7/14/2021
1
AMA Guides Chapter 13The Central & Peripheral Nervous System
By Timothy Mussack
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
2
Bradford & Barthel
Bradford & Barthel, LLP
@bradfordbarthel
Bradford & Barthel bradfordbarthelllp
7/14/2021
2
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
3
BLOG Articlesbradfordbarthel.blogspot.com/
AMA Rating Departmentbradfordbarthel.com/areas-of-practice/bb-ratings/
CE Videosbradfordbarthel.com/education/
CE Webinarsbradfordbarthel.com/education/
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
AMA Analysis & Ratings Division
Website: https://bradfordbarthel.com/areas-of-practice/bb-ratings/
Referrals: [email protected]
4
7/14/2021
3
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Timothy Mussack, Esq.Director, AMA Analysis & [email protected]
Don Barthel, Esq.Founding Partner(916) [email protected]
Susan ColiasRating Specialist(909) [email protected]
5
Meet our Team!Tahmeena Ahmed, Esq.Managing Partner, Client Relations(818) [email protected]
Tammey WeltyDirector, Training(916) [email protected]
Kenneth Tolbert Rater(909) [email protected]
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
6
7/14/2021
4
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Review WPI reporting•Does the doctor explain the WPI?
▫ Objective findings should lead to the correct Chapter, correct Table, and correct Class or Category
•Read the relevant part of the Guides▫ Introduction to that Chapter▫ Applicable section▫ Applicable Tables/ Figures▫ Examples
7
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Rating Considerations
• Impairment values▫ WPI▫ UE – Hand - Digits▫ LE - Foot
• Interpolation of values within Table/ Figures• Combining Impairment – overlap consideration/
limit of 100%▫ Extremity or WPI level▫ PD (after adjustment)
8
7/14/2021
5
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Rating CorrectionsPhysician provides measurements
▫ Any knowledgeable observer may check findings with the Guides criteria (5th Edition - page 17) Look up table values Correct table impairments Correct math errors
DEU will make corrections when ratingDEU will denote potential misinterpretations of the Guides
9
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Chapter 13
“Cerebral” Impairment (page 308)
Mental Status – instructions
Table 13-8 or GAF for behavioral disorder
Cranial Nerves – including Trigeminal Nerve
Chapter 13 ‘by analogy’ – objective findings?
10
7/14/2021
6
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Chapter 13• Introduction
▫ Evaluating “documented dysfunction of the brain, cranial nerves, spinal cord, nerve roots, and/ or peripheral nerves and muscles” (p 305)
• Principles of Assessment (p 306)• Impairment classes refer to ADL abilities
▫ “When subjective…and open to interpretation…obtain objective data about the severity…and integrate those findings with subjective data…”
• Clinical Studies▫ Detailed neurologic exam▫ Ancillary testing▫ Common clinical studies
11
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Chapter 13Methods of Evaluation• Section 13.2 – Central Nervous System Disorders
▫ CNS = brain and spinal cord▫ Several areas of function may be impaired▫ Only the most severe category of Cerebral
Impairment is used:
Tables 13-2, 13-3, 13-4, 13-6, 13-7, 13-8
12
7/14/2021
7
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
13 – CENTRAL & PERIPHERAL NERVOUS SYSTEM
13
Impairment# FEC Impairment
13.01.00.00 Consciousness Disorder13.02.00.00 Episodic Neurologic Disorder13.03.00.00 Arousal Disorder13.04.00.00 Cognitive Impairment
13.05.00.00 Language Disorder13.06.00.00 Behavioral/Emotional Disorder
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Combine impairments – Table 13-1
14
7/14/2021
8
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Table 13-2 – 13.01.00.00
15
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Table 13-3 – 13.02.00.00
16
•
7/14/2021
9
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Table 13-4 – 13.03.00.00** LC 4660.1 DOI > 1/1/2013 **statutorily precluded – cannot use A/G
17
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Table 13-5 (used with Table 13-6)
18
7/14/2021
10
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Table 13-6 - 13.04.00.00
19
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Cerebral Impairment – Mental Status
•Table 13-6 – Class 1 – 4 - based on CDR(Clinical Dementia Rating)
▫ Table 13-5 – Impairment and CDR ‘score’ Instructions on page 319 6 categories 5 severity scores (none = 0 CDR; severe = 3.0 CDR) Memory is the primary category Secondary categories balance (and validate) scoring
▫ Three or more vs two or more secondary categories
20
7/14/2021
11
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Mental Status – CDR score
• If at least three secondary categories are given the same numeric score as memory, then CDR = M.
