World Bank Document · SBP Sustainable Banking with the Poor vi,lJ LIi 5 -l JW i I 1.1I SDI subsidy dependence index #1 ,,L > - SECAL sectoral adjustment loan SLA savings and loan

z4 ~LIJI ~L4

17094;D11 3LLAI? LI 1999

llJi JLizJi 9 ±3 Uv l9, LJ lI

Rural finance:Issues, designs, & best

practices

-Jb .J I

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

I

- I ;, j .L>L.1 9 L^ 12I a w lJ sL1.£ -I- f j,LL

IL M-ij L.-I ti ,,tq l t

:L -

Letfd afSfl

1999 ©) >I j;

1818 H Street, N.W.Washington, D.C. 20433, U.S.A.

4Sok I Sl IuA

L1 11WI L,11 ll .IMg u < L ;jL..

;Sl lAll ~~~~~~~UZ;ll apS;I;, {i.4IL L'i t L Ju 1y

Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data

Yaron, Jacob.Rural Finance: issues, design, and best practices I Jacob Yaron,

McDonald P. Benjamin, Jr., Gerda I., PiprekP. cm.-(Environmentally and socially sustainable development studies

and monographs series; no. 14)Includes bibliographical references.ISBN 0-8213-3737-81. Rural credit. 2. Agricultural credit. I. Benjamin, McDonald

P., Jr. il. Piprek Gerda L., 1962- . Ill. Title. IV. Series.HG2041.Y37 1996332.71 -dc2O 96-34492

CIP

LSNI0-81 3475 1 -

ISBN 0-8213-4476-5

J~ oI,YI

L5.:!=I C-L Lr- Y1S

NV~jl ULLI 41 i

NA ; ,1Lj i = 143L1

NA 1

916il JA

Y~A LdN;.J

L' ;Ju ZL,@1 7,L. ,pW I I

,1 91:c; :>n L;LI ;Lil

£V 2.:II a.tlA J -- J J1 .3IV lUI zjI Z i. I -

LA I %jI & i1l 4 = l .-U.. 411j

jal I IU;Gi I i L±. -U:' b b!u-' Id,ui

,11ilo5sl lilIL 11

o £I:l LWI ^.U i7. Il' l

-Y

AY LG 1

A o ;,L ji UUI = 611 tL X. J-111 .W

W ,,LYls WILL

AV\

AA LLLWI

AV _LWI U IaU ;L4l I W I Ju

A 1 atU oA1 cJ

INV~~ tiL-el JmI

IN - L-;-a ?.I-'

NV1 L.Uj ;1 - >1

NY8A Z.L;41l t

Zri JoYI.;,L L u- II Il V-Y

Yr ._lI J.L. L's ; v 1aiL G9,. .;i I V-Y

YA I I A £J, £-Y

rA ?.I J=L. J11 iU I c,66.11 .LaJ - 4 4 oI-Y

rE I -- I a i yA& I L=l *.I JWI I-r

rA ,dLiJ I JK -1 .L U I JA A-r

rAII 3 ;.I.1l £-f£ li Zkl,?" li lJt X- :eI 1Y 1;il 1> S; -

or 4 1 31Z. ,$i a- , e I vU "-,,I;t T-r

L,~~~~£¢-i -I.Ll11 L& J11Ze. Ql.- Jl, A-o

£oZ III iJzi Lcs 1,..41 .1a N-r

o. ;4i,1,L;ii 1-o

oV 4L;elLJi L ;,Ii t;l :;i ll;l r -l

oA ~ osll wt. . LI -jL zS j~ Lii;LI zj LII Z;-a: I £-o

oA jbLs 'I L;L11_- ;L, Lj6J I ...... I......... IlJi-' :.1-. IYl o-o

V~~o Lr L,..I_a I ZI=l V-1

VI% LL L' ;~L I-!VYL L;-i L -AU I L s - x I-

VA ¢L D4u1 &+ :4 -I)LIoL~ i-'

VA 3 I Iz1^^ i L-V

VS c -V

~.. WI ~V-A

U AY ,. ,,4 J"1jL5 ;I>Il l .4WI J 1u>J.%l Jtt -1 r-V

A.r LiS,ii .t S I 7, yi UL £ -A

N £W 61I JL I ,.Lb I Y-A

N UL~ht - W JL LC=I1i - idSi . il;l r-A

~.V ~)BJQ 9J~~a~ -A

tV 5 J C- 5.L,1 o-A

I J I L=1 LL. 49 -ZIIL.tI A

NA .tjJ LhJLY LiI jL V > I J I ; ,i J-A

VUI o= S l A-A

- \ Lt I Y-A

A .i - Lj ) UI;i.;L_4I L,W1i Ic.W dN .- A

N .Y ~ aJ;;GLJI LSS qz .... IO Fi2-'-I U0 VL2 O- £-AN. U.i.96' .P Cj -'S I>1 jtc ;J 6 I I1 NS °-A

\ . Q es ,1 vojSIjsL21oL -A

NN o * l 1Ê -A

~~~,I I dk- 2, | *-l| I C ;i L I L) L- 6 l5MJ -

IS Z.IIQ L DT ;*1 U I l -_GI I I - i 6%..1 N

N ,d oJJY a) .y I 1 I Y-A

8 \ .>W ,Wjl LR y 1 fr-v

-g lJ£'u~ Z= 1-%~ ,: 9=119 65S LJI SJLjV-{, l S E-r

\5~~~~~~~~~~~~~AA ^CS A\PDLIR;I5LIJ1^; A S43li -

N sM -NNAV o>

- ..... \t£\A {o1 Lt Y1,41 v 1 1;1-(3II b1 & V-1Is~ ~U

- l -1.1 .dy {(L) 1lS1 0L4>t-1I> 61g & L%M t &a . Ji £-AYTA fV~-~~AV .J~ i £A.iV) ~i () @ ' .

' "A;ULAI ~,Jl ~i~ I~~L

62 L I 1 -L )Ij It J Li dil I Z 611 iAOLkNil i-1 1; u11 AVG Jim JsW I 2 ,L a 5

Ir ,;>Ovk-* sr ZG .- J I J-. -q a

EYA~~L L.U-tV IJI .( 1 v L)t;1j o L9

'k i-Y NS ao;it L-fS I,; o.t;iil Jliu'j-

EIJ5ll :1L l;IIJ 4sld~~- .1 Z43 as>i11JUI "-4 JI H -

;1 TV 4WN fi -E AJ 1 0;1.11OJ

a3,, I O "O1.9u. 1 1 I Z_ IJ -¢1 .1 L I I- KU -I

N i - N' AV, ,LL; XIS I .lUlxl Ie1Ao5 1vJ -

XY 8A-\TO11 .IWCAfM; de -IJs 4sXlO11Sl v

~ IJI Qi=9 %J1IT44;1i;il-1'Jl4 SI;.jllL

LI U }l .5j51 _,J I cv 1 U.: IjLM JLi. ;I U, -I , LA *f1 z-L ijL.S-- =IU IaA'Y 2JS1; ': ^ 1

- i I Lr,a 1jk;tI jU.V,4L; -~l L4U U.J>1 kL11 P L9;I V r OLJJI **^

Ls 4:1Ilj I 'sj I L<.p F1J1=1 jL61 LL l=II ls i ;~Ju27S al-1i ,eS

1 -AJV -c LVA- A -L i lj LA3VIOIL .1F11 (el -Il)

J-A-YI 1 * ; * I QjlOL§-IJ-i c- 1 .S. PJ+I 9- *I,5a .S

L A LU Z:sil J5l u1 X11 L+L- a4;@ f+ei -6A11 A-. 1 J* >1,Ll R JIXlY

aSS l;! It Ik7y -,: L- a..; 1-.6 La^ I a'^^ S w a,I , 1 3 ^~- It w2lJ I 1 I

C: L;J I. X<WI Lla ll Cs JI-,I.'I = I -Yl aA... 1

,s6 t I_tI j 1.0 1 , la . .U- l -,. Z,:L9 J 1

L5:l;aLllj owL1LLI*X LaI,SS;ll, j,>,,, Z:. LJ J; S LI ,I=25at,.-1(; f

z1 IL j,S"I lAJ L £JV ' ^' tjj,T U ¢:Lo.=D jsJJ , L,; ae

(4s ZSLa; Ij <- > ,IJI7S. 1, , ) L,->. e

aM z Ji ULSJY vJ12 v,C S ¢L1 ITJ r ,1ais,S J

L;2c:l< -J :-s ;i Ls ji;:Ij IL wliL - l LJ

eS3-11 NQYIaA CV- N JW5; . JL ' La

v~~~A -Z51 &I Yj Z.12y *-JI cL%LJ 11~ - ZJI ,siI 41j.l UI o.l s*:i-

;0&X L-Z o ;Xftl w 1 ;-ll 1S J-C ; *1 451 yfo*t V-ij

*aW ^5,u15 ,1 oJLI.L c ,I a Lcjl vL-Yl ;4tlJ L^'t l 5 3ztL * -1

.tlaAI Z II WS SI v4>il Q s^ d.11 ilUI ol 3 -9 fAIl tLe 1,si Y I I

oL~~~~~J 1 ol > .^s.LI i3 Y I *cjl.S L M s ,iI ,tl<-11~~~~~~~~~~~Z2 LIcU Z, I JiZTt:-.*-Li,j4I;v ssl1* 2flosl

XJIll y~~~~~a.Al j 1;c Le1 I.IJ iS 3II 5lIIY

a ;violJ4; ^. *^-ll alI oliolJ 1 esLb illSel - UI ;JYI ;l d 11* .......................... l

ACB Agricultural Credit Bank of Jamica tI:3lI L L. ,

BAAC Bank for Agriculture and Agricultural Cooperatives (lbailand) ( ;:1;) _IL oU,t ll, sII .ll*

BIS Bank for International Settlements i L I

BKK Badan Kredit Kecanatan .L U ULL•S

BRI Bank Rakyat Indonesia l

BRI-DU Bank Rakyat Indonesia-Unit Desa 1I (I I) .IJ - I E..±;JI .±L

CGAP Consultative Group to Assist the Poorest 1i .Lill . s L.L ;L±L.

DFI development finance institution ,Ui J L.EBRD European Bank for Reconstruction and Development ; SL¢li LJi

ERR economic rate of return C;jL*:I %1l6lI JjxESW economic and sector work ,=t Ull SL ZisYI J,ll

Fl financial intermediary e$SL i

FIL financial intermediary loan iLUIfl,j

FRR financial rate of return Ul ll J.FSD Financial SectorDevelopmentDepartment, World Bank j4 .JUI t= LLall ; . 1;jl

GAAP generally accepted accounting principles 4Yk i il "1 -1 esJl

GATT General Agreeement on Tariffs and Trade LIMIIJ i I cAIMa l , Lzl 51 3LI I

GB Grameen Bank (Bangladesh) ( ) Qpli &

GDP gross domestic product V L21 L2L,I

IDB Inter-American Development Bank i.• I J_,Af ZriI &

IFAD International Fund for Agricultural Development 1,lI :n J1 ;JI

IMF Intemational Monetary Fund I ,i;1I ,

IREQ internal rare of return on investor's equity ,11 L. v Li 1 .1L1 JL

MIS management information systems (.L.L ;IY > ;t L$Y . Lt1;tNGO nongovernmental organization (Uh) s

OECD Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development IJ ILSiSl I EJ&

OED Operations Evaluation Department, World Bank , di;11 - o 1 sa1IiPSD Private Sector Development Department, World Bank u U.lV dI;1 Z j &Uil1 sZ

RFI rural financial institution LIL

RFM rural financial market ,1 1 LS1 A ii*' / , iJ1 j,al

ROA return on assets (Jl Wl ) J>I ;ROE return on equity _=LI - -L & , ZLJI

ROSCAs rotating savings and credit associations , l tj, i cL

SACI specialized agricultural credit institution * ^SAL structural adjustment loan .

SBP Sustainable Banking with the Poor vi,lJ LIi 5 I -l JW i 1.1I

SDI subsidy dependence index #1 ,,L > -

SECAL sectoral adjustment loanSLA savings and loan associations v°),1Ldl -TAL technical assistance loan i;% ̂ 1 jZTSE transitional socialist economy ,11 LI&; ali Jl , > 5.k jl I.51,1 jl

WWB Women's World Banking 5 ,=1 JilJl Li cl IWI tl

J

vlU LI M j5j.il l L W UI ZI=L jl ^JJi . I I

1 i ,iii * .Lj -U jA. - JL& IALII i AJU

L 1_E iJ iL±I 1 .L 9 14Jo L- 1 , E I LJJ UJLJ II 1 1v4Li

1 A,LS .1 .1 J I li j J3 olj:l S Llltl -I L I) d I La I-L ; ilU JI I

-Z:,1 , L j l UUI O1CJl -l .......... ........6t .. IYJ Z -Ul r ^^. - ............; v L

je~I ILW W1 . I 1 _j 61 cAL. L U1 ca4 WV i

L V3 iI Vs], *lc -l -i RJ L ,i LL + a I 'l 51i JU1I JLI

d-- - u n AL O XLJI LiD 5 O,Lx j9Y ~L31 cL-L j 1 - _V v ll

I lol; ,LL f LW tU Ls.] its L,J 11 JLS

L.UH j 1 L3 . l , j:!o Lv o-- a", Ll Sl a# X L dUtz S-*.1*|LWI fluz-, ..- I -1 |? .ig

v] s *iLv ;iLL j = I u -Z (II * r II< bLi>Y) LJ LXJu; L

IL 'ylJ d *' 1,J1 LSE ;-V v ^ ' _j =,LL all f1i L :LI,u SS -at 1d

V i4H Cde|L!;d I . - J - . I | I , |L:11 ,|S. ;. |d .*

u 2J. 1, ,LLl ,-Iz R > --; *t ALll tJ e2Lill 7,1 3 ()<

L- c.- 1;L& a.i! c 19srye A~ L.- d 191 o il Lvi,pLg I i ( ;) ( j,I L dj. f .J. .

,52;LlLd .t - Z= l lU I p " f, asJ> S " L I Si L J -2LiS .LU sI

,j L_&.Y cL1 -:1 L5S 01; A ,d J I O 5UI3l u id - 1Z I; I J I ZI, .t ldl

- - - t I

-Ljgu -CC,lL -f+6 )itvVPv11 t o - t I

:;tl I L tl ;- Li IL W! .1 : 6u 91 v MI9I L

-~~~~~~J.Y ItIA I -tI -- 4......... l LjU ̂1>tI 1o Ij L SI 1

^ t >!1 s-r l ziJul C;, .- ,-a I5 aI -jiL ljL tlL

- -

Z-ekl 4 jy v i jl o o . ; 11i K -£ iLoL *cLr-j-I 4wlj 1MGU E

dlY xaL L6 -1 ;2Y 4L1t IS , J 1'',.J ci4 igL Ls

M ~~~~~~~L_JJ 1 IEI ;;l IJI- ZU LL-.,J 4l. 1ot v:l .-M LJl BIJI ^ ......... ~~ZA-Y 6 41.I YILjA S11 >. LI s

WU JI LI t f 1;Ll ; J--I,l-t4bAv 5SJ

vy :i 11L>] 9 i=l,9 1)| 1;1J;o;JlaL

gsi ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~: 11Ll LI L Io>ili-4L;IJ,IJ;L

i. - 1,s,LIAlLQeFil, ,: -tlvovlS vos g *p1 ;LeL 5i: UI iLI

:;d Ljfi 5LLX VI ZL i. l ELi L.0 Li Uj L Iu u UI j iY~- I Z" ;, L

)*i LAi U LJ 6-L,iI )l II _,1I _J;: * i L-i! I LJLLI - L4

1 jj+& . W, P 1 . L,i z v t ;II it Ll aa J L>

;.Lill JL.A L1 css .3i L. Ll YI d 1>> 1o 1> I U

.d21L'i C5S. 5Ji;"Y f=lJ2 ,6 =Lz; L4 l A 1UUi c,"I

; S .Lll 1 5l LA" LIL; * J4 .- LUJI 4a, .L1l # -

i ..JUI OL11 .l J V L JLu (products)

L YU- I.'l f 11 11 UU i- 11

i JLl 45I iJi L -tl d ALI dI1*

- JL;i 3. ;Ij hh I " 1.4jl.- J I L ;L Li• I flj 1 & 1! I jd$ U. 3L.ZYI-y

'I I I;iJI ;AAWI JI1 V * LlJI jZ.IUI i,lYI 9 <gM1sU

S. L-JI cL;iW I ? L.Ia1 I&.ZI ;U I a9Qll S. l1ll Jlj LAJI ALal

L,L;1.aII e c~,= " ' L, Y l & L L =L. Ya 1 L.iii LU6 JJ 4 5 i

.JU 6L.= V V ,Lia I I'V I

;. UL)4 ULI aoi JedI I.4 ,Ix U I 6-4 ... LO- ,4-6IAIi- - L i;JW -- 46w, U3Lj.

;L c- zl_j l JL -J 11 - A- I '2L1 * I -S .1 aA -1e- 1 j I 1.~- Iu g, M1 v Li

j 14 1 1 L; . Li 11l j 5 AJ 1 U I U U zi LL1 i Az1 L I 1 I

Ju l I jJ i ,I ;3 vf

( 1 - I : I IJu

-,iZ l5- LJU I Is wlj L,A2 j-j *A .'-,d-......z S *- L+- . -. *tl bL-

i: 'u IQ Z6 L4 .J= - wi ZA L l r L.;W1U I J I|j ZJL~ JW I

j!'L Ls;c lJ f1 11 Li -^ V MaMl ;JLyl ti jAI juaiu

jLi &I - -13*1us, -l ;L t L..r j ilUI vcL- I~ J-;J i;.L L; o Zt As i LJci 31- t ;-11 o11 ?S

, u , . ;|| Lj 3LU Li, - l ;.I ;. L L;i l A 4 , i

LUI4 >;1 C I SC >93 v1 5LLJ$ Y I1 >ui IJ UI L O '-

_9L - i gjl ,Ca -1' 1_,=. b:. C;.. a" J LIA LAL b JAJ I L,- U L I

dt~~~~~~~;.j ZJU1 9L1LSAIEL l ¢ o11 >11 iFXiJLS SI

(S 1 H1lsiD .LS;II LS L; 1 ?{ Iu=s,1 SYI VA 1;A *L -lMY >4V;d

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~JILi1 ;*-V< IV s i cLjl L 1 Jj 1 i i Y

JiC141 1r .3 j> 1 C-j:J U; A1

'i t >ii l -:J, iL. WS WU a lia 3 I sjij = i LLL Vi .1i L I -ILLI 9 fiIL

i .1jwV J j Ua LU 4 L-..L.4 .LB a L J.~. -o -A U J UJLA Ii61 jjl _u1

i4 z.,m..fi 1 I a - .! iZi &AVI1 I cg L. Y LJI ii JI a '' ' 'L JILJ; U 41

2LL 3,2Il II Vl;I j.Jll L,.4 aj ji Y l "J -i eL iJ -,•.. U ULA

jL iVJ I VU UtA -vl,gl> . -al -.L UWl okls?I Ju ,, ,L >IJ .

.7" LKII Liitl Il ~Ii v Il > YI V4 g LUJ L3 .I gl ;5 4 L l l

L l I .LALtjLul -isI4 'if J- V - vidIi Li ; l A

- ~JI Ll j- 4lSv JUL.(,J ,LL

-(.3-IY 1IIWgÎil6A.jy I ci

L:<l otLII L.;jJ; o;Li>lL. jL:.fl vi,j5a .i,Y LAs: .cil c

UO. E J<YI caLoL J; Z&u L;p v; UIjLa

;pc Aj~~~~~~~~~~~~u :l a-L3u&; 11 ;pLII ;= JIj iL 'U k3 L .l2l .asleIi1 iLi flt _U fi

L,laILLJ Il1i : iJL q1i;; X1 Y

~~~~~~~~~~L' .Es ocli S Ic ~,-LJIoL j A IL~JI1, -ILt i ljeY a-, i cL~= Zq~,-L

Z43UIA1JL.: Z# 21E,i4il ZJL3 Z - 1i-l -1>1 L,;l -l . :11iv,41

, ilUI ,3I,Yl ' A Yl s| C. .1av rL -a CXJ ;LS.i fI Ll Li.-lY U_CI iZcY 4 olpl Y lS

;54 J ,3 5;VC>4X J oL LLl J -4i LI.H ilei iGoto

1 Y5oS i LA IzUUc i>Ljl iJUI c1 l ^L-,I.^ll . o I !Li u-

L5 *. .111 t=S UL C d61 ,1- 1 .4 b I ACir]I 4 L;:u; 611 ri dls12ii L~ U ljl..IL AM. iic

d- s ;UIs.Y Je lX lvco JIolaYl .s e- .XA Z-,a 13 &X I9 a- *I e I' 2s -3 I

t S 11,EQj;A A 1959i.s - ecJl 4JI * ,1a4L!j Y-+- OIL

OL 5>- 6 U -J -% L ;1 5 * 9. s 1 1 9 4 JIL . 4S I Z ̂ - L L Z

~ L,LLs s a d 1JLJL7I -Vsm ,>L I.^ tL- Z-J t:L L.:: I LA~J I iJ U I :,.I& L1

y . 1(. f) I jji'Y Y J,6: 1 f1A1 3e-,.L &=

ZI 1-4 t- -L; ;;-j U1 LI 1 -l -A1 U VUI aL .1 "IAL1 J_ Ij= ,lL'

,1::L 3 L41 l- 47Jl J L ij.i li -_j >6 L- {I -L l ZtJ J-L L l Z,% Vl :I U otl

J UL eJI i -Ll f Z#LI- U -i Qs1iS U SJ c; l ;i ;Jd- L uj, 1 JJIJ iL YI

- I .;1sLI*,'--W ;

S,-'VSiI ZS I aalll

lZL - 2 ut ^1 'L-, '- [A 4-4, L T>- t J //o,,,j-tj

-,, LA5 CSl3zl 1st-;pqdA

, ;4pliIILJI UL *S w VZlj ,sOLV JLw ,Xtl &ILW L59 61L1 UUDSI , 5l L.9S

uui 1. 4 IL-- gj, d -1 1 ... 1 I >13 .- I g L~ .l L..,I I

?1UG.;.JF-;JLY,1JoDI JSAL LZI ->XiLiOI4I

;LX L%LJ 4-t I ;s -- ., L 1 S*> S - d bJ; I tWli -JI EI 4, LI

.L,-;,J~~ 7llJ LKt1 CLju 1~. ;A1 .:.kLil ;J13 SjF

L4L JLI11 Lj-- eZ1;El Z_.L I2i J fj-11 ---- L^ Ui- U-lII e JJ

zZL-Li- LHSI at I6 iLi V. s................... I d -- LZ iSLALq Lij . -JI LL I

zo-~ J-q Ls: IL I > -- _-gU IU 1- 1 aL ,lI

e45 e o - ,:,u LL,4 I-u ;-L4 LL-'O JL - 21 JU i;-g

L t Ue I ?Jl a JU .l; I aU1 :,I 5.k1 J. - 3. , LlJ.L SLl^ I

UK~ ~L JL~&~L ES ' -j ^ .U l C I ^J-JI L ; J *I CI.;AI l*WI .L ,I U I L::1 ,j4-i r SJL-IEEEli1?4 - CI^ 11 ALI 9l-^ S-i

. i5UI J' J JulAl. Si j I.o j iU,lUI *e 1lit

5 L& Q;U I X• - LiislUI .PY !LIMA '*r V-Liy >1i cI 1? LL~Ig 4 I .JI -v-f~.i~j; ~ L~W.JI U.j.v1 WL-1 t L+• - 6-ol ~ ~ij ,,i i(.L,I

W tW {L lJ Z 1JUI 1 1 I ,L - L lj j ..L I V V ; ; e I ,I,3II SJLL; ,SI iULl

I U. U AJ 1 *jLLI 1.1 *oU O, L4 fLj VC Î UW j1J .I ..J ,I4lj I

G1 - U 6 , , ,-4LI 1, L L,,-;- I l &S4 JLL LA L~tI G ~ L

I.Wl J I UH-L I ,;L:YI 5 _j,1 L1 c 2I•

,,.- N I J,U U U L.), -U - I V . AL,LI. I S1-;

G.J ;aV. JLl J JI-i LL 1; ,i .ii 41 1 .JI Ji J. Z } -VL

o jk SLA 1141,i QC1L;.- .......... A; j. &Ltl^CI J LA LC*1k >A -- ' J

-. L-A f;Xi: Il A-- I ,J U--t ;:;I a_iL JY 1I 811t*t9-opJ

. 1L-II ,,u - IS1 - t k caYI vi L-U -L-a-. BIJ L,H JI ,,S 4lJ (-L

* Z-lk V t! F L IL] ; I r= #I A ";y iII { , *; J a; Z ^YI) L I

I.. 4Lj (5JJ UK JI 1. LL-al L Jj *VIl ̂Ll Y O; - zXJ UI

siLr-jll,6-1 1".6 .I..A l 11 I -,;. a Lg fl Z,AI c, @ L j *V_, 1

71;tILVECL1 Ild1 l f L,J JOLl,I ^ l 1)

1J-: -- I %jLLTA JSU ,A Li-JIJIU'I ,as

.l 14 1 S UL- J..L=XA rL; 4KIS I e:JI ,Z~Lj LJUI ,0 -Lgl Y> S{Y *

;4LYI ULI ZL;Li uf^M Y IV -- Al 'I-YIIIJ,9H I 61 1

. i ,ZmI Ul 1b7&I L.,, a>1i-1 JUI, fIf V I

?,-J1 35 qLW eli~ ,I elJ^ Y+, 1-, J .tL- J-, L1 kII ij .L- VL v I f

;5 U:LX QJV--f oJ JLVSI Î; I Lj I .,.LI. .p, I 34- S wnxs LLs-/ i

JU- l sl ,L-S C .- j 1C- - l .11 >I a 1 UI =J

V

1--l~I W -. -L ALiLI" * -~lILJI,I ULUU L-31,~ ~ -

~ AU1J oiI . LLI ' d -ZL l c jl L 4 1) ;-'I LL L ;

L i i JI I U L i ^ * I ; . JL. L I l 4 ..L.

LA-I l. . .;LI Z L: JLl,L * L- -1 i-I

Jr AiL..l . 4,,1j1 Ltz3 cl ;o LA /

Z. JI *U ii * i:i I , *L iLtI d L .-t5I I1 ,L.L --i - 'Y C7. - LS L a Z:L I I-i gtj -lL t s #

Cij

^ ~ U. Z:VLI UL *14wl | .... |1~ LLll :1

1-7.1 L- --- jLxl QUI~l L,6 Zi.L... ....... ;1vM>I LL1 L Y A &.

L=la1 3s2..1- tt â 1.+- ZL iLal J5UfI5 L s * -^ i:- t "i ALjL v-1 1. - -

-o lsag.L~jI . 5 i j e-ddId * La I i L-- * t t l

Zt~' i1i I s L .... I zLUI d - -- L1 I LA .Jgil Z Ll aJA 1

- . .IS L-| -;I1c;Ll I * ilt >zii,CJ1 . ;tviyill I

*6s g IJ -L1 i I LI5Z Zq.,. LJ [=I

I aa I j&t -u avL*-iJ LzI

.cL@I -L<J JAd 'Lol.alL

M

4 if -L:; ] Lli ll c, L- d I L--. '.-Y LLv Ij Z A. 2. J| dA c O -*

J- ;I;. .C. i s ; ,; d * -t-Z -- j I9

d-J - l i.LL '-i tGUj LI mlw.=4 Z ZUI at11> -YDs;1C YI

_,- o-A II 5;! Y it ( >d-J S_qg11l 1;|e*

d: U tl * t,jl I JISA~~~~1 1 ,= I.;|S 1-F?I~J I;1?

Li * V l > d,L .i; L i* m4j L d 0 ialU d. *~I L- -;, i

d-L><.4J~~5 PN;i; .--.SJ V LI L;5 1 - .1 - IJu d EtJbi

1;1~ - Irj l ;4- I_X1 S ;'L: '-11 -oL La J f 4.1 ;j.,^l ^S^k:i -

JUoIi LZ I = JL.lI U L U,i j I 1JJI aLJVI

-4 >tl j-Ll1MiIIE ll ,-i;j;;11,L4 .Lt ,i i;ll

1UL. -' iS"t '__~ -i L,;'_Jl Li jLj JU Aj cL-6 1t- Zb1 1 .6

i~I~31 ~IJ,U=I ~, Vi,1 UJ ,L Z4I ~k , L~ L ~.IJ- .V I l UI J-IJ I.V; i 1 I I ej1jI 3=t1 Lo.L MjI Li

XLi1l JLJ.iJJ 1 Y i L L I LJi &,@ I U I G L C 1L ;L-L L-LL

Z .S .. 4 A5~ Jj1. j t; 4LI .,I~.ii --L L i J, 4 Jli YlJ - UaU1 r4 L 1--1i I.JiIlYIW G clc i Y l u UL•, 5i3JV iLIJ

-§y j ± 1t1wa C>L S .Ijl .L L.JLI ^ oS -19 L.WV -i&ll I -~hi fl Si1 gG I

VJiLMI.I,] >A EIJa.Ill I BLa -L.Z (aV II S~L~ sw .W L MiI 1IjV O>JdIJ

QLL1vJ .4. e;tL JIJ 9i LL.ij skLi FLJI v1 i,.. y I 1i,,I$)~I ~ 1 4 v.k . Va~

L J i 'M9lSJu S .-, 5kIaLll LL WI...............-,=ll

cLJ UL.%i jilt ,C .<- 61S iJU jiL fJ;U ztd Z'YIJ 1, ;J 1 L, ,pU A

L-;. -LAIId l 2 I L:zc 6 U I *--; L4 1>

.Aj >-a %1 .>; **Q11 L, I.J 1; ... *17IL - dd.-Il 'L- Yl e y1 >4adJ5cL

Zi.J_UI d Z- l 'M1- c L-L& lj Zji YL6 It Z!J JIjy OL#: j o3L& zd ASS LL:!IJ

dr ;_ ,ljY I UNI dj -a 1 * -4|; | i iiJaZ (Sall Lwl L, - .1i te fj

i JL ,1- U_:I L,<L L5;1 11iZJU_I CJLI QL1 1 A-? cL-LS jlY U9caLlJ 1 EJ

,?=1 LI A cLJbL5 i~l,9@b -tl ( v ^LY|deet.Lg |j[,fisel< .L ; -i- I | b-U

LJI L Ul L& _I=l ctiM I .b IB U 1 Zi L:1A cl f, _i; e .*,;11 dL;J L t 1y1 JL LJIS

, :tI d~L I>t ; **jlJ Qjlijal (.s") cS, y t CLiLJI

XiW LI wjsSl '^-YI o=? '2

LZIJ IY Jl itl Iilt SJIrY Z4;L LIL21?Î

1 d-, Loj I YI 1 a ~ L

t LAo;Y 1_ I Uc 1,9 ,A-u I ; > NLa I :I -1 L9 * I L iil * d I ;_ L; IJL atLj+ Lz LI

:;iN! l Ll -111 Li t-,:1 IJHI c >aJi L-i -;-ll L 9l . 9 i1911 ;tI. -l :4 ja

WU iJU &<-YI 1 L. L-J I c, d ._. , I AL.

La La.tiI > i11 I 12 ,lL l U.

)E -> FIJY IC u -t- La 1, -LAi Y il~lLI~ ~ ~ ZZIjI Q"J

-JUL i LI I 3 1JI WaiLLIl lI9.Z;I -I j_4.1 J .,j 1 Ij

-12;Y Ij1*->.lit1j U1 ¢~ 11 I2LL l ,S,t

..; IL )ll * my wi.L .iLJI e LUll , IYIz

it.- SL-j 1. Lv 11 r LJUi 4J;II OI=L L I

Il

'o.: VLza1I a 4 S I J L.!1 L t I jL.I. , 4.&i I 9LII U 1 1 ll#l c.U I _I.l1Q;1L. 4.1 (;) :S1 I1 f, L I ZJ iJU O1L,J i _PL :1JlAl1 45S6 I ,1J 9 U

4;i=L= j L 'i I 1L U 1 3, i . 4Il I 0I.1 .....I.L..-..L ;IIJ l, I ,J1 L= I

Ls:4I ;LU I cL-,~J Z.MIU ~I cLVI j,i zOi l ZLLLJI JUai 1, L: UU "i ~.I ,I4I

S ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Z= *O1131 EAL ;ll 11tU 1, LI I - L-I I L.. -A I2 :;L|>S*

L'.L jl ,UiI Q -_J;l .iU .1 j I V ,i•.1 W %.VI U-4 I .4 L - V I

1;5 I YI ;11 l 1 I .I ~ Lwl LJ;E, 1I

JL t,] I L3=1 &L ~ L.=l J, jLl~j1I ~,.i L ,i ;L,j Liu L3CtI I_zVI I jL~ L

#L z - *tl L LLL *j ^ uUl VWI u

,34- - i fi 1- j.l -z.w. .;JJY ul l Gs u u 19 L)U I a 1 *t I >?I t;Iul L,- J.a.l ( ;il 3L

Iaz;ev ;e$L d- J-1 ^r J~ Z±L qL. L4i Za IlX cL I L6 Jb* ;1 S.1- I> ;i_ na'I

*,.i II ,-d LCl-; L U I *l) VI ^ -_ YI Z:, Lj 3;. U i Z:. u I5

la s I t; ; , I -Y 1 CLZ 1 1 4y§ g|,x, -,-;,t|L

45:il Li I-: St Zxj!1 ft9j 11 "i L - _ --

be~1 ava; I1 UJ j;=l Li ;GU11 =1 IaA ,A1*-t

RJUI LiLIgI Y 0.. 1 AS.- ;Wf -

,jV5i*4t 211 5

Jl;; e611 oM s.LLj

*l; p1 >1a1 e QL-iJlU IYj A lo jUI *!1Y1 ,Y L-L _f _4 L.

Jk ; ~~Lil ;1.X>{p I i Lual ;LL4 J >Iso1 a i ULa7l Pr 1,L

QLJsJ iJjIi Lg ;L-,:. oLL4

jlazi, Lp2t &~ s~ a-Jl c,,i <.p; LJI

L-;:t. I UIli AJ :,- L 'jAI V iJlU L iLL. S ;: Jl L.

Ls ilU ,iL- I v I I ,i , aJL. I L¢alatl

L--,L.*ill 1;UI ' )I1VJ.Ljl51L I 1<a,

t71Ld LL1U v>Au~I ,Lt1 SLjf :vl cLo> i It+i I L-.. Li

J- 1 au LWI1(S O ,>1iU (..A 1.1 I ll +, ILLI+ 7

A L.il 5gLL1 u.4I A *sj 1 i LJ I Z. L,l .i.lC V LlZ I L-fUIl

.J;11 kUI Oo1Ja t.[WIi lI Jl J {lW

'F..

ZZ' - 11 LZ XU1.Aob I. Z-{ 1 3-1- La I1 1- e I Z LI

Z;.1 11 JULSJl Ur- *LiJ S;1? i LtLUI j,# iJLI ZL-NlI

r- _519v9 'JI...AI -2.6I iZ~ lU C;=lsl usN6S11if--LK-i5 iLul :9gJ,YI .:1 -11i JOIFBI

1 - - - - I L-.-I I-K -

.,~ ,ELLJ~

I

Ii

JL; ,WS1 id~ .Z JLS,Il L...1 5,WI * ,1 (E, - tI :SL LE. UL:I ,I 0 LL'Yi (41 v*oLXI EARz,l 1t LyI ,- L. L,Si i.JUI, Z:fLj Vu S1 tj('l

jl J:fl Ll^ JJ Jj .JU!IJI .Id * JL (C)J *41 I D - 1L1 O pI 1 (,La**iI

SLJzLIS rUBJI - ~ * 1 (31 J.'L.. ^,5k1 1.U JICI () * 1 .U&I ,I h 4 UI• ~ îs

U911 5aSLI VLY1IX~ ;S~ *.-* ELSI J Y~1I TS - W1 A -:~.I jILiX - Ii

Lj 4 - LI L. FLJi O- ;

i1 5 i ISYI L)) I )LI 1 1: I Z

.;iJlLI c6u[A 1 1Z1 (1). Li& ,jI 4 1 J ,r 1 II

otIJL1- 1 ll LI-* ,f-YialX U- 4-ci LLI 4A i W6> T4;

LL I -.,,1le-> 11A L,1 j s;1 .fl dI

*~~~~~ fjz-91 JW >11 ,I J-. ,,- - * * dl, %,tIA;J() B

ii ta |- ^11 -tL1 ^ta^^l 1 HLjlgt nill X L >fi.j,11]J ---bl Z >l-(. a 1 vI Zj

W- 1 36 1,51l S jl l v s? J jU IJ HJL sC*--^dI-*CI

j5L', I -- fA * 1)9

X 1 ;I;*;t Ljl1 t; U 1Z L-" Z-@ 'J OJ=LiwI .4¢

*,.a1a L,JI L J9SLY I d-a .

-j UI L-tl~ 4-I 3L^ 1- Illd 1 J5LuJ. L. IC - .................1-j I LaG

5j 8-£ )1~~~~~LY - .). .;LIIUYI : ^l U I L7S

j.t5ti[ ~~~~~~~-,1 I:,..[* 1 iJ;zid I LYdl :u1 -11 ,JY O > J- *eSI

oL-J I b.! Zt-' L1 (- il1 l .1 =9.aU Iico L1s

\V

IU 1L4 i VL oL 8@s I ) 8 .d.,J gJiI 4 A 'iL~J *1I1 c,1± - : ;.*Y~ i=4.11

-. hi l dali I fL4-Il to." JIII I I .J .i-=l &J Ld ggiJ d I l LdL.. A_ t.JL_q I t _ i t Laiil I JI il .lj " a J ti Lt . .L LdI

vP z-vLM S - i J Li HSX.)1 .Ll 5 ,I t JJA I

LV J ii( 1_ JiJIhJi4 Ll I 3iJL•1 IjAJI LIV L+L I ZA-N+-AiJI

2.1-M• I,Icliol I ui I.1 YI¢1 tffit;: -ktl cLlw,1l ZecSlJI Ls 1b L:IIJ v1iI L 1

e I ' ''i 4J S JI y)LF..!' I LI

L, iJU L'1 Q.1o;tvIGlCl1 teii w;>;z# sviia J-

, i ,L .1 I 5;d Lio:Lao tLo VOj LL.iJo 4 _L4 I L L. LtU sI a, A 4a-,.L-J I Jl; ;L I I

L Lit I rl ,I ^ - 1 +L-- -I -- i J,I J

y~tj ;;S Le; xj ojlp L.,,- J ;,L I1

L I!7'; I J d = LI L.; I iA VI V U=]A-5 Z.,LrI Zi ,uJ ;all a ?L%JWL.J ii1 ; L1 a 3j 1 y 4d,1

1 ,LLlI v

IjL.ilel YJI ljl .kJeL1X11N j.L-0; .. iAL MveX

I LI=j*L; UII Z 1 ~ q SJj ;Jwl vi=LG LL L<YI :1c IJI v el 1L

&9-I w11yval,>i B LSIv4-1 9 , jLu:ll1

S-;1 O J L1w*Z L! L ) I iJlUI ;lL-A I Z-iJlllI ... I .!

Li-jlS L4 ^t vJ aI ,L i dac ig_a;U

ZUI-Sw ;.g cLt l~ - ~Ji JL,6 uc- A5u A-Yli Ji AlI:iJJj

fU 1 L,. ;11L j,e taU 1 ̂ ... I-0 = I ;... ;, Io

1 4ij ;JL zL-5.SL,L,- Y.I VL~Ll L+.dw L. I1 1 LS2 IJ - E P te.1 IL LC

S ~~-.4;j-Do 1 1 -L-,; I

I*~L ZJUI g=I ->? Kj I j5 L~- 4I'Y JL L-j

t-I Ij U1 iUI a:1 .I 4 ; Li 1 _,I; 'Yl ? J lJ P^J yl,:,~1U

2t1*I L IU;J 1D, d L, 1_ I J L Y I 1

,t:t-l-= jL,i _:tI - -

.J~~~LdI Z.±JUI t, Ui L*s WLYIaoncV->--:JI 1) tl oL *-L d 5

LA3 _,ii y |I Yj !:d I1 I O1; d~l I z|i _(|l UL. d g1j UUI zY:<9d/d*-roye[ i.,LiL .l LL;I L's Lpl *- L- 1 -~ I -u:1 I11

...LM &1 vU2 GJ .±L1I J,91I 1 .I>a1l'JI - -i-

L.~IU I UL-4I LJlU:

il I-Ule SLLI L4L

ZL;JI J Y I -:1JYI W.Xl ZLS:Jjt t,5,,Ax ,1 f THJ L ;l 4m S SfUM Li;atIL I'I --

JIWI J- -1 L) iJ~UI -I1IYL ,J;t LSI i vliY UL 5Z,,- iLUI L 0 ifilo

GZLjl L-YIX9LII etizLU9j J9ID5 IAJ.8 Schwarz) Z, - *.11

"L l.1 OL'Lu J~ )tlJ LIIJ ;W] L 'W AiI J"6sZa SW . ,Il

1 4 L a;j j1 LAaZL,6 SaWJ4) ;:ULI Li 1. Jl .. ,L.,* G L. ZjLJ i4 a;11 ,i

fL~ ilAI.lI U9~- -L u-1 J;O Lt--j"g_ * L,.:, lyi I A-.: 5E JI LA; ij1_

t.. 3l -j4l qq.e _6 1;U-U _*91Y L,.X . i- L;Y1 L5 tS _-J 4? f,V

,~~~LLI .JM I J k 1vSberban}c) JUYI,: : XFII*< - 5jJ

J Y a I J;:tcl *M1g ,L,11OL:P= (Gosbank) LLl _9( L;idLsj_t

d *,,J4;6 JJ LcL_'Ilji :tWl -Um L- #I sJYJI d-G| Li LSU -L.V L.

