05/22/13RISKPRO1
TACPA May 18, 2013Professional Liability for CPAs
This presentation can be found online at:http://www.slideshare.net/GeraldBrunker/cpa-presentation-may-18-2013
05/22/13RISKPRO2
Learning Objectives
Underwriters’ View of CPA Firms Factors to Assess Premiums Most Frequent Claims Filed Actions to Mitigate Risk of a Claim Cyber Risk and EPL Exposures PL Claims Made Coverage Basics Supplemental Payment Features Special Endorsement Coverage Options
05/22/13RISKPRO3
Current CPA PL Market
CNA/Aon/AICPA Philadelphia
Insurance Cos Lexington/NH (AIG)
(Chartis) Argonaut Ins Co CPA Mutual
Insurance Co St. Paul/Travelers Greenwich/XL National Casualty
Co/Jamison
Navigators/Landy Admiral Ins Co Hartford Ins
Company/Target Markel Ins Co GenStar/Pearl Lloyds of London CAMICO Mutual
Ins Co Arch Insurance
Group Catlin Insurance
05/22/13RISKPRO4
Professional Liability Insurance
What is it? E&O insurance provides insurance coverage
for the negligent acts, errors and omissions of the insured in performing a service
Who is a professional?• Engineers, architects, accountants, lawyers,
doctors, not just professionals, however – miscellaneous pros and Not For Profits
• E&O policies tend to be tailored to the specific profession of the insured
05/22/13RISKPRO5
Duty to Client
Standard of care: level of care that is the customary or usual practice of other members of the accounting profession
Example: failing to file a client’s tax return on time
CPA professional standards: public interest, due care and objectivity
Duty to non-clients?
05/22/13RISKPRO6
Negligence
Four key elements to a suit:CPA had a duty to the clientProve CPA breached that dutyPlaintiff must show was injuredProve breach of duty was proximate
cause of the injury (was breach sufficiently responsible so that CPA should be held accountable?)
05/22/13RISKPRO7
Underwriters’ Views on PH
Like PHs to collaborate and be a team with underwriters
Provide best and most accurate information to underwriters on area of practice and expertise
Allows underwriters to provide best pricing and areas for improvement (engagement letters, peer reviews and areas for specific CPE)
Applications and supplements (add narrative on internal controls)
Loyalty credits
05/22/13RISKPRO8
Factors to Assess Premiums
Underwriters view several variables to determine premiums:
Revenues Areas of practice Types of clients Staff Risk/quality control procedures Claims experience
05/22/13RISKPRO9
Revenues by AOP & Client Type
Most recently completed year Current year to date Projection for next fiscal year Underwriters looking for whether firm has
stable, growing or shrinking revenues Underwriters also look at revenues per staff
member as a gauge May average years to smooth out any
spikes or dips in revenues
05/22/13RISKPRO10
Areas of Practice (AOP) Some AOPs have higher exposure Audit claims have higher damage payouts Tax claims are more frequent but with
smaller damage payouts Other high exposure AOPs: handling client
funds, trustee work and consulting work, high profile clients
Expansion of management advisory services (beyond IT to HR, litigation, etc)
05/22/13RISKPRO11
Types of Clients
Some client types are high risk such as public company clients; athletes or celebrities
Some industries are higher risk with stringent accounting guidelines and procedures to be followed: banking, insurance, construction and auto dealers
05/22/13RISKPRO12
CPA Firm Staff
Size of staff Expertise of staff Revenue per staff member Continuing education Turnover of staff Length of tenure of staff Participation in Society or Association
events
05/22/13RISKPRO13
Risk Control Procedures
Use of engagement letters on all services. Updated annually?