• If three or more secondary categories are given a score greater or less than the memory score, CDR = the score of the secondary categories unless
• three secondary categories are scored on one side of M and two secondary categories are scored on the other side of M. In this case, CDR = M. (p 319)
21
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Table 13-7 – 13.05.00.00
22
7/14/2021
12
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Table 13-8 – 13.06.00.00
23
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Cerebral Impairment – Emotional or Behavioral DisordersInstructions page 325:• Relationship between neurology and psychiatry• “Originating in verifiable neurologic impairments
(eg, stroke, head injury)”, use Chapter 13• Psyche manifestations without “documented
neurologic impairments” use Chapter 14 (for California WC, as instructed in the 2005 PDRS –GAF)
24
7/14/2021
13
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Cerebral Impairment• Example - from one injury:
▫ Paroxysmal Disorder (spasm or seizure) Table 13-3 – Class 2 – 25% WPI
▫ Sleep Disorder * Table 13-4 – Class 2 – 10% WPI
▫ Mental Status (CDR scoring) Table 13-6 – Class 2 – 20% WPI
▫ Emotional or Behavioral Table 13-8 - Class 2 – 15% WPI
25
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Cerebral Impairment• Each of these are considered Cerebral Impairment,
and only the most severe is applied (page 308)[compare PD values after adjustment]
Paroxysmal Disorder (seizure)▫ Table 13-3 – Class 2 – 25% WPI▫ Sleep Disorder * [LC 4660.1 precludes “increases in
impairment ratings…arising out of a compensable physical injury” for DOI on or after 1/1/2013]
26
7/14/2021
14
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Cranial Nerves I through XII
Impairment# Impairment
13.07.01.00 Cranial Nerve I – Olfactory13.07.02.00 Cranial Nerve II – Optic13.07.03.00 Cranial Nerve III IV, VI– Oculomotor, Trochlear & Abducens
13.07.04.00 Cranial Nerve V– Trigeminal13.07.05.00 Cranial Nerve VII - Facial13.07.06.01 Cranial Nerve VIII – Vestibulocochlear – Vertigo13.07.06.02 Cranial Nerve VIII – Vestibulocochlear – Tinnitus13.07.07.00 Cranial Nerve IX, X – Glossopharyngeal & Valgus13.07.08.00 Cranial Nerve XI – Spinal Accessory13.07.09.00 Cranial Nerve XII – Hypoglossal
27
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Cranial Nerves – I through XII13.07.01.00
▫ Cranial Nerve I – sense of smell - Max = 3% WPI▫ Chapter 11 – page 262 – 1%-5%
13.07.02.00 – Tables 13-9, 13-1013.07.03.00 - Tables 13-9, 13-10
▫ Cranial Nerve II, III, IV, VI – optic nerve, muscles of the eyes
▫ More detail/more complex cases, addressed in Chapter 12
28
7/14/2021
15
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Table 13-11 (Cranial Nerve V)
P 331
29
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Cranial Nerves13.07.04.00 – Table 13-11
▫ Cranial Nerve V – Trigeminal Nerve ▫ ‘facial neuralgic pain’ Without objective findings, this should not be used for
headaches.▫ Headaches The DWC/ DEU stated position is maximum 3% WPI for
residual headache pain following direct trauma but without objective findings
Use 13.01.00.99
30
7/14/2021
16
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Cranial Nerves13.07.05.00 – Table 13-12
▫ Facial Nerve - VII
13.07.06.01 – Table 13-13 ▫ Nerve VIII - Vertigo
13.07.06.02 – Table 13-13 ▫ Nerve VIII – Tinnitus
Chapter 11 – Hearing Loss
31
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Cranial Nerves
Table 13-14 (tongue, larynx)
13.07.07.00 – Cranial Nerves IX, X▫ Glossopharyngeal & Valgus
13.07.08.00 – Cranial Nerves XI▫ Spinal Accessory
13.07.09.00 – Cranial Nerve XII▫ Hypoglossal
32
7/14/2021
17
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Section 13.5 – Movement Disorders
Table 13-15, on page 336 of the AMA Guides, is used to evaluate Impairment due to Station and Gait Disorders that can develop from a CNS or peripheral neurologic impairment.
33
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
34
Section 13.5 – Movement Disorders
Table 13-15 (p. 336)
7/14/2021
18
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Station and Gait – Overlap?The impairment Classes for Station and Gait Disorders from Table 15-6c, and Table 13-15, to include the range of impairment and the narrative description, are the same.