Y.4 YI~L I, aA j, W1 -9 L- - Ij Z-C' I -i I-i' I U I l

L5~J L;_A=l 7+J =.;LA1- (0IIo LL1 U-.V YI 11f - V: X

,t~ Ui- --- l- L'I -- 1je 1 L,? i cL n- Z,~j1 IJ L,:-.L, a s L *I- , Yl YI

' 51 .A ,sL_ sriU IY j 1_ 4SL -!- I.3J 'I I- L.L_ I U_ Z1lo1*_- *

-L5 Y i ~ (£).i,5(JUI SJ. ' ,5:

* (&LIIJl l5 5 ..OYL L,.jg *JL; JL.~ cjL WSUI t U_I

J1-ea ,ll 1 eJ LA CL wJ!.

oLO 5AT M s8.............<Ls\A 8t.......... 1l *1f

*X=sa4, +1);_) v 01 J1 s 1 < A ) 1 2 > 4 1 1 . 1 U u S

LL "A 1Z LE Wd1i . -A.j V- .1,

-! U.ill :> L I1 I 51-1->.ljX

-~~~~L LL2 ->X ;1 I j

dI Y l>l -Z-lII~9 W

laA L;l EL+LJ IO , Z- *-_J,2 i.L7 ;,,,1 LW' *i a 'L t -,U d-

- *91 ,6sL ULAjI =l :- ,LALSf-

ee.J I UI.+L W,;'41 1d) ?I____ O_j - &l II

cGillp, 4 z etIF L- L4,j5; I;S,s9 ; o

ijl-l Lo - {2 t- ' IZll] t-ill ^^ I-, UjIW I :;) Loi 1

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~L, , ,N- .j Uri5, ............... i Lu,LL1 SI Co I

-. 1 L,=sij.2 jLZ;YJslliL;lcIj'l -Li 65J1SA Ztt_ jVIjiDJIC

s5,-,sitl ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Jl i L Y1oSAI rx19-Y -=IooA 1'

~~~~~~~~~~~i^'a: -"k 'l 1-I IYI c je ,, ..

.a . t I ~~~~~~~~J)-l S-;jLIo - 1 c lFy 4eS I;3 u $ U LSU

feol i11*ilU~~~~~~~~~~~~~~I,,lL;,*v; l ;c,1, .... ;.1S-.zD

J )a - 11 *A-, Qa qLJ YI, - M Z CK-W A Z-z,,Y LLI > ,,s K Ilc0,A a4

J^ LjU>IL ZL:;JI1.11 -Y JI L;l lrl; Lii .AW;!.<1

(;e -; CI, I7ls>1d*-. i I L'- IJ l.U o;1flv .g tlo;e L L ;,L 1 L:$a , YI

UAlva# s UL-lrlEFLy-JiLv s R C 5 Jl c iJ 4 o

~~~~~~~~tLii> ts 21 U1sSvSll ;1viyaH

>~~' 4 J5LJ*;- '_l- sjC l Ii Zi.

. st Demirguc - ECunt and Maksirmovic ,1"M L.;, -- LL-.~0;

L,:Jo4;;I.t '.LZl2 LK !A£ -t.iZ :,,>2IGZ-.J -- te,,t1

*'A J Ad Iman and Tinermeier)

-L C+ $ I 91 Z L¢ ^' 11t t- -YI 1Jl.aAa ,t E1.t 1 ? f°;ll

*cl2tlL QlA-l.-I YL;

tp1VLXLL-V ZzAt.. ,. jqA1 ,;- *1,...Y£1C L.

JgL-Ul , :; 2 JL ' '-i 4; L ZU I L \- ' I) LA

v uo9sHcil SsoSl js, vi v5j'j ,I;a L,H -ai t 'Y. -t -1 I5Y JLtla ;

(s*Aw (Si nJL v>xl tir iL Si eL; -;%!fi= i 1 1 Lgt I j1Jfl1

J V 4-itJl 'YI9 J13vilv-1L vsltl L5] Zb11 j 1 tl>i. s Zli-7tI CZst lJ8-SI~ ' IP K Ijm,11 l..-l* 1 &Lff>AJI> ej . r u

L.Z I C 1_J c Lai " I . s iL,4 I JJ- 1zSYI

b <YA :, -CZ 1V ,ml Jl eLJI ,Lill ib 4-I4 l;rl c,"llYIjIa itl - ij

U3& 21 2j, d I J f<JL -i L,: I v J1. j I -i L i,S-a. o

L,. in-T JLY ,I -,i) UI L. fj-Ue I.a I C7..L I.

~~~~~3B W .1,Lll , fls ;i ,l l /

Z'il*p JLLU0 I42; :Y- ,zLltl-?I

f

vILjl PVLoY I ;-t 5 L'Si olJLyIl vl ; I rt11 I ozi l I J I co4bsj 1_%, .JI o,.% I U .

rJW2 ta GI vLi I "jsl l I n folJl o. VY,zi L;I o4m .1JI LJL >;;lj li

ul LI LS1-%L= I1 &=y ......... t;YI ol.c 4wl- ;'tL X,1 iI LlolSIu

JLJ I LA L5: .<U;l-l J5l.LI X l 5 LXi oli 1zs4;i J< I L 5 I k ,.al- -s

j,t U Z.S1iJUI111 iIL19;1 .4 9.UYI............... -. tLZ i, U I I L-}Fl)l 1 5v1L

; 1;1 t o liiL Li ZAlllI "-;Y I L-_..va -( V *R

_JAis+*L;<;^liIo tij ttlrLo QL!" tll;;.l.u -L45'stl

LJI 1- Is.A=' oL;YL_ 6 ,.L: J IX Us, 1s .3.-t ?IIfJ RLwI .-Lf lll oj -lI

cl=; (l LA L g v Lzi l o -I QLa &.,tSsL ; ;>U°i::

XL-- * (\4,- A l Adms Gahaml and9l Von) Pschke

, aAj=z UZ, I I L.. °L;j v^ L. , ,1v I

*S;I J tZea I F ,t 5S -;le t1 lvs;lEJ t

J ; 1 3j i; LS:l Lvli cL t!i J:L>> JWagt-4 - ^ Y v I;illv

Z,i .x IJs L --J- r ,:, QJj.L.11 AaA .......... ,, , -,I,S,1N,l- -1 -I "z v\A ;.Idms J!aax In Jo Pishe

I L^91^ ; 1 ee> %j LZY lJe.l ̂i *-n1 l, ZaJ=1 1 4Lall z u #t

^ 1 (~~~~~LF>)< W ^ ;*1a1JlA_tl Jl.= * 1ixlS A ;L Jl ^-L

*t:lL6 I;:W J 1- ~ L-:!AP -1rJ1 U<,^,AU ZJJ L+LX !)L

-,L I;Y vii .,i ;Y U_,7I CiiY I,

IX ,i 1

te M :g; ku L ;;- 'rIf J.LYI

HI ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ -- JL L; VIts ,R ;-( UJ, S L"4911 9J1A5L 415*2-

ZU Li IX 1j * 1 t ; I .UL.IBV1a1( (lwVYi1--o1~I:W

oJJ lSiZ i;JI L1i ,-II ,:6;]1 4- ,SI g1L b o z

:lijlo rIc;J :l, ;I,.g.

'ev~ - l5A'S9'l, el(9u<2t5uLoellvluv

-, ?I cylj s l 4-- &I 1 j.6m>¢ >W W U -1

a"I, Lj, "WI ;.Lj UUI ZI4 i ui_

1,1~~f --.. LRS L.gl 1 ;- s a ->tal1>ule

IlY u4i)Hs L- I 1. YIZJ .- -Slj lj.l YI * L .,.;LLJL Si, -J -: t JI

7,p,,i 1 Ql4 | -zi,;Y Qo'I JL.V Ll i .1 I -Lj-1 D X=lM

4,o,--z ?.AY jil,,X oyU 4 z U tzl tsLYI r11 oL YI y .1__ Lr F Zi I -l

AzI Y;~Y <1A5wtlk; e :- AD

LS> I Yia~ ' z. JUI ,"ui , J obLlI a,k v A; ,,1 , Lail Z1 aWu l JWil ;1: LvJl

I.1 .9w.; J*.SLLL.;I J L.-,,i & ,i Wi 4 T- \ V I; 7,1 IjJ OL ;I1

O*J,71 J.)LWI ;L>Y I Y &S L JoL.I *-7 *:1lj; .. . u\-*.,J

-;41 viJ VLtI 4.yj '6 - 1 S X XI A - Judi S

s4I- jL1I-j_LtlrI LIi Z,s-:YI ll IS; olvii .L'; ."jl ,LLll ,_, -ljji 1li Jtl 4,=M

U_..jj ' -jAIj -_A,l L- j4N1 S'< ,$;al) 4.vil lJY- YL ;S1 ULolj *X . I oYI :1

Ve.14.11 L .. ;iv*UIi\ L 6v I1 uo' I Z-1 li ILi jus I* - 1 1 IS l,iJ VANY -NAA L,,i

L;_,:1 UW I Li .,.- jl ,YI 1,1 I ;YIj Bisage an KhandkSIer)OJ *e >1, v-11tUiI,*

4tLl 7 #j~w lJ 1 >11 L,:J . = ^ Jlijis l .¢~ ̂g I t7o Z.g1 UIjII -Al

;-j5-l IA11 - ,Jl - t=l J.. - L.- -~l ;jL1 CW -- t7: iL L_ _Z_ I tr l

ZIUI I9I ELV .X ;Z V; ,_i" I I Y I I >; J <-oJ 5Lq- =-I t NI A 1 1 a-df LY oL-

.jLa3 o 9*-IL Zf9t- v 7JLF-jWl5 WI L,:;I -i it zL - Y ualfl L :I pIv I tl o. *3 Z.-L Il

m%T S1 -z 'l- J VL;Y L, * O - Y 1,- - 1 ¢ a X eSI *Ll X1 *il l.

<,li Is1 -ijs ' G 1 >;s9L I 4JI * >a L,s l ;YI

. 8tso .Binswanger and Khandker: ,1vlY i UA*g ilo

TYo UtLLI; 1,.D JY 1 +I'.I

A Z D JWI bIA I o 3 * .*I )i ;,i L'4 *l X ~ (JL- 3J 3 .. v..-

Z" ;t: 4D -J ; JI iJ 'W 41 1 ..... l 1 1 ISclillJl

--i * Zl ipw L'i "6jjl .:lil LAI I? 4%J-t- *AV... C-.j Ih r 5X- <;9's1

vZUI Li A 2 J J Iol, t . #1v, JIIDrv

1 ~~~~~~~~~J-; uL ,ss.;, ., .g ^, ;L.s.i r , 'Mlj IJL .L. J- .

Chaves and) c,L.9LIJ v i i , vjii J y 1 c, s1 c J,- WiaiL IL1. (vkoto .Sanchez vy4- I;l,,l.1v i

j 9; S V .J 4>JII - .L;SJ e V'. V 16 *4Ja. k- -i ZI 1L ,1 * U I M A.I ES 45Q11 J;+~~~~~~~cm l ^w J;Y; (11 A )H:^4 ;4I - Yj

-~~~~~' Z'1 *HLr-1 iiSii *",A,j XI .6 -' 'L~j Z 'SIji -- it .Yarbrough and Yarbrough v,. v i

aj.o .1I tIjy I gi j3i (A) * ( Ramola and Majahan)

.31 :^ o.ii] s I - L -VL JiVI , 5J, Lo ,yl (I

iJ,A tl II : oI~I;;l 3 ll iNU Js cc ;±JI L....Ltl J;lJ 1Z ~J<l g UI JLiII i J4L d ^ -JU

'Z-.2|,d.LjI jpulyy L,..- '|fi ", I Q = <$

S 1 d C -jit~~~~~l J]i 1; .1v j 11 I L'IsY l3-c

t5S LA"LIL L o l d JL21 ; -L I 6-1 1Z Zt:i I Aj

=L.. l .J, L±L1 ,d ;AI J vi --

Z vJv YI A I ;iJt• J ' .hiff .Khand al L.LtI s -1 . J

(N 4 -L .U4l Vil• dWj P I J) A VI Jd ~ a ... 0 YI Y jjGJ*CIJi

vs1J J YI f,- cWY ;.w-jJIId - V JUI,

cJlI Si( 1 LY911 "!J'V~JNL) bl'.Ul

< Q~~~_ 1 ul, $ d1 i

*d"iI ;L;L I Lj J oiLs i IJ&- 39X 41 L<9 A:!

d,*.{i*C1 U5Ili .Schiff and Valdes)ol tl- I ^ : :Ajsi

;:~~Ljav UU' Zi< LJ5L 9i;Y dL L-F ZUIX L; r (84=S1 5;,Lt d211iJg 1 . ; da UCLxJYIV ................. ^zgMr.J )bdl L ' i Ld- .u

ZtLj itUI c.L.-3U Sl ;j1I r f"D 1Q -u 1w;;vJ

*I1 i1.?1° 't jSI ..<O L11,-i *IGJL (BANRLTRAL)

ISI> J>x I1 JlS I SL)OL I .,JO

9~~~& , YD I 4, L = 1 I ,Z_,Zi uYl V° SULI ,LlS V YIVJJI ,*

:Su is _. a s o2 M I .s .. %:'a 1 IU _1 _I liY 1 414-YI a 1 L

~U= Z Lzl ; %ILLI*I 01A L1 1 L9I tjirL

, 1 - LI., .iMI .UI 4,-3& ;911 )-,Il I ULlJ IS alril JL.-V ZUI Yj 51

.I 1 ' J -- I41 ,* 4 1 LL.II A 1, L. - I Z,. ZUI ;5i AJV isJ,1 N UikA

JW & 1 jI .~.u ,i... Ljil ;, 5;14-1-p1 .............SO oJJ a,*y9.; . ; . . . . . ... J.t; 1.I"Y

s.ba LaLWi Jl n^ 1 15 1Lil ; ;;lliUI -Lg9:~u GUI iJI ziuS zL-411

1i4LZ ;LXIeAI c ;U '&LI VYI :C-,- JLYI

ISS Z:iLililJI UI i iv55Y sL- L#.- Z:) VVA _Iy; Lp *%-kY l- Li , jJ ZaelZ .

;LULI ,Ls J6-! U 1UI < ................ .U caL_,WI ' i,; I'l) \V%Y-NUAV 3_;'1Sy JJGi 4' iSl oW 1 a

efi "14 V o i)i 1bu Zjlg ZUI £J,u jl ,jla, -il S< ( 5£*'

i;U I Lfi NA L S, V W seIS LSL -1 whi C-L 1I:-. oI;j jl I Zjgil z*' 1 ziljl.i CI "K-1, 1.-Qd,.

iiL -1 ;>G\ V) ,a'rIgri--" wfsLj LSLI)-itll ^DL,!V >1 JW1j,F11.FRA FL->i_:l v *2 l

ef-i I_ UI ,s.Y LI itl 5 i1,ss1zl I i MLi'9 ce- LC 1j;iJ- LicjLILfC-j'il L>Wl J5 51;ULII

. vk5 .z- (Ls(Al 1-11 C.U'il -(AGROASENE, ANAGSA _jL& &=--

, m c . - 1 , 1 .P - °I .-.T - .;. .Ii , : , , , . U & ; J l '

TV ~~I 3OI, c~J *J

44ij L,111I E&iidL aJ.-II vI Ji.l ZL1 ..I .L I L9-1

.Adam, Graham and Von Pischke) J lA I1a =I - 1 i1 JJ l 1k J,1fl

.L .,IW ,L,: DIJ 1 .A£ 1Gonzalez-Vegaj ,LiJlA a3j ,JIcj "I. 4:61l W 6 6Z

UAJ L) p4fI J S4I lil ; ~J1I SL I1 I j t i .ii *Ji1

V ,LI t L 1, , l.7111.1.fiC,..oU, 31 ,J C.@ II iLl 45> 1I,lzl 0

l cetol L,6 -ijJl_4 1 j - .A L L l I.I

*.JI~ iitll UL. i l;L, yi~11 ,l1 ~,; JUILj'l . dIiI UI Y lll JL I .

0A SjI 1 JI ¢lII L . ¢l 1 I l ; YI Ij l LLI .6. J lJ

J ' I C4- , cL41 L.Zj 1 I - L I - 1 J LjG51 V V53 ~~~~~~,..I > -I WiLIv -l jj, ifEg|Xe L Y ;LitlilL14\S.1

V4,Y J1 iI; 4.;511 21 LUi ,FILI J5i'T 9 L~ I ~a U ' .41 ialUI d,lY

.4l 3.gG 4Lz }2t lzQd,Sjl iUis.113~Ylil L

ZL. I- ZA I W1U"5t.11l L.U.cpa JI I3' UiZ .~I 3JL± -L~3I J

'So .(at.Chaves and Sanchez) 4s Li ,o 4i Li ,,U ui aLaW Lf. Li iU i V J

Zlif Li o Z.1L l,L) i U1_ --Li -L Z Z-I1 Zs;l c .LJ t,;- L+l II -i1 1L . Lt-;.:! Hi 1

ELSv ... °1es-ZUILf> ZA 1.sLl;iJ V -L

J1 -JY, Y llJii.;LsrY,* a Ui - *L - ;i ,SL. ASJj

>Lil J,17jl YI ;-LC4 1S sloG-iY *1z l Z= aAZA 1fi1se1 ;L; 6- <eiv

JiL - 11 ,1 YI as ''Y 2 vjli Lif-Ik!. C7 o>-,y g La.

)W;ItI "JS- l QLL ; r Lj *l a t tul1L y ,r

.(J=l jL:Jl -LI1KS) 41 -u, Yt.Z ,s ; aL- G I Ut>) fAC

R- ; .L S ZU|^; 4,jl ij 1) ,LL-L -S15;11.3kyl r .-- V; 1_ QJL U,#9

J-QI L,.; L I iii S9 I LAI I_, .---I .JL J.

. 1 sAo.Chavesand Sanchez /" Li- I~,-1 c,, l *,tWI Z,.s 1.1 ;LLI Li TV ,i

VA

cw-Lal i 4 - %'A Noggel) d;. Lh 31W GL'i iL1 J~IL4,icILV j

'f I ->l1 j , Ui

IL-z. -- :.S *( -^£ ,,i ) 1 L- LI UI I 1I 1 o.& * $ Ivl

* (5Af .Cuevas and Graham) v>-; L~.UX oLaS. I.,1,. 4 !Ui L,j_,l

L,ILLI t 4 Litl - lz , ;; i Vi CllI JaA 1

,Levine) I JLa 'UL I d YlLa,:ayI , 4-

"LLL. l-9 ;a g. i. U cI-5 -.*4w 4X - o tL Csil.

.g LoALlI 5s -1911i .li 51 .. ^L L'L L.54 . lT

I1 Lz i _,I. 1;11 tlj,.al JSL ; t ZLL2I*A1

t9tIW 1 v a':' I 'J A.gl V-`V

V i Z JUX I ZLL ll c L- -i Y.l ,J1 L-l -, I >1 ' l -IjV-

IUIAiI -, W L; ,41 I j,L .YI -TjA V l~

*4 * 9-W1CJILI I te,I ,. .l .o-:lD::It- 5=

1,J 1 J dl I &- Li I. .L LI ,JI .+.. Lil) ,)i 1

d X iS -I _.,I jk I ,JI i L ,1UWI >Z

I cLtI Cw-yiil cLjvI lWl II :"41L jljL - . i Lu UJfL; .

LIA -. Il :a l D' IX JI I - -:'t L2 Vl i1 VLi,YI

.4:;j 1.Ul ;Lll siULL II_ ; I; !-.sf.X ;L;L 1.2. *-jI 9

g1 >u1 J &1 JAw a I

iLlS AL. I iil -Ii .=II iI L'yl.0 JU.L 8s-.tll, 1 3 .

*,+5 A =.O1b&;JI >° Besley ^-ske .:JI ;JI, |aI;;tH1L

Z,. L a ,q: LLL ~ -f ; &a _s P; (1) UALI Jl.L F

- ' -- _w1< yL t I - j

ZcL,f;l j l d YI L C.1_Lt I &L* * (\1 -5j.tl _,[l A-~ iJ L# . J l rL.,-Jj -; ^ -l jtoL LI il r ;^ lWi

,'YI IL Lrt LX _j I~ s,=

z5 ,L& I LA 1i cll liveil,Ll

(31 L+il 9A.lll 4wl; si"15i ;4 4

Z~~*; Lv1 î -L Kz I ; L;LA 5Sr Z6 Lj I1

v-^

o;Li 5k15 L 4- L- *Z ^1 er * J. 5 6_1-r 1 i~Llj jLi5L 4^'' 'Î Vi t9iLd

T~ iS .L P 7; i i 4.4 j IjL z - a -rk bJ_<i l ZL , 7=Li L-g .,31,i l aq1 !U

L+.; L5SI *vJIi ,- AI as t:oJl J Yl L{(&1 ;1), ylUJ fjinf l La jtt

d 3fi aq5LL,:I ZA - i tLJ1j . -1 I'4y . g LL

jL5JI) L+.. iZSUf ;LLgJJ_L _ 1OJI<,SLiLY'i{Ovi1

rLL 5-Y L&YI _, LI v L -i 3 1,9 . (r)Y- ,; I %3il A~ 5Jl , f YI 1L-59li

J-,-; A_ L'} j121 ZILLAIj EX4L) iilA J- -s* lSil ili> JAI UAI,' I.

*JLZYI z4rLlm; Z;L t- ,SiJ,) jrl J.PKioSZ IYI

.Jjj>J1^L,~ * °1l,LQ1Lle LL I-. ,< .~I;Lj

.t ( J Jzw ,LI el *L

e. Lili JiUlI , L I * l jl i L

4,s. -I4J ~L¢s I jjLL J<J1 ;21i .i; bL- 1II .l. L *,>JI .2 0 ~ . 2 1 ~~,b, u.in~, j~i...............

*(LlJI'I;,J,)iJI,,S (ail" L1 t1j ,110;>.

c.LLj I 0

e<-1;LLA JU sok w ~ 93 )jllJI e * >11 ;iL;I ,^ js~ [.L1 J&iJ

*L L~) i1.LiVI y eLdL 11 slril ;I,LI J t *sL>I *Jll *>;1 * k~JoLA

1,; 1I LV± *,91 Li;;J *,^ - 11 VLYJ,ljltULLI YIi ; )]

.sLL *I Z-( I o l L( I I

SJiJra~~~~~~~~ ,1 IJ L JI<II :LL LStl :!*;1I o/l ;:tL1 *f YI L, J(£l~Y

1 "- ;J ;l >1. 1 (j LAI 1 LIjL1 ILii -

.iI j1 UI I Ji -L UW l * oIJIaS4IYYl ;tzQL I0I U s iLu I 3ill JI okiU e ; s LL I , 1j,YZJI I, 0

-JI Z'LL/LI, jj-Y -Jt (L~ -- ,/1 U.il -1

U 1 1 J9..;. ; .j .LtI 11 El; I

.uL, Il j tL; LSl 4I ;L-U jul LJIjl ;ILI ; 1 e*u z1 .,L.fjI 5 s EU ,SIZR Si ZJ L1 ,Ll JI OI

o , i "J)' ; .i,I -l :- J * Ui oi ;U. L U J .L. L i

I;,li ,; Jul .) I W L.11 Jui - :e .;-4 J IS1 JI ,- SUI ;J, ii > 1 JLL... *t

I , , ~ ~ai jui -j o r4ji LL.... * 1 .i cL1 ; l --..

$ i

o.IJ ,, *,11I vI.L.ILiD

L- j;~ p t ,JIWU " ;L.i!.LS-I ~ .. f J ~ ~c LJ ~ I.1 s hI .. I

U:ti, ~iJ ;- L.64 U . lJD g1I ,L..1 * .LIYI lrL ... v; .isl LiWI,SiSA1 *

LA l - Ii l L,k; Lii91u ;11J -A-', Si w c _;L

S, Zl U_j.J,. J-L IJ L. 0ULc -lI eLa1.I J U Il - ;J .al 3I 0UI 0 .- -Il .

.LXu i I Z Jii

( :1U 4 i! L U;t ,,i

-

1,.U5 ,1III1 UI o : 4l ,,-1 -:1

* a,S, , i -

-,L--:'I zt~f Z4L.- IA-- Z.UI W. J L.t. ;jIU3 _,ti * 64.1 L4AUI. CzL~jl, L- LI ZI J4:,iI .J

,-,,;l a,w; I Loa

l ,lSJa9 . : a

1, i-l ti ,1 _ Wl jU- Z.LkLJ

*i (;L , ,, ., W I -1 -i{;,Uil Z )

; ;,1.1 , d 1, i LI c -P LaJi

* ~ ~ ~ ~ ;,) a,-I 1 1 il Iy

aLUI ZLL' -JL -1 <. U1 L J0 U , 1 . I i-YI 1 * L. 1 l >I WL=L A1 Y AL Lo , ULiS

;.,. IF LA1 XIH

I _I; I iLII L L .4Li UL A J, IjI; I I

.jl I jLi i.;I, L IUI -. itl

Vf , 1 ut *141 ,k,1 ;I oi;t1 l , ;:l * l9J *r-;As Ji ,S--;%4SEJyl *6-1 -"fis>l aej

A gj

.Li, IY I

- iSJ j: GUI -yc i= L,.- y J- ,-

.;L L-I21* U'J J e f I ,J J.& (.d11II J-.ll) S -- s i.jl J1 , l WJt;& .J

Z - Zc ;, x k : i l

I~ ~ jo,ijy Zwl .* t. t , -Y

UI okLi o .W.lI CWI * .; l ; Li . * - lV J6L414. -

JUW ~~Ii & 4,U ;t~lMoIJ t * IYYIk L :Jliil e * J YI AIe 3iJjll -._l

~0*0NU .f. j :,M I .. ,Ij. I J.....j -e k#Ulli .s- l :'.-...I lZJUIlei•

-- 5 J .I4 I jjjIyIe IL

2-5 - ' J- Z US ; .L-2 v .. L: . ~~ ^ ALiL - J s 4, V L - ~vi

LS~. va t 3IJi > V L, oU -;- Lf JUf v,-t

zoI - - H iIo~f~ LS1 h . LI U.i i UW s tS .L i

1.j 5; Z,7 ,;t tL-L-> t.(=\ Besley) W JJ-,&

- '1 4Uhi IJI LI Uhf : l. ,,i'YI.. ) 3 u- -j JIJ e) I o LE 1: ^ - ^ L M. LZ

o;5 L-X - ! ULt+ll.......... :-.(u,,

Lie 1,2Lr J,-* ,A L-

(-LYI Li L-, JiLL ±.f1 -.1 LwLL1 I 1, -L

.;.L.#VI L: ic J L.t j~ l j,i ;L-:l I iJ ;s>' I J UI ii]-e^ - J c51 E -

(J l *UIL I~ Li 7ILLI 1 LJLU UA. I 6Z.LRashid andj (%SA ) Udry La1_-, all:Ion 1 -. Y \)+ , s l

_,,-i Xl &r Vt-7 -I (8gAE) Townsend LJUI JA S3J-I1 Jasl JUI ,3L9,Yl J. -

,J ,I Lil U ; >11.if 5iS LULUI 'i U

L I a r * . c I L i jYI ZU I iJI WiI I 1-1 YvJ

J s5 j9G Lj v _,Av' 1 J- - u Y 1 i:l I

Le i sJ' 3el l. i IL, eJ l- ^ LeJ l(Y Li L f .: u -I

1u 11 -. ' -L.J 1j w Z1 1 X,- -t

J 1-1-:Y -. 9j . ,i ,1 ; 1.ii-I>5 Z- 1 JUI DL- y. jIv L

ZO j&L ?-L:JL.l i j-' ;,tt IL i '-; L L

a1.I s lki (\t) Hettige and Steel -.j

,,>i (Wq%r) Binswagner and Rosenzweiga U ------ LA ,>oil l~,>:Yo

JLIJ Ulial.. -êb4!; t1i l .:,; ̂ -I; LWfj.JA'=0 u;f 'LLI Lz:LL II

-L Li# y^Y<s-1 -il -- 1; 1 .1s1tLL;l,;LI -,!All*0

sE,;,Ly41 L-Lu 4;oLuj J.UllS4i tu8Q 5 5 _o1Z -

JLIAJ I5 L o1i *|.z-sIj I- -6j I L. >tl^ Ij :UL;SI, >M4;11iillJ *-- 0V-,11 J

149,LP-1 J-1- WL !.L ;a#Z L;Li Z, L, "G~° I Luyf 6"Sl-JLj ja

SS141L'i; l QL-ijL ::,>J v'4,- ,;,.W;I :-

te^ :l;jh: .E1,43 -;LI- L.:. I e,6 'ou",s, 1 ,L I 1,

4 >L iSS ZâL;jl 3L Jy L'I JL'S Z<a-s5l "Fous" , ;

(J'IL4ILLL)JLA . .t^Y ;;11 iLi s LLJ LLa; SII .Mhii -.;lhta

_ *1 Z4 Jg {. j I t 9 _Yl I _j A^ am e -

XsBottIomley) o:-fL liStL z a."- IJi L a,;u1v -tl "&: -a ,-Jy vcl;

osL-;^Lt *tl iJI -1sS ^JL-~ [s11 J.5SD -J- J12l-;ll\\£RahdnTwn

*G!I.YCj , J; K>tls -L;-v): 4)1,LI j L5 *, ww'olbrkogthrl/cgp/ ,,lap.h9l

*,W L.SZ j6CLU-I (sjLz-IV 1 C tVUl =I ,L;S, JL- Mohn Ma lhotra

.51, ----- L:~L1 JU I 3LLUF I 4HLi51 S. LLV; C, I V LR5 j I t,- -,L1

-31 iiYl -,JL£ I, _1,I l..i t i.jl *:I ,:i4ilI & t Lzil(j |

Z45 IL , = L" I * Z1 aLI isij LeJI lI OL; ILa jS[. J.L Ll jJ VL -I 5I

L,! ;ltYj.JLI 3L",:l I vs- 1>^^ 11 1e.;1 I .t^>g 1 >:M .1- J L jL ; ,Xls9I &1-(\. ,1A tIr,J;-

4,1114.4 1vi LJA.I va.4I Jail '- ,- I _Ail

___ £i LJII 4 J c,t-L. **ol ZJiI5 %JIL- tJL11 J ZJ L LcA4; JIt

Ix.Z1 I JLI:t oLL o JLY-, Z" 1& :l;w o L- !:?.j t. JLll 1 l-. [! LiI,>oLLxII

~~~vclY JLl LfijI J.IJ iI LI ol -.. Ll46 ~I~ il 451UI t .lil *i J. r,e

_I7 _J1jilL 8 X J > ( i es7 1 1^ xee i #;XA1 ZI-1-4 1 r-L?; *c J J- 7a -i f1 J

I.A LL -;-WI I_J I _- -C M*Ia I ,+--J I :L;fI tl7;.j;lvll~

,, - I- 4 16t u-x~ 0-Y,1, | &-e,G11 ol -W:1 1w .qjUI ojlf.L

t+âtl v a * ~~~~~UI f -L I ;-1-11 L;t:w*ii iLl Z41U 1 * * :Wl t ;II<5

:,- ; i cI; 0 tYI o_- - -i o jY

.iJUIL.J oll ok 0;v

:

QYI II _ L.i 3ij, Jc 3I, i jL-i * i -: L; byi LL ii Li (A * .-

t,1j-.6 4 .-J Z GI QL*j;J i- L -_I Li

j.-aj ..> I oy L.'Ylo jI.=J1

.~ 8I.Bennett, Cuevas and Yaron :Y..I YJ.; L.4>c,; L vO. 1

I t.-. 1 1 I L-i.'i L I 1i g--A 4IL I .L-" 1 ;L Jl j -. It

* I ."-' -I.- - -

L31j-:'JI~~~ig LiJ QrLi; J1 JIl &1,UI jl,= 11 -A~k LrqIYSL-ie J I~ 5 E)J Beleyi Z.JI jL I i I UI U LI 1 L..L.L3 .I L-i L< ~J I J1,U1 I ,j I

IL 1-. iLh S -; vi -I LI Jl e I i, I L I ._J.s 45u IJ L I - L

v I.t5i Bely ;U . DLJ SVL1 ;L:l 53i i LUI EJI;II¢iLSI p9Lta ,=.LII J;,ll1 .J1; Lj V L .I'I S V 3I JLi 4u2L9 7 IL- I 5 l,YI Jll e J e1 I z I 1

Greenwl and) ZVL; I ~LJ, . I 1 I k jc-if JIl -V Î L'.; Vi LI - .

J1 aLV Zit1 Z-., iJUI z.nI ~ - I'JYIX ift ,l;.I IY 'LJLS:II ;alUIo t s -_ vt I ;ssi

L5 X-' 1* L-',: t l Li, < s c YS 1 J] -eL-; I =.. rj ; UJ I I | ;JiL>-9 4 I >

OLI : L-iA L ̂-=I;Itlt 5D 2[J >tt4jU 11j L,I-?IJZ(4W1l ->11

ijla] ,kLFÎz -LL-Jl 7,J (W)l YL2 -6- q-Lz-1 IJ vW DlS

2'L vvi 1 1 V.-4W Jla<J:~-! I I I jj_J

L+S - I jJ il Jz V 1a1 YI d z Y4, L-ti,~L ILN-a-: ;i

Greenwsald and) lz. Yletilit 1j I ,1- IS FLj1 lI,6 L- L.11 I............ .1 .y Il5 Cv-,°5

1;;.vi L31u-"J L-^, yilUI,IY lS(4i,Stiolitz *I 3LIz d -L- ,-_.............. b>iLis-vWX;II

.bJI f_s ,,el->llo >i -Ljz (-

;1) JA0 oG6 ,; C,-Li .(a-4 1 4L 1-11). .^ j§L1 ao gu I

.d- *cSij ^ I gu:l J:Lj J1i.AP (").a Lu L-

-- > ;lo I Jgt;l i ;I ~b -L,.c*l; ,<,L.

:f<;;l, l,.:- Li;e5tl dXL-a L-WI _o_ C-=11 ;- ZAkiY, ~ I ;jLL. 19;;. I v° 4L,1 1 I L& -f_ -i -

X~~~~W L4J U*J -- 1< < IR J;LU VAOU L tlX +-1;1 "L.S;K)=M L;I

.A=t,, L.l UL,> j 'V1 I-1 I 1CL. - Li &U Z61L- ,Q /2 / -uk -- - -

Y - J M l J SSL * IL IS (~~AU_et)-?HJJJ I S l IIV

aSDe LL- @J sel*- VDSJL O<gJ( I ID4;LDi F4J I ZS Lb J( -

' ai -;_,6z.'1 cklf L,.1=,I J;1 Aj1

,L 1&l;y ii Ij -J.; UI

, eL; JzzL f )1u j L,, S ioLI u1J= ;S 5:- L* l«c olI.N l 5 L-J(lsl SglL

-1"- lisLL 04$ l7,S(5£Bse^^

O O~~~~,.,,L4Jll it1;io e I,Y s LLI *Iylvo -l; * -I I X b7 L ;. L.S .B1

L ._li. vlr sL~iL J 6;Y 1. ,, -y 4uG.- e S91 YSI -14 L!- I :..1ol

A ~L 1.F J 1 Ie V *- J 6aW ,i ;L~ I j L:. &U la SA :oI5 JI L5 .O ^_ 1 oS I J .( O,, IDIi tj-i-1-

F ;J Liu Js t.,L J=l J_4!J I1 :,L. K

L3= E.AUI DUi coLqI ,Lk J,,.l &^1n Z,2 * ). VU.Besley :

-ISCl~ .t.JJL ,J, ;-. Li.I f.3l 1 SLi1 ;Jb=;; |;.k .. JI ~::** r, JLU;I

u- JWIJ Ls I .tLi W .LLJI * -:iL;

1y1JN ol ~~Uslj .i5 JIjL( kLgl -/Lj iI i JI,SV .LIIc,L :L;A

jL:Lf "i- l~) kerof .!=jiI UI (W Cj v I JAi I oIiII 1;11 V I II I .1L

L-i cLl U V ULI .iVi &U JIL, IC1 f-tI¢ j;iLo -; 1 JI. ; Z_klill J:lw i -AJ9l j 11 LIl

A U = i i Ll4•JA. L-L.,.. Y JCi J .i I .E l UzVI3

;51. -- I --- V z, L~ d .-. .1 .bluI 3 -11 I ,, 4.jlml,-1 eL; AI oLll.± J .,..YI J;lJ

4~~~ LlI JI LJ1UI jll^1SSLIIH OL J.lRE > lo.- ?wl^

I;I Yl Z AI 1- * .1 JL JI ,, i I I YJ *Z;LL, 1 5L I < f - 1UDI 1 * I

K JI LLL U 4j ,II ;1Z L9A , 4, L __ I09

IJ 5L ~ V=L J ~ I ~I~ UJl * g * S I JL Y I ; 5J _,_ _,_L_ _ _ _ _ I I_ _ _ _

J L 5 ..I SUD V4 , d LV L .t. OI, Y ,•I 'i= SI ULi CA

L- 'Yl , S L, .1 d J I I,II )L L21 I UAl.U _I sL

; -~~~~~~z-, V 2I V U*Ll I d4-I ̂ - IJ -7... . ......... , " L,~

Q J g ULAJ I L-AX* l aVY : ^JI 1d jJ Z:tL) J I<: J cO

La I ) l F1 iU Vi L L; J I J 1 Eli c,--I I ;6 ,J l d j L I- . Z# er ll t1; cU I ,I

t1L.; i sl ;d- j LC I Z, < lrrS= I)

b_:jI f i-CI "L -J= L;2I.j UCI U V- L...... t i. S

C,, & -LJ- I vk L,; -t & 1 JI L- v 7i L+al I7 U VL .9 L .

J-"~~,X tz-1 r4;5tJ Lv" -,- I U I _w L< , tS

;SL,Il g I Li vLI Idt lj-:', dfI J M I jL-YOLI ,L J I L '

VNv lJ LIJ A V irmt ani ( -. LLII If t-J) 1(-r- JI ) .3i O9 f# 'J L -

,1,^'",. § L !,j,1 -1 X* L i 11

jlL-1L L.LL,iJ=I j11a;1 1 L" -1 ll yi) +-aSg -. a1 ZkIYI :,a ULIL

t iUlj d= L21> ( - ' $ IY LZIj U l= j> - L-m21Y

WuI 1A ~,,sf ,p J/; 1.t1 i I Li t=i 6" =l C ,: L6

*4- 4 1-Ui:: I vf- ;-Yl "i Lg i LJUI

JL:IyJl L i -' V1~ * cLbS

_ j- ; O ZJSJI J ;i-;@ L'i J-~ JUA ifIIy a .0 Uy 1. I.y -Z Ine;|

QG--a,3L *-r .1 91)1 LjL,.aat ,6 , t7iil J i. - *11 j ;--t

t L ,,,LI SI-1 Ui JL.ll Z&WI J"i, d Z-,-tlf LL:,Jl 1.~ lj ZL:YlI L 45

-a - lyy, ,L3 -: Z.4.J- 11 >6u1 .^-;L La lt 1j ;11

j3 . l1+,y|CllZG2. *. >ul l4ztl,ll *U al-j *~j U6 JSl. j's .- ,WI ;1I i>LWI -.a I

.k S ;L.>1 _,WI s?v9 Lak. '.c 1_,-,,Yi *(L Jl. I ;;I) I JbIJ*IJIl

sLlSI Jl SL J :LpjLII A l,iL; 'i t7sul *.j Xi *da Si )-U;i.eIL--1. 1 I

Nf|Gl YIf*-Q,3SJS1 Z Yl j1fi: d . t I 0

-; JI. j!j.sL3 'J a - , I di d iU<-;. > M§fL2L .

ss~ +1-L 1Y cI>il tll ,;Ii SY ar1o qi JI vil "i lj GLI I JLA XI

.1j.

ij/ (1 -a4wi wti- /x

Qv ;;9 -gLIL 'I - 4 | 1 4 --lsJEU YI f JI

t ~ , UI si .1 LPlA - ;JU= a ',< -s. 1vllHt

L' Z-S{4 sI -L 11 -:l .J.J iLL I I5 JU I LIYI> i 191 - . 13 JDS eI J- II-

. ( 1 £ .Besley) oL.LJ I JL,. LiLL J!iu l Yv vi u j f ji:1U 1.2YIJJ>et 1 1 'SG!'I ? IIYJil

',~~~~~ Eljt-E

i~~~ ~ ~ ~ iC L\8X j

tE: E'kt

E| s t

_

/tA X XC

~L. .

