WORKBOOK
How can we make the most of each others strengths, gifts and talents in the process of empowering localities?
ArtofHosting
ContentsINTRODUCTION:........................................................................................................3
AboutthisWorkbook.......................................................................................................3PurposeofThisTraining...................................................................................................4ParadoxesatWork...........................................................................................................5MultipleLevelsofFocus...................................................................................................5ContentoftheTraining....................................................................................................6
BASICASSUMPTIONSANDCOREPATTERNS..............................................................9TwoComplementaryWorldviews..................................................................................10AFewChaordicAssumptions......................................................................................11ChaordicOrganisations..................................................................................................12OrganisationsasLivingSystems.....................................................................................13ComplexAdaptiveSystems............................................................................................15WorkingwithVisionandPurpose...................................................................................18TheFourfoldPractice....................................................................................................20TheChaordicPath..........................................................................................................23TheChaordicSteppingStonesAWaytoWalkthePath................................................25DivergenceandConvergence.........................................................................................26OrganisingPatternsFourOrganisationalParadigms.....................................................28AFifthOrganisationalParadigm.....................................................................................32
COREMETHODS.......................................................................................................33TheCircle.......................................................................................................................34AppreciativeInquiry.......................................................................................................37TheWorldCaf..............................................................................................................39OpenSpaceTechnology.................................................................................................41CollectiveMindmap......................................................................................................43TheProActionCaf........................................................................................................45ActionLearning..............................................................................................................54PractisingDialogue.........................................................................................................56
ESSENTIALSOFPROCESSDESIGN.............................................................................61SevenLittleHelpers........................................................................................................61PowerfulQuestions........................................................................................................64TheArtofHarvesting.....................................................................................................65GroupHarvestingofAoHPracticeStories.......................................................................73DecisionMaking............................................................................................................83ConsensusDecisionmaking...........................................................................................84
DEEPERPROCESSDESIGN.........................................................................................85The6BreathsofDesign................................................................................................87TheChaordicDesignProcess..........................................................................................93HostingandDesigningParticipatoryProcessesasaTeam..............................................96
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 2
ADDITIONALRESOURCES.......................................................................................110BooksandWebsites.....................................................................................................110StoriesandArticles......................................................................................................115TheArtofHostingStory...............................................................................................115AStoryaboutthePowerofQuestions..........................................................................118TheVisaStory..............................................................................................................119UModel.......................................................................................................................123UsingEmergencetoTakeSocialInnovationtoScale.....................................................124CommunitiesofPractice..............................................................................................128
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 3
ParticipatoryLeadership
throughtheArtofHostingandHarvesting
ConversationsthatMatterisan
experienceforallwhoaspiretolearn
andfindbetterwaystoworkwith
groupsinwaysthatnurturecollective
intelligence,sharedlearning
andeffectiveactionforchange.
INTRODUCTION: WelcometotheArtofHostingJrna!Inthistrainingwewillbeexaminingwhatittakestoconsciouslydesignandhostprocessesthatdeepenyourdialogueandfacilitationskills.Weintroducetheelementsofdesign,mentalframeworkstounderstandhowtoworkwithemergenceandcomplexity,andpracticaltoolstosupportyouaspractitionersinyourlineofworkandinyourengagementforstrengtheninglocalcommunities.Todayscomplexandhighspeedenvironmentsarecallingustoengagemultiplestylesofleadingandlearning.Wemustknowhowtogeneratecollectiveintelligenceandhowtocalloneveryonesparticipationandleadership.Weneedtogeneratesharedclarityofpurposeandcreatespacesfornonjudgmentallearning.Atthesametime,weareaskedtoexercisehierarchicalleadership.Weareaccountabletoourstakeholdersandmusttakedecisiveactionwhenneeded.Learninghowtostandinthisparadoxandhowtonavigatetheterritorybetweentoomuchchaosandtoomuchcontrolisthekeytoleadingtransformationalchange.
Inthistrainingwewillpracticestayingfocusedandcentredinthemidstofbothchaosandcontrol.Wewillsharestoriesfromcommunities,government,education,theprivatesector,andNGOsaboutwhathasworked.Wewillgainframeworksandskillsforhostingconversationsthatmatter,forinvitingcollaborativeleadership,forgeneratingcollectiveintelligenceandlearningtocreatewisersolutionstogether.Ourworktogetherwillbecomerealaswesharereallifestoriesoftransformationalchangeinitiativesthatareunderwayindifferentcontextsandindifferentpartsoftheworld.Asweworktogetherwewillexploretheterritoryoffearandloneliness,trustandfellowship,andwewilldevelopgreaterclarityaboutournextstepsasleadersinthecontextofourlifeandwork.
Ifyouareaskingyourselfhowtofacilitatechangetowardsabetterworld,weofferyouaspacetogetherwithotherpeoplethataspiretodiscovernewwaysofcollaborationtocreateinnovativesolutionsadaptedtotheneedsofourreality.Bepresentandjoinotherswhowishtoexplorethisnewwayofparticipatoryleadership.
About this Workbook Thisworkbook is intendedtobeapersonalreferencejournal,tohelpyouremember,focusanddeepenyourlearning.Itsharesthebasicassumptionsandourcurrentunderstandingofthe topic and how the Art of Hosting practice can serve. It includes several tools andpracticesthatthecommunityofpractitionershas foundsimpleandhelpfuland itprovidesyouwithdifferentresourcesi.e.books,linksandinformationthatcanguideyoufurther.OurteamhasadaptedthisversionoftheworkbookforthisparticularArtofHostingtraining,but is the current reflection of a lineage of shared practice andwriting about theArt ofHosting.
TofindoutmoreaboutthenetworkandjointheAoH
emaillistvisitwww.artofhosting.
org.
Moreindepthconversationand
knowledgesharingcanhappenonline,
ontheAoHNingsite
http://artofhosting.ning.com
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 4
ArtofHostingACommunityofPractice
Agrowinggroupofpractitionersisaddingtotheinspirationandevolution.TheArtofHosting (AoH) isnotacompanyora trademarkbutratheracommunityofpracticeengaging intheArtofHostingConversationsthatMatterbe it inthefamily, inorganisationsorinlargescaleassembliesorsummits.Thiswebornetworkofpractitionersisconnectedacrossallcontinentsservingtheneedsofdifferentcommunitiesindifferentcontexts.Itinvolvessharinglearningandexperiencesofwhathappenswhenweengagethecollectiveintelligenceincolearningandcodevelopingsolutionstocomplexchallenges.Wehavelearnedthattheprinciplesofselforganisation,participation,ownershipandnonlinearsolutionsarethekeytobothindividualandcollectivediscovery.This isdifferentandcomplementarytomoretraditionalwaysofworkingwhichareoftenbasedonrationalplanningandfullcontroloftheprocess inordertoensurethatplannedresultsareachieved.Bothapproachesareneeded.Participatory Leadership is particularly useful in dealingwith issues and challenges of acomplexnature.
Purpose of This Training
Anewtypeofleadershipisbeingcalledforinlocalcommunities,transitiontowns,corporations,businesses,internationalrelations,nonprofitorganizations,associations,schoolsandfamilies.Thisstyleofleadershipgeneratesfreshthinkingandcreatessharedcommitmenttosolvingcriticalchallengesinsustainable,inclusiveways.
WecallthisParticipatoryLeadership.
Thiskindofleadercanskillfullycallimportantconversationsandconnectdifferentperspectivestoaddressourcomplexchallengesandtogrowintoourcreativepossibilities.Heorsheknowshowtocreateopportunitieswheretheessentialknowledgepresentinevenalargegroupcanbesharedinashortperiodoftime.
ThethreedayArtofHostingandHarvestingMeaningfulConversationscreatesarichlearningenvironmentinwhichyouwill:
Exploreandpracticemethodsforactivatingcollectiveintelligenceandhostmeaningfulconversationswhetheritbewith3or1000people,
Harvestwhatemergesintoessentialactionsteps, Understandthetheorybehindparticipatoryleadershipmethods, Learntoolsforprojectcreation
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 5
Neverdoubtthatasmallgroupof
thoughtful,committedcitizens
canchangetheworld.Indeed,itistheonlythingthat
everhas.
MargaretMead
Paradoxes at Work
In leadingorganisationstodayweoperate inaworldthat isnotblackorwhitebutratherblack and white and all the shades in between. When working with participatory orcollaborativeleadership,weneedtobeabletooperateincomplexityandholdoppositesorparadoxes:
ChaosandOrder ContentandProcess LeadingandFollowing WarriorandMidwife ActionandReflection HostingandConsulting IndividualandCommunity
Throughouttheuniverseorderexistswithindisorderanddisorderwithinorder.Wehavealwaysthoughtthatdisorderwastheabsenceofthetruestateoforder.Butischaosan
irregularity,orisorderjustabriefmomentseizedfromdisorder?Linearthinkingdemandsthatweseethingsasseparatestates:Oneneedstobenormal,theotherexceptional.Yetthereisawaytoseethisballetofchaosandorder,ofchangeandstability,astwocomplimentaryaspects
intheprocessofgrowth,neitherofwhichisprimary
MargaretWheatleyAuthorofLeadershipandthenewScience
Multiple Levels of Focus
TheAoHisafourfoldpracticethatrequiresustooperateatfourlevelsatonceindividual,team,community/organisation,andglobal.Thesefourlevelsareconnected,andlearningateachoftheselevelsinformslearningattheothers.
Individual
Toconnecttoourownmotivationandreasonforchoosingadifferentwayofleading Tostrengthenourindividualcouragetoleadashosts
Team
Totrainthecompetenciesofcollectivereflectionandwiseaction Topracticecocreating,codecidingandcohostingstrategicmeetings,focusgroups,
communityconversations,etc.
Community,Organisationetc.
Toexperienceworkinginunitywithotherleadersandmembersofourcommunity. Toexperienceneworganisational formsandworkat cocreating relationships that
servetheneedsofourorganisationorcommunity.
Global
Tounderstandthebiggercontextthatwearealwayspartof Tobenefit from knowledge and experienceof a globalor translocalnetworkof
practitionersandlearnersinthisfield
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 6
Content of the Training The seminar is designed to provide participants with an introduction to the approachdescribed above. Our intention is to provide a good balance between indepth teachingsessionson the key elementsof the approach, combinedwith introducing some relevanttoolsaswellasfocusingonapplicationandpractice.The following isa structuredoverviewof the topicsor items,whicharepresented in thisworkbook. We will introduce and experience some of the theories and practices belowcombined with relevant cases, to illuminate how we can lead transformation throughcollaborativeandhierarchicalcultures.
WorkingTogetherThroughtheLevels
2COMPLIMENTARYWORLDVIEWSBasicassumptions.HowamImakingsenseoftheworldaroundme?HowdoIseeorganisations?
OrganisationsasMachines?OrganisationsaslivingsystemsorComplexadaptivesystems?