The instructions and discussions for the use of Tables 17-5, 15-6c, and 13-15 do not offer any differentiation between unilateral or bilateral Station and Gait Disorder.
35
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Gait
From the Comment section for Example 17-2, on page 529 of the AMA Guides:
A gait evaluation is never combined with any other method…
Class 4 from Table 13-15 and 15-6c = 40-60% WPIcannot stand without help…
36
7/14/2021
19
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Section 13.6–Upper Extremities13.09.00.00
• Related to Central Impairment
• Tables 13-16 (one upper extremity) and 13-17 (two upper extremities) are used to evaluate Impairment of Two Upper Extremities from any lesion in the brain (page 338).
• Difficulty with Digital dexterity is the common issue referenced in each Table
37
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Upper Extremities
Tables 13-16, 13-17, page 338
38
7/14/2021
20
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
P 340
39
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Section 13-7 – Spinal Cord
Impairments resulting from spinal cord injuries and other adverse conditions (p 340)
▫ Station and gait▫ Upper extremities▫ Respiration▫ Bladder▫ Anorectal▫ Sexual
40
7/14/2021
21
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Section 13-8 – Chronic PainPage 343 of the AMA Guides, Section 13.8 is used to evaluate impairment related to chronic pain.
Chronic pain in this section covers the diagnoses of causalgia, posttraumatic neuralgia, and reflex sympathetic dystrophy.
41
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Section 13-8 – Chronic Pain
To rate an impairment for causalgia, posttraumatic neuralgia, and RSD in an upper extremity, use Table 13-22. If a lower extremity needs to be rated for causalgia, posttraumatic neuralgia, or RSD, use the station and gait impairment criteria given in Table 13-15, page 343
42
7/14/2021
22
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
P 343
43
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Chronic Pain
44
Impairment# FEC Impairment
13.11 .01.01 Chronic Pain–Upper Extremities–Causalgia13.11.01.02 Chronic Pain–Upper Extremities–Post–traumatic Neuralgia13.11.01.03 Chronic Pain–Upper Extremities–Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy13.11.02.01 Chronic Pain–Lower Extremities–Causalgia13.11.02.02 Chronic Pain–Lower Extremities–Post-traumatic Neuralgia13.11.02.03 Chronic Pain–Lower Extremities–Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy
7/14/2021
23
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Chronic pain – as a defined diagnosis –▫ CRPS; RSD; causalgia Table 16-16
OR
“Chronic pain is pain that lasts more than several months (variously defined as 3 to 6 months, but certainly longer than “normal healing”).”
▫ https://nccih.nih.gov/health/pain/chronic.htm
Chapter 13 - Chronic Pain
45
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Chronic PainCausalgia – following trauma to a peripheral nerve
▫ Burning pain▫ Swelling ▫ Skin changes: smooth, mottled, cold,
sweaty▫ The AMA Guides does not offer a separate
definition for “Post-traumatic Neuralgia” on page 343
46
7/14/2021
24
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Chronic Pain
RSD- without known nerve lesions; minor soft tissue trauma
▫ Burning pain▫ Temperature changes (warmer, then
colder)▫ Abnormal sweating▫ Trophic changes: changes in skin, nail,
hair growth
47
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Chronic Pain
Causalgia – following trauma to a peripheral nerve▫ Burning pain
▫ Swelling
▫ Skin changes: smooth, mottled, cold, sweaty
48
7/14/2021
25
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
RSD- without known nerve lesions; minor soft tissue trauma
▫ Burning pain
▫ Temperature changes (warmer, then colder)
▫ Abnormal sweating
▫ Trophic changes: changes in skin, nail, hair growth
49
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Section 13-8 – Chronic Pain“diagnosis is key and based on clinical criteria”
Diagnostic studies▫ Demineralization Bone scan X-rays
▫ Altered blood flow(page 343)
50
7/14/2021
26
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Chronic PainIn Chapter 16, on page 434:The medical evaluation is the basis for determination of permanent anatomic impairment of the upper extremities. It must be accurate, objective, and well documented….
An impairment evaluation is based on the examiner’s actual findings.
The AMA Guides require that 8 of the Diagnostic Criteria in Table 16-16 (p. 496) be present concurrently to establish the diagnosis of CRPS.
