Commodifying Mindfulness
The Relationship between Identity Performance and
Entrepreneurship through the Lenses of Yoga on Instagram
Annika Heinemeyer
Master Thesis
Master of Arts (MA) in New Media and Digital Culture
Supervisor: Tim Highfield
Second Reader: Jan Simons
June 28, 2019
2
Abstract
This thesis provides an insight into how the social media platform
Instagram is used by yoga entrepreneurs for self-promotion and
business pursuits. Set within frameworks of identity performance
online, digital entrepreneurship, Instagram’s development into a
business platform as well as the contemporary growing market with
yoga and mindfulness, this study aims to outline the posting behaviour
of yoga entrepreneurs on Instagram in relation to monetization
strategies. To do so, the most recent 20 posts by ten established yoga
Instagram entrepreneurs and their Instagram stories over a period of
three days were studied through a visual and textual content analysis.
The study concludes that yoga entrepreneurs use Instagram as a tool
for personalized and ‘authentic’ promotion, first and foremost by
presenting yoga as initial step to a desirable, healthy and ‘cool’ lifestyle,
which is seamlessly contextualized with the promotion of commercial
yoga products and services.
Keywords:
Instagram, yoga, identity performance, digital entrepreneurship
3
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................. 5
1.1. The Mediation of Yoga in Western Societies .......................................................... 5
1. 2. The Role of Social Media ......................................................................................... 7
1. 3. Research Question .................................................................................................. 8
1. 4. Research Structure.................................................................................................. 9
CHAPTER 2: THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK ..................................................................... 11
2.1. Performing Identity ................................................................................................. 11
2.1.1. Impression Management .................................................................................... 11
2.1.2. Selective-Self Presentation ................................................................................ 12
2.1.3. Identity Performance through Lifestyle Choices ................................................. 14
2.2. Studying Instagram ................................................................................................ 16
2.2.1. Mediating the Self on Instagram ......................................................................... 16
2.2.2. Instagram’s Aesthetics in the Change of Time ................................................... 19
2.3.” The Brand called You”: Digital Entrepreneurship on Instagram ...................... 21
2.3.1. Influencer Marketing ........................................................................................... 21
2.3.3. Entrepreneurship on the Spiritual Marketplace ................................................... 25
CHAPTER 3: METHODOLOGY .......................................................................................... 28
3.1. Selecting accounts ................................................................................................. 28
3.2. Chosen accounts .................................................................................................... 29
3.3. Post Analysis .......................................................................................................... 32
CHAPTER 4: FINDINGS ..................................................................................................... 36
4.1. First impressions: username, profile picture and bio .......................................... 36
4.2.1. The Presentation of Yoga ................................................................................... 38
4.2.2. Identity Performance .......................................................................................... 41
4.2.3. Business purposes ............................................................................................. 43
4.2.4. The Presentation of Authenticity ......................................................................... 45
4.2.5. From Posts to Stories ......................................................................................... 47
4.2. Story analysis ......................................................................................................... 47
4
4.3.1. The Presentation of Yoga ................................................................................... 49
4.3.2. Identity performance .......................................................................................... 50
4.3.3. Business purposes ............................................................................................. 52
4.3.4. The Presentation of Authenticity ......................................................................... 55
4.3.5. To summarize .................................................................................................... 56
CHAPTER 5: DISCUSSION ................................................................................................ 58
5.1. Identity Performance through Lifestyle Choices .................................................. 58
5.3. The Commodification of Yoga as “New Age Spirituality” and Wellness Product
........................................................................................................................................ 64
5.4. The Role of Instagram ............................................................................................ 65
5.5. Limitations and Further Research ......................................................................... 68
CHAPTER 6: CONCLUSION .............................................................................................. 70
BIBLIOGRAPHY ................................................................................................................. 72
APPENDIX .......................................................................................................................... 85
5
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION
1.1. The Mediation of Yoga in Western Societies
In closer examination of the contemporary Western media culture, Zen Buddhism scholar
Jørn Borup describes a striking omnipresence of Buddhist images, especially in lifestyle
and health centred contexts: “Buddha is cool and chic in the West, and as a popular brand
has moved from temple to market” (41). Even though ancient Eastern Hindu and Buddhist
practices and ideas such as yoga or meditation can be rooted back several thousands of
years, recent evidence has shown renewed interest of the public in meditative activities,
with the goal of becoming happier, healthier and more mindful (Sun et al. 378; Mathews
et al.; Manns). The amount of people practicing yoga increased from 9.5% in 2012 to
14.3% in 2017, while at the same time the practice of meditation even increased more
than threefold, from 4.1% to 14.2 (Manns). Equally, terms like ‘karma’ or ‘zen’ have
become appealing signifiers of happiness and overall well-being (Borup 48). According to
Jon Kabat-Zinn, dubbed the professor and “godfather of modern mindfulness” (Booth),
mindfulness originally describes a “moment-to-moment, non-judgmental awareness,
cultivated by paying attention in a specific way, that is, in the present moment, and as non-
reactively, as non-judgmentally, and as openheartedly as possible” (1). Mindfulness has
been described as a self-help tool for “spiritual self-development” (Borup 49) and guiding
concept for people with the desire to slow down and to subvert pressures, stress and
obligations attached to work and other social requests (Melissa Gregg; Raphael). Modern
working conditions such as flexible contracts and working hours as well as constantly
being tied to computers and smartphones has not only led to various mental and physical
health problems but also the increased desire to reverse these impacts (Zambarakji).
Paradoxically, mindfulness has been adapted to media contexts and can be accessed in
various forms, through technologies such as meditation apps, sleeping trackers or other
devices or technologies serving to quantify or improve people’s mindfulness. Likewise,
with the publication of a whole range of articles and guideline books about how to dive into
the Buddhist mindset easily - for example Peace Is Every Step: The Path of Mindfulness
in Everyday Life or Buddhism: A Beginner’s Guide - ideas about mindfulness and
enlightenment have become to be advertised as an easily adaptable mindset for the
masses on a market where “spirituality is for sale” (Borup 41).
6
An article by the Guardian in 2015 argued that mindfulness has been recognized
and used as a profitable business idea and commodity to be bought and sold on the free
market, particularly driven by people who are becoming “professionally mindful”
(Sherwood). Since the publication of this article, the market around health, mindfulness
and wellness has not only developed remarkably, but has also shown up yoga as one of
the most established and popular drives within this market (Manns; Mathews et al.).
Leading yoga practitioners from India brought yoga into the Western world and shifted the
focus from the traditional physical-spiritual connection to a more body-centred practice
and thus, marketed the yoga lifestyle in association with modern ideas of wellness and
beauty ideals (White 2; Mathews et al.; Jain 76). In that sense, critical voices describe this
commodification of Eastern spirituality as cultural appropriation1 in which yoga has been
reduced to a fetishization for beauty and physical fitness, especially for wealthy white
women (Boll 31). This however does not seem to detract from the appeal yoga has
nowadays and research by the Global Wellness Institute has shown that “all the yoga
classes, meditation retreats, spas, aromatherapy oils, quartz crystals, juice cleanses, and
other wellness-focused practices” have contributed to turning the global market with
wellness into a USD$ 3.7 trillion industry in 2015 and even USD$ 4.2 trillion in 2017
(O’Leary and Velasco; Raphael). Consequently, countless yoga studios with lessons
starting from US$15 as well as yoga-related magazines and clothing brands have sprouted
from the ground. Gyms have adapted yoga into their programmes by naming it ‘Power
Yoga’ and highlighting its impacts on physical fitness and appearance. Travel agencies
contribute to the flourishing market with yoga and wellness by advertising yoga retreats in
exotic environments. Yoga institutions and studios in India but also the rest of the world
have specialized in offering ‘Yoga Teacher Trainings’ that certificate participants as
professional teachers within about 21 days by the costs of average US$3000. That is to
say, yoga has become a “pop culture phenomenon” within Western societies (Jain 20) and
a fashionable lifestyle concept and image of a contemporary zeitgeist in which investments
in one’s wellbeing and mindfulness are highly valued and ancient Eastern practices are
sold as signifiers for a healthy, socially desirable and ‘cool’ lifestyle (Borup 41; White 1;
Jain 3; Lewis 538; Raphael; Manns).
1 Cultural appropriation is understood as the adoption and usage of a culture’s specific symbols,
rituals, artefacts, genres or technologies by other cultures. While this process has been described as inescapable in terms of any form of cultural contacts, it usually refers to the the assimilation and exploitation of marginalized cults or is involved in the assimilation and exploitation of subordinate cultures in contrast to dominant cultures, mostly visible in East versus West discourses (Rogers 474).
7
1. 2. The Role of Social Media
In her work on the adaption of yoga to Western cultures, Birgid N. Boll has defined the
presence of yoga brands and entrepreneurs on social media as a driving force on the global
market with yoga and wellness (36). Yoga teachers share their classes on video platforms
such as YouTube, write their own blogs or create Facebook groups to engage with a yoga-
interested community. Popular examples are Mady Morrison, who became one of the most
well-known in Germany through her social media appearance and created the Facebook
group #yogamitmady - Yoga Community with more than 10 thousand members or Adriene
Mishler, a 33-year-old yogi from the US who has more than 4 million subscribers to her
YouTube channel Yoga with Adriene. Mishler’s annual earning through her online yoga
business is estimated to be more than USD$360,000 solely through sponsorship deals with
companies like Adidas (Bramley). Consequently, these examples illustrate once again what a
profitable phenomenon yoga is on the general market and further explains striking individual
aspirations to establish yoga as a business through social media and especially through the
photo-sharing platform Instagram.
Shortly after its launch in October 2010, Instagram became one of the most popular
social media platforms, particularly through allowing users in contrast to more structured social
media sites such as Facebook to communicate predominantly through images which they can
easily make “visually interesting and appealing” (Manovich 40) through filters and in-app
editing options (Manovich 11; Boll 37; DeMers). According to Instagram’s co-founder Kevin
Systrom the original purpose of Instagram was to create a form of a visual diary, a space
where users can capture and share immediate impressions and moments of everyday life:
“We do not offer the ability to upload from the web as Instagram is about producing photos on
the go, in the real world, in realtime.” (Manovich 12). Instagram is potentially open for
everyone, from professional content producers, brands, celebrities and ordinary users alike
and aims to provide a space for people where they can “connect with their interests and
passions” ("About Us Instagram"). In that sense, Boll explains that Instagram became not only
popular for the basic documentation of one’s individual yoga journey and progress, but also a
place for a world-wide yoga community to emerge and has led to the formation of multiple
yoga accounts with up to at least one hundred thousand followers (41). As an illustration, the
hashtag ‘#yoga’ on Instagram reveals more than 68 million tagged posts up to June 2019.
Related hashtags are for example ‘#yogi’ (12.4m posts), ‘#yogachallenge” (7m posts) or
“#yogainspiration” (8.2m posts) that are used dominantly by people sharing yoga content on
Instagram and thus contribute to the high popularity and media presence of yoga.
After Instagram was bought by Facebook in 2012, features were added to the platform
that turned it into a powerful marketing and advertising tool used by business holders,
celebrities and private users alike. Not only got businesses the opportunity to connect
8
Instagram posts directly with external websites and social networks, but also to “have a dialog
with their customers” (Manovich 134). Instagram’s marketing possibilities are especially based
on the mechanism to strategically merge sensations of “intimacy, access and authenticity with
promotion and branding” (Toffoletti and Thorpe 301). Studies on the Instagram performances
of fashion bloggers (Duffy and Hund), celebrities (Marwick and boyd) or athletes (Toffoletti
and Thorpe) have shown that the way users present themselves on Instagram is driven by
feedback and reputation they get by other users, which is measured through metrics as for
example likes and follower counts. The higher the metrics, the higher the influence and thus,
their potential financial successful. This way, Instagram makes it possible for people to gain
attention and popularity without having to be featured through traditional mass media, and
allows potentially every topic to thrive and enables new entrepreneurial opportunities for the
broad mass of its users (Boll 39). Consequently, Instagram proves to be an ideal marketing
opportunity for yoga entrepreneurs to build up brands and businesses, to make them
accessible for a large customer base and thus, to contribute to the striking popularity of yoga-
related products and services experience on the global wellness market.
1. 3. Research Question
Having discussed the emerging role of mindfulness and wellness today, a certain contradiction
remains to be striking: If mindfulness means to subvert influences of the fast-paced work
cultures and norms, how is it commodified and promoted through social media? Apart from
considering notions about cultural appropriation of yoga in Western social media contexts, this
argumentation indicates specific identity performances yoga entrepreneurs perform on
Instagram that are profit-oriented while maintaining the spiritual and mindful associations of
yoga. As previously discussed, the image of yoga in the contemporary media culture is
dominantly based on associations with desirable ideas about lifestyle and physical
appearance and has “become a commodity to be bought and sold as a mode of constructing
identity” (Boll 30). This study will examine strategies behind this phenomenon more closely
and will explain how yoga is specifically commodified through Instagram, how yoga
entrepreneurs present themselves on Instagram and where the relationship between identity
performance on Instagram and successful entrepreneurship lies.
After having been aware of yoga for several years, I noticed that yoga has become
more and more present, not only on Instagram also in the general society. Taken that the rise
of wellness professionals or “spiritual entrepreneurs” has found to be a constantly growing and
- perhaps increasingly - normalized phenomenon on social media (Gregory 211), the
overarching question of this research is: How do yoga entrepreneurs perform their identity
on Instagram and how does this interrelate with successful entrepreneurship? More
9
precisely, what kind of visual and textual content is shared on the platform specifically and
how is Instagram used for entrepreneurial pursuits?
Previous studies have focussed extensively on the medial representation of yoga in
contemporary Western societies, as for example regarding its shift from an once male-
dominated practice to an almost exclusively female one (Boll 27) and its exclusively
presentation through beauty ideals (Cowans). The contribution of this study will be to take the
impacts social media had on modern work cultures into consideration. Through the lenses of
yoga, this research will investigate on how Instagram can be utilized for digital
entrepreneurship. Furthermore, while previous research has been done on identity
performance based on Instagram’s image feed, the more recent feature Instagram stories that
has only been added to Instagram in 2016 has not been researched as extensively yet.
Consequently, this research is an ideal opportunity to investigate on how stories are used for
self-presentation and entrepreneurial purposes - both for communication and self-presentation
as well as in contrast to Instagram’s original image feed.
1. 4. Research Structure
In order to investigate into the identity performance of yoga entrepreneurs on Instagram,
this research is based on a theoretical framework consisting of relevant theoretical
concepts regarding identity performance. Therefore, I will outline how identity performance
has been studied for self-presentation and identity performance in everyday life situations,
predominantly based on theories by Erving Goffman (1959) and Anthony Giddens (1991).
The key argument of Goffman’s theory is that people can manage and navigate the
impressions they have on other people in everyday life situations. This concept has been
widely applied to social media contexts and based on that I will outline more specifically
how users present themselves on Instagram. By reflecting on yoga as an alternative
lifestyle I will discuss that especially the presentation of lifestyle choices functions as main
identifier for one’s online identity. Following this, the next part of my theoretical framework
will address how Instagram has emerged as an increasing platform for marketing and
business opportunities. To connect the theoretical foundation of this study with the
aforementioned research interest, Instagram’s affordances and possibilities for identity
performance and entrepreneurship will be addressed in order to specify Instagram as an
object of study. Therefore, the final part of the theoretical framework will discuss the role
of identity performance on Instagram for self-promotion and self-branding pursuits and in
which ways these performances facilitate digital entrepreneurship.
10
Based on that, this research sets out to explore how Instagram is used by yoga
entrepreneurs for monetization pursuits, first and foremost by analysing the shared content
by ten yoga entrepreneur accounts and the way they use Instagram’s affordances for self-
presentation and self-promotion. Therefore, methods for a comprehensive content
analysis on posts and stories will be set up. Finally, the last two chapters of this research
portray and discuss the outcomes of the analysis and their meanings in relation to the
research questions and draw a conclusion to provide a base for potential further studies.
11
CHAPTER 2: THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
To set up the theoretical framework for this study I discuss how theories on identity
performance have been adapted to new media contexts. This will show that in offline and
online environments alike, individual identity performances are driven by ‘selective self-
presentations’, particularly in the presentation of lifestyle and social ideals. In a second step,
I examine how identity performances determine popularity and monetization on Instagram.
Therefore, I discuss how self-branding strategies can be employed for influencer marketing
and digital entrepreneurship or, in this specific case, yoga entrepreneurship on Instagram.
2.1. Performing Identity
Identity is commonly defined as “the distinguishing character or personality of an individual”
(Merriam-Webster “Identity”). However, based on implementations by gender scholar and
philosopher Judith Butler, instead of being a static, one’s identity is rather performatively
constituted and might be different depending on the way people decide to present themselves
to others in different social contexts and conditions (21). Presenting predominantly idealized
impressions of oneself has found to be a ubiquitous practice, especially on social media
(Deeb-Swihart et al. 42). Consequently, a comprehensive understanding of identity
performance in online as well as in offline environments provides a foundation to investigate
further on entrepreneurship on Instagram.
2.1.1. Impression Management
One of the earliest and mostly referenced work on identity is The Presentation of Self in
Everyday Life by the Canadian sociologist Erving Goffman published in 1959. Self-
presentation according to Goffman basically describes how individuals perform and negotiate
their identities and how they present themselves to others in a social setting with focus on how
they want to be perceived by others (10). In that sense, a performance includes all the activities
by one person serving to influence their perception by others (Goffman 8). Consequently, with
“impression management”, Goffman refers to a performance of self that is achieved by giving
presentational cues about one’s identity (Goffman 14). Stating that generally in everyday life,
first impressions are predominantly goal-driven, Goffman implements that people tend to
12
consider their performances for self-presentation carefully, balancing out individual goals and
the self that they perceive the audience to desire (Goffman 5; Reichard Smith and Sanderson
343). With the dramaturgical metaphors of ‘front stage’ and ‘back stage’ performances,
Goffman describes that an overall impression of the self emerges through negotiating one’s
performances between these two positions. While front stage performances describe a
person’s conscious performances in front of an audience (Goffman 13), back stage
performances are those characteristics and actions that people commonly want to remain
hidden and not judged by the audience (Goffman 69).
As a core aspect of his theory Goffman states that a person’s presentation of self
consists of what they explicitly and deliberately give and give off, the former meaning the cues
an individual actively communicates and gives to the audience, while the latter refers to cues
that tend to be perceived by the audience unintendedly (Goffman 113; boyd 168; Bullingham
and Vasconcelos 101). Eventually, the theoretical approach of impression management
describing people's intention to present idealized presentation of themselves to an audience,
will play an important role in the further course of this study.
2.1.2. Selective-Self Presentation
Scholars relying on Goffman’s theory of impression management indicate particularly that
photography has become essential for self-presentation and emerged to be an important tool
to communicate with peers (Van Dijck “Digital Photography” 60; Djafarova and Trofimenko 3).
While Susan Sontag states that “what photography supplies is not only a record of the past
but a new way of dealing with the present” (130), José van Dijck builds on this by arguing that
photography experienced a shift from being an instrument for sharing memories to being an
instrument for communication and for capturing and sharing present moments and
experiences immediately (“Digital Photography” 63). While photography was initially
considered as a practice and hobby preserved for wealthy people and professionals, it was
made available among all classes with the development of technology (Mirzoeff 72). In line
with Goffman’s implementations on self-presentation in everyday face-to-face situations,
photographs became simultaneously the stage and documentation of one’s identity with the
camera function as tool for affirmation (Nir 17). Taken that smartphones have become
ubiquitous in people's everyday life, the integration of a camera into these devices have placed
photography to a new level of attention and shifted the practice of photography from
professions or hobbies to insertions of everyday lives and experiences (van Dijck “Digital
Photography” 65). Consequently, digital photography and smartphones with a camera function
allows people more control over their self-presentation by facilitating extensive possibilities for
13
selection and idealization processes, initially simply by providing extended storage spaces
and capturing possibilities (Leaver et al. 2; Caldeira 143).
