Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-1
VX[N%!"+7?D31@;7F=^U&TJ\
ĚŸ ƅDžɍƷĕ ŗà ƞÕĉƯƼĿ ƟûȎƍƸĉƯƼZ�]�
230-0045 ƶĄĖƭŷƈĚɊǺÖŧġƤ 1-7-22
Yasunori Ichihashi, Atsushi Fukushima Frontiers of Transcriptomics in Plant Science
Key words: Gene co-expression, Library preparation, Network analysis, RNA-seq, Transcriptome
RIKEN Center for Sustainable Resource Science, Yokohama, Kanagawa, 230-0045 Japan
���'#)%�
� RiyȦÅ,ǽȅA�#��+ɍĂȬ,b�]A¢ljƩ+Ł�ŀƃ'=KxOXǽū�
ą4# ɋFukushima and Kusano 2014Ɍ��,�'8c~�XO�qc�yǽū-ɍRiy�
;ŢǏƩ*ǴƝô0(ĹøAŸƋ��=ȓÀơƖº¢AŞ;�+�=�(+:<ɍƠçƝȋ
,ƞǽ+ă��ȍƛ�=ɋIchihashi et al. 2015; Ichihashi and Sinha 2014Ɍ�ź��V�Q�T�
,łdzȞż+:<ȂƠ� RNA-seq-ɍc~�XO�qc�yǽū,LjĢAăĞ+Ĥ���
=((8+ɍÛƞƩ+)B*ƠƖƹ+��&8c~�XO�qc�yǽūAȢƢßǦ(�
ɋWang et al. 2009Ɍ�ĮŪ,jFp�^F[�V}�+:=wFO�D�F9T�M�ƃ+÷
%�V�Q�Xłdz(ž1&ɍRNA-seq -Ȥ�ćƨƝ,ŲÃDžð�ġ� 7c~�XO�q
c�y,ǸȹķAŻư+ŲÃ'�=ɋMader et al. 2011Ɍ��;+Śǻ,ȓÀơƖɍsmall RNAsɍ
alternative splicing variantsAŲÃ'�ɍȓÀơƖ,ú÷ȦÅAƫŎȅ6�(+:< SNPsɍfusion
transcriptɍȓÀȲąƐ8ãČ�=�(�ßǦ(*=ɋOzsolak and Milos 2011Ɍ��,:�+
RNA-seq +:=c~�XO�qc�yǽū-ɍƠƖĉÄȫºǪ+��&ƮȊƨǺAÏț�&
�=�
� ź��V�Q�T�,q~`ct�y-ĝ+ŕǫ�>ɍV�Q�Xb�],Ȭ�ȏ(8+
ăĞ+ä��&�=��, 7ɍ�ĭ�;+ă�*XQ��'čɇ�ßǦ(*=�(-ĺ´
+Ⱥ�*�����*�;ɍ RNA-seq~Fp~��£Ľ-�4!ÑÍɍšȳɍSXc���
<ăǻŶ*q�WHOc0,ĔȲ,Éȵǹî(*#&�=�Ï &ɍ ( ăǻŶ,b�]
Aŀ+�>=�(�'� (�&8ɍĂȬ'�$Ǹȹ*b�],ǽūŀƃ+$�&8X]�
^�d*śƃ�4!*� 7ɍĂ�,Q�X'ƠƖĉƩĻæAĤ�Ã��(�'��+b�
]�õƂ�=ĸ>�=���'ŨǖȄ'-�>;,ëɄA¸Ť'�=ŢŚ,~Fp~��
£Ľłdz�:/ăǻŶb�]ǽūŀƃAǎ��ɍűƖƸĉ+��=Ś��ƯƼĔȲ+$�&
ǠĐ�=�
植物科学最前線 7:110 (2016)
BSJ-Review 7:110 (2016)
Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-2
��������� ?/:?@FIQR]�
� ��'-ź��V�Q�T�,�':�¥@>&�= Illumina Ƶ,q~`ct�yƢ,~
Fp~��£Ľ+$�&Ȉ�=�
�����H($&?/:?@FIQR]��
� Ɲò4',śƃ(�& Illumina Ƶ� 2012 ĠĨš+ƨÿ� jFX��q`cƢ, TruSeq
RNA sample preparation kitA8(+ RNA-seq~Fp~��£Ľ,÷ŨƩ*Xa`q+$�&
ȄŞ�=ɋñ 1AɌ�4�ƠƖǐǛ�; total RNAAņÃ�ɍmRNAALjǷ�=�į;> mRNA
+$�&�©ȷFK�AƢ�&řƔÕ�=�řƔÕ� mRNAA8(+ 2Ũȯ cDNAâĽA
Dz���,ĭɍI�d�sD�+:< 5’ŧƿ���ȨÕ�> ğƏŧƿ, cDNAřƔAį=�
A a���P+:< 3’ŧƿ+ A A�Ï�ɍTA O��f�PAÈƢ�&D^q]�A cDNA
řƔ,�ƿ+Ŏǔ��=��ǿ,ȧNjÝĵ�(+ɍsolid-phase reversible immobilization ɋSRRIɌ
Ʊſķm�YA¥�LjǷ�ɍ¤�& cDNAřƔ,TFYA=�Č,ă��+ȣŅ�&���
į;> D^q]��� cDNAřƔA PCRüĞ�&ɍRNA-seq~Fp~���ċĽ�=��
,śƃ-ɍƠƖǐǛ�;�:� 3 ŝȳ' 24 ~Fp~��£Ľ�ßǦ'=��,:�+
RNA-seq ~Fp~��£Ľ-ɍĨš,łdz'jFX��q`cAĶɃ+Ȳƨ�> śƃ'
#&8ɍÑÍ�šȳ�SXc���#&� �
����� �������� ��� ��������c ��d?/:?@FIQR]��
� ��'ǯǡ;-:<jFX��q`c* RNA-seqAčƝ�= 7ɍLJª�ȗț�Ċ©+'
�=śƃAȲƨ� ɋHTRɍKumar et al. 2012Ɍ��, HTR'-ɍIlluminaƵ,śƃA8(+
��,Ɛ+$�&ă��ŕǫ� Ɏ1ɌǐǛ�;ƫŎ mRNA AņÃ�=ɍ2ɌmRNA '*�
cDNAAřƔÕ�=ɍ3ɌcDNAřƔ,ŧƿ¬ɆÝĵ,º&A SRRIm�Y�'Dz�ɋFisher et
al. 2011Ɍɍ4Ɍ96k�S�dAD^q]�+ǐ5Ȗ6ɋñ 1BɌ��>;,ŕǫ+:<ɍƠƖǐ
Ǜ�; 2ŝȳ' 96~Fp~��£Ľ�ßǦ(*<ɍĮŪ,śƃ+ž1& 6®,jFX��q