51
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
52
Chronic Pain - Chapter 16
• “to rate [causalgia and RSD]…, diagnosis is key…”
• Diagnosis: rely on clinical findings, three-phase bone scan, x-rays, laser Doppler flowmetry, sudomotor reflex
Table 16-16 (p. 496)
7/14/2021
27
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
CRPS – Chapter 16• From Table 16-16, page 496• Diagnostic Criteria:• Skin color: mottled or cyanotic• Skin temperature: cool• Edema (swelling)• Skin dry or overly moist• Skin texture: smooth, non elastic• Soft tissue atrophy: especially in fingertips
53
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
CRPS – Chapter 16• Joint stiffness and decreased passive motion• Nail changes: blemished, curved, talonlike• Hair growth changes: fall out, longer, finer• Radiographs: trophic bone changes,
osteoporosis• Bone scan: findings consistent with CRPS
According to the AMA Guides:• > 8 Probable CRPS• < 8 No CRPS
54
7/14/2021
28
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
55
CRPS I (RSD)CRPS II (causalgia)“characterized by pain, swelling, stiffness, discoloration…skeletal demineralization”
“may follow a sprain, fracture or nerve or vascular injury”
Chapter 17, p 553
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
56
CRPS I (RSD)CRPS II (causalgia)
Use Chapter 13 (“Central & Peripheral Nervous System”):
Section 13.8 (p. 343-344)
Section 13.5 (p. 336)
7/14/2021
29
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
ICD-10-CM Diagnosis Code G89.21
Chronic pain due to trauma
2015 ICD-9-CM 338.21 Chronic pain due to trauma
Although this might be a working diagnosis, it does not necessarily support WPI based on Chronic Pain.
57
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Section 13-9 – Peripheral Nervous System
Roots of Spinal Nerves; Brachial Plexus; Peripheral Nerves
“Anatomic descriptions should be made according to the usual distributions” of the nerves roots/ nerves/ plexuses (page 345)
58
7/14/2021
30
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Tables 13-23, 13-24
Table 13-23 – classification “due to pain or sensory deficit” (page 347)
Table 13-24 – classification “due to loss of muscle power and motor function” (page 348)
These differ somewhat from Table 16-10 and Table 16-11 from Chapter 16
59
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
60
7/14/2021
31
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Section 13-9
• Page 347 instructions
• If multiple nerves involved, combine sensory and motor nerve impairments▫ “all nerves rated in one extremity are combined”
61
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
2005 PDRS page 2-3
62
Impairment#FEC Impairment
13.12.01.01 Peripheral Nerve System–Spine– Sensory
13.12.01.02 Peripheral Nerve System–Spine–Motor
13.12.02.01 Peripheral Nerve System–UE–Sensory13.12.02.02 Peripheral Nerve System–UE–Motor13.12.03.01 Peripheral Nerve System–LE–Sensory13.12.03.02 Peripheral Nerve System–LE–Motor
7/14/2021
32
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
2005 PDRS13.12.02.01 (UE - Sensory)13.12.02.02 (UE - Motor)
16.01.02.01 (Brachial Plexus)16.01.02.02 (Carpal Tunnel)16.01.02.03 (Entrapment, Other)16.01.02.04 (CRPS I)16.01.02.05 (CRPS II)
63
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
2005 PDRS
13.12.03.01 (LE – Sensory)
13.12.03.02 (LE – Motor)
17.01.04.00 (Leg – Peripheral Nerve)
64
7/14/2021
33
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Chapter 13
“Cerebral” Impairment (page 308)
Mental Status – instructions
Table 13-8 or GAF for behavioral disorder
Cranial Nerves – including Trigeminal Nerve
Chapter 13 ‘by analogy’ – objective findings?
65
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
Chapter 13 - The Central and Peripheral Nervous System
To review WPI from a medical report:
Read the relevant part of the Guides▫ Introduction to that Chapter▫ Applicable section▫ Applicable Tables/ Figures▫ Examples
66
7/14/2021
34
Law Offices of Bradford & Barthel, LLP – www.bradfordbarthel.comNew File Referrals: [email protected]
• Alternative WPI is not automatic• The ‘strict’ use of the Guides is presumed correct. • Can be rebutted by “resorting to comparable
conditions described in the Guides”• The burden rests with the party disputing the
Guides.• There must be adequate evidence and reasoning
rebut the scheduled rating.
Guzman
67
Timothy MussackDirector, AMA Analysis and Indemnity ValuationsBradford & Barthel, [email protected]
[email protected]://bradfordbarthel.com/areas-of-practice/bb-ratings/