With the general digitization of communication, sharing photographs has become the
most efficient way to express and communicate oneself which established sharing images
online as natural default mechanism on social media sites (van Dijck 68). In that sense, Katrin
Tiidenberg and Edgar Gomez Cruz argue that regarding the dominance of online interaction,
images have become a crucial determiner of how we make sense of everyday practices and
experiences and “shape our world” (79). By referring to identity performance and impression
management, scholars ascribe the advent of social media extensive capabilities to manage
and control their identity performances (Goffman; Marom 12; Reichard Smith and Sanderson
344). Just like in offline environments, similar strategies to present idealized images of the self
could be observed in the ways in which individuals share images of themselves on social
media (Djafarova and Trofimenko 2; Baker and Walsh 4555; Caldeira 155).
According to the social philosopher Pierre Bourdieu, photographs have always been
marketed by aesthetic value, given that in its origins, photography was dominantly used as a
tool to portray and celebrate the good aspects of life (qtd. in Verdina 12). Consequently, image-
based social networking sites offer users a whole range of possibilities for idealized and
selective self-presentations, especially regarding to an attractive presentation of the body
(Tiggemann and Zaccardo 1010). Based on that, Sophie P. Caldeira argues that users
consciously tend to create images that aim to be conform with common aesthetic ideals in
order to get more likes and appraisal (155). In a similar vein, Kirsty Young points out that all
features and affordances provided by social media platforms including imageries, texts and
audio serve users to perform their identities based on purposefully selected intentions (3).
These implication match Joseph B. Walther’s theory of a “selective self-presentation”,
describing users’ intention to present themselves in the best light possible which sheds light
on their motivation for particular posting performances on social media (Walther 2540).
Exhaustive research on self-presentation and identity performances on social media
has found that identity performances are to a great extent driven by feelings of social
acceptance and affiliation and that users tend to alter their performances depending on how
they intend to be received by others and the feedback they desire to get (Marwick and boyd
“I Tweet Honestly, I Tweet Passionately” 124; boyd 119; Young 4; Farquhar 468). For
example, Baker and Walsh described that users producing healthy eating related content on
Instagram, predominantly publish pictures of their bodies together with compatible hashtags,
being aware that these images are likely to get more measurable approval and reputation
(4555-4559). Similarly, Young differentiates between a “real” and an “ideal” self, in which the
ideal self would be one’s self-presentation in the best light possible (4).
14
Based on Goffman’s idea of front- and back stage performances, Alice Marwick and
danah boyd describe that users adjust their identity performances to an “imagined audience”
(“I Tweet Honestly, I Tweet Passionately” 115). While unmediated environments presuppose
the immediate presence of individuals through spatial and temporal constraints, the audience
on social media is less specific and theoretically limitless (boyd 121; Marwick and boyd “I
Tweet Honestly, I Tweet Passionately” 115). By taking cues from the respective social media
environment, users tend to conceptualize their audience and adjust components comprising
one’s online identity, such as style or language (Marwick and boyd “I Tweet Honestly, I Tweet
Passionately” 115). Regarding the commodification of yoga in Western cultures, Jain has
found that yoga entrepreneurs constantly construct brands in correlation to consumer desires
and needs (79). Consequently, this research will investigate not only on how yoga
entrepreneurs present themselves on Instagram, but also on how this responds to follower
engagement and community exchange.
2.1.3. Identity Performance through Lifestyle Choices
The implementations outlined so far go in line with the work of sociologist Anthony Giddens,
who investigated on the changed nature of identity from the traditional societies up to what he
describes as “post traditional” or “late modern” societies (Giddens; Buckingham 9). Building
up on the earlier theory by Goffman, Giddens argues that a person’s appearance of self is not
predominantly dependent on external influences and relies on an self-presentation on the front
stage based on social norms and conventions, but more on people’s own choices and actions
performed in everyday life (Giddens 6). One of the key aspects of Giddens’ theory therefore
lies on the increased importance of individualism. This led to what Giddens describes as
“reflexive project of the self” meaning that identities are in general more fluid and that
individuals are able to constantly make decisions about their identity performances in order to
create biographical narratives eventually building up and sustaining consistent identities
(Giddens 75). By this, one’s outplayed identity can be flexible, changed and altered over time
but still be portrayed as a coherent image to others (Giddens 76; Buckingham 9).
One main aspect of Giddens’ implementations focuses on how individuals can perform
and narrate their identities based on what he calls “lifestyle choices” meaning that people are
not what they are but what they make out of themselves (Giddens 75). Speaking about
lifestyle, Giddens does not refer to a concept associated with economical consumerism but to
a concept consisting of a specific set of routine practices making up the material of identity
which is an inevitable and ubiquitous aspect of late modernity. More precisely, all the small
lifestyle decisions individuals have to make each day from what to eat to what to wear and the
15
performance of making and remaking construct biographical narratives and thus, self-
identities (Giddens 81-82). Highlighting the aspect of choice within the variety of lifestyle
options in modern times, Giddens indicate however that rather than taking a choice out of a
purely free will, all individuals necessarily perform lifestyle choices in order to create and their
identities and senses of selves (Giddens 81).
Regarding social media, several studies have shown that in order to portray desirable
self-images promising positive feedback, users must constantly portray “desirable lifestyles
and hegemonic beauty ideals” (Tiidenberg and Baym 3). In line with for example studies on
women’s display of pregnancy (Tiidenberg and Baym), clean-eating (Baker and Walsh) or
“fitspiration” (Tiggemann and Zaccardo) on social media, the role of performing lifestyle
choices on platforms like Instagram serves on the one hand as a powerful tool to perform
one’s online identity and on the other hand to situate one’s narrative within various trends and
movements within digital networks and to actively include oneself with a community of like-
minded individuals (Baker and Walsh 4565; Caldeira 155). Consequently, identity is to a large
extent achieved through consumption of material goods or services connected with lifestyle
choices (Giddens 2001 qtd. in Dittmar 12). In the case of the commodification of yoga, Jain
has found that contemporary yoga entrepreneurs market yoga detached from its original
principles, but in connection with other consumable and easier accessible lifestyle
components ranging from outplaying diet choices such as advertising clothing brands or
wellness products. Through that, they position and market yoga within wider fitness and health
related market discourses (78).
16
2.2. Studying Instagram
Based on the mechanisms of imageries and social media for self-presentation discussed so
far, Instagram has been described as an “increasingly popular platform for self-presentation
online” (Baker and Walsh 4553). In the following part of the theoretical framework, the concept
of affordances will be taken into consideration to examine how Instagram has evolved from an
exclusive social media platform to a business platform. Based on that, l discuss how
Instagram’s platform affordances enable specific identity performances and determine the
kind of content shared on the platform.
2.2.1. Mediating the Self on Instagram
Generally speaking, social networking sites revolve around individual users and their
interaction with the site in means of sharing content about themselves (Bakhshi et al. 966). In
that sense, Instagram provides users extensive possibilities for self-presentation as they can
literally “write themselves into being” (boyd 121) by setting up online profiles and sharing
selected personal information (Khamis et al. 196; Caldeira 142).
The theory of affordances basically describes a construct of possible actions in an
environment (Gibson 127). This concept has been adapted to different contexts, as for
example to design studies (Norman) or the connection of technology and social research
(Garvern; Wellman et al.). This research will refer to the concept of affordances by analysing
what media technologies or objects offer, provide or permit the user to do, or more precisely,
which specific preconditions Instagram provides for specific user behaviours and actions
(Bucher and Helmond 3; Gibson 127). Consequently, by using the available knowledge of
users, features of interfaces and platforms can be designed and adjusted accordingly and be
built into devices or technologies to create normative ways of engaging with a platform (Stanfill
1060). On this basis, the basic steps to create an online identity on Instagram lies in choosing
a username, setting up a profile picture and potentially a short description about oneself, a
‘bio’, at the very top of the profile. Additionally, this space allows users to place direct links to
other sources that potentially complement their online identity, as for example personal blogs
or social media platforms.
While setting up a profile counts as initial step for identity performance, sharing content
takes up the process of performing one’s online identity (Caldeira 143). Even if written captions
can be used to contextualize images, the visual culture remains to be the most significant
platform-specific feature and more powerful for self-presentation (Caldeira 141; Carah and
17
Shaul 3). By adding hashtags to their posts, users can influence the visibility of their images.
If users search for example for the hashtag ‘#yoga’ on Instagram they get portrayed all images
labelled with the hashtag (Baker and Walsh 6). Photographs of users or ‘selfies’ -pictures
taken by oneself of oneself- can function as a two-sided way for identity performance. While
visual strategies for aesthetic presentation, for example signalling attractiveness through
revealing outfits or making use of Instagram’s in-app editing options discussed earlier, function
as a way for seeking and ensuring attention and visibility, this “aesthetic appeal” can be further
contextualized with personal views and contents in respective captions (Leaver et al.).
Furthermore, besides performing identity through sharing images of themselves, users
may decide to perform their identity based on what has been previously described as ‘lifestyle
choices’, including images of locations or material objects, the consumption of services or
commodities and, generally speaking, every day and trivial practices and decisions (Caldeira
155). In that sense, particularly the presentation of desirable scenes such as beaches and
travelling settings has become a widely used practice on Instagram to glorify a particular
lifestyle and to portray desirable and “beautiful lives” (Leaver et al.).
Whether or not one’s performance on Instagram achieves the desired effects however
depends on the “feedback mechanism” built onto the platform which shows itself in the form
of likes and comments. While receiving a like or positive comment serves as “a quick
validation”, negative feedback or the absence of it indicates disapproval (Caldeira 153).
Consequently, this feedback mechanism allows users to adjust their identity performances
and actively influence the impressions they want to convey. The extent of all the interactions
and feedback possibilities on Instagram however depends on if one’s account is set to ‘public’
or ‘private’. While technically anyone can get access to and give feedback on posts by public
accounts, the account settings of private limits an account’s content to approved followers.
Even though Instagram is public by default, these settings allows users to some extent to
control and influence their online presentation on Instagram (Caldeira 155).
According to Tarleton Gillespie most platforms are geared towards being profitable
(348). Agreeing with that, Tania Bucher and Anne Helmond argue that the affordances of most
platforms do not only relate to end-users and their activities but also to third parties such as
developers who extend the affordances offered by the platform, and advertisers who monetize
platform activities (19). Regarding the normative nature designed on social media platforms,
the affordance approach can help to understand why, when and how social media application
change, for example in branding practices and can therefore be used to investigate
Instagram’s possibilities for monetization and entrepreneurship (Treem and Leonardi 147).
This is particularly interesting under the premise that the success of Instagram discussed in
the introduction of this thesis has found to rely predominantly on the fact that the features of
the platform have been largely expanded and adjusted over the years which eventually led up
18
to Instagram’s transformation into a business platform (DeMers; Leaver et al.; Manovich 17;
See Ch. 1.2).
First and foremost, the functionality of hashtags as one of Instagram’s strongest
features has been extended from merely making content visible and categorizable within the
platform by introducing the ‘explore feed’ in 2012 (Constine “Instagram’s New Explore”). Since
then, hashtags got predominantly repurposed to influence and measure hashtag reach and
thus, overall entrepreneurial success (Carah and Shaul 73). Using Instagram for business
purposes has been further increased by allowing people to connect their account with other
social media platforms and networks and by facilitating advertising through the introduction of
the ‘sponsored post tag’ (Manovich 134). By 2013, Instagram provided a video function, which
allows users at the beginning to produce 15 second videos with filters which was later
extended to 60 seconds (Strange; Constine “Instagram Launches Stories”). This function has
been extended throughout the years, not least through the introduction of IGTV in 2018, an
independent app where users can publish up to one hour long full screen videos. Even though
IGTV is a standalone app, videos can be accessed and shared within the normal Instagram
app at the same time (Systrom). Since 2017, Instagram allows users to post multiple images
or videos within one post instead of being limited to one (Leaver et al. 9).
According to Taylor Lorenz, Instagram has changed in many ways since its launch and
has shifted from being a platform for merely sharing selected and filtered images to being “a
messy, tangled social network where photos fight with stories, IGTV, GIFs and video clips for
attention” (Lorenz). In that sense, the ‘Instagram story’ feature introduced in 2016 which allows
users to post 24 hour-lasting images and videos that are portrayed openly at the very top of
one’s home feed has been one of the far-reaching innovations on the platform (“New Ways to
Interact on Instagram”). By being vertical by default Instagram stories do not only portray a
format opposed to usual posts, but also offers a range of new possibilities for user
engagement, as for example the possibility to answer directly to these stories, either with
(emotion-)stickers or comments. With favouring immediate “in the moment” experiences,
stories have broken with previous sensations of highly selected content shared on Instagram
(Lorenz; Leaver et al.). In contrast to posts, Instagram stories allow users new aesthetic
possibilities by editing pictures directly with text or similar components such as emojis and
GIFs, but also with features such as polls, countdowns or surveys. Besides that, they can
conduct approval/response sliders through featuring the heart-eyes emoji, share music, tag
people and locations and additional information as temperature or moods. Story filters, such
as ‘boomerang’ and ‘superzooms’ as well as playful elements and animations such as dog
ears or flower crowns, allow not only more playful or fun representations instead of featuring
predominately aesthetic ones, but also allows users to direct the focus of their story and thus,
the viewers’ sensations (Leaver et al.). For verified users, Instagram provides the possibility
19
to add a ‘swipe up’ function to their stories, which is located at the bottom of the screen and
directs users to chosen websites or blogs (Instagram).To enhance sensations of immediate
and intimate presentations, users can record ‘live-videos’ through which they can interact with
their followers in real time, who can react to the stories directly through a question sticker tag
(Leaver et al.; Instagram). Beyond that, users may choose to share stories as ‘highlights’ so
that it gets archived in a separate field above one’s image feed and can be approached at any
time until the user deletes it (“New Ways to Interact on Instagram”).
What is striking here is that, stories provide extensive possibilities for what Marwick
has described as “selective posting” meaning that users carefully consider the frequency and
amount of posting and post as “posting several times in a row is disfavored” and might “over-
saturate” their followers (“Instafame” 143). Instagram stories generally encourage users to
share more content on Instagram, including “every little thing that happened in a day” (Leaver
et al.) without having the feeling of spamming or “over-posting” (Constine; Instagram). In
addition to contrasted aesthetic realizations of stories and posts, Leaver et al. argue that
“stories become a way of posting content that was shareworthy but not perhaps deserving of
permanence on the profile”. Given the relative newness of the story function, this assumption
might be confirmed when investigating the identity performances of yoga entrepreneurs but
could also show up potential differences.
2.2.2. Instagram’s Aesthetics in the Change of Time
Following Brian McNely, Instagram’s basic platform infrastructure provides similar affordances
to other popular social media platforms such as Facebook or Twitter, including a reverse
chronological timeline, asymmetric follower relationships and the possibility for express
reputation through liking and commenting features (McNely). However, Manovich has
indicated significant differences of Instagram compared to other platforms: “Twitter is for news
and links exchange, Facebook is for social communication, and Flickr is for image archiving,
Instagram is for aesthetic visual communication (41). As aforementioned, Instagram’s filter
and editing options allow for highly selective self-presentations. With a view on these features,
Leaver et al. describe the development of certain aesthetic standards and styles emerged on
Instagram as well as a general aesthetic of everyday life and situations: “The visual stakes of
any image can be heightened by strategic filter use, transforming the mundane into a more
dramatic or emotional scene” (12). Initially, the newness of Instagram’s filters was widely
perceived like a default action before posting and resulted in an exhaustive use of retro- and
vintage filter. With the development of the platform from solely being a social networking site
20
up to be a professional commercial platform for brands and professional content producer
however, Leaver et al. argue that the initial exhaustive usage of filters has been replaced by
more professional use of editing options (12). This, according to Lorenz, resulted in a specific
“carefully staged, color-corrected, glossy-looking” style of Instagram, particularly visible in
ubiquitous, perfectly arranged and edited images of avocado toast, beaches and coffee cups
that are most exemplary for the aforementioned implementations and particularly
disseminated through Instagram influencers (Lorenz). However, Lorenz further indicates that
in line with Instagram’s general ephemerality and as “every trend has a shelf life”, a new trend
emerged on Instagram over the last year targeting to present authenticity and accessibility
over apparent aesthetic, which is often referred to as “Instagram vs. reality” (Lorenz). Within
this movement, users increasingly post apparent unstaged and unflattering pictures along with
long captions thematizing emotional or personal topics such as mental illness, which is not
uncommonly used as a new marketing strategy by amplifying perceptions of authenticity and
thus, credibility into Instagram influencers and brands (Lorenz).
Given that Instagram’s platform is constantly concerned with refreshing feeds and
providing user with new image flows, users aiming to increase one’s visibility constantly must
perform particular actions and behaviours on Instagram. In their study on Instagram’s branding
culture, Carah and Shaul have emphasized that the ephemeral nature of the platform
significantly encourages attention seeking performances that are thus, “persistently
promotional in character” (72). In a similar vein, previous studies on the presentation of yoga
on Instagram highlight the platform’s possibilities for popular yoga Instagrammers to emerge,
predominantly by constructing their identities towards aggregating maximal follower bases
(Boll 39). By evaluating aforementioned theories on exclusively idealized self-presentation on
social media (Carah and Shaul; Cowans) and more recent studies on Instagram’s changed
aesthetics (Manovich; Lorenz) as well as considering Instagram stories as more recently
introduced and less extensively studied platform feature (Leaver et al), this study will
investigate on how these more recent features have affected identity performances and the
way content is shared on Instagram. Consequently, in addition to examine on how yoga
entrepreneurs perform their identity on Instagram, this study will connect those identity
performances with entrepreneurial and monetization pursuits on a growing marketplace.
21
2.3.” The Brand called You”:
Digital Entrepreneurship on Instagram
The previous part of the theoretical framework has discussed Instagram’s development from
a basic social media platform into a business platform and the impacts respective changes of
the platform had on the ways Instagram is used for identity performance. The following section
bridges the gap between identity performance and digital entrepreneurship by examining self-
branding and marketing strategies and performances on Instagram. More precisely, I discuss
how these performances can be employed for digital entrepreneurship on Instagram.
2.3.1. Influencer Marketing
Instagram brought up not only new forms for online self-presentation through its specific visual
culture discussed earlier, but also a new type of user, publicly known as “influencers”
describing commonly those users with particularly many followers on social media (Djafarova
and Trofimenko 4). Following Gandini, to “influence online” describes an individual’s ability to
affect other people in their behaviour, acting and thinking through social media (86). The term
influencer emerged from the phenomenon of “lifestyle bloggers” who built up their career by
constructing “micro-celebrity personas” and harness their medial presence and blogging
activities to promote their own businesses such as for example web shops (Abidin 3). In
contrast to celebrities in traditional mass media whose popularity is widely portrayed,
influencers are commonly “famous to a niche group of people” (Marwick “Status Update” 114).
In previous studies, scholars have described specific identity performances amongst
influencers, in means of attracting and maintaining followers as well as in the way they use
their influence for commercial pursuits (Abidin; Marwick “Instafame”; Djafarova and
Trofimenko; Banet-Weiser; Erkan; Carah and Shaul). First and foremost, Instagram allowed
the influencer phenomenon to emerge by allowing users to actively accumulate followers
without requiring following back in return (Abidin 7; Marwick “Instafame” 137). This system
resembles the phenomenon called ‘para-social relationships’ which describes the illusion of
real, face-to-face friendships created for people, for example when watching television shows
or consuming music (Marwick “Instafame” 139). Through the advent of social media this
phenomenon has taken new dimensions and shifted from evoking “para-social” feelings to
evoking “potentially social” feelings through enabling new forms of social and emotional
connections (Marwick “Instafame” 139; Baym 44). These connections unfold themselves
predominantly through the opportunity to connect with people detached from spatial and
temporal constraints (Baym 1). Within these predominantly one-sided relationships, the
influential accounts make their lives accessible to their followers as a whole community without
22
taking the individual user into consideration, while the followers in turn respond to influencer
accounts “as if he or she were a personal acquaintance” (Marwick 139). Previous research on
the relationships between popular beauty YouTubers and their audience for example has
shown that the intimate setting of the platform creates feelings of trustworthiness, closeness
and friendship (Rasmussen 280). Consequently, evoked feelings of intimacy and identification
constitute the main characteristic of influencers and micro celebrities in comparison to
traditional celebrity media figures (Rasmussen 283; Djafarova and Trofimenko 3; Khamis et
al. 7).