Co:

l-C L-

'Q6. C,_

El Co

-'~ ~- .C,~ep

s:~

F _

,L.I .. 5s¢f1 j &J13 L11 i. - . I .k6J J"V C7U- cLL exkd1jIAWJ 1 Lll

, ;jkasIull f.11u ~ Ji <9 oI - la s;l;ill J1,;1 Y1 sU ,Jull ilili

.i;Us, U61 - ,v Ii- | ,l.^ ^j Wclt

ZA; li 5I e i , I-Gts 0 >I J. VLLI Jc I

vc;I L Wfi .ILJc if i - L ?% 5J +IA ?L; ZL+L; Y4,:J1 t vI K 9T>iitl os ol .Li 1;H .:U I l J a S

45L;41J-Lid?t@15 "i J J51-I |*Y ¢JL Ll-Z'4L -7 l49>YJ=YI x&+. I

*I*- t1O ,Y Ifitl Z- Vig ^ ; -6 I -3 L,1i sU=

L L: LJil c;l.l lS L' - a Yj,LI ,Lj; Al o Yl.a1:JULI.t- ;tiuL;LjMbLI3 I~ I"L,

C7,15 L- L>yL .ys*s Zf J

;5S; . SS AYI RXT1; Ob I3YI > e(N lklS ) Mole LaI,S; * lj dul,eJl*C2 ;

s C(7bO ose sl>test ,- 1 _ * 0s6

C,- 61 Ld;-'L, 2 J_,IO . VB;I ,-,^;'jf111XVLY dpl -IY

d-* X4jd l;ll,-#L S V;I j L, , -a* ;*t1oIYIVYl

°.) HjjLI l jS6; 1 lI .3.A... . ......... -l jLI , X-I _,, I L. j &- ug : S

V C L 7O14 L;-S iLÆOS EaLJ ,*r ,1 QL' i C

Xj,lmg lLfi aLs a l; tl OkI9YI m l asYI 1H1A° ,S U.J JIl ^ -J

*l U IjLx. ]_@ I WVA I LLJ I Z| 91&' -b-l I d, LA ;" AI L 1 i - Lat. -* |!

Lr4 1-9 L%tw IU 1 Ij ALIVI I Z.i=I 4 Z....J . )tLI ZLa I dL rl a ,t I U IIJIcI ; 9 S - I

13> I- LSIJI I ~ J JLiJ * d GU .. 1) ~3LLI M GU ~Lj1•19iI 4 .......................

L;Jz- .lj ULI. dL I &L L=Y I.A LiL a J aI -LU L qJI d;ii,gJ>llaAo ;11~ C+JJl Ua> L;Jlitesl;= I -ii j,4: I

- I ;lI d L 5 1 U.; - L-;..V I GLLI J..A. F 1j ( )YIAs -I Z, L: LP " -III oL-iL< !=J1 .:I5; C ;1 e

;9DAj IJ I. cl 610 (Lij O Lx - .... L .:! & VIl1 -L ;5dL~ I JLl;3J j^ 1

L L3~~~~5-2 S -I JiXlO 1LJ9aIj :Lul ,,, -- J * ; jl.l 454i ijt. 9,'

;5I - I: I I 5.a | I 4 J d fi - - U;l_ I ;.L iL|

'q - L.L d ZLLUJI ZIZLJ;. -L-,ll a 1 A Q I l ;A-,l U;ZLYI .LS;l I5 L+ .Lt L,.W; :J l 2S¢)I,L ;Y

:eal"WlL sL ;i LL*fLJl Z-llll;l t3UIji'l

Lv1 s3 I L U1 Aill I C-.- I I I aA@

VS_L *1 4 %.ii aILj. J.-... ? _,1 ;-6 YI_ I.J I Ad .1 1 =C I v ;&I I

L,;I ;= * ;LIJ * U V l; _7IL Yr pLj Lis ̂ .jjr LL V-;I

S1L.,4y - ;XD VLAl Z1. LA LL-i V 1 j L+L L1:, L.............. ..- 1;i SI aVL! I5 :.VJ I1 &Al

*¢'i9 ;PI L Le. j. &cff a, GVA lL A )1 v1 IV

J_JljtA V V?VS'1_ :LE SM ,J5,,il :-i 41U :J C ,-1 IJULSKr- f§ 6.I~ Vd l L; ~.IJl J*L {; J I U - L4 JVSL V~a ,VR9 L..I.iI {V1. ;;DI L.~

* ( t;LL) Z , I S j 1 J C JjS I -- ,.di ;& :'j j.J .i V IJ J 3lL

L- , L-; L jJ eJ WI -AI vfl H -dw i- J J * Sj "

!, LA -,c USK I 'bnL J ;1 _. IL a, * *-.4 5 :5 ; S 1 jJI {JI-; L- L ji: L .F?14 L- _IJ -UJ; -t;

,vl .~ Jt- JJ2 ' 1" vI:v vAvl,"T l

tU)J J 2-11V.9 U V, 5CIJDJLI{AI L*L

BEl,61I VJI IJL Li d^St IIVYi O4II 11 O1 AL. t

LL-LL~~~~~~L I OWSI I O,51ÆSa, I . C lJiA Ia L;- V y I1

-- = la L,.ji.t _Lj -=Jx -e,LY " tU >1MGI jIY

QL Ij -;L VL 1 Ddgz 1 LU I L,. 1~ c1 *U 1 1 UI j_+I. kY. 4~ I d G IJ d, -

J +J JC WIJ j9lU ^1eLSI L 1

C.Jl UA ^ mAa

ACB Agricultural Credit Bank of Bana;ica UQ)llWrll L6 dBAAC Bank for Agriculture and Agricultural Cooperatives (Thailand) (;Lt) 1 ,i cU,,LWb1 -I,, I ;-BIS Bank for International Settlements Q4J)l cL.II )BKK Badan Kredit Kecamatan Wt I Z.BRI Bank Rakyat IndonesiaBRI-DU Bank Rakyat Indonesia-Unit Desa esII (Q,,i) 1 I - faVY I *I - 1bCGAP Consultative Group to Assist the Poorest L.. Z.i11 i ;.1% LY.L e lDFI development finance institution ifLLEBRD European Bank for Reconstruction and Development ; :L±LI ,±'I zu IERR economic rate of return Lj;iL YI 11JI J.UL.ESW economic and sector work LlLill, <LJYI JlIFl financial intermediary JLiL,FIL financial intermediary loan LI Il,iFRR financial rate of return LU II J*FSD Financial Sector Development Department, World Bank ,Jb.,ill IJI.Jl ,. J . 1GAAP generally accepted accounting principles 4* k4ItII "WI jL...GATT General Agreeement on Tariffs and Trade i l li 1 c -Lkl 'I WI LIGB Grarneen Bank (Bangladesh)GDP gross domestic product I flilI L IIDB Inter-American Development Bank lYJ d.!4 ;l -LIFAD Intemational Fund for Agricultural Development aILI L.l 1 lIMF Intemational Monetary Fund ,J alUi; .IREQ intemal rate of return on investor's equity -L.1 ;..L. ,1 l AlWI Jix..MIS management information systems (cL.jktU *,I.dI j i) DIJYI tL 3 iNGO nongovernmental organization (Ua) . e. :OECD Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development i I. LjpL. l l L;: "OED Operations Evaluation Department, World Bank ,11 :I;JI ,U1 1PSD Private Sector Development Department, World Bank -,,liI .vlJl Jl Ll1 SjIzRFI rural financial institution L.RFM rural financial market I L'I IL ,iROA return on assets (v..YI v oIJI) LI 1ROE return on equity I LA a £t.JIROSCAs rotating savings and credit associations , l A

SACI specialized agricultural credit institution * . ...... fSAL structural adjustment loan , o v

SBP Sustainable Banking with the Poor cidl jl LLi LSi UIAbU L.WI ,itI J..J iSDI subsidy dependence index I 1 k ISECAL sectoral adjustment loanSLA savings and loan associations ,L I- j L.XY I =JTAL technical assistance loan 0:a a ...TSE transitional socialist economy j11I ,l I,I J_,] I _k - e j I_I jL.1IWWB Women's World Banking i1 Ji I i CL-W I ;U:il iZaWI 1l L i;LLll iJUI iLl-l j-i -. 4.Û 11sE -o UI;- 1i 5I^

L- I Zd jg.- -J -il s1; L<ill YI4JjiL.S -,=L U -;1 1 1i-*S I pS

L ;.L3 1 * -a s) o - 51 ,llsi iI;jr9 L- Âtwl jLIYj V L, LUI -tWFI o LIH J

L4 *JL-.l lvo,SIIA >Js , 1;.,, i. -L- I j= ^l LlJi ZJLLI)dl LIGIo

L; U Izl O, L- =~ I L; I I ;VD Z± (!L I. L 9;^j X45O5;

L' H-1 v-L 4--- L- 51 OIJ I4a1 - a,6' 1 .,lJl I LJi~-l I LLq VI I1 Q-;.lI

4L+-i. 3jLLaIi ilsl ZLi JUI JL-I0 llj LJ,

a V r L~ I }1<SJ L I>d-|

VJ-74#fl ;2 Ji l S u.XDX1GJ ,;A4 - oLll -i (f i I( LL-

Sll Dl31 . -11 ,l - S _ l J .I Li, Z lAL o I L- L -o2 -(,TULY 1g

: o L- Y_J -A; 21ET J S L1-La Le1 V$9; :Ll t;L. du LI JL-

*dIJLL ; ,j<i2 dI... 1tLJYI~G U; 4 ;L,UI

4sA L-U.- sIJA ;---L5 J., 1 L 1, - u V I VZa_JJ . Jl c.LJj ~ y UIl LLW ZAU ,i ,iJ I LI- J, W +4

iWL-il I J I1I ;iy U- .U9L ; J . 1 il ) il O. .^

~~~~. LW~I .LIJl 1-i -i sjXJ *S A *tUil Lfl W.il OvJ3;

jt1J~I L l~ 4-LI Ua_LI *L 1^ - 1ul ^-eStl ULLIL 2LU.? ll .±Jl Jl 3

I 141 L JL2 .ii :21 .Lj -X Gs,l G,1 91 , *l ZI;Z ZLU 1 aZL;lLlJL L VI j., 3 -L.i QlI 3 L1

- 4~II~~~Jj&~v -v 3L j L .ii] LAli li, ~ ~ J~~.I

OL EAl I C ;LjI 4 1,,LL Lll2 ', IX _,aJ IYl ^ I15U.-. 4S21 O LdUIJ ) I;

L Lb ;,f9 lUI g51,% c, -e ,:i; -g11 1

g1k ji L. L-i j,I.W Ylcll

Z 4#i.-a S L ; -. 1 WJ1 _;6V4 J AYI 1S9 S A; LIUI ;JLL*_ 1 --,Q

L;l - -L 1 1z;L1 l -. lSJI -fl I -* L t

41 l -I ' -1 LLLaI t•llI 1.l kZ U - --YfL Il -lLL1

a I Z L, :;II Z ; L; 3l.-..t.]1,iY tt

L (L:Y L IJI>J L L - IJ~ OL 1-) 1 .I i:-

L5j ol L 1 1 1 7 j1 'IJ ̂ I - OiUI ZLLII ,9 4S1 Ji L_jI >>11X

U= eZ II^Y Ii4l *I Y Zs _93 L;l 1 IIA .g1au

(+;SIJ ;l) Sl s~~~LLI,1 fi Z11 jLll k LRj_Jll coLS-Sd -JS

<5I : 1 ( LL L I L,5i .>L*:llv a J L= IJLIJ i-;LoL

j,1, .Jlll laA -s,L iL= L,i v- I .Q11 Ul I L-,, iLI

31flU S V d.^ AI L. LS SLF=I 415JI

zl.sL .ol L L-Zj1 9 i^J;I ALJ^_YI- LI S ;I 7,Lj,LUDI w i;Jll -ALX 4J]

OLZI Jeli=;l ^ I ,J - ;V j L. U1 -ZJW"*^ 3vL OJIJ-L,~ JI :C9Wf

ZL! xl I L; L- 1 -U (Li;_DI,LJ1 LI IJ ;Ol J~ L<z I= Z- u) 1 I^ a9g L

.b1 ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~' IjJ.II..1 1,jLI*4 §iS

-,..~. j3 l -I 14, zL I ~ ~z %Ai.J l 6-VI ...II, . T L,2J ,*

_;L L4..LI L I AI L LJi•"L L L-1rVI JL1 JUI;1 U'L1 J IL

LJI JL:.A o>l L,1-t L,;,3 ",x,-. l k=.l L LeA ,I. * eLj Y l *1 1 U Li1

JL 1

(s~.jL .;:i;Y Li I L. L ii *A ; , , Li -.~, :,xLu ilal ju s vyL I L u il V U1;UI LIJ~

JL -:- 1j ;5 41 lil l JL16-11 Z3CIA - *: t .jJ Xil jJ*il LJ

i z_9:3_ ;;.LI LFLl L J-A a lU.. (products)

-S L;J i - -LA L. l--, -, I I tl-'ji I Z Ll - , I i Yt

_U" ll I j l I L9VI ll Lk, j lL 1i - i 1I ULLII .1 I ^ Yl

L A I ;i 3 1 j±ll, aug Ja lI U ' 1 VA L| * - .J * ?6q i iU L IJ I 9 i

J3l) L.I 'L Y IJ VL- LI iL EA 1

~~~~~IIL%S ,* UW1~4 Iij ~ * Li LA ,,~~Ji~:J 4 L~

;3 Li:-II i I I_Jl PI IL. U"J I CIAL; Ij * 7Z1aU.l LI I jlU " ,e1

.f;1 J,LI B F.I -,L IM ,kX1 jW J.-e U" J( A 5i .L t L&.i6 .1 *11 gl I SJLS

U"LS Wo GH {;di• *s^Si UUIS YI esJI *dJ ~L~I ~ {? VLI ;'gi .^~ LI ;#GA I; AL kI

I LA4jJ.LI-ZII

L,r I -' I uL";l. I .s fi L,=; I ;L-l A1 -I Vi ;1 d..1 iUI 1. VlA= uO

Wal Jhi: Vai II oi V .Jl J Uls .LLJI I li.UL 4Jl.L 4zJs 4J1L~I 4=X Si A •~ L,g

;.( JUI 4.lt ) U j * Y ii I Z;LA iJ OL,lJ aUJI 1- l 1iIK L I * *-J. I LU l" ul I.L

UX g ;YI Z1- *; 1z J1J LA -5. 5Z , LS: 1VJ l Z)-ij iJU L ̂,L= S

ilI ;;1u AJ JLL 4l -i,.Jit ZLOW I,ui.,1Al iiU LI 1'-F

i.3LUI i ljsII oL L-% I J V L &:I ,i I t j aA VK Li ;- 1 Jl ii .4 LS*Li

.1 d .13j,Z<Ll 6iiUI L,i LLJI U.L;1 LJ sa-I UUil 1 U;..JJ cL.YI -u

u I I 51 Us&. Z Ij cLl! q= A6L I Z1 iAiI =b,?I 4i L ) t Il IJ WF1LllS V

L,~~~~~:a I - .. L I,Li I ,~- .3 J . ,1 1 L53 L S-l -J 1 . L- .L- 4- 1 LJ5-

Z~~~~~~~j~ia lv I: -, -'. IJ v>J J-"--- Iit L,1 L+Ji -i I14 ZZ,L-

Li;LGL- s 91 Li. 4L 1,iL,;SJA Z_.A & I L ML .1 ;Ll iJJ~ll ;l LJ-l> a f, t J=Y

.3ja i a1 yI -zi Sl I Z,-t I8 U 13 Lr a LXJ i J>L- LIa I L-;J1 ;.3 UiL=i I L+-,a% 3L1- sSJ Li'JI L II

rLJ I i L'Eiz L:.j 1 I ;.si X yLc > ]ll- ;yL M I

fIjit &l-4j@1 -L _-191 Ia I.A . LIL= .,

L.UU Lljil aIgz IJ jI SL > 1 1

.kT~ ,1i ij1 1JUC-i ^ . .l M U41 1 ZpA -S LJS2 zsma U ;L i 1+

* 9 1 Z ULI ,5 U jil J1 , L. Li u ;j L k 1 L 1 V s s ~ l C s b n 5 I L M L > 1 U L

,j vi Y I LL1 Iu1 Li s 4 bL J-Y ; L S 1U03" La 4L. ,x;l I L LT1Fu I I LS142 L I ZLj= I L'

.JJlSLJ" , hel e v > 1 4S * b > 1 4- .d .......... t1 _

_Y 21 t7l j 61 sLLz ;j U I [.:Y IS Ju ri z 9LsLL ALi f.W cJ vl 1 1liv;^ JU3,'YI c Jibll JL--.LviI

J;H LI i v 41 JI LLL;,l j I <-, L Ie -I Is C Sa IL-I 'Y I _,A L . X-L L5v 131 U& I

_,U1 > lilljt as j (jUY I liA

ialU I sLl 1 13ii I EY I t .(AY:I S ai) YG I JL ;J, M 1 .:;1 , .f

-.- U,I &JIA L11 J,,. ̂ rYI LL.: j..s2 Jt Lj ;I ,L

oL-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~I EAiLIJ> 5id' LI?Y L9 I L3LJ*O,il;Y J{Lt

k 1 a- $1 :LvALjf _ ;16LUI I Qfi iJLUiLI UL-trU LZI .+; L i.LI jm a ZIJI l L* 4iZL1ji s IJT

LiLIS;.tla cLL-J tl ;I1 ,Al j.,zYI jlj................. . ..l IY f LI,jI-:'YI J5 1 L,i o4XiLI X L L. Ui-

,; /> J /Aty k <G L Ke I- , ; |. Li I US -U g-,L j~Y .;

J -PJ G=I , A., , , IJ L- Li I, LzY I - L;

L.E U ;- : 5IYI H9 J 1 ,,UZ I tL- A|- -,

Z, L . Ic JI UU :.tYI

A 11 jlY I X L L . L- IJ :Y -JgI I c , I -p I ;,l L2 -LX I U: L-- a., L -AA

'tA I VA SLL SJ L f- Y LL L) tI Sf. I 3M t X, I V D AU I &5U I -3 I_, y I jE

JV I Ya S;" XIL uj- Y Z4JI Nj- l,- v;~ -a x5 J& ;9; tISO b ;]jL v v-i ;_,vt

-A Ll -i ilL 91YIs,11 dA lV J ?11 I_ LA. L, L I ZisldJ; I 6 ^, kIY I

H l,Y qsc Lev 9~VV- Jl .j--1 c JJ LI" I oyA5|Ct- .|L - t LA- I , J\ IiAl UUI JL iI

&5j9 -Jul fL=l I A-1*) , 9 i {iU? is,l SI *J" U1 t_f l> tiX -s '.4lP I.l a93 YL'J L.j I 4.

;JJO ;UI JLI Glj c L l L- 1-1 i J j± , 1I, 1 L

4 1 J'j 3 'j ' ' ' I - .k;iJ jI jZji L9.~j *LL1i _AdIJ U ) J_ I;Av1

&.i LIIZI JI FL 4 >LI •j1I I . l - -L I ULI dI _13 UI CL.LI L JI i 1

li ;1 LLi l ,1il L, .l QA 1 Jul 4 t7 US "-II a ,k >1i I ;U1 JlI ,l'JI I -YI

-. L SU UL IJS ck-I , -IZ §u.l JI ;,i Z 1_21&Y US s U L la I ;L.1

I :JI j I-_ 1-

L1L L I dLLI 31oL.W | U 1 9 | 1 LLI Jl*,IW* I ; 45ji i UI 3 Y _,JI UL5I 1 if

:3-. J M -; II_jtI A.&LJ-Iz i t +A

L V5I J L t~~~~~~IIJL. ~~LJ i. 1.111 ~JlI __J 4Z I SjU ff- I .I i 4aIj

j-LU "L.;i j | d,,,L_A d^k.J I

,II -]; f1 O-41 oW .1 aacq.~ U LJL d |d^..1

L"& -,lUS,1; LUI? V SCVIPLS1, S ,1W 4-4dCtl siO 1 OLL I

. ( ,| dLI *-1 -- dA |-G| OU1J ,iI d L bi J .d~~ c-1 0 J1 -UJI

I d g1 ,ZI 3- I JI .J L -£ L

11ilII U ls 11 ,L I ;1 L-l Vl 14 L2 iL. I !L=Y kNti :L5 jij

- ;31 : - .-. <- d" L- |,jl| ;o,L,J

-11 Lt:1 I v sitW vLK v. _+' 'a - It-,x Li I ;ML Id '-- 3 __-s

VI C GS }|I t I WOLj V ;1 9dL7 ...........A......... A| *1l |d- -t I Z21 iiIa!

a.* it -U LIL *q~ di 9 I +J I J_"Sl c UI l WI .L s L JZS: jI L j I

'LIJU9 lel;l J1 k LSJlUI a(v.ill J)<- 1j1 _WL LI p AL 1BUEU;2

L'A; JLL I ;if. Il az; L,: VI i5i~j I Z, - izz,J Ic j; -$,t iJj Cl ,w Il

¢ C' eI tiziE:XIY cLB D1 ^*SIOSJ,L OL-1 i I ,lj I1

;.iAlaS iJ];UVJY IS] ZxZ_ l; _6 j* ZA -i *. .Az I

_ dIiL9I 5l >'Y : l /4,b11,I 1sI I tZL ZL l

Li f Uae I , aUr S Z C.Lj I4 ZUII cL-P d,LU... cjL ,J, .- - IIIJ-d i li I |L- e Z|11

1 s *I d I JU IL iJ LU I LiJIJ .. ;1 L j 4 * F ,l Qi gL1I . UJd

K S tJJU Lt A.%j1 JUI v JL t U 4. . IjJjI ey1 lALL,IUUu Q JJ .

tIIJ ZILI ̂1; JI Z C LJ -JL1 ZJULI

J,:i ~J L2 j_,L L&W_Jl U.I,-L4j UUUJ l ~ k 4J 1I ~I Lk L fl~V ~ I co.

i.JL,I, ,1 - ,U...Ji UlII ~IFEZIVI 4i4 US cLlJ d - -L~4I, Q;J il (ii ±.fJ

. US ULhJaUI i l s L•L j~i;l 4 .i5JJL i i.LUI .j ;La~1I) 11J

-L vi 4U, .eL1 i.al {I..SYI JLL tvU ow 4 ly±g ;l.J Jil 5,4 -~L - *1 ^-1Elel

I1-^ a ^ vl U1I t L~ GoJ ;j V .i 4 .LL) l I os UO1l *41IYI a S1 J

JL,A~ .JLI I . L . I aj J.<..: LLt Z -L ... I

Vl P ; YI .. 11O1-L.AIV LrI cl;^J -

v 2J *%IJYI =S~IJ VL ;;Y i JLL l5 1Z,1 L; AO,Â ÎIcJ ,?

;L#;, ;1-'Y;1 LL; .- A I ai,. ................ ,Ii d L,a LJl; LI v,- I l ., SJ

LL;I;Zl _,L. i-< . i -; jJIA "C ;I I ; 0I I !;JO1 a1 J ; L .11 4all I ............... 1 , ,

*Jj L<sLLI L T.JL;JI JTVl L;1 L.z'Yl i vI 1 I^ rJj I .9,- IjZFI

a~~~ L- LJLLi J;..-L frtl *,. l L-t I '1-:1Z ,JT Z:Lj I :.L- J

;jL1JI ZUI ZLLtgfl cbLI.t lil *1 i j ^sol;I *1o;Ji uXJ

549 *J LUI ,-L ,SS; I Jt 9la' gL" I "i

,- A 1_Ae1S I I,J I ~,; *L 9GZ I JLLl CI,,&a G Sil esl.I WUiA 4l

lyIJ(fuinjibility)J1Jl llJ1V L. VG9iJ;I 1i ^ ;LA c -,-S

L*YjLJ la LJ2Lzj VI- jYI% VE jI Lii 1 I-!JS1 L-4 -*I - 1O 1

4 IX>Jl l LE LI*S .1JI ;He 'U. *J1v VL. L' LAL3 ,LLLL L,

PL;>L;IA S.; .L; L., I * - S !-sJfi 31.1J2 ,lL.1721 cl I# -'xII _tcio .

J L- : L.A rJ> v L ̂ 9S l ;lS IJ JLll S J 1,31 * *=I L yLi I 4-si 1J r 6TJ

Ld ui L,-j1 1 SI JUS** *I_MI- ,,I LL ;j SI'.lI , "WI u3u2I U_l ;JIIL:u 'Li ZlU Iu

4.,,11 WZV1 JJ*I(JLLAV)I-*Jl j

U, L,J 1> ;^................. j1IlJUI .1 ~i f oILSI UJE o= ' Le I e

A Lt L6 jJ ,L:ll Lpmull VA L,L. >LAL gli p I.At ^Q

.I I ;JUI QL,ji.,l LL I 4,1 * I-J (5l ;,4 JUI

I j 5 _;.L)I LL .. j - 1Jl LJ• I ?. A ULV .4 LUISj 6 JOOd*'tJ*JI;)v1 J%-L ,

11: 1 qj o Ij ~1 J I,Y I J 5 I I Y lU f.LLj Q,; L 1i .A c l l 9 -- 11

* f:- 1< -- I S-) 11 4 fi a 9 L- * _ ;L;L I LL d ̂ fA! I d U1 )I Z1JL I L-= L, -

j-la L-' i:i, $yl Z L,:J d L ti ZjA a .1_1 Sjl, Lul L-X 9 l , . "I

ClI Z .l L5 I I A,l 4Jl; I d * -- I SII SL l4 Li IJ

t=a Ij I IYI J - I UI-Ls *lu *^-~ LAiaa eJ sL;) Lrl;ll LA i-IL~LU,L-3 9

Ll , ;.ill .lUI 5 K Li. L ;.LLi L * : .I1 .- k, ,.III L 1 ^ ji

dL A 4. L;j I a JUl GUI K1 L &: < iil dU-a v

->-11 Z:!,-L * ,J- , o - I *, L UI ,j , - -it *ti Iij .9 ~ I L"^ -I -' Z4L.F4 j4I *~p 4 ,oL ;.aa P .iL- -Lia

.;IW'Y Z1L V.12 ji J>::ll -

, ; 4 .tI -l JLL * os Z. _ - A- lj I LLI I c1

iL:.l 1 JV°l L J izUI JU * tl 0 UI __ -. iW , -; LI•U _ L+ i

--ll il LKY j V J (-1-u d 0 i -- l- Z"..' e-

I J °H > L^4s*-7 IjYr;lt^ Ie.1 UF g1v--

I 9.a L.. , I L -:I v.=.l : LJ ;' S1 sLl

d*J= * i L &*-I V l ~ , 4> 511 ; IJILS

~. j d 5L I > ZJU Zo I c * 51 ::S IJ~ i Z. I J g I U1 ,,Iv

* 1 JiaLI TSJ41JKl il L,l>1itIO 1 -ojJb

JA4,I-YO2lIV LIi 216 I i-LlOJA J *2Is151 LLIL

15,5 L5 d. l J d ¢ l 4 ]V-;,,,ilj Y I1

* ilZW j 5U LAill ;.LU j ill tkSl?l bs f-q L#-d j ,.:,iJJIDl LUJ4 l-, * * I

- ,1 JLULL,, ,&,L,dI A

JlDI ;U.I OII Z;Z , A411 PU;I , iL-I3? J1, ;I Vl Z5AS LL 3~j.>

I4g ,S I ,#i;~ i I Zi.L-o ,; JL-1I a=- IJ ,j#; iI

1V J-S a1A~ L i 5L,;_t L,- 1;J 7LIA L.. LI W wl.L.1 >1IJ.j

J;;SV IJ5IJ 1 -Iaj. Il a. 5 -1-ZY I

j"L t 9 1I ;113 *JO-I La Ylj -L :A,L,U1 ll , SL; .> J GL 41 ;AR1 jll S

i;l AAAI ; ,1 &15d.1 -~iKJ 7 'TI Zkl2 2 V U 11 J 4 j, a4;YI W21

_,YI JUgg.0I -u - U LL.;& 1 Z4.' I I if Vi QL4 a4vLK4~f

VYIJ.u MJa L,;.^ JlEj, s ,0 I 4 11 c| ,61-l J ;! ,a99 IJ eJYIV

(-L - 1)1 4Zj L;p L. L,I L,lj I tE 1. 1 I2 4LL. 3 I -J YI . Z.- u dII-Ut ZiJW C V_bi ,H,1 -L 5 iL+i .:,, DJ I OL;~J U-lJ W1I -1 9S ZL., AA

Ll Va5l '(519 jL,---s J- I 4L- L L Mi Lix L ................- 11

pL ,6, ,;1 U UI 4i L41 zt-z * lf1;1; 21

JLJU - U 1 f It L4L L,; I Z....... 1I WJ LI I L-_- re1 ......... . .I L- la I IJ

_lS. Ij L . lj*LUI¢ *d.Q" -. JLlo S

Ja LA cJL I- 13 Ili * Lt I ; L -J 1 vi1 7IYI gi^ ^1l .:ill J , I A I L da -Z- l It 1 S;I

;X L U:V I%~ lj ., L+-A Î YdA,3L1IJ LU I ;Jl-Ll I ,

,Zi-;UI QL+.ll V-J& I ELJ .Î,L ,L

.JLA* 1.1.19 EjLI -I 1. L ^:IJIIJ L1- S........:d.^-:l; 41IY I

,itl JYI JIIJ {4l9l JIYI;L :i

L:>&- ;:Lj jjm L'i Cd-J 9IJ Liz Qt

t~~~~~~~j '.1 Liss^Y JUI Z .Vil I~ LL9=41;1 ' I . Jliall JtI V X JK@

t_Id 4,21 laA .4YJuJ ;.ff1 s:J;l? J9- ° ..:Jf a., kj5

.J )..e &i4 Z4 Z$A L UU .LL .JLA& J.*

:Jul Z" V L6 .1 jI'IfJ ................ <cLL o

Z": ilU 21 a1 I< ti= Ili so *; S 6 Izl _11 Lis -Jf LiLisl > ZL1k4 L

L-J.,, I Jw] i ZLJ L i A U.

:1).j .c I _A!Y I' * II 1 . I , "4 I

-~ iLk oL-II ,41 UL.. -u gU L1)i v dav L.U J MW *oG .. L..I

VU4J & . O Q# * &J V *I L1 j -'IOS II --- I

1 1 ,IiIIJ

I ;

LY ,ZJl LJ I JLal SLte LI W I jI U-1 1 •i 4 UI I,WI i o;.

iUi i (i) : U I 1 UI 3 ,i : JI -LL. &, w 1 U IL L - ' U,,.IUI

4LL'5u.:;I U I J5L W .1 -L-U llI Q1 L¢_I, o tA I 1 U= 1i I .L... V1 . s1 1 VI

d L .M L4I ; w L LaVI j1m LU LU4 I : .

Il3 I l iJI ,UI i YI L 4JI : JLiI LA L VI. JIO, l C -IL

LiI "W I u , ^ •L +.IC, V L1 ' I kL Ai I -L l j1

1 ;SLI I I L;YJlON-Y Ij A-4^; Z I5 ip ilI . I,YI ji 1,J I 1L ;uI J

&!gL: <; Li5 vl j_ & .1- i5L. +; LJ Y I;SS i, Yll 1 !&LI a7i -4o 1 J *4>y

,)JI L , L , i,UIiul 6L,s_41 L,.9 _ iial '1,v1-l zU 1- I -4« fS

L,iI ZltF ^ U l LL.Lj L+. -IJ ~ I^ I, - Ll ^- IY VL IjqjM

,,1IJU1 LFi ;- - Li -;> j~I L-;: YI Q L I 1 ;3 jY I 11 -;. 1J1 ;=Y

U1 I.> L. -j 4. . 1 Lv1 Jn- G L - UI aoL1 l- < -il IW

,,WI \1V 9CI 5 ;J* I *AJ iji U ?1ItGa* *+.J ;a-->l ;LL J UI ,I'll

bL.L c;^ -1,-jl 1 I -j ^1 =i Ll o'Y 1+SSlI jIIf

a ojA l. *IL -J 1 oYI I j k:eJ L IfilUcll

L ' ' l4 af .gi o, U U.3 1 2J 1l -* 0o

. aAI. .i1 3;iiLI ILl ; 4 I _I jL 9iV L21 L I j UA L.

;,. 5 ~iaI j I jL uI" ~ U 1 1~Wl J~Ii L % LJUI QL.LJlj Al jL,.!V cL.J jAL

* 4- I(,i JJI LL.JI i 2 il >.. ULI E.L.gI 6 i>-. >1 .oL U-.1

~~5 iJU iJ.lli @WJ L, i>J i. *î .J~I JJI ... ^.L 4 •_l jj J- s;Z Lj l tAjLLL U4 anl-Al 3

LJ.L.> ZI.A._JI es SS,1.-t

5 Ul1>l3 :~ z1 Ul aL.±HI ul-L -Y.. I ,WI JU.L J- lLt I 6 I.A _9^ 1 LjA

; iJU~uI I Y >I J5;- 1- L11 .- sLe I.il

e- .lLiAlI J o - -. 4I .LL .i^1

v-§ WLsLL U±LI Jil <5i iJU iL~LJ;.^Jjl WLl o

;.3 I JIiLI L i3 L :

%zU.V,l jA I; 1,,Aiy 2stU IJ i L Ut d L I aL.J I Z;,l- i5.al 1 3Y|y9L.

)LLl Lsi iaU iL,Jl;; o^<9 alU iI,9I V Yl 1 soLIJ., l ,- c llV

OLAaIz , ,L S vW Z.Ljl I -L ? e g, iLL

L ,L) .*1.I Zlc Lv^ a-LJJlaLj 51¢ :, Iyo

.^1 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ !l iI e2 Jl JLii*eolI> 1

z.-J v' oL oLi~lls JIJI 1 .r; 1 ; 1îJ U 6 g I Y I e- -

5 e L,{Ig 11 V &,I_o A l L,; YI C5, - 1> L*-..j u aI 11 zLJSli

_;i Li k:LjlS I L1 vi v5-,- 51:1 all I1 si>l i I iL I L ctv 5

j.= LllJ Lill U,;iLL j51 vJl v-dl L-;11 a5 9. 51 s: o: JLtl 'YiI

@ AM .j5A LL-JI *I~tI L~z1I, ~W~,iU AL -II5J 11 J IA I _LLI Mj A

.JA1 EUI jilJ S Cl1 MI [j1l IX {IX

GJ l X I : 11 - a-1 J,.aXI 1)Lu zLl.= .1 31^ C. lJl ; ,SjI zl L J 1l -1 OLr I ,1 5D'

f-U (5;: Z1 A^X IGLli Lr-_1 ?;IJ i UzI Z9 - l,-IJ JE JA iaWU I Zg l^9 10 Li;11J^LL

ZL qIl cL-L M UL4L _,= il WI J.. s I9 4-il *:ij .-iL XU J îL~u Sj-11, ivL

L;LIi +I -,Aj .,L,.LIJ .L. J! i Z 5U L LI M ,1 JI

I - -Li ,s i.

, \0y1

I

iIf

I

eU 1 ~~~~;~JI oL. tli XS-1 >L. k=IU UIj9 L

&.!ALLI ieZl I "A115VI 4a l;JtJ BI jIj-'YJL 4L I - i141 (i)

reFJJXBI-.lol a J d -OIaYI( S ULI jlI-YI Ld. =l. . I4

--J-YI fLj ^ ^ 11 I Ju oit jP JI L U..I E1 2

L - -j I . 1, ̂ '-1 a?1 . I I e U I Iit-1o 1

;l-04-1l L,Z ;F IJ3 I S 1-jpq* ;I*II;FL>-LO-IBA

.g Q) 6L LI L vli L L W Io Z, L, J1 L - L 1, ,J I j U

4 JIOKl 0l I *-J0 j515 J" . BE1;WS 3;VU lL P i

L.V I &A 1 OI jriu *& 6t I .L& -W ULl -L Lij I, , I ~ I .31b A 4z LiA (5 N Y11

.111 .36A ^ I 7, L,llOF ? A L I L63U'

QL-L-JI~~ 4J.l&; I.W L-" L~ J.-Y,:UL1 I ,\

t-£ LYI - J 1 iFLil l JULYId uj .sal ZIK iLals

<L;3.: -1 cj,L-L- It J^L'ID :el- g Lf Jl sI YIo ¢ J Z;,-

cL L--l61 ;1 i J --J I 13, 1M L1 a-l oL .I -:IYI fl 1.1 LL 1F.:!e. i.... ............. 11

y ZJL. : L%L VY 'VLI V4 Z ,iJ i ;.LjI Uk.LI vIZy ij !i ,I I cU L-I jI W' Sax I 1. ,I

5i1 LsLmL *d-L 1J;W ,1 - L 1 4LAL dI !UMI ;Ll .I., JLLI LJL IJ I f4L W VJ I J

d.-.l -ÂYI L; i ,, I j . 1 I I b - ij LI L ; t I _ L 1 . L; I 1. I L I | Il3 U 1

_*YVF IJl ,.~-. L4:J I -La1 I t wI S jxLI J?;1 -1 LI L.AW15 ,; LIi J> I- di |- 1i, .^ld t ^

L, L i L Al -Z- I i t t I1 , 1,i1,i L,4 1AII L41 vaL v I

I LII J1.4 ±L I l L

54 JJe iJ 4 tiMU ~lI yo JASII s 1L 1 L *ojl &U• <.Il; - -LLV I :1A1 L.3e .J-a

_* xCIiuj LJl a LL.t L;.s%Y : l L-L. - L4

l.;L, Z- U I C.; I* j 11 WI d4 V-. j I GJ II c.tLJI I 4.L 14 iLL I L J1IJ

d ffi Lp -i JS b {I Q ,J -I .JI 44 I L

7 j l t illI &LLhJII L- I J LjI a 4 & ~ JI LJlJI . .1 I y y J2 l; 4AjqL3j.w Li | Ll L.g|U - d-*I -L_. j 4aJil I Lit ,t oI L' aS i)j 4 1- >1L1,l

Z1 * - I- |A; LtL 1 J;I Cl S Lc >A;4LJ:I UJ; 41,.V1 Vi VAJi i 1-1ll

J1; L4L *jUYl lI- Lo, YIJq -HY LJK L-W a. *gAi ?.nAa L,1 L;Ei 4A.;;.Lu;- E;V sL

Ll1 I j.- I;Y V- I; ; ! lllVL A I ,;Y I ,_~ I ,,i 1. ). a4l] iat IY IA

L;q-ji "Ic VYI 1 JVLY V 4 JS3 V=I 1l. JK B SVaI V 4 &tLL ;s vtLi

SL-ML,; C*d '-s I ct1 .L I... .11~ J , I i YL IL ;-1 I 1 GU I F. I J.1. 1_, I I 61 A51_, O1 '.1_ I

L> I Ll - Ulu I4 ;?J iil. jlLa .; I-LS I I^l K- '3 LJ ZoL I

U-Zt "i ;lU L4.,aw L4LJ LSI-,L cI- .; .-. I2 -,YIA

S.j .i.lL 4. E ILh v4 YW X I L ,1 U., LL;i I_a 1 oLL I cNv 4i Kz .3 Lt JIA

S L L6s w1,V I I1 4, - 1LxL,W

J~~~~~~LI ;.1 vlYI jl JIj AL LLLI .4S9 oL,.i 1=

UlI aW P J>I , L, i.116z -> y 4g.S;tl ,J L .- w1L. I1g

- L+; l id I;l aL &3,= I I v> > * Y 1

- LA It LL -SIJ.L-)IJ .dlil JS-L-I AMS ;J1'

_I-Ul1 Laljl d=LA 1_L s-WJ I 1i V- V3L J DI iIJ 1, ZL ^-?I etSLj;

>j1 J 1Y I aOj~Lj I ,| U-,. i 1(- 11 L:J 4 sl JL,:LYI L41j Ai 4L14U gy

Leg LH 1a. .i Z 1SJ*- WS I *; 1 L ;L; I M -I dIL

LJU "- or a ,- 51 - - -

11 Ail ,r511 eJ .ôYILz l LMIV M J > iA , > jl

a I

;a1j J6M1 Lr thiZ Cs

L,6 Jt;,L GYJ*>1Jie ?GJv L= SJLj aL1 OL': IJ ,g1i

JWIV J.I L IS)i U DiL2LJ s UL5I S o Y &. QLSLU Li Y0o LJ1

j L.J V I YL I1 *-I A J< -=j S1 i h w.1 aJ r z8*Y{Sh) C.i-1

*(-LqWSLW-J ,4 LAaz,; L.z 5J- Ia;L),1 iSu I L' *. Jp I L. -L 91 CI V4 4141

LA U >L' lUI it l ,#g- I JLZ O L IGl JA -91 - ,FL * LI L AI -ki ;I LX Alj

ti I3 . 399A1 I4 ?f 11 j.,l A L 1I ,1A JLZYI LS -. 1 1;4?1~lI QIL. ic AAS L-

ML,:L" L IS-i JUl J.%. -,. ^;L4 I )A I (Sberbank) L&,Il :L ;jIW I -4tZ- &&FOVA('Y bL 1t~ I LZ-I 1 * -,611 Ll&i:Al cL-e ) LW*(Gosbank) LAl_,U 65Ls.)t J-f

J,:. L -- 0 *l '4, OLu- ;,:.-a ,I JUJI t MW Li1 Jy &zLV

L+-i -I1 I s*Y Ji L,, L;JI SUJ Z-5.I Jj.I I4G ;L J.. ;-- GU 1II L" gg ° I LLLJ

L%J.A DIJL * -Yl ,1 L-.Aq

YI L2l J-1J L,-_;.. Lz1 4;t d l-i VJ9 .OLW ,;J LIJY II,]C-.:1,

_KI ,-- 5311 L;5Ll +'l c5- a aA <;L. 51 M1 L- &D;IJ (£ VI t LLi I I §< L,j ^~ S1 I

A. L!;L.2 j-1 L,! Z:.jl IJ.L VEI L,L Z .- I I1 IC LI '?I I

N'1 \ S- L,:J djl . - .............. *- CI tl'J1 I .3i l;-''')-1 I

. (SWI ,~~LAi_C (5TYL J *JI, *eUI lJ~

; 1*-- d'LiUl5 u:lS ?l> ,-.1 ^ - J ' LD

I:L t It 1_atl I.<v L--,@lL J-"l o,

Y.