MENTALMODELSPatternsormetaphorsthathelpusunderstandanddescribehowweseetheworld
TheFourfoldPath TheChaordicPathDivergence&ConvergenceOrganisingpatternsorganisationalparadigmsUprocess
COREMETHODS&PRACTICES Thesearesometoolsthatareavailableforchaordicleadershippractices.Theymanifestourworldviewinhowweactandworktogetherandthroughwhichourworldviewcanbeexperienced
Practices:Beingpresent&TheFourfoldPracticeDialoguePowerfulQuestions
CoreMethodologies:CircleWorldCaf OpenSpaceTechnologyAppreciativeInquiryCollectiveMindmappingProActionCafe ActionLearning
Supportingpractices&methodologiesTheArtofHarvestingConsensusDecisionMaking
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 7
BRINGINGITALLTOGETHERDevelopingandimplementingstrategiesforspecificcontexts/application.
8LittleHelpersChecklistfordesign5BreathsofDesign TheChaordicDesignProcess/ChaordicSteppingStonesThe5thOrganisationalParadigm
Cases:applicationindifferentcontexts
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 8
Howdoyouexplainparticipatoryleadershipinonesentence?
AsformulatedbythestaffoftheEuropeanCommission,practicingParticipatoryLeadershipinthedaytodayworkoftheCommission.
o Imagineameetingof60people,whereinanhouryouwouldhaveheardeveryoneandattheendyouwouldhavepreciselyidentifiedthe5mostimportantpointsthatpeoplearewillingtoactontogether.
o Whenappropriate,deeperengagementofallinserviceofourpurpose.o Hierarchyisgoodformaintenance;participatoryleadershipisgoodforinnovationandadapting
tochange.o Usingall knowledge,expertise, conflicts,etc.available toachieve the commongoodon any
issue.o Itallowsdealingwithcomplexissuesbyusingthecollectiveintelligenceofallpeopleconcerned
andgettingtheirbuyin.o ParticipatoryLeadership ismethods,techniques,tips,tricks,toolstoevolve,to lead,tocreate
synergy, to shareexperience, to lead a team, to create a transversalnetwork, tomanage aproject,anawayday,brainstorming,changeprocesses,strategicvisions.
How Can Participatory Leadership Effectively Serve?
HOWDOWECONVENESTRATEGICCONVERSATIONSTHATENABLEUSTOMEETTHEINCREASINGCHALLENGESOFTHEWORLDTODAY?
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 9
BASIC ASSUMPTIONS AND CORE PATTERNS The following sections in this Workbook will give a short introduction to some basicassumptionsofhowwe vieworganisations and someof thedynamics thathappenwhenpeopleworktogether.
Weallhaveaviewoftheworldandsomebasicassumptionsaboutwhat istrueorrightorwhatworksinourworldoragivensituation.Manytimestheseassumptionsareunspokenorevenunconscioustous,yettheydetermineouractions.
Aswecommunicateorworktogetherwedonotalwaysspeakfromthesameworldvieworsameassumptions.Thisusuallyresultsinalackofmutualunderstanding.
Making these assumptions clear and explicit helps us communicate and bridge ourunderstandings.
Tobeabletotalkaboutourassumptionsormaketheseworldviewsexplicitwesometimesuse metaphors or mental models. They are like road maps that we can use to orientourselves. And, of course, the map is not the territory so these models are clearlysimplificationsofthetruth.
Changestartswithachangeofperspectiveorinourbasicassumptions.
Edgar Schein, a wellknown organisational theorist, at the Massachusetts Institute ofTechnology (MIT), suggests that corporate culture can be considered on at least threedistinctlevels.
Thereisanemerginggroup
ofmethodologiesforfacilitatingconversationin
groupsofallsizes,supportedbyprinciplesthathelpmaximise
collectiveintelligence,
integrateandutilisediversityandminimiseor
transformconflict.
Processesfacilitatedinthis
waytendtoresultincollectiveclarityandwiseaction
sustainable,workable
solutionstothemostcomplex
problems.
Theapproachensuresthat
stakeholdersbuyintotheprocess(becausethey
participateinthedesignandtheprocessisby
definitiontransparent)and
makeongoingfeedback,learning
andcoursecorrectionanaturaland
efficientpartoflife.
(sourceunknowntous)
Thereisanemerginggroup
ofmethodologiesforfacilitatingconversationin
groupsofallsizes,supportedbyprinciplesthathelpmaximise
collectiveintelligence,
integrateandutilisediversityandminimiseor
transformconflict.
Processesfacilitatedinthis
waytendtoresultincollectiveclarityandwiseaction
sustainable,workable
solutionstothemostcomplex
problems.
Theapproachensuresthat
stakeholdersbuyintotheprocess(becausethey
participateinthedesignandtheprocessisby
definitiontransparent)and
makeongoingfeedback,learning
andcoursecorrectionanaturaland
efficientpartoflife.
(sourceunknowntous)
ArtefactsManifestation
Values/principlesBasicassumptions/corebeliefs
Thevisiblelevelconsistsof:1)Artefactsorhowourassumptionsmanifestinthevisibleworlde.g.language,rulesandprocedures,organisationalstructuresetc.Theinvisiblelevelconsistsoftwolevels:
2)Valuesorwhatwebelieveisgoodandrightortheprinciplesthatguideusinourcooperationandpursuitofourgoals.
3)Basicassumptionsorourcorebeliefs,whetherweareawareofthemornotultimatelydecidehowweactandhowwemanifestandshapeourorganisationsandourworld.
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 10
Two Complementary Worldviews ThefollowingsectionsattempttogiveanexplanationofhowweseetheworldoforganisationandwhyandwhenthechosenapproachofParticipatoryLeadershipmakessenseandhowitcomplimentsmoretraditionalwaysofleading.Whenweareaskedtodrawourorganisations,inanybiggerorganisationitusuallymanifestsasanorganisationalchartororganigrammewithboxesandcommunicationlines.
Thispicturespeaksofabelief(basicassumption)thatifwecandefineeachpartandtherelationshipsbetweenthem,themachinewillfunctionwell.Thismayalsotellusthatwebelievethatleadersaretheexpertsandhavetheanswers.Thatiswhytheyareatthetopofthechartwithabiggeroffice,moreresponsibilityandabiggerpaycheck.Itmayalsotellusthatwebelievethatpeopleatthebottomofthepyramiddowhattheyaretoldaslongastheyaregivenagoodplanandclearinstructionsorjobdefinitions.Itmaycommunicateasenseoforderandhavingthingsundercontrol.Itisalinearsystem,whichmakesitstreamlinedandeffectiveinstableenvironments.
Thispicturespeaksofabelief(basicassumption)thatwecanselforganise.Thereisnocleartoporcentreandeachpart seemsas importantas thenext.Therearemany leadersandleadershipcanshift.Allthepartsareinterconnected.Itmayalsoseemlessorderly.
This is a network and a parallel system (as opposed to linear), which makes it resilient,flexibleandadaptiveinchangingenvironments.
Whataretheassumptionsandcorebeliefsweholdaboutorganisationswhenthepicturemanifestslikethis?
Thisrepresentsabureaucracy.Italsorepresentsamechanisticviewoforganisations.
Theassumptionsandcorebeliefsweholdaboutorganisationswhenthepicturemanifestslikethisarebasedonalivingsystemsworldvieworviewingorganisationsascomplex,adaptivesystems?
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 11
These two paradigms are almost diametrically opposite and often cause a polarisation ofviewseither favouringoneor theother. Instead, thecomplexityofour timecalls forboth.Weneedtolearnhowtoleadandparticipateinbothcontexts,embracebothworldviewsandknowwhatisneededwhen.
Seeinganorganisationasa livingsystemorcomplexadaptivesystemmayseemchaotic tothosewhoareusedtoworkinginahierarchy,whichbycomparisonseemsorderlyandeasiertocontrol.
Bothapproacheshaveadvantagesanddisadvantagesandaregoodfordifferentthings.Livingsystemsor complexadaptive systems are flexibleand resilient they canembracediversityandcanbe innovative.Hierarchiescanbe stable,effective inactionand streamlined.Bothareneeded.
Leadershipinthesetwosystemsrequiresadifferentsetofskills,asdoesfollowership.Weareinvitedtoembraceoppositesandholdbothworldviews.
Thereisawayofthinkingandoperatinginbetweenthesetwoworldsthatactuallycontainandcombineelementsofboth.Wecallitchaordicleadership.Chaordicleadershipisalsoahighlycollaborativeformofleadership.
DeeHock,founderofVISA,addressedthisdichotomyintheearly1990s.BasedonhisVISAexperiencehebothcoinedthephraseChaordic(containingbothchaosandorder)andexploredtheChaordicorganisation.Thisisthedancewewishtoexploreinthismodule.
A Few Chaordic Assumptions
NewSolutionsAreNeeded
AoHisbuiltontheassumptionandexperiencethatanincreasingcomplexityintheproblemswe face compelus to findnew solutions for the common good,whether in corporations,government, education, nonprofits, communities, or families. These solutions are morecomprehensive and more readily found and owned if they are cocreated by thestakeholders.
NewSolutionsGrowBetweenChaosandOrder
Ifwewanttoinnovateorworkwithchangewehavetobewillingtoletgoofwhatweknowandstep intonotknowing. Innatureall innovationhappensattheedgeofchaos,or inthespace between chaos and order (the chaordic path). It is in the chaordic space that newconnections are created and new possibilities emerge. The way to any major change ortransformationwillgothroughchaosintoneworder.
ConversationsMatter
It is common sense tobringmorepeople together in conversation. It is thewaywehavedoneitingenerationspast,gatheringroundfiresandsittingincircles.
Bychaord,Imeananyselforganising,self
governing,adaptive,nonlinear,complex
organism,organisation,communityor
system,whetherphysical,
biologicalorsocial;the
behaviourofwhich
harmoniouslyblends
characteristicsofbothchaosandorder.Looselytranslatedto
business,itcanbethoughtofasanorganisationthat
harmoniouslyblends
characteristicsofcompetitionandcooperation;or
fromtheperspectiveofeducation,an
organisationthatseamlesslyblends
theoreticalandexperientiallearning
DeeHock
SeealsotheComplex
adaptivesystemsTheCinefinframework
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 12
Conversationisthewaywethinkandmakemeaningtogether.Itisthewaywebuildstrongrelationshipsthatinviterealcollaboration.
MeaningfulConversationsLeadToWiseActions
Human beings that are involved and invited towork together only pay attention to thatwhich is meaningful to them. Conversations that surface a shared clarity on issues ofimportance fosterownershipand responsibilitywhen ideasandsolutionsmustbeput intoaction.Actionsthatcomeoutofcollectiveclarityaresustainable.
OrganisationsAreLivingSystems
When human beings join together in an enterprise or organisation they have more incommonwithalivingsystemthanwithamachine.Livingsystemsareintelligentandcapableof self organising their own and unique solutions. Theway you lead a living system isradicallydifferentfromoperatingamachine.
When these systems grow big enough they organise in levels. They need structures,containersandboundariesthatcanfacilitateoractashostforthecollectiveresourcesandintelligence.Thestructuresaretheretosupportwhatneedstohappenratherthanimpedeit.
