 51++;8 $u&lished
findings that seemed in contradiction to his negatie conclusions )hen he argued that
left-handed children seems to hae greater ca$acit! for a&stract thought and diergent
thin'ing. #hile at first &lush the research seems at odds )ith itself% a $attern did form of
a sort of inerse2 &ell cure. =ohnston 5"((+8 summari6ed this dissonant conclusion of
the findings &! sa!ing Left- or mied-handedness has &een associated )ith at!$ical
cognitie a&ilities% )hich can hae &oth disadantageous and adantageous outcomes2
5$. ">18.
For those tr!ing to find constructie )a!s to im$lement the research into
$edagog! concerning left-handed children% researchers )ere in a *uandar!. Seeral
ne) theories hae &een $ut for)ard to e$lain ho) lefties can occu$! &oth ends of the
cognitie s$ectrum. Some of the methodolog! of the findings concerning mental
disa&ilities )as reealuated and found that much of the research had diided the
su&ects into t)o $rimar! categories% right-handedness and non right-handedness. /his
$roed to &e an erroneous s!stem as the degrees of lateralit! are much more com$le.
8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 5/27
;
/he three more accurate classifications are mostl! no) descri&ed as right% left% or non-
dominant. /he most consistentl! lo)-scoring su&ects on these cognitie ealuations
are those )ith no $reference 5Godrigue6% "((>8. /his is seen as a characteristic in man!
deelo$mental disorders. L!le 5"(1"8 concluded that hand $reference either )a! )as
the strongest indicator for memor!. Li'e)ise% rouios 51+++8 esta&lished that those
)ith a clearl! esta&lished hemis$here $reference of either sort scored similarl! and it
)as onl! those indiiduals )ithout a dominant hand )ho ran'ed significantl! lo)er on all
fronts.
3dditionall!% &esides those indiiduals )ithout a non-dominant hemis$here as a
result of other larger disa&ilities% some students are )ithout a clearl! $referred lateralit!
as a result of conersion. Mentioned $reiousl!% the act of forci&l! conerting children to
use their right hand has a long historical $recedent in the #est% and is still actiel! used
in other $arts of the )orld toda!. Meng 5"((98 and an 51++>8 tell us that in /ai)an%
?hina% and Singa$ore roughl! ;"A of natural left handers are een no) actiel!
conerted% )ith close to +(A haing &een attem$ted conerts.
#hile $erha$s not seeming li'e that large an issue to some% the im$lications are
staggering. 0euro&iologists such as lo$$el 5"(1(8 hae $roen that conersion alters
the er! structure of the &rain% s$ecificall! the $ericentral corte and &asal ganglia% the
latter of )hich is inoled in oluntar! moement% $rocedural learning% cognition and
emotion. Sattler 51++C8 ela&orates on $recisel! ho) com$le the ramifications are for
the deelo$ing mind During )riting% the greatest ariet! of cere&ral s'ills are included.
Eam$les are the fine motor s'ills% s$eech% the $ictorial re$resentation of imagination of
the series of letters as )ell as the simultaneous chain of thoughts% associations% gra$hic
8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 6/27
C
re$resentations% memories% and recall of $reiousl! learned material )hich also run
throughout. Scarcel! an! other human underta'ing is com$ara&le to )riting in its
multifaceted connections &et)een the most differing &rain functions2 5$.8. Sattler
51++C8 also ado$ted the term &rain-&rea'ing2 from the neuroscience communit! as she
felt it more accuratel! descri&ed the deastating effects more clearl! than more su&tle
semantics such as re-education.2
0umerous studies hae highlighted the $ossi&le conse*uences of conersion
including- &ut not limited to- memor! disorders% $ro&lems in concentration% d!sleia%
s$atial disorientation% motor s'ills discoordination% s$eech disorders such as stuttering
5Meng "((9% Sattler 1++C8. /hese are stri'ingl! similar to the original disa&ilities )hose
origins had &een $rescri&ed to left-handedness. /he $s!chosocial effect of these
com$lications are e*uall! $rofound: insecurit!% introersion% oercom$ensation through
heightened $erformance% o$$ositional defiant disorder and emotional $ro&lems. /hese
also har'en &ac' to some other studies such as ?oren,s findings that left-handers )ere
more li'el! to engage in delin*uent &ehaior as adolescents 5?oren 1++>8.
Because lateral dominance is an in&orn genetic condition% the cognitie
dissonance of liing in a right-handed )orld &egins er! earl!. #en6e 5"((78 related
that most $arents hae noticed their child,s hand $reference in their first !ear of life.
#hile most $eo$le assume the &rain functions the same for lefties and righties )ith the
ece$tion of the hand or foot lateralit!% Bo)er 5"((;8 has demonstrated that een the
conce$t of $erce$tion and identif!ing $arts of a )hole ersus large $atterns is
$erformed &! different areas of the &rain de$ending on hand dominance. 3dditionall!%
?assanto and Henet6 5"(118 found that children innatel! $lace $ositie or negatie
8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 7/27
9
alue udgements on images or characters &ased on )hich lateralit! the! occu$ied%
independent of learned cultural norms. /his &od!-s$ecificit! h!$othesis sho)s that from
an earl! age% humans literall! $erceie the )orld differentl! &ased on the dominant
hemis$here.