Use of written checklists Diary system in place to track work Participation in peer review program Use of client screening process (unsavory,
financial problems, poor internal controls, lack internal stability, uncertain futures, change, sue or shop for CPAs, substantial litigation, expertise mismatch, professional intuition)
No suits to recover fees
05/22/13RISKPRO14
AICPA Suit Sources
20% Individual tax returns 6% Compilation 5% Bookkeeping 31% Corporate tax 38% Other (estate, audits, consulting,
financial planning/advisory, review, tax planning, trust engagements)
>20 years – 67% arise from taxes
05/22/13RISKPRO15
Percentage of Total Claims(By Service)
55%
13%
11%
10%
5%6%
Tax Claims 55%
Compilation &Review 13%Consulting 11%
Audit 10%
Fiduciary 5%
Other 6%
Copyright 2010
Ralph G. Picardi, Esq.
www.lappingpicardi.com
05/22/13RISKPRO16
Percentage of Total Dollar Losses(By Service)
17%
13%
8%
37%
5%20%
Tax Claims 17%
Compilation &Review 13%Consulting 8%
Audit 37%
Fiduciary 5%
Other 20%
Copyright 2010
Ralph G. Picardi, Esq.
www.lappingpicardi.com
05/22/13RISKPRO17
Percentage of Tax Claims(By Type of Client)
35%
20%
16%
13%
8%
8% Individual35%C Corp 20%
S Corp 16%
Partnership13%Trust 8%
Estate 8%
Copyright 2010
Ralph G. Picardi, Esq.
www.lappingpicardi.com
05/22/13RISKPRO18
Percentage of Audit Claims(By Source of Claim)
40%
5%10%
9%
6%
25%
5%
Failure to detect 40%
Conflict of Interest5%
InsufficientDisclosures 10%
Engagement Disputes9%
Fraud 6%
Financial StatementErrors 25%
Other 5%
Copyright 2010
Ralph G. Picardi, Esq.
www.lappingpicardi.com
05/22/13RISKPRO19
Claim Trends Since 2008
Most frequent claims are tax related and will continue as tax laws change
Uptick in embezzlement claims with state of economy – CPA staff stealing from firm’s clients
Firm does tax work with no engagement letter – dragged in as a “deep pocket”
05/22/13RISKPRO20
Claim Examples
$170,000 -An accountant made a $1.9 million error in a client’s financial statements. Client filed claim for cost of another accounting firm to correct the mistake.
$205,000 -The heirs of a wealthy investor brought suit against their accountant for not filing a timely tax return resulting in penalties and interest charged to the estate.
05/22/13RISKPRO21
Claim Examples
$185,000 -An accountant audited the financial statements of a client. Failed to detect and recognize irregularities associated with an employee embezzlement.
$375,000 -An accountant set up a client’s investment properties as a corporation instead of a partnership. Client alleged losses for tax liability that must be paid by the client.
05/22/13RISKPRO22
Major Settlements
2007 PWC $225 million to settle investor class action suit at Tyco
2005 KPMG $22 million SEC settlement over Xerox audits
2005 D&T $50 million to settle US regulators claims over Adelphia
1999 E&Y $335 million to Cendant shareholder settlement
05/22/13RISKPRO23
Actions to Mitigate Claims
Documentation Client Management Areas of Practice Fiduciary Liability Technology Form of practice (PCs, LLCs, LLPs) Personal asset protection
05/22/13RISKPRO24
Documentation
Document, document, document Engagement letters – ALL services –
specify work doing and NOT doing Avoid “drift” – additional services w/o Include ADR/mediation clause Include limitation of liability clause Use checklists and diary system Establish record retention policy Keep current on time and billing Quality control document for tax work
05/22/13RISKPRO25
Client Management
NEVER SUE FOR FEES Know reasonable fees (trusts, elderly
or unsophisticated) Do not create conflicts of interests (no
investing, loans or borrowing – maintain independence)
Screen new clients. Background checks. Use risk management committee. Call PL hotline.