`cÕ�čƝ� ��;+SXc8Ĩš,Ěù©ů+��& 3-11®ÊƊ�=�(+ĽÎ� �
Ï &ɍ~Fp~��,ȏ8 IlluminaƵ,śƃ(23ãǁ'<ɍ6�?�u\�y RNA,
S�]xh�V}��Ē*�ǫȏ,8,'# �HTR( IlluminaƵ,q�cS��A¥#
&ã�T�q�Z`c+$�&Ȥ�ćƨƝ,ĘƧAǽū�=(ɍăÙ,Ȥ�ćǝ+$�&-
�q�cS��+:#&ŲÃ�> �ɍq�cS��ȳ'Ƨ*=ŋÓAƳ�Ȥ�ćǝ8Ă�
Ǻ$�# ��, 7ɍƧ*=q�cS��'į T�q�A�Ǘ+ǽū�=ȸ-q�cS
��ȳ,ȡ�+×ÄƄĻ�1�'=�4 �í,ǽūǒŬ�;-ɍHTR,2��łdzƩÝ
ıȳ',ȃĘ�Ē*� 7ɍǓǾƩŲÃÍ�ɉ�b�]AÃ��(8@�# �
� �,śƃ-Ğġ�űƖƹ+ĵƢ'�ɍƝò4'+Ă�,ǭŨűƖ+Ï &ɍƀÄAĂ�å
6DZɅɋCaulerpa taxifoliaɌ9�Pf��ǰƻ� ŦŨ,űƖɋGevuina avellanaɌ'8ɉ�Lj
植物科学最前線 7:111 (2016)
BSJ-Review 7:111 (2016)
Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-3
Ģ,b�]AÞį�&�=ɋRanjan et al. 2015; Ostria-Gallardo et al., unpublishedɌ�4 �,ś
ƃAƢ�=�('ăǻŶ* RNA-seqADz��(�ßǦ(*# �¦ .ɍǯǡ;-cwc(
Șǚƹȳ, Introgression line 76ljǓ+��& RNA-seqǽūɋƠƖĉƩÝıAÏ &ɍ�:�
300T�q�ɌADz�ɍ introgression,ûƦA�ú÷�r�'ƗČ� ɋChitwood et al. 2013aɌ�
ãš+�,b�]A¥#&ɍȤ�ćƨƝAȬƩĩȏ(Ł�ɍ�>+ĪȽ�=RiyɂöAƗ
Č�= expression quantitative trait locusɋeQTLɌǽūADz��('ɍȤ�ćƨƝÉİARiy
�r�'Ş;�+�=�(�'� ɋRanjan et al., unpublishedɌ�
���������������������������������� ������c������d?/:?@FIQR]�
� ǯǡ;-ȘĠɍ�;+LJªɍɉțɍȐ¡©ůAčƝ� śƃAȲƨ� ɋBrADseqɍTownsley
et al. 2015Ɍ��, BrADseq'-ɍ�ǿ, HTR+=Xa`qAŕì� !�'*�ɍD^q
]��ÏA 2Ũȯ cDNAâĽ((8+Dz�śƃAƚǧ+Ȳƨ�ɍq�cS��+Þ<¹>
ɋñ 1CɌ�½¢Ʃ+- 2ŨȯŮȨ,ŧƿ�ÕĉƩƗķ+:#&Ȳȱ�=ƝȋAÈƢ�&ɋvon
Hippel et al. 2013Ɍɍ5’ŧƿƗƧƩ+D^q]�Aǐ5Ȗ6�(+ĽÎ� ��, BrADseq-ɍ
ǐǛ�; # 6 šȳ' 96 ~Fp~��£Ľ�ßǦ(*<ɍSXc8 HTR :<8�;+ 7
®ɍĮŪ,śƃ:<8 21-77®ÊƊ'� �Ï & strand-specificity,=~Fp~��'
= 7ɍĹøȬ�:<·č� b�]AÞį�=�(�'�=�HTR( BrADseq,q�cS
��'Ȥ�ćƨƝ,ĘƧAžȕ�=(ɍȻĝ+ɉ�Ƭȴ�į;> 7ɍHTR (ãŴ+
BrADseq8ǓǾƩŲÃÍ�ɉ�b�]AÃ��(�'�=�
� �ś'�ǿ,śƃ�ā+8ŘĂ�, RNA-seq~Fp~��£Ľśƃ�Ȳƨ�>&�&�=�
¦ .ɍdUTP A¥# strand-specific~Fp~��9Ă�,T�q�Aq���& 1Ýĵ'
~Fp~��£ĽADz�śƃ�<ɍ�>;84 ƚǧ+SXc^G�9jFX��q`c
Õ�čƝ�>&�=ɋShishkin et al. 2015; Wang et al. 2011Ɍ��, 7 RNA-seq+:=ǕǜƩ
Ȥ�ćƨƝǽū-ɍ�,Ȥ�ćAđȋ(� ČȬƩ PCR,:�*ƨƝǽū+Þ#&�@<ɍ
:<ȒȘ*łdz+*=(ǯǡ;-�ƌ�&�=�
植物科学最前線 7:112 (2016)
BSJ-Review 7:112 (2016)
Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-4
ñ 1. RNA-seq~Fp~��£Ľśƃ(ǹ�=ŝŘ,žȕ
ɋAɌIlluminaƵ, TruSeq RNA sample preparation kitɍɋBɌHTRɍɋCɌBrADseq~Fp~��£Ľ,�
�Oo���ȘĠ,łdzȲƨ+:<ɍȚĝ 3ŝ' 24T�q�,(�?�ɍ6šȳ' 96T�q�(��
jFX��q`cÕ�čƝ�> �
���6F4^U��
� ��'- RNA-seq,b�]ǽū,�"ɍ�Ƈ,ȦÅǽū+$�&'-*�ɍăǻŶ*b�
]Z`c+:<ǓǾƩ*ëɄ�Ơ�9��ɍƨƝȬAǃÃ�ŻǻÕ� ĭ,b�]ǽūŀƃ
+$�&Ȉ�=ɋñ 2AɌ�
�����KLaEMLa^U��
� Ëș� ~Fp~��£Ľłdz,ȼŚ+:<ɍĮŪ:<8-=�+ăǻŶ*čɇ�ßǦ(
*=�ś'ɍb�],¿Ď�ǸȹÕ�&�=�(�Ďş+ĺ´'�=�¾ôƩKxOXb�
],ǽūDq��_(�&-ɍ2 ǝȳ',žȕ�Țĝ:�Dz@>&�=�ºƨƝȤ�ć+$
�& 2 ǝȳ,ƨƝȬ,ğó,ĘAŲÃ�ɍt ŲČɋŻǻÄě�;b�]�į;>&�=�(
�ËŐɌ*),�ȄŲČA=ţĻƀƎ'Dz�(+:<ɍđȋ(�= 2 ǝȳ'ƨƝŴģ�Ƨ
*=�ï,Ȥ�ćǝ ɋdifferentially expressed genes, DEGsɌ AãČ'�= ɋñ 2BɌ�DEGs
ǽū+-��dŘ�Ȍ,�ɀÄě+Į��(A�Č� ŀƃ'= edgeRɋRobinson et al.
