11/12/2003
2
2
Shiftwork and Fatigue
Once, a pilot crashed after 16 hours on duty because he read an altimeter incorrectly.
He had been flying safely for 15 hours, and suddenly he couldn't read an altimeter?
This is hard to believe. That's fatigue.
Fatigue is a loss of alertness which eventually ends in sleep
11/12/2003
3
3
Fatigue is a serious issue• Fatigued operators can cause accidents, (eg Three Mile
Island, Bhopal, Space Shuttle Challenger, Exxon Valdez and Chernobyl)
• USA – cost of sleep-related accidents estimated to be between $43 - $56 billion
• UK – annual cost of work accidents caused by sleepiness estimated to be £115 – 240 million
• 25% of fatal truck crashes are due to fatigue • 7% of motor vehicle accidents may be attributed to
fatigue, a figure that rises to 15% for motorway accidents
• pilot fatigue is implicated in upwards of 20% of near-accidents in aviation
11/12/2003
5
5
I’m safe at work so it doesn’t matter if I’m sleepy?
False…being sleepy can cause:• slower reaction time• impaired judgements and decision making• decline in attention• decreased alertness• increased moodiness and aggressive behaviour• difficulty in remembering things
11/12/2003
6
6
I can tell when I’m going to fall asleepFalse….• People do not know how sleepy they
are• The more tired you become, the less
able you are to make a good judgement about your ability to remain awake
• Being awake for 18 hours is as great a risk as driving drunk
11/12/2003
7
7
Signs of tiredness
The signs include:• not feeling refreshed after sleep• difficulty keeping your eyes open and focussed• greater tendency to fall asleep while at work• more frequent naps during leisure hours• lots of yawning• extended sleep during days off• increased errors and loss of concentration at work• feeling irritable, restless and impatient
11/12/2003
8
8
Lack of sleep is the only cause of fatigue...
False… but it is the only cure
Causes of fatigue include:
• Workload
• Social factors
• Individual factors – e.g., age, diet, fitness etc
• Shift work
11/12/2003
9
9
The older you get, the fewer hours of sleep you needFalse• Sleep needs remain unchanged throughout
adulthood• Older people wake more frequently through
the night• Shift work becomes harder with age (40–50
yrs)• Ability to cope with ‘early starts’ may improve
11/12/2003
10
10
Most people need 8 hours of sleep to function at their bestTrue• 7 – 8 hours is recognised as an average and normal
need• Less than this and you build up a sleep debt• Sleep comprises several stages which must follow a
certain pattern if you are to feel fully rested and alert– Stage 1 and 2: transitional phase between waking and
sleeping – Stage 3 and 4: deep sleep– Rapid Eye Movement (REM) sleep
11/12/2003
11
11
If I sleep a lot now, I won’t need to sleep much later
False
• Sleep is not like money – you can’t save it up and you can’t borrow it
• While napping is an effective means of managing alertness it is not a substitute for regular sleep
11/12/2003
12
12
Everyone has a “biological clock”True• We have evolved own internal body clock /
circadian rhythm• It controls a number of internal rhythms, eg,
sleep/wake cycle, body temperature• It is this body clock that makes us feel
sleepier and less alert when we try and work at times normally reserved for sleep
11/12/2003
13
13
The human body can adjust to nightshift workFalse• Our body clock programmes us to feel most sleepy
when it is dark• Eating meals at times normally reserved for sleep
means they are less well digested• On night shifts you tend to get less sleep and it is of
a poorer quality (e.g., after one week of night shifts, workers had lost the equivalent of one night’s sleep)
• Successive night shifts, eg, 4, result in an increase in accident risk
11/12/2003
14
14
Features of shiftwork that lead to fatigue
• Timing of shifts (earlies, lates and nights)
• Duration of shifts
• Rotation of shifts
• Rest and recovery periods
11/12/2003
15
15
Early Starts• Associated with a reduction in duration of
sleep• Sleep periods prior to early start are on
average 3 hours shorter• Difficult to compensate with earlier bedtime:
– Social pressures– ‘Forbidden zone’ – Fear of not waking up early
• Successive early starts – cumulative sleep deficit
11/12/2003
16
16
Snoring is not harmful as long as it does not disturb sleep
False
• Chronic snoring may indicate sleep apnoea, a sleep disorder
• Other common sleep disorders are:– Insomnia– Restless leg syndrome
11/12/2003
17
17
Drinking coffee cures drowsinessFalse…• Caffeine has a short term effect• Caffeine should be used carefully as it will
disrupt sleep• Other measures such as opening windows
and putting on the radio are not effective• The only cure for drowsiness is to get some
sleep
11/12/2003
18
18
Conclusions
• Being tired impact on our performance and increases the risks of an accident
• The amount and quality of sleep are important factors in ensuring you wake up feeling fully rested
• Shift work makes us more prone to fatigue because it makes us work against out natural circadian rhythms
11/12/2003
20
20
Sleep Strategies• Managing your work time • Use naps to improve alertness• Create a good sleep environment• Establish a regular pre-sleep routine• Establish a regular bedtime and wake-up schedule• Manage your caffeine intake• Other advice:
– Avoid alcohol– Take regular exercise– Manage your diet
11/12/2003
21
21
Managing Your Work Time
• There are different tips for managing fatigue depending on your shift pattern and the type of shift you have just finished.
• Example: managing night shifts– Go to bed as soon as you get home– Have an afternoon nap– Avoid exposure to daylight– Eat 3 regular meal with “lunch” during your night
shift
11/12/2003
22
22
Creating a good sleep environment
• Quiet
• Dark
• Warm/cool
• Comfortable bed that you associate with sleep
• Fresh air
• Free from interruptions
11/12/2003
23
23
Pre-sleep routine
• You can learn that it is time to relax and go to sleep
• Establish a pre-sleep routine to provide specific cues:– Reading– Listening to music– Getting dressed for bed
• Only get into bed when your tired
11/12/2003
24
24
Napping – Not to be used whilst at work• Limit naps to about 30 – 45 minutes including
the time it takes to fall asleep• Naps of 15 – 20 mins are most restorative• Give yourself time to get over sleep inertia• There is no minimum time period for effective
napping• Improved alertness may last for several hours