Because of this% all left-handers undergo a sort of 4soft, conersion. Sattler 51++C8
sa!s this can range from more oert forms such as $arents and teachers $lacing
o&ects consistentl! in the child,s right hand% using $raise or caoling% to the necessar!
neural changes re*uired to ada$ting to a )orld &uilt for right-handers. /here are also
instances of self-conersion )here am&itious% &right children attem$t to s)itch their
dominance to fit in2 )ith the larger societ!. /he research carried out &! #en6e 5"((78
found that children as !oung as four )ere a)are that it )as easier to &e right-handed
and often e$ressed a sense of isolation.
3rmed )ith the 'no)ledge of the im$act such forced conersion can hae on
deelo$ing minds% it ta'es onl! a cursor! glance at the aerage instructional setting to
reali6e the needs of these learners are not &eing met. First% the &asic tools necessar!
for lefties are a&sent in man! classrooms. Ges$ondents to #en6e 5"((78 indicated that
t)o-thirds of left handed elementar! students thought &eing a left! $resented
challenges at school% and the num&er one o&stacle )ere right-handed des's. Besides
des's% other &asic tools often omitted &! teachers and administrators )ere scissors%
ada$tie s$iral note&oo's or &inders% and rulers. #riting instruction also has a &ias
unreali6ed &! most teachers. /he direction or flo) of circular sha$es% letters% and
$atterns flo)s out)ard from the &od!% the o$$osite of )hat usuall! right-handed
instructors are modeling. Vaughn comments that 5"(1(8 the confusion arising can often
8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 8/27
>
lead to erroneous diagnoses of d!sleia and more often than not% teachers do not 'no)
)hat to loo' for. 3 child ma! struggle )ith t!ing their shoelaces or using scissors or
)riting &ecause the! are left-handed. @nce the! see their friends doing it and that the!
cant% the! )ill gie u$ more *uic'l! and &ecome more frustrated2 5$. "8. 3s Morris
51++>8 $ointed out% sometimes een the sim$lest e*ui$ment% li'e left handed scissors%
are unaaila&le.2
/he emerging digital classroom also host its o)n range of challenges. In school
com$uter la&s% it is common that not a single com$uter )ill &e set u$ for a left-handed
mouse user. @ne $iece of e*ui$ment has highlighted ho) much differentiated
instruction can &enefit these learners. In Ha!)ards 5"(178 sure! of 3ustralian left-
handed $rimar! schoolers% the! found that left-handed children that had $reiousl!
struggled )ith )riting in English class &lossomed )hen a&le to use a 'e!&oard )hich is
lateralit!-neutral in it,s a$$lication. 3nother eam$le illustrating the im$act of
differentiated instruction is that in art class% &oth sets of learners $erform at usuall! the
same leel. Ho)eer% Vlachos 5"((78 found that one glaring ece$tion )as in the
attem$t to dra) straight hori6ontal lines &! follo)ing the teachers modeling% )hich
)or'ed counter-intuitiel! for the left-handed learners. Music class as )ell is an
o&stacle course for this educational minorit!. /he most egregious of )hich is the
a&sence of hand-s$ecific instruments such as guitars% iolins and cellos. More
camouflaged are the )a!s in )hich the music itself is )ritten and arranged. McDermott
5"(18 highlights the fact that most $iano sheet music% for instance% is )ritten )ith the
left hand $erforming chords and the com$le melodies &eing $erformed &! the right
hand.
8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 9/27
+
Gesearch done in <ortugal &! Freitas 5"(178 demonstrated that <ortuguese
elementar! school children )ho )ere left-handed had a higher $ro&a&ilit! of
deelo$mental coordination disorder 5D?D8 and challenges in $h!sical education
classes inoling &ase&all. #hile not entirel! de$endent on e*ui$ment% the *uestion
must &e raised that if most $h!sical education de$artments are lac'ing in items such as
left! &ase&all gloes% hoc'e! stic's% etc. )hether or not those are an im$ediment to
ecelling at s$orts. Li'e)ise% one of ?oren,s 51+>+8 studies finding that left-handers
)ere significantl! more $ro&a&le to &e inured in accidents )as found to &e due to the
uta$osition of using e*ui$ment and tools designed for right handers.
Some hae argued that these u&i*uitous challenges in eer! facet of
deelo$ment for left-handed children might go some )a! to)ards e$laining the
$reiousl! mentioned inerse &ell cure. Denn! 5"((98 $ara$hrases multi$le sets of
earlier research to e$lain that )hile some of these hurdles sere to hinder some
learners $rogress% the! ma! actuall! sere as a &oon to others. @ne argument that is
fre*uentl! suggested &ut has not &een studied ma! &e called the 4adantage of &eing
disadantaged, theor!. 3ssume that &oth left-handers and right-handers each $ossess a
certain set of a&ilities. ien that the enironment is geared to)ard right-handers% left-
handers hae an incentie to inest effort in ac*uiring additional s'ills% naturall!
$ossessed &! right-handers that ma! foster creatie &ehaior 5<eterson and Lans'!