2010Ɍ9 DEseqɋAnders et al. 2013Ɍ*),Ǿǃ\oc R'ÈƢ'�=l`Q�W�Ɲò:�
植物科学最前線 7:113 (2016)
BSJ-Review 7:113 (2016)
Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-5
ÈƢ�>&�=��;+�Ƈǽū(�&ɍ�>; DEGs+$�& Gene ontologyɋGOɌǽū9
Gene set enrichmentɋGSEɌǽūADz��('ɍƗČ,ŹǦ9�ȉǑȑ+ȴ��=Ȥ�ćǝ�
DEGs¿+ǓǾƩţĻ+Ă�Ĉò�&�=�ŲČ�=�(�'�ɋHung et al. 2012Ɍɍ2ǝȳ'
,Ȥ�ćƨƝ,ȡ�AƗIJ%�=�(�'�=�
� šljÅb�]*),Ǹȹ*b�]+$�&-ĂĀȬǽūADz��('ǺȚ��:�*=
ɋñ 2CɌ�¦ .ɍƨƝl]��AņÃ�=ƪƩ'ɍk-means clustering9 hierarchical clustering
(�# O~X]��Pǽū�:�¥@>&�=ɋAndreopoulos et al. 2009Ɍ�4 ƨƝl]�
�,º¢Ʃ*ƗIJAŃő�=ƪƩ'ɍ�ĽÄÄū9Ăź¶ēĢųĽƃ�:�¥@>=��>
;-ĂĀȬb�],ĀŘ+Ȫ5A$�&ĒŘ,âĽĀŘA£=�(+:<ɍĂź¶b�]A
:<¡ź¶+�=�('b�],ǽȩAÐ�=��;+ă�*XQ��,b�]'-ɍǸŘ
,ǹî�¹>ćƘ+*# ĂĀȬb�]+*=Q�X�Ǡ ;>=�ŢȘɍ���# Ăź
¶b�]Aǽū�=ŀƃ(�&ĭș�= ΔPCAƢ� superSOMO~X]��Pǽū�ţÒ
'=�(�Ƴ�> ɋChitwood et al. 2013bɌ�SOM-ɍǧęǐǛÕw`qɋSelf-organizing
mapsɌ(���ėƶǑíȑh`c��O,�ƹ'ɍŖĜ*�ĉǟ+:#&¹Íb�]A�Ļ
,ź¶0À´�=�(�'�=ɋWehrens and Buydens 2007Ɍ�Ɨ+ superSOM-ɍĀŘ�(+
Ȫ5���'�= 7ɍĂź¶b�],O~X]��Pǽū+Ƣ�=�(�'�=���'
Ăź¶b�]ɋ¦ .ɍƧ*=Âƞũ�+��=šljÅ,Ȥ�ćƨƝAžȕ�=Ɍ�;ǹî
ȳ,Ƭ�£Ƣɋ¦ .ɍÂƞ × šȳ,Ƭ�£ƢɌAņÃ�= 7ɍ4��ĽÄÄū+:<º
b�]A¡ź¶ƽȳɋPC spaceɌ�+w`q�&ɍƧ*=ǹî,ȳ'ĀÕ�=Ȥ�ćA PC space
�',ĀÕȬɋΔPCɌ(�& PCȔ�(+Ǿǃ�=�º ΔPC+$�&ɍĀŘ�(+Ȫ5��
�'�=O~X]��Pśƃ'= superSOM 'ǽū�=�(+:<ɍƧ*=ǹîȳ',Ƭ
�£Ƣɋ¦ .ɍƧ*=Âƞũ��'šljÅ,Ȥ�ćƨƝl]���ĀÕ�=ƗIJɌAVX
ay�r�'ǿș�ƞǽ�=�(�'�=��,:�*ǽū+:#&ɍĮŪ,sD�FY
DEGs ǽū9O~X]��Pǽū'-ŲÃ'�*�Ȥ�ćƨƝ,^FexOX�Ş;�+*
=�¦ . Chitwood et al.ɋ2013bɌ'-ɍcwc(Șǚƹ,Ƨ*=ǐǛ+��= RNA-seqb
�]A¥#&ɍΔPC AƢ� superSOM O~X]��PǽūAĵƢ�=�(+:<ɍƹȳ'
,ǐǛÇ,Ȥ�ćƨƝl]��,ĀÕ,ƗIJAŞ;�+� ��,�'ɍcwc,Ȥ�ć-
Șǚƹ,ƬãȤ�ć+ž1&ɍz�XayAå6ǐǛ'ɉ�ƨƝɍÄÕ� ǐǛ'-¡�ƨ
ƝAƳ�³ä+<ɍ�>-ƹȳ,z�Xay,ă��,ȡ�AÝŠ�&� �
�����857CF1^U�
� ƠƖƹ�Ƴ�Ŵ�*Ɲȋ,Ă�-ɍŘØ�;Ř�,Ƨ*=Ȥ�ćǝ,Ǹȹ*Éİh`c�
�O,Ō=ǩ�+¨Ĉ�=��,:�*Ǹȹ*VXayAƞǽ�= 7+ɍȤ�ćÉİh`
c��O,ŏČ(�,{W|��ɋTph`c��OɌ,ÒƜƩ*ãČ-ɍƝ�,VXay
ƠƖĉ+��=�ijƩȆɄ,�$'=�T�q�Ř�üÏ� c~�XO�qc�yb�
植物科学最前線 7:114 (2016)
BSJ-Review 7:114 (2016)
Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-6
]-ɍȤ�ć X―Ȥ�ć Y ƨƝl]��ȳ,Ʌ�ķɋ¼ƨƝɌAǕǜƩ+ȇ1=Ȥ�ć¼ƨ
Ɲh`c��OǽūɋȤ�ćAƐ�Ȥ�ćȳȴȝķAǘ'Ǵ�h`c��OɌA�;+ħÍ
+�=ɋñ 2DɌ��,ƨƝl]��ȳ,ȴȝķAȇ1=Ʌ�ķēĢ+$�&-ɍnD\�Ƭ
ȴ«Ř ɋr-ɍ�ĀŘ X, Y(,ȴ«ķ,ʼnŵɍ-1 < r < 1,°A(=Ɍ �Ţ8:�¥@>&
�=ɋde Siqueira Santos et al. 2014Ɍ����ɍnD\�Ƭȴ«Ř-ɍƨƝl]��ȳ,ƫǘȴ
«,5�ŏČßǦ'<ɍā>° ɋ�,°+ž1&ȸƾ#&Ƨ*=°Ɍ +�@7&ĥ��
�, 7ɍƫǘ,5*;�ÚȇüƊ+ȴ�&ŏČ�ßǦ'ā>°+ħ�XnDw�,Ɂ Ƭ
ȴ«Ř,ȢƢ8ţÒ'=�4 Ȥ�ć X( Y(,ȳ,Ƭȴȴ«�Ĉò�&8ɍǀ 3,Ȥ�
ć Z A�� Ǻ���,Ƭȴȴ«AǺ&�=Q�X8=��,:�*ĪȽAȶ� 7+ɍ
±Ƭȴ«Ř�ÈƢ'�=ɋde la Fuente et al. 2004Ɍ�
