8/11/2019 2010 Full Txt Cases Midterms Evidence
1/16
SECOND DIVISION G.R. No. 172357 March 19, 2010
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, !!"##"",
$%.
MRCELO &'STMNTE ( )PNT, NEIL &L'*OT ( T&ISOR, RICHRD DELOSTRINO ( SRCILL, HERMINIO +OSE ( MONSON, EDIN SORINO ( DEL CR') a-
ELMER SLVDOR ( +VLE, !!"##a-/%.
D E C I S I O N
Th" !o#c" a/hor/"% ar" /h" o-"% /a%" /o !roo/" a- a-/a- !"ac" a- or"r - or co-/r(. Th%,
/ 4"co"% o4#( "!#ora4#" h"- /h"( /h"%"#$"% co/ /h" cr-a# ac/. I- /h% ca%", a!!"##a-/%
-%%/ o- /h"r --oc"-c"6 /h"( "-( /ha/ /h"( ##" /h" $c/ Ro"#"o -/o% o- +-" 1, 1997 -%"
/h" "/"-/o- c"## o8 /h" N-o( -o I-/"r-a/o-a# r!or/ :NI;. &/ " ar" -o/ !"r%a". " /oo a
%"co- har #oo a/ /h" "$"-c" !r"%"-/" a- " ho# /ha/ 4o/h /h" /ra# cor/ a- /h" a!!"##a/" cor/
corr"c/#( 8o- /ha/ /h" !ro%"c/o- !ro$" 4"(o- r"a%o-a4#" o4/ /ha/ /h" a!!"##a-/% ar" >5 hch a88r" - /o/o /h" March 17, 2000 D"c%o-2 o8 /h" R" R"%o#/o-3 o8 /h" C "-(-< /h" %"!ara/" o/o-% 8or
r"co-%"ra/o- 8#" 4( /h" a!!"##a-/%.
Fac/a# -/"c""-/%
O- Ma( 22, 199?, /o I-8ora/o-% "r" 8#" a
8/11/2019 2010 Full Txt Cases Midterms Evidence
2/16
a%%
8/11/2019 2010 Full Txt Cases Midterms Evidence
3/16
Ro"#"o a% %ho$" -/o a c"## a#r"a( occ!" 4( !ro%"c/o- /-"%% No"# Ga4or-"% :Ga4or-"%;, ho
ha "ar#"r 4""- arr"%/" 8or 4"-< a- -a/hor" !or/"r. Pro8"%%-< h% --oc"-c", Ro"#"o cr%" a-
%ho/" a/ &a#(o/, D"#o% Tr-o, +o%", Sora-o, &%/aa-/", L-
8/11/2019 2010 Full Txt Cases Midterms Evidence
4/16
I- $" o8 a## /h" 8or"
8/11/2019 2010 Full Txt Cases Midterms Evidence
5/16
## /h" a!!"##a-/%, "c"!/ &%/aa-/", 8#" -o/c"% o8 a!!"a#. &%/aa-/" 8#" a- 'r
8/11/2019 2010 Full Txt Cases Midterms Evidence
6/16
ha a" a r"/rac/o-, /h% crc%/a-c" a#o-" o"% -o/ r"r" /h" cor/ /o %r"
8/11/2019 2010 Full Txt Cases Midterms Evidence
7/16
o-" a-o/h"r - r"r-< /h" $c/ /h a4%" o8 %!"ror %/r"-
8/11/2019 2010 Full Txt Cases Midterms Evidence
8/16
## /o#, a!!"##a-/% %"ra4#( 8a#" /o %ho co-$-c-< r"a%o-% /o o$"r/r- /h" D"c%o- o8 4o/h /h" /ra#
cor/ a- /h" C. I- /h% ca%", /h" C a%c"r/a-" /h" 8ac/a# 8--
8/11/2019 2010 Full Txt Cases Midterms Evidence
9/16
J Do (o ha$" a-( "$"-c" /o %ho /ha/ h" "ar- F$" Tho%a- !"%o% %c :P15,000.00; a o-/h a%
!ro@"c/ "-
Th" 8or#a27 8or -"ar-" -co" % a% 8o##o%A
L8" E!"c/a-c( Gro%% --a# I-co" :GI; #"%% L$-< E!"-%"% :50 GI;
h"r" L8" E!"c/a-c( 23 :?0 J a o8 /h" C$# Co" !ro$"%A
r/. 220>. Tha/ ao-/ o8 aa
8/11/2019 2010 Full Txt Cases Midterms Evidence
10/16
HEREFORE, /h" +#( 19, 2005 D"c%o- o8 /h" Cor/ o8 !!"a#% - C=G.R. CR=H.C. No. 00>>5 %
MODIFIED. !!"##a-/% N"# &a#(o/, Rchar D"#o% Tr-o, H"r-o +o%", E- Sora-o, Marc"#o
&%/aa-/", a- E#"r Sa#$aor, ar" h"r"4( 8o- >5 % #"%" SET SIDE -%o8ar a% M/a#4 4#a@ %
co-c"r-".