Beyond that, social media enables people to ascribe themselves to online
communities, which forms a significant part of one’s online identity (Baym 38). By actively
engaging in a community on social media, one automatically gives off identity cues by
outplaying lifestyle choices, which has been described as a component of building up one’s
online identity earlier in this thesis (Baym; See Ch. 2.1.3.). On Instagram, hashtag-
communities present the most dominant form of community that allows people to identify with
a particular interest, such as fitness (Tiggemann and Zaccardo; Baker and Walsh), eating
disorders (Tiggemann et al.) or sexual identity (Herrera). In cases of Instagram influencers, a
sense of community is predominantly based on content and actions shared by the respective
influencer (Seargeant and Tagg 9). Consequently, in the case of yoga entrepreneurs on
Instagram, users interested in related values and practices would be more likely to engage in
online communities maintained by those influential accounts that in return perform their online
identity based on maintaining and enhancing their community, seeing them as potential
consumers.
As already briefly mentioned, the more followers an individual has in general, the
greater is their perceived influence on social discourses (Djafarova and Trofimenko 2; Marwick
“Status Update” 96). Social media platforms do not only provide a space for sharing textual
and visual content about one’s personal life and to mobilize and build up online communities,
but also a space for engaging in commercial practices that has been widely taken advantage
from by brands using influencers as new advertisement intermediary through strategic product
placements or electronic word-mouth advertising on a greater scale by documenting personal
experiences and recommendations (Rasmussen 280; Abidin 86; See also Toffoletti and
Thorpe 15; Manovich 112). With this practice, understood as “influencer marketing”, those
who receive larger amount of attention and influence, can assimilate “authentic personal
brands” that can be employed by companies and brands to reach consumers (Hearn and
Schoenhoff 194).
Influencer marketing became a popular marketing strategy for advertisers as
influencers are more relatable to consumers than traditional advertisements. More precisely,
influencers can function as embodied presentation of the brand and assimilate trust into the
23
goods they advertise, but also evoke that followers get more attached to the influencer, than
to the goods they advertise themselves (Dittmar 12; Abidin and Thompson 468). The
mechanism behind this marketing strategy is: If a specific public figure or stereotype is
associated with a brand, consumers tend to identify more with the respective brands in means
of becoming like this desired stereotype or influencer.
Jennifer M. Whitmer argues that regarding modern market conditions, the cultural
value of a brand became more about their identity than their utility. Consequently, influencer
marketing is not only about promoting brands, but about conveying ideals of wellbeing,
happiness and beauty, or, has Dittmar describes it, about “communicating lifestyle and identity
constructions” (12). As influencer marketing emerged to present paid-off business
opportunities, attaining the status as influencer became a highly existent feature of social
media use amongst users (Marwick “Status Update” 5; Van Dijk “You have one identity” 203).
Therefore, influencers engage in self-branding practices, meaning they strategically adjust
their online appearance and identity performance to build up personal brands (Marwick
“Instafame”138).
2.3.2. Self-Branding
One of the earliest notions on self-branding was articulated by Tom Peters in the publication
The Brand called You for Fast Company in 1997 invoking to create a unique and dynamic
brand in order to be outstanding at the labour market (Peters; Khamis et. al 192). In line with
that, Wee and Brooks define that in self-branding practices “the actor is expected to present
a self that is constantly working on itself, to better itself and its own relationships with others,
all the while demonstrating that its behaviours are reflections of an authentically unique
personality” (56). Similarly, Marwick defines self-branding as a form of self-presentation relying
on perceiving oneself as a consumer product and selling this image as a product to others
(166). Self-branding has been discussed predominately in social media as well as in marketing
contexts. For marketing, self-branding is according to Gandini “a device for self-promotion for
the pursuit of self-realization in a context that reifies entrepreneurialism as the main ideological
stance” (124). In social media environments, self-branding practices describe investments in
social relationships and online performances promising a potential for fame and celebrity
through attention and reputation (Gandini 124; Khamis et. al 196). These practices are not
only rewarded with personal attention affirmation by the social media audiences, but also with
economic or social benefits (Khamis et. al 196). By combining social media use with
entrepreneurial pursuits, social media users are potentially able to monetize and commodify
their identity through social media platforms (Abidin and Thompson 468).
24
Extensive research has found that portraying exclusively appealing and aesthetic
images is crucial within Instagram’s influencers marketing economy (Toffoletti and Thorpe 13;
Marwick “Instafame” 156). Studies retrieved for this thesis have shown that especially
individuals maintaining wellness and health related Instagram accounts perform their online
identity mainly through body representation the presentation of white, thin and aesthetic body
types, such as athletes (Smith or Sanderson) or yoga bloggers (Cowans). Other studies have
shown that this phenomenon accounts not only for female accounts, but also for male
accounts (Tiggemann and Zaccardo; Toffoletti and Thorpe). In line with that, previous research
on female cover images of established yoga print magazines has examined the visual
representations of the body as agency for the fulfilment of general ideals on the market with
wellness, health and fitness (Webb et al. 93).
According to Crystal Abidin, with Instagram’s development into a marketing platform,
especially images received high commercial value (3). In other words: Presenting certain
image styles and types became a major determinant for attention on Instagram’s image-based
ephemeral platform (Toffoletti and Thorpe 308; Carah and Shaul 72; Dobscha 103). In that
sense, according to Sarah Banet-Weiser, some bodies are for example more brandable than
other bodies, all depending on the specific audience's perception of social codes of desire and
desirable femininity (58). Interesting for this study is that previous studies have shown that
yoga today is commonly associated with physical fitness and aesthetic and resulting from this,
overall well-being, happiness and health (Jain 78; Boll 40). To bridge the gap between body
representation, yoga as a lifestyle and self-branding, Carah and Shaul’s implementation that
Instagram enables “endless loops of body work that both produce forms of calculable attention
and embed the construction of the self within market processes” comes into play (73). Given
that the phenomenon of body-centred selective self-presentation and self-branding in online
environments have been observed remarkably more frequently in female social media
practices, it has been described as “postfeminist sensibility” and linked to neoliberal values
(Gill; Duffy and Hund; Banet-Weiser “Keynote Address”; Liu and Suh). According to Michel
Foucault, the neoliberal subject constantly works on improving him or herself and calculates
invested work and profits through self-branding strategies, predominately by portraying
narratives of free choice, autonomy and individualism (226). By drawing on several studies on
contemporary social media production, Duffy and Hund argue that the ideals of individualism,
creative autonomy, authenticity and self-branding explain the narratives and forms of
gendered social media production that have emerged in the recent years (3). Despite women
tend to portray themselves in independent and feminist attitudes, they are still bound to certain
neoliberal guidelines in which for example presenting an attractive body is seen as key
sources of female identity (Liu and Suh 18; Gill 149; Fitzsimmons 8).
25
Taken Instagram’s public accessibility and a heightened presence of self-love and
“body positivity movements” (Cwynar-Horta 37) as well as previously discussed “Instagram
vs. reality” discourses into consideration (See Ch. 2.2.2), the aforementioned studies indicate
that despite social media providing users with the possibility to take potentially more control
over their online self-presentation, identity performances on Instagram still occur
predominantly through idealized body presentation and aesthetic and sexual attributes which
portrays normative and stereotypical gender images in both, professional as well as user-
generated content (Gurrieri & Drenten 103). Consequently, this research is interested into
potential alternative body representation of self-curated images on Instagram and its
connection to marketing purposes and monetization and will show how identity performances
and self-branding strategies are entangled on Instagram to realize entrepreneurial pursuits on
the contemporary wellness market.
2.3.3. Entrepreneurship on The Spiritual Marketplace
The rise of new media has manifested itself not only in people’s everyday life and
communication but has also been the subject of study of several scholars about the impacts
it had on work cultures (Duffy; Duffy and Hund; Drenten et al.). Facilitated through social media
a whole new archetype of new media workers emerged over the last decade who “seemingly
make a living from their passion projects” (Duffy and Wissinger 4655). In addition to influencer
practices, Instagram became a tool for individual users to openly portray and promote their
businesses or freelance work (Manovich 126). Social media platforms redefined the traditional
understanding of consumer and producer by providing users a low-cost infrastructure to create
online content and, subsequently, to visualize themselves as self-employed workers and
entrepreneurs on the platform (Drenten et al. 21; Gregory 214). Likewise, several scholars
have evaluated that the market is driven by the stance that one’s job should not seem like
work, more likely, it has to be compatible with one’s “love” and “passion”, and is this dominated
by mantras like “Do What You Love” (Duffy 442) and a highly consistently outplayed, almost
flaunted “fuck you money” attitude (Marwick “Status Update” 80).
According to Marwick, the new affordances provided by social media on the neoliberal
market have led to the stance that self-employed entrepreneurship is taking up the highest
status within the creative and new media work cultures (“Status Update” 80). In a similar vein,
Brooke Duffy and Emily Hund argue that this has led to the aspiration of a whole new class of
creative workers that perform their online identity like “creative self-enterprises” (1; Duffy 442).
By performing what Duffy terms “aspirational labour” (446) these workers invest time, energy
26
and resources of themselves and commit themselves fully to their work in means of being
rewarded for their work at some point, even though in percentage terms only a few individuals
eventually become successful through social media influencer or entrepreneurship activities
(Duffy 454). Consequently, the symbiosis of neoliberal market logics and social media made
it possible for individuals to transform workers into self-regulated and entrepreneurial
commodities (Gill 26; Marwick “Status Update” 167).
One of the key conditions for building up a successful self-brand has been examined
by several scholars as authenticity, a concept that is associated with the idea of presenting a
true and actual self and has gotten increasing interest in marketing and social media
discourses (Duffy and Hund 3; Khamis et al. 203; Marwick “Status Update” 17; Duffy 447;
Marom 22). Following Gregory, a huge sector on social media is taken by a “spiritual
marketplace” in which users build up authentic online personas and self-brands in the first
place by engaging actively in online conversations and by documenting ones “‘authentic’ daily
life” (214). Agreeing with that, Marwick argues that authenticity is conveyed through
consistency: “authenticity is judged over time, in that people’s authenticity is determined by
comparing their current actions against their past for consistency” (“Status Update” 120) which
aligns with earlier implementations by Goffman about an expected consistency between
appearance and manner for desired impression management (Goffman 16). Consequently,
regarding performances of Instagram influencers, authenticity refers to an individual’s motifs
and motivations, relying on their personal passions and beliefs and the portrayal of one’s
“hidden inner life” (Marwick “Status Update” 120). Aligned with that, Marom points out that the
concept of authenticity is often strongly associated with the idea of living a “meaningful life”
(Marom 22). In a similar vein, Helga Dittmar argues that in our contemporary society,
consumers can be “thought of as identity-seekers” (2). Therefore, consumers strive to invest
into goods that are linked to desired attributes of wellbeing and physical attractiveness,
embodied by those promoting those goods (Dittmar 2). This phenomenon strongly relies on
the aforementioned implementations about embodied lifestyle presentations by social media
personas and its effects on marketing pursuits and links to Sarah Banet-Weiser’s observations
of a general “spiritualization of the corporate system” in which investments in self-care are
highly valued as “buying good is being good” (“Authentic” 176).
Connecting the contemporary ideals of turning one’s passion into a career with the
raised desires for wellness and mindfulness discussed in the introduction of this thesis, this
market provides fruitful opportunities for entrepreneurship (Khamis et al. 202; Marwick “Status
Update” 193; Duffy 452). This is mainly based on the fact that Instagram has been
characterized as an intermediary for professional as well as ordinary users to create content
and to carry out consumerism and advertising activities (Gillespie 351). Consequently,
Instagram has found to be especially dominated by self-proclaimed wellness and fitness gurus
27
selling their expertise by linking to various coaching and consulting programs, books or other
products and services by themselves or related brands (Gregory 209). According to Gregory,
the rise of the spiritual marketplace is mainly based on the contemporary spirit that people
increasingly invest money and time for personal care, health and wellbeing. This has given
rise to self-appointed “life coaches” offering guidance to achieve respective life improvements
(211). With “going pro” or taking the step from “blog to brand”, Gregory describes a neoliberal
spirit to rather brand themselves instead of remaining merely a brand strategy. Thus, she
indicates a distinction between merely creating online content and being a self-employed
“spiritual entrepreneur” (211).
In line with Instagram’s functionality as a powerful tool for self-presentation (Baker and
Walsh; Smith and Sanderson; Döring), previous studies have concluded that yoga content on
Instagram demonstrate predominately images of white, thin and female yoga practitioners
(Cowans; Jain). In these studies, however, the user behind these representations and their
potential entrepreneurial purposes has not been taken into consideration - as to if the publisher
of the respective images was a yoga teacher, an owner of a yoga clothing brand or merely a
passionate or occasional practitioner (Cwynar Horta 41). Consequently, this study is interested
in how ‘spiritual’ or ‘wellness entrepreneurs’, in this case yoga entrepreneurs, present
themselves on Instagram and more specifically, how Instagram is used as a tool for digital
entrepreneurship and self-employment on an emerging market with wellness, health and
mindfulness.
28
CHAPTER 3: METHODOLOGY
3.1. Selecting accounts
This research focuses on individual identity performances with users clearly indicating that
yoga comprises a major part of their business, which they promote on Instagram. A huge
number of Instagram accounts are concerned with topics related to wellness, wellbeing, fitness
and health, within which the publication of occasional or regular yoga-related content is highly
visible. To detect accounts that make a living with the aid of Instagram a selection process of
different steps was conducted to form a final and comprehensive data corpus for the following
analysis. Consequently, several articles of yoga- and lifestyle-related online journals such as
Yoga Journal or doyouyoga.com were searched through in order to find matching accounts2.
From there, Instagram’s feature of recommending similar accounts was used as a ‘snowballing
system’ to discover more potential accounts. However, only accounts with at least 100.000
followers were included as this indicates that those accountholders realized successful
entrepreneurship based on their Instagram performances and are thus most representative
for this study. Additionally, only accounts that are clearly maintained by individual people were
included. This was evaluated by a mentioning by one of the yoga-related journals or webpages
as well as through a ‘verified badge’ which confirms that the profile belongs to a real person
(Instagram Help Center). To differentiate yoga entrepreneurs from users that merely practice
yoga as a hobby a close-reading of the individual account’s ‘bio’- the space at the very top of
a profile- was conducted include only those individuals that actively target to use Instagram
as a monetization tool or platform to make business in any way. Therefore, it was mandatory
that the accounts have set their profile on ‘public’, meaning that they consciously want their
profile to be accessible and visible for everyone. As a last selection criterion, only accounts
publishing their content in English were included into the data set. This does not only serve to
create a common ground for the research, but also indicates the user's intention to make their
content accessible to a larger audience, based on the language’s wide reach, detached from
any spatial or temporal constraints.
2 Articles retrieved for the selection process were for example “6 Most Inspiring Yogis on Instagram This Week” (Yoga Journal) or “10 Instagram Yogis You Should Follow” (doyouyoga.com).
29
Having set the selection criteria, I constructed a total list of about 50 Instagram
accounts. After eliminating accounts not matching the mentioned criteria, the list was narrowed
down to ten individual accounts, within which seven belong to female users and the other three
belonging to male users. This distribution is based on the fact that yoga was in its origins
reserved as a practice for men but is today perceived as an almost exclusively female practice
(Boll 21). However, Boll argues that the yoga market is still marked by patriarchal structures
through a significant contradiction between business-holders and practitioners given that more
yoga-related businesses such as popular clothing and equipment brands - popular examples
would be Manduka or Lululemon- belong to men (26-27). Consequently, even though the
selection process provided more female Instagram accounts, more male yoga entrepreneur
accounts than initially expected were found, which might rely on the fact that this study focuses
on yoga entrepreneurs instead of merely practitioners. Consequently, the decision to include
relational less male accounts than female accounts was made in order to maintain the general
gender evaluation of yoga entrepreneur accounts on Instagram, but was still perceived as
promising for discovering comprehensive results and interesting potential differences in their
identity performances, which might explain widespread stances and understandings of the
modern yoga market.
3.2. Chosen accounts
The chosen accounts for this study are as follows: @yoga_girl, @kinoyoga, @sjanaelise,
@kathrynbudig, @koyawebb, @beachyogagirl, @laurasykora for the female accounts as well
as the male accounts @carsonclaycalhoun, @patrickbeach and @dylanwerneryoga.
The selection process has already revealed an analysis of the account’s profiles as
initial step to set up the methodology for this research. This aligns with boyd’s notion on “writing
oneself into being” - meaning that profile descriptions present a space for people in which they
can explicitly describe what they want to present to others in the first place (119). In their profile
descriptions, the accounts have presented yoga entrepreneurship through “explicit identity
statements” in form of “autobiographic descriptions” revealing their conscious intention of how
they want to be categorized by others as well as “implicit identity statements” by presenting
their affiliation to yoga throughout profile pictures and descriptions (Zhao et al. 1820). More
precisely, the self-descriptions of users in their individual bios, including profile picture,
username and description, serve as “first impression” identifier of how the respective accounts
want to be initially perceived and situated by their audience (Goffman 22). To provide a base
and context knowledge for the following analysis on the respective accounts’ profiles and their
shared content, short introductions of each account will be given in the first instance.
30
username follower (May 2019)
bio
@yoga_girl
2,1m Rachel Brathen Brand Yoga Girl. Mom. Creator of #yogaeverydamnday
❤️
JOIN OUR YOGA RETREATS + TEACHER TRAININGS! → www.yogagirl.com
☀️ linkin.bio/yoga_girl
@beachyogagirl
1m Kerri Verna Fitness Coach Get a strong #core, practice #yoga, & learn to
#handstand with me!🙌🏻⠀
Get my Playbook app!🤳🏻⠀
#vegan 🌱 🧘🏼♀️ @kerrivernatraining
Train👇🏻🔗 beachyogagirl.com
@koyawebb
885k 💗Koya Webb💗 Public Figure Founder @GetLovedUp
📚 Author “Let Your Fears Make You Fierce”
🤸🏾♀️500hr E-RYT Yoga+Meditation
🌴Los Angeles, CA
💃🏾Online Training/Eco Vegan Lifestyle linktr.ee/koyawebb
@kathrynbudig
224k Kathryn Budig
🎧:@freecookiespodcast
🧘🏼♀️:@yogaglo
📚:Aim True + Big Book of Yoga
👩🏼🍳:#aimtruekitchen
💄:@vapourbeauty Ethereal Collection
👗:kb x @kiragraceyoga: tinyurl.com/yxo7a7t4
@laurasykora 1,2m Laura Kasperzak
31
Public Figure Wife, Mother, Handstand Addict, Dance Mom, Great Dane FurMom, Gym Junkie, #YogaTeacher •E-RYT200•
@kinoyoga
1,1m Kino MacGregor
Author, Beachbum, Yogi 💕
@miamilifecenter @omstarsofficial ⚡ Workshops: Guatemala, Arizona, Portland
Online Classes Only at Omstars.com 🧘♀️ linktr.ee/kinoyoga
@patrickbeach
434k patrick beach creator of @awakeningyogaacademy
owner @communeyoga seattle now open😊✌🏼
for all workshops and teacher trainings! 🔽 www.patrickbeach.com
@dykanwerneryoga
607k Dylan Werner Fitness coach Upcoming workshops
April 26th-28th London 🇬🇧
Sept 13th-15th Milan 🇮🇹
Sept 20th-22nd Nürnberg 🇩🇪 @alo.moves NEW SERIES!!! BEGINNER
FLEXIBILITY ⬇️ alomov.es/beginner-flexibility
@carsonclaycalhoun
126k Carson Calhoun | Strong Yoga Coach Yoga, Handstands, Weights, Jokes. Next up: Mexico City, Denver, Chicago, DC, VA, Boston, London, Dublin, Prague, Zurich, Berlin, SLC, Fishkill, EPTX linktr.ee/carsonclaycalhoun
Table 1: yoga entrepreneurs Instagram accounts (profile pictures, bio descriptions and
follower counts retrieved from Instagram on 25 May 2019).
