1
COVID19FISCALIMPACTS
FOR63UTAHCITIESFY2019-20&2020-21
PerformedfortheUtahLeagueofCitiesandTowns
ByEconowestAssociates,Inc.
April2020
2
COVID19SalesTaxImpactson63UtahCities
Summary
BecausetheCOVID19hasnoprecedenceithasbeendifficulttotrackandforecast.ThesimplemodelsweuseinthisreportutilizerecentU.S.surveydatatoapproximatetheimpacton63citiesfortheperiodbetweenMarch2020andFebruary2021.Thenwecalculatethesefactorsintofiscalyears2019-20and2020-21.Overall,weestimatethatthetotalforthesalestaxdistributionsofthe63citieswilldecline3.5%and5.4%infiscalyear2019-20.Growthrateswillrangefrom-7%inVernaltopositive11%inEagleMountain.
Nextyear,weexpectanotherdropindistributions,butonlyby2.5%.Quarterlypercentagechangesinshouldimproveattheendofthefiscalyear2020-21(-20%,-10%,5%and15%)whentheywillcomparefavorablytothesecondhalfoffiscalyear2019-20.
Whenwefirststartedthisproject,wethoughttherewouldbemuchbiggernegativeimpacts,butbecausethefirsteightmonthsoffiscalyear2019-20distributionsweresostrong,theytooktheedgeoffthe-25%to-36%declinesthelastfourmonthsthelastofthefiscalyearwillprobablybring.
BythisNovember’ssalestaxdistributionwewillgetabetterhandleonthetrajectoryofthepandemicinfiscalyear2020-21.Ofcourse,citiesaretryingtocreatebudgetsrightnow.
TheStrongEightMonthsBetweenJuly2019andFebruary2020HelpSoftenTheBlowofCOVID19
TheCOVID19pandemicisunprecedentedinrecenthistory.Wecertainlydon’thaveanymagicbulletstoforecastthiseventwithourcurrenteconomicmodels.Theapproachwetakehereistoestimatetheimpactineachcity’seconomicsectorfromrecentcalendaryear2019datafromtheTaxCommission.Thedurationoftheimpactisforanentireyear.ItisbasedonsurveydatafromvarioussourcesthatsurveyedU.S.consumersalesinMarchandApril2020.OursourcescomefromtheU.S.CensusBureau,EarnestResearchandtheUniversityofMichigan(Table1).
Basedonthesesurveys(Table1)andourexperiencewehavemadereasonableestimatesattrendsinspendingforanentireyear,probablytheyearfromMarch2019throughFebruary2020(whilethisdoesn’texactlyconformtothecities’JulytoJunefiscalyear,wemodifyourresultstoformfiscalyearestimates).
3
Table1.RecentTrendsinU.S.ConsumerSpending
RetailCategories Direction SourceVehicles -11% UniversityofMichiganVehicles -35% EarnestResearchVehicles -24% U.S.CensusBureauHomes -21% UniversityofMichiganLargeHouseholdAppliances -46% UniversityofMichiganGroceryStores +29% U.S.CensusBureauClothingStores -51% U.S.CensusBureauGasolineStations -18% U.S.CensusBureauRestaurants -45% EarnestResearchSportingGoods,Toys,Books -23% U.S.CensusBureauSportingGoods,Toys,Books -65% EarnestResearchNonstoreRetailers–InternetandCatalogue
+10% U.S.CensusBureau
DepartmentStores -45% EarnestResearchElectronicStores -33% EarnestResearchLodging -85% EarnestResearchTheatersandEvents -95% EarnestResearchHealthCare -25% EarnestResearchDrugStores -24% EarnestResearch
Foraboutonefourthofthe63citieswestudied,theimpactofthepandemicfitsveryclosetotheStateofUtah’simpact.ThosecitiesrespondingsimilarlytotheStateare:
1) Draper2) Hurricane3) Layton4) Lehi5) Midvale6) NorthSaltLake7) Orem8) Price9) Richfield10) SaltLakeCity11) Sandy12) SouthSaltLakeCity13) SpanishFork14) Taylorsville15) WestValley
Table2presentsOrem’sfiscalimpactsby38economicsectors.Orem’spatternofdeclinesaresimilartotheStateofUtah’s.ForOrem’s$2.63billionintaxablesales
4
lastyear,aModerateScenariodeclineof-11.7%ispossible.ThePessimisticScenariopredictsanear30%dropintaxablesales.ThiscomparescloselytotheStateofUtah’s-11.6%ModerateScenariodeclineand-28%PessimisticScenariofall.ForOrem,largedeclinesmaybefeltinWholesaleDurableGoods,MotorVehicleDealers,Clothing,GeneralMerchandise,andFoodServices.TheFoodandBeverageStoresalesincrease14%willpartiallyoffsettheabovedeclines.