Chaordic Organisations
o Arebasedonclarityofsharedpurposeandprinciples.
o Areselforganisingandselfgoverninginwholeandinpart.o Existprimarilytoenabletheirconstituentparts.o Arepoweredfromtheperiphery,unifiedfromthecore.o Aredurableinpurposeandprinciple,malleableinformandfunction.o Equitablydistributepower,rights,responsibilityandrewards.o Harmoniouslycombinecooperationandcompetition.o Learn,adaptandinnovateineverexpandingcycles.o Arecompatiblewiththehumanspiritandthebiosphere.o Liberateandamplifyingenuity,initiativeandjudgment.o Arecompatiblewithandfosterdiversity,complexityandchange.o Constructivelyutilizeandharmonizeconflictandparadox.o Restrainandappropriatelyembedcommandandcontrolmethods.
Oneofthecorebeliefs
underlyingtheArtofHostingConversationsthatMatteris
basedonviewing
organisationsasliving
systemsorcomplexadaptivesystems,
ratherthanmerely
machines.
Inmost,biggerorganisations,
bothexistsimultaneously
Inmanyorganisations
themechanistic
viewisstilltheprevailingoneobstructingthecreativityand
collectiveintelligenceof
theorganisation
Inawst
taskfaci
babourelat
growthingsneedb
coangro
tale
Marg
alivingsystemwewillneedtotopdescribingksandinsteadilitateprocess
Weneedtobecomesavvythowtobuildtionships,how
tonurturewing,evolvings.Allofuswilbetterskillsin
listeningmmunicatingndfacilitatingoups,becausethesearethe
entsthatbuildstrong
relationships
garetWheatley
mogds.oydwegllng,g,geedg
y
Orga
PeopleOrganismeanin
Forthreinfluenctendtowithcle
Inacomproblemaswell?
Living stogethehaveai
Therea
1)
1)
Whatifthatop
Whatw
nisations
e are intesationsarelingseeking.
eehundredcedbyratiooviewouroearlydefined
mplexworld,msandchall?
systems exier to formarconditionin
aretwoexcit
Nature hasdoingwhatSelforganisandqualitie
forganisatioensupthep
wouldourorg
A
as Living
elligent, creivingsystem
years,sincenalism.Werganisationsdrolesanda
,thismechaengeswefa
st everywha system thangsothetem
ingphenom
s the capabiisneededtosationcan lees=1+1=11
nsreallyarepossibilityfor
ganisationsa
ArtofHosting
g Systems
eative, adams.Theytoo
Descartesahavebeenaasweviewpredictable
nisticviewmace.What if
ere in natuat is capablemperaturest
enainnatur
lity to selfoosustaintheeadtoemerg1orsomethin
livingsystemremergence
andcommun
g
aptive, selfareintelligen
ndNewton,able to figurwmachinesoutput.
maynotalwaorganisation
urebacteriaeof creatingaysthesame
eandlivings
organise aesystem.gence=thengtotallyne
msandthereeprovidedt
nitieslooklik
organizing,nt,creative,
ourthinkingre thingsoutasconsistin
aysbeadequnsshouldbe
a forming cananthill.einsidethe
systems:
all parts of t
emergenceewandsurpr
ecouldbeatherightcon
kethen?
and meaadaptive,se
ghaspredomtandbe inngofclearly
uatetomeeeviewedas
colonies orSome termithill.
the system
oftotallynerising.
simplerwaynditionsarei
P a g e | 1
aningseekinelforganisin
minantlybeecontrol.Wdefinedpar
tthecomplelivingsystem
ants comintenestseve
participate
ewpropertie
yoforganisininplace?!
13
g.g,
enWets
exms
ngen
in
es
ng
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 14
Iforganisationsaremachines,controlmakes
sense.Iforganisationsareprocessstructures,
thenseekingtoimposecontrol
throughpermanentstructuresissuicide.Ifwe
believethatactingresponsiblymeansexertingcontrolbyhavingourhandsintoeverything,thenwecannot
hopeforanythingexceptwhatwealreadyhave..
MargaretWheatley
LeadershipandTheNewScience
Herearesomeofthequalitiesoflivingsystemsthatstudieshavediscovered:
Alivingsystemacceptsonlyitsownsolutionsweonlysupportthosethingswearepartofcreating
Alivingsystempaysattentiononlytothatwhichismeaningfultoithereandnow In nature, a living system participates in the development of its neighbouran
isolatedsystemisdoomed Nature,andallofnature,includingourselves,isinconstantchange(withoutchange
management) Natureseeksdiversity.Newrelationsopenuptonewpossibilities.Itisnotaquestion
of survival of the fittestbut everything that is fitas many species as possible.Diversityincreasesourchanceofsurvival
Experimentationopensuptowhatispossiblehereandnow.Natureisnotintentonfinding perfect solutions, but workable solutions. Life is intent on finding whatworks,notwhatisright
Alltheanswersdonotexistouttherewemustsometimesexperimenttofindoutwhatworks
A living system cannot be steered or controlledit can only be teased, nudged,titillatedtoseethingsdifferently
Asystemchangeswhenitsperceptionofitselfchanges Whowearetogetherisalwaysdifferentandmorethanwhowearealone.Ourrange
ofcreativeexpressionincreasesaswejoinwithothers.Newrelationshipscreatenewcapacities.
Wehumanbeingsarecapableofselforganising,giventherightconditions Selforganisationshiftstoahigherorder
Alivingsystemcanalsobecalledacomplexadaptivesystem.
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 15
Complex Adaptive Systems The Cynefin Framework
Thewaywe lead is verymuch formed by thewaywe perceive reality. Social reality hasbecomeanobjectofsystemsresearchandcognitivescience,which inturnoffersnowusawholerangeofrealitiesthatouractualrealityismadeof.Inwhatfollowsweintroducethenotionofasystem tounderstandsocial reality.Asystem is thewholeof itselementsandtheirrelationshipsaswellas itsrulesofbehaviororprocesses.Youmaywonderwherethebordersofa systemare. If theelementsofa system include livingbeings likehumans,ornaturethenittendstobedynamicandmaymoveitsborders.Itactuallydefinesthembyitsownrules.
A highly instructive synopsis on the various states of systems is found in the "Cynefinframework". Developed by the Welsh researcher Dave Snowden, it distinguishes fivedomainsofrealitythatagivensystemmayrepresent;theframeworkclassifies the systems by their state of complexity and order, and offers advice on what strategy to adopt to impact each.
TheFirstFourDomainsAre:
Simple,inwhichtherelationshipbetweencauseandeffectisobvioustoall,theapproachistoSenseCategoriseRespondandwecanapplybestpractice.This istheareaweknowfromtheassembly line.Thefactoryworkenvironmentconstrainsanyactorsomuch,thattheyare leftwithfewoptionsandperformasthesystem instructsthemtodo.
Complicated, inwhichtherelationshipbetweencauseandeffectrequiresanalysisorsomeotherformof investigationand/ortheapplicationofexpertknowledge.Theapproach istoSenseAnalyzeRespondandwecanapplygoodpractice.
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 16
This is the area of the "expert" that knows better than the actors how the system'srelationships actually fit best together. The experts design the way to follow and soundmanagers implement thisadvice.Note that in the "complicated"domain, thereare linearcauseeffectrelationships,buttherearesomanyandnotobviousthatsomeexpertinsightisnecessarytofindagoodwaythrough.
Complex, in which the relationship between cause and effect can only be perceived inretrospect,butnotinadvance,theapproachistoProbeSenseRespondandwecansenseemergentpractice.Here thesystem's relationshipsaremutually influencedby theactors'behavior.Thus, it isimpossible todiscern causal relationships inadvance;andexperts failasmuchasanyoneelseintryingso.
Leading in complexity is a game of trial and learning. The art is to launch a number ofdifferentpossibleactionstogetherandseewhatworksbetter.Thosearethenamplified,andthe less effective onesmight be stopped or revised.Herewework on the basis thatweunderstandthatwedonotknowthebestwayinadvance.
Chaotic, inwhich there isno relationshipbetween cause and effect at systems level, theapproachistoActSenseRespondandwecandiscovernovelpractice.Leading in Chaos is stressful, as thewhole system is in stressmode. Systems tend to beunstableandfallfromchaoticintosimple.Thisisacatastrophiccollapse,asthesimplificationbrought into thesystem tends tooverdoand tosuppress the inherentcomplexityand thesystemmightrecollapsebackintochaosagain.
Theway to stabilise chaotic situations isbyActingSensing.That isactingat large scaleatonce (there is no time left for trying), until the chaos stabilizes into 'normal' complexitywherefurtheractionscanbetested.
ThefifthdomainisDisorder,whichisthestateofnotknowingwhattypeofcausalityexistsandinwhichstatepeoplewillreverttotheirowncomfortzoneinmakingadecision.
Infulluse,theCynefinframeworkhassubdomains,andtheboundarybetweensimpleandchaoticisseenasacatastrophicone:complacencyleadstofailure.
Thenewperspectivegainedby this is theview from complexity. Leading in complexity isactually simple. It suffices to maintain a number of high quality learning nodes aroundconstantexperimentsaboutwhatcouldbeanewor improvedwayofacting inthefaceofconstantly fresh constellations; in a world where all actors have some large degree offreedomconstrainedlightlythroughboundariesandrulesofthesystem.
References:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cynefin
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5mqNcs8mp74 (A brief explanation of the Cynefinframework)
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 17
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Miwb92eZaJg (how you organize a birthday party forthirteenyearoldboysusingthevariousdomainsofsystems)
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 18
Working with Vision and Purpose
Havingaclearvisionand/oraclearpurposearethefirststepsinbringingorderintocomplexityorthechaordicspace.
VISION: Wheredowewanttogo?Whatisouridealfuture?
Definition: Theactorpowerofseeing
Avisionstatementissometimescalledapictureofyourorganisationinthefuturebutitssomuchmorethanthat. Yourvisionstatementisyourinspiration,theframeworkforallyourstrategicplanning.
Avisionstatementmayapplytoanentirecompanyortoasingledivisionofthatcompany.Whether for all or part of an organisation, the vision statement answers the question,Wheredowewanttogo?
Whatyouaredoingwhencreatingavisionstatementisarticulatingyourdreamsandhopesforyourbusiness.
Itremindsyouofwhatyouaretryingtobuild.
Itisnotwhatthevisionisbutwhatitwhatitdoes,thatisimportantPeterSenge
THEPURPOSEOFPURPOSE: Whyweareallherecollectively?
Discoveringpurpose istodiscoverwhysomethingexists. Oftenwehurrytoget intoactionbeforeweproperlyunderstandwhyweneedtotakeaction.Gainingclarityonpurposeandespeciallygainingcollectiveclarity issetting the rightcourse for takingaction. Apurpose,therefore,becomesanavigationaltoollikeacompassasithelpsustodiscoverthedirectionoftravelforoureffortssotheycanbeofservice.