� Ȥ�ć X―Ȥ�ć Y ƨƝl]��ȳ,ȴ«ķ-ƫǘɋǘĩɌȴ«,5*;�Ŵ�*Ȼǘĩ
ȴ«�å4>=ßǦķ�=��, 7ĹøƞȈ+÷%�ɍX( Y(�¼ţ�=ĹøȬAƌ
=Ƭ�ĹøȬA¥# 2ĀŘȳ,ȴ«ķ,ŏČ���B+ƯƼ�>&�=ɋVinga 2014ɏWang
and Huang 2014; Liu 2015Ɍ�ȘĠ'-ɍŢăĹø«ŘɍMaximal Information CoefficientɋMICɍ
Reshef et al. 2011Ɍ9 Hilbert-Schmidt Independence CriteriaɋHSICɍGretton et al. 2005Ɍ�ĀŘ
ȳ,Ȼǘĩȴ«AČȬ�=�21�NJ,Ƭȴ�*)(ƪ�>&�=�4 ɍǘĩ�Řŀƃ+÷
%�&ĀŘȳ,ƫŎƩ¨ĈķAŏČ�= network deconvolution8ŐŰ�>&�=ɋFeizi et al.
2013Ɍ� !Ȥ�ć¼ƨƝȴ«,ŏČ+ȵ# ùâɍƬ�ĹøȬ+÷%�ŀƃ�Ƭȴ+ž1&
Ĵ��8µ>&�=@�'-*�ɍùâ+:#&-ā>°+ħ�Ƭȴ«Ř biweight
midcorrelation� MICAÁ��(�Ƴ�>&�=ɋSong et al. 2012Ɍ�
� �ǿ,:�*h`c��Oǽū�;ɍȤ�ćƨƝ,5,b�]'=+8��@;�ɍȤ
�ćÉİh`c��O,�ȥAŏČ�=�(�'�=�čȸǯǡ;8cwc(Șǚƹ+��
=Ǯ,Ƨ*=ƨƠXa�W, RNA-seqb�]�;ɍǮ,ĩļȞÕ+Ȫǹ*Ȥ�ćÉİh`c
��O,{W|��AŏČ�ɍčɇb�]+:#&�,ǒŬAŔň� ɋIchihashi et al. 2014Ɍ�
Ï &ɍh`c��Oǽū�;Ȥ�ćŹǦAŏČ�=�(8ßǦ'=ɋHansen et al. 2014Ɍ�
ƨƝl]����&�=Ȥ�ćãþ-ŹǦ��&�=(ťĬ�>= 7ɍŹǦŜƮ,Ȥ�ć
AMFd(�&Ȥ�ćŹǦ�ƌ�'�=ɋAoki et al. 2007; Usadel et al. 2009Ɍ��,śƃ-ɍű
Ɩ,Ǎǥý9�ź�ȉƖ+ȴȝ� Ȥ�ć,ŹǦǽū'�,ĆÍAƨŒ�&� ɋSaito et al.
2008Ɍ��� 10 Ġ,ȳ+»¼ÈƢßǦ*b�]AÈƢ� ¼ƨƝb�]AŐ§�=b�]r
�X�ůŽ+ü &�=�Æť,ȿ-{b�űƖV�FgeYe��ij'# �ɍŢȘ'
-ƹȳ'¼ƨƝȴ«,žȕ8ßǦ+*#&�&�= 7ɋǴ 1Ɍɍh`c��Oǽū�;Ă�
,Ȫǹ*ƠƖĉƩ*Ļæ�ņÃ'�=!?��
�����6.9-BD2>A857CF1�
� �;+Ǹȹ*ƠƖƝȋAƞǽ�=�'ɍƧ*=h`c��OAžȕ�=ŀƃ�Ĵǹ(*=�
植物科学最前線 7:115 (2016)
BSJ-Review 7:115 (2016)
Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-7
��'ƨƝĘƧɋDEGsɌ(Ȥ�ć¼ƨƝ(Aǐ5â@� ǧƒ*ŇĦ(�&ɍ¼ƨƝĘƧA
Ǡ =�(�'�=ɋñ 2EɌ��>-ɍđƓǝ�:/čɇǝ, 2 ǝȳ'Ƨ*=¼ƨƝȴ«A
ãČ�=ɍ�*@"Ƨ*=h`c��Oȳ'ĀÕ� Ƭ�£ƢAVXay�r�'Ş;�+
'�=ɋFukushima 2013; Kayano et al. 2014Ɍ�¦ .ǯǡ;-ɍcwc,Ǯ(Ŭč�;į;>
wFO�D�Fb�]AƢ� ăǻŶ*¼ƨƝĘƧh`c��O+:<ɍ�ȉǑȑ+��
=N�Xa`qAŞ;�+�&� ɋFukushima et al. 2012Ɍ�
� �;+ȘĠ'-ɍ¼ƨƝĘƧ(ȓÀîćĹø(Aǐ5â@� differential regulation analysis
ɋDRAɌ�ŐŰ�> ɋHudson et al. 2012; Yang et al. 2013; Yu et al. 2014Ɍ��>-ȓÀîćA
S�d�=Ȥ�ć+$�&ɍ2ǝȳ',ƨƝĘƧ(¼ƨƝĘƧ(A�>�>Ȫ5%��ǐ5
â@�=�('ɍ=ȓÀîć,h`c��O0,ĪȽAÝŠ� ǓǾȬ+:<Ɂ ��A
Dz��ǯǡ;�Ʈ=ȵ<űƖƸĉ',¦-4!*��ɍǂǢȏ*nI{�aƕ(èƕ�;į
;> ǸŘ,ƨȠXa�W+��=wFO�D�Fb�]:<ǃÃ� Regulatory Impact
FactorɋRIFɌǓǾȬ-ɍǂǢȏǂǢǣă,ÛîȤ�ć'=xKX]_�ɋMyostatin; MSTNɍ
ɈůǂÄÕńÉȤ�ćɌAŻ��ŏČ� ɋHudson et al. 2009Ɍ�ǨæƉ��(+ɍȚĝ:�
¥@>=Ȥ�ćƨƝȬɍƨƝĘƧɍ¼ƨƝ+÷%�b�]ǽū,��>8 MSTN,ȪǹķA
Ƴê'�*�# 7ɍDRA-c~�XO�qc�yb�]A¥# N�Ȥ�ćōnj+��
&Ś��Dq��_AŐ§�=�RIFAå7 ǸŘ, DRAŀƃ-ɍ¼ƨƝĘƧAǾǃ'�=
R,l`Q�W DCGLɋYang et al. 2013Ɍ'ÈƢßǦ'=��,�(�;b�]ǽū+��
&�,Ȥ�ć,h`c��O¿',īÌ9Ǎǥ¿S�aNXcAh`c��Oº¢�;Ȁ
©�=�(�Ȫǹ'=�(�@�<ɍĂȬ'Ǹȹ*b�]�;ţƢ*ĹøAį= 7+-ɍ
ŢŚ,ǓǾǽūƃAčǵ�&Ŋ6Ĵǹ�=�(�@�#&8; =!?��
�����0<136F4^U%!"+WPGb�
� �ǿ,b�]ǽūǒŬ+÷%�Ȥ�ćŹǦčɇ,ǾƥA�=ȸɍƄĻ�1�ƐAŋ�=Ɏ
1. ������ �� Ȥ�ćƨƝl]��ȳ,ȴ«ķųȜAŃő�=Ļæ'�@7&Ȫ
ǹ'=�¦ .ɍā>°�# ùâ,nD\�Ƭȴ«Ř+�� =Ĺø-*��
2. �!!����!����� �� :�Ôȡ��>=Q�X'=�ɍƨƝl]����
&�&8ɍĴ��8ã�ŹǦ(-ȵ;�ɍ²ƒ� l]��AƳ� ùâ8<�=�
4�&9ɍƫŎƩ*îŬȴ«AĴ��8Ƴ�@�'-Ƒ�,'ɍb�],ǽȩ+-×Ä
*ƄĻ�Ĵǹ'=�
3. ����� � ���������� � �� ÈƢ�=b�]r�X9ǽūŀƃ�
),:�*ƙ�'ɍ),:�*b�]�;ɍ),:�*Dq��_'ɍȤ�ćƨƝl]
��ȳ,Ʌ�ķAČȬ�&�=�ɍ�,Ǥĭ+=ųĺ9ƄĻƐA×Ä+ƞǽ�&čɇ
ǾƥAƾ&=�(�Ȫǹ'=�
植物科学最前線 7:116 (2016)
BSJ-Review 7:116 (2016)
Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-8
ñ 2. RNA-seq,Ȥ�ćƨƝȬb�]�;,ǽūśƃ
ɋAɌV�Q�V�P�;�Ƈǽū,ȦÅǽū��oC��X+w`q�> ��dALG�c�=�
(+:<Ȥ�ćƨƝȬAǃÃ�=ɋȚĝɍȤ�ćŘ p >>T�q�Ř nɌ�ɋB-EɌƨƝȬAǃÃ� ĭ,
b�],ǽūŀƃɍɋBɌDEGs ǽū�=Ȥ�ć A ,ƨƝȬ+Ę�=� t ŲČ*)'ȇ1=�ɋCɌ
ĂĀȬǽū,O~X]��Pǽū(�ĽÄÄū�Ȥ�ćƨƝ,l]��AņÃ�=�ɋDɌh`c��
Oǽū�ǸŘ,ƨƝb�]�;Ȥ�ćAƐ�Ȥ�ćȳȴȝķAǘ'Ǵ�h`c��OAųdž'�=�
Ȥ�ć�Ȥ�ć,ȴ«ķ-ɍƫǘȴ«ɋǘĩȴ«ɌAƳ�ùâ(ɍȻǘĩȴ«AƳ�ùâ�<ɍƬ
ȴ(ĹøƞȈ(+÷%�Ʌ�ķēĢ��>�>ÈƢ'�=�ɋEɌ¼ƨƝĘƧǽū�2$,ũ�ȳ'á�
ƌČ�> Ȥ�ćǝȳ,¼ƨƝl]��-ɍ2ũ�ȳ'Ƨ*=ùâ�=��>;¼ƨƝĘƧȤ�ć+
-ɍȮȧNjȤ�ć9ȓÀȇDŽîć*)�å4>=ßǦķ�ɉ��
��
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
植物科学最前線 7:117 (2016)
BSJ-Review 7:117 (2016)
Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-9
�
&1 $)�'��%� " (������
��
��$
����
�*����
#�(��������!��
URL
PLA
NET
Ara
bido
psis,
bar
ley,
med
icag
o,po
plar
, ric
e, so
ybea
n, w
heat
,br
achy
podi
umm
icro
arra
yPC
C an
d re
cipr
ocal
rank
PFA
MM
utw
il et
al.
Plan
t Cel
l, 20
11ht
tp://
aran
et.m
pim
p-go
lm.m
pg.d
e/
ATTE
D-II
Ara
bido
psis,
fiel
d m
usta
rd,
soyb
ean,
med
ick,
pop
lar,
tom
ato,
grap
e, ri
ce, m
aize
mic
roar
ray
and
RNA
-seq
wei
ghte
d PC
C an
dm
utua
l ran
kA
oki e
t al.
PCP,
201
5ht
tp://
atte
d.jp
/
CoP
Ara
bido
psis,
bar
ley,
pop
lar,
rice,
soyb
ean,
whe
at, g
rape
, mai
zem
icro
arra
yco
sine
corre
latio
nRe
cipr
ocal
Bes
t BLA
STH
itO
gata
et a
l. Bi
oinf
orm
atic
s,20
10ht
tp://
web
s2.k
azus
a.or
.jp/k
agia
na/c
op09
11/
POD
C
Ara
bido
psis,
rice
, Sor
ghum
,to
mat
o, g
rape
, med
icag
o, p
otat
o,so
ybea
nRN
A-s
eq
corre
spon
dens
e an
alys
isan
d Pe
arso
n's c
orre
latio
nco
effic
ient
Orth
oMCL
Ohy
anag
i et a
l. PC
P, 2
015
http
://bi
oinf
.min
d.m
eiji.
ac.jp
/pod
c/
STA
RNET
2
hum
an, r
at, m
ouse
, chi
cken
,ze
braf
ish, D
roso
phila
, C. e
lega
ns,
S. c
erev
isiae
, Ara
bido
psis,
rice
mic
roar
ray
PCC
NCB
I Hom
oloG
ene
Jupi
ter e
t al.