Therestofthe63CitiesindividualimpactsareintheAppendix(Appendix–COVID19FiscalImpactonEachCity.pdf).
Table2.OremCOVID19FiscalImpact
Largerdeclineswillbefeltincitieswithheavytouristspending,orcitiesthatdrawinneighboringconsumersintotheirretailers.Morethan25%declinesmaybefeltinthelastfourmonthsoffiscalyear2019-20inthefollowingcities:
1) Farmington2) Kanab3) Moab4) ParkCity5) Riverdale6) SouthOgden7) Springdale8) WestBountiful
5
ThePlusesandMinusofLaggedDistributionData
Thelastfourmonthsoffiscalyear2019-20canbelookedattwoways.Onthedownside,distributionlagsfromactualsalesbytwomonthspreventusfromseeingpandemicimpacteddatauntilMay20thandJune20thforMarchandAprilspending,respectively.Thismakesforecastingmoredifficult.
Onthepositiveside,significantCOVID19relateddeclinesinMaythroughAugust2020distributionswillbemitigatedbythestrongdistributionsfromSeptember2019throughApril2020,whichwereup7.1%forthe63cities.
CurrentYearEstimates
Weestimatefiscalyear2019-20salestaxgrowthinTable3.Thisisbasedonthefirsteightmonthsof“harddata”fromthedistributionsthatare“inthebank”andourestimatesfortheremainingfourmonthsofMarchtoJunesales(MaytoAugustdistributions,underGAPP).Weuseda80%PessimisticScenarioweightinganda20%ModerateScenarioweighting.
Becausethefirsteightmonthsofthecurrentfiscalyeargrewveryfastata7.1%rate,themomentumtakestheedgeoffanestimated25%declineinthelastfourmonthsoffiscalyear2019-20.Duringthefirsteightmonthstherangeofdistributionchangesranfrom-3%inRoosevelttopositive21%inEagleMountain,averaging7.3%forthe63cities.
Overthefinalfourmonthsoffiscalyear2019-20,weexpecttoseesignificantdeclines–closetothePessimisticScenario.Ifweusean80%weightforthePessimisticScenario,thedeclinewillbealmost25%forthelastfourmonthsofthefiscalyear2019-20.Thefirsteightmonths,weightedat66.67%(8/12thsofayear)contributes4.9%growth.Thisgrowthisoffsetbya-24.8%inthelastfourmonths(4/12thsofyear)equaling-8.3%.Thesumofthesetwoamountsequalsa3.5%declineforthecurrentfiscalyearforall63cities(lastrowinTable3).
Becausethemodelisdynamicwecancalculatetheimpactsofdifferentscenarios.Ifthelastfourmonthscomein20%worsethanthePessimisticScenario(-36%),thecitieswouldseea5.4%declineindistributionsforfiscalyear2019-20.
6
Table3.FY2019-20COVID19SalesTaxImpactfor63UtahCities
7
Chart1.
8
FiscalYear2020-21Forecast
Atthispoint,theviewoutintonextfiscalyearismurky.Weassumeagradualreturntopositivegrowthmaynotoccuruntilthesecondhalfoffiscalyear2020-21(Table4).
Table4.
1%SalesTaxDistributions(YearoverYearPercentageChanges)
FY2019-20
1stquarter +3.5%actual
2ndquarter +10.0%actual
3rdquarter -10.0%estimate
4thquarter -25.0%estimate
TotalFY2019-20 -3.3%to-5.5%
________________________________
FY2020-21
1stquarter -20%
2ndquarter -10%
3rdquarter +5%(thiswouldbe+5%overthe-10%prioryear)
4thquarter +15%(thiswouldbe+15%overaverynegativefourthquarterFY20)
TotalFY2020-21 -2.5%