,aLi1 J-fU ,z1; 1ag sx 11.I Z1y. ctG~

.l t - e~IJ,-J1(,4tu 1) &"'Y L+L (^1) I 1 -j .fl -

I_C It *~ "a */ l, 9 //g W =Ia Ij1

* LzI1i e yl ; 1 il ,t !z -,jl * LI j4.,V Z,_L jLAL UI Li 1%

,,L:i;s I3 L i vte_(j.( OLA_4* 1J ';'&3A, Luz Jf 1 LU Li vâ L-il EL1 , J a

- L eI J 1Ao 1 LA L, lj; I L," Zs - L3*(- DLAA .Ai iSl C1 j 1 - .t I

<,J.0 I .- . .. Xil JI I1v JLliL -L; ~ L-t '.s U. 1 UI 1LIL,I 'i

Ls J,i i JI L_= LL lil; JSt .- s lU I 4 I _,S J If JL WI I ?I LWJ1 JI JL1s-;l JA 1

UU]l "II J ;_A I 4Ag txY} J ,-J la o J- "1_ -- I J^ .2

qsv.lJ1lm jL Ys1;,SI; -4 :J e4XI JI JsL (:Io351 1

,) ;- jJ,'IELL4S-U,sIYIvf.X ,EZLJ lSSlU;3 A Li

As:- l *SI M irFl I- L+:j --! JYI ,kJ oSI c, LjK=ll c.-Z C.11 ,PUI f1 l;,

Jfztl L- -MJLlllAu u jW ~4i;l La---; ;@9 jL3

Vi X.z Ul -:r_,Z v Le-_,I v^M L,.ILvlAl t7, L'UI> 2lu ZLJ ; , ll SIjI L VI

j.4 J; i I,oY. I L o ~j ot+I ; ie. * ,LL;YIJ oLAS3 7 Z : s

;il,11JY L-L v.l<>IvI;uMLii: &Zk ,;l Jai<l L laA

VU;Jl V°i I,s I JI j - ~ I1 ClL=z _G iJill leJI V î t r ;lLA,io - ;21J

-A ) {.l 6 Jk I J LI I- I ZL < ll g4l2,YI 59I S 5J s:1 'KLe.?tAl

t;j.. :1131f L.''-e L:L,. ,6 L~L J lljfis Z-iGs4Le

.1 \N.Demirauc - Kunt and Maksimovic :v1.,p L-, Z .-LLb J._LS icl i; zli

, i LjLl R jl1- -IJ; L;Ul fI& tiL. LS

.( A£ .Ladman and Tinnermneier)

Cq; L4i; &IQ J I LL :-. *j OYI * *-11,j I oL ;I

. ~~~:,L,.IvTA5 _--Is ;'5 iL e -9* ,Y I KLIgv.i 4 i;l iLLI L E1>1 v4l" LuYI

c48 4le-1 (r- -i IYI~ CA li (i)z ;4L9 %L W ;1- 1n ;-YI ALJI2 -L v~l a.! Q=) JIS1

1_1qW ;aMi I s Uz :IYI.J IvY ;.3 L.A

,z/ A,/,z,X ti,- ,/F,/ L:,

j5LUI e 4 *''', -I e 4 UI ,1) IL.Z _,; &T lii L,j 3vL-a .Y1) j(- IY LA) LYol1 1 lv X(Y

.(Y-y isLLlI L.s -LI& JJI .1 -- I ilz

,;- LO .,J d- t- a4l ~ Z:S-t= I I t i tL- lJ/ j;I/ >laJ e ; it ;

' sL '; -'i ;Xg k l ti LA| d J I WIJ tjlg Ja

I sYYI I j l, y.^âSD oLrj1 _,YI v4 lxI l A Iny L+ llv JM

.(rC--Y 4YIAl &IU t L,Il d fL'I >j.Z 4-L 14UI j;_LI U- L --- l

(Tk1 ,*lt ,1 =-'Y Jl *=l .a' 1, 1 4 -It L L l, LId -lL9lj

'_.LJ Io;IiYIETI L+, J- L^,5L.:

,L-t,, ,alCGyEL, - ,. .IY,;Gl lsiLp .LScj51 ,1 L ILI ;.L,.lL -

D IJL,M~~~~~~~I &5*-'PYI, , = A<N*IjI *a 6 S1 1:L Y-11 iJI 1 I .J{;IOb1

ij I " IG L5 1 6=1 I?F91C Ii C'ct , s 51 iQU 93 >J

JLzIMtul , ;;11 J5LAjJ 1 iolL 0:19 ;- 1ol!= I *i-' uJ_ I -svLl :;I u-6 i tr A

11gU JI 1*JYI vLALl.- Z L ;JKL 1 /6 Li ,6j9 l bi d I C l)- *s L i5 I lL.-t -- 4 z ' -.

4LuIij* 1u I ilq-t -bvlj c2e I ?I Ij;JI AIL olae-%: ~ l<- ;-..'. -' i J.<

IJsik;l JtUl A,K -c61U OI;tleJY s.EAt jLilc lolpli>51

-,L. I 11 Z#-p cIoLLZI i *JIJI / 6p l US c lij :,l)..ll ,js ;LL4 Q _;. ,l a l :L.*J ;JUI E 5 A

ol.= LA;it= L,&_j &L.;;1I Q, L & *eL, -t1.3 Q- a]L5s

LdwL Z YI r6 J"=e

Vi 1J1 -J *8st ,o 1^t1 : fi 11/J1 1-t1 l &I ( i *Adas, Graa and Von Pischke)

L*4 * L,J I I JL A!L: I 11, jM (L

Z: ojg jl .L~ .- LLL .J17 AV-) J ei 1ij L,<3i; o XI SI 1jl 1&16 -l*~~ ~L; I :.I. L91 1UI L:iiYv J:* I J-. Ld 1'

SJ,.;.tji ^ ;IL SiY -sZY

f'..9 Io;l J.1l j,>i V .;; ;->=t sI U J itiLz -x 1¢ 9] Lrlj l 'L9-$I otx* - L- a

Z1JV c > s ;-:L * IIA J i ZiL.L11 4i ,ZJ,-AWJl 5~4 JI

7;1 L'i Ajt ,;-,LU84 CtJ>LJp -,L-. i l -ZK. Y .ill 69

- .:;,1 - s 1 4 1 1 .; L j -tl J iUI Lri A. Llt

I Y:iaL # ljLall @I * i .'CLMYI Li -UiJI

I L~i Z& =L-

:,11 .(jL JI i.l i,lL JI LI Z I,JJ;1,9LLdL 3_ll4L11 - d 1 QLIjJI

4,(Jl I Q3-L L . U,OI JI Z., , . - A) J" *- 1 iLL..L 1 c• I 1

;3:u: ,1jf L*I , I :-, JA - J j9 ; cS3 .L:lId dCI j LL.J = 1 OLI 6L1 .:IJ,,11 "LLVI ^Z:ILaf QI ,LL _-ZU -I -.ULiA

L;y J-k j I ,-!J J9i -L~± -. sU3i ljjItLL L.j.iiI I L,i Z~__Ij,4 II .( 4 oiinwne and KL nde)j I

J YVi F<iI .:, | .. YIIJ d,, ,- 'd -,3iK X.|Y 3*411

G441 L' ;LL( d- | L8 ;J1J 1 Y J, | d . .J&i t,L l I - 4

* ZL.BnwageUadKhnde J~~I~~1 ~~iI. ana~J rXi an Kbnkr

42- JL<_I; :.S :I ............li t. L-L- , L. Y *Lu4.........d1 ~-0.:,,111Jl-I,1-LILU i< E;' I La-Ll 1-+7 L* ij viL Ai 1, SL tu l ;A PJ*.. L;

.S.ZU11 jL 1 1 cALL1IV Y I> L -LI5A it -kL= 'JY -JI 1 Lj

j- Li-- Ifg 51--1 L;j I,t < e - ,

I,L5z L1, JU I ,,;, 1 - ,,6A U--I ZA ,1S1 t ;.ll , c1a;LA L+Aa9 &1A 1 i 1

1 ,1z 1 G L; I J_- LA 1 ;Ll ; II LLJV -1JS -s-*(\5 Bnwne n hnkr

g I VL61-4;J1 4 j ZA I C~ J M cL- 1_~ I U- 1; ,,6| 1J ,1 . -: ,] >[5 I-t leal-; Ll -,4 Li ,9-LjI ;L 1 I C9L LS.- Y-J I ,- @1 _Gj LH-.IL~

Jl CV L;A L ) .ij j : l -lJJ 1-,1OJSI YL

.Bin 11 x swaae lan1td Kblande & i uAl 15^1 _1,---; :1

.A I1 9u;1 A14 ij U'J.L 1S ; -I L +, -j~ I L,,,...... 1,M O;I J:L =

ZULI L,- A ,LlI Lu J,: ZLs Zlll JjI lj..~ _ 14 - ^-6pl i1ot 1v

Chaves and) c,1 -;11 JI v i;UUI L,- &A Vra J ." ,b u ,, -L" ;'I, o LL Jj,- s;jil;:;:

.(Nlko .Sanchez v elt -- gs; lj *,>vJi

VLUYL 3L5,:t- Li 1I I5LDsJ- U >S jVj ... aJs

VL 12g l vk ^ L-ZYIJ d i |l-a A 1j'1j A.- ,1 i,

Iae1 J '-- V J I l ' ''-1 V°

L' .' Is vmYarbrouah and Yarbrough vV- 1

_. I ;U.~j' V (A).(%,N1k .Ramola and Majahan)

L,. - i;UI1 ,f; rr ,j1 V j j 1

*4vI I~ L vo:.IjY- I laALi & .- ~-1 I L'IpY l-Iv

_ijl _*fal-L_Jx7I E LA" = *(Lf7I *tEWI ;.ZUl _," i ,.t I JuI V"IL Yg

t LX VAVOI § L 1 1 >Y I tl l (8 SV .Kan)t di ;LLEI'a ,5 L ,,1 L-J1 III^SLI iI , .I,L ;141MJL Y

; Lw . S, IYI 11 .lil-1 '1J

:,:Lj ILI 4-ii Je ;1-1)SJA11 4.>

_4,I;Ll L va_J f <11 &UJ A.J vL ;jJ!I JA 1 t,Ja lA.

ZL61 iSII .,>11 sl I o;LIL- <.11S*YI )159;I *vaJAi SL. IL : I LYI :

; l ai TIK~~~~~~~~~~~A j ,llil.LII lL liL,,1L YG1 l;-: I u a(S>l

*)1 I )+GA : 9; WI L5SS *e~Jtl#SS\--^ PlaS " j

~L IZ AU I O1 .... L I. ij I, I LR5:- ...... I1V Ui- uI aw A I o;J-I J I jo- IJ**-* 4- I ?1iU I V L2I l-- J1 <1 If L j lJIL (BANRURAL)

4-DZ IJ "zifl1 S; 4JyL-z/l! .;(1:toL-s c-LS 1 U 1u s L: Lf l

.JLU I J- 11; .- : I 11.)1 Yl Zs Lll L,11L -1 -Y.I VOIFEi U )* 1 LMJ5lJV1 zIC Y 1 l L I C l ft f l V S ; I A L; . LI ,LI; I i UI 5j l

Li1 L j.1 f .; Z.-L ZL::I3"5;H Io.U .111:-;11oW*

Z11 ,11 &LI1S I L -,m I 1b tE 1

J"..I S ;.IS.Ltl ;.Ll -t L- i'li Zy. e1J U I .I vI

J L L1I' A (AIJ'I SL2JL e YI V SHVLoW _,,.J I L * tIV Ls , YL-

VLU CW ,) .?,l iZUI O;11 S14-& J,.,V JL... ,VA .!-..... 1llSY

I lJ YI J V, L-UI I; V9j Ili VL-; ;;YI Il.

;.LW _1- ZJU ,13L1 tl -_qA1 UI lYj

1 ,1A1L Li I LL I 1.,1o -jl(5Y I YI ,YA L,6vY

aLA r ,;1,- tIfLUI Z,ol1 Uo.iXi 1) (%s-%*IV z:tl S , W:1 &9

~~~t I JLI -L;4J,;-*C.Cll5 Q-I 5 -,* :IJ *4 ,IUI J; 4sH cl J 9,= jUI ,jv C A.id,~Jt L,1 1 ZLLIJ LiS E JIt 1S1,~ L:.l 4A MEsj L1 ;A

,:.;LI IP ZUI -L_,# .,Y) -61W }, 11tLil L;SW,i,,;,l,,1> Ul, 1

G91.11 :;wY -(A 1LI.(GROASEM[EX,j ANAGSA _j-; &UL

N, JJ. AiLI "'uAl .-. . -1,

L I L- :i) -.L)4I 1W -L. .4 - a .Il * ,U I L,k L,1I Ii L S

L -1 SJI &I JW J ^ L-Z 'YI Ji ,l -1 LUI -L-_W .!A 11 )1

ji U i , ~ I | ........I O 1A L SI L ;l... 0 ............... 1 o1v ;Io 1 1J

.J,M)U -l,ll

'ILill

'i :l Lli Vl ( l i) I J JlO I * U4i - L, Y I-1 ;"uI J I- II ;.61fl ,LLgI >) l jL Z'sLJ

-I __6- - I) ;1 , l -; ,L.S *1, U 4. I,,l S;, ,1,U

wi we~~~~L . 1g.'S I GU ;X.v1

.UW L .; U Jl 5. J1 JI ;JU Z-I Lf.11 ;j- V (j5 t-!LI

.~~A*I JIaJ9 vE -11 *) ol *a UW ;L

*5 1W- IJ ,y1.; vi UA W1 U aJI i,J

N- I

; 1111 etJIUZ Zff -Jj U;

jLUi ZZ.A- L, U -gt. LIU iStI *.- L) JI ULLj I c .4 'Lli-I v,. 1

;JLw L- ) d *LIi v iJI j;L.;U ,k y. 1 oJ)I

Z,i ~>= J~UI ijjlL. Z:!W j LJLII 7,-piL7I .L 0 U ;ZW I ~~I "i L, 6 U UIa

;±~ c 1,"I L.: 'I L.,5J j .;U c+-J* I ( W.ZI U U l. , ..UV Z2, I 1-

v! .ij j. i ;Jsi'1II -U I ! L-P * •U 1 siJI UQI L&I i. 1 ; LJLL I a U Jj a SI I

L-.ZYI ,bi,J ea.,liS ;;.l

L-L; L-iSl jLtl u ie .;,j iaUI ll

jl ?.-<-oAl;U.LjZJI cL-P le>k-L;lUIlJLvl j6l L+* C4-: UA- ;Z(ili-Ll Ll;ljl_WI

c -r . 1 ,,LL. t . ; 11 aAUUI L1l1 *r4 V - Il J .Lil J ; ;L ; - J ;ii 1

L- U I , li 'l j 1 I EL. L. .4UI U 1<,' ol ,-I;UJI iJI Qt .s1i cS11 i.UI oLj. IiLj Ll.* 1 JUi oLIJL I1wl& -lo

j4?iLt,111 CtJ,filIL.: : I .. j JY.. --. * L =1 I j1 o lG1ojI L WlL-

VOGIJ O L,:J SU L IzLJ

tjg ~ ~ ~ ;W LWIUIef,pl;

'li

j ll-l UL .laAJ

_ _ *JA ,W,. LI j..J a

Z,- oL '.L, I ,1- L,w a 1 J.9-- Ig U 2 l L,iS

~U.~1 Ukla S~. e *iVi, U l ,i 1 * Y I•± E,i1ii ~tI So

~,i JILl I z54!j ai I ,jJO UI I 1 1 l J

Q1 L;. (N Slktoi4,S 8S) Besley ,j_ 1 L (1) -w ;.esejl ,1LL I

s Gn-~ ~J*~I t•. JAl ~L v t ~*L• ; >L I 1Jl 3 (-) s j,iJI l S ;LJI _I

i I II i - I -l It5LLf

'Î L,Jll 4Yl al.lYo E ZiaLl^ 'ZU1S

LL,J

LLf tIC-bij,FY IL a Y I Ve j O T) I ;Lj J a -. fi 1 i

dt ^-! Lll pLI_ a4tL-U auY v' iLW 5U1 J L-LaL~

v 'Y I -L, L 4e v.* U1 wLi va Ju J1 ,iLI -(j I iI JlJI; LU.V : LI

vi~~~~~~_ v L1;LIJ;saL Lj,1v

:- aL j I 4 *i uJ SJI J. Lj6L5i,I 2 d <, 1 IL ILvI I L 1 JL. V1 Jej I I LI I

; Lit aL clL,-1Y jLu Zl*kLStG u19t;-U

L. ) -=J aqJ L II i Ldy1;1 ZJA1 :1J1 -,c|d.a-j1 31 j.1Yl LA -^¢

*j- Z19Ki L,J :il l -- sVI Li _L=' ................ ; u J l J l 1, o

J >.(8 aW )|6fi j 1 4.: li U-5 f, C": I M ̂ sjIi e

d:2 1IL. Y Z.!.4l i1oJ1- Y v ;

L,;y - jy 3L9l Y'-~jI _,A Lc o.^^ 4;o I -k zI L..- ;1 IJ

*& > I O LcS Ct ,f>ll W,L1 < -YI,t*9Y

rx

*QL"I oLI;-IIJj

*LJI i *- -a-IIL * o Jl . S11 5 ¢ L- L.nhl , ;JL e

L--:-' 1 Z4,~~~ (A;, o LL ',I g1 " :L4,6 j - ) ~.

.c i !iL I * .. . I I1 ,il ,6 -

61 Z:-j 6 "i (JUl~ YL Jc~~.J~;.ii ji I 3 i= I Si L-v! I -1-1YI U,k I UJI L,k 'i

-~ -j

eLJ -i Md ±LtI Ij j^JI . I~V *I; . ~L.::1;..L:, =*.~I*.^,I eX * s s L ~ i >W14~,1 4 ,L. aI 4511~J LiJJ ,ifL J L -* (J~gI ~LLW,I J ~,JUf U-*L;: : )IIo _LJb $4I L ,. U .LC uk jWI

- ~J ->1 iLi ML~ Jol-t 1 -- JI jvi%l J LUt * L' >Lj~ M 0..iI l ^ ij. ..]> J- JSi *

.,. Ui Ayl Z_"I 4J.= L.LI i L..J ,LWGL *

V~:I g 1 JL1LI LU.iflD 8k BJIW5I Jy.t 4fl3 * U ~ i~I c.y1 ,LLJI ~,,jk-I1 J J&a M-L- VS

4j -Z i6-1i U 1lu rIrl; jL * j L -LJL'il l SI -

;jj IV'. I I%I..

i)I4l;;ll,lZ1,'1 J! .......... I X;SLI.:.L,.I . .... iI4+. * b (W;I LLs iLIJ~ .hIJilL;2v,J t ILil M eIla

i ;-L") 1 U 4 1 ,Q;Jj,II ,,L,J I ;[JL * SUU 6= 6 ,L -UI *) .UL tJ J_L I i ; oLI

.(I j L- aLI J 3I tXI - -bLn . . UW_ Jl4..~j - 1 , L 0 . AL -I41 0L~1

oLt JL&.j 0 ,ttZ tLL

L.,J Jj:.i -,i l~ ..L Y __ 316- 'dlXi 1 UL3 I V- . IJI ;JI- .11 i.. LI-I

j~~~~~~XI I d IL_;II;LLII -

*S11 iLLll L£s i~~~~JUI QLJ-!IJJJ 1 ;Ll UI oIu-tl IZ6t ;aw Ill oLJ) I -: l !4 IIJ;L-

,A-11G-iCJ ,) L.:;" JI ... . r1i-v&J)~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~;tl - v;U lJl oilIoLvl -L |Ilt.>il'iA L-GII QYI

a - - ,;, LAI . -.JW. -. YI QL L i * 5 .a LA L _YI L.i ZL. IU1

A j4Ji d IJjLAI I I1 I M) -1 J- v-y j L

;lSajIlitiIlii ev,W sj.c LtL U^JsiIvi VIGUI jIYI veL#! Z= ^1 -UW LE1mg i c r .L1 l 1 LA.1J

m>YI ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .L" jtUI sgl#Y zo .i,;A lEi5l il Ijit1 o

I L l L0i iLLiJI dI CJI 'Si 1 • i lju± I J3 I

L.U l *1J , 2 iJUI JLL ±caI L,JI - Yi 4.L1 JI;I

W- LaZ IJ~ LiUcL I ij-1 coLIJ lA Z iSW L_4V 1

L~J .jJ 1~I~~I U 11.1J~ t U,UII a.Jfl ,l I~ Lt I "j I~~ WI3 Ja

4- 2 1 -LL WII VAL; . LXI Li OW1 59

iLLiJ °c- 4is -51 ilI ,1 lL- *( 4 J ..5lOLI&A5)J

WLJLI iJU I j >LIL5.) -aI ,A1 | Z~LII t7UI L9 jl ]Y J.1I

JLI L Y ;WUI ;i. I o, 1 Lj-_-j LJ_:J I I it -1

¢1 ~~.: . lU LUt ji1 ; ~JLLI g1 J .(±.~.•II....... ........ X @H ULS ~ i .ISJI

9 ,? - p LSiJl L 4 zW;11 J lUll J5 VI ±J1 L. / if,, -L-J/

i ~ujl J;I L Wi KLu LW1 .- il l - ZIL e i 11i Z jl J J tL. 1Li3

.!k-gv ZauI.L-ilDl - L- -*J -jLIetvfeiv>^>

A 1F- 51.....5.J,- 1i ....L1I J_4 I Li d -fI .. J*t .........I. tilxi1 aI,-L s11 W 5 l ZLLJj J *iSI

eL Ui,-Ul pil e .-. L'all i.JUI ZLL-I. : -l1iEELLUI RJLz ill ZaLLI

j,lULI iujsejl i2UI ZIA,4I1.. J li AJ k Jl Sj0II j Ij 7$L JI Si LLj Il>YIb a. M aA 1 Xv=s

J>D;tI ZJU ZLL,41 &LsII ,>1 .-;11 ZIJ Uo- IH - itl I5 ;t l1 I ZSYI

d -|,, 19 Lil0 L 4IA J- J1 Ll; L,I; C'; 'l lw- J5A IL Yj , RJ

i 9l _J.I iL-UI vjU;II ,:J d I . . 1i I O I v

iL. WLL Let 4;I UU>I =A4 d-11 -J,L" 1A;l Z YUI L S. L U

Zi<ll oL.3 .si. s YI L4zLII 9L r s d -L-, - ,> Jil. 1- J

li C llL ei Yl .I sLj'Y I SLlL ;Lt ;1 iwUI ;--LL 7Z1 4;61 1vY ,1s1 U " Y cjl.0

_a_ i -ll - t Y 4;i -X OLJI 8;F>;= 1OlJiJ

lj s 39 MJ Li3S lZ I Zj o_ L 1.?1;5 95 ,5 I Z) ti 61 Jg

Kndsn L LIL I oL.i LIJ Vy19 (IIIT) -LA- i ,JI IiJU

Lk JAJ1 JJI 4SyiI *5LL;I ^L;~1 ~I L11 i

Knudsen) .;K A I Ji 4;I .L• VLJ . LiiYI JUW *a ,1 .H 5ifI , Uk l lJIiU1 -. ,> v -and Nash 4i .. Sh and V .* () -

i~ LA-11JUI LIII .1 dLI ;j jd-11 LJoI -c lll YI :,-1j

> -I - i (Z 49_ L_ J1II i i- *I -V 1j I. 3C i .L.JL I iL "J L &L

j9LLO L94;Ji - L.rj1 i 2U sI oU ." l411 Ql :,L &. ili L 1 1 _L il :LLil

.;.I I LI ; 11 I I I -4 u zU4 * ;_% ;LA Ii 1-4I L1 -'(L n iI ;ll IJO ;;11 oL

d~~~~~~j ; W I , j E I L lzL^S/3- V / L i)i1 IJ 1

d-xt W tLl;,L;WI XjilSciff and Valdes,a;J1 J.JISII *(N-f

-,_ JI L, ;2 18 tZl .4'11 LtI o L;l 50 J _-L4S 1 D lOVLYIO.J J1 L -- J ISI LgL?t JjSL,.J c,iJl, O L y :si i;U 5 *d*-d j

La.9 LS I.JkbaA4 ,;U -lD t5,.LL di --I -= -*1 5-@ sl LIQ 1 v jJUI Lf9 £Et JsL;z L_lj 1b

zOL. Y ?.J; Y IS-PJ,j1l;J qkrd I 511 °L9IDV laA ; K ;)II JtID1.V 5

;V VI DA 61V Yl I L>5l * L-Il [I :,U VL Ij <jJ ;,I)ltlOJ SI 4_SS VAJC. L l LLIvlJ< sll Y,iio^>

yL 4 ;;l.(vms) .Schiff and Valdes J*()Q

,L;X1 L_ B L ,, N *AA£ L. LjlJ \s1. 1 ;-J L-4 I - I; fi tt 1l I SY lA;J1-,5J I I "A il oL= -'ijx_IJj dtS 9 yI OYJl(ZUI Q¢9 VI) +. esLv*:fi * ,

V.l,. I ,==iS L.,. -- I WI ,J Iv iii zUI L5;SJ "Lu-L1 --5lJ ?J L_.J L; IGJ .z

jL3=1 L,.i LL=I 1>1 --,YL L_WL>1 LI 41W1 QUflL. dlJif WI1 oL_L_IIlaAlJ -1 L.l SjL, 6e ijJ 1 a+L,.L Q6=L;,

LIL w1 * 1wil I1 L;LLlolY ~1 LjLI 1-jL- 11 -............... 1 1 x- L;'-a -i4 ZLILJ.

L>1 o A11 ~- W : t ;- i ll l > IJ a1 9 V o J i I oX v L I S

(ISjIO 6BYI-,J,WI-- OLLji 4;); L, I1 Z,_L I ,*;,L-111 ,6b1 -Y

ELJI, U.11I ;~- 1.J WLLll L)J,Y l i l L.-iI l

._Ij ol> II L iL I .. o1-Ax IJ :j ox <4LlHLd..>11 1i....11 31& 1 ,z1 g;41 1 2 51............11U j oLl l<Jy>U m i -1 ° :A I -£

; I OLs,I OL 4a111 4oil> LII JIJI ,>I) l 9 v L-L; I . YIL ^ jj >i1 j;lJL- Lll jI LIoll.L91

TV L IL Ail

YVILf Z6II I V 4 j L I l 6II JL,3NI ;.Lai ,,slil JlikI L.allJL<sJIlC 5. U.I j .LaI LI c- jISI NW Li3I4L1 1 0

'Adam, Graham and Von Pischke) J!I 1 - L ql, jil j LtJaII . JI I

.00,'r .L(.Jo *-1: ajnd A SaGonzalez-Vega)!NykAi zW.iLI Ji , J,8W[ L_ ul ;ijI aII L L

_,,1 LUI- ,JUI zOlLiJI c., -ilA51.1 I1;a &V93|)S

V°LI i JL U ° 11 1.1 I ,,W 4.'i 2. Z51 L ~. : 'J ^ , U-L1 L L 4L, I

1 (~ .36i I LjiJ WIj) LV JV Wi•l = I *JI jI L±. .'AI I L13, JALJ jj L o

iSiL kjAs J2 ,IU I., -AYI 91 1 51 JA

J 5i.J~I~AVIy~i

Jq.s/ ,I a1;^£ 1iUi i,Y J.~ 1 UI Ls,- YI

a;JI e,.zJ^Lrl-ijL:lOLI9YI- ,1 ;.V-Y WL L:

-u- 1 C. 4ijI 4 , 1 t-LiJ 4 Z :I ;-J J -

5 .(\,o o.Chaves and Sanchez) . .iL.i qU I J_*L J I ;.LII ;e IJi 1 UIi -, ,I

i:;UsM: )>,gll, ooj) :LjLLLr 1- -1t L-0 Z-l,.LI 4.11 l u -Z-;-J .atI

L,I s ;,, JI ,1 i 3 "t-j C.; Sa L , ;,] :y Ij - [J :,1 U.1 L,1

;L,- I r4L J ZoAl*" v ;s;UI , o , 1- L ....... *1, ai V1 a,1 ,. d;

:SU i,J1,-, ,^1uaI be L A *;fSJ Z;C2lt

L+!! 1. 11 LI, 5;-9 S J.P 1IvL

A; *19-; 4;1 o -AS

le L-- -Y , ' I J" I ILi; Q;uI IF Vi ;,I- J" ;" Jo . -lL-; V . L-; ,> "J; ;Vi

_* ~,iCl VI :9 t1§1v J

;US,; Y j tj - 1-,91,L-YI 1 V1JI .1 LCL<- I ;M Vl ,:1 V- 5l1 L+;

J-- Lc- uI al L --'I oJI LAJ YI v oj ;;i sEI o:a :I Y I 31; L-~ 4; C7=s

.(J:LUI JL- 1 q L-:1 ;I 15:K;) L+S1 Y. AI.% 1; -L-1d KZ I *II : J-:J >lf -<- c p c -J- L-4

;L L,-l ZU v L *; I -;.J=) ;;iLf ;_,-VYILp *' fI ;;A19 I_;.ÛI J ji- IC,

Q ~~~~~~~~~~ ~~.iJ;aaJ Lo &_,< ;L 'f il I.eii dJ R1

CU I 1 ,11 JI LAI- I J 1,1sc-y .J LI J-

5 .V so .Chaves and Sanchez:--,-I Li 1 ,-WI 1 L-uI vl ,i TVu s , i

S}} it; le ,6a4;l YfA

4 i- 4 iJ , - o L1 I -. A ifI LI I d4d -.t| L.i WUki~ > 41j

L ,, ); j4 'JjI c Ll J1L .- Lll *

L--I - .L - -dUaL

4L S 4i 3iL ,11 iJUI JJ.5.A1 JA ,jj 1sI LiLa AL 'l- .I I

:;IZJ I LJI I JA;I . . - .Y

;i l 3 * 1 JJI v1-i I -Lit 1 L i LI

tu 3i 1_ L4;A1 -6Z1- . li

,Levine) J I 5a, J1 .S - Y;11 -,j

,dl LLllLS9f 1- JlL .J Q1 ^Lj ILi,;" * Ll

d l |; * .t j l- ; o1 p;aLLl JGl; :L) _,LL-:l I Vz > ,Z

L,- Z:Lj H1>M;jLLUI ..........

.;a'11 ZdU U.LI 41 csLIr LII J,JLD JJm 9 L >&o1 J- ;&st

LLI w I

IIiLI iLJ

,L1I t I (L u , , Ir A ~ - . I 1 Ja,tU ij,

J9.:L Z19N IC L-1 In LL 14 -- iLI U1 1>1boJ S L;lMJ

L,.LJl -= l L-il -i" 1 WI t LsSIail 1 Z.1A Jjui .1 i OLYIA L:

F. L L5 I o1 I ilL ll 1 - J;liL

*Ll5 iJi 3•Al U;E 1 :u Lr U~aLJI Q± 4 a' OI);LI 43............... *

V; .5~ {*Ji JI.. T U~ 9 1 .L JJ ;•. - + SlSS ol , UzL ,,1iA. U'1 S1~

U"1 (9; i;5S J..y2I t lL HI~. C~i ,±I U,SI S L y1;L1 Ul ;5MJJ ,UV U" -';I j .a -iL4 2U 3 4L ( = 13 . Lt I clAlJ I M 1 U j">t .:L O1';l , jLj aI* j L i*

d l.J1 O Ly-ISU -L•i L -Z ,I,Jll UcLL 4I ULLI I Li I Jc-L 4 .

J'IJilil -!,sL I cL,-i g) Ial ;. Li *cljl IJ a;~ 1L' -;iLll UUI ji -v1 Z,. Z, :

,.iL Z-Jllj U 11idI - L Jl . I - (L L, I IJJ U" I JLIY I .L. J, I .V Ij0 l

;"'I a- j 14J IL - J1I djt LI La 1 * d I ULLi U4I iL Ia J1u. L s

.L 6 L -sL IJ ss9 . | d-- il.i ,L J1 . i IJ L--lt fl d Li * aL ; IJ

MJ.,.=J ;%liU JIl iI RfL.I . i~ I L>I .. i,5Sj GlijI :5J-~i4 ,I• t11 U OL ~ SYIi UL.

.I)ii . *J *LO L•I W; U s4E Z.LI .J L4J La 1 -: ~I d~ llI 4 i2 J ( t J*1 i fiI

L3*0 U.UlA

O Ud*---}1Ls1^---1lV = l lv lJ 1 1d I J1 1 1.w3 = 1 Li D kl l?l j .Li Ji

. , 11 J I I -L]i ............ i=l J.YIi,LI dW| d tfi f 1IilUI .1 JvJ HI

{- 1 LÎ Q;JI Qa,.olal J-r,'II 1.

21j L J4 i ;1 1 LI LiS . 4 IVj LW 'L1 SJLY,I kl,~ ilV

-.1. ,li:- I Hu I DI I ;jLAIO. 4 1F,=;LU kil l Ijllv11Ot x>1V IL_jl,,i L 3J Y U <4;'I)U,11 sLl .sMl t-1 :,L Jll -WI -I1

a Y.LI;JSjlEL 1MLg4(ILL) -1Vl' (lt5LC, ,I S l ZZ L J &1 L-,I:1 3ZJ- 1 eJ V l L,^ L4 ;1v1'- y 1,Pl L*-L ti L#L-l 'L- " L.1 YI Zq

.;J- Ve2 U.-'i ;1-"Jl^ U, Io .':1 ig Uli^§ I ;J o-L- UwS I5 l l IcLu -jail ,i J 1s Ljl ; . 'I b * L L&.YI vi~ Y,Jl Z*LN 11JI Q1% ;tj4 Y I A-s JL; L a,E_Y

J fi Ji ,U 1 S. lU l -,s tY ;L .5 'ej ,} _ _,71 VI al_ i , .;^c jiD*li -;Sis.L alI l,61 _,- Ylt i;ll ;.,L. , fa-k - %j Z," V , 5U tJ&J . d -,I0lie t!:!all S,,.,YIIS;

.C I .t U S 4 .1 Y 41oLuL - : 151 L',I Volli bj

t- L Y s,L..YL L _,- i eJ vl

LA

~5 .L~WlIOL. ~ i~~IJ ~~ ~~iIlIj z.,I.J CLL.~13 Z~L• 13U1 c L-, I

~.~I~JL' -U~lA l ~LvIi JJ-A-a1 I qUU UL-) J U

>,~ZfI l4i,, L. I U uj Ud I 1 J S 1 GU I lU I vUS I 1 I

Mijllls eLlJv and -) LCode !\JAL saS Knightllll5Gi

.4 -9) Z -- 1

-.qJLl 4l,., - , I - y J I | j2 SUI - ;LJ aI 10

_4..JLLIJI

ZLU 1il- iis : -Li v bULJI L S - :-Z - l -LL; :.-' .z-L-J1 =,Loll L li)>|4*J1 ialUI -1j L;

S;; l eLi I -,. I ilI .-* UL JI ( )JI C _ __ L

,1 .~~~~~~~~~~j - .CL;Y;1 Q 2>;G1 *-1 31 C (-5LJ lJ

Khn cl_, ,i :!a Le" I L' ;-;1

Mills and,f2 i IaCorden an unAn..and Knight

Ltz --A Jul-4 Lib N= , ,,.( Nalla riI Yl1 1S ILL .C .L- L- I W1DY ,Y-1 1 ai :%-£ LK-:11

Xj1 - ,Jd LI AR;1Jd

L- .,, -l Z:cLl 131-il L' iSUI ZIL-lI Lrl L'4y I ZWI J-

':.-tl L _,71- I - 18-

;.bLit L-ii I J ij U I r . Zj Lu ;p -,j Il. 16 -

Ls,( 1 4.l6 L ; U I L. Ld . I . -I 1

,5tE;SI U C U 1 RI 8 LiJl; L I-

{E2I ,.L -A Li YJ .iJ iUI O LI J14

~~~~~..L.i I LIUI tyI L - L?zy Io-iJ~

> ~~~~~~LS:l ZJUb I cel;-.L- II4s zcl,

1- LLII U- 1 4lS& I1 ;ULl -1 411

+5ua5pI >1 i.lU -glY ,rk t: .sharn and Kaufmrann ,-

I(LJI&J4IJ4

Lo(L i LLI I L1 4 AL W I

Drbensot and Bakm) 53 i gi > 1 .UW e Gg UW *5 .1l JGUI j11

W ,vr;xL- _- ,s;. L-i ->]1j S L c11ol LmljIjl

> 11..eI ZLl &IJI *c, 5L;êsil iL,

ueY Z LJ I c{fk * -II iJU-I�I3 1i > L sjJ s i

VJe a z LecL~jil J,-1I ~ ~ li1Jl 3J.1 " 4.3 - ., I451

Q. La- Lli JI-4 - U . )oI iL.L ,l ZS I-- J AI .417 Y I S LIi ZJL Ult: 1I

L.: 4; vl>il-i 1,1 ("mSA Corden) UL> is_,a. e ~. 9 lU*>L t s ifilLeA L;lj 5J;As,l s. S Al iL- aVI

Al - .11 I l LLiYI 5i JliL .U V I j l I /U Liv

L,i 6 UI s-:{J . LJ |tUI ;L,431 * -- I - I 4t1_, tLV I ?iS

"UI iL-il qj1 * L -1 Jl A l iLS ASl 6A1 Pq1-= *J aY j CAaXLiL1S

I-t 1,. Y) tAZLjl Li iLLA QliLl v'- j.. L. .1- IS I LS LM Z. Ij N>J I\ 5 I1 U

.Drabenstott and Barkema) L1 G1 vJ ^ -Yl ,j 41U I,YIi;JUI l oL6n I JiL5v

.~ ( Vr L' fl." L L~ YJ I1; F1 1 I

YLll fj"VDl R ;IVMV U0 ;2

vo)l L4 WI ,L_9_A dseIj '- ' Ul 3J-z-'lI i o* g

6- ,JAAq,: ,YV I L, y I L=I

-1 L,.:21 "UJI -L~~-Ljl 'Y II :,LA _; ¢ I Lhl Iif lUI iLsi ;,:41.1 .,3'I 04

v Y l. ll 4tj1 9 LJ e .;~ Al >t iL:!Y , Llt , iJU kin Li- X 6Yl9 i, - z 1| cJ2l,~Y ^ -Xu e4

£V

v I Y ,L.A * , J.;l W i M9. v ~I~ *IjiiJ;;I ( J .1 .lUfI *i 1 VLY MUI ,~d ,I; ;La

.; U<1 c4,iILl > JJ Jisk.. - I ( wiill J5i -U.4 -~ U1~J LLJI -~ 2.k vWJ I oJ4Uj

j L.=-Y I JIA _.A L.=Y L 4:I 6 la

oriWi XaRavala5;.LIilon :,.;1IU L dwQ 1jYJ ,I)i L.i;iti . YA ,k 44 -- (5 y^

~Q,.WI C: ZJJL -| 1'II bS lil , *

J - - j Jl V- , .v LLJ :

v ;? Jid *4 zl iL-.tl L 1; : u j c-f L LIEi l Q ij"j c.J- ct- Jw....................l

_•7IotI J ,- I jL.e LI JI Hi -+Vl J v° 1

. JI aY I &rlL J *1 oLIv

YJJ * .1vyI i vLA-. vA zL! GL vUl =Ii cIY .U #aj L=Y 1, '.-II J........................ .