BMC
Bioi
nfor
mat
ics,
2009
http
://va
nbur
enla
b.m
edic
ine.
tam
hsc.
edu/
starn
et2.
htm
l
ECC
Ara
bido
psis,
rice
mic
roar
ray
PCC
Orth
oMCL
Mov
ahed
i et a
l. Pl
ant P
hysio
l,20
11ht
tp://
bioi
nfor
mat
ics.p
sb.u
gent
.be/
supp
lem
enta
ry_d
ata/
sam
ov/a
pr20
11/
Mai
ze-ri
cem
aize
, ric
em
icro
arra
yPC
CRe
cipr
ocal
Bes
t BLA
STH
itFi
cklin
and
Fel
tus,
Plan
tPh
ysio
l, 20
11ht
tp://
ww
w.cl
emso
n.ed
u/ge
nene
twor
k/ne
twor
k.ph
p
Com
PlEx
Ara
bido
psis,
pop
lar,
rice
mic
roar
ray
CLR
Orth
oMCL
Net
otea
et a
l. BM
C G
enom
ics,
2014
http
://co
mpl
ex.p
lant
geni
e.or
g/
PLA
NEX
Ara
bido
psis,
soyb
ean,
bar
ley,
rice
,to
mat
o, w
heat
, gra
pe, m
aize
mic
roar
ray
PCC
-Yi
m e
t al.
BMC
Plan
t Bio
l,20
13ht
tp://
plan
ex.p
lant
bioi
nfor
mat
ics.o
rg/
ORT
omto
mat
o, p
otat
o, to
bacc
o, p
eppe
r
EST
pres
ence
/abs
ence
prof
ileco
nser
vatio
nbi
nary
asy
mm
etric
dista
nce
the
Euka
ryot
icG
ene
Orth
olog
ues
data
base
Mio
zzi e
t al.
Plan
t Mol
Bio
l,20
10ht
tp://
orto
m.iv
v.cn
r.it/
MO
RPH
Alg
orith
mA
rabi
dops
is, to
mat
om
icro
arra
yPC
C-
Tzfa
dia
et a
l. Pl
ant C
ell,
2012
http
://bi
oinf
orm
atic
s.psb
.uge
nt.b
e/w
ebto
ols/m
orph
/*
PCC,
Pea
rson
's co
rrela
tion
coef
ficie
nt; C
LR,
Cont
ext L
ikel
ihoo
d of
Rel
ated
ness
植物科学最前線 7:118 (2016)
BSJ-Review 7:118 (2016)
Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-10
���!,*%��
� �ĭ,űƖƸĉ+��&c~�XO�qc�yǽū-),:�+ÈƢ�>&��!?�
�ɐŨǖȄ'Ƴ� :�+ɍRNA-seq �ɉĢ+jFX��q`cÕ�=�('ɍ:<ăǻŶ
*q�WHOc�ßǦ(*=��>+:<ǓǾƩ+ɉ�LjĢ,b�]Þį-8"?BɍoE
��dAđȋ(�=Ơļĉ0,ĔȲ9ɍ��,ƯƼǡ'�$,űƖƹ,c~�XO�qc�
yw`qA£Ľ'�=*)ɍŚǻȤ�ć,ƨǺ�Ïț�=!?��Ï &ɍ:<ȁǍ+ǐǛ
Ç,ƨƝǽūADz� 7+ǐǛÇq�{�]�9��U�wFO�^FZOV}�AƢ�
ƨƝǽū9ɍȘĠ,Ƈ¢Íĉ,ȞĔ+:<ßǦ(*# 1 Ǎǥ,c~�XO�qc�yǽū
8ȒȘ*łdz(*=!?�ɋPicelli et al. 2014Ɍ�4 ǀ���V�Q�T�'= 1ÄćV�
Q�T�-:<Ȱ�ȦÅAȅ6�(�'�= 7ɍȓÀơƖºȰA�Ģ+V�Q�X'�=
ɋTilgner et al. 2014Ɍ��,łdz�c~�XO�qc�yǽū+ÈƢ�>=�(+*>.ɍ:
<Ż��ƨƝȬ9 alternative splicing variantsAČȬ�=�(�'�=�
� ŨǖȄ'-ȁș�*�# �ɍV�Q�V�Pĭ,ȦÅb�]ǽū'-:<ɉț'Żư*
�oC��X0,w`n�P9Ȥ�ćƨƝȬŏČŀƃ,ƆǙ�Ɓ7;>&�=�Ï &ɍc
~�XO�qc�yb�],5*;��Ğġ�z_��y�q�aK�y�z]u��y�
oHi�y(�# Ŵ�*KxOXb�]AǓâ�ɍ��+Śǻ,ƠƖĉƩĻǞAĤ�Ã�
��ǾǃƠƖĉ�kFKF�oJwaEOXÄȫ,�ijȆɄ(*#&�=ɋCavill et al. 2015Ɍ�
Ɨ+�>;b�]AƢ� ǓâƩ*h`c��Oǽū-ɍȪǹĩȏ+ȴ��=ȮîćȤ�ć
,�ƌ9oE��d',ǴƝô�ƌADz�ÒƜƩ*{b�A8 ;�ßǦķA8"�Ȥ�ô
�ǴƝôȴȝķ,ǽŞ+ď��=��,:�*łdzȞż+:<c~�XO�qc�yAå7
KxOXǽū,đȋ�wO�+8xO�+8Ňă�ɍľ��Ǻ=�(�'�=�Ʀ�ġ�
=��ĭɍ�,Ś���ƦAǺ=�(+:#&ɍ��+�ƦǼ�*@"Ś��ƠƖĉƩƮǺ
Aƞǽ'�=��ź��,ƯƼǡ+Ɓ7;>=ȆɄ'?��
���_`�
� Ũƺ'ǎ�� ǯǡ;,ƯƼ,�ȥ-ɍƞÕĉƯƼĿ�÷ƲƸĉƗÇƯƼéÉĢ�:/Ƹ
ĉƯƼǶÐȭ�ǬŀƯƼ Bɋ15K18589ɌɋĚŸ ƅDžɌɍÜ/ƸĉƯƼǶÐȭ�ǬŀƯƼ B
ɋ26850024ɌɋƷĕ ŗàɌ,ŔœAį&ȟDz� �4 ŨƯƼAȞ7=+ <ɍŘ�,T
v�cAȾ� ɍL�oJ�fDăĉb�mXŭ�Prof. Neelima SinhaɍDr. Ravi KumarɍDr. Brad
TownsleyɍDr. Jie Pengɍde�d^�oJ�XƯƼĿ�Dr. Daniel Chitwood+ɍ�,ùA¯<
&�ƴƣ���4��
��OZSY�
Anders, S., McCarthy, D.J., Chen, Y., Okoniewski, M., Smyth, G.K., Huber, W. & Robinson, M.D.
