102

Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 2: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 3: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 4: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic

Zeroth law of thermodynamics

Page 5: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 6: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic

The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic curve.

Page 7: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic

Energy conservation law holds for irreversible processes as well. So we can measure in principle the energy of any macrostate.

We first go from the reference state by adiabatic process to the state which has the samevalues of the external parameters as the desired final state, but is still a differentstate differing for example by the value of the conjugated parameters (practicallyit means by temperature). Now we keep the external parameters constant and perform heat to get to the desired final state. We perform (”produce”) heat by an irreversible process (Joule) performing mechanical work on some other (macroscopicbut very small with respect to our system of interest) auxiliary system which is incontact with our system and exchanges heat with it, with the auxiliary system performing an irreversible process where external work is performed upon it. Theauxiliary system is small, so even if its temperature is gradually increasing its energy increases by negligible amount.

Historically the procedure was still different from the procedure using the Jouleirreversible (work to heat transfer) process as described above.The notion of heat was older then the fact that it can be measured using the unitsfor work. The notion of heat developed in calorimetric measurements.

Page 8: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic

Problem: heat capacity may depend on temperature, so the more realistic calorimetric equation is

Idea: parametrize heat capacity by a function with a few free parameters, then perform a fit.

measure work

measure heat

How to measure heat. Fixed volume, no work. Contact with hot water until desired temperature reached. Measure heat exchanged by measuring the hot water the hot water final temperature.

Page 9: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic

Historical problem: work and heat measured by different units.

First law of thermodynamics:there exists a universal unit converting constants that the sum lof work and converted calories to get from an initial state to a final state does not depend on trajectory

Therefore there exists a state function E, which can be determined as

thus the energy conservation law was discovered: any energy change is balanced by the work (mechanical work + heat). To perform work there must be an agent. The work performed by an agent on the system is the same but with an opposite sign as the work performed by the system on the agent. Therefore the energy change of the agent is just opposite to the energy change of the system and the overall energy of system + agent is conserved.

Page 10: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic

Second law of thermodynamics:

does not depend on the trajectory. So entropy is a state function.

Cyclic reversible engine:

Page 11: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 12: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 13: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic

What was essential to derive the concavity property was that the parameters were extensive.Other thermodynamic potentials do not have extensive natural parameters. However, they are derived by Legendre transformation. And the Legendre transformation preserves (or changes the sighn) of concavity. So we get concavity property for other thermodynamic potentials as well.

Page 14: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 15: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 16: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 17: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 18: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 19: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 20: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 21: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 22: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 23: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 24: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 25: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 26: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 27: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 28: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 29: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 30: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 31: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 32: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 33: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic

So the specific heat at constant temperature does not depend on volume, it can beevaluated for large volume where the gas is sufficiently dilute and behaves likeideal gas, so we get

Page 34: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 35: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 36: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 37: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic

na izoterme

Page 38: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 39: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 40: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 41: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 42: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 43: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 44: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic

grupová rýchlosť

Ak rátam balistický prúd v nanofyzike, hustotu stavov treba vynásobiť grupovou rýchlosťou a ostane univerzálny vzorec nezávislý na tom, o akú tuhú látku ide.

Page 45: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 46: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 47: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 48: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 49: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 50: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 51: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 52: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 53: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 54: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 55: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 56: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 57: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 58: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 59: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 60: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 61: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 62: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 63: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 64: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 65: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 66: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic

spinsDomain boundary is like a random walk from top to bottom.At each step 3 possibilitiesEach line typically steps dividing linesEnergy difference

Entropy ln3ln3Neither energy nor entropy is a clear winnerPhase transition possible

Page 67: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 68: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 69: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 70: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 71: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 72: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 73: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 74: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 75: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 76: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic

Fázový prechod druhého druhu: nespojité (divergujúce)druhé derivácie termodynamického potenciálu

Page 77: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 78: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 79: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 80: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic

Small means large High temperature expansion.

Page 81: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 82: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 83: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic

Low temperature expansion

Page 84: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic

Dual latices

Page 85: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 86: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 87: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 88: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 89: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 90: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 91: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 92: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 93: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic
Page 94: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic

Fluctuation – Response Theorem

This is how one calculate numerically, since calculating it via is numerically intractable

Note: cumulant

Page 95: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic

Fluctuation – Response Theorem for arbitrary quantity

Note: if is extensive, then is extensive, so

Page 96: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic

is a generating function of moments of is a generating function of cumulants of .

Page 97: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic

Probability of fluctuations

Page 98: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic

Be careful:

but

Page 99: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic

Sometimes we can reasonably guess the dependence of

on M. Like in the Landau model of phase transitions. Then we can have a phenomenological effective theory like

Then need not be calculated from the original microscopic Hamiltonian, but as a normalization of an effective theory

Page 100: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic

It looks like a canonical physics of a simple system with one degree of freedom, , with a Hamiltonian

The (nonequilibrium) free energy of the microscopic theory effectively becomes a Hamiltonian of the effective theory. This is why people in textbooks suddenly switch the language and start to speak about “Hamiltonian”.This happens even more in effective field theories, when one introduces a nonequilibrium field

The nonequilibrium free energy of the microscopic theory is then a functional

Page 101: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic

External field

is then a functional of and is a generating functional of moments of .

All moments and correlations can be calculated as certain variational derivatives of the generating functional.

Phenomenological hamiltonian

Page 102: Zeroth law of thermodynamics The problem is that an arbitrary final state cannot be reached from the reference state via the quasi-static adiabatic