JÎ FC LLYI" ;I Z iiL4 VC Je .I ll JI L 6 . lii L I1_ * .-U oLi o: I; 6 i1 LIS C

Ulj t: L=;Y IA ~J-l 44- *1X CsLW ;I Q *j O1 V YJI ZL:L;I IJ, ;LCv o

6L9 5FI: V L¢ LosYI ZiJ4J ll IJI aM L vL {I 18l54. tU.I oY Il v vi C

ubpY iiI5 ,LI,aL L&, IedSl aIJe Ct- *;G;L;LC.

, . - ui -4l;j;L Yl l-j^l Wvv I +-j --- *i &J 3 2 Is s ljwi LL- 'J" z * 5Q C;=l

* 1,,,11 Ll,ltv oLY I Sc Sc .JSI -E i > 9 L L-P I Q tL IUoCo

11 v 5L LL *1e O,;ljl-y *I _,21 I *aA J I Zn A, V C -1 J15 4ZA1;1§ V1UI~

.NA1.avillon L U1 Sll ,, LJ.F , ,~JX _ia V I41 I.l aL y

~~,L.ZY~~*aM IL ZJ7L-, I'l kaUl vZ;I I C'i _~JIJ

.J L; J II z ILI& 1 L

~~~~~Li -JnLYI . 4 lIiil bl>Y sli*il ;vw:ikllL

O%IJlIV j ?alilv a (EY .Yaron) ;Lm,j,SiL L.

a"[ J!La I~ I -* jk ,.

.;;- I &iI .: I I ; ,,J U I .li I ;- -L LS Z,L.- Iw I. 1 Ijc - I ; l

- iI. 1 vi- ii L Lj k & A ;JLJI . LL *,I (Mosley

Ii) ,i JVIi -(LA.jII as-jLri- -f4 JLjl Z_LL Mos.zle fA;.:,1

g YJ 1. L-. 1v r W' I a4-?All J,L #.!-I 1) .1 I W jL. LKL - LJI ¢

- ri-u I L_J 6.A1 t=G; -. -:

r+L ZZ- vX l 1-s* j,a,:3 i.,9 iSl ,"...................... ij- I M '7 vLj=l 'Z;S

VLa ; V I .JI J .l l " j' 34f U i 41 V 5 I JI

L IJI A J L ;AV9 -- ;L SvJl)~ ~ ~~jL.t L,:.*s ~1_*LV :LIA I L-i_,,.L ;, IL I II r

~L26

,0 I ge, - Z,.' fA i5 0

J JtA 0L t,Jl tiki

-20 10 201004 0

; ;.~i ~ ~ * jLj L. ,. -J U- .EJ >, -Lc. . .1.I I s. J i - vji- ,I IA J )L .

'U-1

20 - .... and M i e

2L -- -- ---- -9 -----2

->3 A 0---q---------- 10 2}) 33i - A -- A-K-REP

-10 -t030 0

Z,= Z- L151 oLLJ[j .oL-; .ZiL- ze1v L-,;l 1 j i .11?oLX Li' 11 I -,.:-,. :Zl.ztxJull:a

ma .Hulme and Mosley:,

.;1 ,-: V1 Ij LM * 1J1 I V U- z* I^ ;.- ̂ 11) CJL6'i 5s.;YI #1jZ W OL5J~ fal

* 18-,* 1 Jl lp 1* LLIJl 95111 f-jLII aj U1.1vsS 9AIll

& le;;LI:LIJ jllJ5:>,IJS I-, LvILY aji.z>L iu;lI

&US Ubi jL La L'i _,1: e a>iev I;YJV2Io

i ; oc1 YI l j sla Ju I>il IJ 1j Lw I Z lu<)h 3 Q e a |

,-JK-lz U6-. :1.LlJ;fi . i l Iy ju1

ii .~~~~~~~~~~~~Lai= L- l L .M OUIV l 6Z1'YI,L -Y {lI LI,

i,*-9LL 'I.IL . 1 Jl -U- ¢LJ

L4 YI*1DII)Y >-e 1V V jll S .-l SJIY6;1

V1;LV U- 'I^ )-<1; l 1 Y .U1e.L1;SflX W 2IA

5i IA i LtI>i1 )I eLLL 1. J:itwJ -jMv ; UIA

l~~~~~~~~~~6 'il I,:C ;L.L W. , *1J* A1 ^,1ds,1,' I A il.1

Xv \5)Mosley LAI H A -i ij. I1 I1.F

.<-LL.isL;YI l; *11 o; l ?Yi $il-'I L-J ss f Iiilu1i ) ;Y 1l >

X521 Lt I ,s; 9115;~~aJI 5 JgJiv; vi 1v. -A &*Yo iJ4e1 hL;~

4e; ISIJfL Uic le i;l51 RiSII vSi vjJ X.,L1.......... :i1 I >YVll

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Lg -alJ,;J.EU ,1 SIYI-).V1D;§ il -9 ,

CU f;u_ ;_L;:n IS SLj ;, 4aA 4lIa11VCqLl i:I, 1 !;LW

t,-E iL krAI HeG* JIgA 1 QiLL -Cjl; -,I j

Ov) .(A-Yr ,U.YI,-ii l ,LI

LIUI O1 ,J LIW 1IV NS L J Li •llI; .::,i () Z2,1SV ~,i iE.I ±3lC/,I? J ,L• ( u (XlV4,

tp., 4 IAJ "U, ULLU

-,CI AWI CIPI bLJ -. L=lJh LJLj O l1 I 1U• (1t

I IJ L.iS I bL _,aY I AVE - ;L I IL L.L

L,.i~~~~~~ ilt di -,II I V L-- L' lji -%r ? I - d=l ;JL% L ~ < l -tAi!L11

z,61 1;1L L L

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 4i4 L..±I .Af~.iI I

/) ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ jiA ULLIVA oi- L•, ~ * ~ ~ 1L. * .S~

(ja.t I hI - --

L1J a J*L_ ;JI U 1

J.m.

: llr- L ;, I 4;-1 :,I>i LrSi ... LWI :-L- .aS8?I ;.-..J... Io Elu-0M

5J ;IUI,I I -tS, X *; LAAIv, ... A LL¢...... H4;I E

-~~~L - -- ---r

lj.- I Li Li j,ULI LA

G -Ij -I iJL ll J.L-3L _LI . v ' L 1j LI 4.v I J ULL --

dL3 J3WI , *14Jl i -j L4 (4 VI J .4... jLL"I o l j1 .

-"41 LLi L-4,fl Lull t 1I i iJUI

lLi USI s sl i. -vi l *WJ >SIL

,1s4 J11 o u"- IU LtiW1V L1 M ~ WL•iJ *I J.ti u a1I Ud1 -I jilAl.V- W• I)i .i l I1 i-sL,Y I v ° J JI Ij & U y

v I, iI I ^ *I ..:1

I1: - 3I.L - l 4 L' ::UI d.. iI jYA LL.OJJI sJA Li " .Iuli; ZF I l *-34 L1 t ic. L.

,,1- -1eiey 5 JI JI..A J1l j1 4.V UlI Giy...CJI i L.Ii L;Ul Oi ai

A L. Ul.4As 1 -ZsjLll 1 ii1 L aJ I =s lYI 1 s; a11ss IJ- 1-Si I;iJ I 5

_,1 ;-l L. V .41 >.u1 ji& fi .L,~ll J, IJ;I

*;sLL I Lg;5 cj-LJI ;Jsla- V_" s5i iL c I ,ILYU. I oiLL.I i5 t l il..1YlY -i1A

F.; LKO Il 13FsY ZLl UJ I>t ;L3l 4-1ilsl Jl II wKI 1 l LII; Y SI

,4- s .1 LLI f OS?u°JIIIUL> 1 .?li*(LI I, ,ii 1r JIJ 1,BIy I Ia

;ll Jii al ;L<l Z. -1 5i)-a I;1 s,gi. 3; L~y >e 3IA LfAL

LL11~~j J5 Jia L,-i L. *lil .- L-,;1^-tI j Li= YlA t7*. -j

*FJiI -L b - a> d<*- "L& *Y" U I 4a y i &. 61 "i21

d * il.5 d ~~~~:;- <jlw1 I U;Lj..0 I c, * l-i Jlj (S3 lI~ y I * ;lRl

Y; &'. la VLiL YI Y Jl 1 V-;- U1 ? j1 A 1Xk(121j !LJ Lt I I L I < J

dIC-?I 01,W1 1;U IL, I].Jl CI?Yi ll ,QJULIJ6 -esisy 1; L-Y cL;"l;

ui &I L-> s ; i ar, *- LSIli)-SSi

C7J: :4- oL;.3?I L'J-a tJL ;1 I ilY &U;; J'ov -rJ.Y

t4=85* tigitz W J 1U L;-:I.eA I .! 4W ;X-> :L5L ZIUi ;ai1iloS I -I Y

; Z,51-;lYIeL j,1l111 :- ZL J 1>yJUI j1_'S1lM-ZB a L&

oBeley J1 oa l JL, tG~ eLt f11 S- AY I vlA 11 iy- I .|bJ 1

EiJlD Ml J i,~~~LU-IftJ;l,-sJl // - ;J L;-la 6U li

1j vL5 lilt- a-L- I; 1...... ,, -i L. L.: ;jI? 1 .k La .v*,I l; QLI

Qj-il f L iil ~WiL<z L5LLI ?=J1l NJ L-eil o >? I 1v:u ;Z--6l QL_,II ay! L&i Yl *;a4,a L -iit

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.a, L.1 UUl; 14" -M. zL ,l^v z J . >1il S:lj kil JL Ji Lz-- Ie= 1

ZAJ iUUI LI 4 L,,j41 1, ^- ;.,LIX j i ji l li

*K- Wf ;616 ; , 4.J l ,LJ4iYZ ,,HIL i-lSl ol J,>?-,

JLlaJ 5 .Jii L > ; ; JL ;cs1 o,L; IJI i;<1 5p4j.LIsJ

J.-I!,.1 YUI J = jli~ll _ l faw 'i LYJ .iL~lJv;: iL+K ,LI j, il;sLj-

,l a U (,I LJ L Lil L,IIM Z-JbLL3. L.J' -L-jwe 4Lall Zl<

OIJ J vLII ll x. C= LI~jI J-LjI , s IS L l g) *' 5.J _,WI -,jcL.L ol L ;,li

1 1 L a! LJIA I?,e la ,; . .l t;,I

-oUL I 4A L- I LIIl I LL *n .t1 Zkl>YI. 1 1IDJ iJl;1 o ;Li]

4 Cl tL:,. vl &'5 LsJ1 i^)Jl l:lj &XII 61~

I re LL& I iJr-IU I ,:,1 .... It

SS9Zl 4;-. -i4 V--.I -I Ji t& t -W L I

al JILlY LJl I W I L L+" iiLlul ZAiF XLLA rli L;X .gL ;v

,:L-WI va5 lz :Li i;U -~ ,11 It Vafjh .s ,Stipalitz) iL Le,

- .! I L.i -V Z A lU L.i LLS ; It a J | , L-'L' - U ; I L, LY v LK Ldl

Jwil cL-y ?6JJ &Jll ckGlS >~; Z L"I1 aIII J -lal L ;. -. L - Ig

u-J lj' -- Ts -I LiiLt-- 1L-L vi ;s41 L.A I Z: c L.!.J=

.(\8 tAV Nirmnani) tbL4 r v-. fl 043e L,;l I JL-; LO 9J l s 1 *1}4ZJ

e9lYI~~L+L5k,5 _IV Ll;lo>?i) JLsUSI z,L-,lssJsJ"

V4l;I;JLI -. IMI;(o~¢?JSfi5lbf *Er LS,;;)VYO5L,SL JL-

,l.~jLt", j6=1 :J -&ALiLL ,pL-;1 6L;!I rL -1T) j LL v YI

6U ) -JI Lqlai S (i1- - d uj IIj1$ot 1Iv

.A; , i, y i a L_ ° v i as v9 529i ;s S- ijjl

Z"- W <;l °I ;Liil il ° I L Li fi 5l 1Y Gk l I J1, j

Y Yl;.0 1.1S . iL§ 40 1 L .. L; I A ;l-11 CL:;

Jael ?5,- l>, IL.: Zs;- ,S1 W I L U l ;-Zs eIQ I 5U; ;L.L ;Y gj,liilJJJ_oJ-: 'i I LvAj3 Ze- ,II I= J-L 0. jLo L^!i 4 =o

Z>,; tylL, 9 -) 'LuIv 1 , U1_ ;-1- lcl J3.JL_Y ILL JA+- -i v°f

vo+iwl JQ L>> ¢ L >YI L,-, L. U v - + I 'Y l o - L. 1 jY I 1

Z's.- 1 .:;,-oA;+S ZUe Zu1j'l M- " 2 1 W1 >-_ a

UeL5 l 4 LIO S ^ )lLY ;J.;) a1 -aj Id LM LLIHI .1~ .. -YI AU

DS; ;_oej JLi Z:- ,J I zub Z,) 11L JA 1j% I J <;*_1 YX*=>sG,I -- (

IE Ji L. 1, L 5 9 J VE-L - I iUL VY I ."1 0 I , Li I I^l^ L:5 1

-j i,JLU-J1_ 'i-llo 411-i, (1pi Ae L'.

La ,~J2I -YL I LS-Ut -LA -XV *@LIM

.,,MAo Wt\Ac .Rees LLU1 - 'VL5 i*;'5Lj.i5 6~

.J-I s us°JjtLivL -G vl51 J!_

ajlil ;L5JLfiOvs1(5 Besley*

1L,~ I- ( p La L.li U X@ ill fLl l ,I= JIyYI

*1X? e >I L ez * ,-*L ,.z", Zvijil o t slj1tSIti v t

L , L.O II4 ' 1_>L;; Ll YC L'YI _Lz OL3 I L,Yi L-i 0;IL jI ; * .-A 1 6' I V° 1

SS~~-1 ZV1. YI :Z1.4 tLAJI SeLw,',Fl.;1 L, 0 1 luli f.lib

' Ui ePJ> li e±.a.Z n. (-xl .. ]U~I 4; = > 1*i .i,J i ul

J_D ;-z--!I -34;! ,L5I,, t-o Li 4 L14 I t!kW I~v

jL-M tilul I , L*i I isU ,1! as: Z - - -NMs .Besley

. a C7 9 J Y );JL PM

'-V

rv L. 4 ~,I J- N . .. VI 4 ,LjmI -Ll L.-j 4 L; VM L,.Ji : 5J J

;AIj;II L * . 4UII ; ,4, & s I J l-tj'.1 .Be1nett, Cuevas and Yaron 1 VtJ JL Li.o 141 L4 1i I VA. JL J1 1y. - ;

. oLiL;L^Y va iLL1 >U i•Ll.i L~IL o iI UL lU L3J g tL~il 0 1tl

,IW ,Li-1J.ll SjLI.z1. VL ,-1 e--11 * -- 1el.A1 VJ s"z1

4:1; &IIIL LAIIJ 4JJ v u lillLo'Is .I illLJ1Mi&U iI& LI L9 4 JJ

\ = sV¢;L4,11 ,:JL ;LL.41 r L Q- j ^v- L;I J1_*xll fj

I' i 5iu 1 L ,i~L

vLI oY LI t v. A LLtfA J _ J, I LJ ILIJ i1 +4A

;; , -- . IV 4. I w 4i Y V V I L Il oIJ i-lU L3i ' iji J .QL.

Le tlV+fJ >~I ~ 5IL J*011e EMII OtLLjI C:llJ,II tU0 "t :It.Lf .:J1 t I 0,9

v ai,lJI oLI ole, JvIL WI.U,1 V t1I rWI~=

Gre.noad and)LYI ~II,, W~1• IJ J 5.k 4 ~Li1I JW V * Q$ 0 ISJ-a1 J tL 11 ,I I* 4

LI 3 L.(I I 1 ,1

* % 8 sBennett, Cuevas and Yaron :,.-I Y J . L+] ;I 6L?. Ue VO LSiJ Lii; -e

-131 c,!L -,La c,L- Ib .? I9 sJL..s 41*1 jlj 1LL-,1 j. 4

d a -t1 ELL Y....... I LiJ It J1 ay f,EI OLA,.................................= Is L-2L~ L*il j

gH i * 9 a *till QI6L-L> JJSI

QIIU Ilj ; tV l.YC4L jLL-illL Ja eJJJiIJL

v'( VM £) Besley 1L,:!L & LU11(92I Lsi iLU11 I iI I ,.-II I Lr9 if ULW I L @121 J.' 1 *W/

L.i a1, ILi z L,YI U9IaD t iJlUI jII *LlL....... HI ll ;YI *A &l ;i II5i

;L I1 iL Lil I9 i.lUI I WI, Y I zYlJ ::'L=, L':21 iJU OLX I a.i Lsa4 vl 1 v3 Li; j1- s4

wi=l ZiK Z: l ;tlS 11 UI t A .- - ji l;2.. . .............. 2Lir d I;t U LI >I 1. L-. I L -A 1,9; L + Vt V

L6 -I t7i LI IA I W I J ,:J I?S( 4 I 1 A -- ;L3 I; l ZS W-y 1J IH J . I J! u Y

-y-1 lilj * IkIoJA i2ja Ri,l ,:,LII I 1:S 1 , .il,gl " W LI.-I

UI ? 1 L<,L Jv DAÎ VA V9 Y L5 I| d" ...........Li +

_9 131 WsLaxsj -L..W YJst a r V*JJ1 e 5I t

Greenwald and) YIL:-ltil -9;iJ,Kj -1t11 J rL ~Lwi 'L1YI 1' *---|---VJ

J:; vl'~ 1 i d YiJU jI i L~ -(VkAX .Sticylitz .i*-^- k A L:1 4-i v Y L, ilj

,s5.l je l A . i (8 ) Hettige and Steel I

.A Li ,l' nsj iUIi19 9oS 1 u t---21:-

J,i (NIk) Binswagner and Rosenzweig * - r -

L,. oi JA I ,: isll L1 *l5;1i,=s.t ;e;t l z = U J I1u

L5L L I 9. 9 L) L4J -L11i i J i C J.uUIl iLWa ,, U; .±L.il

JLI.j-l J JL Vl,i Z•Jl JL JI 4 --I I L.

*~~~ .Jlti;J I 1; 5 L#g5;j iU5- 1 < AdI L Lir tI J-l .Ji

Lit.l• w . lda1 5 I ofhtmllcg 'WIp .Ltnl

-~SJ j ~L•I - - * G1=1 1 ^;--- *4n*)jI 3jJ0U11 zjrLL• 4 . t ILII osilol1; JU 3I 1 9

-zLiS l L * Li J;l J 1 * - -: d -- 1.A -(L Rmasi and Townsend

vL I,1" I I ,;1 L; PLL cJ.*1f J1JI JJ.- ;> -

I J Ul tLL L. I..LJl. LL.:J I a ( I) Gl.;LSI L 01 ... ; ",yl , , Il ,I -4,

6> 1 L L-l:- j' l *-LI ' rU "ou", .,o c ,;

(J Li),6 IIV A, : 01t Y af,lI ItI Ou L;UL -_; CL I,:.

.Bttmey 1 J5vA L a5AUx;; 4Al L; :J * L ;s; J-9

ZLi .^- *- r 1 1 C (AtQL,Ij eY l k LLIT 4. EL. Jp

1L ^N 1 -I4L>49 i> JL e 1.OES I asdl WS&EL

-J-15 _4 V I L., 1) LJvj I 1 cx1 -A 4- * J;a-tI-wwwrdakoghticaigph

(;Y Is L Lli -iLl -Z ;31- - C,2 I -,: i; Iu -IA -2 V. ^.tI.oii Iahta:

.;SJ ir j;i1iyot 3L11 lz/- L,a ;U "Focus

(J i 1 I Z YI s itgee] Ji A 61 t -,q U al /I LLLI cLLJ LL.P ZX^ a .

It Y/ Z,5 1~ -, ,15l ; IY .lS .il:. LsJ2 AIaXL

,§1 L E I C--Ll , ; -1/1 L .; - J , Aif JL-9 ÂiY lLtIj .L

.LJAi ;. iLUi j-,: LJIi Jl XJI sL--< ';i 9aL 919 2

. ibJ jirllM UlvlYgM A t vvi l i ., 1611

iLi5 ¢,.V tA.& f, Zri 9I U =j a It ww .orJldbnkorgthtll/cIaapca.ht i

.s;5LS u4l *I L3 f,JUI egI AL'i wLS WI, 6. u, itJ L,6 J; .d-l I -i UV

skLl;-?YI CIj s,1 I.^;" fij v .L-I I J141 ' L; ^-:J I zi Ls a.I t

.Z .LJI LL dr Z.J U11 3 L 4iY LLj:Q I-g ( t£g LiIiA1- JS-iU I L.< li.ll~-L

Vu i-1 IeI:l - .

*j I ;. LLf - -, Z- --

i.S J>j4j/ ta;t i aK&5 -Jj;, *4 z, S

3.0 _-J ji li C.i W, L,1JL S

0L0 - V *Ll > L L; - Z,JLJ Y I

204 - Ji el V-1 usS " SJ .1 " J

2.0vie 'V* _,. (5=.I ZL4I_ s 1~1

j I~ ~ VLi ~J~ L•I.,. U . LI J,.Lf Ll i L;LLI I

1.5 -,. ;..Si -, ; Cl. L -i .<Jl . Besley) aM JJ &

4. J11 Ja seVJ*L n,.Y

10-;y I LI L) jJ511 VI^;L zL ^- UI La ' fL

0.5 -L•J .I .OA2 ^WJ (5lM) Tonsn LUJ (JU J- IJ Jh

SS,1~Li~~ ~~I J49~tI I 31 J LJUI -9,YI I V

0.01 Jl 11 i* 5 l lLLl

t1-o *) LJul C1 (.JL, ji) ':L;. -i.~ Ji j;=l < L,- ;.iescLLIJ Z vUO".5 .L. \\-E) 1j IY -l- 'Yl- -l

ZLj;II Vi -L>>Yill ,L'I$iSl Z. li :,1 UI ,11 Z-.2Lj L L I Li5 ;U I lj.S1 I2 _L cL{ 5 L 1

¢ ;l 1;Lls 1 ,iS U _l i--.U i 4 L il I LJ U I 6 ~L

Irl II-j; Z:-j I 13 . YI L'i Z: U I; C9 1,-Y1 J9-.=LZ:]k + yLIA Il + J =

c,L-f,lI ?I I ' S-1 Z...... v-;iEJUIJ I c L.] -.......... _..... 1_, 1-( ,,I) d ^4 . Si (Ly[

Rashid and, ( S)Udry Laf,,-i Lr7I r, ':L i[ .dul- 'PYIl(£C* 4IKe-i5 ,

,.L1b1 l;; t(8tQ)Townsend IU U 1: L-,I LL& I= .U I L; IYI J)o

c,~ ~ ~ 1. I j Y I iS,h ZIj eL. 1, li.~ ,1L. iJ9 L-= J& &. 4 11

j'. La I L,; I~ J '1 I ;.l I_ I LV l-i ,SJ G I ZI-a I 2 AV f i

Z.Ll U5 L,iU L,sIY I JoU .JI-,-z, ZSL , i I iL%llj7 e' Il,s LL I LAU Ls . 5,1 ; I LA L.

; LUtl Li -i vLL2I SLiIj-: ,; WUS tl 4i J-SE L+,;]t -1 ;Y LA .CH11 I I,

svi5J (L~lI Zai_UI ; "91.1 i*YI aCUs ;L,2 LY ;V ,,< LJ 4Z Ll JU L-_ll ZJLL I i

J-1j uL,i l" 1i iL-lislol? L;J .:l lJYI &5 Z1 JU .j1 Q, lL I

L- Ji 1,.;ll laA Y L,.fi 4.LLs j5b t7jtl j; jluU

L7I I L'i; ,l JI>I LI J -- l I a L,s1 I ( 'li I iLA Z I1-1-JLI , D,1 L,Li -.:IX)l Z# k.1l Lj r l ; ZJU ,L J &S-0 .JU

I l ^ g1 ;L-LO I LLJ .1 >1 . Vl. dl- iJ,UI j L:; U" cf -

.(-7J ZIr VIJl) La1 LLI ,' I1

II

;LA

F I

1999 C -JIIJ 511 I

1818 H Street, N.W.Washington, D.C. 20433, U.S.A.

Library ~ ~ ~ ~ ~s of Conres Caaoigi-ubiainDt

* iE 4;, >1ou I

d.. at;_9,sW,1 :it I pl L ;Jlj =1 1.'1l Ll LI,J: ^ Ls 1a1dii I,J-il il J-l S 4 lL- I I L; i JL SI-r*l,

Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data

Yaron, Jacob.Rural Finance: issues, design, and best practices / Jacob Yaron,

McDonald P. Benjamin, Jr., Gerda I., PiprekP. cm.-(Environmentally and socially sustainable development studies

and monographs series; no. 14)Includes bibliographical references.ISBN 0-8213-3737-81. Rural credit. 2. Agricultural credit. I. Benjamin, McDonald

P., Jr. ll. Piprek, Gerda L., 1962- . III. Title. IV. Series.HG2041.Y37 1996332.7'1 -dc2O 96-34492

CIP

J1,41 -W L IaIB 0J I 82 .. 1 1 4 a4 7A-

ISBN 0-8213 4476-5

NV ;g1j GULI ELLt oLa Jj I 1W

NV VLuLU~ iLLji,7I QU

NV dL,*Jl jLL;= b1 cL.L

\ A d j1 U U I d IY I-; Mi M -1

\ s 1 d l- ..t O L | L

NA "9-L:j

TN .LdI J5, = >>l6,II e SLW LY. ~ ~ ~ ~ L L,l;*2 .,JI, .|tt

£V iLUI 61jI Z!4; e&IJl L.;1I

£V ;i JAI ,1I jL31 I 1£A 45Li~ISI GR>LLSJI .. I j^ Uj

o h,iiI~I~ ii WI a JZ6K .UL.V 1WI J L -L,I

0'r

oi Lz JLUI

-,Ai l Li;u 1 -1

O'r L-ui

£o 7>1il9I ULLphI 5,Ls;11 *ll alY V±lAl W;II

o £ : " o1 : l J-! , ...... ,v a

IjIW U.L.JI CIL U S L-J ill J.lJiI

v r 5L;=l l

AV LLJ

t,Lj;W LIZ61 pLI,T,.6. Jll .;I J ll

\ 2i ;l I l u ..11I OUJI

WIWl VL l V-W L L

AO iM 1iJI C1, L11l <-, VO L) AI LK L-II

AV ;JILVj1- JilltAA R 11 VLyI kl~ Z- I LI\\ V L ¶l 5WI', . - ^g JSId

8, .d H GUI O Y.

D\ IJJj GIiJjd .@l >-vr \ 3llJ L,I1

;Yr %L,s C ;l fa bjtLA =l r-f

Yo ,yI4.,J IA II ZJi. .L. JUl o-Y

rv *1l ILL<j 5 : eUlislAi -

rA ; I,Y Uli Il .L1 ....l WIt JlW IL JSr-rA aUIl :LJY^4i1JlLI iUI aLlUWI eLj VL~ £-r

rS gjbL:l Uj4 tl ZLZ.?Y' I I illl ;K -t c-r

££ E s *K .-.I J~ V,L=-I JA A-T

£oj-zL, ;LUJI i^J :cliil 1s Lzei I

£S 't ,gLll c,kLil IS OLLu. iziLll ^'I -o

o'k co -,121I f=i L&L= oL Y ZA.X I I I- 'V-o

oAa1 1 ldiei14 a' -o

Li .-- : I LOV I L; L .11i IF, Z,5,L .:,- :L I -% I A. -o

° Jl V?XI^ Z5JuLl L- 9 GX >l V.90UI f:; -O

OA ;il ;JjdI ~, = J1 I LiL-ZIJ-G;l L. I O-O

vo Li OI Ail ,Lu L--'I !CYI V-O

1£MV4lA L;il, L, 1_1 ,JIY 4L' t1* I -;ELV , -1 LYI L,. J,HZ C_Hd 4I ilA 4 -1

VA . .I IISI \ .--

VL 6j=Yl 14 LJi J 'r -v

VE 4 J.11 iJU ,,I,,YI ,4d >Lil , - ,,I L I ,LaY B9 .I;Li i -V

AY J"ol=Il . JLaSU W =1 ,;L,L Z,W Jl Q L;4I ;JIL 'r-AAr slio LLiI LCA111 ZA' 51-,: 8 £-1

r IL,Ji. L 1 .5I ,.. -v?=£ S1 ,Lr-AZ1I _A.y1, Y-v

So tW UY M= U4r-vL1: V'l ;JLc . Z - - sj V,l9Y ULk l c1..,4 )>?- J2 iEIOv17............. -V

SV ~ J .............. V-AAA L IL) u4 V4 j;I J=4J ,SU UWIJ ,ELLI JL;41 A-A~o.V

A II L,11 Z ,1 y-A

; . . JI j67_S1 vL-YI Y-A

. JLISU ;; C.71Z PL; ,L L11,9; - LI.-a ;.UJ _;6jil ,> r-A

L .r I7 - ?L C; I S1 LU M 14-AI . ~ £U H oi IJ ;--_;I I 1 .- -A

r *i ° J , e 4YJ - ;IIJ LL.;1l c o I -A8 E Lj i fi41o,;1t a j1 ^Y iJUI O;.1 6mA V-A

~I Li LO

N.V I ,il1< ?; -A\.A ;4jl iULI i4L",,jl 1. H -:l-?l8-A

,i * akiL L%^ I 14 L^ I \-A\~4Lal . (iL LJIJI .nIj tlldill dAiY Y-A

\\\ iH1V*I L3VAI\X-AM LJ. I2 I^.Zl;,l- ljl-{>YI J9 E -A

N Vr ailI i;L"7 I _,S >L-.Y DI Cr?4 -L i~I;± I i.41 I L= I 4 \ O-A

\\o L+."-Fjj J. LI I \-k-

\A'2 skz-l I55 3le Lit Irbt ciLII 6-1 I4 L-6 Sul? l4\ i 1-i aI -rr£ \ M L, ,1f v vt I LIj L,_ I-

EA J4:,.Jia Lta;L; 5:l Z=1_j)l, a,6= : t j;4 sYIZ iiWI i : Y I 6-1 s -£

,4u~~ - i CJa9~llj iJUI o.Li Y o l.X ;;I4 \-V

q3 Z -9 ;I jY I isi: Y-V\

M Y i55- \tAV I1> .?1ez1 ua a,v a I A1-(i) 1,--A J.- j LAv c

1 Ji *(I J. - ( -.Alie) Q ,i Q I. L

- ____Y ~I~:j 1 *( ) 1S LIJ3~ .~UjtsiIJ e I 11 & J I SY ~ I Vo

NT i Z £j I (E 1,i) L1, - .S1 (±) 1 U

XYr 4; 1> (~,J)1 1 1 V-5

L:uL1O I Z I1J Ie!.1 w I 1S13- i1 LA1j~i I jL W .IL-1- ZaS A-k

Y 5£-NAAV A1v1 . Au .,1 (s) 1 - 4YI 1 A, .IJ1

.:,LWjt=IJ eIJ1I Au JA ; ,~ 4 .5U1@1 JA1 .A9I *- JyI;'fiY \5£-SA , 19 .>1 141 .,pY Z4 L-> I "cl

.(.Lt) l~Jji .U,~l, oLsI A i alJil vs ,JI JLI;l> s - • iULLI WZlbII 8 -

-~ ~ i L ?~J~'I 3k

rY,L~,, 9 , > I Au ;L ~ .ju1I . , < l = 4J . l rNAA V,)u 4<S IL^Y - VS1 aLlll, Il9 Q-t -

;1j,p Di. IjIJ sl- -1 s":lj ,11 eJ2Yl S JWI JULoIj ZL> _ I ,*J1 ,$W 91 -V

%NA JllU >.1K:;-4

N~~~Y lflJt E- kMQ_SJ

\YS S*£~L-8AL- OJI J.1It UI C Lvus>4--IJ Ij 4l l 4Lj il lt -

,ISI~~~~~~~~r JL=-ES 4S u jl,lJ,I ;I1-g

iIII

I

I

iii

i

L LS I QI;II D L4 Ji z .. I LiU 1.y ' i 4 ,JLL[:=I.i1LI *,L lI,

JA 1 U I ZL.a A I 1.1U.iII , . ,L4 1I . .,,I U; 1 O, j ;1 1 o Liii ,WV - 5ILtJ r."iJ '4hI

U'VIIIU' z ~Ld1-.i Z~LJ"c 1.4"LLi-j'-, :, ~L.4~1I s Li UILj

.Levine,fN\vr.Giovannini and de Melo) Ji:,ii LUL," dLJ UL.JLJ I; U0 Ltol4YI

Li L,LU ;zWI J 1 o vI L, U'1 L. IIj ,YI M L L 4 ZUI , £ -

13 Vl5< L.W -L.1s 11 UL Z 1 A.3AL

iiUe Lil-lI L&a>15d1- ' lQ;IS E & >1 V ^;;v l 451 41 cst J

*e -J W 4 aJI JL ;JLWI i * -t-v J ojjJJUIj 5i-fl .L.....: 4l.Lj_)- ILJl

ill.'i: >uL .U' 1 ; 2YI LvI ,i: .il 4_I Lcl -ill o 9I I.a J11W .,± ti•IW. Z >111

Ut.!. I Q3I l l ULII ZL,iI > oL> I lo jJeSII i * - 4H 4. l lYI i J59.i4 LI 451 UL. L o fb.I lUJI , Jl Y I LLL 4I-' 4J 1 * fi " FALL I 1J V 4 .. I 4 <1 ;a jt tJI L- L•l

i Ir ** i.± ;jIl-ill j l * ' ,I ;; . LLLl Lf L" _%a5i i..iI-i .*- -l L n1J1 iJUI .3_)tl

tL'JI Zi Jtv A l& . L. .L., *1 Z=;J I A vs U Li .i - A 4k L. 4 4,';'' S

4aIl j .. Li L .JY I Y;l.4.1 iJU. I .1i1 I -; k I-'JI I t JL4 I I I

C: z. Z1-1 .1A a 1 J1.s L .LL4;J.i c t4 Z LLI3 t ;Lil Lj

,C,jWl 'Ci Le t,as.JU LIilJ i 4:kAj z4L&L- k:?-, -;YUI z6LLs,s

J1 N laA Kt-,5 J9--; :Y- Ziss *L,fiii S Z6 L9i - iaUI- ;I-- o <i 1-.1 Il

fU;J,0s I eI;*; J-%L-& J_" I c r. L ji JA~J I WJ, L LLC - i f S XI *1,1

Gt -- ; Yf I Li -Ii L ,.-L 1-_ J~ 9A (;L- Li l

* L.~j-;_A gL-_I t. sJL 6.2 te1 I0 Jl- I L. It c' I

Ji fL5.- aLA.6Y JL-t§ -'_ I , ; U;-FS Z- *[ &l s..eL J _I,-6;11-

I -' iA o r I i ;L.I JI .;: -. t

\jAY Dale '.I . Bae an A A : J. IL Z, ,i L IL. L i, i iI 0

oLZZ &,-L i l I ZL-2 I * 6 si-t L v I-I1 I ,i i ,,0 9Lo-S (J---JI J Li-J

. ilUI 3 I Y, l ,';SI C-uL -jil Z-= ee -lj eL, ,,1 JU I 1Jt

iUI1 L A * j-:l Jl iJ, LI

.Y I3 co iSI ojl ;9a~U

,¢,,A,YDale{X fv. Baer and Caprio :,L. r "L. lcl _LlS>ll~ ULI I &r-

. Y8.olizatto, J Iv ,,.lJ

JL~l 1dI 5.LYI I WI Y J L ca~ UL5J-) 2,L I

4L- ~1 I, L OL- J I I L,l Yl , ,1. jI Yl ;.t I

LL L4W isL kI a J1I ;U UI ziJI L f9

,;.:21j I LJ U 1uiJ I I and; . ; hwI I jiJ I I 4- . .1 Y,. d I,a I E - ,I

-~ ~lsJ , 5J, 4:1 ,L,1I..11 4W, E9 LI~ d ,C-L iJU iz UI Z;LiJII ,,1 -,. -L JISIYi jU. JLE1 A~I(J

1_I3 ;l VS2lI tLA, JZf :I ;v.i _,6A ) JL ; L.C5 (v=L;l JLL 1 jil) IH S L;V2J

-Sllj7 L.Z 11 .IY ELLJ I ;5L; Ij C.. >,aI Oe J 4baA LJLIZ .5G1

N - 4il ; .1L:JI iLc UI L- V-£ A, IY L UJ .

8\s .Jramli, Schiantarelli and Weiss !%VTr llL ;eLLGjA1 Y AI1 S

n ad Lvin L .McKinnon and Shaw, Ii

-41LYI J .(\,kMA.Fry, MTr McDonald) L-Il s a1 vL,-j I sL. IA ,k 1,-J IA L4L- j: I L L.g K

~ rJ Jk eoW ;li j 1 vil l . JIL L e.- il I ,7 Li -JI J 1 IUJI.

aS- lVj XAp,- -- 7 - t:jilL JK Z:@ Lj I -j I

. 8 sJES-\tV£,~~~~Li ,;.-,1es tJI U i I Lf 1.,'l I lo1JQ -1

.King and Levine) QYLÎ 1 iA. Jlg

0 __ _ _ _ _ _ _

-0.5-5.00 -2.49 0.16 2.88

( ; )tel'J ,, ' :-zI;. of1 L-,,I

oT Z.WIZtl Z6

L-I U lU JI JJL-mI U ;• I5 I ; eD l I ;L._

j L) LUJIf ; -I3U , dI ca1 IJ U,Ai L J d II -;I.

~5. ]I>; }i±I l ^ S OLJLI L5LW ; L) AIJ ; ;5jllI LC~1I JI, S4,I *.-*,I4i1

,,tj.A>>JI1 a J2l aji -K lI jLz-i Li jlrMY ; ;7i SJL �L _4JAIU

Caprio, Atiyas and) *1 IS j L_k1i3 L L;..ii ;;a ULI c - t LJLI U

* w-9JI ;=it L dx cg :) Gis± j J (8aE MHanS LLsenI d-h 3 . ALt l31 -L-L•-JI J5.k *4 I

CtL U9 I I - I V~- -"e l M I 4l j SLl,;, I1 ; S :,- V: *

B~~IL O�L-jI_ iL W.3? -;~Lj I V-SJ;t ;UI sI c.9 SLIIt ,YWLvl IU

ZZ-LI. =,L" ... Uq-1 c*lalj aUZs d 7JV- Ul * 9:1 UI' "LjIL vl E"V 1;16 '-1LJ L-ill =

_'LLIl IL mg iaL dj l "i I._J JF?I; 3L~-l .^! E 1>^ wd^l-tlil L

U. I .i z, pl Lj,~ k Xl >lj L," <t! IJ- oi; JL-lI IA lvi 5

O" WIJI

~~Sajli 1.I LAl a-l;UL

IWL u 4 11I ,LjJJLA1J JItaV

65 iL < 1 IU J 1 I 'JJ , ;-LI JI. IJ ;1ih k VlII J ij I V j-I ,,

I 'JD ' l,LLiJ I I L-iS1J lL ,. L - 1 1

-iLi, I Li' I I i Iu#j I JU -Li IIVL llvYlAif 'A''''TL,V-1e¢> vUll l = X ^ J5L,;.

L,v- J' E_LrYL L J ,11 v .i tL L _.

LW 1 ;.i 'oL : U lI vLi-L XtJiI ol1i l i5k

; ^ u- IL IJ ,i Ea J JIW W ll_, -J L YLA

vi .3 U I , i J_ll 4 VJ ul yJ , d- 14W 1 t3L4 -L 9 ieJI L ;il yI j1 Vo i J1 -.ai I l .ii JI J I e l I IL JL UI I U> 5.i LA J.1V I a- I I

*j&l ,JU 1 L d LI V 31 - Y *C Gfk - i ,IJ L, iM ,!YJ.LI Li Y :,L" 1UU J5A: titli v 1 J5UI 6 .Lli.,>,

_,I J U V" V LlP- JI l ,J-- J .U=,1, LK

LL U- *Y~: I-i _,w ,L I I I ,L, LAJ I Iy a ,,J

-e .-; -_ | i: L,1<t ^ t I1.d. ; . ^ ^^J -- a 1~

4Aj- -L-J.1-11 ,$S J LSSi; ^ IJ ;f- LL,~ L 1eS

l•I ILA - -- L.a J,lJI U I L -& J,I I * 91 ;3 L LK i 4; .j:jL jI

U J-1 -Q l (s ALj .3i L,.): I L iI Q, pi Ji L w 'i -if 3 i ;?." I ZtL-I I

Ri c; .:tllQ- IzL '

9 J l t • .oL'II s *(oaI ~I LS JL - (Di8I ) L1LU ......... ;,WJ 8

- -.. fLS -J1 J.. (i oii) J s;Li . 1 ^ 4*-ILi ,.WI ~I;I~~. 4J~4

4l1J1i .Z 4 V esI H1i .o lCd U 52 ,iiy vL.L~ jJI vL VI; ;1I ÎI '. . - 5 iij. L

v >5I tLi :1sVI -.~LJ LLsJI tj J, S I ~j~i..LU 5L,. 1 ;3 Li;: 1 ~JelJ i i.l ,ILg

5i (v I yU VI2 JoJI eLi JL ; î&A 4W SI ; -l o Lld > l•i VaI ^ . U1

&L V4 L, * -1 JL~I B29 IA V • I .±ilYI . ZIXI s iJ 3 l LJA~ JIJ.Ql J..-Z cL.i JsLV

esLS2 L: -11 jJ V1d e VY~I b.l J L.Vi ~o eS Y j 3 i ~J 4OVaI JV4 JI .~j JUUI G5

oL- ,t -5 - oL,, 1 vil dL.JL- (SlaAt. - 1)jlS I V L

1t9j I Ll dj-- I ji IC LA -& L'. dU~ I1 I . ,j Li. IA zo L i a U Li. I' I L

3IAS -y J-j il8***<j L;j vol vL' IJ U LI ;i 'I" L14l ->lj U q: JL;L I- L..................... J d . I

< j ±,:wi o Vjl.&!l ^ < Ail vLJ L,J Z5Jll c ,13 " Vc;I LrjLe r>bL a I

aJ .,a1VSI4- ve :1 il L v^4il V'J td l L,it 91 OLzYl J|tI t4

v 1 t7J Ii l: L- is 4J ji V4 'Jc Ljj SI k I Jv I Ii '.;i a; Z1Jei; 4;Ll -U U^ I Ls

L.,-°., s 8 -° IY ->it) 44Lll &Vg *ol U?YI

Is 4,L 1J L-U L 5*DJ :L-71 ai -IJI ;Lill LA uZZl1 ;al

,,o,z2,l~~~~~~~~ d- 5aq :> 91t. L Y 1 OLL. aulIveS

aLs 4>;s--X 4,0 ll J~UilLV'j is-;F - 2 YlX ... L1-.1 L6I l; I S:m ltv

L,.-, ;.3 L^ ^< i A * dl1 s1, oi L.SUl I v° S 1 Iojl -%; Jj LA

,1- ld S;:#ll<.bj 'Ij Jvl 'k v3 " e L. I1 a Li Y :,A L-J . -II I o<-L4

La. |.f 1o gl,I 1 LA <t 1 JL? -, ,l- e L1v LIL v~I L.

i <- Z::9 i: is- ,I, LJt (el-Z L k 7,1 <z I Sl-| Jil a,; | 1-- i ai:; iLwI Y11

.s5c I;l goI A 4 bIS 11 4 A. dA L = tMijJ4 I JY v-~

kAQIeLo- :%-- jEl.1

CS; cUE Cll L; J .-.- IU -- 4L .UI;Y

= l U i 1j1 -LY j;ll VL-' j_,L I &y .y!-At. f, u1i YI . I ,,.aL, I I, LWI LI l.YIJ- v j i lI -l- j.

(Si (Ld I :A_ IJi oL -- :C - %,-LJlA 5i A L ;zA I Y --J 1 t ,A1 4 .1, t1 ; I L? #

J- -)LmJ yJ U- Iim u j S:i OI Lk,! il jU

.)ovwFleisig and de la Pena : &._J , ffi -

f J t - vt, uXi s cl-§.LL* jXj ~ hlI (,1Y.L BI) L~J 5 ~ L E £............. ..... .a.. IL.W

UK7 1;AL. .Lxl4 I I L UJII AlJi C - L L1I .LL*J .•I

LS Js-IU Y J-1 Jfl .<a s U J. J. --- • I L4 L 1 I L.V 1LJI I0"L -J ik"JLYJWS 1*.31 LZ ,jJILI1. V Z .JSIl L ( ; 4.L.lI 411 4.. L L-1 ,i l i I -kJZJI L1I

YJ ,L4 J.;U, ,IC .11~ . L~ lil JL w...ii... .......... X C LL~I gLXP .... OWA VC. V.W J,IjJJI S1 L

' JI c, < L.) LI J, iL1 L. ii ,L= 1 , JIll.JI d t iull bLi I V

CAEaAI~~iJ~~~~ -~ JYl ~iLX-I aaA L~ UJL* iLILUl4 oWl ii L otfl e E i , V LOWI L -11 :Y-o, vI,LY

l;.. CALR) LJtI JaJL _ 1 ;4J L=L'Y Ji L;.l Cl,;il Q Jl h;A Ll l V4I; ;:1 N iJI

4+S] ;JLS-YG[S LjJ I 1-L Z3. ;IJ Z.,:,= c .. . .................. , L & JJJ ;," g L2al IAEatalv 'L L j0Q-fl 4 Y;A4;~IIOSL-OLR

IV IL - 6ll4LJ ; A, L;!Ie Ll J- 1 u5Y.SLI:5kl

&5-JaL-j.: Lii L-19 1v 1 -LI t, e '_-=gI _A f, iJ~fi jYgD W Î G A s oiiX ll Z.1 'Ifvil* J eb

99UL ,w lJ> -;IIJV L -L;J;1. 4, 1V ' -l aL; JIJ1I

_)-_CA E D- S Z LJ Q VJL ;^J-

!J- 11 8LJ CARE;*J Z:: X 91 .I.tl,I; ,L z JU1olalsL1 ialOLI tJ%4; J

,,,--,J S-. 1.J JUJ -Je- -- 16: v^ VJYCC L tu ,lslJVJ9l1 1, -a A-ji tk, VY-I -k,VJ V L, * ;&1 eJ SCgl 1zj L.. ._x UL IJe-! -

_+I 4"J LILJI ? --1SSU¢;:J I 1A e s aSij -< 4V s= YI baA ', I LZeG DMZVa .OYI,J I L'- l9 I;YI OI J 1.1 I .,A J .CARE J:LLi- .al.Z ................. UI

. wo .Farah :J ,aJI 1 I

" a.6 L UI i 9 1, •le 6 i L-5 i LZ iJ;l JL- * ;ILlI y, 9 * '

S.$ a5. Z LaII LLA.±I X Uj= I,l L< A I 4 I,-&*I -.L;LI J# a4LI -1

V#; Zj . t LW I I< t- I -E 1 UjLl I CL<LL I & , 1-9 (IjJ I jLL c LIU1 I J $LI < S i§LU-<

- MjL~U~J Ba9iI o1 - . t ~~II iL, s,k oLJ U JIJ.i1 ,L * , >

;,L JI L '2 &l; ;:LI1 ; .LIIvLb.oIJaj1l 4V LAL L .:jZL2I o 11 bI Ug ¢ oigai,

L I~ , j L a4v Up -,•rU 9 :~

(J J 1* O V I4iJ.I I Ija I CL,.J j. ILA a JIJj** I : J l i L L^

41 1 3 I -,•1 1 1J - .^ 1U•c ,i tl -i J Va ii UILA

Ili LSXZYJL1V). 19>1.- Li L- I - 31 LAt jLaI -J1

V1 U-6 tJ- LA21 SI j &A

L~~~~~~~~~.~ I V lUJ s *IV ;1-TLI 4•IjJUS(lylL>O;:1,i vl

L.1L;._= :U I -v1 It: 1. s; ^ 1- LLII

I3L A-1 *- -1 V 11ÊEJ*1;1M YV;d1 d^1:J. .;9S _,JJ.,.,

J l- LU. ~L-, .~ . U.Li ,±Jll I.

; w iLig and de ,1 Pen a &1 ,L i I : iIVCiLiB S J .eL O1k1V L V V 1** I ;S (IVX5tfi* X 31V4'

ul;; U- S;a21Jl1 #JI0 J Z-11 AL5 L-J VIli HIJ

LJ WU I L .I-5V < 1I- .:CILL 9 iiJWI Z~w 1%=11 L ,; E ' l ClYIVlVX.

&AD5OT L v-'Jj Q1 -. < Q5 ¢LKL1 &K 1 L? ()UL

ESII 4. ^1 1 -i L1 lM 2 1 JSI LA;Xl 1.Sl 4(- ; 1AYJ.

C-L-i oL- 7.; &=YjN e D o ;Azyl 3 ;*,t.. t;S J

Z,-4 ,IL - .lel 3 ] b.

)oiJSFIe<isXig oand de ola P> F-en vYI-l ; Lt,LI Î J

4LJIjWI~iJ.~JJcA

& A3Ji~ Ic L.5• J..ii Ua L L-, *_-, I ct.JiI - z Z.L j IJ. 6-t6'-yI

.1wiSFIeisig and de la Pena :j....f a -- 3 ,L .- , L"L3 Y

-Y.IJ. 7-cYL. ~ -~I 61>•W Li i~ U.S I, LpLJ - L11

t-.IJJI t;.-i-aJ I L.- i eLI L. I4,:" LYI L4 L L L 4 .i QU2tlJ;I J1

.i j iJ I cY 71 I k .I . i i , Y ,11

.'wt.arangs, ;IEC, WorldltJlL Bank>a :,.i,o sol L.

:y-L, t-l v- Ila;ll,L >

Z=s>Feii and deL la Pena -K, 'L 1-, Uj^)a I ,. I

§w;J,uI,*~~L 0Y :-oJU I

L*:.Y IQ - YI Zu ', If 9- 'J)Li; I LL. Ltl l I I M i Y .,il

111 5'.L :1:li ... :I Ijl ;U - ;1 ;.;,Lz 'I ;1 LI o

c,;Laj!-1 cY-1 oL'Ji- o LK va~~j cL.ylj tL-1 t-- 4-1 LII cEeIjI o oI

olFil sLL Is ul j- I il,. :i;91-31 i;-ll I LL ct- 4;ll JLLfi jil ;=iYI UL u1 -W -11 oLSI

oLJL oY I tfi LqIiiLI Z. iJyL J5 cllu oL Ijil ,k 1 0--?IJ ,l lJ LI= 'IH

f.UW 1,, Is ¢t -jP' 1,0,9)L='Ys1X

iLLi_ 1 ts; ,L- LS{I-; 6I L-llW L 1 oYI r; JLl v L j ,;11tA L.u 'jLI,,5 U;, Lj IJ lD f,1 -- , ;L>OIjYJLI 111 "il>Q

_L-L 'I-g Z'J - 4;a VV Jg&L i t J1_ I; ic~ L l SI cLt i,tL= i l o LI LI ,- J I;

,;1A. Io:.......1loL L L'-Y Y ;tI;I-1J11 j;LA <po Y

J;.e j e~~~~~~~~~~~~~unii j ofIOJ- U IIJlY E DES LJ; -I

laS L1 k,A I 1;

> *-- I ^- -L. L= 1

Z- I-IL ; I ,L 3L, LI VI JL,: !Ul t51 ULA 4JL4 L" VVJ

L4 .LL1 ;j. JLL I j .• .Lgil1 l ..Aj1 &l 1 L eJ .ili )?:i Jt ,L ( )::,1 JiLi -Y L O1 . .1 1 L4 a11 jLL Jf i VI .L 4 1 -iI LLI .,-L

> .izlL aML,i v >4;îL fivp4;tUI YI js~W laA1 ;L-ilajo '>*

~ Lo~1 L+jLj.il iil cLII I 4 1 LIIu .iII

J.J .: t1L*.;L - j1.' j-. -1 Ii L IA JL. v

j-,-dJ X vL,l 4c4- Llc l V4*Aill

~,VLYIv 5L9YI ;- :,U "l WI 6I.LWI ,ev aJ 9vi.,U ;iL 11 a,bL a 4i.2J s 4;LA

:7, VoI at J- I L5jj O L -. L-L L.. vt I L~I

.w UU.1isi an Y I Yl aLL, Pen : I

rjU. L- ; LA> l I t :-aJ I.1 L- SGjN J L;6 YJ. a YIl W" I-,II A I J+ ,11 aS ; I l.A QLL I t I

V,A Y~a I I1& jlJs L ;5C; l41~*1 #ii ;u.. Ll I *L=iil -LW JUv

LWI L1 _,lZ Z=C ( * l L YJ) ZC j al VS 11^ J.1

V --u J-- ,1 zt! C J L V>Y~ I 5 iLi ; ZL -1 I6 1 J -a I;(J *? L) .1 - ^1V = I 4CjJi-Li c6 L 1 L. M9J Li. sLLYI U.IV9A IC L I L=Y^S > I = I Lj VL UYI) 1 I S S

3JI.SX1.1 &A 1 DAL ,i;LY ",)l eLi S LII RLEE{ I u

J I . SV-JU+ s;, . JYI AX)HM Ie:lU

C; 0";L F V I~ UA ;IIL, L+~ OLJE .;,iy I VLri , O1 OUYi O u

Z,11 , LjL-l I ?, L61 IS ieIÛl1;

\,vvn.Fleisig and de la Pena ..I,-.,,;Js<S .

V S S I.2lfol 4M .i l, Ll 5iv.L.I diL>a w, ~L.LLIo. I ~.d ~~

ij 1t• °IJI-> Vi 1w:; X9 L 13~ .;j) c,: l ; ;e 1,?1V .4LU..I o1,i v Li u jY ol!,JI G1 t .eJ L- ,j,4l .i i 11 7, j Ji LI I i X i I

oLJ J;1 u9± i,iJ olL~JI eJ; tL ,i1 tLIvii Uj, :- JJI ;ea;JY WH :IL .Mii v 5J JjL;I

vi *.-.- - J,L J1J *k * . * . .i Yl .11 vL-Li,L vlI6il &Yl'!A vZ Li. l j-- jDl WYk J Ioaj ;.e;- L.-;.JY

J- ,Y I L3a ;Si eI *r1-,3 1; 1Jiq .:1 ,j5 . ;=w *i ;, :_/- v ° zJI 0 5W1t v -Jj I

LL JoLI V ; LJa a 9Jl ;, 4Li :ia .J I .

L -J2 WI I I 1 1 *L;:U I Ls 1 ; -- i Six U v°¢l L d, i 1

-L.I v _,J v i L U 4;i v- v.J .LW oLLIIj .9 ~i; J 5lL,Y L I c

I;z e;j l i5 v l tL ol 1oL- I v k,- v FUII 6ci Lz<-

L^Jk $uI oI; J ;;,s cLLvtt< -.1 < LL-L Cs.. S>I; t.Lj J. Jsivffie ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 'Al 3i '-lL,,2loJlLjo-

J .1 JL LI;*L ., ;-v

-k4 LAwLs vi; a"--,I "J al:1-- vYJ ; IyLI;I

.%vta.Fleisig and de la Pena gL%1 LAt; ; 4l5yl>............l-J

bi,41 ,,, Lq- l UI Li .Lel L L< I- I . LL,,...... -11ii

-ILA lj * - a.S!L i X LLJ I aA k ,j>J ,] Yl

J i 44 >=s U UIJ "It J,.el VIllg ,L 1 ;.dIll! wu-

L v4 -1 I uLW o;i IJ .~,1 U J IJ i ^ J iJ-9Vl | -+J

UL SLa, 1 cI IL a ,! jL->SII i^. Y -I

v LJ b,YI , L- L-J I5 -i I,

,I, Lit I U;d il DI_, SI CL'U, l I f1,- L: 4I_ LlPnL,1 oi-. Ibj fl ti ~i EJIJ 4 YÆ L W Ir i.it LLCi LJj; IJ9

Iii . j!• I 1 L4 V C. 1i Ij.,," J A r bUa*iz &S -S L. aw. U. L LLA .I L1 1 S U :LA t; ! jL rI L t. ,V 1.,1x L.l Li I 6,j .- j I

IIo v~I 1 Y l ;,i -yIjV -j•. 1 Vy JJ 1 v 4diaI ÎJ vL.LaI .o:iI~ ~,i ss -1+jl

CL 1 IV -L-. * ; 1 .I4lI & JU Li ,Ila 1 ,_ II l

4I II J. kYI ll .LL A.J ;dL fii a,LU*LI .,=I

I- I 01 'I V U L t. 1 ' vY 1 IIaAA I

d cl8 t4O--t Zx U u d^|61tUU oS

L,i j-,l V! SI L= LL V4U. LaJ JI . .> U LJWi . ta i ,I t,A4 -' tu'. )L I L'~ tLZ-1 L' I92 vA l I I l- , f,=1, aI a4l s l 1-4 RJ

J&I' ~LV ~ ~ JJ Vi ~J.! LUl

~W Uiiii 1L,! ,sLA4 ~LsV ss . e; ,LJilJ 4- vu .d,jld1 ;J Ijb . V 3

S1 LI l5 J1 .bL~i ; IJ<i s UeI9 UIV iLii .i ,; L*a1U JA Xo SLL v.ob J3 i1~ .LF S

a1A Cy. -1- - A :Lj ,-I- _.vA L.SW

LiaL, JJ 1 r,~ J• ga tlI Il JII eLILI V ±~ I UV,1,)YI 4;.i3 iJI ;1

L-8 Es 4 L fL +1

~ ~.L.V,iI3 .~II ~idI3 W• .ll J4I LL qIiJ { ~,.UJIO J.. Vl YI v .U..4

itl 45, Lf l.V?yl Q .UJ3 L.L WL. L V3 LV1 L 1 s4 V W I + ULL.L=1 I1 L .L -i ' I dq!- ^ L.Y ll-LIr ^ 1J Ol YI d-' fq t1 iJ i l Li Oa 'YlJUl i - -ll lI; -L

j--' ZJ; | ~ Li l L :11 ,l ' '- I | ti4A-1V|v d

J I VHIJ VI ' v l.ydL}L J L,X IX &L v

o ^^1o- vilva-ea t o aSI oYt fi b IIJ l,I oLS J LL9aI JL lLY At1ill il aj!11- s5 L. Llihi .i >11 ; :LLlI 5i &LAVil a -Ll1

iztUI &L.L.Wl 'iY o Fj_1q J:~ Y Li i2UI

;1,61 Lll* k- ......l I sil t;i 4il J1 .i ii rl J

J ~~L-3SU I i, -oi 1-9 ILJ .iW tl 1I -- LI I L-'H YI L4 0i 1 J9tlj 1 IUL

aLlijLIa .. ;1 :fl J _, .iil I o -. ;A lI I, 0 i1 .L : Is9 a-,1 vlI c L; i L l Jj Iil a11sL- Ll1 I .LWi I j5E Il 4 Ji i J.O11 1 g i jYEs a

~~Aal I i ULI VL- v aSII Jd W .i .L L. 8C ix yJ dI giz11 il c-, 1 -. ilob11

;tL i9l LI ̂ cLLLI v2l 6= 1 S 1 IC1491 baA v,l ri

a:'LI 3 UJ i il jiL 2I .L.- i* 2I a ;.X :,iLLl *L'.ViA

vI4 vH v P4Jil .1 -A! :I &vA L. LlL".3 ,4 v4 i UI J v ef,l J*Fl i

IJ ... 1 l lv iajs LK HEI L..................... duail o ;y,j I ,iJ vi

5k9IjS IialtA5 Li~Ui L--. IJi1 fp1¢ Y .ali L *IV Ui

L, j5 ,Y I 1 I. -.'L;4 L..; ' Vu Ill oI§ o IY J? V4 iUI L'i ° -^L-!

,L Vi O,L.11 _Lil>;,j1!- :414, VZ&,1r6c.JIil :A° jLY I1

N J .> Jl.6L L*.j I I 4,i 9 L , . jt Jl i JLa 04L JLJI * lt i., jUI LiA ,. A

V;I Sl -iI Iv I lljI -ij L L t > 3 L -lLIyJ

A-il LsL9 :&j5. P;Ulj 1>1 L (LLW;"<:diL) .~W LJ1* Ll*11 -Y

C;- $ 1CJliLlw 16 4e ti-; J?- zt- .. ! i.L s11^2 L^ LI*sp ~I,' J

.- ,*?; aLI -IJYI ZLJ t Z, -, 1 L+, 4; : Y Lpi LVI

O4 $W :L.LC cLII.-I ZLrLJI I" 1Ksai .J

Lj ;x Y .ii- JI Ci L !l i 1; 1. . J J;1 :LJ . Let t *, sJi ILJ

13l. U LLl lIIcl l L; * E1 &1J *"';VJ lt S ;is 5 JL>I ,1 .I11

M r,T EconomistL. :fJ LII LLjI . e .LI-VI

I.L-J IA k S f , LW.I Lt w1l ol lill

L4<1- t--- Lu]*Jl*904Jvaie ;JLiYI OlOSJOIII L- Lei5 4;V

Si M M w A o - -+--fI I 4;JL- .- 6w oL JILS <1,L YI , I jj I I lej L

L J~~~~~~~~I 9- ;ti YV ,; ',SJ 1 D jC J. Y I c," -1 (4X D,I s;4 - sJI i5 D -t|

; .e; ô 1 Ja t;EH, .L: JLAI >ti * :g zJ l21OJid lj - ,

o SQ d s .,! a5/| a LI. t; Jl L,; cL -A -LL o jl I Z.A | v 1

Z& 1U sx ljf ln A^5 J U I J L. 4- L ; I0 J|Jj%U I-.K; L|U I o L SJ (oD# Jt c, L,AAU I o4 J S1 1L.t

jji 1 1_ 1;C j-L , - V-jJI Z^ DJoLtL2 1 ijl L UI i Z-WI J.H soIYS a;SDL I I LI

J .1 - liB l LL ;L= I IK. - jI.D I LitU I IY-L,7j11LlSJ1 I K 1- _ 1 jJ.*-;;I

v ;11 va t.'e J;&Y~~~~Z I LSyti Y.>vtJ;fLcLsSII Jv vLe i N11 ;= * ; ljl." --|ci v

,A Matter of Title," The Economist 1--J *1 44 *1 Zl-- I QLDNY, V e # . D

v \ A s ° 8 CK ~La5a £ A L ejaa iDZ,> l a Y .V.. .;.................. ,l

ij1 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ,.wsu I JAm911>1M U i1v*s-19

*&AJ.. 4JLJI yIrVI* 1J- J,IYI J u 1 v . fU.0 iSI I ZAI ALL I- - 61

JI1 UW1 tL1 4 i ~.U~ 5 UJ LMY 5*u1 t1 sL 0 J. 4, oblJ L~ ,i LliI

63Ujlll 41 .> ~4ftl 4-61.oe 2 Jj9¢1j 4 , i

- - - - -

d4 9)4i -- - d - - - ys. - 1 -i I II I

WtftII -LI ^; I I J . - 1l

±iL]II d ^.L;. L~I L L.L v : - y dIL j Iil )G 1,1 ia

U-;1-...1 kl>Y i LL- J9.>=lU Lr-$1 IdL c;1 ̂ - 5 slal Y9lJ .; jiill

,d I,zI UI - I, ' uA L SI <2 I Z-L J1 _

L=-il&WI LiA- 4 i 3.ZI cl-ALI UI eI *, U LY

(, QLi 4 : ;: U UI I JI Li UIIl ul S -, 1 AI J1LL I LfL

I L=J "I JIL KZ4 I Lj IL- L,U -1("L, 1;I i ).a J 1ULI-IifY 1 J JI -J&L MIf YI JL Lg SlI QL I , (d- :9 IL" Li .... . . . ........... TI J ;LLjI

AA V;: I;A OSI Y 4J IS Sqduire,^ JU34 L-JL ,LI 1 ;,.G SJ .'IL -S a1bI2Y

(tH) i Ju :1L,: T 9 ZL<2 'KL-w iJU L.5;11 J,LWI LIZ--IL _rJ ̂ I od I aA2 U OL'

i9SI I V.4 o+Iy tI '-i41 Z- L;j.l s kI V Lu I IJ-4 1-:! |14 1

* ?1 VS A; E 1, 1 JU iLI ;JuI-> LJU jv Z _,.1 41 A tl j L s( L.Aj. ;j ;1J1I

OIj ;,L:J I11 iJA 5 1O9; *I L ;.Ll _1 ?1 r L,95 5I oL J*I ., J. I ..L I . 9-!. z, . J AJ1L. .,- J_ .. I. _,-

j.,j jL.j >Wi "WI 3U1 aL4 liil I« ,6 c5Lt I +; LL I; ZL tL. 4t I= d-3 4y SL-.T;f aI 4;L~ ̂-- I.c, i4j1t tI -,S j; l, sJ=I La2i =J1 L:u Lei1 A x .LLLI il(,js

v-~~~~~~~~jJ ^^ * i iox I r,;1

oXljW IVe; LrL UL;<-5 VL O I j.* 15 I i&L 3f t~ L- IJ n=LA- .,J C

JU I L'.i_ ,4l ;6e ¢ 1 JJl- 1 U1 aai lfle -. 51 OI -?IawfLIJjl*OS' I L" liJ I1 <> (u OI Q L 1,,.j IJ ;-. - fi Il 1. I)L J .s La1

~~)FlU 1- 1zi &.u"J LjSJj ;LJ Ul 1-Jl eA4^ *-a 1:II wl

Z,- ZtJ UI !L L.41 L-;1 Y,IJ (- JLAYIi J;1) ;asLjI

LMUS- L'' -" UL 1 -- ; JQUi4a lI 0 S JLP1&jUISAO1lJ1.wi2Sil 4.11 aaA( la1 ~- f ,Lil ;e) -,-L- Iwe I , ,I;J(Ve I J-L L-J J(

3L 1 -& - '''-' L ;JI'' ;t; J S IJ 1 dI. VC> 4= )_j ; 1s

IJJIl; l I 1 y1 j;j L I 1; -S ;.Ll"- IIL JKz *-- &-1,~l OlII

J! jALI JV ZVe LL-, 4a; je dW1 :jV .,

LO L^,1 RL`,7t JI) I V1L-. ;-5Xx La L 1s 1,6 YI

Bennet and) qUt QL,3l ol G - 1o-LI;l>i)f1 ,J jiZ' La ~Ji j1 314Y ,j jj

.\r Goldberg 'L& I lJI i2> vL'Lii LZI 1 .'.L W

,il I 6 1 J L r ;@ v ;.J Si- -t Q, IjS Li L. U I I LL,t I8. IW ;.-% c

YUjtl JAYI- L,6-i ,-LjLL adA> vJLj il .W IJ Q iUI1 - -l a..! *K:, 11-1 -~LJ IF SL6C<1

?= aA,Lli JLIIJB Zh e;.!I jQSc1tiL-selc dl5 V:Y d>1 .- 1ioA.- I

Vz&lDllouL. U -Z +<- J -. ,.,,,,; I , ll ll o L- L

LL 1L- IB C, al dl Z1.13 vl; 1oLIb.Lc1 a u '6.

os'eS ' t , 1 VA U .Isy i ,G11 -1 1 JLL lj'- L,1

:s- L.:aJ. I _ V J oLLUiiE > 1uUIdI

,iJLIL , 419*,:;'' '-Jel ''gk 1 .L Lel-lI o AjLI ,d ~ o k IJ z'0 G l )Lt 1f-'lt N

I~ -!J L2l :..LZilS :V4ba ,-1 ia >~U iL^31j-AI

cM I S i L vLZYI PLl xJL. Lj~jU~ - Z=,1JY1 ji, LJUI 9i1f

'N ;LwII~L 1,,bl,=dI

-ilW SL.LeJu J-- ,I1 -W .L-LI1-LVI V4JJ~~J~~~l~ I 4.L;I~I4 i

1 ;l_ - 3 dlii o. - , J1 ' Y - ; YI Li LI .UL I ji ..1V LA 1_ O-i

L o t L .11 4 II . 5LLI la i

UA 3=I ~i~ i C- t~j 1uk *- I.- l,- -1 _ ;J

L W ; - fl c_L_~. J. _,I 1 >1u iI I US LJ 1 o 1 Kt"" JijLj6-vjd-1 1j LI ; _i;LIUaFVYl;lSY IS 1LIUIoil

.-i1 d U JL.9 ZLdl ,:iL_ vi L-.LlI ,hI3 'I J I iII o L j i ;LL lI

;= l- zi,Vl ,,11 JL ,i UI LULl G I I,," I .

RkAod jig11 C,hae ad ,L Lsana-.t =.i jjIYI I ,

S anchez .LJ I LWiI J..)i Y I ji, vi1 .Ll4 -19,pLta l L I a i L.............U L: > J.a lIJi ,- ; I J J1, YI l i . L

Ut; j" i ; t= -:, ;i olli 91°l .;.1 iLI ?;,11 a ) ,> ill i L i oL>l JIol;i l i i1;. Iollioi ;l

JL,Y I ;.S;1 3LJ i Lj; s*(-1 YI ;c 1 ~ iS o\5oL J;l &ji o

(rj.-LJ J- -J Pj l1 6iJ;;.L" 1 ,WJiL~ ().iL5L -l , .l'il sI; okJs .L,YI - l H> Ll

*e>* :- L:l %CIj_ oLli JlUl Jl-,bl UjZ .l U ,L. 0 1_L; *Zj._ - ;~

_.JE;-ul 41;JI ;1%L - ZjgS1 J,j,- l.9 vU l L-1i YI .imlUI;,S J.;Y

- 1 LLI L i a. oL Ij,,1 -L-V LIUI cL . t;Jl L,i,l ; : I J-Ll I; L fi L i & UL lilj *JF

' -S ;^JUI Ql-j;.l l ;- 1L. QlsL-jl t..;. A ; 1 ' Ii,- i4v t14 l jJYISl

;i .p1;4LLI c--uri t-1;1 iLIoL L >;1*,1J......t , >ik L,-L b1¢1j l

L uVl J.LLUI L,ri UI I C:Liuv1 ilLdi- L iiI g r Lj;l Z"i Al ;1-L_s C-;Y i .F i V 1 uDIX..L1z^ V Il ~L-70L Ld%.1 oLU I L' _-1 ,;iI 4L7

iZU LJI il-.l L ,91#*L-0 US tJ=c JLB,=,5, LllvziiIu-'5 U j J

ZJ U oLa-i;lJ I iiJ Lilv s ;I-Ll s :,u cAIW O;VY Lr.4 L.,5 JLLl t:l L ke_> v L

,fiZ li a^ J vL u . L' a vi biHL- Z - 1 J O1J1 ll L- I - l_ bJi

*1vu lY 1iiiliU ,f,Y t1 il

Rodrigo Chaves and Susana-b dL+_ -1,^1 °*I;YAiV;-IlYVS-*-Sanchez U-11 oli Li: J_L M_ il efi_ul :Jl L,i ;. < x tl

S 11-,411 ,jpi ~, J', Li UI U-L-4I J9- ,- ,1, Lis

* ..- * I1 aA f,A7 U 13 L.Z jaI~ W I J I9-1

hv] [ 2| d . 0| >u1 M JUI LL|o |d8- t; * I

L -,J; 1- -L -JILU=Il ZdI i : L__t Is ,;15 J_Ji L- JL lA lz 1 31 Jlj~

xL l - ' W iJ. 4j Lts Y t,I U ,A 1I

JLX;lJb XJUISIgI1u

LLJUI ,) &L.ZlJl JUl;-l L JVl &i Lab'v

:tA vk, il JU-Iol ) jL-;;IJUI o sLW 1ul ;ev t;;t1 J jYI Jo Q ,,1 U JtMl L,AIL;uli wi1 "JIGUIo LU J- 1

j)iYI 1I- v ol .IjI U,. jJJ vI

Jii;ll ;l>1 uu1 IIzY 1E 4,1 i 1'd I et,l J 41 *

I LOL I JL.Aj J11

t..- -jL%Jl z-.JI J,wJ .LL ,.I

;JUI Ll,dJl Uk

t~ -i i :U -t

s c;, rl i Fe

,ii',fLL '~f ~Ft.

-F EQ,~

V.

L,_t;i &UIL ,Li *Ii ;L,J,i 4;ll Ji cL * I ' - ILLi l , L1 iLII jLY l

:- L.-i1-:4. L J-kLpIII 41 .- , ' J I - .i JAA I]L AVI*.ojl Ji"LLl LrJ lh> *Irli e,I vkl4 * l . i-;MYlA Z- -I- 1 -4 ., IJ

_0 iLo &JL e, 11 l il il ,6i Li-.I A.Z.l "I -" i U - J I G J 1

Z.( JAv ILPI 'eu a AbIaham) -I1.-UI 1 . _41 J s. -Yl;I ; Lj

-s2 >.) U LI-, ...... J aI. I Vi L~i~ll ,1i 21 L>i l oL o;l 4S1JI oLJIJ 1,i1 t.La;IJi1E JI

- ;liiJ z1JU. 1. J .i 51-W ij oV JtILl>l J~ 0~ v- Ii-' JJI- .<M• > ,LUJI ri Jf Lss b LoYI

.U.1 I .J!A J1-4 Y I_ I I Ui oLL LM ;II L i ;

M < j,)Ji 4 -11 01l I v * v * 5J~ Zsjc h.2J) L .-ll I J.j11 ,t3U j--l QI-YI

LhIl,- Z.!ij 'J Ij ,_sI Li UlL ol I j IL, I1<J (IjJ LY i

L vjL Z U .i Lo li ;I cAY v. -- tl *; -ct 1_4'-'.-

,=s 16)" I14 164:-11 -ILL&I I Lr1 I Z-i ;>1Z

i;l jl: ;,IJJi Z-=! :: JLA -2J,A9 .L ,jLLll1

J3~ j Z*4> °u1-4 1 j-! viu ZvX z;i ol jl,?YI ccvwok¢i;l--JSl aAAI ;1W1,> I vL;YI 5k

cd, J ;Liz o-Y rLl;Y Sc A Jjl~I *l i l . oLI o, L. l SS * -= 4LJ-; @;;, lLo-S

LLt o - .% I;ILI, LI;iWJi*j{L:IG

L,I-_Il LWiDl ,1 L, QL-L-I ZL!Lj,15K11 *YLt,I vo>1 ^'L+ ;5^l L;11. JL+-il 1

.(E>^v,Plateau and Abraham); >11ijL.)lI ,-J-Z JVt L.F I- Lvi sLZ iLitIlJ lU I

iLI L-z I I ;11 VA t-9Lj VL;l t jEJ c- a Z--I_ LLLP 6il ZAL1 d1 I1 zlf .

jj * DL. Wl.E "-;IJ .31 Vj Yl ;L1 L LqL I b&O. v¢ V I JA 11 i j

-"" U>)j d1 SL'r Li zi-."I 3L i:l -1 2 I ,F JLA I ~jS-L I ;L11 L+ L.Fra IA ,rJ,j

;:,I ~ ~ ~ -4 eil I?,^j ^@ 8LIa S

-lL1YI ai) ,!Al ° J- J;;~ *--LjgL &<C

Al .U9 Lt I , _ *l cL~ La I Zr La li L. :S ,=11- JU V I JJLV VY.JY I;.

ZJlUI 1 I (5-iLc LI JLfI ..1;U It jf........... . . . ......... 9 DL'JI1.^-J .I J , YI ju 11 .L~~ cAJ,JY