Purposecanalsobeendescribedas thegluethatbringspeoplescontributionandeffortstogether. This isbecause itdefineswhyweareworking towards somethingandwhy it isworthworking on this together. In fact, purpose becomes an invisible leader as it bothconnectsdifferentactions takenand supportseveryone toknowwhy their contribution isvaluable.
Collectiveclarityofpurposeistheinvisibleleader
MaryParkerFollett
To be a useful navigational tool in seeking the way forward, purpose contains threeelements:
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 19
HigherIntentwhyactionisneededforthegreatergoodinserviceoflife,e.g.Wearenotformingcoalitionsofstates,weareunitingmenJeanMonnet(abouttheEuropeanUnion)
Statement of Purpose what effort is needed here and what is being pursued so thatdirectionofactioncanbeset.Thisdoesnotdefine thedestinationbut instead invitesandinspiresotherstoparticipatewithclarity.
IntentionThewilltobe inpursuitofgroundingthehigher intentthroughtheactionswetakeregardlessofthechallengesthatmightarise.
When these threeelementsarealignedandcollectivelyunderstood thegreatergoodofwhywe need to take action, the clarity ofwhatwe are pursuing in order to ground thehigher intentandthewilltodothisregardlessoftheconditionsthenpurposebecomesapowerfulattractorthatallowspeopletocombinetheirindividualeffortstoworktogetheronmakingadifferenceforall.
Inanorganisationoracommunitymanypurposescoexist.Alltoooften,insufficienteffortisgiven to interconnect these purposes so that it can feel that different and conflictingpurposesareatplay. It is therefore important toremember thatdifferentpurposesareatplay.Forexample:
Thepurposeofthestakeholdersthattheorganisationserves Thepurposeofthewholecommunity/organisation Thepurposeofthecoregroup Thepurposeofeachmemberofthecoreteam
In the light of this, the following questions may inspire your collective inquiry into yoursharedpurpose:
Whatisourcollectivepurpose? Whatisthepurposeofourfunction,teamorproject? Howdoesmypurposealignwiththepurposeweareallheretoaccomplish? What is the purpose that is at theheartof thiswork and thatwill alignus all to
accomplishit?
Puttingeffort, therefore ingaining clarityand specificallycollectiveclarityonpurpose isakeystrategicaction that ifoverlooked,usuallyendsupwithentanglements,confusionandevenconflictsinsteadofachievingoutcomesthatmakeadifference.Seekingpurposeisnotsomething tobedoneonce,either.Asaction is takenandmore isdiscoveredasa result,comingback to check inwithpurposearewe stillon courseordowehaveanewonearisingisawisethingtodo.
AStatementofPurposedefines,withabsoluteclarityanddeepconviction,thepurposeofthecommunity.
Aneffectivestatementofpurposewillbeaclear,commonlyunderstoodstatementofthatwhichidentifiesandbindsthecommunitytogetherasworthyofpursuit.
Whenproperlydoneitcanusuallybeexpressedinasinglesentence.Participantswillsayaboutthepurpose,
Ifwecouldachievethat,mylifewouldhavemeaning.DeeHock
The F
Therea
1) 2) 3) 4)
Being tandengbutitta
Apractability.
1.BeingP
...hostyinthefi
our-fold P
arefourbasic
BeingpreseEngagingskHostingconBecominga
rulypresentgagingwithakescontinu
icemeansac
Present(PreS
yourselffirstireofthepre
A
Practice
cpracticesth
ent(presenskilfullyinconnversations(acommunity
t,engagingsothersincoouspractise
ctivelyandre
Sensing)
bewillingesent...
ArtofHosting
hatarekeyt
sing)nversations(contributingyofpractice
skilfully incocreationaretohonethe
egularlydoin
toendurech
g
otheArtof
participatingg)(cocreating
onversationseallpracticeeseskills.
ngsomething
haoskeept
Hostingand
g)
)
s,beingagoesorskillsth
gtomaintain
thespaceo
Participator
oodhostofhatareeasily
norenhance
orpossibilitie
P a g e | 2
ryLeadership
conversationyunderstoo
easkillor
esopensta
20
p:
nsd,
ay
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 21
Beingpresentmeansshowingup,withoutdistraction,prepared,clearabout theneedandwhatyourpersonalcontributioncanbe.Itallowsyoutocheckinwithyourselfanddevelopthepersonalpracticeof curiosity about theoutcomesof any gathering. Presencemeansmakingspacetodevoteadedicatedtimetoworkingwithothers.
Ifyouaredistracted,calledoutorotherwiselocatedinmanydifferentplaces,youcannotbepresentinone.Formeetingstohavedeepresults,everypersonintheroomshouldbefullypresent.
Beingpresentalsomeansbeingawareofonesenvironment,otherpeopleandwhatimpactsyouandhowyouimpactothers.
It is good practice to become present collectively as a meeting begins, be it through awelcome,agood framing, through checkingin to the subjectmatteror taskathandbyhearingeveryonesvoiceinthematterorsimplytakingamomentofsilence.
Inviteacollectiveslowingdownsothatallparticipantsinameetingcanbepresenttogether.
2.ParticipateandPracticeConversations
...bewillingto listenfully,respectfully,without judgmentandthinkingyoualreadyknowalltheanswerpracticeconversationmindfully...
Conversation isanart.It isnot justtalk.Itdemandsthatwe listencarefullytooneanotherandthatweofferwhatwecan intheserviceofthewhole.Curiosityand judgmentcannotlivetogetherinthesamespace.Ifwearejudgingwhatwearehearingwecannotbecuriousabout theoutcome,and ifwehavecalledameetingbecauseweareuncertainof thewayforward,beingopenisakeyskillandcapacity.Onlybypractisingskilfulconversationcanwefindourbestpracticetogether.
Ifwe practise conversationmindfullywemight slow downmeetings so thatwisdom andclarity canworkquickly.Whenwe talkmindlessly,weneitherheareachothernordoweallow space for the clarity to arise.The artof conversation is the artof slowingdown tospeedup.
3.HostingConversations
...be courageous, inviting andwilling to initiate conversations thatmatterfind and hostpowerfulquestionswiththestakeholdersandthenmakesureyouharvesttheinsights,thepatterns,learningsandwiseactions...
Hostingconversations isbothmoreand less than facilitating. It isanactof leadershipandmeans taking responsibility for creating and holding the container inwhich a group ofpeoplecandotheirbestworktogether.
Youcancreatethiscontainerusingtheeighthelpers(seelaterinthisworkbook)asstartingpoints,andalthoughyou canalsodo this in themoment, themorepreparedyouare thebetter.Thebestpreparationisbeingfullypresent.
Thebareminimumshouldbetodiscerntheneed,getclearonthepurposeofthemeeting,prepare a good, powerful question to initiate the conversation and know how you will
Youcanhaveagroupofindividuallyintelligentpeoplebutuntilthatgroupknowswhatitknowstogether,thegroupasagroupisnotintelligent
InspiredbyPeterSenge
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 22
harvestandwhatwillbedonewiththatharvest,toensurethatresultsaresustainableandtheeffortwasworthit.
Hostingconversationstakescourageand ittakesabitofcertaintyandfaith inyourpeople.Wesometimesgiveshortshrifttoconversationalspacesbecauseofthefearweexperienceinsteppinguptohost.Itis,however,agifttohostagroupanditisagifttobehostedwell.
4.CocreatingWithOthersBecomingaCommunityofPractice
...bewilling to co create and cohostwith others, blending your knowing, experience andpracticeswiththeirs,workingpartnership.
The fourthpractice isabout showingup ina conversationwithoutbeinga spectator,andcontributingtothecollectiveefforttosustainresults.Thebestconversationsarisewhenwelistenforwhatisinthemiddle,whatisarisingoutofthecentreofourcollaboration.Itisnotaboutthebalancingof individualagendas, it isaboutfindingoutwhat isnew.Whenthat isdiscovered,workunfoldsbeautifullyaseveryoneisclearaboutwhattheycancontributetothework.
Inatrulycocreativeprocessitbecomesirrelevantwhosaidorcontributedwhatthegiftisinthesynergyandinspirationwhenweeachbuildoneachothersknowledgeandthewholebecomesmuchbiggerthanthesumoftheparts.
Thisishowresultsbecomesustainableovertimetheyfallintothenetworkofrelationshipsthatarisefromagoodconversation,fromfriendsworkingtogether.
Thecollaborativefieldcanproduceunexpectedandsurprisingresults,especiallyincomplexsituationswheremultilayeredchallengesneedtobemetsimultaneously.
FromaLearnertoaCommunityThatLearns
Aswe learntobetrulypresentandengage inconversationsthatreallymatterwebecomelearners.Aslearnersmanydoorsareopentous.
Aswebegintohostconversationandconnectwithotherhostsorpractitionerswebecomeacommunityof learnersorpractitioners. Asa communityweownamuchbigger capacitythanasindividuallearners.
As a community of individual practitioners or learners truly becomes a community thatlearns, that iswherewe reallyenter the collective intelligence.Wemultiplyour capacityandenterthefieldofemergence.
The C
.
Chaossafestinareloowill bestableexactly
Thewoflexibilitfor innochaordi
Thechacomplenotharlevelso
Asinnacollectivourorgaccesstamess
To leadcourageemerge
As wethroughreachnWearesometh
Chaordic
OrderConthestateokingforpredto staywit
andwherewhatisneed
rldandtimety,asmoreovative,newicpath.
aordicpathix,diversesyrdwired,buoforderbeco
ature,soinovelearningaganisationsothecollectivsyprocessu
dourorganise to stay inencethatallo
tread the lhconfusionnewclarity,tallcalledto
hingwhollyn
A
Path
ntrol are dioforder,orfdictability.Ihin the realweproduceded.
esweliveineofthesamew solutionsw
isactuallythystems. Attare flexibleomepossible
organisationandrealtimorcommuniteintelligencuntilwereac
sationonthn the danceowsthenew
ine betweeandconflictthatthetemwalkthispanew.
ArtofHosting
ifferent statforsomepeofwehavealms of orderestatusquo
are,howeveesolutionswewill find
hestoryofotheedgeofeenough foeoutofchao
sthepathbeinnovationtiesfromtheceandcollecchnewinsigh
echaordicpof order a
w,collectivei
n chaos andtowardclar
mptationtorathwithope
g
es of beingople,incontmechanisticr and controoormoreo
er,neitherprarenotmeethem inap
ournaturalwfchaos iswornewconnos.
etweenChan.Insteadofetopdown,ctivewisdomhtandclarity
pathweneend chaos lontelligencea
d order, indrity. It is intrushforcertnmindsand
and experirol.Beingocviewonorgol,where thofthesame
redictablenoetingthechaplacebetwe
world,asformwhere life innectionsand
osandOrdefrelyingonmany leade
mofeveryony.
edchaordicong enoughandwiseacti
dividually anthephaseotaintyorgradsomeconfid
iencing. Weutofcontroganisations,hings are prwhich in
orstableandallenges.Ifwen chaosan
marisesoutnovates,whesolutions to
erleadsustocontrollingeerstodayseee,whichcan
confidenceto supportiontooccur.
nd collectivefnotknowinbforcontrodenceifwew
P a g e | 2
tend to felisscaryifwourtendencedictable ansomecases
dcallformorwearelookinndorderth
tofnonlineaerethingsarooccur. Ne
othenewteverydetailetheneedtnbe,attime
,tohavetha generativ.
ely, we movng,beforewol isstrongeswanttoreac
23
elwecyndis
renghe
ar,rew
tointoes,
heve
vewest.ch
Inthissofusin
Theartis couneverythno movextremeStaying
Chaos/
The prabetweewaywetimes oleadersstrategy
Order/C
The pramaintaimoreoTherefoclearlyd
Linkwit
Thepatoutofconstan
Thepatorrecipsystem.