1+998. It follo)s that the! ma! end u$ )ith a higher oerall leel of a&ilit!. /his is
consistent )ith a theor! of com$etenc! that argues that indiiduals are motiated to
achiee com$etenc! as a desire to master their enironment 5#hite 1+918. /his theor!
)ould $redict some adantage to &eing left-handed2 5$. ;+8.
8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 10/27
1(
/here is a clear need for &oth s$eciali6ed $edagog! and e*ui$ment to o$timi6e
the learning e$erience for these learners. /his has onl! &een recogni6ed and
e$ounded u$on in the $ast t)o decades. Earlier suggestions for differentiated
instruction included ell! 51++C8 )ho adised instructors to hel$ and assist left-handers
in as uno&trusie a )a! as $ossi&le to aoid eacer&ating $otential self-consciousness
and not to use )ording li'e clums!2 )hen descri&ing incidents. 3lso in the late nineties%
a grou$ of cam$aigners in the United ingdom $etitioned the goernment to im$lement
certain $roisions for these students. Montgomer! 51++C8 tells us that their agenda
included teaching techni*ues% re*uirements concerning $ro$er e*ui$ment% and the need
for the goernment to &egin 'ee$ing records of num&ers of left-handers and the im$act
on education. De$artment of Education =unior Minister Go&in S*uire said at the time
that the! had no $lans to include left-handedness as $art of teacher training. It is near
im$ossi&le to thin' of another situation )here the needs of 1(A of the $o$ulation are so
routinel! ignored and neglected.
Hoo' 5"(1(8 re$orts that $arents in the U.. $rotested again on &ehalf of left!
students again )hen it )as determined that the format of man! of the multi$le choice
tests discriminated against left-handers. /he la!out )as such that the ans)er &u&&les
)ere situated on the right hand side of the tet% causing lefties to hae to sto$ reading to
&u&&le in an ans)er then find their $lace again. /his amounted to re*uiring su&stantiall!
more time to com$lete the test as )ell as additional frustration. /he $ro$osed solution
)as to $ut ans)er columns on &oth sides of the tests. Lang 5"((98 and #en6e 5"((78
hae com$iled a series of teaching strategies to assist in ma'ing the classroom more
inclusie. /hese t)o educators are &! far the ece$tion rather than the norm. 3 "(("
8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 11/27
11
tet&oo' concerning differentiated instruction included onl! one idea a&out left handers
the fairl! o&ious solution of $lacing them in grou$s so their el&o)s don,t clash )ith
neigh&oring students. #en6e summari6ed the oerall $ro&lem e$osed in the research
&! sa!ing Scant research is aaila&le on the accommodations that left-handed students
are forced to ma'e as the! enter and $rogress through school. It is im$ortant for
educators to &e a)are of% and attend to% the s$ecial needs of left-handed students. 3s it
a$$ears from this stud!% the students are ma'ing their o)n accommodations &ecause
others 5including educators8 are not there to assist them. /eachers need to understand
left-handedness as a uni*ue diersit! in their classroom2 5$."+8.
Purpose
/here is insufficient information on the leels of a)areness and accommodation
among educators concerning the needs of left-handed students. /he $ur$ose of this
stud! is to gauge )hether an! ste$s are &eing made to address the situation among
certified teachers from arious international &ac'grounds )or'ing in a ariet! of
international settings.
Methods and Design
/his *ualitatie stud! too' the form of semi-structured conersations )ith o$en-
ended *uestions. /he interie)s )ere $erformed during the 3utumn of "(17. /here
)ere si su&ects% all of )hom )ere certified teachers in their earl! to mid (,s and had
&een teaching &et)een 7 and 1( !ears. 3ll &ut one had taught internationall!% and most
of their e$erience had &een oerseas in international elementar!% middle and high
8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 12/27
1"
schools. /hree )ere 3merican nationals )ith the other three &eing from ?hina% ?anada
and South 3frica% res$ectiel!. /he! )ere s$lit e*uall! &et)een male and female. /he
aim )as to create a mosaic of their res$ectie e$eriences to sere as a &arometer of
the current status of leftie a)areness in the contet of differentiated instruction. /heir
shared age and amount of teaching e$erience guaranteed the! )ould hae a
contem$orar! ie) of the to$ic &oth in training and eecution. Because of their arious
nationalities and international )or'$laces% ho)eer% the! create a 'ind of $ol!$hon!
)here their e$eriences oerla$ and !et sometimes differ in modern educational
settings. /he maor limitation )ould &e the sam$le si6e% &ut nonetheless certain themes
and trends can &e esta&lished from the data.
Results
=on is " !ears old and receied his Bachelor of education from the Uniersit! of
/oronto and then later attended the @ntario ?ollege of /eachers. He s$ent four !ears
teaching English in orea and another t)o at an international middle school in
Singa$ore teaching literature. /hroughout his e$erience as an undergrad and then at
teachers college he doesn,t recollect the conce$t of handedness &eing addressed one
single time. In fact% he had neer discussed it in regards to education at all until our
conersations. /here are therefore a num&er of facts a&out his left handed students he
couldn,t remem&er or had neer noticed.