05/22/13RISKPRO26
Client Management
Know clients, screen clients and disengage from difficult clients (get help from underwriters if necessary)
Know your expertise and time constraints – do not take more than you can handle
Manage client expectations at outset and during engagement
Do not make unattainable promises Do not predict or guarantee outcomes Communicate progress regularly
05/22/13RISKPRO27
Area of Practice
Make sure you have expertise Do not move out of comfort zone Be aware of outside experts such as
tax lawyers with new schemes Be cautious of new areas of practice –
SEC attest work for financial firms. Investment funds, mortgage bankers or brokers or real estate related clients
05/22/13RISKPRO28
Fiduciary Liability
Trustee work problematic when family dysfunctional. Trust agreement with indemnification of trustee for liability claims funded with trustee liability insurance
Access to client funds – careful supervision of your employees. Dishonesty bond with third party extension for client funds
05/22/13RISKPRO29
Technology 2010 – Chinese Hackers Target Law Firms
to Get Secret Deal Data – (Potash-BHP Billiton Ltd) – if law firms vulnerable – CPA firms?
Strong data protection procedures Reinforce with encryption and firewall Client electronic records on site only Consider an outside technology audit Consider cyber liability insurance (rather
than endorsements on PL or BOP)
05/22/13RISKPRO30
Cyber Risk and EPL
The frequency of online attacks against U.S. businesses continues to increase, along with the cost of defending against those attacks and mitigating any resulting data breaches
According to the 2012-2013 Edition of Jury Award Trends and Statistics, the national median award for employment practice claims in 2011 was $325,000, up from $172,500 in 2010
Separate limits from PL and specialized services for cyber and EPL risks
05/22/13RISKPRO31
PL Claims Made Coverage Basics
Claim made during policy period.
Claim or circumstance reported during policy period (or if ERP activated).
Negligent act happened after prior acts or retroactive date.
Good faith statement no knowledge of negligent act on inception date of policy.
05/22/13RISKPRO32
Accounting Professional Liability Insurance
Covers claims from rendering or failing to render professional accounting services.
Claims made trigger. Prior acts coverage. Defense and payments to third
parties. Endorsements and exclusions. Limits/deductibles and cost. Contractual liability (vicarious liability
of consultants). Extended Reporting Periods (Tail). Hammer clauses
05/22/13RISKPRO33
Basic or Broad Coverage
Simple application Basic coverage for accountants,
bookkeepers and tax preparers Tax engagements, planning Bookkeeping Reviews Compilations Independent contractors Notary public
05/22/13RISKPRO34
Broad Coverage More detailed application Higher limits and deductible options Coverage for reviews and audits SEC acts/security related activities Computer hardware/software sales Investment advice, management
advisory and financial advising More ERP options (1,3,5 years) Free Death or Disability ERPs
05/22/13RISKPRO35
Supplemental Payment Features
Defense Costs Outside Limits Loss of Earnings (per day/aggregate) Regulatory or Governmental Actions,
Disciplinary Proceedings (aggregate per policy year)
Subpoena Response Assistance (legal representation)
Pre-Claims Assistance (reporting of events; legal representation; subsequent claims covered)
Mediation Deductible Credits
05/22/13RISKPRO36
Special Endorsement Coverage Options
Electronic media exposure including social media
Cyber liability and identity theft Sarbanes Oxley Gramm Leach Bliley Life insurance sales Services as a registered rep Employment practices liability (defense
only) Non-Profit D&O (low limits)
05/22/13RISKPRO37
Summary
Questions?
Underwriters’ views on CPA firms, factors to assess premiums, claims and actions to mitigate risk of a claim
Improve your CPA Practice and Services to Your Clients
Coverage Checklists on Professional, EPL and Cyber Risk
05/22/13RISKPRO38
RISKPRO Insurance Agency, LLCGerald P Brunker, CPCU, ARMPrincipal/Owner
Facebook: Gerald Brunker & RISKPRO Insurance Agency, LLC
Twitter: RISKPROInsAgy LinkedIn: Gerald Brunker Blog: www.riskpro.us/blog Email: [email protected]
This presentation can be found online at:http://www.slideshare.net/GeraldBrunker/cpa-presentation-may-18-2013