32
Holding more than two million followers, @yoga_girl by Rachel Brathen is the commonly most
popular yoga instagrammer in the current yoga online world (Boll 45). In her profile bio the
yoga instructor living on Aruba describes herself as “Yoga Girl. Mom. Creator of
#yogaeverydamnday” and offers a linktree to her various businesses, ranging from yoga
retreats and trainings up to her online shop, podcast and blog. The account @kythrynbudig is
run by an American yoga teacher, podcast producer, author and designer. In her bio she links
her respective businesses as well as her designs and collaborations for clothing and cosmetic
lines. @kinoyoga is the account of a yoga instructor, author and co-founder of a yoga studio
in Miami as well as Omstars, the first yoga TV network. Despite linking to these businesses in
her bio, she offers a linktree providing direct access to her various workshops and classes.
@laurasykora is run by “Wife, Mother, #Handstand Addict [and…] #Yoga Teacher”.
@sjanaelise provides their followers mostly with images of herself performing yoga postures
on the beach and links in her bio to her YouTube Channel and advertises her yoga program:
“Find my BAM yoga program in the SWEAT app”. @koyawebb is run by a yoga teacher, author
and founder of the wellness app @getlovedup from Los Angeles. She links to her classes and
programs relating “Eco Vegan Lifestyle.” @beachyogagirl is the account of Kerri Verna, a yoga
instructor and fitness trainer. In her bio she links to her training account @kerrivernatraining
as well as her website with “all my stuff”, ranging from her eBook up to her own app for yoga
equipment and programs.
The account @dylanwerneryoga uses the space in his bio to promote his YouTube
channel as well workshops about which users can find “details on my website.” The account
@patrickbeach is run “creator of @awakeningyogaacademy” and “owner of @communeyoga”
and provides access to his workshops and trainings on his website as well as the yoga platform
alomoves. @carsonclaycalhoun is owned by a yoga teacher specialized in giving workshops
all around the world, who provides a linktree giving access to his various classes, yoga teacher
trainings and workshops.
3.3. Post Analysis
Although Camilla Vásquez has stated that online identity is commonly studied through the
analysis of user profiles (6), this research will go beyond studying the clearly given identity
statements. By taking on-going identity performances through sharing visual and textual
content into consideration, I argue that the outlined ideas of successful entrepreneurship,
authenticity and self-branding on social media could be observed and contextualized more
33
efficiently. Therefore, I decided to analyse the most recent 20 posts of each account
backwards as at 10:00 am (Amsterdam time) on the 6 April 2019.
A coding procedure was applied for the images posted on Instagram in which each
image counts as one unit. The coding scheme was established throughout the theoretical
framework and was inspired by Goffman’ work on gender representation in traditional
advertisements (1979) and his adaptation by following scholars such as Kang (1997) who
indicated the categories “body display” in which women are predominantly represented in
sexualized images as well as “independence” describing a seemingly more empowered
representation of women as well as Smith and Sanderson’s work on athlete's self-presentation
and Cowans study on the presentation of yoga-related images on Instagram, which both found
that respective self-presentation mainly occurs through body display and physical
presentations (Cowans 37; Smith and Sanderson 354). Consequently, each image of the 20
posts was first classified into the initial coding categories selfies, yoga videos, presentation of
yoga poses, normative body types, body display, entrepreneurial cues, outdoor settings and
social scenes that were redefined throughout the analysis.
While a content analysis predominantly shows how frequently certain images, words
and themes occurs, it does not provide much insight about the respective contexts of the
images. Despite Instagram is in the first place a visual platform, I argue that taking captions
as textual complement into consideration provide more profound results for how the accounts
argue, promote and contextualize their visual content, especially within the double sidedness
of achieving successful online entrepreneurship while simultaneously maintaining authentic
and desirable self-presentations. On the first sight, the majority of yoga-related Instagram
posts present images or short videos of yoga postures with appealing backgrounds such as
ocean settings accompanied by captions portraying for example longer texts about one’s
feelings or thoughts motivational quotes. As being discussed by Smith and Sanderson, textual
elements might neither necessarily reflect the content of visual images nor can visual coding
criteria be applied to textual content (349). Consequently, a more reflexive and interpretative
approach seems to be a more efficient option for this research. Following Braun and Clarke,
the advantages of this form of content analysis are based on its flexibility to allow researchers
to search for meaning and pattern instead of merely reading through given data (4).
Consequently, I conducted a textual qualitative analysis to discover potential themes and
pattern provided through the image’s captions. In contrast to quantitative analysis, qualitative
research seeks to understand a phenomenon through capturing and analysing it through
closer observations or case studies (Yilmaz 313).
To carry out this research, a grounded theory approach for the content analysis of the
captions was implemented. According to Corbin and Strauss, grounded theory described the
“identification and integration of categories of meaning from data” (70). Throughout the data
34
collection, grounded theory served as a guideline in identifying numerous categories, creating
links between categories, and establishing a relationship between categories (Glaser and
Strauss 1967; Corbin and Strauss 70). Data for grounded theory can be retrieved from various
sources, simply aiming to shed light on a research question (Corbin and Strauss 5). Following
Corbin and Strauss, grounded theory aims not only to point out conditions, but also
emphasizes how actors respond to changing conditions and to the consequences of their
actions (5). Beyond that, grounded theory relies on the idea that in addition to previous studies
the researcher’s existing knowledge influences criteria selection significantly. Consequently,
this approach is a promising choice for the nature of this research. Inspired by Smith and
Sanderson’s approach, I read through all the captions of the 200 selected images and built up
striking and emerging categories for identity performance to work with. Those a priori defined
categories were based on key themes of the theoretical framework, given that these points
will be visible within the respective captions and were more exploratory and adaptable in their
nature and allowed for refinements, additions and adjustments during the more detailed close-
reading process of the analysis. The a priori emergent categories for the caption analysis were
gratitude, authenticity, self-branding promotion, self-love, self-development, yoga as a passion
and lifestyle and brand endorsement. Eventually, the analysis of the visual and the textual
content were combined into general emerging themes based on the theoretical framework and
research question of this study which are the presentation of yoga, identity performance,
business purposes and the presentation of authenticity.
3.4. Story analysis
As discussed before, the ephemeral nature of Instagram stories allows users potentially for
“less filtered” content or “behind the scenes” presentation of the images posted in their image
feed (Amâncio 26). According to Marina Amâncio, Instagram stories serve users to show what
is happening at the immediate and exact moment of production, in order to provide more “real-
time experiences” (82). Consequently, a significant feature of Instagram stories has found to
be users giving followers self-contained narratives that inform and update about one’s life,
aiming to set off and enhance attention and interactions within one’s online community
(Amâncio 54). While this previous research focused merely on the use of Instagram stories
for digital storytelling, it has not been examined yet how this relatively new and highly used
feature can be used for entrepreneurial purposes.
Given that the ten Instagram accounts conducted for this study produce rather high
amounts of content in their stories, all their story performances will be captured over a time
period of three days. As most of the stories published by the respective accounts consist of
35
short videos instead of images, simply taking screenshots of the stories would not be sufficient
for capturing the content. Therefore, the free and publicly available online tool storiesig.com
created by the Instagram user @jlobitu allowed to download users Instagram stories over a
period of 24 hours directly to a PC, Mac or phone. Consequently, all stories published from 2
and 6 April 2019 were captured for the analysis. Given that these days overlapped with the
posting performances analysed in previous steps, it seemed promising to detect potential
similarities and differences between the identity performances in the posts and in the stories
of the respective accounts. Therefore, the emergent themes of the post analysis - the
presentation of yoga, identity performance, business purposes and the presentation of
authenticity - serve as framework for the story analysis, with the goal to detect potential
similarities or differences not only content-wise, but also regarding the way of use for
entrepreneurial pursuits.
36
CHAPTER 4: FINDINGS
Studying the visual and textual content shared by the selected accounts allows to define a
certain representation of how yoga is presented and carried out as a business through
Instagram’s platform. While a content analysis of posts shared on Instagram gives on the one
hand insight into the specific type of imageries shared by the entrepreneurs, it helps on the
other hand in understanding the respective contexts and narratives of the posts through a
textual analysis of captions accompanying the images. Comparing the results of the post
analysis with Instagram’s more recent story feature provides additional insights about how
Instagram is used for entrepreneurial pursuits. Furthermore, as outlined in the theoretical
framework for this study, the information given in one’s profile bio, including a profile picture,
username and description, serve as “first impression” and provides indications for how one’s
online identity was intended to be perceived by others and how Instagram is used specifically
in the context of presenting an authentic self-brand (Goffman 22).
4.1. First impressions: username, profile picture and bio
Similar patterns were found for the initial profile set up amongst the accounts that included
usernames and profile pictures as two major elements for initial self-presentation. Eight out of
the ten accounts used their real names as username, either only their first name (@kinoyoga)
or their first name and surname. Only two of the accounts did not use their names in their
username but directed it clearly to yoga instead (@yoga_girl and @beachyogagirl). However,
all of them indicate their real names at the top of their bio. Seven of the accounts used profile
pictures in which they perform yoga postures as given the audience an initial impression of
themselves. The remaining three accounts however used close-up and clearly visible pictures
of their faces which makes them possibly more recognizable as ‘brand’.
Similarly, most of the accounts used a feature available within Instagram’s ‘business
tools’ to influence strategically how they are categorized by the audience which matches
aforementioned implementations about influencer marketing and digital entrepreneurship on
Instagram (See Ch. 2.3). @yoga_girl has categorized her account as ‘brand’, @koyawebb,
@laurasykora and @sjanaelise as ‘public figures’, @dylanwerneryoga, @carsonclaycalhoun
and @beachyogagirl as ‘coaches’. For the ones not labelling their accounts as businesses
(@kathrynbudig, @patrickbeach, @kinoyoga) it can be added that here they link to business-
37
related Instagram pages in their bio such as @kathrynbudig’s podcast page
@freecookiespodcast or @patrickbeach’s account @communeyoga. However, given that this
study focuses on individual identity performances for entrepreneurship, these additional
accounts will not be taken further into consideration.
Yoga as a business has found to be a dominant theme amongst the accounts’ bio
descriptions. In general, all of them except @laurasykora link to a range of other businesses,
such as websites (@yoga_girl, @patrickbeach), podcasts (@kathrynbudig), clothing lines
(@kathrynbudig), other social media platforms (@sjanaelise) or apps (@koyawebb).
Therefore, they often provide ‘linktrees’3 to give easy access to programs or online shops
(@kinoyoga, @carsonclaycalhoun, @dylanwerneryoga). This was commonly accompanied
with clear invitations such as “train with me” or “join our classes” (@yoga_girl,
@beachyogagirl, @sjanaelise, @dylanwerneryoga, @carsonclaycalhoun, @kinoyoga,
@koyawebb). Furthermore, they either describe themselves as business holders in the first
place, for example “founder of @awakeningyogaacademy” (@patrickbeach) or emphasize
their expertise, for example “#yoga teacher E-RYT200” (@laurasykora), “500hr E-RYT
Yoga/Meditation” (@koyawebb).
The option to save Instagram stories as highlights at the bottom part of the bio was
used to different extents. In general, while all the female accounts provide story highlights, for
the male accounts only @dylanwerneryoga only saved one story. In general, the story
highlights were used to provide permanent, categorized and easy to be accessed content,
such as information about products and programs, links to it as well as different categories
regarding personal topics such as a travel or food documentations.
4.2. Post analysis
After having provided insights about how the general affordances of Instagram’s platform are
used to situate first impressions of one’s online identity and narrative, the analysis will focus
further on identity performances based on continuous sharing of contents. Selecting the last
20 posts of the ten chosen accounts provided a total dataset of 200 posts, which resulted in
255 single images and videos based on Instagram’s function to post multiple images and video
sequences within one post and naturally 200 textual captions.
The distribution of posted images and videos is the following: 34 for @yoga_girl, 33 for
@sjanaelise, 23 for @beachyogagirl, 20 each for @kinoyoga and @koyawebb, 23 for
@laurasykora, 28 for @kathrynbudig, 21 for @patrickbeach, 25 for @dylanwerneryoga and
3 Linktree is a free tool advertising to optimize Instagram traffic by allowing specifically bloggers and entrepreneurs to “get one bio link to house all the content you’re driving followers to” (Linktree)
38
28 for @carsonclaycalhoun. Out of the 255 image and video units 57 are videos or short
sequences shared from IGTV videos, 177 photographs, additionally ten selfies, four images
showing text on a screen, five screenshots used as advertisements as well as two memes.
The individual account holders were the main subject in 54 out of the 57 videos and in 178 out
of the 187 photographs or more precisely, in 232 out of the total 255 images and videos. In
order to conclude these results, the screenshots of each video and the content portrayed in it
on the first sight was treated as an image.
In 56,50% of all posts (113 out of 200) the hashtag feature was used, which however
varied between the accounts. Some accounts, such as @carsonclaycalhoun (1x) or
@dylanwerneryoga (3x) made almost no use of the feature, while some used it occasionally,
as for example @laurasykora (6x) or @yogagirl (11x) or constantly, as for example
@patrickbeach (20x), @beachyogagirl (20x) or @kathrynbudig (17x). The analysis of the
visual and textual content of the 200 posts have shown emerged, recurring patterns and
themes which will be portrayed and examined more closely in the following thematic analysis.
These themes are the presentation of yoga, identity performance, business purposes and the
presentation of authenticity.
.
4.2.1. The Presentation of Yoga
In her research on the Western imagination of yoga, Boll has found that on social media yoga
is particularly represented through postures, so-called asanas as “without featuring asana, an
Instagram account would not be linked in any way to yoga” (42). In line with that, this study on
yoga entrepreneurs on Instagram has shown that visually, 41,18% of all posted images and
videos present the account holders performing almost exclusively advanced yoga postures
such as handstands or arm balances (See fig.1). Together with images presenting workshop
or yoga class situations (See fig. 2), a total of 44,71% of all images and videos could be on
the first sight associated and connected with yoga. Similarly, 63,16% of the videos show the
account holder performing yoga. However, the behaviour of posting yoga-related images
varies among the accounts. While @yoga_girl has only one post in which she is performing
yoga, like @kathrynbudig (4x) or @koyawebb (5x), other accounts have almost all their
images representing yoga, such as for example @kinoyoga (19x), @dylanwerneryoga (23x)
or laurasykora (18x). Align with that, 41,18% images and videos show the account holders
wearing yoga clothes.
39
Fig.1: Example for an advanced yoga posture” by @kinoyoga.
Fig. 2: Example for a yoga workshop/class situation image by @carsonclaycalhoun.
By contrast, only six of the accounts used hashtags clearly related to yoga and only two of the
accounts used yoga-related hashtags more constantly. More precisely, whereas @kinoyoga
(20x) and @patrickbeach (15x) have been found to use yoga-related hashtags such as
“#yogini”, “#yogaflow” or “yogapractice” in the majority of their posts, other accounts used
respective hashtags only sporadically (@beachyogagirl 5x; @laurasykora 1x) or not at all
(@koyawebb; @carsonclaycalhoun). @kathrynbudig and @yoga_girl used yoga-identifying
hashtags only in posts that directly represented them performing yoga, which occurred only in
one post for both accounts.
40
Thematically, yoga was presented in different ways throughout the posts. First, it was
highlighted continuously through the importance of physical practice under the wider goal of
self-love and well-being, especially in view of the body as for example in @yoga_girl’s caption
“love your body, move your body” or @sjanaelise’s caption “Find the movement you enjoy -
the movement your body and mind love and crave, and do that”. Second, yoga has found to
be emphasized as a concept that moves beyond its physical appearance though postures to
be the reflection of a spiritual and profound mindset, and is expressed predominantly through
self-written texts accompanying the presentation of yoga in images, such as for example in
@kinoyoga’s captions “If you come to the practice of yoga and think it’s just about some poses
you will find out that we are seekers on an ancient path of awakening” as well as in a post by
@dylanwerneryoga saying “for me, and I know for many others, yoga is a word that we use
to describe our journey to understand the self [...] This is how I define yoga.”
While the visual presentation of yoga is based on portraying aesthetic images of yoga
asanas, traditional principles of yoga were not thematized explicitly within the captions.
Instead, the captions contextualize yoga as a lifestyle and path of self-development to overall
fulfilment and wellbeing. This was expressed dominantly through long inspirational self-written
texts in the captions such as: “If you are one, meaning whole and complete, then there is
nothing that you can add or take away that will change you from being you”
(@dylanwerneryoga) or “Let it all come. Let it all unfold. You are in the right place”
(@yoga_girl) so that happiness, love and self-love can be experienced as ultimate goals: “only
those willing to risk everything truly experience the totality of love” (@kinoyoga) or “you are
becoming that which you have always been. You will discover not some new shiny self, but
an eternal self that glimmers with the pure light of timeless love” (@kinoyoga). However, there
were some exceptions found to that finding. For example, @dylanwerneryoga used the
hashtag “#svadyaya” meaning self-study (Newlyn) once, while @kinoyoga dedicated one post
to the description of the yoga posture yoganidrasana and another post to the collaboration
with her teacher and yoga grandmaster - which however, was accompanied with a give-away
and thus, promotional content. In general, content directly connected to ancient principles was
found to be more neglectable in proportion and only @dylanwerneryoga thematized
sensations about the shift from traditional to modern yoga in one of his posts: “The face of
yoga has changed as well as its practitioners [...] Yoga is an ancient system, but very little that
we do today looks anything like that system”.
41
4.2.2. Identity Performance
In the theoretical framework of this study, it has been discussed that the body serves as a
major tool for self-presentation and identity performance on social media. The analysis of the
ten accounts has taken the presentation of the respective bodies in revealing outfits, such as
no shirts for males and only wearing a bikini for females, as well as the body being the clear
focal point of the image as indication for identity performance through body display. In total,
30,98% of the images have found to present body display through clothing choices. This has
been found in 74,37% of the male images, but only in 13,26% of the female images (See table
2 for detailed distribution).
However, the focalization of fit and thin body types was a dominant theme in the
images and videos portraying yoga and has been found in most of the images portraying body
display through outfit choices and additionally in yoga-centred images and videos. In total,
more than half of the images and videos (51,37%) had their focus on the presentation of
bodies. The distribution of male and female images and videos however has shown interesting
results: While only 41,44% of the female images were found to focus predominantly on thin
and fit body presentation, this was the case for 77,03% of the male images (See table 2 for
detailed distribution).
account name body display (shirtless/bikini)
normative body type (thin/fit)
outdoor- setting
family, friends, pets
@yoga_girl 1 2 15 21
@beachyogagirl 1 10 4 1
@sjanaelise 9 18 25 13
@kathrynbudig 0 3 2 2
@koyawebb 1 8 4 0
@laurasykora 0 17 12 11
@kinoyoga 12 17 16 0
@patrickbeach 12 13 8 7
@dylanwerneryoga 23 23 15 1
@carsonclaycalhoun 20 21 6 6
Table 2: Detailed distribution of image coding categories amongst the accounts (n/255).