/he onl! time he could recall noticing handedness had to do )ith ada$tie
measures on the $art of the $u$ils. He o&sered that those )ho )ere left handed and
8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 13/27
1
o)ned s$iral note&oo's )ould &egin on the &ac' $age and fill in the $ages in reerse
order due to the fact that in the traditional format of s$iral &ound note&oo's% the left
hand rests u$on the )ire s$iral% )hich can &e $ainful and interferes )ith the )riting
$rocess. His school em$lo!ed long des's% )hich sat seeral students side to side
hori6ontall!. During the first )ee' of class he )itnessed seeral students changing
seats )ith other students to &e seated at the far edge so as not to &um$ el&o)s )ith
their neigh&ors )hen )riting.
Guth% 7 !ears old% )as &orn and raised in Shanghai% ?hina and has &een
teaching for almost a decade. She is certified in elementar! education and teaches
?hinese at an international elementar! school in Seoul% South orea. She sa!s during
her teacher training in ?hina the issue of handedness )as neer $art of the official
curriculum &ut )as inde$endentl! addressed &! one teacher. She e$lained that
children didnt need to &e forced to conert an! longer and that &eing left-handed )as
acce$ta&le. /his ran contrar! to the long standing social norm in ?hina of forced
conersion. Guth sa!s that gro)ing u$ and in her first fe) !ears as a teacher in ?hina
she )ould neer see leftie students due to this $ractice. She also sa!s there seems to
&e a recent $henomenon in ?hina of &elieing that left handed students are more cleer
or intelligent. 0onetheless% she sa!s she still &eliees it is common $ractice for $arents
to $riatel! urge the teachers to encourage the students to use their right hand.
Since teaching at an international school% Guth has &een sur$rised at the num&er
of left handed children in her classes. /he aerage class si6es are a&out 1"-1; students
and she rec'ons that usuall! includes one or t)o left handers. She doesn,t consider
lateral $reference )hen assigning seats or in the method of instruction on ho) to )rite
8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 14/27
17
?hinese characters. During our conersation she reflected that the direction of &rush
stro'es inoled in ma'ing the characters might &e counter-intuitie for these students.
/he leftie students stand out to her for a cou$le of reasons during these calligra$h!
classes. /he first is that the! are usuall! much slo)er than their right handed
counter$arts. /he! consistentl! hae to sto$ and lift u$ their hand to chec' on )hat the!
had ust )ritten. Secondl!% and $erha$s related to the first% is that in her o$inion their
characters are neer &eautiful and often missha$en. /his echoes a $reailing
stereot!$e in the #est a&out the slo$$! *ualit! of left! hand)riting. She said her school
does hae left handed scissors &ut that is the onl! accommodation made as far as she
is a)are.
0ic'% "% is originall! from 0e) Jor' and has taught in international schools in
South orea M!anmar% and ?hina. He )as a semi-$ro MM3 fighter and no) eclusiel!
teaches $h!sical education. He is licensed for -1" &ut has taught $rimaril! elementar!
and middle school age leels. During his teacher education and training% he didn,t
remem&er the conce$t of lateralit! eer &eing addressed. 3s an instructor% he modeled
actiities )ith right handed form% een though he is left-handed himself. Ho)eer% he
)ould also ta'e time to model the reersal of each for those instances )here a left-
handed $u$il )as $resent. ?ontrar! to the common &elief that lefties are more a)')ard%
he sa!s on the )hole he thought the! $ic'ed u$ on conce$ts *uic'er and actuall!
seemed more natural )hen the! did so. @ftentimes if the! had $ro&lems it )as the
$roduct of )hen the! hadn,t $reiousl! receied lateral s$ecific instruction from $rior
teachers and had to unlearn &ad ha&its )hich )ere self-taught.
8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 15/27
1;
3ccording to 0ic'% most of the e*ui$ment )as &ilateral things li'e &as'et&alls%
um$ ro$es% etc. so s$eciali6ed e*ui$ment )asn,t much of an issue. Ho)eer in certain
team s$orts li'e &ase&all% or field hoc'e! there )ere 6ero left handed gloes or other
s$ecific e*ui$ment. He said some of the adantages from &eing a minorit! in certain
s$orts )ere also $realent among his 'ids in com$etitions. /he same )a! in )hich
&eing a south$a) in &oing is 'no)n to &e adantageous% he said the same idea holds
true in &ase&all and other s$orts )here $eo$le train against an o$$onent )ho is right
handed +(A of the time. He said the su&ect )as neer &rought u$ &! teachers or
administrators% so it )as entirel! &et)een himself and the students on ho) to address
the issue.
=en is a ; !ear old 3merican and has taught for oer ten !ears in the United
States in &oth 0orth ?arolina and Florida. She is a licensed general s$ecial education
teacher and coordinator for grades -1"% &ut not for $rofound or seerel! disa&led
$o$ulations. Half of her e$erience has &een in middle schools and half in elementar!
schools. She sa!s she has no recollection of the su&ect of handedness &eing
addressed in teachers training &ut can,t &e sure. She has noticed some left handed
students &ut its al)a!s &een an afterthought. Usuall! if she has o&sered the lateral
$reference of a student its &ecause the! hae turned their note&oo's at er! strange
angles to facilitate )riting. 3lso% as a result% she sa!s she is al)a!s sur$rised that their
hand)riting is good &ecause it seems such an a)')ard $osition to )rite in. =en sa!s
she has no idea if her scissors or an! other e*ui$ment is lateral sensitie. In fact%
throughout our conersation% she )as consistentl! sur$rised at ho) little thought she
had eer gien to the su&ect.