SO ORDERED.
R"!4#c o8 /h" Ph#!!-"%
SUPREME COURT
Ma-#a
THIRD DIVISION
G.R. No. 184600 March 9, 2010
PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES,!!"##"",
$%.
ANACITO IMANA!A,!!"##a-/.
R E S O L ' T I O N
NACHURA, J.:
I-c"%/o% ra!", "%!"ca##( o-" co//" 4( a 8a/h"r a
8/11/2019 2010 Full Txt Cases Midterms Evidence
11/16
a$a-/a
8/11/2019 2010 Full Txt Cases Midterms Evidence
12/16
Dr. E%/r"##a Pa(o(o, /h" M-c!a# H"a#/h O88c"r o8 a-, Sor%o>=; o8 /h" R"$%" P"-a# Co", a% a"-", -
r"#a/o- /o r/c#" III, S"c/o- 5 o8 R 7>10, h" % h"r"4( %"-/"-c" /o %88"r /h" -$%4#" !"-a#/( o8
RECL'SION PERPET'. To -"-8( /h" o88"-" !ar/( - /h" ao-/ o8 Ph!50,000.00 a% c$#
-"-/( a- a-o/h"r Ph!50,000.00 a% ora# aa
8/11/2019 2010 Full Txt Cases Midterms Evidence
13/16
THE TRIL CO'RT GRVEL* ERRED IN CONVICTING THE CC'SED=PPELLNT OF
RPE DESPITE THE PROSEC'TIONS FIL'RE TO PROVE HIS G'ILT &E*OND
RESON&LE DO'&T.
III
THE FINDINGS S CONTINED IN THE MEDICO=LEGL REPORT DOES :%c; NOT SHONDOR IS :%c; NOT CONSISTENT ITH THE OFFENSE OF RPE, CONTRR* TO THE
FINDINGS OF THE TRIL CO'RT.10
Th" O88c" o8 /h" So#c/or G"-"ra# :OSG;, o- 4"ha#8 o8 /h" P"o!#", a#%o 8#" /% 4r"8,11/h a
r"co"-a/o- 8or /h" o8ca/o- o8 /h" c$# -"-/( aar" /o . I/ ar
8/11/2019 2010 Full Txt Cases Midterms Evidence
14/16
Co-/rar( /o a!!"##a-/% c#a, /h" !ro%"c/o- %88c"-/#( "%/a4#%h" /ha/ a!!"##a-/ "!#o(" 8orc" a-
-/a/o- - %a/%8(-< h% 4"%/a# "%r". ca/"
8/11/2019 2010 Full Txt Cases Midterms Evidence
15/16
Th" ar
8/11/2019 2010 Full Txt Cases Midterms Evidence
16/16
/h" Ph#!!-"%, hch /oo "88"c/ o- +-" 30, 200>. S"c/o- 2 o8 R.. 93B> !o%"% /h" !"-a#/( o8 r"c#%o-
!"r!"/a - #" o8 "a/h, h"- /h" #a $o#a/" a"% %" o8 /h" -o"-c#a/r" o8 /h" !"-a#/"% o8 /h" RPC, a%
- /h% ca%". Th" !"-a#/( o8 r"c#%o- !"r!"/a !o%" 4( /h" /ra# cor/ a- a88r" 4( /h" C %, /h"r"8or",
corr"c/. Fr/h"ror", !r%a-/ /o R.. No. 93B>, a!!"##a-/ %ha## -o/ 4" "#
Recommended