~~~~~~~~~~~1 & v.(L A)g1> 1--IvJ w L .L-II VL,O_

4-9 -

LSPJ~~' ~L~JI - ;e s L,s9 jvs'UI

.L'i Z.t-LI LJU1~ .L•~ iJIZ6 DZ:~lz1G -U.I , II.~ rM I .Ji 4Ie.a .L? J9 - 1;LI falUI iLLiII J~ ,L, IUI iII j,L >oI1 J1

?I oll ui 4.djlI ^ tI oL iJLl L * -*-, 5 I ill "VLi ,

L - L t I L< 1 J I Lal L.-,; . I A t o l I o 1;;'1I L W

li U *tLii Va I -LLI l y1d ;31-1 4 t ' Il J 1

.-. exvill eil =l JL ;jW AZ ol lt>tb<.-1 -J ;P C°t ^- *st*1

ju $;:,:JI ;L; J '#l C;;LJ LlI 0S aI IdU L ; AOII ; U {LLX;I L ,; 4I - I 0L O

> ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 -ULI.I ZLL._.J .L -- t f

vw TuckI an Yao 'LL LIA LI, I5J L_LsyL-41

L.Lx 5;.%- oI ,_ L,m L.; 1,,1 IiI vjlw 21 o ; ,alI

vl I-1 Al, :Ljl olj I .F o~ ,1 LJ;.L -Y Ix 13 L= L- L.tj

Js LaL I ji, I,,i ,L "S ,tW I;J L'= I 31

_:g al5: 4Li lj,' IaU LALs L.J>c' L4j,11

J_ ,I t ;L/*.3 LogJ-e 1u l iUI I , I.t L- L, L f 1 es,.^Y t

L- e-JI 6.j UJ9I: ELA ,1 '31. <L I L,i L' zUI ZiLLD JJI L1 ^ - ll &i I1 M

z,A a. v A 1 L i Zl.l I z&. *r- I -I L<z 4>L I LA.;

vtCC >?WV>F-II lS-J

L UJjl - ~.- 3.L L, I I t I, L-,--1; L.C, oL.,.!I.: J l : i t^ ~,V s-. -A-JL eI tUioL& l

,Ji I .9-.4111 4 , ,< <tL;-1)4 ,H<5 L -. L YI-) l-iil- J-.-J ,;. aj!~ L l I GL LA

L;A S,' L.Al 6=11Y ,J :r-l j,LYI

(SI;:L : eX-SSsLo(ZUI£Xp LiS8SlLUA *S)ZULI ,i Y.. 4 $L1: : .- 1L J. oY I,1 -I J1L \, L- J L A . al TA. 8 '`

jsa .kI,LiU..JL I , N .IZUI - , A%V( m l .'1I f; .UL..ni L,1 1 WLUl *,

* ktso rkL ,, ;;m L A Z- t.L l Jjo * . ZIL-;Y i; ULi v.-L p. J1.6Bu 11

U" ZLlw. IL;I __,,Z a9 J I _16W o u.I5J 611 j.L- I f=Ul I ,^

iSJLY.I : Ulj ..L4 .. JI I l .iL.VI v. 1.1 o. * 1 4 . Ji v *JLL±l1: -L LI~~~~;-YIWLt 4-J1;1 Jl G-oL;fvL 1llcLll 2a: c L

, Jal YI; 3 1 ,LI 1 C.iL & . Iu ,fq11 U. I CAI .I U U"<I UI L 11 * ,I .I I I L4 i I U.s±i A 3..I L ..O 1 1 j *_,i ;jl*jl ? 1 .

*.1L1 ZIYI L-_ ;l * U! A ti .4"I v sL-JI o I4_i .-Ui 4;- *i1i W LI.,J /

v 4l0 ,.LII l s*:L e ;11 .. Lr Y1 ~± 11 OI .;L91 ;Il, ,LLI U4, I &Ji ZL;cY ui 1W vi LL LI Z lY I * :;llJI 4,ii (Sal I Z 1UI I iLLI

!: p zo WI Z-2 i,.. -ii vt U" ; Al I J•t4p -IY O ;6Li_4

I5,1J LvlI jL i -51 U". 1 - Y I °*J JII. i.u *Lll ,r GJ L YL LLII LJ L Lz.