8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 16/27
1C
ene 5$ronounced ina!8 is from ?a$e /o)n% South 3frica and has &een
teaching oerseas for a&out 1( !ears% )ith her $ost-grade certification for grades 7-+.
Her time teaching has &een roughl! s$lit &et)een international schools and academies
in u)ait% South 3frica and South orea. Her class si6es range on aerage from "(-";
students% )ith a&out one or t)o lefties $er class. ene is left handed and sa!s that she
)rites all of the stro'es to form her letters in reerse direction as a result of mirroring her
teacher )hen she )as !ounger. 3n une$ected result of this is that all of her students
learn to )rite in this fashion as )ell. She said the issue of handedness )as neer
addressed during her teachers training or an! school orientations either. She al)a!s
notices left! children and sa!s that )hen the! discoer that she is left handed as )ell
the! often ehi&it a sense of relief and camaraderie.
During her time in u)ait she )as forced to eat )ith her right hand for $ur$oses
of cultural assimilation. Li'e)ise% her students )ere all forced to conert and she )as
o&ligated to &e an accessor! in this endeaor% something she had dee$ moral
com$unctions )ith. In orea she e$erienced one instance of a $arent tr!ing to forci&l!
conert their first grade son. 3fter seeing the difficult! he )as haing ene interened
and said the mom seemed er! o$en to the information and ceased all efforts at
conersion. 3fter )hich the child,s hand)riting im$roed considera&l! )hen he )as
allo)ed to use his naturall! dominant hand. She said the orean school had left handed
scissors &ut nothing else related to lateral $reference. In &oth u)ait and South 3frica
the $arents &ought their o)n su$$lies so it )asn,t an issue.
Dennis% 7% is from 0orth ?arolina )here he taught fourth grade for seeral !ears
and has taught grade three in orea at an international school for an additional fie. His
8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 17/27
19
licensure is -C and he also has a Masters in Education. He sa!s left and right &rain
studies )ere addressed in his initial licensure &ut it )as er! su$erficial% such as lefties
are more creatie. His classes are 1;-"( students and he sa!s there are usuall! a
cou$le of left handed children. 3s most $edagog! in the $ast decade has &een geared
to)ards differentiation and grou$ conferencing% he feels that most teachers )ould ta'e
that into consideration if )or'ing closel! )ith a $u$il. He said his school does hae
some left handed scissors and that the des's )ere all &ilateral.
Discussion
3fter reie)ing the interie)s% seeral oerarching themes emerge )hich seem
to confirm much of the information in the eisting literature. Beginning )ith the content
of teacher $re$aredness% all of the stud! su&ects stated that there had &een no
significant discussion of the to$ic of handiness during training% or $erha$s at all in an!
ca$acit!. /hose )ho said there )as some related content e$ressed that it )as done in
$assing or inde$endentl! on the $art of the trainer% as in the case )ith Guth in ?hina.
/his sho)s that calls for a s!stematic accounta&ilit! of the needs of left handed learners
from researchers such as Montgomer! 51++C8 hae still gone unheeded. Li'e)ise% the
demands for an integrated $edagog! li'e those &! Lang 5"((98 and #en6e 5"((78 into
general teacher,s training hae also made little to no $rogress in the $ast decade.
Seeral disadantages for these students &ecame a$$arent throughout the
course of the conersations )ith the instructors. 0ic',s e$erience tr!ing to hel$
students )ith fossili6ed errors as a result of &eing self-taught )hile tr!ing to model right
handed teachers is reminiscent of ?oren,s 51+>+8 findings that left-handed $eo$le )ere
8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 18/27
1>
more li'el! to suffer inuries )hile tr!ing to $erform $h!sical tas's in a right oriented
)orld. /he lac' of s$eciali6ed s$orting e*ui$ment ties into the stud! &! Freitus 5"((78
a&out the disadantage suffered &! lefties in &ase&all and other team s$orts. @n the
$ositie side of the literature% ho)eer% 0ic',s $ersonal e$erience did seem to erif!
that once these hurdles )ere oercome% left handers could hae an adantage &ecause
their o$$onents hae &een training to com$ete against the o$$osite side% Denn! 5"((98.
Guth,s comments a&out the unattractieness of the students, characters in
?hinese class% as )ell as her lac' of training in ho) to model for these minorit!
students% is com$ara&le to the effects of dra)ing in art class o&sered &! Vlachos
5"((78% )here students )ere fundamentall! uta$osed from the st!le of the teachers
instruction. In addition% Guth commented that these students continuousl! had to lift
their hands to loo' at )hat the! had ust )ritten% ma'ing them slo)er than the rest of the
class and also smearing their )or'. #hile the left to right direction of our )riting s!stem
is o&iousl! geared to)ards right handers% there are other instances )here this &ias is
in $la!% &ut need not &e necessaril! so. Guths o&serations seemed similar to the
$lacement of ans)er &u&&les on multi$le choice tests &eing $ositioned in such a )a! to
&e a hindrance to left handed students 5Hoo'% "(1(8.