2013. Count-based differential expression analysis of RNA sequencing data using R and
植物科学最前線 7:119 (2016)
BSJ-Review 7:119 (2016)
Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-11
Bioconductor. Nat Protoc 8:1765-1786.
Andreopoulos, B., An, A., Wang, X. & Schroeder, M. 2009. A roadmap of clustering algorithms:
finding a match for a biomedical application. Brief Bioinform 10:297-314.
Aoki, K., Ogata, Y. & Shibata, D. 2007. Approaches for extracting practical information from gene
co-expression networks in plant biology. Plant & cell physiology 48:381-390.
Aoki, Y., Okamura, Y., Tadaka, S., Kinoshita, K. & Obayashi, T. 2015. ATTED-II in 2016: A plant
coexpression database towards lineage-specific coexpression. Plant & cell physiology doi:
10.1093/pcp/pcv165.
Cavill, R., Jennen, D., Kleinjans, J. & Briedé, J.J. 2015. Transcriptomic and metabolomic data
integration. Brief Bioinform doi: 10.1093/bib/bbv090.
Chitwood, D.H., Kumar, R., Headland, L.R., Ranjan, A., Covington, M.F., Ichihashi, Y., Fulop, D.,
Jimenez-Gomez, J.M., Peng, J., Maloof, J.N. & Sinha, N.R. 2013a. A quantitative genetic basis for
leaf morphology in a set of precisely defined tomato introgression lines. The Plant cell
25:2465-2481.
Chitwood, D.H., Maloof, J.N. & Sinha, N.R. 2013b. Dynamic transcriptomic profiles between tomato
and a wild relative reflect distinct developmental architectures. Plant physiology 162:537-552.
de la Fuente, A., Bing, N., Hoeschele, I. & Mendes, P. 2004. Discovery of meaningful associations in
genomic data using partial correlation coefficients. Bioinformatics 20:3565-3574.
de Siqueira Santos, S., Takahashi, D.Y., Nakata, A. & Fujita, A. 2014. A comparative study of
statistical methods used to identify dependencies between gene expression signals. Brief Bioinform
15:906-918.
Feizi, S., Marbach, D., Medard, M. & Kellis, M. 2013. Network deconvolution as a general method to
distinguish direct dependencies in networks. Nat Biotechnol 31:726-733.
Ficklin, S.P. & Feltus, F.A. 2011. Gene coexpression network alignment and conservation of gene
modules between two grass species: maize and rice. Plant physiology 156:1244-1256.
Fisher, S., Barry, A., Abreu, J., Minie, B., Nolan, J., Delorey, T.M., Young, G., Fennell, T.J., Allen, A.,
Ambrogio, L., Berlin. A.M., Blumenstiel, B., Cibulskis, K., Friedrich, D., Johnson, R., Juhn, F.,
Reilly, B., Shammas, R., Stalker, J., Sykes, S.M., Thompson, J., Walsh, J., Zimmer, A., Zwirko, Z.,
Gabriel, S., Nicol, R. & Nusbaum, C. 2011. A scalable, fully automated process for construction of
sequence-ready human exome targeted capture libraries. Genome biology 12:R1.
Fukushima, A. 2013. DiffCorr: an R package to analyze and visualize differential correlations in
biological networks. Gene 518:209-214.
Fukushima, A. & Kusano, M. 2014. A network perspective on nitrogen metabolism from model to
crop plants using integrated 'omics' approaches. Journal of experimental botany 65:5619-5630.
Fukushima, A., Nishizawa, T., Hayakumo, M., Hikosaka, S., Saito, K., Goto, E. & Kusano, M. 2012.
植物科学最前線 7:120 (2016)
BSJ-Review 7:120 (2016)
Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-12
Exploring tomato gene functions based on coexpression modules using graph clustering and
differential coexpression approaches. Plant physiology 158:1487-1502.
Gretton, A., Bousquet, O., Smola, A. & Schölkopf, B. 2005. Measuring statistical dependence with
hilbert-schmidt norms. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg
Hansen, B.O., Vaid, N., Musialak-Lange, M., Janowski, M. & Mutwil, M. 2014. Elucidating gene
function and function evolution through comparison of co-expression networks of plants. Frontiers
in plant science 5:394.
Hudson, N.J., Dalrymple, B.P. & Reverter, A. 2012. Beyond differential expression: the quest for
causal mutations and effector molecules. BMC Genomics 13:356.
Hudson, N.J., Reverter, A. & Dalrymple, B.P. 2009. A differential wiring analysis of expression data
correctly identifies the gene containing the causal mutation. PLoS Comput Biol 5:e1000382.
Hung, J.H., Yang, T.H., Hu, Z., Weng, Z. & DeLisi, C. 2012. Gene set enrichment analysis:
performance evaluation and usage guidelines. Brief Bioinform 13:281-291.
Ichihashi, Y., Aguilar-Martinez, J.A., Farhi, M., Chitwood, D.H., Kumar, R., Millon, L.V., Peng, J.,
Maloof, J.N. & Sinha, N.R. 2014. Evolutionary developmental transcriptomics reveals a gene
network module regulating interspecific diversity in plant leaf shape. Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 111:E2616-2621.
Ichihashi, Y., Mutuku, J.M., Yoshida, S. & Shirasu, K. 2015. Transcriptomics exposes the uniqueness
of parasitic plants. Brief Funct Genomics 14:275-282.
Ichihashi, Y. & Sinha, N.R. 2014. From genome to phenome and back in tomato. Current opinion in
plant biology 18:9-15.
Jupiter, D., Chen, H. & VanBuren, V. 2009. STARNET 2: a web-based tool for accelerating discovery
of gene regulatory networks using microarray co-expression data. BMC Bioinformatics 10:332.
Kayano, M., Shiga, M. & Mamitsuka, H. 2014. Detecting differentially coexpressed genes from
labeled expression data: a brief review. IEEE/ACM Trans Comput Biol Bioinform 11:154-167.
Kumar, R., Ichihashi, Y., Kimura, S., Chitwood, D.H., Headland, L.R., Peng, J., Maloof, J.N. & Sinha,
N.R. 2012. A high-throughput method for Illumina RNA-Seq library preparation. Frontiers in
plant science 3:202.
Liu, Z.P. 2015. Reverse engineering of genome-wide gene regulatory networks from gene expression
data. Curr Genomics 16:3-22.
Mader, U., Nicolas, P., Richard, H., Bessieres, P. & Aymerich, S. 2011. Comprehensive identification
and quantification of microbial transcriptomes by genome-wide unbiased methods. Curr Opin
Biotechnol 22:32-41.