J- LiY L. Z:l l t V' ;t. - cl S 1J13 I c. ,6 Lv5. IjvYI- ;-- -J

vll;LAI YI i C : ' t ., , L,=; I ;L "I A yv;o ;:

.5J oilS" li ZL LX?;l 141,> I c Ui4 I, J-liJ Jj-jII &0- L LLII; L JJlI

S.j C; 15 L o a ?-JI 'Al <7ul. i:.a PjsY Ixo O- .- z- Is L l, LtS . Y l J-U

voI ZL- l pLb ib l vL v l4LLîJc l F vilJ"î I.l=1~ I- v,j C°4U e-L; .SIJy

n!. I SO,1- 4jX;k<JL° jae- T L lXV.S£.*lo L ti, ?,. so .

*f N ]Lj J14J Jj L:L I IY"i To. ,* MI

.(ZUI ,,i lo) Z;ZuI o,; ol Ze.-. : ".6-1 .;;ui

. Aswt.Nowak , A iU,)^ lsL<l.(I,Yoc,;4I_Z4j

7 1;11 SL - I. j1a; VV1 IUl Zr-v. £-1 JdLY

QL 11S5JIL.J _W..l ~Lll UL c-_l L...I * , zt-wll :niAW L-tl -1 L-. ?5c¢,L Lit-I

-t'fi4a Lj~ , ,. L- u Le - J 4L- J i u11 iU ;_fYL.,il ,lI5 I , 1 il

;,d , I ; : _,-A LSVV 1 ( *O LJ) I iLI-

il .6-l 1 Ll 7.11 vo YIo e :t L.Ji,UI- 0 _ IJ Lv wLI j..IiJj ZilUI clj Iju

* g>Y L lJ ,ffLI,sO ii Jl UI b,11 --!A i.ta I11 cL..%-;I eStl k LI-FL I

VA~ -1 Z:IejlQYAUa ,=L :L.;cYL iZ:LOl LKLÎ olEl.-l I; l. ;- -

.1f 4El LUI.L11; a; I l ; t liw I j i-l il t w ,,J I I

. =i-,LI EJi-l I ,Li col..611Lil i L..!;U I i I -,L;A :yS t41 I i;L~ ZL:,1o "v L*l ' IJ 1 ._iLu

%MLt I fle L,7

vr a>LI :.tol<

,-~~~~~~~~ tZ L71L, L-Z.7JI JI;;5 ,L ,~-s,1a j L-5 -4J .................. 1 SI jj-1 vl4*1

-1jI : 4cur;1v iz *L+j5<L.L Uwj -- ^- --. I .............. LM ;&1L I '3 La I

5 ,ML,JL L JaiJ Lj,JU 4vvi~ L I-L ll .J UI &5~11 o'l ij1 4L I16 1 1

D a I a14 ^.'q1 V7 ug "i L+ I9 IZ a3 UU _ IL- L. JI J V,A .1 vtL L

LLS 4S I:t frIj

IiYI iJUIl LJL j-I 51s0

JA -Z\ . IJ I PUY; SI a' Z:If q^l- L- - FLL; W1 Cl L+. -.-.

FJA< PH14;o L;1. a1GI M 1.V J Y l fl,l -I QL-_%- ,USI cL4=JI "j -................... .;

"- ,1 Ll 1 -. 1 q Z* J1 I I u1 uLJ 1B; ;51 (;.- I L; -11 Z~ ;L-

ji (.=W 11U L,:it) Z:LAIIJ4 U1a t ~l 1.31 .Xi l @ I;x ^

La / J|Ul, I L.....; 13 ISl- L4 j,J sLt f,A vt........@ '2^>| 1 (;"uJI | g Y di

J1 9 ,iuo11> L;ljl 4r l, .. U JI I ;j U 1- Ii i- WI 451 *r-& I ZA LUI 4511d.-ili lv

3L;l eLi U! - ;vu_l. tL 1Eyg izloS SJL.n 1U

J_" LL t I ilSk t1| Z , |,- LG<~ ZLS L sIU L, ;I S J ,d@L I 61 .................. J

fl;is; jl tr.I il L ,,L1LJ U. .............. )11 +< :tl Lc.O.. ;) iLgll a5;dsialli, d '''''s

s ttS,Jul Liatt L-L uje LSaWl LLtl L#lo ;JI Ll AA L d,klt 1 1 ;Ar ci ,,t

i~ I L' I lst ,, 1, Lt-1 Ij Lv4 rL.L I UU1;. LJ ,I2tJ at<z L i;I ;.5t.L -r l

~ W *f 6;t I - tî ot U .; il.: L is z1sa; ,25+1Z zSj JL

YI - -j LAt,all -.JIct zb, Li ;5Q1 .5 ) -0 (.i ju 68

(1-Z-~ - t ),t Li .'71 JI 4 1A oLAL._dL.JI ZLMS Ib4

I -,,6-1 . ,1- .t::t _,,> Lv $;1 ; Lt-Y

JLio X l t WA '7

EJ1WI $ImtL¢9 WI (1JI 44lUI UL -LI SL4I d' IJ L11iJUI <JW ;11~.L - ^1 ~LJ .GtkIJi g-I6J I J4L Ji UJSP I j1 . 5L.I * LIS JL1 L j? I cl *A - ; * { U f,a

L)- (J1W Ij I L LF c L-k 1 I1JI q I J_A. LJ,JI ; J d*vL-t - W L 4t9; 1] C+ l l-% czL *J I(-' sUW I< ;ri_;a d.k -,31 I4;)IJII L ,# DS 1^

(- UY V LLYIAi Lbdl I -LS litl I SkJLj Y ;lz 2j11 ;J'YI L^1 ^YI-17 -; Lk.' -- -Lt. oIJ

6j,L, L-AJI IJ 1 1 -lJI 1 * Li I . t )L.Y II J 11. YiI!O4I, 1.1ai ; 1 ,, .. z IUI iL L-i L.F. .1 t ~ d L.M t

O,L,3 ;jL 11U LJ QLV J L d}- d................ |,1j

VDILD IV I - &! L ZJI AM:11

4.;l VL~Y 1 UW L*y 6,1L 1~

- -- 3t .iij2 / t

v- ^- L%J Y -A -v L;LGIYP YSL Y7M VL;:YL OIJ6; &; c;L1 \- J.

a iiIJl r JLIiJ J .JI J J U 9 i& ZWUi L.- U;z1 Lj Vl L.JU.Sij j 71l

* Vl-;Y~~~~~~IJ X^.f)JI E2 A YJI ^~i t - JILV^;LJI DJlY~& I(~A *;c.d 21 )L

.1cB c and Ricarso : *- -, -1J4, a S4 .s L(Se-iL;U*,i ;.,ILj -il _o,iL.,: Vz K i < Jy 3A1

;-_,JL. ;JlL. 11ua *.- e L.5,L;ISJJJC I1 JgU-L.L ;6 V Ql oL-Z.Yf 4,a Q,7IKJ * ls O, i "L ZLL

;.ZJ Dj L;Jil I _J ¢L i LI L_.1J Jj L-iJY L-L i"Zi zg; e) L L-

V°lil itil L Y -DlY Y

&1- Y g> J Il>L L .IY -il -1 Dj vol ~ ji ciK o . LLLI 1 aj .iiZUI';1- SMIJWJ ° Q-_t J i QI..i l a A CLAI , WiLA Dl - -Yl LiJ.(iu * | l

V2 1 D§ Ju is ~~~~~~~~,Au1UIC:iVJ LU l olS2 i 14- j(tU I L 'r J lj1; :^-;

eS -,51 4ky al;y 1- -;l., j;L, ZA W ju K._ Lo'Y_ 1 -S,,j l - =Y Q1 1 .' y LL l6 il

e4v 4iY-Alu i JLG s M dil EvJu Y oY =Y1 zl ru

tL@uS WiY lLI,jZv d!L i* YI QlJiLZl -IL t.. r I " SJ I r J

trlo I;l i-;Y LIJ~l I e 1-L *1; iul; Z!LtoY aI iLe ,16 t-;1a -'I

yi V J*oi ;J;aZ,.. 'Z a Le, Ui4 °12 A

;j oiY tD l:J. 61 ;,4ia l lS [l- oJlirJLfdi ft il sL. J_,£ L; -J-1 L"7l) ZIl y jfy liDly iBUU yi oe 1J (NNAA fL) dj,.Yl,;UUI Li YE vp tZji

j aL:oLI JIJl ol UIaL- J v. wto .Branch and Richardson :,a 1 i I ... :f:Jj ZaKalS o- ;sJ1 Ztl;ll QLLL--YI, LLj_Xll

11t 1,r _lVI ,LI ii 1 _ZI 1- C4~_4 tl IiY I LjL iI

t.- .-J1 "I.e Lio. 4Lt LiU ,1 Li v 1.9 U L ;...........a a1 YI

, U5 L3Jt 11.tI jlil vY 1A . + Il il i s;.i; a 5 i . d ~ .j ^S

i - Wt ,/

Uk J -~/ j, ~I;I a~L .iJ Ig I W_z i.,,•Zi I ~•L+az L#:; I-, .j .L -,-I - L 4j U I 1 I1 LJI v UL] L ; ,I

. li 1 sal LIUILll e=l ijs t=_ jW31 t. &4j !M

I ' ~L- j quI -L -6 I ;.i3 JI :4 C- JUj~W L_ 4 zd I 1 ,i4! tr .: L-LiI aJ4 J I L,.,. JI IWj

", i :,a ZLLK- 41 I1 1 vi dI ...-1 , 1 U1 AJ &4 1 e .AL

Besley and) iu.r ~zai Lj J+~ Jd1~ 131~

sl MJJ±I U I ,. K4:0 , l UL& - Kabu I .41 , =1 I.i 4d I d GC7,

J - L.@ U *-t 3- ^,. It L jil,- U l SJ L 5K4 sf l a.6l ZUl2l GLL A"l ".L-, d-L I 1

_J.; .IUI JII S L - - JL.Il A vi L; -tI 14J alj YI La

4...41 .I JU .11 4 .- J l LI C. L.~3ll I ; L- LW l I jz jj

WL ; LfA mr L. jill J - lplI

B Jeley .J6±lI U.-U,J_,, ,L I LJ~jJl LofLi ±~J VI -and) uli I 6 v

Z:4s-1ll ,1 64 t L.1 L,L I - , U4 -j1 IL vtA tUi1 v4 = L- .YI

I l LLIliJIj -LL.I L !L= i cLZ U a d- -I

L-_,;IIi it 1 Lga ll c I.AL:2,z 1 :.U..AI.. LLLd-a'

,e-,LolV LLI z A Ll.^ i.,e 1 GH1 1 ^ , >8s t 1

; _ I -- I t-;1 ,L I.; ,,.p;S.,........ .......... L -, -J1 L:i L' . .;~ Iof _)U I1 M

pjj- l Lyl., Lti ZL ,7,L?1j LjK1J t. '-J la c L , IL- L . L+- 5

J_J lL ll i592- tlat Ll J,,II t iS 1 -, v v-"i

.f t1 so > i.Mical Simo Z , -5JI L+ l IS ol > 9 Lu d li HL iJ5e

LZL4S ,, J L 11 U jL'I j, yS; ,AU ,iI *J LYI,

ZLi Ljil l - ' ' .,Liall -r , Ji 1 L .; * - .

j." -J I CJ-u Y &.A * - YI A 4 L , f-;-l

Q - 111 c*L , 1,1. 1 L1 Z L I J. v v J I. J Z .J1, *MliJ. tU.i

. ; C VLi1 , 1 ,L~LII ~LJ vY Lcll X-O £JLY : - C e (, ) ~a. |*1I .LL1.l I,LI &,5 *........... ,.

c 1 ILaill 4 .I-tI J o 5. - :JI okl i I (E) J iJ JC o=;8lM

_ j. 1 3 L.:1 . )_Ui Jj (A L,k JiJI i.II LL Z:Yj L l Z, 1I 'Jjj aLLI

aA IWi itiz .L1_¢ L L t^ ICI 4.Gasch *nd GL;lasn)

ot c llslo l yl*j -. 1 :Il 5Q;f:1 1 L _s. iJU iLfII

LS . 11 ijLll L(RI ;ll) Sjt4•l v° oLlo ;1X : Jlil YIo;jl v L &,L siS:i .L...c l I

J5 lj ', - -6" f Lel >LD 1- jdIZ^ C,- Y L L ;_ I .IA -i9 L'

e LSI a JtI Li l• rI-JI J1lLi .1aIiAs V,§ JI

oLa jt. Lo;! &ij I,i I Wii.yLgJ. L J--tI jJi L l SlI

t'li tU«l vi uL I ;1YA A,L cilJ YliLva 4 iJjr KV 5L2 111924U

yoi-i -Vlocl;lILu oUlLX*slJll~L

_Z okA l4 Lit I51 N.Zj IJ .iH; I L& 13:-I ,.L (L.I (LAjJIEA aMIv1,eL

;QueWci ;l" Z"l iv-;i-.it t~ i 4-oij L+Lll4:sis1 LYlj 1Llo s-I .:,J I j= ZIwL oJ/>Llcl---

sLilXiJUiL3=> lH _,1 LvSL slj (!sS 31- J ;LY)JI J-lvt

_,:11 I UAZ. ;411. IoL I -Ldc J I YI I ILLO I L=lsLrc LqsjSl *I;l J sjl ; I ,e a ,1 ;37u1 J ¢ Ij

.NIAl ek. uL Vinod Goel Fe- :Ic,wtlce L v!i

-;IcL ' -v.ccI>L I L'i Lz . 11 iLSY I o1 ;,,i I.... tlZ>t1 ,A L I I4li 1l ::- 1 -s r LI¢c e . s ; yl > M 1.......; L.± -S- I

;1 LIC4J1SML. m., ;* ,8 Y XGuasch and Glaessner)

Jl4YIF FL+JZ L1; I ;1 Gj I . U I 11 ,~ I 4LL ;-j L3 _

u-tU 5I SZ A1 K Z I Z4.1 PLIU .W I

,~~~~~~~~~~~-i4l &9J)LK UlN44c 1t j*-d|c

w 4IJIoL-If

g1 t• dI s 4- JcI ;J -1 -UI -1L-11I -,LU .0tLI 2JL

aS Y.,,. I .LJL 1 d 1 | i.iILI 1. I -a 1.. I

_)J o dI OIJG Kt ;L> '1 L dZ -ljl U-*11

.ZJl1I QW3 .Jll ( Uh 4;Y" u - L'"!

I -,j alJ 1 ̂ . .. 1joL .vI

s Li VLtl Jl kI IL I ZW > I L= I

, ;iS .I ;: l- :t1¢ bt L 1 1 J ,1 p 1 -.on -A I L y , d L. |d -Ul

oj 1i L -11, _Iu J.. 2 tt:Liil<j iijS;I J- ^'.IJia Iasil

U 11=iL s _1I )JLj JI 4 v L, U L I

L bW J &Ij ( UAI 1 :loj!. (L "Je 3l I4--.J 1 Z.3~~~ L3 _,: I L; IJ,) 5 1 j- Z,!s ( i a L.j~ aLA) c 1-;"l

J- 1II 3 l OL )JII 4L.7 I) V LW1I ,,I -L:L

W LII I vL.I ^ w -eI.Y1I L, -sJI LJ I j1L JII Ld-l ,L k JO1 L .1

Li cJ% )Li) I ,3LL I4I U LAJL.a (JJ1 -Ij L Ai I >JI . 1 5JA

i.1; U I ~,^LI iL4~J d,l US1 .(I C i)

U ss.I4elIL3LI 4^ sloi.L;Lf.+,lII f W L41f

JLJ •J vSU AiL J: II Il _I,iVI LJU,JI d

~Lg ,aJ I d < y J 1 5 (VI t-9W J9 LJU v v .iLiU v LLL

;l "I .-. t -,l jl 3" :11 LL- LLs'I uj -LSL1 (vLII

.s- L4L5YI1 IJU Lli Jd-l- 1

,so L *SvI ;Jj °[2

;,1| ^ d-:I 4 4 V v-i f ZO9t w X& iaa -- J L1 I J;L. Y

9 eoLLLI V ;J d - AI vo ;Sl> ae1C|d,d. - OJ1Y

.Lai A.W L' IR4 'AT...l,5 Iov J t. K 4I l L Z>E1xSD Y I 2 1^\

OLLLY I v~~~~~~~~~~~J v I ^:1v9 U of&a41t1V8

.W, Iv JLlIL aJldSAFzsnS1

=JIs jl;1, ,LytlVA

*cP sc * 11 s1 vlysI js ~~, u L s .:!1=,j .: .?,6J1 t= LIai;L- L,.1l 6L;=Yl

.L" jL "ACCION International" ;2Fd zA od _jt:; ULL . ,g>i LLI -,IId I *

.4z1 _,WI;i le Ia ze, 1 tl JI , -,,LI; Y L 1 11wk l1sJ*

->:W ls.1. 61.1 v: cs lJLV ,i L..Z1 4I L., iLj t7 ;Is 6L :C1

L, d XqYJ1Y,jv 4Lv6 I ;L -d-21 VJ, I L+.: L,:J I IiLl J~' ,LL,I IJ

-J i a J ,I JL LA-;: '- Y l .",&

LDyd L JMll1 ;-,U ?t cL ZJ ̂ t EIj ='Y.I JL ^Z U il OU" ^ oLs 1.s SUi

91 X aL.-A1 fea oZ ,cU .s I L=1 JA I^ &%UA 1 >>1Su L ou .^1cliVoA

C-%"YI,?,3v.... tJ~ I- w>;L2 ,JSL3o <; L 11 Z,"I l..2 ,J*u ll1 ?."5I 'if .4~ -Yl -yLI;

i.J!UI _.J11 _,:LVI cL*I *--YI zLYi a&Jt vi JL<-7 Zv3 JA.- iLAc* Lil ^1 v7 1 LjI #L11

1JL L 1; 1 C7.J VL5 1; L jiM SLI i3WI L-fJI v aLjK11v Yl I ^;, ZL Li f¢X :,L 'Y1

L.L Vi j! LJI,3,6M Vih J AD L ';:L61 L. A :-1 jLLIl

bj3 UJ fI J a I j1- J-1 Iol 1Y iA °J oil;Y 1Y A .ALIL=

4r ,;.>?eSI Ne ' 1S,V ;...................s-WI ;l+ IF,>J;Lp I4O-.S1 c ti :YI -U-

; ~ t<g"-U c 9DbL.6 ;Iel c 'L *!A sl LY Lj l t; J-Jf -L:Ll-

UAL1IA L4 il ai-Y ;tLjtll U_.8l 1:~ - ;I*:I L,i L UA,1

L,L Jll-. I ;J;I L1 UU-Y I -aX4, ;jA-1 I ~1J I= "i - ;IJ @)l51, I U5L: ,i L;;YIL OL;t e.°

Lo 3-1,6,,WyJLa'YIo io^ ;J1s-Z aYo11 ;g- 0- L :-1 . jI* cl;1 .Q1;o-Li J1Jf J;

11 L i ? j,,; oUL-. l t7iUl VI os, ,-L , J Jl t y L*11

L,i .. L_.:-1, SII Z91., I Z.g Lc c-, oL " U- -4 ;a J; o > I L^,:

. L ,S- JI .4elYI oiLf JI L 1 .uf

1.L S i k, Lynn Engstrand Z,4 ?t+- :,"a L,-= v _J; 1 G9 v ° cU 11 s-jLI

'A" L IY Lk .A e- ; J ; 1 61&

- . -;1Z j ~ l .jS -1 Li-L L u ZLL4 o l44 *:~ j.Li -. " L

? iijl,9 1 as ;d5: i y * UI ELi 1) LA ... P os J; u Ju.- l ' r

* JL iUI, r) ;.AJ;i "&tc u ;4^,,,i-e -y;

- jjl 6 t. -Y iJ;-gil j94ojj- -6 i 11

,5 ~~-'.JI JI 1 a.~ GLIoS jUkli

l -5 J I Lr6 yL,% IAt UU I I ,F]

L 9i Kg JI2-VI Bj bl41 J-L-:'I~-Z- - I.s ~ ,*1,> LA &.445 Z-1 11

Uel>s.il I iSA l p wJ vl 1iL

LJL1L J- L-U 4 3 U.1 teHJ L e ;1 L ^,.

GeVIS(>eWA Levitsky and Prasad)

Lee* L.LZ ;EDLI ;IJLLI I Li LZ'lI L,* cJ;,O >1 9-11 LrLA 5 t :34_, ;:J I c C5SI

L A~~~~~~~~~~~V i JL 1 -C jS III-e 1 1L 5tL 21 I ;14 <

- f, L;]<JI L5,- IIIJd (sseM Stearns) VI b" U,5ilL4,;l;2v : Si 1ê;.r

K] .J9 L Z:) &L :zv o v >lla ; -voAl IvAl .LLI

o='jja1.5J;vL 1 tA LAd LILlLiu11-i , \asE

;j.1I.31;Jvilll?li- ZI,5Ls (-5U01 LlL -s;YI .f ijillLl, -J;2I.UOS

;J ~~~~;L O t l :JveaLc Vl YI l LL.;t

Meyer and Nagarajan 1 996; Philips , i Iokzoil1(.11;;2

A.

L41 t I 14.L Li Zi_i - (,JL- . .= 1 61 iJUI- I 1. WA I ,.;t 1 JL iJsal I, -I ,YI Ct_Li ,3LI ,g1 1*

Q; AD*JLLLI U Ls 'GILDLAii, jilL

L4Y; 19; &KI _,6LLLlijIJI Li UtL' -,LS IS- .. L agZ -;lt vLILI

jl.~ ,Ltl;. &U.U= At3 U

itS I 5 5 9I * j- I SY 'i0Dl

iL2L L I ~,31 -I Z• 9 * S: .(= >Dc ~I,taJ*1i *.U MY Ij L~JI e t 1 F L.

d,5.l -L 1 -i. f-LmU S.L•t*JI UA U ' L' VJ - 3.9I -J UL4 -7 i

t.II1 -^ SA.t O FIdsg.1 t1 Li> L -L c'.'U iLLi 6 ;l :;t(r,T).4 L5.- :11t L, 1: 'Jll -L LA LAAIa LI > LAJz

L+ko J"li 4:J ll n.LA,& 65U

Le;l Ulj L,. I J[ ..a J tU±I I gUI IdI I Ponr 1 ;J I. ,9 U1 :Y - IJ .Je

4ii L<:S WI " -:U I1 >4L; LL. :I GL,;1 I1 JI; - I j (51 A-, C.IL JU L1 t

-..;. LlL ¢ cL ,@%1 J JJI ; IY :U ;LLi-- ,= E I jJ (d..

JI J ~iL,'L, •1I B S L. &I =l 1I t - .I .1 I LI LA C!J -I

U I:~•U 114 Li uL("WJI

IJL r >l ;L g1 lY Lli Z - c,1 AL:l J Jl QJ.IJ aG "K;I S

ES ;(P) V>L1i *;V I; U(Z) Y OI --. ./y LoJ

CILLUL IQ lul *LL (A ) e =j lyII (/ ) J_LLSIv Z.L I?/L;t , ^ 1~J (C) b|51V ~lj ;1 :

Roberts and {s .ael v; U .J~L_l I Li....- ,LULI Iâ; ;JjL >

J Z I'L Z_. I' L 'Fg i .u(m\st D i ck L,, J (i ti.. Z.X v,a 1 VJL -- Ld ,i | j Z

Z =A + /+ C < I nlf?d j31 fJI L,;- zMI

JL1 L,i Ll,s ,Jl L.Lal dj; ^ L.II L<.II zj UN I &Lu S.% L.A LI Jx -.C JI v~ 4IJJLlVL- L- Z jg{AII I ,f- zst-l: I Udry!~ Ai.Posner) dA va *YI 63 L- ;, * Yl

L,;U9 Ja V.! . ; ;,vL S,.:t| :1V LIaSI S

O ZiU I ,4a o\ LI I , ] U,l-6 L .*....... . ...l a, I Z:1.2-L) I 1d 11 lU I L_o I Ls~..(0 Aq 'k FAO) . Ll ll.1 7jlJ; JI' Li f Z U LI ui -AVj S1A 1. :jl JLY(1 vlo

C3tF'yiX?LP s^*2} J;j VL I ,i r. * V i LJ1 a1I O~Lii l V U IJL

LJ 4#M 1 ?i LIiYIoIt;*g1; *sL,;1- 1 J -4I, v 4,1jYll aU:

U1,I dLI o l - hIJl i -(\IJI .Hazell) QLLI

.s5~~~~~~>}lJV) :;-LAiYI I.k~L ,i s (*$J A jI Y S-(,Il, I * L1'i U1 -^ JIJIRU AJ~.L IJ - R~~I SII L;U~YJ L*l *V 4WI .. lil 4 JF ,:III ;WLI L L;t W0

L 1 v l bj. 4 JJ - - . A iLxI ;

11 ; J_ LL; ljL .4 _L _ * LeI1I L K LA UL U - ll 4 Li - I LL-

.L.I * Y LI ctL.L I d;Ai . L LŽ7II JA.aL..I , L : *--* - > U .L5 I

L$J:'^ JL; VJ 't L ,:Lti ifA~ -v *9 *d~•I 4.ŽAJ i . JI Ut•..JL.L L.I -9IJ OLVU ,i~ I * i•]

, ,Lil tU dU. Vd J I D I.c. tL1 ^ 1i (UiJI ;.L S I ^.s 1 41L

-;.III iLJlJI ,,Y 1 I Y 1 oI::O- u

vi LgI*H y U13 aUI°H )L' z1 - 111- U L I 'I

,L;II 1S JL iJ' o,u wialUI_;t 1r 4ti. IH ;i:L I ZJ IU ZL l ".j UI O ; >>

SL;J~~~~~~I. 1 ; -Rl 1 L1I0 L @SJl Z,tJ L, L: ljl b.Y!l AV4*l;l

-4 JLAli 1;t VLA "V; UYJ ' tiL ~Vl ,#( - EV;,'I Vi LL;~

,L L J-*-l EI& ;-1a 1 Jl ji ;ljJ1V11 UI 0;J1 S 1; UI ,I AII L

ZL;I ¢.J ;1l' Z-l L';~L1 <C< lMUIUI 01c1xW L-I Ul il '6ua J=J 61.1 YI S 47-VL

iLlitl ~ ~ ~ ~ f'L-iS IMU *JIJ1 "L., ZD- e- I-C . ; ,, L l IJ IL13 , j J j l I OL+ I V0; '4, 1 -Lf

;L,VUl iLJI ;UK9 LiiV TLSV1 VO *L-) 'Vl Z5 -l Zp?l J, J 41 &iB.

6ULL v'-

plilll4 J laA LI e l4 1J U IL-I3IJ^s L,'0_ 4.AJ-oll .3WI iILll ;l i*-U JlloiL.d

51c. 1.~ _yL; jl;j - b.> *-o5:l itbl L.'ll UL- ,JILi:L;l &L=,'I -J-" div5 -i

Z>1LIIlloIjU >1;l ,r JUI 13 (itl oLi LUo ;l i;JI

vY ll J "k 1 ; "K:v j < - -XX lall UAfll &,<L OLi

bAZ.Ljl jsM- -iJ 1 zUI Zo;l Zv- Jee V-gl G U t1 ;2;5V LS j

liA -:4 ; J,r J--i Li jei 4-1J- , UeelJj,Z 1 .4-gL.l J,-1 1 1u U ;;

At=v,1 iZLUI j_Isstt LJ. Jj,- l , L- _l .5A*i-a &J V ' 1

Z;'L-I Jz rf LS -1 ,LY ZM9 V fiWI L: ,1JJ

LJL? n Li J! r L-'g vL6Y I 41 s>u1 > I C"!.W1 LJ1 $L JL2I

*.kl ,>ipj LL-j 'G11"-L:=l r

1G:J q.-U2 iLil >LtI*L-v *i SJ

el alU Y SG,, Xll=I*~<rL<iLt Sl;lUI iL39-oJil L'i oi l p:1o;1 U.01 ILl j s I f L d~Ltl OiJ wA

izlI ua~- L I cY I Z=.16 tW(ZI Li1 VL- '--- I1 JK Z- -- ' LL Q^;l

L*!4 ,: a I f i 7is *fll I vC. -. =41 L S LIJ i I ll :,L-JLAI jLID O :;1Sol?Ib c=1 S cS kxI 'L1 l 7 '6 -'A -I - ;IY -

_J~l a'Y i.1 -l QY I ,?Y Li -~13 ji ,.1X. VJ9 La Ol<1et;1UJ IF ; II

J vk U >1- * -t .? J *U L§ *, t2{?I Ajl ( L 6aJZ l J9 -:L LIL1 1 J9Lia- Y

WIl "Ic .1 r,CL s 6ail -a4e,biSI Iv C,( f.:1 ;1

OLiLi;_,-Wha I f -L:l J1u ;-1 Y YI ciJ5 jyw tv)balE eLoLL

*akT C ES-°: t--Imu 33-XtU;l ; Ii.6;1 -J Y

.;,j ZK-l QUYI fLM G1S1X ;1 U LS Z,=i L,J '- g-S

-bLal UaL-f Ilrl U-j S I) t - J l L. zujz- so L ill Er

L;L1 i!Jil1I 4oljl q?14iKil oLLIll t.s- ZW J0S U J= vi Y .1i Z.,J1 jLirYI ,

7.11l L:: yikiSff Ol^Lzqj Le -'- Jl L .i.3I> ap-1 L;a I l,XJI 4 - iif;S 1 ;1 ^

Lt,,,ZU Ai IA ,0A S I; zi ' ; - ^ ts]i,1 -4-xY 9-~zZe-1-11 -L-i <.i LA- ;j.I ,.1 I-

cL.;.* v.;sJv+; .JLl ;1l°141 Ul c,-L31.6La CoL; NAI . f1 lc -J v ,1 (Si ] *

.> LI I. -92 vovL-J ;--"Z 5I "Ji'l I p o L < lJS8 I jL. Lj! J ,; oi.~l S Li Uj o ,LUil M 11 v l ~ . r Ls I;IJ JLLl lal J;j - :lu.......-........1 QLJIL

L;.>lEEJI15Vj &.i(ZUIu LNY.) I0:;1" 'J-$ Z; :L -9- J 1 )I f~ .- :....... . .a : V (.S;I W U I e;-L ZLOW. Q e S ;jII r : 1:.I.;l=

.- llij lLIL IL >o5 i _"z I- 9 i U: Lze ^ c l;CI 4,i a;'L L.~ iJ.-

Z1 1 - Z W§ - -'i a# CL; * i;-; --l jUA X L+*L lja iiLZ :y Li j.J I X£J

j.;t:stL7-.11v-';,,J 5_-L 1iSvI Q.,9~ J L ~z*- ; 11Ll.:j-La -iL I ;U L11j~ ................... U:-; i z

.* - s- j ,-w, IL LiL E ej L , I *ri , ° Z-k ., , LK ,

i~- v1 * J& t I "I-) ReCJj 1il IL JLA I2 Is Li.mNs Roberts and Dick V. 1- - ~ . z^ y ;t11 ,5-J I . - "i c U I .

L+i-_,--;;A;--t gILDIJ a1l .)YI-1 !II lF d'i -WN;9u1 1JaV

L I*} MSL^ J Z;1 -VS I]. W11 t!;J 1 IJ .i HSI ; 11--L c- OI;I 1 - i, C;jil

.lil oUILJI 6.!A LI-JLl ,r.L Q;:tv L I LlL Y ;Z-1;1I *.- vl1y JI .J oA

;U"f A. C e-.;cul f,s ICJW voll O.; 4i ;L lS J L-1 CtL j. .Li vl

RLjI ;;dn- H UI eLL il51- YJ. 1 JJ;;IIl->v ;

Ui I1 ~ Ijl J- -i 0E^; lLvb.gJ I . Lil LJl &'Vj -i. I v- I . L I ;jJ (I

ZL;jq11 JI 1g VLUI -i5iJ1 I: j-z cLU1 I Vi LL 1;§ Y LIL. -k 1 A-,. I I a4- V Y *u.1 1 ZAlw~

Y V.-LJI U 1 ; V ~'l AJ* £UI11 JYJ4IJI-6 L Ldf- 4*- WI; l -L2;Ltle LA >pl

U a -, U-11 o l -[ Z*;.2{13 a J £LVi L I &J'I J,.jL LLi.i o;l.5 li t- YJ ,;i *%t Lt LLk ,:,'L:;X

IiLi-JI CJUl -61 zL 11 V;4 °I. B5LULL X ^l; Z UJ Z -- &9I - L i :;- ~L ;I 1AZ Li

ZtJUJI IYLi ;,j-I ,e;j1 LLMI L- UL- Z:1..O;I;>IO>W jS. 1 1 _,U. L ,;l<. ;j M1 u i J.a iC1v2 uJ.,4J

,>vuI'&V - i"loI as u'e LY6 v i=Y I JA_, e ; I K- t ?Jli dlL-s' I

'Z, LI ZL,b U 4 UiJi.Vj A. cL%y;l til.!.;jL -i4 ae e L L- C.,n P-21

.- -,>-L11 Lil- *; c L I II ZLSJLLA "L2 1.ii 1L I U.,:j OF;I J I *V-sI ;Ii UjYJ

L,:l Is -i Ul ,WL L;- J-qL. Ie Lt;e v5 JiU L UI MV-) aj Si.C- vS U- Lt. L ) ;

VUl- U L (;II;Jl -1J;)Z;1; 0, rl *-Y LWi >;ILi t. 2

~~,I JI, -43~~~v *UI ,slal~. U t. L-I ;S a,W - 1j.1 ;Ji"1,1 't-6S V C'L; t.

.J-a.Hael ,1_ oJY, -;"jy -U=1, 4 4#L S IJll,I ;>i

,;|~~~~~~JI LJi'i LL-II IS4 )xl;L (Z~4-;DJU d ;l tL'ilil 19x X9dJ

( ef9 ZL . di Z-. *-> a o L" 5 ;-U 1 YU< I~lz QLI R;191t L;Y

6. e I -Y\LlE - 5 I *2 Li ;!AI I11X=R

JA; Lo ̂ 1t11 Ia ,1 ;L;lJ V I LI.W1 os , SJEI Q l-I L JA I L

- SJSV L t LWV-L-I ILL LL I,T JU I - .JL;SL

J3jI .::l -j L-Z I .j-? L+.l I 1-L1 LF I .' t? I- -. USI :| - - {

I

JJll JL. - fi .IL MU11 zMi J 1 fI .1 L 4 Lk L. &J1I U1I

k: H JI (z,i) .. L D - .L1, 1 Z (.)UL• &yI J1 .Ul 4-,L4 L-r 1 lf1jS Lrg t 1^-J 2 I iLL jlI L.; o- (3)DL e<4g lIO ..................;I

.LL IIj &I CI * . X . Qa l 1a C il <LiI I,LLI ,1 5L L5 ) 4lI

a,A AD i RJ z *7 L; L.S UM I UDI JS P1 *L 1;1 IY ELLX jl1- UL >

S LICL L*IA LI ---J I ! 5 L4 i J u1 CyLlaJ LJji I Z LI WI

J .=I L vi,j ULIJ :,II 4--'I ~4JJ"II, L~~i ;I UL'JI i Li IO~L 1IJLL I as. 1 PiA ...-.............1 ,< ; ¢ ^1s1O LI Lo a-,;

I J 1U I ;L1 L IU _,Ao S

A¢W

i

iIi

Iii

r_L2fl I L,*jIl

W4, 1S. LU ~U.. JI ILl.I aL..J Ir~~ Z,..Lp.4JJ)I rU . i. L.- L.L-J (311 ~ .11l GU a E ¢>UI ;Lo 1~ .;........... I, A1 -_1 Ij .... 41 o1J9-¢ L1

a,I !ALIj i . ^ L W 1 oLI LULl a 6 (5J 1 _4I E ..LiI

- - -~I U L LJ&I L~i ,; 1 .3 1 J=

~ Go,., ~U~ LU~L;VflI 1_) a x I 1.3 JL. 31 J1 )l,LLU (. I

'3 .- i~ Z=liSl LJUY "L'l dIj .1 L '1 liVUji& 1 0*La 1

J9 , GIA 4Dlj 1 iUI, ,1~4 * - * A IJ; Z- I JI _,1LL . Li1 .Jill VL UI , , 1 (3

v ,lL .Lc 'PI V Lall LA L >Ji-#â4'UI ,LII<;1

.JI) iUI l I LJIUJ I S =.

,i,l - >! ; .... ul,W :, gLL vl II vS.W vLik* ,L1 4l jLcI A S ;lljL s j vl 3J17

*AL;VL I IUUI {L LLIE^ Lsi Lil:l zLci L" LA :1; T j,5t I

OMp1 Jii l U : .2 ..... ..... --.l I, I S1 4i [A g o UIl LK LJ itUI sI sYI L-L- s

1) LI 4Ji iJUI i-.lL0 Mx 1i laA 4JLYI

. ( 8 5No ,jL11 .1 o-S1;;........ . ...... ILI ,1fs1 Ji :,1" Jea j.UiJ;-l I L

.iu., iU L IUI L,!.LI (k 10 1 S 1) Z- I il-UI L_1 l . ALI.i

AV

-KV 31 *b @1> ,IL jl *gA JtYl JllZ ^S LaY 'L JI K "' I

JLI Li ; OLI~A Z:i" L'c'' I -I I; -It I a

ol-S L 4 11 iw t, LII 21L aI;j'

JI -- my ZzKW ji ;1 ZL J1 1 ............... p , 5Lu - .t I;? r L,;./'l.Von Pischke and Adams),QYl QUjt,~jW

vIJ l l va5e vi J ̂ -L -l I v~ vi Lj - A - sL.8 XL.^ . -E Vll() vr1 S L J

U>. vL:es adA L-l ZUL L,Lc Ii ,, ;i q.LJ. Ii Jl, LU I L;L Ji ID() llM

vel -~ La> .d I * L1-i Li.,Llr J Li;l I-i 1- V vLt- YI JEl 1 jj L-- IU JJI, Jrj- *(5A IjI I LI IILkJIIjL

;a...11aK cLcjid211 J3LWL Jjlji l vês J Lfej Iv

I... 1 -. ' 2 ''' '' Is a; ,J -Y Il K- <. v L<_4 Lfj I Li - I_ d-. ...... .. . . .......... :L,-a A < I' I I

JJIp LX9-)JYI iz< l I ZD *-T J.0 *9 LlIlSl i"di-L6.z t- J1 Z-j^4 SFMYG Z LL U2 D1_; UL UL OLJ' I 13A a,Ll V II 1;^ L V I J

t > J 5{I a-=IKYL ,Y I 4iL ziJ * (L.i * ;<J ll1.-- I

J-9t=JjS+J=VY _It.

V J9. JL,11 ZH. dLGWI c,el - -i *J,6L LJL aj I .= d ;L .- ^?

,4.DYIVY)i;I.a dA JE ,O I I> iL,rl J,:LVZ;YI J." TLSiVagg VJI I I

J _d i-l j.~ I t. ., L1= I1, Sjj -1 j -2 _,1 L '- Jl ) Li jJ i

&;aS1 dW aLL LJr. d,t Di2r Li viL *aUt.L -1 Zd!. 14= 1 &J Udew I

LJ- I L,C [:il EJ sg -l LY 1 &. Z:; 6- Z- 1 &( tv

J-;- §V J *1LI,) Jc- * I j- ;;Y1 j,= L. 4J. -j C4J

LJ ,ia Jl :Y L;-L I a.! 1lL Y Z;L-l LU ILK.! .... L l J

917tAl ,iu *Jtu1 ,eiLsL Y 4+s'Y J1);-t 5 -- sSdE I Ifi-f/ ItbC-? 4.W1 -/-: t| ZSi *~ JI . . ,/ I jid Z . .

aA _;- Zv § UL D LI V-I i i;l Jt i UL 'l ILl

I p1I ".L- II'

;L Lt j~~l Ul~~c ~la 1_Jl.Vi J- ZlS.=I ~~t± •A

JiIL A 4J j -e L 4 3 I lL lal J JL4.2 l(jIi-J\ ,LoVl Ls qAir,Il IUII Ly.

- , Juid ? o6 .lijl ,LLIOUsL J 1 M 1A4T LI ~L..Jl j1.V LW $. Ip X_L )I 5 1 ;L j 4I SW (AU X) L .JI LJ i 541 J-1 J R, , L .