42
Identity performance through lifestyle and lifestyle choices was found to be a dominant theme
for the accounts. Almost half of the images and videos were found to feature outdoor setting,
more precisely beach and ocean settings (41,96%; See table 2 for detailed distribution). Align
with that, themes such as travelling, summer, sun and beach adoration were recurring in the
accompanying captions. For example, @sjanaelise contextualized her posts with captions
such as “I pray the sun never stops kissing my skin” or “My favourite place to be... in your
arms, by the sea ✨”, while @kinoyoga wrote “Life is a Dream — Bondi Beach Yoga” or “Life
is better in the sun [...] If I haven’t felt the warmth on my skin, or the salty ocean breeze I feel
like I’m not myself”, or @patrickbeach “sunny days always make handstand a little bit more
fun!”
The importance of the body has also found to be a dominant theme in the posts
captions, not only in relation to yoga, but also in connection to one’s lifestyle, mindset and
thus, self-identity. In general, in particular for the female yoga entrepreneurs, the body was
connected with diet choices such as veganism and wellness, while male entrepreneurs
highlighted exclusively physical benefits through the yoga lifestyle. For example, @yoga_girl
wrote “Entering my third week of raw food, no sugar, no grains, no processed food of any kind.
[...] I have a very healthy body image. I want to inspire self love!”, @koyawebb indicated “the
answer is never numbing the pain with too much processed food, drugs, alcohol or anything
that is damaging to the body” while @patrickbeach wrote “steady practice leads to steady
improvements over time.”
Beyond that, they contextualized their own experiences in means of helping and
inspiring other. For example in the cases of @carsonclaycalhoun: “Go to the gym and hit
some squats!” or @beachyogagirl: “I struggled with my self esteem and I always hated my
body [...] Later in life (age 27) I came to find my passion in life ~ helping others find freedom
in their bodies, minds, and hearts”. In that sense, body, wellness- and health related topics
have found to be contextualized as ‘life advices’ through aforementioned long and profound
captions, as for example in @kinoyoga’s caption “Do what you love [...] but first [...] learn to
love yourself with a love that is not predicated on good outcomes, a love that is unconditional”,
@dylanwerneryoga’s caption “the end of every journey is the end, but it is the end that gives
the journey meaning” or @sjanaelise’s caption “If you want to find happiness, be happiness.
If you want to find love, be love.”
A dominant theme for identity performance has found to be the use of self-referential
hashtags with the effect to highlight originality and to accentuate one’s online persona from a
wider pool of similar content on Instagram. For example, @sjanaelse marked her self-written
43
texts with the hashtag “#writtenbysjana”, @yoga_girl used “#yogaeverydamnday”, @kinoyoga
used the same two hashtags “#onebreathatatime” and “#practiceyogachangeyourworld” in the
majority of her posts, which can be understood as a form of personal ‘mantra’”. Others used
hashtags directly connected to their businesses, for example @kathrynbudig with the hashtag
“#aimtrue”, the name of her book and @koyawebb who used “#getlovedup” as a connection
to her app and main business. Consequently, it has been found that the entrepreneurs did not
only employ Instagram’s affordances to navigate their self-presentations, but also to
strengthen their brand identities, which is presented more closely in the following thematic
section.
4.2.3. Business purposes
In total, 76 posts have found to be associated with sponsored content or contained any other
form of tagged branding, for example clothing brands as recommendations or potential
collaboration deals. Sponsored content was presumed when the hashtag “#sponsor” or
“#sponsored” was used in the caption or when the text referred to a brand as sponsor, which
eventually was only found in nine of these posts (@kathrynbudig 1x, @koyawebb 5x,
@sjanaelise 3x). In the other 67 posts, collaboration were assumed when a brand was
mentioned, recommended and thanked for, as for example in “Thank you @3dprmarketing for
this amazing wellness retreat (@koyawebb) or “Spending the next four days in Byron Bay
with @biossance” (@sjanaelise) and when a tag was accompanied by lines such as ‘outfit by’
in the captions as for example “outfit by @aloyoga” (@dylanwerneryoga).
In total, about half of all posts that provided the use of hashtags (52,63%) and 20% of
all posts were business-related, either in the form of a clear indication for sponsored content
such as hashtags related to collaboration or sponsorship partners or by using hashtags that
are specific for their respective businesses. This was found for example for @yoga_girl with
“#yogaeverydamnday” or “#yogagirlpodcast” (3x), @kathrynbudig with “#aimtrue”,
“#kiragracekathrynbudig” or “#freecookiepodcast” (13x) or @koyawebb with “#getlovedup”
(8x) @kinoyoga with “#kinoyoga” (1x).
44
account name collaboration/ sponsored content
connected with aloyoga
self-promotional content captions
entrepreneurial indication in images
@yoga_girl 0 0 5 3
@beachyogagirl 2 0 8 6
@sjanaelise 16 8 0 0
@kathrynbudig 12 0 15 3
@koyawebb 12 3 13 11
@laurasykora 16 19 1 0
@kinoyoga 0 0 18 0
@patrickbeach 3 3 13 0
@dylanwerneryoga
17 17 1 0
@carsonclaycalhoun
14 10 11 2
Table 3: Detailed distribution of business-related content amongst the posts
The distribution of posts containing content dedicated to brands, collaboration or sponsorship
content however varied amongst the accounts. An interesting finding was that many posts
connected with sponsorship and potential collaboration content was connected with a US
based yoga clothing company aloyoga that also own the online yoga teaching platform
alomoves. Aloyoga has potential collaboration deals with @sjanaelise, @koyawebb and
@dylanwerneryoga and they are described on the company’s website as “part of the aloyoga
family” (“Meet the Alo Yoga Family”), while @laurasykora is described as “official VIP
Ambassador for aloyoga” on her website (“About Laura”). Consequently, 78,95% (60 out of
76) of the posts detected as sponsored or featuring potential collaboration deals related to
aloyoga, exclusively by accounts connected with the company (See table 3).
Connected to aforementioned findings about normative body types and body display,
94,74% of the posts that contained sponsored content or brand collaborations subsequently
showed up normative and disposed bodies as image focal point. While this was the case for
all the potential aloyoga collaborations and sponsoring, the same could be observed in post
promoting own content, for example in the case of @kinoyoga who promoted her own clothing
line along images portraying body display in eight of her posts.
45
Besides sponsorship or collaboration pursuits, Instagram was found to be a tool for
self-promotion. While accounts making higher use of sponsorships or collaboration were less
likely to indicate clear self-promotional content, other accounts focus on using Instagram to
promote their own businesses instead. In general, entrepreneurial cues based on images such
as the presentation of logos, images of workshop class situations, edited images for
promotion, so-called ‘giveaways’ or preview shots of podcast-covers were rare and only found
in 9,80% of all images (25 out of 255). Instead, self-promotion occurred more frequently in the
captions and was found in 30,5% of the posts. To give examples, the accounts were found to
frequently post excerpts of yoga videos or images accompanied with prompts in their captions
such as “Practice with me here, Link in bio or beachyogagirlapp.com” (@beachyogagirl) or
“Here’s a sneak peek at my Sculpt and Flow workout, download @getlovedup app via link in
my bio for full workout” (@koyawebb) or “Sign up for everything on my website [...] (link in bio)”
(@carsonclaycalhoun). Here as well, structures of an overarching yoga market could be found.
Just as with the clothing company aloyoga, some of the accounts related their businesses to
the respective connected online teaching platform alomoves and promoted their classes on
alomoves in their posts (@dylanwerneryoga, @koyawebb). In addition to yoga classes and
workshops, some of the accounts used Instagram in order to announce and promote additional
businesses such as podcasts: “I’m excited to announce the @GetLovedUp podcast is here!”
(@koyawebb) or clothing- or cosmetic lines: “Outfit is my Omstars by @liquidoactive design”
(@kinoyoga) or “Wearing the Kathryn Bra and Slashed Legging from my
@kiragraceyogacollection” (@kathrynbudig). Additionally, self-promotion was strengthened
through making use of Instagram’s community building aspects. For example, some account
holders conducted give-aways for promotion and follower engagement such as
@carsonclaycalhoun (“Free workshop giveaway! Here’s how to win! 1. Like this photo. 2. Tag
3 friends who like to have fun”), @koyawebb “or @kathrynbudig (“Giveaway time! Join in to
snag my new Ethereal Collection with @vapourbeauty”).
4.2.4. The Presentation of Authenticity
A dominant theme found in the posts was the presentation of one’s personal and unfiltered
life. As for the visual representation, 23,54% of all images or videos presented the
entrepreneur with their families and partners, friends or pets, which is due to the possibility to
post multiple image units within one post distributed on 22,50% of all posts. This distribution
however varies amongst the accounts (See table 1). For example, @yoga_girl’s account is
strongly concerned with representing her family, pets and children (50% of her posts)
alongside with giving personal insights about their private life “Going on a last-minute romantic
46
surprise trip for 24 hours”. Similar results were found for @laurasykora (40% of her posts):
“😴 <— Current mood after a long but exciting day with my mini at her dance competition”
and @patrickbeach (30% of his posts). In addition to being family driven as a theme, others,
for example @sjanaelise dedicated a major amount of her posts to represent her relationship
and her boyfriend (25% of her posts), accompanied with romantic captions such as “You are
a walking example of a life well lived, and a life well loved. You are prana itself; powerful and
pure” to portray love and feelings. The same was found for @kathrynbudig (25% of her posts):
“I celebrate my wife and all the love and patience she offers me every single damn day”.
Furthermore, the expression of feelings and their inner life revealed to be a major
theme to convey authenticity, particularly by distancing oneself from stereotypical shiny
images portrayed by the wellness industry and social media influencers: “The dirty secret
about the wellness world circa 2019 is that it’s talking about balance while showing you bodies
that, for the most part, take extreme, unbalanced discipline to achieve” (@kathrynbudig),
“anyone else struggling to make it all work?” (@beachyogagirl) or “Have you ever had some
many things that you need to do and no desire or motivation to do any of it? That is pretty
much me right now” (@dylanwerneryoga).
Earlier in this study, it has been outlined that Instagram has shown a change from
presenting staged perfection up to presenting more authenticity. In that sense, one major
theme found in the analysis was sharing personal histories and experiences the entrepreneurs
made earlier in life and overcame in order to share it and help others. For example,
@beachyogagirl thematized her experiences with body shaming and bullying but writes that
“later in life, I came to find my passion in life ~helping others to find freedom in their bodies,
minds and hearts [because…] helping others makes everything I’ve gone through worth it”.
@yoga_girl and @koyawebb for example expressed their own struggles and weaknesses,
especially in relation to lifestyle and diet choices and how they overcame it: “This body has
been through so much [...] There were months, years, when I drank every day. I spent the first
18 years of my life completely clueless about health, filling my body not only with alcohol but
with chicken, meat, fried foods and pretty much anything” (@yoga_girl) or “I've experienced
trauma, pain, and so much fear that I've built barriers to love [...] I realize I'm emotionally eating
and this is not healthy for processing my pain” as well as her way out of it. Consequently, the
expression of personal thoughts and mindsets got frequently connected and intertwined with
sponsoring or self-promotional content: “I try to reflect during my meditation daily but it’s
always great when I can take a weekend vacation or girls trip to really dive deep and pamper
myself. Thank you @3dprmarketing for this amazing wellness retreat” (@koya_webb) or “If
you know me, you know I am passionate about finding and supporting eco-friendly,
sustainable brands. And I truly believe skin care is no exception” (@sjanaelise).
47
4.2.5. From Posts to Stories
The previous analysis has shown that in Instagram posts mainly aesthetic and appealing
images are displayed. Consequently, in relation to the theoretical framework and research
question of this thesis, the identity performances of the respective accounts were
predominantly marked by a selective self-presentation enhancing sensations of desire for the
audience. Simultaneously, yoga has been portrayed as a lifestyle choice to fulfil potential
desires, which was overall contextualized and complemented with promotional contents.
Beyond that, providing insights into one’s personal life or sharing profound and inspirational
texts were found to build up sensations of authenticity and intimacy. These presentations were
strongly connected with entrepreneurial pursuits, either through promoting sponsored
contents and deals or one’s own businesses. While the posts on one’s Instagram feed are
what other users get portrayed on the first sight once they come across a profile, Instagram
stories exclusively address users that are already familiar with an account’s nature based on
the fact that users normally follow accounts in order to see stories and have to be accessed
more consciously. Consequently, posts might be more staged and carefully considered in
order to get attention and desired feedback and thus, match aforementioned implementations
by Goffman on front stage performances. The next part of the analysis discusses this idea
within the context of Instagram stories. Examining whether this notion hold true, such as if
stories offer less staged background performances, adds to this study’s reflection and
discussion of implementations about Instagram’s changed aesthetics and increased demands
for more authenticity that emerged on the platform in recent times.
4.2. Story analysis
Capturing the stories of all ten accounts over three days provided a dataset of 359 story units
in total, including images and short videos. Some of these short units form whole video
narrative strands, based on Instagram’s affordance to only not allow single stories to extend
15 seconds. Consequently, the single-story units make up a total of 206 self-contained stories.
The distribution of the dataset varies amongst the accounts. With 153 single stories units
making up 73 complete stories @yoga_girl posted by far the most stories, while
@dylanwerneryoga did not post any story during the three days in which the stories were
captured. All stories are archived in the appendix of this thesis and the respective citations
48
given in the text refer to the respective file names. The detailed distribution of the story usage
amongst the accounts is as follows (See table 4):
account name single story units
images video narratives
stories in total
@yoga_girl 153 47 26 73
@beachyogagirl 5 3 2 5
@sjanaelise 54 17 32 49
@koyawebb 68 31 17 48
@kathrynbudig 35 14 1 15
@laurasykora 5 5 0 5
@patrickbeach 4 0 1 1
@dylanwerneryoga 0 0 0 0
@carsonclaycalhoun 10 3 7 10
Table 4: Detailed distribution of stories amongst the accounts.
More than half of all the single story units (51,94%) were edited by applying text or emojis to
it, out of which 14,97% were edited with a ‘swipe up’ or ‘tap here’ in order to direct users to
external business related websites (See fig. 3). In 8,61% of all single story units images were
edited with GIF’s or animated text or swipe up options. Three of the accounts made use of the
story to direct to recently published posts, namely @koyawebb (3) stories, @beachyogagirl
(3) and @carsonclaycalhoun (1; See f.ex. cc_st_2). As pointed out before, Instagram stories
provide users a specific use of filters, such as boomerangs, time lapses or focusses. This
feature, however, has found to be used only in a total of 11 story units by @sjanaelse (8),
@koyawebb (2) @kathrynbudig (1; See sj_st_27, sj_st_32, kw_st_6, kb_st_6).
Features such as polls or questions have not been found to be widely used either:
While the story function was only used by @yoga_girl, the poll function was only used by
@patrickbeach, both only once (See fig. 3 and 4).
49
Fig. 3: @yoga_girl uses the question-tag Fig. 4: @patrickbeach uses the poll-tag
While these findings relate more to the overall appearance of the dataset, the content will be
examined more closely in the following while focussing on the same thematic categories as
well as potential similarities and differences to the previous post analysis.
4.3.1. The Presentation of Yoga
In contrast to the findings of the post analysis, the presentation of yoga has not found to be a
dominant theme within the stories. Only 1,94% of the stories (7 stories) presented the account
holders performing yoga postures, amongst which only one story is not contextualized with
promotional features such as “class is now on @alomoves swipe up to join me” (kw_st_12).
However, instead of functioning for the presentation of yoga, stories provided extensive
possibilities for identity performance and entrepreneurship given in posts in other ways, which
is presented in more detail in the following.
50
4.3.2. Identity performance
In the post analysis it has been found that the presentation of one’s body through normative
body types and yoga poses served as a dominant tool for identity performance, which has not
been found in the stories to the same extent. Consequently, instead of focussing on normative
body types and displayed body presentation, stories either framed the entrepreneur in a selfie-
like perspective or their immediate environment out of their viewpoint, which is based on the
way Instagram stories afford users to hold their phones while recording stories (See fig. 5 and
6). Stories were dominantly used as a tool for documenting one’s life and lifestyle choices that
goes beyond the respective presentation in the posts. Consequently, self-identity and lifestyle
were less portrayed through appealing and aesthetic visualizations, but more through ‘behind
the scenes’ strategies. While health and wellness-related topics in the posts were exclusively
thematized in the captions, the entrepreneurs used Instagram stories to share recipe videos
or food (See f.ex. yg_st_2; sj_st_7) or to discuss health- and wellness-related topics (See f.ex.
yg_st_1; kw_st_1).
Fig. 5: Screenshot of a story by @kinoyoga. Fig. 6: Screenshot of a story by @sjanaelise.
Above that, the way the respective accounts used the affordances and features provided by
stories to express specific and unique styles and therefore, identities. The use of GIFs and
51
animated letters or emojis for example, might have been used to create a more humorous
atmosphere (See fig. 7) or to attribute clear emotions and messages to a story, so that the
intention of a story gets conveyed even though people might potentially watch a story without
sound (See fig. 8). @sjanaelise for example dominantly edited her stories with filters, time
lapses, boomerangs and music underlays in order to maintain the aesthetic and self-selected
impressions given in her posts (See sj_st_32).
Fig. 7: Example of a GIF in a story Fig. 8: Example of text and emojis applied to
(@kathrynbudig). a story (@koyawebb).
The aforementioned aspect is strengthened by a range of features Instagram stories provide
for community engagement, such as questions-tags or polls. These functions, however, were
not widely used by the entrepreneurs within the three days. More precisely, @yoga_girl was
the only one using the question feature. By encouraging her community to “ask me anything”,
she got confronted with personal questions but also business-related questions such as “Why
did you choose not to do paid advertising on Instagram?” or “Which yoga accounts do you
52
suggest following?” which she answered with “None. I pretty much despise every major yoga
account out there. Give me another skinny girl posted in sponsored yoga-pants with a generic
quote and I vomit” (See fig. 9).
Fig. 9: Examples of using the question tag for enhanced self-presentation (@yoga_girl).
4.3.3. Business purposes
Stories have found to be used by some of the accounts in the first place as a promotion tool.
For example, @kathrynbudig promoted her business in 74,29% of her stories, either through
the use of Instagram’s features to direct followers to external websites or other accounts such
as ‘swipe up’, ‘tap here’ or tagging her brands or collaboration partners in the image or video
units (See fig. 10). The same was found for @koyawebb in (42 % of her stories) and
@carsonclaycalhoun (30% of his stories) as well as sporadically for @kinoyoga, @yoga_girl,
53
@beachyogagirl and @laurasykora with only one story each. Additionally, some of the
accounts used stories as an amplification tool for their posts by sharing them in their stories
and by using the ‘tap here’ affordance which directs users to the respective post. Even though
this function has only been used in 2,91% of all stories, it has been exclusively used to draw
attention to posts that self-promotion contain self-promotional content (See fig. 10).
Fig. 10: Examples of using affordances provided by Instagram stories for self-promotion. left
and middle: swipe up affordance, right: tap here affordance.
The editing features and affordances provided for stories and the changed aesthetics for
stories discussed earlier in this study, encouraged new promotion possibilities. By editing an
image with text or animations, some accounts created stories looking like advertisements,
which could be found in 13,11% of the stories. For entrepreneurial pursuits consequently,
stories functioned like a merger of images and captions: On the one hand, capturing attention
through visual appeal and on the other hand, conveying information immediately on the first
sight without having to rely on textual contextualization as in captions (See fig. 11).
54
Fig. 11: Examples for merging images and text in stories to create “advertisements” (left:
@koyawebb, right: @kathrynbudig).
Another form of more direct self-promotion could be seen as well in the possibility to post short
video sequences in their stories. This feature was used for example by @kathrynbudig who
announced in her post to discuss her new clothing line “in my story with swipe up links to shop.