Wearesimplewith tincreasiandtolearningthatwetofollow
spaceofemedividuallybr
istostayinnterproductivhingdisintegvement thaes, the resuonthechao
Orderisthe
actice of leaenchaosandearecurrenof uncertain need to inyanddecide
ControlisaP
actice ofmainedandexeof thesameore, it iswhdefinedand
ththeCynef
thbetweenChaos and intlearningm
thbetweenCpesorproced.
ethen leadinorcomplicatthe inherening theposssuppresscreg. Here weknowandw.
A
ergence,weroughtintot
thefinebalave. On theratesanddiet eventuallyult is apathordicpathisw
PlaceforLe
adership andorder. Whtlyworking,ty and increnvite othersethewayfor
PlaceforMa
anagement lecutedroutin is requirederepredictaneedtobea
finFramewo
OrderandCis stabilisedmode.
Controlanddurestofoll
ngas intheteddomainnt risk ofsiblechaos,eativityandwe assumerealityhas
ArtofHosting
leaveourcoheroom.
ancebetweee far side oes.Onthefy means dey or rebelliwheretheb
eadership
d particularhenfacingneweneed toeased compto share dirward.
anagement
lies betweennelysothat,e.g. landinability is calladheredto.
ork
Chaos is infoagainst it.
Orderiswhow.Theyar
g
ollectiveenc
enchaosandof chaos is cfarsideoforeath. Whenonthe vealanceisand
rly participatewchallengeo learnnewplexity, wheriverse know
n order andaparticularnganairplaned forandw
ormedbythWe know t
enwebeginenotemerg
counterswit
dorder.Strachamos orrderisstiflinn we movery oppositedwherelifet
tory leadersesthatcannwaysofopere results cawledge to dis
controlwhstandardresnesafely,opwhereproce
ecomplexityhatwedon
ndeclaringagentandfluid
hsomething
ayingtoofardestructivegcontrolwtoward eitof chaordithrives.
ship residesnotbemetwerating. It isannot be prscover new
ere activitiesults.Itistheperatingonaeduresand s
y insights:Onot know an
nddefiningdbutconstr
P a g e | 2
gthatnoton
toeithersidchaos wher
wheretherether of thesc confidenc
in the placwiththesamsduring thesredicted, thapurpose an
es need to beplacewherapatient,etstandardsar
Orderemergendwe stay
bestpracticeainthewho
24
ne
dereissee.
cemeseatnd
beretc.re
esin
esle
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 25
The Chaordic Stepping Stones - A Way to Walk the Path ThereareclearstrategicstepswecantakewhenwalkingtheChaordicpath.Thesestepsareawayofbringing justenoughstructureororder intothechaostokeepusmovingforwardon the chaordic path. These steps allow us to progress gradually giving our project ororganisationmoreformasweprogress.
The first step is identifying the real need, followed by formulating a clear purpose, thendefining theprinciples thathelpguideus towardsourgoal (asattributesorcharacteristicsdescribingwherewewant to be or howwewant to get there), gradually proceeding todefiningaconcept,thengivingitmorestructureandmovingintopractice.Thesestepscan
be used both as a planning tool and to helpunderstand what you are discovering about anorganisation,communityorinitiative.
TheChaordicprocess is incontinualmotion,eachstep integratingand includingtheprevioussteps.It isan iterative,nonlinearprocesssupportedbyanongoingharvestand feedback loop.Onceyouhavedefinedtheprinciplesyoucheckbackiftheysupportthepurposeetc.Theprocessallowsustobeabletoremaininbothreflectionandpractice.
Principles of Cooperation CreatingaContainer:Howarewegoingtobehavetogetherinpursuitofourpurpose?
Whenweenteraninquirywherewedonothavereadyoreasyanswersandwecannotseetheobvioussolutionwealsoenterchaostogether.
Inwalkingthechaordicpathtogether it iswisetostartbycreatingtheconditionsthatcanhelpcontainthatchaos.Wecallthiscreatingacontainer.
Onefundamentalwaytocreateacontaineristoagreeonhowwewanttoworkortraveltogether inpursuitofourgoal. Inotherwordswedefinesomeagreementsorprinciplesofcooperation.
Principles, when defined with clarity, conviction and common understandingguide ourpursuit of purpose. Principles bind a community together and serve as a touchstone toremindusofhowwehaveagreedtoactanddecidetogetheraroundourpurpose.
Scientistshavediscoveredthatthesmall,braveactofcooperatingwith
anotherperson,ofchoosingtrustover
cynicism,generosityover
selfishness,makesthebrainlightup
withquietjoy.
NatalieAngier,PulitzerPrize
winningNewYorkTimesreporter,
describingarecentstudyoftheeffects
ofbehaviouronbrainchemistry
Foradescriptionofthechaordicdesign
process,seetheDeeperProcessDesignSection
FortheVISAstory,seetheadditionalresourcessection
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 26
Divergence and Convergence
Inenteringintoaninquiryormultistakeholderconversationweoperatewiththreedifferentphases in the processdivergent, emergent and convergent. Each of these phases aredifferentand it is important forahost toknowwhereweare in theprocessandwhat isneededineachphase.
Thethreephasesaredifferentwaysofthinkingandworkingthatiscomplimentary.Theycanbe likened to the three phases of breathing: breathing in (lungs expanding/diverging)holding, breathing out (lungs contracting/converging). Divergent and convergent ways ofthinking and working are complimentary and different. The breath of divergence andconvergence,ofbreathinginandbreathingout,isattheheartofourprocessdesign.Everyprocessgoesthroughseveralsuchbreathingcycles(Seealsothesectiononprocessdesignpage32).
Inthedivergentphase,orPreject,thereisasyetnocleargoal.This isa goalseeking phase where a clear and shared purpose gives the collective direction.Anotherdriverinthisphaseisaskingtherightquestions.
Ifyouclosethedivergentphasetoosoon,thelevelofnewnessorinnovationwillbeless.
Ideally a groupwill stay in inquiry in thedivergentphase until anew shared and agreedsolutionemerges,oragoalisseencollectively.
DivergentThinking: Typicallygeneratesalternatives,has freeforallopendiscussion,gathersdiversepointsofviewandunpackstheproblem.
TheDivergentPhase Isnonlinearandneedschaostime. It isprocessorientedandneeds prolonged decision time. To host this phase well, it isimportant to focus on the process and allow sufficient time,
Groan Zone
Clear purpose
Diversity
Divergent phase
Emergent phase
Convergent phase
Clear goal
Time
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 27
knowingthatthenextphasescangorapidlywhenthisfirstphaseisallowedtoruntoterm.
ConvergentThinking: Means evaluating alternatives, summarising key points, sortingideasintocategoriesandarrivingatgeneralconclusions.
TheConvergentPhase Is goaloriented and focused, linear, structured and usuallysubject to time constraints. It is focusedongetting resultsandmayrequirequickdecisions.
TheEmergentPhase Betweenthedivergentandconvergentphase,isfondlyknownasthe groanzone, it isthephasewhere magichappens. It isthephasewhere different ideas and needs are integrated. It mayrequireustostretchourownunderstandingtoholdand includeotherpointsofview. We call it thegroan zonebecause itmayfeel messy, an uncomfortable stretch, but it is also the phasewherethenewandinnovativesolutionemerges.
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 28
Working With Emergence Putsimply,emergenceisthephenomenonofOrderarisingoutofChaos.
Amorenuanceddefinitiongoeslikethis:
Emergenceishigherordercomplexityarisingoutofchaos,inwhichnovel,coherentstructurescoalescethroughinteractionsamongthediverseentitiesofasystem.Emergenceoccurswhentheseinteractionsdisrupt,causingthesystemtodifferentiateandultimatelycoalesceintosomethingnovel.
Participatoryleadershipworkswithemergentchangeprocesses.Theworkisdonenotbytraditional'commandandcontrol'approaches,butby:
Settingclearintentions
Creatinghospitableconditions
Invitingdiversepeopletoconnect
Therearesomecatchestoworkingwithemergence,howeverthatcanbeespeciallychallengingtoleadersintraditionalcultures
Gettingstartedisaleapoffaiththeseedsofmostgreatideasaremisunderstood,dismissedordiscouragedbyothers.
Successcanbeahurdlesinceengagingemergenceinvolvestheunknown,itisrisky.Organisationsareafraidtoproceedwithoutcertainty.
Outcomescanbedifficulttorecognisewhenweencounternovelty,ourfirstimpulseistotrytofititintoourexistingframeofreference.Sometimesseeminglyminorshiftscanchangefundamentalassumptionsabouthowthingswork.Yetyearsmaypassbeforeweappreciatetheimplications.
What'smostimportantisprobablynotonourradarscreenorganisationstendtomeasuretangibleslike'numberofprojectslaunchedandsuccessfullyimplemented'.Butthemostpowerfulfruitsofemergentchangeprocessestendstobeintangibles,liketrustandfriendship.Selforganisingnetworksarisethatcanbecatalysedintoactionifanintentionofsufficientmagnitudearises.
Noteveryonemakesthetripmostofushaveexperiencedsituationsinwhichothershavedivedin,bywe'vechosennottoplay.Arewemissingsomething?Oriseverybodyelsedangerouslyderanged?
Deathorlossisusuallypartofthemixperhapsfearoflossisthebiggestreasonwhyweresistemergence.Fewofuschoosetoexperienceemotionalturmoilifwecanavoidit,soweinventstrategiesthatburytherootcausesofdisturbance,perhapsinadvertentlysettingupasystemtodie.
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 29
ThissectionisadaptedfromEngagingEmergenceturningupheavalintoopportunity,byPeggyHolman.
Practicesforengagingemergence
Stepuptakeresponsibilityforwhatyouloveasanactofservice.Thiswillenhanceyourcapacitytolistenandconnect.
Prepareembracemystery,choosepossibilityandfollowlifeenergy.Thiswillhelpyoutofacewhatevershowsupwithequanimity,ifnotdelight!
Hostfocusintentionsandwelcome.Thesepracticescreatehospitablespacesforworkingwithwhateverarises.Invitediversitytoincreasethelikelihoodofproductiveconnectionsamongpeoplewithdifferentbeliefsandassumptions.