/o oercome some of these challenges% there are usuall! t)o a$$roaches that
)ere utili6ed &ased on the interie) su&ects ada$tie measures on the $art of the
students and differentiated instructional techni*ues em$lo!ed &! the teachers. /he most
common among the data for this stud! )as the students inenting techni*ues )hich
allo)ed them to ada$t. Some eam$les of this )ere =on,s e$eriences )ith students
self arranging at des's to aoid &um$ing el&o)s and )itnessing left! students )riting in
8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 19/27
1+
note&oo's from &ac' to front as a )a! of co$ing )ith the s$iral )ire &inding. =en also
had o&sered students tilting their $a$ers at etreme angles and using the classic
hoo'2 hand sha$e to &e a&le to see )hat the! had )ritten and not smear their )riting.
Des's and note&oo's are the t)o most u&i*uitous eam$les of lateral s$ecific school
su$$lies% as discussed &! #en6e 5"((78. It also &rings to light the argument made &!
Ha!)ard 5"(178 that man! of these student,s $erformances &lossom )hen furnished
)ith ade*uate gear )hich assists% not hinders% their academic $otential.
/he second aenue at reconciling the challenges faced &! these students%
differentiated instruction% is also the one )hich most teachers had neither &een informed
or made a)are of. @nl! t)o of the interie) su&ects em$lo!ed an! DI techni*ues. 3s
discussed% this )as not a result of their training% &ut rather a &!-$roduct of &oth
instructors &eing left handed themseles. Both 0ic',s alternatie modeling of athletic
maneuers and ene,s indiidual time s$ent )ith lefties )ere re$resentatie of the t!$e
of cogni6ant% indiiduali6ed a$$roach adocated &! researchers such as ell! 51++C8.
Both ene and Guth had e$eriences illustrating that in man! $arts of the )orld% such
as the Middle East and 3sia% forced conersion is still unfortunatel! a realit!% causing
untold damage to such a large $ercentage of !oung learners% as documented &! &oth
Meng 5"((98 and an 51++>8. Luc'il! there does seem to &e more )ides$read
'no)ledge a&out the issue of handedness glo&all! as discussed &! Guth% &ut there are
still numerous hurdles to &e oercome.
Implications
8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 20/27
"(
/he most o&ious im$lication )hen com$aring the results of the interie)s to the
eisting literature is that the su&ect needs to &e addressed in all teacher training. /o
merel! &e made a)are of the to$ic and the modern scientific 'no)ledge of handedness
)ould go a long )a! in im$roing the educational outcomes of left handed learners.
Ideall! the to$ic )ould not onl! &e addressed% &ut differentiated instructional techni*ues
in arious su&ects% es$eciall! )riting% )ould &e im$lemented as )ell. For those
educators in countries )here forced conersion is still $racticed% the! should &e
encouraged to o$en a dialogue )ith &oth the teachers and school administrators a&out
the dangers of the techni*ue. @f course% this inoles a com$le inter$la! &et)een
$olitics% religion and a host of other factors. Besides the aforementioned a)areness and
strategies needed% &asic lateral s$ecific e*ui$ment is the net area that )ould &enefit
the most from reform. S$ecificall! des's and note&oo's )ould hae an immediate and
)ides$read &enefit for left! students. Follo)ing that% su$$lies li'e scissors and
s$eciali6ed su&ect gear for music or s$orts )ould also hel$ leel the $la!ing field.
Ultimatel!% a fe) minor changes and additions to our educational s!stems could create
a ne) host of o$$ortunities for ten $ercent of children and their educational endeaors.
8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 21/27
"1
References
3nnett% M. 51++8. /he Fallac! @f /he 3rgument For Geduced Longeit! In Left-
Handers. Perceptual And Motor Skills, 76 518% "+;-"+>. 51++% Fe&ruar! 18. Getrieed
3ugust ";% "(17% from US 0ational Li&rar! of Medicine 0ational Institutes of Health.
3nnett% M. 5"(118. D!sleia 3nd Handedness: Deelo$mental <honological 3nd Surface
D!sleias 3re 3ssociated #ith Different Biases For Handedness. Perceptual And Motor
Skills, 112 5"8% 719-7";. 5"(11% 3$ril 18. Getrieed 3ugust ";% "(17% from US 0ational
Li&rar! of Medicine 0ational Institutes of Health.
Benamin% 3. 5"(("8. Differentiated instruction: A guide for middle and high school
teachers. Larchmont% 0.J.: E!e on Education. Getrieed 3ugust "7% "(17% from EGI?.
Beratis% I.% Ga&ailas% 3.% !$rianou% M.% <a$adimitriou% .% K <a$ageorgiou% ?. 5"(18.
Inestigation of the lin' &et)een higher order cognitie functions and
handedness.Journal of linical and !"perimental #europs$cholog$, %& 578% +-7(.
5"(1% March 18. Getrieed 3ugust "7% "(17% from E$u&.
Bo)er% B. 5"((;8. 0euroscience: Lefties% righties ta'e neural sides in $erceiing $arts.