Hit me up with any questions!” Consequently, a video sequence of her “virtual dressing room”
consisting of 22 single story units allow for more personalized advertisement by encouraging
engagement and bypassing the risk of over posting (See kb_st_1). Another way to harness
Instagram stories for promotion purposes is by engaging the community. Consequently, the
entrepreneurs did not only address their audience directly through Instagram stories, but also
activated a sense of community and the motivation for participation through sharing user posts
they were tagged in in their stories, as form of sharing reputation, as for example “Did THE
most relaxing @alo.moves flow with @koyawebb #heaven” (kw_st_37).
Previously, it has been outlined that stories provide extensive possibilities to express
one’s personality and manage how one wants to be perceived by an audience, for example
through humoristic or aesthetic editing. These posting performances in turn have found to be
widely connected with promotional aspects, such as swipe up options or tags (See fig. 7).
55
Consequently, stories as well provided opportunities to connect self-promotion with authentic
self-presentations, which will be discussed in the following section.
4.3.4. The Presentation of Authenticity
Like the findings of the post analysis, stories were dominantly used to document everyday life
situations that increased feelings of intimacy and authenticity. In stories, this has been
strengthened however through documenting one’s immediate surroundings detached from
yoga. For example, yoga_girl posted 17 story narratives (in 56 single story units) about
everyday situations with her daughter and even posted stories of her in which she is taking a
bath or sleeping (See f.ex. yg_st_7; yg_st_10; yg_st_3). @patrickbeach did not use the story
function for entrepreneurial purposes in any way, but to provide his community with insights
about his girlfriend’s pregnancy (pb_st_1). Giving insights into one’s life through stories has
shown itself through documenting one’s environment, for example while travelling (See f.ex.
ky_st_14; sj_st_1) or recording stories during everyday practices such as exercising (See f.ex.
kw_st_1; sj_st_19) or the presentation of food (See f.ex. kb_st_4; sj_st_45; yg_st_59;
yg_st_2).
Furthermore, stories were used as a way to present sensations of being ‘behind the
scenes’ of a post (see fig. 12), for example through posting additional material to posts, which
could have been observed during the three days in which the capturing of the stories and
posts overlapped. To give examples, @sjanaelise posted a post about her dinner plans with
a sponsor, which she portrayed more insights about in her stories (sj_st_2; sj_st_15), while
@kathrynbudig’s dedicated one post about inviting her followers to her “virtual dressing room”
in her stories, which was simultaneously portrayed in her stories and constantly connected
with self-promotional features such as swipe up and tags (kb_st_1).
Stories were dominantly used as a tool to directly address one’s community and to
initiate audience engagement. Consequently, some of the accounts used stories to express
and share feelings, mindsets and emotions. For example, @yogagirl recorded stories in which
she gave insight about her emotional and physical wellbeing: “I don’t think I have recovered
from my little burnout from last year” (yg_st_1), while @koyawebb expressed her feelings
towards her work: “I hope you guys get as much out of it as I do...the work I am doing right
now is something that I wanted to do for a while [...] and I am basically over-joyed”, then edited
with text for voice-off: “So grateful” (kw_st_3; See fig. 8).
56
Fig. 12: Example for creating ‘behind the scene’ atmospheres through Instagram stories
(@sjanaelise)
4.3.5. To summarize
As outlined throughout this chapter, the findings of the analysis of the collected data provide
interesting initial impressions of how Instagram is utilized for entrepreneurial pursuits on the
yoga market. First, the accountholders’ basic steps for identity performance on Instagram
show up similar strategies based on setting up their usernames, bio description, profile picture
and an account’s verification. These findings indicate that even though yoga is presented as
common and main theme to ground the entrepreneurial nature of their accounts on, they
present their individual identities and narratives as determining factors to the audience.
Consequently, the majority of them - eight out of them - connect their Instagram to themselves
in the first place by using their real names as username, while all of them indicate their real
names as first indication in their bio. In line with that, nine of them maintain verified accounts.
By making use of Instagram’s business tool to label one’s account, the account holders tend
to position themselves apart from ordinary Instagram users. Through categorizing their
57
accounts as business-related they indicate yoga not only as a personal hobby or passion, but
as a source of potential income. By categorizing themselves as public figures, they emphasize
the influential potential they have regarding their large follower base. In line with that, all of
them use the space in their bio to situate and promote their business by highlighting their
expertise as a yoga teacher, by promoting respective programs and by providing access to
websites and further business-related content.
The content shared by the studied accounts show on the one hand similar strategies and
form of representations, but on the other hand also interesting differences. While the images
in posts were predominantly concerned with aesthetic presentation of oneself, foremostly by
drawing attention to the body by performing yoga postures, written captions were used to
contextualize the images in order to strengthen the conveyed feelings of a desirable lifestyle
through thematizing yoga as a path for self-development and overall well-being and
happiness. Additionally, written context in the posts circulated a lot around self-promotion or
promotion of sponsorship and collaboration deals, which shows that identity performance on
Instagram is strategically used for entrepreneurial opportunities. The analysis of Instagram
stories however has shown that this feature of Instagram most notably functions as an
amplification tool for self-branding. First, the technological possibilities of Instagram stories
provide users a way for more direct promotion through creating ‘advertisements’ with direct
access options. Second, stories opened new ways for community engagement and self-
presentation, which paves the way for intensified ‘authentic self-branding’.
This chapter has laid out how yoga entrepreneurs use Instagram for self-presentation
and entrepreneurial purposes. The next chapter goes deeper into the meaning of these results
in order to provide an all-encompassing understanding and connection to the topic and
research question of this thesis. This is achieved foremostly by linking the findings of this study
to the main points of the theoretical framework in order to situate them within the wider context
of online identity performance for monetization and entrepreneurship pursuits on the
contemporary wellness market and how this is facilitated through Instagram.
58
CHAPTER 5: DISCUSSION
5.1. Identity Performance through Lifestyle Choices
How do yoga entrepreneurs perform their identity on Instagram?
A key finding of this study is that all the ten account holders use similar identity performance
strategies on Instagram in order to present themselves above all as entrepreneurs. This has
been conveyed through the way they set up their profiles, more precisely their usernames,
profile pictures and description. By indicating their real names, identifiable pictures and profile
verifications, the account holders connect their online identity to their offline identity and
present themselves as identifiable individuals. Through indicating yoga as main identifier in
their profile, categorizing their account and by using the limited space provided for a
description to bundle up links and access to their respective products and services, the
account holders actively differentiate their online presence from users merely sharing yoga
content to be directly identifiable as yoga entrepreneurs on the first sight. Consequently, based
on aforementioned implementations by Marwick and boyd, initial profile setups determine an
account’s supposed nature and indicate a distinction between personal and business account
(115). Additionally, their overall self-presentations indicate to not only aim to make oneself
identifiable as a yoga entrepreneur, but also as unique self-brand. In the theoretical framework
for this study, hashtags have been described as a way to increase visibility and to build up
communities on Instagram (Baker and Walsh 6). Consequently, while someone trying to
establish a yoga account on Instagram would most likely use popular hashtags such as ‘#yoga’
or ‘#yogaflow’ to increase visibility, the studied entrepreneur accounts did not use a huge
number of these kind of attention-seeking hashtags in overall terms, but more likely hashtags
related to themselves. With special regard to their overall high follower counts, this finding
implicates that their individual existence on Instagram does rather not require actions to
increase one’s visibility further, but instead more to build up ‘recognition value’ and sub-
communities within the wider yoga sphere on Instagram in order to make one’s content and
brand more unique amongst the big pool of yoga content on Instagram. Beyond that,
especially by presenting their real identity as initial cue, the account holders indicate that their
content will go beyond the presentation of yoga up to presenting their respective lives and
lifestyle choices. Consequently, in line with writing their identity as yoga entrepreneurs on
Instagram through profile construction into being, their posting behaviour and content is
59
generally consistent with their aforementioned initial impressions. This goes in line with
Marwick’s notion that authentic identities and narratives are built up through consistent identity
performances (“Status Update” 120). In a similar vein, even though the way the respective
account holders curate their identities on Instagram shows up overall similar strategies, the
content might differ slightly amongst the respective accounts. Consequently, while some of
the accounts focus on presenting themselves predominantly as yoga entrepreneurs through
posting exclusively yoga-related content (See fig. 13; @kinoyoga, @dylanwerneryoga,
@carsonclaycalhoun), others share more content about their private life (See fig. 14;
@yoga_girl) or their respective businesses (See fig. 15; @koyawebb; @kathrynbudig). This
finding goes strongly in line with aforementioned implementations given in the theoretical
framework about identity performances. In that sense, identity performance is based on
individual lifestyle choices and constant selective decision-making processes in order to create
consistent and coherent narratives while making one’s identity unique and distinguishable
from others (Giddens 76; Buckingham 9).
Fig.13: snapshot of @dylanwerneryoga’s Fig. 14: snapshot of @yoga_girl’s feed
feed portraying mostly yoga content portraying mostly family content
60
Fig. 15: snapshot of @koyawebb’s feed portraying mostly business and promotion content
Content-wise, in line with implementations given in the theoretical framework, the
entrepreneurs overall discuss lifestyle choices portraying them as “lifestyle icons and
devotees”, predominantly by presenting yoga as initial step to achieve an aspirational life
marked by overall health, fulfilment and wellness (Leaver et al.). In that sense, the process of
presenting oneself on social media has been described as being carefully considered and
selected based on desired feedback and impressions of the audience or more precisely, to
create likeable content which commonly includes the presentation of “desirable lifestyles and
hegemonic beauty ideals” (Tiidenberg and Baym 3; Marwick and boyd). Consequently, most
images presenting the account holders performing yoga is contextualized with ‘wisdom’ and
life advices in terms of struggles they overcame through yoga and related lifestyle choices,
such as obtaining a vegan diet, supporting sustainable brands and especially maintaining a
positive and mindful mindset. Such content is continuously formulated in long self-written texts
that in line with Lorenz implementations increase perceptions of authenticity and credibility
that in return contribute to the creation of strong identities and successful self-brands (Lorenz;
See also Duffy and Hund 3; Khamis et al; Marwick “Status Update” 120; Duffy; Marom 22).
To strengthen sensations of desirability, the images portray predominantly ideal body
presentations and desirable visual settings. In that sense, the body has been described as
marking agency identity as well as ideals on the wellness and fitness market (Webb et al. 93).
61
Consequently, in a remarkable amount of shared visual and textual content featuring body
discourses, the entrepreneurs promote the benefits yoga and lifestyle-related choices had for
their physical appearance and health. More precisely, while male entrepreneurs seem to
advocate physical benefits of yoga more than females (@dylanwerneryoga, @patrickbeach),
female entrepreneurs are more likely to thematize diet choices, such as veganism
(@yoga_girl, @koyawebb) as life changing characteristic. Consequently, an openly displayed
fit and toned body type signifiers not only a physical transformation, but also a psychological
transformation, from an unhealthy to a healthy lifestyle and thus, overall mindfulness and
wellbeing. In that sense, the body accounts as the most striking example for the impacts
lifestyle choices can have on one’s identity (Giddens 56). By presenting body types that are
conventionally associated with attractiveness and desire (i.e. thin, fit, toned), they use
Instagram to portray obvious results and to attract followers through visual appeal (Rassi 8).
Thereby, they contextualize and promote yoga and their lifestyle as desirable and aspirational
concept. More precisely, the entrepreneurs convey their audience the feeling of being able to
experience the same health and happiness once they adopt the same identity performances
and lifestyle choices as they do, which presents the key mechanism for successful Instagram
entrepreneurship that will be discussed in the following part of this chapter.
5. 2. The Zen Entrepreneur: Self-promotion and Monetization
In which ways are identity performances used for entrepreneurial pursuits?
The findings of this study indicate that yoga entrepreneurs portray predominantly appealing
and desirable impressions of themselves on Instagram. Specific identity performances in this
direction can be instrumentalized for entrepreneurial and monetization pursuits. By creating
likeable and appealing content as discussed in previous parts of this study, the accounts
actively contribute to maintaining and increasing their status as micro-celebrities or influencers
within the yoga niche (Marwick “Status Update” 114). Consequently, in connection to the
theoretical outline of this thesis, the performances of the studied entrepreneurs go in line with
Marwick’s definition of self-branding as a form of self-presentation that relies on presenting
and selling an image of oneself as consumer product to others (“Status Update” 166). In that
sense, their overall identity performances respond to previous studies of health and fitness-
related social media content by posting a striking amount of body-centred imageries that
portray exclusively fit and thin body types Duffy and Hund; Carah and Shaul; Cowans;
Toffoletti and Thorpe).
62
While establishing the theoretical framework for this study, certain expectations for
alternative body presentation as well as different body presentations between female and male
accounts have been raised based on Instagram’s reliance of user-generated and recently
emerged “body positivity movements” (Cwynar-Horta 37). However, while themes like body
positivity or self-love have found to be widely preached within caption, the images overall
exclusively portray fit and thin body types, interestingly even more displayed by the male
accounts. This finding strongly confirms Banet-Weiser’s argument that specific bodies are
more likely to evoke desire and are thus, more brandable (58). While previous scholars
referred this argumentation particularly to female bodies as a signifier for desired femininity
and appearance, this study neglects any form of gender superiority and suggests that
entrepreneurial pursuits are more likely based on aforementioned associations of physical
fitness and aesthetic with well-being, happiness and health for males and females alike.
Consequently, in this study presentations of identity on Instagram has found to be dominantly
instrumentalized for monetization purposes and explains why content promoting for example
yoga clothing brands portrays exclusively desirable bodies. This notion aligns with discussed
ideas that constructed identities are determining factors in consumers decision-making
processes as “consumption depends on whether or not products and services are linked to
consumer desires” (Boll 83). In that sense, the yoga entrepreneurs fulfil conditions similar to
influencer marketing outlined in the theoretical part of this thesis in a way that they assimilate
trust into goods they advertise by functioning as embodied presentation of the brands, either
for potential sponsorship or collaboration partners or their own brands (Dittmar 12; Abidin and
Thompson 468).
Consequently, self-promotion is a dominant theme for entrepreneurship on Instagram
and manifests itself in addition to the respective account bios predominantly in the post
captions and the stories. The terminology used within the captions accompanying
predominantly appealing images focus on encouraging users to purchase products and
services by providing links to their websites and programs. The branding and self-branding
behaviour of the entrepreneurs have provided an interesting and striking system which reveals
itself in the combination of aesthetic and desirable content, authentic contextualisation and
promotional pursuits. In other words, the predominantly appealing content of the images which
functions to create a sensation of desire is combined with inspirational self-written texts
evoking authenticity is in turn contextualized with promotion content, such as tags for
collaboration deals or self-promotional content. This creates a sensation of ‘authentic
branding’, which on the one hand strengthens the credibility of the entrepreneurs and on the
other hand provides an identification potential for the audience and possible clients and
enhances monetization potential.
63
In establishing a theoretical framework for the study on the identity performance of
yoga entrepreneurs, it has been found that desirable lifestyles and beauty ideals on the
contemporary wellness market are seemingly easily achievable through the purchase of
certain material goods and services. More precisely, consumers are being conveyed that
personal fulfilment and the elimination of all problems can be achieved through downloading
for example a meditation app, starting a raw vegan diet or juice cleanse or - very common -
doing yoga (Blei). However, authentic representation and advertising of respective lifestyles
and choices have argued to be an inevitable precondition so that a common stance is that all
kinds of health and wellness related problems can easily be solved through purchasing certain
products or services “because consumption will get them closer to these ideals” (Dittmar 22).
Consequently, through practices of authentic (self-) branding and the promotion of yoga as
life-changing and improving initiator contextualized through own experiences, the
entrepreneurs package yoga as a commodification product. Notions of authenticity, in turn,
have not only been outplayed for promotional purposes, but also to verify one’s whole
existence as yoga entrepreneur, potentially to counter critics about the monetization of yoga.
On the whole, the way the entrepreneurs present themselves on Instagram and
communicate their businesses, responds to the general market drive to go from “blog to brand”
and to distance one’s business from general and amateur yoga-related online content by
constantly highlighting their expertise as “spiritual entrepreneurs” or “life coaches” (Gregory
211). In that sense, this research supports studies stating that successful entrepreneurship
takes up the highest status on the contemporary market, which is driven by the general stance
that one’s job must be driven by passion and love (Marwick “Status Update” 257). More
precisely, a common theme within the general identity performances have found to a
contextualization of self-promotion with a drive to help others by doing and sharing what they
love. Consequently, the entrepreneurs outplay an overall attitude of “getting paid for doing
what you love” or even more accurate, an attitude of placing the benefits one’s expertise and
businesses might have for others over one’s own financial profit and media popularity
(Marwick “Status Update” 80; Duffy 442).
64
5.3. The Commodification of Yoga as “New Age Spirituality” and
Wellness Product
How is yoga presented by yoga entrepreneurs on Instagram?
Despite its ancient and religious roots, yoga has become more of a “fashion statement than a
sacred practice” on the modern market (Hoffmann). The results of this study have shown that
even though yoga is used as the main identifier within the respective account descriptions and
visual content, traditional yoga principles were rather not explicitly thematized. However, major
themes of the captions can be connected to traditional principles in modernized and adjusted
forms. In that sense, traditional principles are thematized and literally ‘translated’ through more
accessible and marketable themes such as self-development, self-love, lifestyle choices or
‘being present in contentment’. This theme for example can be connected to traditional yoga
principles, described as “samadhi” or “cultivation of one-pointed concentration” in the Eight
Limbs of Yoga, a guideline paths written by the Indian sage Patanjali as part of the Yoga
Sutras, the central source and foundation text in yoga. The eight limbs offer moral, yogic and
ethical guidelines that eventually lead to ultimate sensations and feelings of enlightenment,
happiness and joy (Jain 10; Carrico). Consequently, the entrepreneurs repurpose traditional
principles with indications about related lifestyle choices, frequently followed by self-
promotional content. This can be traced back to observations on identity performance and aim
to present yoga predominantly as desirable and easily accessible lifestyle commodity. In other
words, thematizing traditional principles explicitly might be too abstract or even deterrent to
potential clients or customers that are more interested into the postmodern commercial
interpretations of yoga widely advertised on the contemporary market, such as overall fitness
and weight-loss as well as increased mindfulness, stress release and overall well-being (Lewis
541). Another interesting aspect relating to that finding is that this form of posting yoga content
could be observed widely throughout the posts, while yoga was found to be barely portrayed
in the Instagram stories at all. Instead, stories were predominantly used to curate promotional
content or additional material about insights into one’s personal lifestyle. Consequently, yoga
is by most of the entrepreneurs not promoted and thematized as a single product itself, but in
combination with other wellness-related services and products such as skin care, yoga
clothes, health-related podcasts or diet programs, as for example a ‘7 Days Chakra Smoothie
Challenge’ (@koyawebb).
Consequently, yoga entrepreneurs on Instagram are more likely to commodify and sell
a whole range of yoga-related lifestyle products and services instead of aiming to convey
original meanings and principles of yoga. Through revealing and openly discussing one’s past
and struggles and providing ways out, mostly in form of long spiritual and inspirational texts,
they present themselves as lifestyle gurus making their expertise and lifestyle accessible to
65
potentially everyone through creating and promoting related programs, products and services.
In that sense, yoga is used as the main identifier for extensive and further purchasable lifestyle
choices through which the entrepreneurs “define who they are and what they do (or want to
reflect that they do) in their everyday practice” (Schwindt 216). By taking these argumentations
a step further, it could be evaluated if yoga has become as popular as it is nowadays because
of the verifiability of actual positive effects on the individual or if it is mainly instrumentalized
as identity marker in order to be perceived and categorized as mindful, healthy or spiritual
given the positive associations these characteristics have today (Lewis 541).
5.4. The Role of Instagram
How is Instagram used by yoga entrepreneurs? In which ways are Instagram’s platform-
specific affordances used to perform one’s identity for entrepreneurial and monetization
pursuits?