Stepininquireappreciatively(themorepositivetheinquiry,themorelifeaffirmingtheoutcome);opentotheunknown;reflect,nameandharvest.
Iteratechangeisneverending.Letusnotgetlostinourroutines!
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 30
Organising Patterns - Four Organisational Paradigms Over the millennia, human beings have developed many different ways of organisingtogether. Eachnewageof civilizationhas its signature formoforganisation. Oneof thequestions that theArt ofHosting community is continually asking itself is What are theorganisationalconceptsthatwecandeveloptogetherthatareactuallygoodforus,andaregoodforthistime?
Circle
Asnomadswelivedinsmallgroups.Thecirclebecamethemotherofallourorganisationalformshumansstartedsittingincircleassoonastheyinventedfirestositaround.Wetoldstories,held elder councils and solvedproblems in thisway. This form is veryuseful forreflection,storytelling,beingtogether.Purposeisinthecentreitissharedbyall.
Hierarchy(Triangle)
Aswestoppedournomadicwanderingandsettled inoneplace,wedevelopedagriculture.Our communities grew bigger, and the clergy (for ritual) and the warrior or soldier (forprotection) classes emerged. We began to develop hierarchies and organised in levelswhere one person or group of people had power over others. The triangular form ofhierarchyisveryusefulforaction,forgettingthingsdone.Purposeisheldatthetoplevel.
Bureaucracy(Square)
Simplehierarchiesarenotdesignedtodealwithahighdegreeofcomplexity.Theindustrialage brought change and more complexity. Bureaucracy became the predominantorganisational model, specializing horizontally and embracing hierarchy, which controlledvertically. Together theymanagedmuchgreater complexity thaneither coulddoalone..Bureaucracy is fantastic for stability, optimising and maintaining the status quo, and formanaging complex situations to a certain degree. As complexity and speed growsthebureaucracy isnotagileenoughtorespondquickly. Ittypicallymovesslowly inthefaceofchange.Purposeinthebureaucracyisalsoatthetop.
Hierarchy Agricultural Age
Circle/Council - Nomadic Age
Bureaucracy Industrial Age
Networks Information Age
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 31
Networks
Amorerecentorganisationalform(firstdescribed inthe70s)ofnetworksemerged intheinformation/communicationage,asaresponsetoaneedtoorganiseandreorganisequicklyand flexibly. Networks are collections of individuals, circles (small groups) or triangles(hierarchies)nodes that are connected together. Networks can link all types oforganisations. Networksalsoexist insidebureaucracies. Networksusuallygatheraroundashared purpose and are great for relationship, flexibility and innovation, and for gettingthings done fast. The connection is guided by individual purpose harmonising with acollective purpose. The different nodes are connected together because their respectivepurposesneedeachother. Oncetheneed isno longerthere,thenetworkconnectionwillmostoftenlapse.
Source:JessicaLipnerandJeffreyStamps
Whenaneworganisationalformemerges,theolderonesdonotdisappear.Eachformhasbothadvantagesandshortcomingseachisgoodfordifferentthings.
Whenwewanttostartanorganisationourselvesororganisesomething inour lives,whichoneoftheseorganisationalformsdowechoose?Whatwehaveseen intheArtofHostingcommunity isthatweneedtobuildstructuresthatcanuseanyoftheseformsattherighttime.Asneedarises,howareweabletorespondwiththemostusefulorganisationalform?
When something needs to get done, then triangle is great. Whenwe need to stop andreflect,circleisuseful.Whenweneedstabilityanddealwithsomedegreeofcomplexity,itisgoodtohaveabureaucracy.Whenweneedtoinnovate,networksworkbest.Sowhatis
M
Mechanistic Models
Simple
Complex
PaceofChange
Random Slow
Fast Medium
A NEED!
Organic Models
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 32
the next level of organisational form that can hold all of these? The Art of Hostingcommunityisobservingtheemergenceofanewpattern
A Fifth Organisational Paradigm
Thefifthorganisationalpatternisacombinationofthecircleorcouncilforcollectiveclarity,the triangle or project team (hierarchy) for action and the square or bureaucracy foraccountability, structure and stability and the network for rapid sharing of information,Inspirationandlinkingallthepartstogether.
Atthecentre,always,isourpurpose.Typically,acoreteamwillgatherinacirclearoundapurpose,whichwillbebasedonmeetinganeedthatisfeltinourlifecontexts.Aswegatheraroundthecorepurpose,webegintoformrelationshipswithothersinthecirclethat,aswemaptheconnections,starttoshowupasanetwork.Butwhiletheserelationshipscanhelpus allwith our individualwork, they do not necessarily allow us tomanifest our sharedpurposeintheworld,whichwilltypicallyinvolvemakingthingshappen.Thefirststepmightbetodevelopactionstosustainthecoreteam. So individualmemberstakeresponsibilityfordifferentaspectslikeorganisingmeetingsorraisingfundsothermembersstepupinasupportroleandthis leadstotheformationoftriangles(e.g.projectteams). Thetriangleswillbedictatedbythecentralpurpose.Hierarchyformsinresponsetoacollectivepurpose.
Oncethecoreteamissustainable,thenextstepistypicallytoopenuptheconversationtothewidercommunity that feels theneed tobepartof theendeavourandthatinformsthepurpose at the centre of our circle. A trianglefrom the core teammight then get together tocalla largerscaleassembly,whichmightbecomeacircleofsupporters for the largerproject. Theinnercircleisreachingouttothenextlevel,whichwill in turn reach out to a wider community,creating concentric circles rippling out into oursociety, each circle connected to the others bytriangles animating action informed by the core
purpose.The pattern of core purpose, circles, triangles and networks repeats again and again.Another typical finding is that as the core team goes out into the community and theconversation expands, the core purpose is informed by a broader perspective and isadjustedaccordinglytoaccommodatethenextlevelofscaleandaction.
Itisimportanttounderstandthatwhatwearedescribinghereisnotadeliberatelydesignedmodel,butapatternthathasemergednaturallyandspontaneouslythroughouttheglobalhostingcommunityaswehavecollectivelydevelopedourworkofhostingineverlargerandmorecomplexadaptivesystems.
Example of the fifth paradigm: the Food And Society Conference organised by the Kellogg Foundation in the USA
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 33
CORE METHODS Thefollowingpageswillgiveashortintroductiontosomeofthecoremethodologiesthataregoodpractice inparticipatory leadership. Theyaredesigned toengageagroupofpeople(largeorsmall)instrategicconversations,whereourcollectivewisdomandintelligencecanbeengagedinserviceoffindingthebestsolutionsforacommonpurpose.
Thereare somebasicprinciplesorqualities thatarecommon toall thesemethodologies,e.g.
They offer a simple structure that helps to engage small or large groups inconversationsthatcanleadtoresults.
Theyeachhavetheirspecialadvantagesandlimitations.
Theyareusuallybasedondialogue,with intentionalspeaking (speakingwhenyoureally have something to say) and attentive listening (listening to understand) asbasicpractices,allowingus togoonanexplorationanddiscovery together, ratherthantryingtoconvinceeachotherofourownpresenttruths.
Suspendingassumptions isabasicpractice. Itallowsus to listenwithoutbias (orwithlessbias)andtoexamineourownpresenttruths.
Circle is thebasicorganisational form,whetherusedas theonly form (e.g. circlepractice) or used as many smaller conversation circles, woven into a biggerconversation,(e.g.WorldCaf,OpenSpace)
Meetinginacircleisameetingofequals.Generallyallthesemethodologiesinspirepeertopeerdiscoveryandlearning.
Inquiry or powerful questions are a driving force. Answers tend to close aconversationwhileinquirykeepstheconversationgoingdeeper.
Thepurposeof all this is to thinkwell together, that is to engage the collectiveintelligenceforbettersolutions.
Facilitating these engagements or conversations is more like stewarding orhosting,allowingthesolutionstoemergefromthewisdominthemiddle.Hostingwellrequiresacertainproficiency in the fourfoldpracticeof:beingpresent in themoment to what is happening, engaging in conversations with others, hostingconversationsandcocreatingorcohostingwithothers.
Thereareanumberofconditionsthatneedtobe inplaceforengagementtoworkwell. Anyengagementorstrategicconversationneeds tobebased ina realneedandhastohaveaclearpurpose. Anygivensorboundaryconditionsneedtobeclearaheadoftime. Youmayalsohavedefinedsuccesscriteriaorhavean ideaoftheoutcomeeveniftheconcretesolutionswillemergefromtheconversations(seealsothesectionondesign)
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 34
The Circle Practice
Thecircle,orcouncil,isanancientformofmeetingthathasgatheredhumanbeingsintorespectfulconversationforthousandsofyears.Thecirclehasservedasthefoundationformanycultures.
Whattransformsameetingintoacircleisthewillingnessofpeopletoshiftfrominformalsocialisingoropinionateddiscussionintoareceptiveattitudeofthoughtfulspeakinganddeeplisteningandtoembodyandpracticethestructuresoutlinedhere.
Whatiscirclegoodfor?
Oneofthebeautifulthingsaboutcircle is itsadaptabilitytoavarietyofgroups, issues,andtimeframes.Circlecanbetheprocessusedforthedurationofagathering,particularlyifthegroupisrelativelysmallandtimefordeepreflectionisaprimaryaim.Circlecanalsobeusedas ameans for checking in and checking out or away ofmaking decisions together,particularlydecisionsbasedonconsensus.Becreativewithcircleandbereadyforthedeepwisdomitcanuncover!
Thecomponentsofthecircle
Intention WelcomeStartpoint CentreandCheckin/Greeting Agreements ThreePrinciplesandThreePractices Guardianofprocess CheckoutandFarewell Tendtothewellbeingofthegroupremainingawareoftheimpactofourcontributions
INTENTIONIntentionshapesthecircleanddetermineswhowillcome,howlongthecirclewillmeet,andwhatkindsofoutcomesaretobeexpected.Thecallerofthecirclespendstimearticulatingintentionandinvitation.Additionally,thecentreofacircleusuallyholdsafocusthatcanbesupportedbyplacingthequestioninthecentreorobjectsthatrepresenttheintentionofthecircle.