Science #e's, 167 5>8% 1";-1";. 5"((;% Decem&er 1+8. Getrieed 3ugust "7% "(17% from
E<S?@H@S/.
8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 22/27
""
?arlson% D.% K Harris% L. 51+>;8. Hand $reference for isuall! guided reaching in human
infants and adults. (eha)ioral and (rain Sciences, 6 58% 9"C-9"C. 51+>;% @cto&er 18.
Getrieed 3ugust "7% "(17% from =S/@G.
?asasanto% D.% K Henet6% /. 5"(118. Handedness Sha$es ?hildren,s 3&stract ?once$ts.
ogniti)e Science, %6 % ;+9"-;+9". 5"(11% =anuar! 18. Getrieed 3ugust "7%
"(17% from EGI?.
?oren% S. 51+>+8. Left-handedness 3nd 3ccident-related Inur! Gis'. American Journal
of Pu*lic +ealth, 75>8% 1(7(-1(71. 51+>+% 3ugust 18. Getrieed 3ugust "C% "(17% from
0?BI.
?oren% S.% K Hal$ern% D. 51++18. Left-handedness: 3 Mar'er For Decreased Surial
Fitness. Ps$chological (ulletin, 1-518% +(-1(C. 51++1% =anuar! 18. Getrieed 3ugust "7%
"(17% from EGI?.
?oren% S. 51++;8. Differences in Diergent /hin'ing as a Function of Handedness and
Se..he American Journal of Ps$cholog$, 1-/ 58% 11-11. 51++;% =anuar! 18. Getrieed
3ugust "7% "(17% from =stor.
?oren% S. 51++>8. <renatal testosterone e$osure% left-handedness% and high school
delin*uenc!. (eha)ioral and (rain Sciences, 2158% C+-9(. 51++>% =anuar! 18.
Getrieed 3ugust "7% "(17% from Educators Geference ?om$lete.
8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 23/27
"
Dee$-So&osla!% 3.% H!de% /.% ?allicott% =.% Lener% M.% Verchins'i% B.% 3$ud% =.% ... Eleag%
B. 5"(1(8. Handedness% herita&ilit!% neurocognition and &rain as!mmetr! in
schi6o$hrenia.(rain, 1%%51(8% 11-1"". 5"(1(% =ul! 18. Getrieed 3ugust "7% "(17%
from E$u&.
Denn!% .% K @Sullian% V. 5"((98. /he Economic ?onse*uences of Being Left-Handed.
.he Journal of +uman 0esources, 2 5"8% ;-97. 5"((9% =anuar! 18. Getrieed 3ugust
"% "(17% from =S/@G.
Eaton% #.% ?hi$$erfield% =.% Gitchot% .% K ostiu'% =. 51++C8. Is a Maturational Lag
3ssociated )ith Left-Handedness 3 Gesearch 0ote. Journal of hild Ps$cholog$ and
Ps$chiatr$, %7 5;8% C1-C19. 51++C% =ul! 18. Getrieed 3ugust "7% "(17% from =S/@G.
Freitas% ?.% Vasconcelos% M.% K Botelho% M. 5"(178. Handedness and deelo$mental
coordination disorder in <ortuguese children: Stud! )ith the M-3B? test. ateralit$:
As$mmetries of (od$, (rain and ognition, 15C8% 1-"". 5"(17% Decem&er "18.
Getrieed 3ugust "7% "(17% from Info/rac.
an% L. 51++>8. Left handed ?hildren in Singa$ore.‐ !arl$ hild De)elopment and are,
1% 11-119. 51++>% Ma! 18. Getrieed 3ugust "7% "(17% from =S/@G.
rouios% .% Sa'adami% 0.% <oderi% 3.% K 3leriadou% 3. 51+++8. Ecess of non-right
handedness among indiiduals )ith intellectual disa&ilit!: E$erimental eidence and
8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 24/27
"7
$ossi&le e$lanations. Journal of 3ntellectual Disa*ilit$ 0esearch, %578% (C-1. 51+++%
3ugust 18. Getrieed 3ugust "7% "(17% from EGI?.
Hauc'% =.% K De)e!% D. 5"((18. Hand $reference and motor functioning in children )ith
autism. Journal of Autism and De)elopmental Disorders, %158% "C;-99. 5"((1% =une 18.
Getrieed 3ugust "7% "(17% from EGI?.
Ha)'!ard% G.% Dem$se!% I.% K 3rthur-ell!% M. 5"(178. /he hand)riting e$eriences of
left-handed $rimar! school students in a digital age: 3ustralian data and criti*ue.
Australian Journal of !ducation, &/ 5"8% 1"-1>. 5"(17% 3ugust 18. Getrieed 3ugust "%
"(17% from =S/@G.
Hoo'% S. 5"(((% March 1( 8. Sinister &ias of multi-choice test. .!S #e'spaper4
Getrieed 3ugust "7% "(17% from Educators Geference ?om$lete.