Miozzi, L., Provero, P. & Accotto, G.P. 2010. ORTom: a multi-species approach based on conserved
co-expression to identify putative functional relationships among genes in tomato. Plant molecular
植物科学最前線 7:121 (2016)
BSJ-Review 7:121 (2016)
Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-13
biology 73:519-532.
Movahedi, S., Van de Peer, Y. & Vandepoele, K. 2011. Comparative network analysis reveals that
tissue specificity and gene function are important factors influencing the mode of expression
evolution in Arabidopsis and rice. Plant physiology 156:1316-1330.
Mutwil, M., Klie, S., Tohge, T., Giorgi, F.M., Wilkins, O., Campbell, M.M., Fernie, A.R., Usadel, B.,
Nikoloski, Z. & Persson, S. 2011. PlaNet: combined sequence and expression comparisons across
plant networks derived from seven species. The Plant cell 23:895-910.
Netotea, S., Sundell, D., Street, N.R. & Hvidsten, T.R. 2014. ComPlEx: conservation and divergence
of co-expression networks in A. thaliana, Populus and O. sativa. BMC Genomics 15:106.
Ohyanagi, H., Takano, T., Terashima, S., Kobayashi, M., Kanno, M., Morimoto, K., Kanegae, H.,
Sasaki, Y., Saito, M., Asano, S., Ozaki, S., Kudo, T., Yokoyama, K., Aya, K., Suwabe, K., Suzuki,
G., Aoki, K., Kubo, Y., Watanabe, M., Matsuoka, M. & Yano, K. 2015. Plant Omics Data Center:
an integrated web repository for interspecies gene expression networks with NLP-based curation.
Plant & cell physiology 56:e9.
Ogata, Y., Suzuki, H., Sakurai, N. & Shibata, D. 2010. CoP: a database for characterizing
co-expressed gene modules with biological information in plants. Bioinformatics 26: 1267-1268.
Ozsolak, F. & Milos, P.M. 2011. RNA sequencing: advances, challenges and opportunities. Nature
reviews Genetics 12:87-98.
Picelli, S., Faridani, O.R., Bjorklund, A.K., Winberg, G., Sagasser, S. & Sandberg, R. 2014.
Full-length RNA-seq from single cells using Smart-seq2. Nat Protoc 9:171-181.
Ranjan, A., Townsley, B.T., Ichihashi, Y., Sinha, N.R. & Chitwood, D.H. 2015. An intracellular
transcriptomic atlas of the giant coenocyte Caulerpa taxifolia. PLoS genetics 11:e1004900.
Reshef, D.N., Reshef, Y.A., Finucane, H.K., Grossman, S.R., McVean, G., Turnbaugh, P.J., Lander,
E.S., Mitzenmacher, M. & Sabeti, P.C. 2011. Detecting novel associations in large data sets.
Science 334:1518-1524.
Robinson, M.D., McCarthy, D.J. & Smyth, G.K. 2010. edgeR: a Bioconductor package for differential
expression analysis of digital gene expression data. Bioinformatics 26:139-140.
Saito, K., Hirai, M.Y. & Yonekura-Sakakibara, K. 2008. Decoding genes with coexpression networks
and metabolomics - 'majority report by precogs'. Trends in plant science 13:36-43.
Shishkin, A.A., Giannoukos, G., Kucukural, A., Ciulla, D., Busby, M., Surka, C., Chen, J.,
Bhattacharyya, R.P., Rudy, R.F., Patel, M.M., Novod, N., Hung, D.T., Gnirke, A., Garber, M,.
Guttman, M. & Livny, J. 2015. Simultaneous generation of many RNA-seq libraries in a single
reaction. Nature methods 12:323-325.
Song, L., Langfelder, P. & Horvath, S. 2012. Comparison of co-expression measures: mutual
information, correlation, and model based indices. BMC Bioinformatics 13:328.
植物科学最前線 7:122 (2016)
BSJ-Review 7:122 (2016)
Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-14
Tilgner, H., Grubert, F., Sharon, D. & Snyder, M.P. 2014. Defining a personal, allele-specific, and
single-molecule long-read transcriptome. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the
United States of America 111:9869-9874.
Townsley, B.T., Covington, M.F., Ichihashi, Y., Zumstein, K. & Sinha, N.R. 2015. BrAD-seq: Breath
Adapter Directional sequencing: a streamlined, ultra-simple and fast library preparation protocol
for strand specific mRNA library construction. Frontiers in plant science 6:366.
Tzfadia, O., Amar, D., Bradbury, L.M., Wurtzel, E.T. & Shamir, R. 2012. The MORPH algorithm:
ranking candidate genes for membership in Arabidopsis and tomato pathways. The Plant cell
24:4389-4406.
Usadel, B., Obayashi, T., Mutwil, M., Giorgi, F.M., Bassel, G.W., Tanimoto, M., Chow, A.,
Steinhauser, D., Persson, S. & Provart, N.J. 2009. Co-expression tools for plant biology:
opportunities for hypothesis generation and caveats. Plant Cell Environ 32:1633-1651.
Vinga, S. 2014. Editorial: Alignment-free methods in computational biology. Brief Bioinform
15:341-342.
von Hippel, P.H., Johnson, N.P. & Marcus, A.H. 2013. Fifty years of DNA "Breathing": Reflections
on old and new approaches. Biopolymers 99:923-954.
Wang, L., Si, Y., Dedow, L.K., Shao, Y., Liu, P. & Brutnell, T.P. 2011. A low-cost library
construction protocol and data analysis pipeline for Illumina-based strand-specific multiplex
RNA-seq. PLoS One 6:e26426.
Wang, Y.X. & Huang, H. 2014. Review on statistical methods for gene network reconstruction using
expression data. J Theor Biol 362:53-61.
Wang, Z., Gerstein, M. & Snyder, M. 2009. RNA-Seq: a revolutionary tool for transcriptomics.
Nature reviews Genetics 10:57-63.
Wehrens, R. & Buydens, L.M.C. 2007. Self- and super-organizing maps in R: The kohonen package. J
Stat Softw 21:1-19.
Yang, J., Yu, H., Liu, B.H., Zhao, Z., Liu, L., Ma, L.X., Li, Y.X. & Li, Y.Y. 2013. DCGL v2.0: an R
package for unveiling differential regulation from differential co-expression. PLoS One 8:e79729.
Yim, W.C., Yu, Y., Song, K., Jang, C.S. & Lee, B.M. 2013. PLANEX: the plant co-expression
database. BMC Plant Biol 13:83.
Yu, H., Mitra, R., Yang, J., Li, Y. & Zhao, Z. 2014. Algorithms for network-based identification of
differential regulators from transcriptome data: a systematic evaluation. Sci China Life Sci
57:1090-1102.
植物科学最前線 7:123 (2016)
BSJ-Review 7:123 (2016)