This study supports previous studies that have described Instagram as a platform used by
brands and advertisers to carry out marketing pursuits (Abidin 86; Manovich 112) as well to
build up and promote self-brands (Marwick; Duffy). This study has shown that Instagram is
used by yoga entrepreneurs as a tool to promote their businesses, such as yoga classes,
products and challenges by presenting and advertising them on the one hand bundled up in
their bio description and on the other hand by constantly performing what has been evaluated
and described earlier as authentic branding strategies in continuous posting processes. In that
sense, the overarching research question of this thesis could be answered as follows: The
relationship between identity performance and entrepreneurship on Instagram is determined
by how Instagram’s platform-specific affordances are used. More precisely, the key to
successful entrepreneurship seems to lie in finding the right relationship between evoking
desire and maintaining authenticity and presenting both consistently in combination. This
function relies mainly on contextualizing aesthetic and appealing content with self-promotional
impulses and links.
In view of the findings, studying and comparing the use of posts and stories to
investigate the relationship between identity performance and entrepreneurship on Instagram
has shown that Instagram’s platform-specific affordances and general features provide
determining and interesting influences and opportunities for entrepreneurship on its platform.
Consequently, in addition to aforementioned interrelations between visual and textual content
in the posts, Instagram’s more recent and not yet exhaustively studied story feature has shown
66
up crucial amplification potential for entrepreneurial pursuits. More precisely, Instagram stories
do not only encourage more direct promotion through the possibilities to create advertisements
with direct links and access to external businesses, but also through transmitting extensive
sensations of authenticity, closeness and intimacy through for example enhanced community
engagement and a changed camera perspective. Even though not equally used amongst the
studied accounts, Instagram stories have shown up not only complementary, but also
enhanced opportunities for identity performance and entrepreneurship in different ways. Most
striking, Instagram stories allow for more personalized self-presentation and branding. In that
sense, in relation to Goffman’s implementations, stories provide new and extensive ways for
users to give off cues about one’s personality and influence how they are perceived by others
(See Ch. 2.1.1.). While for example a predominant use of humoristic GIFs and animations is
likely to be used to present oneself for example as a funny and accessible personality, an
overall aesthetic style might be used to express one’s life and lifestyle as perfect and desirable.
To give examples, in line with her dominant use of humoristic animations, @kathrynbudig is
described on her website as known for her humour (“Kathryn Budig|Me”), while @sjanaelise’s
exclusively idealized and aesthetically edited self-presentation match the presentation of her
life as “the good life” on her website: “I consider myself one of the luckiest people in the world,
because I get to do what I love and call it a job” (Earp).
By setting up the theoretical framework about users general posting behaviours on
Instagram, it has been discussed that Instagram is driven by “selective posting”, meaning that
users carefully consider their posting behaviour and content to avoid “over-posting” their
followers feeds and to only present selected impressions and moments (Marwick “Instafame”
143). However, taking the structure and environment of Instagram’s platform into
consideration, stories aim to exclusively address followers, while posts in addition to providing
content for their followers aim to attract a wider audience and get them to follow their accounts.
Consequently, the content of stories assumes a prior and general knowledge of the account’s
nature and interest into their respective projects, businesses as well as private life.
In general, the findings of the simultaneous time period of capturing posts and stories
shared by the entrepreneurs indicate that their image feeds are indeed overly concerned with
portraying snap shots highlighting exclusively the positive aspects of their lives, most
dominantly in terms of yoga, travelling and family. Simultaneously, stories were generally
concerned with the same sceneries, but provided a range of additional material that evokes
the sensation of getting provided with ‘behind the scenes’ or more precisely ‘behind the post’
content as well as intimate insights into the entrepreneurs lives. This is amplified through the
camera perspective afforded in stories as opposed to images in the posts. In other words,
while images in the posts were dominantly images of them taken by others, stories indicate
self-presentation by the “real self” instead of the “ideal self” (Young 4) and thus, reveal more
67
immediate “in the moment” experiences (Lorenz; Leaver et al.) and closeness to the audience.
In that sense, this study has confirmed aforementioned implementations about the rise of a
new authentic aesthetic on Instagram and the emerging trend to present less staged
“Instagram vs. reality” content, carried out predominantly through Instagram stories as
opposed to posts (Lorenz).
Therefore, the aforementioned original purpose of Instagram to create a space where
people can share realtime impressions of everyday life as stated by Instagram co-founder
Systrom (Manovich 12), has been taken to a higher level through Instagram stories that
encourages rather than frowns an over-posting behaviour. In reference to Goffman’s
implementations about impression management discussed in the theoretical framework of this
thesis, stories provide a sense of “back stage performance”, while images posted on the image
feed rather count as “front stage performance” (Goffman; See Ch. 2.1.1.). This effect is
amplified through new ways for community engagement and exchange that eventually allow
followers through new affordances provided through stories, such as question or poll tags, to
influence the entrepreneurs content and performance more actively in comparison to merely
commenting on posts and sending private messages. Equally, the feature to share follower
posts and reactions in stories extends the original feedback mechanisms of Instagram’s
platform in form of likes and comments (Caldeira 153). More precisely, it provides a fruitful use
of Instagram stories for promotion by portraying audience feedback as a form of proof of one’s
business being efficient. In a similar vein, the features provided by Instagram stories allow for
extensive possibilities for identity expressions. While content in posts is normally exclusively
initiated and staged by the respective accounts, questions and impulses by the audience can
hardly be planned or might also be appropriate and dispatching to their general online identity
and performance. In case of the aforementioned example of @yoga_girl’s use of the question
feature (see fig. 9), the feature eventually allows her to express identity statements and topics
that would simply not fit into the general positive self-presentation she is maintaining in her
posts. Even though one single story is not representative for all entrepreneurs, it portrays
however the significant extensive possibilities Instagram stories provide to navigate the
impressions of the audience.
The aforementioned aspects however effect the way Instagram is used for
entrepreneurial pursuits in a twofold way. First, the sensation of getting insights into their ‘back
stage performances’ and thus ‘real life’ amplifies authentic perceptions of the entrepreneur
accounts. Authenticity in turn, can be outplayed for branding purposes, which is a dominant
theme throughout the stories. In that sense, more personal use of stories in comparison to
posts have been confirmed using it for self-promotion in contrast to promotion for other brands.
While a majority of the posts have featured sponsorship or collaboration deals, for example
68
for aloyoga, promotional content in stories have found to exclusively refer to the entrepreneur’s
own brands and businesses.
Stories have found to amplify opportunities for identity performance as well as
entrepreneurship through encouraging more personalized and authentic posting. However,
given that Instagram relies on user-generated content, it remains the individual user’s decision
what to present online and what to hide from their followers (Bullingham and Vasconcelos
103). Consequently, the new experiences and sensations provided through Instagram stories
require a more careful definition of authenticity. More precisely, also outplays of authenticity
through alleged ‘unstaged’ or ‘unaesthetic’ content can be a fruitful strategy to enhance
entrepreneurial and monetization opportunities, which must be considered when doing
research on Instagram stories.
5.5. Limitations and Further Research
Just as any research, this study had certain limitations. For the scope and lengths of this study,
the data provided a convenient and appropriate sample to get interesting results on the identity
performance of yoga entrepreneurs on Instagram. However, different strategies for the data
collection might have provided a different data sample and thus, potentially different results.
For example, instead of taking the most recent posts into consideration, collecting posts from
different time points, might potentially lead to different results. Similarly, the accounts were
almost exclusively selected based on popularity, filtering out ‘micro-celebrities’ within the
Instagram yoga community in order to assure a study on successful entrepreneurship and
corresponding identity performances. However, there might be a not inconsiderable number
of Instagram accounts belonging to yoga teachers and entrepreneurs who also utilize
Instagram for self-promotion but are not equally popular based on their follower count.
Consequently, instead of taking exclusively established and entrepreneurial successful yoga
influencer accounts into consideration, it could be interesting to study identity performances
of accounts that are still in the process of actively striving to build up successful and renowned
businesses. As outlined throughout this study, specific practices to increase visibility, such as
a wide usage of hashtags has not been observed for the respective accounts, probably based
on their popularity and established visibility on Instagram. Therefore, the use of Instagram’s
affordances by more ordinary accounts could present interesting additional findings.
In a similar vein, further studies could investigate on the identity performance of the
studied accounts in earlier time periods and on the ways their identity performances might
have changed, both in view of increased popularity as well as changes and developments of
69
Instagram’s platform-specific affordances. In that sense, given the newness of Instagram
stories at the time of writing this thesis, I consider this feature as promising for extensive further
studies. Consequently, further research could elaborate on the use of Instagram stories, either
in isolation or through studying the relationship between posts and stories in an extended time
frame.
Another opportunity for further research deriving from this study is to investigate on
identity performances of yoga entrepreneurs on different platforms with the possibility to carry
out a cross-platform analysis. As stated earlier in this study, Instagram is similar to many other
social media platforms, but has a unique nature of aesthetic visual communication (Manovich
41). In that sense, it could be interesting to investigate if the results of this study are equally
present on other social media platforms such as specifically YouTube based on its focus on
video-content. Given that the same yoga influencers tend to maintain accounts across several
social media platforms, contents and use of Instagram, particularly IGTV due to the similarities
to YouTube, could be taken into consideration. Exploring identity performances and
approaches of entrepreneurship across multiple platforms might thereby provide an interesting
contribution for research on the opportunities for entrepreneurship and monetization of
different social media platforms. Similarly, external business platforms found to be bundled up
on Instagram would make for an interesting further study on exploring the relationship between
identity performance and entrepreneurship. This is especially interesting in the context that
some of the yoga entrepreneurs simultaneously maintain podcasts which have lately been
described as a new and increasingly popular medium for people to consume wellness-related
content and thus, for wellness professionals and entrepreneurs to reach consumers (Kohll;
Ryan).
70
CHAPTER 6: CONCLUSION
The fundamental relationship between identity performance and digital yoga entrepreneurship
on Instagram lies in presenting yoga as a desirable and aspirational lifestyle concept.
Detached from its ancient and religious origins, yoga today has become first and foremost
associated with a ‘cool lifestyle’ that seemingly facilitates the achievement of common beauty
ideals, physical fitness, overall health and wellness as well as a somewhat prestigious positive
and mindful mindset. In response to increasingly digitized and networked stances in society
and work cultures, ideas about mindfulness and wellness have not only been discovered as
auspicious self-help tools to subvert any form of stress and discontent, but simultaneously as
especially easy to access and achieve through technological innovations such as meditation
apps or, as this study has shown, yoga-related online programs, challenges and products
promoted on the social media platform Instagram.
Based on Instagram’s primary reliance on user-generated content and users’ sole
responsibility for what to share and how they want to be perceived, this study set out to
investigate on how yoga entrepreneurs use Instagram for entrepreneurial pursuits. Based on
the initial ways in which the entrepreneurs set up their profiles and perform their online identity,
they do not only actively navigate how they as individuals are perceived by others, but also
how yoga is presented as a desirable lifestyle representing aforementioned health and
wellness related goals. According to the saying that a picture is worth a thousand words,
content on Instagram have found to be particularly conveyed through appealing visual content
to secure attention, ranging from desirable bodies to travelling scenes. The idealized
presentation in the images in turn, was generally contextualized with personal and particularly
emotional texts representing yoga as initial step to overall happiness, health and wellness
based on their own experiences. Consequently, just as traditional ancient yoga gurus, yoga
entrepreneurs today present themselves as lifestyle icons and gurus on Instagram, conveying
the impression that merely the purchase of their products and participation in their programs
will provide people the same sensations of health and happiness.
In that sense, this study has found that Instagram provides ideal conditions for
entrepreneurial and monetization purposes. Instagram is not only one of the most popular and
widely used social media platforms worldwide, it also allows users to make content widely
accessible and reach potential customers detached from spatial and temporal constraints.
Consequently, Instagram has given rise for yoga entrepreneurs to build up a larger following
and become ‘yoga influencers’ or ‘yoga celebrities’ engaging in commercial deals with
renowned brand or succeed to run completely on a self-sufficient business. The latter
71
corresponds to contemporary stances on the labour market in which self-employment and
following one’s passions are valued as highly aspirational. In addition to the possibilities
provided for self-presentation and entrepreneurship through Instagram’s image feed, the more
recent feature Instagram stories provides additional opportunities for both aspects. By freeing
users from general normative and aesthetic boundaries set through Instagram’s image feed,
the more ephemeral story feature allows users to increase sensations of authenticity and
credibility through sharing not only more content, but also supposing behind the scenes
sensations, meaning less staged and idealized content. Facilitating this feature for promotional
pursuits, Instagram stories provide significant possibilities, first and foremost through merging
visual and textual content in order to create recognizable advertisements with swipe up options
that direct users straight to respective programs or shops. This interplay between presenting
an authentic online identity and simultaneously promoting either general brands or their own
business has been found to be best described as authentic branding and describes, simply
said, the key element within the interplay of identity performance and entrepreneurship on
Instagram.
72
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Abidin, Crystal. “‘Aren’t These Just Young, Rich Women Doing Vain Things Online?’:
Influencer Selfies as Subversive Frivolity.” Social Media Society, vol. 2, no. 2, 2016,
p.1-17, doi:10.1177/2056305116641342.
“About Laura.” Laurasykora Yoga, www.laurasykora.com/about.html. Accessed 20 June
2019.
“About Us.” About Us • Instagram, www.instagram.com/about/us/. Accessed 6 June 2019.
Allen, Samantha. “10 Instagram Yogis You Should Follow.” DOYOUYOGA.COM,
www.doyouyoga.com/10-instagram-yogis-you-should-follow/. Accessed 12 June
2019.
Amâncio, Marina. “‘Put It in Your Story’: Digital Storytelling in Instagram and Snapchat
Stories.” Uppsala University, 2017.
Baker, Stephanie Alice, and Michael James Walsh. “‘Good Morning Fitfam’: Top Posts,
Hashtags and Gender Display on Instagram.” New Media & Society, vol. 20, no. 12,
2018, pp. 4553–4570, doi:10.1177/1461444818777514.
Bakhshi, Saeideh, Shamma, David A. and Gilbert, Eric. ‘Faces Engage Us: Photos
with Faces Attract More Likes and Comments on Instagram’. CHI ’14. Proceedings of
the SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems, ACM New York,
2014, pp. 965–74, doi:10.1145/2556288.2557403.
Banet-Weiser, Sarah. Authentic: The Politics of Ambivalence in a Brand Culture. New
York University Press, 2012.
Banet-Weiser, Sarah. “Keynote Address: Media, Markets, Gender: Economies of Visibility in
a Neoliberal Moment.” The Communication Review, vol. 18, no. 1, 2015, pp. 53–70,
doi:10.1080/10714421.2015.996398.
Baym, Nancy K. Personal connections in the digital age (2nd Ed.). Cambridge, UK: Polity,
2015.
73
Blei, Daniela. “The False Promises of Wellness Culture.” JSTOR Daily, 4 Jan. 2017,
daily.jstor.org/the-false-promises-of-wellness-culture/. Accessed 6 June 2019.
Boll, Brigid Nell. "Image of Yoga: Instagram, Identity, and Western Imagination". Senior
Projects Spring 2017, 2017. Bard Digital Commons,
http://digitalcommons.bard.edu/senproj_s2017/259.
Booth, Robert. “Master of Mindfulness, Jon Kabat-Zinn: 'People Are Losing Their Minds.
That Is What We Need to Wake up to'.” The Guardian, Guardian News and Media,
22 Oct. 2017, www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2017/oct/22/mindfulness-jon-kabat-
zinn-depression-trump-grenfell. Accessed 6 June 2019.
Borup, Jørn. "Branding Buddha – Mediatized And Commodified Buddhism As Cultural
Narrative". Globalbuddhism.org, 2019,
http://www.globalbuddhism.org/jgb/index.php/jgb/article/view/178/194. Accessed 24
May 2018.
Bourdieu, Pierre. Photography: A Middle-Brow Art. Reissue, 1996.
Boyd, Danah. “Taken Out of Context: American Teen Sociality in Networked Publics.” OSF
Preprints, 4 Jan. 2017, doi:10.31219/osf.io/edq6c.
Bucher, Taina, and Anne Helmond. “The Affordances of Social Media Platforms.” The SAGE
Handbook of Social Media, edited by Jean Burgess, Thomas Poell, and Alice
Marwick. London and New York: SAGE Publications Ltd., 2017, pp. 1-41. (Pre-
publication print, June 2016).
Buckingham, David. Youth, Identity, and Digital Media. MIT Press, 2008.
Bullingham, Liam, and Ana C. Vasconcelos. "‘The Presentation Of Self In The Online World’:
Goffman And The Study Of Online Identities". Journal Of Information Science, vol 39,
no. 1, 2013, pp. 101-112. SAGE Publications, doi:10.1177/0165551512470051.
Butler, Judith. Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity. Routledge, 1999.
Bramley, Ellie Violet. “'The people’s yogi': how Adriene Mishler became a YouTube
phenomenon”. The Guardian (Online), 25 September 2018,
74
https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2018/sep/25/yoga-adriene-mishler-
youtube-interview. Accessed 4 June 2019.
Braun, Virginia, and Victoria Clarke, V. “Using thematic analysis in psychology.” Qualitative
Research in Psychology, vol. 3, no. 2, 2006, pp. 77-101. ISSN 1478-0887.
Brooke, Erin Duffy, and Elizabeth Wissinger. “Mythologies of Creative Work in the Social
Media Age: Fun, Free, and “Just Being Me””. International Journal of Communication,
vol. 1, 2017, pp. 4652 - 4671.
Caldeira, Sofia P. “Identities in Flux: An Analysis to Photographic Self-Representation on
Instagram.” Observatorio (OBS*), vol. 10, no. 3, 2016,
doi:10.15847/obsobs10320161031.
Carrico, Mara. “Get to Know the Eight Limbs of Yoga.” Yoga Journal, 28 Aug. 2007,
www.yogajournal.com/practice/the-eight-limbs. Accessed 2 June 2019.
Chancellor, Stevie, et al. “#Thyghgapp: Instagram Content Moderation and Lexical Variation
in Pro-Eating Disorder Communities.” Proceedings of the 19th ACM Conference on
Computer-Supported Cooperative Work & Social Computing - CSCW 16, 2016,
doi:10.1145/2818048.2819963.
Constine, Josh. “Instagram Launches “Stories” a Snapchatty Feature for Imperfect Sharing –
TechCrunch.” TechCrunch, TechCrunch, 2 Aug. 2016,
techcrunch.com/2016/08/02/instagram-stories/. Accessed 6 June 2019.
---. "Instagram's New "Explore" Brings The Future of Photo Discovery into Focus".
TechCrunch. AOL. 25 June 2012. https://techcrunch.com/2012/06/25/instagram-
explore/. Accessed 19 June 2019.
Corbin, Juliet M., and Anselm Strauss. “Grounded Theory Research: Procedures, Canons,
and Evaluative Criteria.” Qualitative Sociology, vol. 13, no. 1, 1990, pp. 3–21.,
doi:10.1007/bf00988593.
Cowans, Skyler. “Yoga on Instagram: Disseminating or Destroying Traditional Yogic
Principles?” Elon Journal of Undergraduate Research in Communications, vol.7,
no.1, 2016, pp. 99-109. Elon University, <elon.edu/docs/e-
75
web/academics/communications/research/vol7no1/000_Full_Spring_2016_Issue.pdf
#page=33>.
Creel, Bee. “6 Most Inspiring Yogis on Instagram This Week.” Yoga Journal, 8 Sept. 2018,
www.yogajournal.com/lifestyle/6-most-inspiring-yogis-on-instagram-this-week.
Accessed 12 June 2019.
Cwynar Horta, Jessica. “The Commodification of the Body Positive Movement on
Instagram.” Stream: Culture/Politics/Technology, vol. 8, no. 2, 2016, pp. 36-56.
http://journals.sfu.ca/stream/index.php/stream/article/view/203.