=ohnston% D.% K 0icholls% M. 5"((+8. 0ature,s e$eriment Handedness and earl!
childhood deelo$ment. Demograph$, 6 5"8% ">1-(1. 5"((+% Ma! 18. Getrieed 3ugust
"% "(17% from 0ational Institute of Health.
ell!% E. 51++C% =anuar! 18. Left-Handed Students: 3 Forgotten Minorit!. 5ast*ack Phi
Delta appa !ducational 5oundation% 1-7(. Getrieed 3ugust "7% "(17% from EGI?.
lo$$el% S.% Mangin% =.% Vongerichten% 3.% Frac'o)ia'% G.% K Sie&ner% H. 5"(1(8. 0urture
ersus 0ature: Long-/erm Im$act of Forced Gight-Handedness on Structure of
8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 25/27
";
<ericentral ?orte and Basal anglia. Journal of #euroscience, %- 5+8% "91-"9;.
5"(1(% Decem&er 78. Getrieed 3ugust "7% "(17% from =S/@G.
o6el% G. 51++;8. ?onsideration of Hand in the Geading of Braille. 0eha*ilitation and
!ducation for (lindness and 8isual 3mpairment, 27 5"8% 9>->". 51++;% =anuar! 18.
Getrieed 3ugust "7% "(17% from EGI?.
romm!das% .% ourgoulianis% .% 3ndreou% .% K Mol!das% <. 5"((8. Left-
handedness in asthmatic children. Pediatric Allerg$ and 3mmunolog$, 1% "7-"9.
5"((% =anuar! 18. Getrieed 3ugust "7% "(17% from =S/@G.
Lang% =. 5"((9% Se$tem&er 18. #riting Hel$ for Lefties. Parenting % 1;>-1;>. Getrieed
3ugust "7% "(17% from Educators Geference ?om$lete.
L!le% .% Hanaer-/orre6% S.% Hac'lNnder% G.% K Edlin% =. 5"(1"8. ?onsistenc! @f
Handedness% Gegardless @f Direction% <redicts Baseline Memor! 3ccurac! 3nd
<otential For Memor! Enhancement. Journal of !"perimental Ps$cholog$: earning,
Memor$, and ognition, %/ 518% 1>9-1+. Getrieed 3ugust "7% "(17% from EGI?.
McDermott% M. 5"(18. .he lefthanded curriculum: reati)e e"periences for
empo'ering teachers. ?harlotte% 0?: Information age <u&lishing. Getrieed 3ugust "7%
"(17% from Educators Geference ?om$lete.
8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 26/27
"C
Meng% L. 5"((98. /he rate of handedness conersion and related factors in left-handed
children. ateralit$: As$mmetries of (od$, (rain and ognition, 12 5"8% 11-1>. 5"((9%
=anuar! 18. Getrieed 3ugust "7% "(17% from EGI?.
Montgomer!% =. 51++C% @cto&er 1" 8. Left-handers do not get e*ual hel$ .!S
#e'spaper . Getrieed 3ugust "7% "(17% from Educators Geference ?om$lete.
Godrigue6% 3.% K #aldenstrOm% U. 5"((+8. Fetal origins of child non-right-handedness
and mental health. Journal of hild Ps$cholog$ and Ps$chiatr$, 5+8% +C9-+9C. 5"((+%
=anuar! 18. Getrieed 3ugust "7% "(17% from EGI?.
Sattler% =. 51++C8. .he on)erted eft+ander or .he not in the (rain 5"nd ed.8.
Donau)Orth: 3uer. Getrieed 3ugust "7% "(17 from alegrou$.
Schiffman% =.% <estle% S.% Mednic'% S.% E'strom% M.% Sorensen% H.% K Mednic'% S. 5"((;8.
?hildhood lateralit! and adult schi6o$hrenia s$ectrum disorders: 3 $ros$ectie
inestigation. Schi9ophrenia 0esearch, 72 5"P8% 1;1-1C(. 5"((;% =anuar! 18. Getrieed
3ugust "7% "(17% from =S/@G.
Vaughan% G. 5"(1(% Ma! 178. E$ert $oints finger oer treatment of left-handers. .imes
!ducational Supplement % 57>+(8% 1;. Getrieed 3ugust "7% "(17 from alegrou$.
8/15/2019 Differentiated Instruction for Left-Handed Learners
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/differentiated-instruction-for-left-handed-learners 27/27
"9
Vlachos% F.% K Bonoti% F. 5"((78. Left and right handed childrens dra)ing $erformance:‐ ‐
Is there an! difference ateralit$: As$mmetries of (od$, (rain and ognition, 578% +9-
7(+. 5"((7% =anuar! 18. Getrieed 3ugust "7% "(17% from EGI?.
Vlachos% F.% K ara$etsas% 3. 51++C8. Visual - motor organi6ation and memor! in the
right-handed and the left-handed child: 3 com$aratie neuro$s!chological a$$roach.
hild #europs$cholog$, 15"8% "(7-"1". 51++C% Decem&er 18. Getrieed 3ugust "7% "(17%
from EGI?.
#al'er% . 51++>% =ul! 18. ?lash of the el&o)s confounds left-handed. .imes
!ducational Supplement . Getrieed 3ugust "7% "(17% from Educators Geference
?om$lete.
#en6e% .% K #en6e% 0. 5"((78. Hel$ing Left-Handed ?hildren 3da$t to School
E$ectations. hildhood !ducation, /1518% ";-1. 5"((7% @cto&er 18. Getrieed 3ugust
"7% "(17% from =S/@G.