WELCOMEORSTARTPOINTOncepeoplehavegathered,itishelpfulforthehost,oravolunteerparticipant,tobeginthecirclewithagesturethatshiftspeople'sattentionfromsocialspacetocouncilspace.Thisgestureofwelcomemaybeamomentofsilence,readingapoem,orlisteningtoasongwhateverinvitescentering.ESTABLISHINGTHECENTERThecentreofacircleislikethehubofawheel:allenergiespassthroughit,anditholdsthe
Resource:www.peerspirit.com
ThishandoutisagiftfromPeerSpirit,Inc.
aneducationalcompanydevotedtolifeandleadership
throughCircle,QuestandStory.Foundedin1994,PeerSpirithastaughtcircleprocessintheUS,
Canada,EuropeandAfrica.Itisaconsortium
consistingofChristinaBaldwin,
AnnLinneaandteachingcolleagues
withareasofexpertiseinhealth
careadministration,religious/church
administrationandcongregational
health,education,nonprofitboards,
environmentalandcommunityrevisioning
Formoreinformation:
http://www.peerspirit.com/downloadabl
egifts.html
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 35
rimtogether.Tohelppeoplerememberhowthehubhelpsthegroup,thecentreofacircleusuallyholdsobjectsthatrepresenttheintentionofthecircle.Anysymbolthatfitsthispurposeoraddsbeautywillserve:flowers,abowlorbasket,acandle.CHECKIN/GREETINGCheckinhelpspeopleintoaframeofmindforcouncilandremindseveryoneoftheircommitmenttotheexpressedintention.Itinsuresthatpeoplearetrulypresent.Verbalsharing,especiallyabriefstory,weavestheinterpersonalnet.Checkinusuallystartswithavolunteerandproceedsaroundthecircle.Ifanindividualisnotreadytospeak,theturnispassedandanotheropportunityisofferedafterothershavespoken.Sometimespeopleplaceindividualobjectsinthecentreasawayofsignifyingtheirpresenceandrelationshiptotheintention.
SETTINGCIRCLEAGREEMENTS:Theuseofagreementsallowsallmemberstohaveafreeandprofoundexchange,torespectadiversityofviews,andtoshareresponsibilityforthewellbeinganddirectionofthegroup.Agreementsoftenusedinclude: Wewillholdstoriesorpersonalmaterialinconfidentiality. Welistentoeachotherwithcompassionandcuriosity. Weaskforwhatweneedandofferwhatwecan. Weagreetoemployagroupguardiantowatchourneed,timing,andenergy.Weagreetopause
atasignal,andtocallforthatsignalwhenwefeeltheneedtopause.THREEPRINCIPLES:Thecircleisanallleadergroup.1. Leadershiprotatesamongallcirclemembers.2. Responsibilityissharedforthequalityofexperience.3. Relianceisonwholeness,ratherthanonanypersonalagenda.
THREEPRACTICES1. Tospeakwithintention:notingwhathasrelevancetotheconversationinthemoment.2. Tolistenwithattention:respectfulofthelearningprocessforallmembersofthegroup.3. Totendthewellbeingofthecircle:remainingawareoftheimpactofourcontributions.
FORMSOFCOUNCIL:Thecirclecommonlyusesthreeformsofcouncil:talkingpiece,conversationandreflection.Talkingpiececouncilisoftenusedaspartofcheckin,checkout,andwheneverthereisadesiretoslowdowntheconversation,collectallvoicesandcontributions,andbeabletospeakwithoutinterruption.Conversationcouncilisoftenusedwhenreaction,interaction,andaninterjectionofnewideas,thoughtsandopinionsareneeded.Reflection,orSilentcouncilgiveseachmembertimeandspacetoreflectonwhatisoccurring,orneedstooccur,inthecourseofameeting.Silencemaybecalledsothateachpersoncanconsidertheroleorimpacttheyarehavingonthegroup,ortohelpthegrouprealignwiththeirintention,ortositwithaquestionuntilthereisclarity.
GUARDIAN
Thesingtherolesafeguar
Theguardeveryoneagainand
CHECKOUAttheclwhattheClosingtreflectoAspeopintensitywilloffereleased
MATERIA
Chaitable
Objepurp
Talki
Chim
Mate
Mayyou
glemostimpooftheguardirdgroupener
dianusuallyetostopactio
dspeakstowh
UTANDFAREWloseofacircleeylearned,orthecirclebyconwhathastrleshiftfromcyofattentionrafewinspirad.
ALSNEEDED
rsarrangeinesordesks)
ectforthecenposeofthega
ingpiece
me,belloroth
erialsforharv
urcirclesbeg
A
rtanttoolforan.Toprovidrgyandobserv
mploysagenn,takeabreahyhe/shecal
WELLemeeting,itirwhatstaysincheckingoutpranspired,andcouncilspacebeingincircleationalwords
acirclepeo
ntrethisistotheringorany
herinstrumen
vestingconver
reatteachers
ArtofHosting
aidingselfgoeaguardian,vethecircles
ntlenoisemakath,restinasledthepause
simportanttontheirheartaprovidesaformdtopickupobtosocialspacerequires.Ofsoffarewell,o
pleshouldbe
obringfocus.yotherobject
ttocallevery
rsation
andplacesto
g
overnanceandonecirclemesprocess.
ker,suchasaspaceofsilene.Anymembe
oallowafewandmindasthmalendtothbjectsiftheyhceorprivatetftenafterchecorsignalafew
abletoview
Itcanbeflowtthathasmea
yonetoattent
orestonthejo
dbringingtheemberatatim
chime,bell,oce.Thentheermaycallfo
minutesforeheyleave.emeeting,achaveplacedsime,theyreleckout,thehowsecondsofs
eachotherw
wers,aposteraning
tion
ourney.
ecirclebacktomevolunteers
orrattle,thatguardianmakrapause.
eachpersonto
chanceformeomethinginteaseeachothost,guardian,silencebefore
ithoutimpedi
rstatingthein
P a g e | 3
ointentionistowatchand
tsignalskesthissigna
ocommenton
emberstothecentre.erfromtheoravolunteethecircleis
iments(i.e.
ntentionor
36
d
l
n
er
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 37
Appreciative Inquiry
AppreciativeInquiryisastrategyforintentionalchangethatidentifiesthebestofwhatistopursue dreams and possibilities of what could be; a cooperative search for strengths,passionsandlifegivingforcesthatarefoundwithineverysystemandthatholdpotentialforinspired,positivechange.(Cooperrider&Srivastva,1987)
Assumptions
Ineverycommunitysomethingworks Whatwefocusonbecomesourreality Realityiscreatedinthemomentthereismorethanonereality Theactofaskingquestionsinfluencesthecommunityinsomeway Peoplehavemoreconfidenceandcomforttojourneyintothefuturewhentheycarry
forwardpartsofthepast Ifwecarryforwardpartsofthepast,theyshouldbewhatisbest Itisimportanttovaluedifferences Thelanguageweusecreatesourreality
WhatisAppreciativeInquirygoodfor?
Appreciative Inquiry isusefulwhenadifferentperspective isneeded,orwhenwewish tobeginanewprocess froma fresh,positivevantagepoint. Itcanhelpmoveagroupthat isstuckinwhatistowardwhatcouldbe.AppreciativeInquirycanbeusedwithindividuals,partners,smallgroups,orlargeorganisations.
ProblemSolving
AppreciativeInquiry
FeltNeedidentificationoftheproblem AppreciatingandvaluingthebestofwhatisAnalysisofcauses EnvisioningwhatmightbeAnalysisofpossiblesolutions
DialoguingWhatshouldbeInnovatingWhatwillbe
Basicassumption:anorganisationisaproblemtobesolved.
Basicassumption:anorganisationisamysterytobeembraced.
Resource:http://appreciativei
nquiry.case.edu/
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 38
GeneralflowofanAppreciativeInquiryprocess:
Appreciativeinquirycanbedoneasalongerstructuredprocessgoingthrough5phasesof:
Definition: Surfacingthefocusforinquiringappreciatively.Discovery: Identifyingorganisationalprocessesthatworkwell.Dream: Envisioningprocessesthatwouldworkwellinthefuture.Design: Planningandprioritisingthoseprocesses.Delivery: Implementingtheproposeddesign.
The basic idea is tobuild organisationsaround what works,ratherthantryingtofixwhatdoesn't.
At the centre is apositive topicchoicehowweaskeven the firstquestion containsthe seedsof changewe are looking toenact.
Appreciative Inquirycanalsobeusedasawayofopeningameetingorconversationby identifyingwhatalreadyworks.Whatdoyouvaluemostaboutyourself,workandorganisation?
WhatisAppreciativeInquiryGoodFor?
Appreciative Inquiry isusefulwhenadifferentperspective isneeded,orwhenwewish tobeginanewprocessfromafresh,positivevantagepoint. Itcanhelpmoveagroupthat isstuckinwhatistowardwhatcouldbe.AppreciativeInquirycanbeusedwithindividuals,partners,smallgroups,orlargeorganisations.
MaterialsNeeded:
Varies depending on how the methodology is used. For more information:http://appreciativeinquiry.case.edu/
Definition Topic Choice
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 39
The World Caf
TheWorldCaf isamethod forcreatinga livingnetworkofcollaborativedialoguearoundquestionsthatmatter inreal lifesituations. It isaprovocativemetaphor.Aswecreateourlives, our organisations, and our communities, we are, in effect, moving among tableconversationsattheWorldCaf.(FromTheWorldCafResourceGuide)
OperatingPrinciplesofWorldCafe:
Createhospitablespace Explorequestionsthat
matter Encourageeachpersons
contribution Connectdiversepeople
andideas Listentogetherfor
patterns,insightsanddeeperquestions
Makecollectiveknowledgevisible
AssumptionsofWorldCafe:
Theknowledgeandwisdomweneedispresentandaccessible.
Collectiveinsightevolvesfromhonouringuniquecontributions;connectingideas;listeningintothemiddle;noticingdeeperthemesandquestions.
Theintelligenceemergesasthesystemconnectstoitselfindiverseandcreativeways.
Resource:www.theworldcafe
.com
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 40
GeneralFlowofaWorldCaf:
Seat45peopleatcafstyletablesorinconversationclusters. Set up progressive rounds of conversation, usually of 2030 minutes eachhave
somegoodquestions! Askonepersontostayatthetableasahostandinvitetheothertablemembersto
movetoothertablesasambassadorsofideasandinsights Askthetablehosttosharekey insights,questions,and ideasbrieflywithnewtable
members,thenletfolksmovethroughtheroundsofquestions. Afteryouvemovedthroughtherounds,allowsometimeforawholegroupharvest
oftheconversations.
WhatisWorldCafGoodFor?
WorldCaf isagreatwayof fostering interactionanddialoguewithboth largeand smallgroups. It is particularly effective in surfacing the collective wisdom of large groups ofdiversepeople. The caf format isvery flexibleandadapts tomanydifferentpurposesinformationsharing,relationshipbuilding,deepreflectionexplorationandactionplanning.
Whenplanningacaf,makesuretoleaveampletimeforbothmovingthroughtheroundsofquestions(likelytotakelongerthanyouthink!)andsometypeofwholegroupharvest.
