Upload
msphix
View
219
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Yale Investigation Finds ‘No Evidence’ of Racism at Frat Party Alleged to Have Been for ‘White Girls Only’ - The Washington Post
Citation preview
Morning Mix
Yale investigation finds ‘no evidence’ of racism at fratparty alleged to have been for ‘white girls only’By Michael E. Miller December 11
It was the Facebook post heard across the Ivy League, if not the entire country.
On Halloween, Yale undergrad Neema Githere wrote that black friends of hers had been turned away from a
fraternity party because it was for “white girls only.”
That accusation, combined with an administrator’s controversial email defending “offensive” costumes, ignited a
firestorm of debate over racism on campus.
Students confronted the administrator and her husband who also holds an administrative post at the undergrad
college, and then they confronted Yale College’s first African American dean. They packed protests at the
prestigious university by the hundreds, using bullhorns to demand more diversity on campus and that the school
rename buildings after people of color, rather than proponents of slavery.
Faculty members rallied to support the protesters. Students at universities across the United States marched in
solidarity, as a wave of antiracism demonstrations swept campuses from coast to coast.
There were troubling moments, too. A discussion on the importance of free speech on campus was, ironically,
interrupted by protesters. Campus newspapers reported claims that people leaving the event were spat upon.
Now, more than a month later, Yale has finally released the findings of an investigation into the incident that set
off the soulsearching series of events: the socalled “white girls only party.”
The verdict?
That the party might not have been racist after all.
In a statement sent out Wednesday, Jonathan Holloway, dean of Yale College, wrote that the
university’s investigation had found “no evidence of systematic discrimination against people of color” at the
Halloween frat party.
The investigation itself has not yet been released. Holloway’s statement, however, leaves the incident, that
incited Yale’s recent student movement for greater diversity and sensitivity, shrouded in mystery.
The inquiry’s only concrete conclusion appears to be that the Oct. 30 event at Sigma Alpha Epsilon (SAE) was not
a “white girls only” party — at least, not at first.
The investigation was carried out by Burgwell Howard, dean of student engagement, and a representative from
the university’s Office for Equal Opportunity Programs. The two officials spoke with SAE members, students and
guests at the event.
“A partial picture of what happened has emerged from these accounts,” Holloway wrote. “On the one hand, the
investigation found no evidence of systematic discrimination against people of color. Students inside the party
reported that early in the evening, before the party became crowded, guests were granted admission on a first
come basis; men and women of color were among those admitted.
[Students accuse Yale SAE fraternity brother of saying ‘white girls only’ at party door]
“On the other hand, students also reported that as the event became intensely crowded, hosts restricted
admission, applying subjective criteria and using harsh language.
“When the investigation focused on what hosts had said specifically, two students provided credible accounts that
they were told, or heard either one or two SAE members say, ‘white girls only’ as they were seeking admission to
the party, although the SAE members interviewed denied making these statements and nobody else who was
Neema Githere
I'd just like to take a moment to give a shoutout to the member of Yale'sSAE chapter who turned away a group of girls from their party last night,explaining that admittance was on a "White Girls Only" basis; and abelated shoutout to the SAE member who turned me and my friends awayfor the same reason last year. God Bless the USA
**If you think that I am lying, I urge you to read the comments below andsee the ridiculousness that other students have experienced on thiscampus. If anyone reading this has experienced or witnessed a similarsituation, PLEASE reach out/share your story below/ANYTHING.
1,690 Likes · 39 Comments · 297 Shares
Like Comment Share
ProfileYale University · 1,007 followers · October 31 · New Haven, CT,United States ·
interviewed heard the statements.”
In interviews with The Washington Post’s Susan Svrluga, however, two students said that they had overheard
SAE frat brothers denying minorities entry because they were looking for “white girls only.”
“I was shocked,” said Sofia PetrosGouin, a Columbia freshman visiting friends at Yale. “I was disgusted.”
The investigation found even less evidence that student protesters spat on visitors at a Nov. 6 free speech
discussion in honor of conservative writer and National Review founder William F. Buckley, Jr.
“During this investigation, no one provided direct accounts that anyone spat on attendees,” Holloway wrote. “At
no time did police present at the scene or staff observe anyone spitting, nor did anyone report spitting to the
[Yale Police Department] or staff. No police reports have been filed with the Yale Police as a result of the
conference or regarding any allegations as the event broke up. Students appeared to have adhered to the
university’s guidelines for protest and free expression.”
Yet, according to the Yale Daily News, at least one student has insisted that he was spat upon and has
expressed frustration at not being contacted by the university during its investigation. Mitchell Rose Bear Don’t
Walk, one of the lead protesters, also told the newspaper that a protester had spat on someone, calling
it “disgraceful.”
Ultimately, however, Holloway said that “the findings do not provide grounds for the Yale College Dean’s Office
to pursue formal disciplinary action against any student or group of students.”
Despite the results of the investigation, there is little debate that racism remains an issue at Yale and other
universities across the country. Last year, someone drew swastikas on campus. Meanwhile, the university
recently announced a $50 million initiative to boost diversity among its faculty.
The incidents have also had serious fallout for some faculty members.
Erika Christakis, the Yale professor and administrator who was lambasted after encouraging students under her
care to defy the university by wearing “obnoxious… a little bit inappropriate or provocative or, yes, offensive”
Halloween costumes, announced earlier this week that she was resigning from teaching.
“I have great respect and affection for my students, but I worry that the current climate at Yale is not, in my view,
conducive to the civil dialogue and open inquiry required to solve our urgent societal problems,” she told The
Washington Post.
Her husband, Nicholas Christakis, a sociologist who runs his own lab at the university but is perhaps best known
for being yelled at by undergrads in several viral videos, said last week that he will take a sabbatical in the spring
so that he can focus on his research and on the needs of students. The couple has said, however, that they will
remain “masters,” in charge of students’ wellbeing within Yale’s Silliman residential college.
In his statement, Holloway said he hoped to “use these occasions as an opportunity” to foster peaceful debate
and “create a more constructive, inclusive, and respectful climate” at the storied institution.
In other words, the “white girls only” party might never have been. But the reaction has been very real indeed.
Michael E. Miller is a foreign affairs reporter for The Washington Post. He writes for the
Morning Mix news blog. Tweet him: @MikeMillerDC
Your Three. Video curated for you.
Show Me More
What can babies teachstudents?
Play Videos
In search of theDelmarva foxsquirrel
0:00
A flood ofrefugees fromSyria but only atrickle to America
4:19
Play Videos