Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 1
Kansas CityJanuary 17, 2006
The Public Forum Institute Meeting ReportThe Public Forum Institute Meeting Report
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 2
What Worked• Approximately 200 participants• Ran on schedule – started on time & finished 5 minutes early• Very low attrition in closing hour• Collected input on all questions
– Qualitative: eFORUM call out sessions, open plenary discussion, worksheets and audio recording
– Quantitative: keypad data collection
• Media: 1 radio, 1 reporter, 1 editorial board meeting• Varied questioning formats kept participants engaged (table talk &
call out, simple polling question result discussion, and closed-end multiple choice)
• Smooth production and logistics: registration, technology, meeting materials, table facilitator briefing, etc.
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 3
Challenges Ahead• Participant diversity
– Age
– Minority populations
– Lower education levels
– Uninsured
• Balance those who can only participant in a shorter meeting and those who want more in-depth discussion
• Advance media & making our mark• Helping interested citizens stay involved afterwards – moving
forward on a more dynamic online interface• Final approval of discussion guide
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 4
Demographics
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 5
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 6
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 7
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 8
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 9
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 10
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 11
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 12
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 13
American Values
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 14
American Values• Recommendation:
– Current phrasing: “What does “health care that works for all Americans” mean to you? And as we consider ways to improve our health care system, what values and/or principles do you believe are fundamental?”
– Recommended phrasing: “We want to talk about changing our health care system so it will serve all of us better than it now does. As we think about this together, what should we really hope for? What should we really worry about?”
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 15
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 16
American Values• Recommendation:
– Change order to discussion of question before polling: “Should it be public policy that all Americans have affordable health care coverage? [By public policy we mean that the stated public goal is set out in federal or state law.]”
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 17
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 18
Deliberation 1: Benefits
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 19
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 20
Deliberation 1: Benefits• Recommendation:
– Reduce number of options for ‘basic benefits package’ question.
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 21
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 22
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 23
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 24
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 25
Deliberation 2: Getting Health Care
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 26
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 27
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 28
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 29
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 30
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 31
Deliberation 3: Financing
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 32
Deliberation 3: Financing• Recommendation:
– Current phrasing: Should everyone who can afford to do so be required to obtain basic health insurance?
– Recommended phrasing: Should everyone be required to participate in the system?
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 33
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 34
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 35
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 36
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 37
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 38
What should the responsibilities of individuals
and families be in paying for health care?
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 39
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 40
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 41
Deliberation 4: Trade-offs
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 42
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 43
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 44
Some believe that fixing the health care system will require tradeoffs from everyone – e.g. hospitals, employers, insurers, consumers, government agencies. What could be done -- and by whom?
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 45
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 46
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 47
Evaluations
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 48
Evaluation Responses
www.citizenshealthcare.gov 49