MaterialsNeeded:
Smalltables(3642),preferablyround Chairsforparticipantsandpresenters Tablecloths Flipchartpaperorpaperplacematsforcoveringthetables Markers Flipchartorlargepaperforharvestingcollectiveknowledgeorinsights Posters/tabletentsshowingtheCafEtiquette Materialsforharvesting
Thisinformationwasadaptedfrom
CaftoGoatwww.theworldcafe
.com
wwResource
ww.openspaceworld.org
Open
Thegoaengagewith thtransfopowerfthrivein
Principles
The fouandbou
RolesinO
GeneralF
Thegro
Thefacinvitespapera
Theseptimean
Thegrosessionin.
e:eg
n Space T
alofanOpedeeplyand
he power anrmative expulwaytocantimesofsw
sofOpenSpa
WhoevercoWheneveritWhateverhWhenitsov
urprinciplesundedbythe
OpenSpace:
HostannoParticipantBumblebeeButterflyt
lowofanOpe
oupconvenes
ilitatorprovipeoplewithandannounc
peopleare"ndaplaceto
oupthenbres.Participan
A
Technolo
enSpaceTecreativelyarnd desire toperiences fotalyseeffectwirlingchang
ce:
omesarethetstartsistheappensistheveritsover
and the laweresponsibil
unceandhoparticipateshopbeaketimeout
enSpaceMee
sinacirclea
idesanover issuesofcocesittotheg
conveners."meet.This
eaksupandntstakenote
ArtofHosting
ogy
chnologymroundissueso see it thror the indivitiveworkingge.
rightpeopleerighttimeeonlything
wwork tocrlityofthepa
ostaworkshoinaworkshetweenworkttoreflect
eting:
andiswelcom
viewoftheoncern tocogroup.
Eachconveprocesscont
headstotheofthetime
Ifyoufindycontributin
Followyou
g
eeting is tosofconcernough. Typiciduals and gconversatio
e
thatcouldh
reateapowarticipants.
opopkshops
medbythes
processandome into the
nerplacesttinuesuntilt
heagendaweandplace
TheLaw
yourselfinasngorlearning
yo
urPASSION&
create timetothem.Thally, Open Sgroups invoonsandtotr
ave
erfulevent
sponsor.
explainshowecircle,writ
heirpaperothereareno
wall,bynowforsessions
ofTwoFeet
situationwhg,movesomoucan.
&takeyourR
eand spaceheagendaisSpace meetolved. It is aulyinviteorg
motivatedb
witworks.Tte the issue
onthewallamoreagend
coveredwittheywantt
t:
ereyouarenmewherewhe
RESPONSIBIL
P a g e | 4
forpeople tsetbypeopings resulta simple anganisationst
by thepassio
Thefacilitatoonapieceo
andchoosesdaitems.
thavarietyotobeinvolve
notere
TY
41
toleinndto
on
orof
a
ofed
Dialogugroup)reports
Followithe issutheroo
Thegrocomme
WhatisO
OpenSenvisioncommu
OpenS
Openspenough
ue sessionscapture thewillbeharv
ngaclosinguesthathavm."
oupthenfinients,insights
OpenSpaceGo
paceTechnoning the futunityplannin
paceTechno
ArealissueDiversityofComplexityPresenceofAneedfora
pacecanbehtimeandsp
A
convene fore importantvestedinsom
orabreak,tebeendiscu
ishesthemeandcommit
oodFor
ologyisusefure,conflictg,collaborat
ologyisanex
ofconcernplayersofelementspassion(incaquickdecisi
usedingroupaceforseve
ArtofHosting
r the rest opoints and
mewayandr
thegroupmiussedandat
eetingwithatmentsarisin
ulinalmostt resolution,tionanddee
xcellentmee
cludingconfliion
upsof10toeralsessions
g
of the meetpost the rereturnedtot
ightmoveinttachesactio
aclosingcircngfromthep
anycontextmoralebuil
eplearninga
etingformat
ict)
1,000(andpstooccur.T
ing. Recordeports on thethelargergro
toconvergeonplanstot
clewherepeprocess.
t,includingsding,consulboutissuesa
foranysitua
probablylargTheoutcome
ers (determe newswalloup.
ence,aprocthemto"ge
eopleare inv
strategicdireltationwithandperspect
ationinwhic
ger).Itsimpescanbedra
P a g e | 4
ined by eacl.All of thes
cessthattaketthemouto
vitedtoshar
ectionsettinstakeholdertives.
hthereis:
portanttogivamaticwhen
42
chse
esof
re
g,rs,
vea
Sea
Ma&
Thisprocessiadaptedandinspiredby
Futurearchasocia
technologydevelopedbyrvinWeisbordSandraJanof
group ihappen
Materials
Colle
Amindradially
ACollectiv
Acollecopportufocus topportu
Theminmappro
GroundR
isdyealyydff
is uses its pn.
Needed:
CircleofchaLettersornuAblankwallAnewswallBreakoutspPaperonwhMarkers/PePostersofthMaterialsfo
ctive Min
dmapisadiaaroundacenandasanai
veMindMap
ctivemindmunitiesrelevathat can beunitiesyoua
ndmapcanogram,proje
RulesforMaki
A
passion and
airsforparticumbersaroulthatwillbeforrecordinacesformeehichtowritencils/PenshePrinciplesorharvest
nd-map
agramusedtotralkeywordidinstudy,org
p
map isaquicanttoapartcaptured insateamare
bedoneeitectedonasc
ingaCollectiv
ArtofHosting
responsibil
cipantsundtheroomcometheagngandpostinetingssessiontopi
s,LawofTwo
orepresentwod oridea.Itisuganisation,pr
ckandsimplticularsubjen a burninefacingnow
therona larcreen.
veMindMap
g
ity (and is g
mtoindicategendangtheresult
ics/question
oFeet,andR
ords,ideas,tausedtogeneraroblemsolving
lewaytocrctorchalleng question?
rgesheetof
:
given the ti
meetingloc
softhedialo
s
Roles(option
asksorotheritate,visualize,g,decisionma
eateasharenge.Theminn, e.g. What
paperorel
ime) to mak
cations
oguesession
nal)
temslinkedtostructureandaking,andwri
edoverviewndmapalwat are the m
ectronically,
P a g e | 4
ke somethin
ns
oandarrangedclassifyideaiting.
Wikiped
of issuesanayshasacleamain issues o
withamind
43
ng
edas,
dia
ndaror
d
The hopresent
Makingth
Theminanyonetheposwhowicanpre
If thegtherun
Theactmap.Thmaprad
Voting
Whenatheprioonthet
Thevotleverag
AllideasareWhoever pwhetheritiIt'sOKtohaWheneverp
st explains tttheirideas
heMindMap
ndmapprocehasanideastitandholdllthencalloesenttheirid
group is largenerswhenit
ualmapisdhemajor thdiatingoutf
allthemesanoritiesbyvotthemesoris
tingprocedueforfurther
A
evaluable!Wpresents anisamajorthavecontradipossible,give
the proceduandsuggest
cessisleadborissuethed itup.Runoutthenameeaorissue.
e therewilltisthepartic
rawnupbytemesanddromthecen
ndissueshating.Everyosuestheyse
uregivesa craction.
ArtofHosting
Wedonotevidea or issuemeorasubctingthemeeconcretee
ure and ruleions.
byahost.Alywanttosunerswillcolesintheord
beaneed fcipant'sturn
twoscribes.ifferent issutralquestion
vebeenrecoonegetsanueeasmostim
clear indicat
g
valuateordie decideswbissue.sorissues.examples.
es ofmaking
lparticipantuggestforthellecttheposerreceived.
forradiomictospeak.
Thecentralesunderean.
ordedontheumberofvotmportant.
tiononwhic
scardideasawhere it goe
g a collectiv
tshaveaccesemindmap,stitsandgivOnceaper
crophones.T
questionisch themear
emindmap,tesi.e.sticky
ch themeso
atthispoint.es on them
emindmap
sstopostit,theywritetvethemtotrson'sname
Thesewillbe
atthecentrererecorded
,thegroupcydotsthatt
r issueshav
P a g e | 4
.indmap, an
p. Participan
notes.Whetheirnameothe facilitatoiscalled,the
eprovidedb
eofthemindon themind
candecideoheycanplac
ve thehighe
44
nd
ts
enonor,ey
by
dd
once
st
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 45
Scribes capturewhat is said and draw themindmap, either on a bigmindmap or on ascreen.
In thevotingprocesseveryonegetsa certainnumberofvotes toplaceon the themesorissuestheybelievearemostcrucial.
The Pro Action Caf
The Pro Action Caf is a space for creative and action oriented conversation whereparticipants are invited tobring their call,project, ideas,questionsorwhatever they feelcalledbyandneedhelptomanifestintheworld.
TheconceptofProActionCafisablendof'WorldCaf'and'OpenSpace'technologies.ItwasfirstconceivedbyRainervonLeoprechtingandRiaBaeckinBrussels,Belgium.
WhatisProActionCafGoodFor?
Asaconversationalprocess,theProActionCafisacollective,innovativeyetsimplemethodologyforhostingconversationsaboutcalls,questionsandprojectsthatmattertothepeoplethatattend.Theseconversationslinkandbuildoneachotheraspeoplemovebetweencaftables,crosspollinateideas,andoffereachothernewinsightsintothequestionsorissuesthataremostimportantintheirlife,work,organisationorcommunity.
Asaprocess, theProActionCafcanevokeandmakevisible thecollective intelligenceofanygroup,thusincreasingpeoplescapacityforeffectiveactioninpursuitofgoodwork.ProActionCafcanbeusedwithanetworkofpeopleand/orasamethodology fora specificgroup, organisation or community to engage in creative and inspirational conversationleadingtowiserandmorecollectivelyinformedactions.
ProAction Caf is also a growing global community of people, groups, organizations andnetworksthatpracticethisconversationalformat.
GeneralFlowofaProActionCaf:
Startwith aquick checkin circle to connect to thepurposeof the sessionandwitheachother.Ifcheckinhasalreadytakenplaceaspartofalongerprocess,gostraighttobuildingtheagenda.
Youneed2 to3hours foragoodProActionCaf. Inviteparticipantsstep forwardwiththeircallandinthatwayaskthecommunityforthehelpyouneedtomoveyourprojectintoaction.Peoplewithacallstandup,speakitandwriteitontheagendathatcorrespondstoanumberedcaftable,otherparticipantsareinvitedtomovearoundandengagearoundthethemesproposedbyothers.
Dividingthenumberofparticipantsby4givesthenumberofcallerswithprojectsthatcanbeworked.Forexample,with40peopleyoucanhavemaximum10callerseachwithaproject.
MoreInfoon:http://sites.google.com/a/proaction.eu/proactioncaf/howtobecomeahost/hostingkit,
ArtofHosting
P a g e | 46
Theprincipleisfirstcomefirstserved.Ifyouhavefewercallersaddchairstocaftablesbutnomorethan5ateachtable.Duringthisprocesseachcontributingparticipant(thosewhodonotstepforward)getstosupport3ofthedifferentprojects.
Whentheagendahasbeencreated, invitethecallerstogototheirnumberedcaftables.Therewillbe3roundsof20to30minuteconversationsincafstyle,eachguidedbyafewgenericquestionstohelpdeepenandfocustheconversations:
Round1:
Whatisthequestbehindthecall/question/project?todeepentheneedandpurposeofthecall.Diggingunderthesurfaceofwhatweknowalready.
Round2:
What is missing? when the quest has beendeepened,adiscoverqu