Deeb-Swihart, Julia et al. "Selfie-Presentation In Everyday Life: A Large-Scale
Characterization Of Selfie Contexts On Instagram". Proceedings Of The Eleventh
International AAAI Conference On Web And Social Media 2017, 2017, pp. 42-51,
https://www.aaai.org/ocs/index.php/ICWSM/ICWSM17/paper/view/15692/14793.
DeMers, Jason. "Why Instagram Is The Top Social Platform For Engagement (And How To
Use It)". Forbes.Com, 2017,
https://www.forbes.com/sites/jaysondemers/2017/03/28/why-instagram-is-the-top-
social-platform-for-engagement-and-how-to-use-it/#5c541cbc36bd. Accessed 19
May 2019.
Dittmar, Helga. Consumer Culture, Identity and Well-Being: The Search for the ‘Good Life’
and the ‘Body Perfect’, European Monographs in Social Psychology, 2007.
Djafarova, Elmira, and Oxana Trofimenko. "‘Instafamous’ – Credibility And Self-Presentation
Of Micro-Celebrities On Social Media". Information, Communication & Society, 2018,
pp. 1-15. Informa UK Limited, doi:10.1080/1369118x.2018.1438491.
Döring, Nicola, et al. “How Gender-Stereotypical Are Selfies? A Content Analysis and
Comparison with Magazine Adverts.” Computers in Human Behavior, vol. 55, 2016,
pp. 955–962, doi:10.1016/j.chb.2015.10.001.
Drenten, Jenna, et al. “Sexualized Labour in Digital Culture: Instagram Influencers, Porn
Chic and the Monetization of Attention.” Gender, Work & Organization, 2019,
doi:10.1111/gwao.12354.
76
Duffy, Brooke Erin. “The Romance of Work: Gender and Aspirational Labour in the Digital
Culture Industries.” International Journal of Cultural Studies, vol. 19, no. 4, 2015, pp.
441–457, doi:10.1177/1367877915572186.
Duffy, Brooke Erin, and Emily Hund. “‘Having It All’ on Social Media: Entrepreneurial
Femininity and Self-Branding Among Fashion Bloggers.” Social Media Society, vol. 1,
no. 2, 2015, pp. 1-11, doi: 10.1177/2056305115604337.
Earp, Sjana E. “About Sjana Elise Earp .” Sjana Elise , www.sjana.com/pages/about.
Accessed 20 June 2019.
Erkan, Ismail. “Electronic Word of Mouth on Instagram: Customers’ Engagements with
Brands in Different Sectors.” International Journal of Management, Accounting and
Economics, vol. 2, no. 12, December, 2015, pp. 1435-1444.
Farquhar, Lee. “Performing and Interpreting Identity through Facebook Imagery.”
Convergence: The International Journal of Research into New Media Technologies,
vol. 19, no. 4, 2012, pp. 446–471, doi:10.1177/1354856512459838.
Gandini, Alessandro. “Digital work: Self-branding and social capital in the freelance
knowledge economy.” Marketing Theory, vol. 16, no. 1, 2015, pp. 123–141,
doi:10.1177/1470593115607942.
Gaver, William W. “Technology affordances.” Proceedings of the SIGCHI conference on
Human factors in computing systems, ACM, 1990, pp. 79–84, doi:
10.1145/108844.108856.
Geurin-Eagleman, Andrea N., and Lauren M. Burch. “Communicating via Photographs: A
Gendered Analysis of Olympic Athletes’ Visual Self-Presentation on Instagram.”
Sport Management Review, vol. 19, no. 2, 2016, pp. 133–145,
doi:10.1016/j.smr.2015.03.002.
Gibson, James J. “The Theory of Affordances.” The Ecological Approach to Visual
Perception, New York, Hove UK: Psychology Press, 1986, pp. 127-143.
Giddens, Anthony. Modernity and Self-Identity: Self and Society in the Late Modern Age.
Polity Press, 1991.
77
Gill, Rosalind. “Postfeminist Media Culture.” European Journal of Cultural Studies, vol. 10,
no. 2, 2007, pp. 147–166, doi:10.1177/1367549407075898.
Gillespie, Tarleton. “The Politics of ‘Platforms.’” New Media & Society, vol.12, no. 3, 2010,
pp: 347-364.
Glaser, Barney G., and Anselm Strauss. The Discovery of Grounded Theory. Hawthorne,
NY, 1967.
Goffman, Erving. Gender advertisements. New York, NY: Harper Colophon Books,
1979.
---. The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life. Pelican Books, 1959.
Gregg, Melissa. Counterproductive. Duke University Press, 2018.
Gregory, Karen. “Pushed and Pulled to the Internet: Self Employment in the Spiritual
Marketplace.” American Behavioral Scientist, vol. 63, no. 2, 2018, pp. 208–224,
doi:10.1177/0002764218794768.
Gurrieri, Lauren, and Jenna Drenten. “The Hashtaggable Body: Negotiating Gender
Performance in Social Media.” Handbook of Research on Gender and Marketing,
2019, pp. 101–116, doi:10.4337/9781788115384.00010.
Herrera, Andrea P. “Theorizing the Lesbian Hashtag: Identity, Community, and the
Technological Imperative to Name the Sexual Self.” Journal of Lesbian Studies, vol.
22, no. 3, 2017, pp. 313–328, doi:10.1080/10894160.2018.1384263.
Highfield, Tim and Tama Leaver. “Instagrammatics and digital methods: studying visual
social media, from selfies and GIFs to memes and emoji.” Communication Research
and Practice, vol. 2, no.1, 2016, pp: 47-62. Taylor & Francis Online, doi:
10.1080/22041451.2016.1155332.
Hoffman, Amelia. “The Commodification and Appropriation of Spirituality in the Modern Age.”
Ameliamhoffmann, 3 Apr. 2014, ameliamhoffmann.wordpress.com/2014/04/03/the-
commodification-and-appropriation-of-spirituality-in-the-modern-age/. Accessed 8
June 2019.
78
Hutchby, Ian. Technologies, texts and affordances. Sociology, vol. 35, no. 2, 2011, pp: 441–
456, doi: 10.1017/S003803850.
“Identity.” Merriam-Webster, Merriam-Webster, www.merriam-
webster.com/dictionary/identity. Accessed 20 May 2019.
Instagram. “Introducing Instagram Stories”. Instagram Blog, 2 Aug. 2016,
instagram.tumblr.com/post/148348940287/160802-stories. Accessed 9 June 2019.
“Instagram Help Center.” Verified Badges | Instagram Help Center,
help.instagram.com/854227311295302. Accessed 9 June 2019.
@jlobitu. “Instagram Stories and Stories Highlights Download.” Storiesig, storiesig.com/.
Accessed 17 May 2019.
Jain, Andrea R. Selling Yoga. Oxford University Press, 2015.
Kabat-Zinn, Jon. "Mindfulness". Mindfulness, vol 6, no. 6, 2015, pp: 1481-1483. Springer
Nature, doi:10.1007/s12671-015-0456-x.
Kang, Mee-Eun. “The Portrayal of Women’s Images in Magazine Advertisements: Goffman’s
Gender Analysis Revisited.” Sex Roles, vol. 37, no. 11-12, 1997, pp. 979–996,
doi:10.1007/bf02936350.
“Kathryn Budig | Me.” Aim True- Kathryn Budig, www.kathrynbudig.com/me.php. Accessed
20 June 2019.
“Kino MacGregor.” Kino MacGregor, www.kinoyoga.com/about/kino-macgregor/. Accessed
20 June 2019.
Kohll, Alan. “6 Of The Best Podcasts For HR And Wellness Pros.” Forbes, Forbes Magazine,
4 Jan. 2018, www.forbes.com/sites/alankohll/2018/01/04/6-of-the-best-podcasts-for-
hr-and-wellness-pros/#2e2c75186633. Accessed 6 June 2019.
Leaver, Tama, Tim Highfield and Crystal Abidin. “Aesthetics”. Instagram: Visual social media
cultures. Polity, 2019. (Preprint).
Lego Muñoz, Caroline and Terri L. Towner. “The Image is the Message: Instagram
Marketing and the 2016 Presidential Primary Season”. Journal of Political Marketing
79
vol. 16, no. 3-4, 2017, pp. 290-318. Cornell University Library, doi:
10.1080/15377857.2017.1334254. Accessed 19th October 2018.
Lewis, Clara S. "Life Chances And Wellness: Meaning And Motivation In The ‘Yoga Market’".
Sport In Society, vol 11, no. 5, 2008, pp. 535-545. Informa UK Limited,
doi:10.1080/17430430802196538. Accessed 17 Apr 2019.
“Linktree.” Linktree, linktr.ee/.
Liu, Rendan, and Ayoung Suh. “Self-Branding on Social Media: An Analysis of Style
Bloggers on Instagram.” Procedia Computer Science, vol. 124, 2017, pp. 12–20,
doi:10.1016/j.procs.2017.12.124.
Lorenz, Taylor. “The Instagram Aesthetic Is Over.” The Atlantic, Atlantic Media Company, 24
Apr. 2019, www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2019/04/influencers-are-
abandoning-instagram-look/587803/. Accessed 18 June 2019.
Manns, Andrew. "Meditation And Yoga Are Fast-Becoming The World’S Most Popular
Wellness Activities". Wellhomeglobal.Com, 2019,
http://www.wellhomeglobal.com/news/Meditation-and-yoga-are-fast-becoming-the-
world%E2%80%99s-most-popular-wellness-activities/340153. Accessed 15 June
2019.
Manovich, Lev. Instagram and Contemporary Image. 2017,
http://manovich.net/index.php/projects/instagram-and-contemporary-image.
Accessed 10 June 2019.
Marwick, Alice. “Instafame: Luxury selfies in the attention economy.” Public Culture,
vol. 27, no. 1, 2015, pp. 137–160.
---. Status Update: Celebrity. Yale University Press, 2015.
Marwick, Alice, and Danah Boyd. “To See and Be Seen: Celebrity Practice on Twitter.”
Convergence: The International Journal of Research into New Media Technologies,
vol. 17, no. 2, 2011, pp. 139–158, doi:10.1177/1354856510394539.
80
---. “I Tweet Honestly, I Tweet Passionately: Twitter Users, Context Collapse, and the
Imagined Audience.” New Media & Society, vol. 13, no. 1, 2010, pp. 114–133,
doi:10.1177/1461444810365313.
Mathews, Bejoy et al. "History Of Yoga". Yoga Basics, 2019,
http://www.yogabasics.com/learn/history-of-yoga/. Accessed 3 June 2019.
McLuhan, Marshall. Understanding Media. Cambridge MA: MIT Press, 1994 (1964).
McNely, Brian J. “Shaping organizational image-power through images: Case histories of
Instagram.” IEEE International Professional Communication Conference, 2012, pp.1-
8. IEEE, doi: 10.1109/IPCC.2012.6408624. Accessed 8 May 2019.
“Meet the Alo Yoga Family.” Alo Yoga, www.aloyoga.com/pages/meet-the-alo-yoga-family.
Accessed 20 June 2019.
Mirzoeff, Nicholas. “The Age of Photography.” An Introduction to Visual Culture, 1999, pp. 65
– 88. Routledge: Social Science.
Morrison, Mady. “#yogamitmady - Yoga Community.”
https://www.facebook.com/groups/736511383221956/about/. Accessed 22 May
2019.
Newlyn, Emma-Louise. “The Niyamas - Svadhyaya or Self-Study | Ekhart Yoga.” Ekhart
Yoga Online, www.ekhartyoga.com/articles/philosophy/the-niyamas-svadhyaya-or-
self-study. Accessed 20 June 2019.
Nir, Claudi. “Identity construction on Facebook.” 2012,
http://www.academia.edu/1878518/Identity_Construction_on_Facebook. Accessed
19 June 2019.
Norman, Donald. The Design of Everyday Things. New York: Doubleday Business,
1990.
O’Leary, Lizzie, and Paulina Velasco. "The Industry Of Wellness, By The Numbers".
Marketplace.Org, 2019, https://www.marketplace.org/2018/01/04/world/wellness-
craze-numbers. Accessed 24 May 2019.
81
Peters, Tom. “The Brand Called You.” The Brand Called You, Fast Company, 18 May 2016,
www.fastcompany.com/28905/brand-called-you. Accessed 16 May 2019.
Raphael, Rina. "These 10 Market Trends Turned Wellness Into A $4.2 Trillion Global
Industry". Fast Company, 2019, https://www.fastcompany.com/90247896/these-10-
market-trends-turned-wellness-into-a-4-2-trillion-global-industry. Accessed 24 May
2019.
Rasmussen, Leslie. “Parasocial Interaction in the Digital Age: An Examination of
Relationship Building and the Effectiveness of YouTube Celebrities”. The Journal of
Social Media in Society, vol. 7., no.1, 2018, pp. 280-294.
Rogers, Richard A. "From Cultural Exchange To Transculturation: A Review And
Reconceptualization Of Cultural Appropriation". Communication Theory, vol. 16, no.
4, 2006, pp. 474-503. Oxford University Press (OUP), doi: 10.1111/j.1468-
2885.2006.00277.x.
Ryan, Carrie. “Why Are Podcasts Gaining In Popularity?” Forbes, Forbes Magazine, 12 Oct.
2018, www.forbes.com/sites/quora/2018/10/12/why-are-podcasts-gaining-in-
popularity/#2aae17bd5321. Accessed 6 June 2019.
Seargeant, Philip, and Caroline Tagg. The Language of Social Media: Identity and
Community on the Internet. Palgrave Macmillan, 2016.
Sherwood, Harriet. "Mindfulness At Risk Of Being 'Turned Into A Free Market Commodity'".
The Guardian, 2019,
https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2015/oct/28/mindfulness-free-market-
commodity-risk. Accessed 25 May 2019.
Smith, Lauren R. and Jimmy Sanderson. “I'm Going to Instagram It! An Analysis of Athlete
Self-Presentation on Instagram”. Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media, vol. 59,
no. 2, 2015, pp. 342-358. ResearchGate, doi: 10.1080/08838151.2015.1029125.
Accessed 18 June 2019.
Sontag, Susan. On Photography. RosettaBooks, 2005.
82
Strange, Adario. “You can now post 60-second videos on Instagram.” Mashable. 29 March
2016, https://mashable.com/2016/03/29/instagram-video-60-seconds/. Accessed 19
June 2019.
Sun, Heshan et al. "Choosing A Fit Technology: Understanding Mindfulness In Technology
Adoption And Continuance". AIS Electronic Library (Aisel), 2019,
https://aisel.aisnet.org/jais/vol17/iss6/2/.
Systrom, Kevin. “Welcome to IGTV.” Instagram, 20 June 2018, instagram-
press.com/blog/2018/06/20/welcome-to-igtv/.
Tiggemann, Marika, and Mia Zaccardo. "“Exercise To Be Fit, Not Skinny”: The Effect Of
Fitspiration Imagery On Women's Body Image". Body Image, vol. 15, 2015, pp. 61-
67. Elsevier BV, doi:10.1016/j.bodyim.2015.06.003.
Tiggemann, Marika, et al. “Tweeting Weight Loss: A Comparison of #Thinspiration and
#Fitspiration Communities on Twitter.” Body Image, vol. 25, 2018, pp. 133–138.,
doi:10.1016/j.bodyim.2018.03.002.
Tiidenberg, Katrin, and Nancy K. Baym. “Learn It, Buy It, Work It: Intensive Pregnancy on
Instagram.” Social Media Society, vol. 3, no. 1, 2017, pp. 1-13. doi:
10.1177/2056305116685108.
Tiidenberg, Katrin, and Edgar Gómez Cruz. "Selfies, Image And The Re-Making Of The
Body". Body & Society, vol 21, no. 4, 2015, pp. 77-102. SAGE Publications,
doi:10.1177/1357034x15592465.
Toffoletti, Kim, and Holly Thorpe. "The Athletic Labour Of Femininity: The Branding And
Consumption Of Global Celebrity Sportswomen On Instagram". Journal Of Consumer
Culture, vol. 18, no. 2, 2018, pp. 298-316. SAGE Publications,
doi:10.1177/1469540517747068.
Treem, Jeffrey and Paul Leonardi. “Social media use in organizations: Exploring the
affordances of visibility, editability, persistence, and association.” Communication
yearbook, vol. 36, 2012, pp. 143–189.
83
Stanfill, Mel. “The Interface as Discourse: The Production of Norms Through Web Design”.
New Media & Society, vol. 17., no. 7, 2015, pp.1059-1074.
Vásquez, Camilla. ‘“Usually Not One to Complain but...”: Constructing Identities in User-
Generated Online Reviews.” The Language of Social Media: Identity and Community
on the Internet, Palgrave Macmillan, 2014, pp. 65–90.
van Dijck, José. “‘You Have One Identity’: Performing the Self on Facebook and
LinkedIn.” Media, Culture & Society, vol. 35, no. 2, 2013, pp. 199–215,
doi:10.1177/0163443712468605.
---. “Digital Photography: Communication, Identity, Memory.” Visual Communication, vol. 7,
no. 1, 2008, pp. 57–76, doi:10.1177/1470357207084865.
van Dijck, José, and Thomas Poell. “Understanding Social Media Logic”. Media and
Communication, vol. 1, no.1, 2013, pp. 2-14, doi:
http://dx.doi.org/10.17645/mac.v1i1.70
Walther, Joseph B. “Computer-mediated communication: Impersonal, interpersonal, and
hyperpersonal interaction.” Communication Research, vol. 23, no.1, 1996, pp. 3-43.
Webb, Jennifer B., et al. “Downward Dog Becomes Fit Body, Inc.: A Content Analysis of 40
Years of Female Cover Images of Yoga Journal.” Body Image, vol. 22, 2017, pp.
129–135., doi:10.1016/j.bodyim.2017.07.001.
Wee, Lionel, and Ann Brooks. “Personal Branding and the Commodification of Reflexivity.”
Cultural Sociology, vol. 4, no. 1, 2010, pp. 45–62, doi:10.1177/1749975509356754.
Wellman, Barry, Anabel Quan-Haase, Jeffrey Boase et al.“The Social Affordances of the
Internet for Networked Individualism.” Journal of Computer-Mediated
Communication, vol.8, no.3, 2003, doi: 10.1111/j.1083-6101.2003.tb00216.x.
White, David Gordon, editor. Yoga in Practice. Princeton University Press, 2012, JSTOR,
doi: doi: 10.2307/j.ctvcm4gpf.
Wissinger, Elizabeth. “Modelling a Way of Life: Immaterial and Affective Labour in the
Fashion Modelling Industry.” Ephemera, vol. 7, no. 1, 2017, pp. 250-269.
84
Yilmaz, Kaya. “Comparison of Quantitative and Qualitative Research Traditions:
Epistemological, Theoretical, and Methodological Differences.” European Journal of
Education, vol. 48, no. 2, 2013, pp. 311–325., doi:10.1111/ejed.12014.
“Yoga With Adriene.” YouTube. YouTube, n.d.
https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=yoga+with+adriene. Accessed 2
May 2019.
Young, Kirsty. “Managing online identity and diverse social networks on Facebook”
Webology, vol. 10, no. 2, 2013, pp. 1-18.
http://www.webology.org/2013/v10n2/a109.pdf.
Zambarakji, Ahmed. "Kale, Hot Yoga, And The Rise Of The Wellness Market - Raconteur".
Raconteur, 2019, https://www.raconteur.net/retail/kale-hot-yoga-and-the-rise-of-the-
wellness-market. Accessed 15 May 2019.
Zhao, Shanyang, et al. “Identity Construction on Facebook: Digital Empowerment in
Anchored Relationships.” Computers in Human Behavior, vol. 24, no. 5, 2008, pp.
1816–1836., doi:10.1016/j.chb.2008.02.012.
85
APPENDIX
Please use the following link to access the Google drive folder holding the complete data
set the analysis is based on (screenshots of the posts and captured files of Instagram
stories) as well as a folder containing exclusively those stories referenced in the text:
https://drive.google.com/open?id=1CshDFDpazRJ-gktDe0P6ymr_7aVANYFL