LY.1 4 V 'Il JII W I1i aL ' I -IIW.11 %.l : jI /I e V

+'CV' ~ I- ;-- I U11) 41 1 U

z'J;l sI ZLY~'I ; i I vil-.;LiI I1 ve. i VT VII ^

L :* y LT Dai a1 nd1w ZUI V Ps Voa

1 l L-.;ui I ujI .a lI vLYI -,III

. ^; * L js . i+JI ~1 -- 1 i l;.LiS4 I -LcJ 1);el -y

I Z" Jl >iÎ 4QCDavid and f\'A- .Von Pischke and Adams)

44L ' :d ,1W dZ---; oLZY I z4i. Ix .-4 -- I; I1 -c.(6,A NA£ eyer

Vc Y Y SSl EScJji ulYI L 4i -E- ' (850 Binswanger and Khandker)

*>- l 3atZ iL,:da.AvJl = ,l >L Jl ; L- Y I -AI i ;P1sll

v^Ylk sL.4 c; *eIEi 'YILVliS J1vJ. ll ,2 y

.i-iU o4ol 4JF52 ZsLtoS iJ-1 JU 1;l 9*v a^^

L J,f -= I L4 ..tc * 11 gL ti j1 i 1.. -lg Ic ,;se iI OD-l

1 Z... ;l c4clJl vLSL i 21 i lI 1 LI :JI llL A i U

aaA o ft; etiyl l &U l ,Z± S 4LM oLLill J1--IJ OIDL4I v4z.Y 1:~ a: u41>y,;: y, Z.ul .3 .J .... . . ........ ..

&91 L&LlA ~;~. L ;& L iLcAll V I jTSzU &.!Ad^y l&dr^--L'I.I dLi;.l I

LrLIYl A=I; 1A-Z L+iAA 1v1S p1 iJUI L1--1i; Yaron d-ii S.I ll JI . I.

913 t;g ; ZLAA oilijl &%wj' ;LI! ;arY usS-1,,U

j8t .lkiChristen) J -I

JI_,yu ; Ramola f,i£ Chaves and Gonzalez-Vega;J1 * Iv I alL Jl J .(8til .and Mahajan

- 5a eI LE-U g jL L; 1d LA&

,,J , aU "u;1;, 1.- ,:j , I LUI iJUI "WL il L,/l/l _,1lZ£Y XLi @z

JY~ * UI01**- 1 5 Cll Y L ZLLS 61fiiVLaA 'I - l -g YJ(\V J)5 l) >1)

1 EIl oLIU c.1j1 .V , AV ,, S I

JUI~ ~ ~ ~ ~ QLAe ZLW 1.U9 1,K L-,. -yt-j1tL6.J L

II I

J JI'4..IJ. * go

,,aI;tl~i~ S # 11

Li U9i JL GLI= 5 JL . - Jj.gjI G1 L- v J_ . I ) (?iiL L 411 ( JjiI

jet LI VJ I jljzCI~I SI L UJ JiI l A eLJ lI JOl d5 -JJI , '1 L l- X oiI JS l.il

L101 _,IIL.I :ll Al .I I VViI

~J ~~~=i l,1 LL L -I JJI .L'~I31 -V Jji.YV I I IL- =Z Z,,~ I J-.

JL.;.l ;.J l Y ELl; 1t J I e ll Y . N-V -U S

iMS IU I ji9l I EU11 6I j ,J2I I ^- f '' L,6 L&4

1: 1 ULilj Ja " I LA

Un,

L..Wl L5 I ;1 ,Ir- J3...?.Jl uL I Ct1-,Wl Zyw jMah n ,j-- l1i..1.-1 aI o iL- s:.j (4J,)B Z5i~L l koLjl ^F?JUI l .9 . - 11 _

;'I QSI ;L_ L.~ Il>l Zt L-t.11 ?.I -L #I.31 wLJU VL Y L -, ZL9:Z S vlj - IlJ v L-J If

-;&L l JLI L~J <, I N1 :¢ ;IJ(91) d- J Li V 5 5 QuqV11 g;wj_;q

V 11A.1J ZVA") JUI -1J I+- Vz,' :t JI

,pUI C ; I V s- I :-w * J L'1LL I 6jSl .JYI ,K > l ID'^vyVLL

LAj ;J W ZeSJ_ L L,; 'i JL*. Y-vJl =ML L 'f -V .g-- I......... .L,

ZL- r. 1L.L

.%t.tM haa

1LU1 ;l.. I 1 i I,91 LS LL;J >. . -1 d. I hS V .JLBJ1I UW , i I, L•J l LLI I -i L- l j •J¢L;:iII . L iL I *J Ji..AI "l

L1iu H J 4LI6;;lL~ Cel ?.Elf.=-1 XsLYyl L' La* ;L iUIl uu1 -,S1 JEL J1vi -" (--:~ -- LP14Y2; ,,k:koJ 'j' Z: 1.v L,,

LJUI j L;ti:.J I jtiJ-L ,- ' -L i 'U I i= ~;.l ilUI; Z-,j LI -J J<:-'- vi~- Y, jl i

.J' U -AQQ I I V -. jY I t v

: l J.I .LC- -l ai f S y j l I1 eLI * -4I i ,lA sl F v I.-IJI

Z ZJ 'r 1 I 4i • _J I 61 5 I ,i.;c I

- - LJI J.Benamin )IJfV Sl. -JJ vi.Iul c8..4L ~~3 ................... GUO YU4yiI r S.IIYJ:: vl5Ail

J 11 1 JI liii ;. k 1 &Y S .jL4I ai L; I ;Y I*bS J~il 4 ai J1I 4U -j ;Ii) - all f =Jl t vu , o

SI~~~~~~~~~~Z WY 41 -I= LUlbLlA .L ............IISi.ll SJ ;JgUI Z-'94J ZLJ - ;J Y.YI

. M .LII .DU.I J t SJ L _ l 6 .1 Jl_" .-J .i j s i .L..I; 21izt ;1 4 jyl I VIY

I 1 4'Y , y , &R.Il LL ;JL 1 ;.sL,S 41 4Jt -1 ;_j-il JU L,-Ijc.:li - ...... tl 4 JJL L B V' aY L-J tI

Z -- J.- j

- ,3.LI .LUs1I bv ;tl I.a Vi k jo *ci il -

j,K. Ij jj-~Y u i- :J.IuY >LJl t-1-loiO

d~I Z~Ui*~L~.iI .k~L;V ,,9. - f ZJI ~. jL-gj 41 L 5 ...jil

1_- 4LLI VI V J- ) ilIJI W I 5 --.L .. II II LIU l u• Jl I v ,k jL.LV ;,L6D~~~~~~ ;YI 11~ I; aul I CAl;2 LCIJ-S 1 : --LA -L' VL-YI V S L

V l * 4- 1 ,=j II-Al a I1 5J ij II J.I L ,:j 1I J ;r CLY L

.l.LA:Y 1., -L ,JilJL ;w'X=J LLJJ 4

IFUPtUJU 4-.>9 laA II

_,j4 I) OJK I L 11.lDt sl*;*-L *, : * .Y

->;" H ~Z~. Z i al ,1 t I LvtIJI ,c1el S

IC_.sa l}zLI UlU 151 ^.aall L'Ir J1 - cYl LL ,I .J

Z t 111 ZL call 5,1c 4S *rL ?-J LL31 jL.L.=;I r tss

iL. L' I- j,a Ict s J1.& Y -1 ZH~ I L#= 711,I .aJI I =l I 1j. j -Y l Iyst L-i a.y I I /1 j

f eJl;YIJ 11 L Y tl4i-lim Jj 1 5is l- la';KS l ZJJ4 L 4I ~;-1 1 A= L 1f

-ij Ij -=J.LJ45-< "- L. L'- FLli? L5,2,dS XAPj5 LUL >i*el*1 91 15a1 1 4J l;WL U ge41 x r.d, I D ; I6 Aq7 L- d u I 6.! J. > I Ji

j - VU,I; LIY d L .I -[j; I?L1 1 ; =S LJ-I Z-J- V(0.Squire PLDI HA1 ,L ;.,LI I L,- 1499 ;4JLa1 .L_] 4U

~ ~ . 4~I ~A~ ~Ll 1.4J A- LL

- ;A z L,- .LLi c tUi I L

cLDYI, ~~~~-a -; 1 Xi I ii > \t\,AA 1l y 1l.i. q-l Xl Z r

.';UI ,l TTA 1 ZUIi V1 tZU iti uVe L

v°lU± J]UI J,; . VX .l - LJL. LJ.IL, AA X , 1 JUI %J1l .s V-

0U sst>^1s1o .. YI 4i = 1 > . \V .s;jLA4

.;!;W (-ft s lD L vaL O l Ssi6 vl Z;L Ui TEl A,l 'U 'i %T, ZLI LvX Ve F i

la11 S I ;571 , ;VY I _ Ul ,-L-1 _Lx J-l>Y fJ ,,I l 1 l 1; o_T Zat xi 1j ;n. -1 ;-1

. GL4 ,rL-I J- L-L I al ILJ V1 IX-\sAa OW1 .e1 ,; 1 R uJL1J 1 , .1 tcjf laA L kY,f;Uij\VLI=

|9% 9°b 14° 13% 21% 23% 24%

O- 9% JL I - -uJUil

100- .- I

200- s

2501 °

300 - 291%

350 . I 312%

1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991

\'AT zl!J 1:_~ I

t L - , .sj 4 ,, -, -

,c I L4+11I5 L._95X1 z f I sLI LL gl*

ir- -g 51 .. x1 YI iljY1'i L-Y I iiLJLI I , aL.l I J L. f. eI Z.,1 ux, l J

L-DIkI ^)I Lu AI L11,L- L ZiJg L- ?SJYSkJl, -,k1

I ZL-- ^5w-l '*!-G9IY ? '= I o Ijl .- L4.L L<- W_ 5~11

*g6DJ J-;j J1<.tll ZlljY .s;lillz -

:41tJl ;Jj6txL ?,"Il ;Lc AziYI, 4^

i = (SDI) 11 t,L ,.I(LP *i) &;41IL - IJ ( Jl ;.I L-i

A (m-c) + [(E*m) -P] + K

n (LP')

; .L 6 L1 (4IL.JI -i.LI) ;W uil JU .JI ;Z;I.l = A

.a>L +.i;iL~L "Ll "' Lu1L ;aillolll iul i>iCij iLI;alc1;U -6 Jl C- ji;-J;lLl

Li Ill 4 iAiIL L.I C Ji ULL ;J Ai- 4.il L.F C P

.JULI EXyJ f+Y jJI ,;li = E

"WLI 2AU;±1 ;fl Jtl ii e. ellJI 4;JI L:-JI5) L.11 ULUI ;4I L+.= 2Il I 411 e4l ?,"I UL = K

.(4,LjI 4I1I IL

.LJ W~4 .W . Xii,iI JLJ _,Al = 11'ZJ.UI L-_4L L;i XI ZJiL, ,i L> 1 41U L1 I 1l W I , JW = i

.911 4lUI SaI IAl 5>ULa IA; L,,. Iz.p LJIU 1 I; S 1 >jlJTLz

- TY .Yaron

a.l 4I.LAz 21 iJUI +I;Ll -1± 1 j.l JLj,.ll &4 "lr l_-, ¢-l UAz ,< ("V).d,li

-V 1..I~I iJ U. I -_* I UI &UlJ0t% ~ .~ciLLI ZA J1 ,U . YIII ( II U I t LL_I i;il1I LIO I'l

~I S 41 I5. L;:~ L R.~iJ y

(NVjj= I Yi -.±-Lj RI a;IY V A LIU I *L ;.l;-|- 1i51

I L-L Z Lf,l l4l 14Z2 11 -

.(UI Z Jt -- J SL.i d -*LL'l ,Ia1) illLjl ..!A L. iI± iL eL'J vS.

*.j (j I- 1_, ai I 4I i t aU .......... , | z9*fi> L I < k ~ 'SL&~~~~~~~~~~~~I Je L- ̂vlJ ;5L^ ^- jsd U-l %X. L[ W;

I a^. I ->tJ.-- r-A LL1 I 4 ;tU I :,1L- ;I , ;11 JL: Z iil5; -S *LoI

*j w:lI ,s~ Z-- R5S~I ;*!,, 1 iJU IL .I 01g1 Z. w JI 2,1 I1,

L,:JeS I U>>- &t - l <e,;1t II< .j; 1; s ky lL

v>M Z L

*1vi;JzaoS; .,X L..:-,,kI-E¢ I

.Ll JLt3 ,1 YI.;Ej-11y,s1 ,jL AI !,11 L .>1JyAo * I? iJ

,<] WI ,Il- D J.Y vl 11iU i;I V LI sJ5 JI .Zf : I L'i J>

iJ;\is 1|aS1 tuy <1& a1>=1 & 9 L1tii. :r-Y SLWI KZ

450 1-

t

350t300

250

200

100 - 7 767 9

50 - - - D ||E a 52 i

\ sO.Squire VX,.L .,

1 >!1 ;~Lj -l 4 i sl i cS;-- apX ZaLO Gs ll o ,L t I t>f .- M JI J I f6=S

* 11; i: Ot-V I iL - 1 -:o;21 ) ' i Lws fi

,f .;L f aLJ :,-L L-i t L gj_ --............I_, JJ-S l ,L. I 1 f6A 1 -J4 1 > ^JLj 4-

Li ---?1J I LZ ~-ll a4e ":o ,-v{iz Z" L, L5 U< t1;. I

,y l-j i I; iI i XLl -̂ -. nv1 . - I .-1LI .il1

ULI LI d-, I jl J,.lS l g -- I I O .IJ1 :£-V JLLVl

(K.; I 11; (9WI J L JI 8) J;DI 1 _

I L .LL.. VI I 1 J 1 LU. ZA I L i

4(L-; i U L..1 j UL I i l J0J I I4 1 vi d , I U_j I c - >1 ,et$ ,iL s l.Y

; •Jol :L Ž 2 L iI JjLiI j. JLVl Q-_ a

U xli &L...11 tj Z~.L +1l ;LjIul ~LL ,JL ' .*:. I . -9 -

Zd": wJUI JuI a j ,v , -ai a.~ 4 /& IJ . - |1 W1 Li -LAIL*

ti IjJv.11.J .L LI Il i ; JlaIl JUl j 1 I ' L ; .L J, ±L Jul Jj*:ZlJ iLJ I4, I JJ IAJILf?. rs; I i ,; 1l . J nl * IJI.,,L &rSJLL WI 6-;1 L 91, I Li 1jt~ JI s

SCr - all i 1>>l v J;;S :.l 1 l1 . -. Il

0J= '; ; o6|,§.:A1A1o1*f 1 \1v!M A,H

ili . I .. .:I LJLI-,, i:sc - ,94 J.uz L;.L I ;J (;I) LSl LI

*AU LI ID Z _ L41 1#.Vi 21 Ji La S J 41 a, -L a:;.IY

'~ ,i -tI LillS L)-.sJ2l= :IL du Il>@ Jb

i;ll (j= 1 1 ). vlj- ;s u 1H

L V)441 ; 1(t U;* .,Il La Aa .11;: 1 - J E L-

ELIKW lJYL L ^ 1=1 JU CH V4 Jo5. izS LL VL IIiU 1 11-.2Z JL I V 4*L;l=>

s 91 i I ; 16 I J OL ; Lj S IV

tiESt. -. _ Itu J-~ Lty tEy -/9 E

r, Zr,;, o4 v4 'va Y£ \ N

Y r £ Y**\A

V Y. i \SAA

y .llo r J

tU I oW I J V LO I I YI ; -, JI- V-V I

L) Li UI oL LJ I i s U ̂ I; <l'

;t.N1 ,S I oA W Ij , Jav .1M ,1 1 ial I

,e5 -j 4- YI4 -. L, I(5 ^ ; .1 I) 1o: 198 1983

,lSs4II1 6-xUiI ;_'i l -- 1986 5 ..........;

ai L. LL .: I V- I Je:l - 19ll80 /

1 Lm IS I I JLS I ,L , #LLv° I s. s

It - ;I v',- Z,. L,.U ,WI ;j-,Y -L4 NrYje -

:, ,5l o=J. Lj - SL v v U.N 75

L;Z I i LJ LIU>:1ssSIMll

~~~1t L= 1;1JFI HLll J. Ic -=il -JIL*WI -i I U I,.

¢aJJI .AL.,JI iS6l EweL sLIY .1611IJuL.

-->L , LalY YI,, -oL Li, i zUa 9,I> il.1d*r L,.il ;I,JL ................ sUll

I-l IJ LLY 1i vg' t I9 L i~ Lv 1 ; 1 LYI J JI ".i rill I

Vl U--1lul =Y I1 .LtLsES*1-1 Sll e I J4jXJ Ls KI I L.vL

- 1 i15;.a LJ >l L--: UvL I Le- I y1 LI ;

*iLII fiI 'i;U i+ll ; -- Yl i L.I -.-Yls

"oL-, Yi I tal I ,

Ls^ :--ILY LJL-U L,1 jU I x I v j1

(¢:6119J*2i l N LEJIRR. I ;LoL-1,LSI >-<; .5 Z............. ld- Z4L? O ; I -- LIIJY

-- 21J ,.,zs1 Ji .. A....J.. - 11--I,9 I J ;a 1 L LO*Y FR .L.:IL J > 1) 1 - Y L L J,

TS DI LJ 9. §;I D l M I 3!ERR

SL2 LI J- JA X * i 9IW DI J i - IH RRQ 1 ~ LJ U (I NI J I) J5Ll.l uL :L.I J~ L-e

I~D. >L;.! -j J ;lI Z1 J IRE I 'vztU .DI J, L IA -

- 2 S J LL JU I NI1J L..............-.J I,J , L-VJ,- 1 LIo

NZjUsI tJ- LI U1 oI L< L.1 JI j v~ _, P .t( jIojo1- .AY Ix J

Ijs tFt; L,1 = 6. I ;-AL Z; LLu I ZYI J.L._ ":U l L '*-1 ZA,g1 v,s WI JJEs-- -L-1

L,i .; .l - ... LAI j i La.U aLto I JrL- ;ZU I ,- Y -l-w J.. *JIYt ,tJ l e1v "*(cvL,isY L,- I; Z.A YLi YI UI ;M IA 1 y I MIA! JYJ I 0 j

-6.IJ ,11t,] , LYJA l 2- Ju ;;--1 Li L.AL- Z)t,U ,, ~9 e LA-Joi I-1oLC J a-t' ,I U. . - -,10 1, llUI ,, .U I, LtAi II ,LIj , _-:: ,J1 WIJ, dilSl

4s; lJ1 J.AI J-L11 E]I>-L1 Jl; L,11 L,-L .,lJMtI I YIA ,,1 o Aii-~ l ,iUL °1 NJ a_.i; UJG

ZWI Jj^ I,Y L<.. L.S^ Vi-t ;- 1. LIgl; ZL I L'i; I-! LkA ZI wS "i 0 -:J I JAJ~ i; f A;I ja J LY

; SJII LL s l ZY LOLIL 1,> ;., -lo;Lltl ; J iL I M v 9J,, t.- .......-1|;-LAV SlAl S

is ;Lj I t-'- . L LZ- I Y, I *L I Jl1 1A Ij ?*a ;;UI -_

Lri-i ZZAI .. JU v- jJ , Jl AW) :1- ,LYI JLll 1~ V.A. vU Y VA ;LW Y v

-A - :. LrLLJI IWI 6 11- J U

-1;-1 1- 14 SLr U;t1 YjLrLlAL.'I S 1LeJLAX;Y IY A L 2 -; ; lIJ

J A L >u L A I L I J-A (1 :L 1 1.Y A 1 tJ J LLI .A , 1 , ZI J1

Es~~~~~~~ttlJ LrK VMJ11NEJYI,9I .- l Lj (Sil .,JuHlA;I clwl (oj1 )Rj 1 .

Li, I;C L W ;jlI ;L. .! iLUKJ I L&A I -,-, 1 LA uY SlI i+Lj Ef LI U A Ijl,U

, )rIn an Scm tI L :...L....

V-31t1 rp11 uW1:610i -A jLSI ~ xl ,j, lXl Il 2 LNuil

&LL Ic C.,r LeZ z 1 .1 -L t uLIUI I;

L4 5 9iL I |L I D U9 3I Q d .Lot -I i I h J B WiJ I J i I

~JWJ[

L;JLI oL.II ,i L, ,11 ZL:LiI o;ll X *IJ U; LY I3 J I 1-4f 1 J4 V - 5i

ULlj.N.iJI J)Uo I U.-y*L I ..iYI r .L_LJI tJlII I

LJ " LlI 3 dUJI I Li YI J-jL ?0 * -I o l Li* J ,JI 3LI - - -

ol>ill~~~~~~~~Z: LI Il il- J-Si-1 i> I Z . .La t-l , tW

. . .L 'ZS,.;sLII o1>1

.A.Mo0.Krahnen and Schmidt _,1 jilJ-6l= <5 g,;4 1 -; I lliSUI I1 :I LIM L,-.1 * 1 J41 1 ,J LJ Liel Z3

1 1 ,J9 IJ,1, LqL L 1t,A I - *;~L * IIYI al.i iJx 1 1z'

LJ.JS1 IIJ.OU-I 41 *L5 LiilW iljlI. ,1_,1-- I ;IJ

, j *- !)lI S I I_9 a, @L. J * 1V -1V1 lLii ll& ........... 4>5 1Y

d j isl JL Ip I . ,1 Ij).S-l ;LlJd Uil.-.LJV > I S L

- IJ . ;jVI ;JjY f_AjS L.. i ^. .,:t ^ f D JL Ls lAj U I . -- L. X- . lj1d. '.l

*;jljl} j.al~ IVi K,,L *;11 U=L, ;f ZgliSI.L i-4 i-L.' o I

>;LC5- 1 1JS1 t-L d| -- 4|,AI 1 bjb

I~1 _)UilJ I "i L j t ,* iliU r)(

A - a .1iaL,L-* a-.61 l 1*1iL J,I f L ols JI 1 L1e1j

. ;1.:t,z1 L .L;IS LJU ,I cLX11? ij IJ *j 1.-1 J J~ L Z.1) eI k UI L-,I. -I s

i1Lj_qJ1 ,IU,1- Mj >S la |d-) | *- -- |IJA5L- -

Uj L L 1 . ;^ i 4 L l (mAf) Edgecomb and Cawley.4..9

,,i L=.I I , I II.I J *4 I J I

; . i V t a lj JJ L;= A.hk LYJI iI I

ji LJ I jl Y l li' jJ1

L f .Lii-I LlLsi Li *1 f *l. I ZJUI I 1 y3d

j3>;L..il ,d G.i' 3i £U.I -L..V - |v = V| U|. WIJiL |I~ &LVtL

1s1 . o 1 p1 J-1Y ii LJI 4i>;Ui Z4?I

iI Y .Jc,U ;jiJ d *a; I•Q I 4 ... I 1 ....:

,.Lj.L4 J L -;LIj j9-J I J... &,1 J. L il-IA 4jlIiI LW

*iMPl~~ iJlU OL&I~ '

CA LII ILU ,L *;l.W I OL<LL q- - ;I ;-, fA /4X9g/ -L -tl I1 11 LL;LYI I HLA C--. I *t L X : J4 i..Liaj l ,

*(T-A J ILSI ,1ii7 Ys~ ̂ S1 Il I aS I I

LW L#o i 461>1 1aR1 1 i6i s;a.LO YJl ................-.. * 2 F >

iiilJLI ie LUI I 6 1,'Y 1 ;oLt I ti t @LIL-I ;, Hz JWl t L L I^1

v?ti {LL~ L+I .I.L.S ........LJ I .-L- IL ; L- * It Lgj I ac....... ;:,L I,1 ,11 iLLI c,L;ll Lk

-j i ,.1 - s J pt1v MJ. F;-FP J1 "i .............. ISt1 ,,; 4U,I J"'I.l ,L1 S C. " V 'i ;:

Lo-zl- Sf JL.^11 &121 1 sL;4 iJi _v i & * u ULI O l S2/Ll¢ :14yJLAI; I QOI, 61,-- Y I .S9 4D!Li I "'Si f;J;: SY< a 5lV tA -'IWSJ

Jll J il,-i ,M GJ JLY Li UJS L-

-ZSLl XFAj I 5 I Lri- J-LJ -L ;Ll IJbt- ,fi LJ lIl

VI.,L9 t,t - IJS I vj10I> > , II e U= 2ul a * .' I - jl" Z ,olJ

Y 1 JI J I9 1L A I> I H l tiJ1 L,..t,.W IaAD £ 1J

JLt>;{.;,9iLtIil Z-;L .J>W ,I5 ;jl -; L f= ; I - iL l a l

,sk'YI iiallS;]"i L =1- Jii ;.Ou LL S1 t

Z-; ; Ij U 51 I L::l- , A I JLGI .4 J LA&j - ; ;I .J--J 1bS

i;U:LlLLI Z-611 J--- oGSIIwi Lr **i ?J i1 1 1a1J 3

4V >11 izUI p1 J ;ill Ji ¢z etall Lj. Silv i 5);:L

Jl.l;--:.. jL4. LI -1 ;461;I 6.1 :T-A Lj.VI

LV. .j.II f i .5J1 tiu. .1-.. )1 V L *W1I c,4) >.i ) LSV JL -fl 1 >1>* >J

, -V 9 L5-I J, _ -,ijLI i 4,jl

I I £L k 4,L,-1

;.LU3

_,6 i

M , JW e 1 ri JAL.I i. A

Z J 3 t il ZLLG;1 1 : -;L I I1- I V LUI .u.44i J J 1-1 IJi 4 L jL I

UlII >Lo4J lit U .IiJI yil U aLILi vW U..,4I ;,L:tI ol-l JSSi i;^s*1 h¢I Jl ~:i Al

I * UW e , 3iI .J6 U jLi; l "-I L 5l

1*,Jl Ibl bi Y£ ;iLtCl L(:i L Ji .,I ,,I I1 MpA J YL

8 ( >) lI J~L1~~ JVIb C31 :iLY I ,ILU _6 * (_- I ;

- L I ?N. b1 *l ., ZUI wi "i . ZUI LLi o $ I .. J

Jo: /TA -,1JO N .... t4:\* -- qvi ;--i:luJ ';ZjLll bILAI ,L *sL; L;il 1

;i~~~~ v iJI - 'YslJZllavI;LiUI Lifir 1ds-) zLu} ,,iY :-iVi

- - Vi*v LLL °iD J,;1;*LU I l1A

ai ,1I l. oL,i ALYL L;jil .lf oLL ;.%;WI siISJ - lll- -1p;

SJJ L" * Xl 7- 1z -'L 11 ^YIS I1 ELJUi JLI "J J; o IY i; &4e:"L

- lIX:, ,L'iLI; '%-f 11 -O L;,i JI . ;lE L ,g4 -Lc-IS 1 X

LIUI ;t~~~~~~~1 4-k, -,;11 O 1 S1ÆBJ J1I jI 1*--;11ZuJlO 5il 4J -1 s

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~!- 1 - ;142L,J iiLlW1OSIOL. -tJ R 1

iL a-Jlsu;JL vt1 au.1 LI - -i - zp1 ;-I -II; &A--

,ltA aqLr_S 41 >1j iatUI sL;t I - :1L ly

fa jlJ -,JI L29 Qu t-W , ;Lzil CL -, ...... 11 1(1 .-slDI

.L 11 .I 1 lU I*-I lUI :,L_tY ~¢ 4=ioL-6 _L >nj LI

ZiL -eXil I "IUI, .~-L I Y- I L -& ( j).,1I oL ;li Lj-S .s

LA~~~ i .i o L -l. I a, W .sj o1=^ l.J ,ii

iAtU I i-i ..!Y 3l JJ W ;1 A sl . (; L ,l.s oit L e Z1 ,Ll

VI.>1qx j-~

-i- LLA ;<;fS Ll,"l e ̂ f Ia SZ I¢ U L Ij oL^1 iL-; ZI tJI ZL K-,LIaiLlS

f5-i aA L' 441, 4 .1- Pl ,I Io*X -'-%l &L.=YI v°., iiwl 1J - tMA &i jo. A1 : 1 l L ,i L. V-M Z- -l,>-11I

olitw.L,." YJlAl 4141 V 1>. F."j"j i, Z-@1 M 18#'- LA1J v2 vll

.ILJIl LII) z z>Io *1*LL LI w l> ;^;Iol fEL: :tl,; Li dv-l

- qrL I Al * .Ui Ai - I - Low 11 va. I

v^t; ~'YI ..e,11 V I -ul

j.,85 <,l,M ij ~J 9 L 1 Ie i; IJY, V 35l ,1 U.L9 -Yl I !Z - 4i.r-Zx1 L+a.<L j

_ .I-at9 v tS,2 g ll- j1 1 ;_o l1511O J41 t; 1LS 4.T -I~ -: IU. t^>E, u^s I Q L--;I I

JLS , Z I Lj - I4X VL- ?1 411 LJ; 1 I c, V L ESJ I a: 1 P 4a@S

a(z.- t I t::j I iL,I21 1e] z1*-1 .

L4 J.:U IA L;>1^st :i I I1b I _I-9 LCLf &Z 7J ,Ll....... 11 ;iv *-* C l YJ4>

a11^. JUI clI V.Y11 . I L.-, I< jiW 3 L *-11 JI Z19 j IL:YI Li4? 1 Y 4;i L

* 4L.J CI LI.44 L.s:; -1 Lg 19 ,Z 1 l t1; 1.1V YI A

,LI, JZ- IzLI J LY bIJI IJL I

U1; 1 IL; YI ialJ V4q- ji V ZLI Ie4YI@8lJ J1 'VELJ.

I L-. <LI A l4( II :9 J-S.J Z;l iMUjI U-L4 J LA . V4,=. *_. 7,LY6I V4. r L-I

AL ; Vi- L * 41 1^-4 Df W*JF _M1aj I V4~ L, JJ.82 11X 1 1 1;1 . 311 C IJ7 V'6 U1 -IJYI -ifl "1*^^; L J L If-. 1 oLiL oMY 4SJA .Cae n ozlzVg)@JJ L21

,,1,1&L IiiisbiY li4jo -6- I; JAJM ,- I la4 I ;=YCJIJ :-,I6L,

L<t DI LJ.ij I V'4 'JII LH I ji 1)l - ; 6l IU Y

_;1 _OSHL:J 1 ) 1 5I al-4 LZ L2 1 L I? ; _L WI^' 1 =1ILl.?

.(\-A tLYI LG J LAII Ivi(- ]l

Al ;1 LJ I c,; U I ; 3^ LicJU Ilij L,,clfiD; IIcll l

.:--1 * 1 t-,3V LiYI s*f J1aI1 6aA *cuLS . Sun Multi Serve rQ ;* Lwj

lil Z*!. L..aL .;2li 1 f ^- I jYI JS L; I r J.3bu,, L.) 0jil apL . 1,f,-Jal .W14 -a

*I 4JU L - l AU* L 4 6 ,1^' ' Lri 1j| I Lr iUtd I -- -,- - zo

C--L1 Ij 1t I" i-T I,ji '-- IsD j-Jti -. LYi ,>

L- ZL,U J1 uUI d L t -:I a, Le- Y sjW I -L jl

Stockvel LLa .O;i ,Dr ,e-;I ,GD,

).4 ZJ Li:-Y1si9JI,lla

O ;J Ss.~ j,1J SV:l iLLill ilAL CtLS L,L11- ! t;.z<

"South African Finance: Not a For-.L /

:1L1ialI oYI .e ; Xs9ssaetJxr ,-usI; Z mality"

LLIJ 1 tI d;L ,l 5 V J5JI 1,Y1 L*; -r 1 II J 5 L5S I J Sv CÎ

L's Ld- li =e s1 I 1- ,> s,-J ,I i-e- Us I1 a. I Jli. d-

- i',YL L" ib L I -. Z J.: j 4 ,$ ,Y '

Jj ,L=Ylj jL-;.YIJ Qlu"I jj JU9{LI J~

1 ,#~~~~~~ (OL F4l 1 X^^JL.,Y& Le- SZ Z.L. 1 LJ UX gI d ;31 I ur L-

(C16I ' J1 l'aA:I) ;LII-J ;JUI LL:;-l V1 llII L---" 1+1 4 I;J aA i L. L, 1 II

J iYI4 C I : -1 V1 *;*^tI , d d;1e ; .- t ,1. 7 w L JI V

L.a Lz, .. ^L U ; I.. I k I Jd YI iL6; L S1 L5 1il tJi I J. LiL LealL.,

J; LljL L . I1 ,1"* fu IS 1,lib *Ja_ IJY 1i j-;: 'Y I ; 2 YILIIe?

f. L j S 1C J.l I d.,L I a, Ld I J I L h p I SJ Xd I L Lf

SC; _H9LL.j l- : I ;w YJLi I z1 ,3 .dI )Id-

JUS ,5*1PiV S LWI ;o v 1 r,S -i JIYJ 1 S w I I-

i ;XSJ I S >5 LL $J I &1 -<IA 1 lS I- L-e A- A V UIJ-- - 14,a. L,- &........ lJ[ Zd,1 UI; .......g

- iI tss I * , It .. I.I I

YTV... a.UJ , LJLt. -.... L.c.L.I Ui ,i I - - &nUWa .1 *t,a1STs. a-< i;IU 1 JUl , .... .. . ....... J X .- .; L IJ ., ..........II SlrLaII t L1U.iIJ 4 II :I;3il dO.L

, j lj,l *,y lsUI ,y ¶ L. LJ5L 4Yj L I ,.JL I Z*I..A _,j * W ,L- 1 c tJ

.-- ;vt*sSJ UM£ t;llJl @JIl;l2L0;6IYIJU-xif

j L-j .ZUI L.i SA Z-,; :L J.I,I aL.:z1 , ol. Al o1 - -I ;-L-_I I

Zi UjI 1 L- -ILfJ& UI. l LtW LJJI) J U 1 ahILill0l -Zi ^lJa LLL olI > i ti 43L1I Lt;U I *LLUI tiJIJ1 _L+.1l .LYI &,LJ 4 bQLL 1_;1

C.4- l >I > J~ >,kLSI cItYij~~I 0l*- ;L.II J6Xkl =2 cJi;ii II^ - oL~.A cI~I MS * l _g5. L J L JA -g i/ 1 Z6LL_II Jlta._ L,i ;J V l l I .^*,J

L- c A.A llL o. ^ i * -jt.i *Zi.pil L*YiLi U9 cL.

x~' .- L-J.±1 ¢b1 U .L ill A t LJiL.- -, 1 J 1 .lLi.... @ ; L:

L-t-Li ;-A AI Ii~L~ U ~A,2I a,.. zg;jUd ;AI 1"JI &L<- ZtL

cL-f- r~Y 1_ v tli -1. vL- ,L-i Q LL hlj Z-!1 1i, 4-LC. ;16;1 <5I ,Q1 ;fI'S > I ,;LLll vI ;i_pi c

J0 La- IZ" , EE I Z4u ^ ; ; LtX,! 5 11OJ I :-YIOI> *

-Q9;-lI ,)-141 L; ;,!" O2 1,4-° J? 1 1

.k1 iUI °-11 l4I & .JL II O N;;JLi LI( i-,. L C LI ,L.I- 1

V .aif (_. ;°IYI ;~Y I 4JD ;YI (I KahLen and Sm id t_,,j ; J AL I f YbJ Y I rj,, I J I9,J IJ -S a°YIusfi^ 0>r11Z lYI LGIV 8

VL-° ? Y a jll [.;L11.^-1

<1.;11 tt-oYIt;1>?1Cli -ol,liaol,i lz1

~Z I -j a1 1 L .oveI ,LE s

-Luciano Mosele fê4 .IU iil ._,jYljY * )11

b,1 aU ;jj-g IJ; ia LV La I Z-L11i*Jl 1-Ls vi (8NVka) Krahnen and Schmidt

5 lJ L. KE I Cl 1,;,llJ' --d I OI ;Si ,"-LSSl t.a-I *s

Ij J>;t 6la--Jl I &a -b-&J IJAl ',9 -i.L- Zt_2 4;l C;s=~ L,.~ li a

L4, oLIj,.W GLY ;

.V~s ~ ~j~1 ;j1 Z1. :V-A jLLVI

- * L- :^t r- 11 S l , ; * J '4 M ( 1J1-) - yJ gA 1O v1 bSJk *- - :

Wi UIj ; Jl1 %kALI JI oa .AVI ;JLl L 1 o 1 1 LLYI

cL I Li I j-iI S. * c A Li *.IY1 , i L .?l ;JI cC_ _ VM -. - L1 i j

A L.Li JlVI *s54I :I.5y L1B L J t C.; '-*. / JLL K

L,--LI ' Y .4 1

, *. 11 LL- Yl ;LI 0 - - -lZ6=1<-0P 2 K')L laZJl4 =b1 ^ LZ°lXl c;JI,=,K iS1J I9a -:1a1;o

*l Lynn Bennett and Mike I3berg L ,6 .V :-1I - I r L.: L Y u,

t-- 1-1-l ;,LJj y.LiL;t I cAI ..LJ .+Lo

L uI. I L.4 5 I L - ^ l .YA L 01I

* 4 Z I c5Jy1IIe bS w*L?L* ,ne ;1^1'

Ltr(/ L i ijL1 tj,_U . -1 .. = ry .z L _,1 '

i5;toL~~~~~~Zj_ I -S6 1 1 IH J: I ialL L 2/ Y l-il bL&2.Y -1 I LS> JU LIL

A.- ZIJ CW;1 I;YI v ssO-E4Lo4*ilB F$LSt ;L

DAf.U LUp-s. L L i W .;~ I ZL4.WJ l *JL ULI,DY

L) J I Ls L5 *, Y;,1 OL_c; - L I I L SdI °

-JIiZ AL.Jl VL Lt .L l :-ttt-=u.^ VJU .1--;,!Y 1 oj-4 v 1 Jof L.S2

1 ' '''' ; I L9¢11i 0 1 i, 'oII I.%.-411 Y^ l

Qil.aY~I ZL4o oL y?1c* I v} v*: .1.u |... J1J .I &.j1 Z:~ 0 '

iL;l Ia 1 Kil I L ,olJl- L ^ Ij L * ,-

Z481 I Lj3 . ;>L- i( Z-_- 1 4_-l_ -L us I cLHL" ZtL .L. cLA

,Ilo : , ZJU I =Jii Lf,L - ~ = Y 3U = I :,J YI l Jl L . ................ . l.

ZJA~ .L L;;UI Z, ..LJ UI ur c£ vil_l 1 3! J J [J I J.*- L<e

L5U U II 1 Il ul Q9l_ {uW1 -._L .I j iL LL I L' _j _;j 1 ua_ L;1 I 7-c- 'J 1- I , Lll

VIj J 7.1 *L-41LI _V V1e«;UI *L-,llAif A-A1 :,LWI

,YiLeJ ? M;-.J <D i Ji ;: ij ilL "stockveljf> ;a

6-Yl 1 6 -5L"J I j aA - ' Y jl ji ;_, -I ZYI ~ J ;.$L. Lzl L,;L;: Ij 1

J3 reL C§l u 1 L . Hi ;IUI -L--,II L,- L4-Ass ~ ,K au ¢*1;; l5*eg-tC4î. Lz1 6(S<tLYls*1oI44Q sle-l:l* , ;.LArI JL. C]Lf, ju,'lBl4 t.s 'i

_,L>. ..ill ,,LkY ol^ -; * - ^ 2E I Qoj,l" Li l; *LLyi JL :' '**1-5

.+1,, ~~~~~~J ;a;;.zI,1i.;il ,;:Ich- t Lwl ;*1>};:

aS aA L6 J;j* I e -J ;ZI JltAJJ Z S1 "1g AIS: 1 r6 dj............. .eIt

*L-t::1E,DI1--j;,41 Lit-YJIY jpsWl i (LtkJI.U- J11,e;L -M- ,-I VAj,) fi

J-6. LJ I C,l g I s @t;U 165 L-, fC Il9

,"South African Finance: Not a Formality" 4-oL. e.W AaA .,>;LII

,;J ^ 1 W, -L-- t.A .L"1 ii+ e I ;Ki ,Ym A.JiL l I;t s1 ........ .1 9 I jLlzo EIl

,u ,) ja1 AI 6-1 Z4-L F1t U-? i _ X'Yl *LL1 F.*4 II u1 LP IÂ JlLJ

t7*1 L11 *ILJv j .'YI a1cUI t 1 Ii liS-!

t~~~- l ,z,lf -YI I;Z 1 ;1 a.SId

,J, .Y1 L;,|.i.l Ij Ll lS ll.> Ic LQ_ UI Lt.1 I- *S9Jt

,,L ^ 11s % L=L ,jlU J J; I~J .{LIU rj.B Al QlJ i11 - I l 11 SI J-s I; t L A4-1Y L9 al;J,. Ll;i I I *L9 tl; .1 -C,5i *; 21 l:; *- ~IJ *;jjil &Kws * (-AJI:LSL I QA;;);- 7- *tliUI X31 _:.ll I

9 SI IJ J 9# L LPJI; I S SL:Y V1 -,Lt

L;LZLl IJ At1 cU51RAlj ;LUJI Z,. V5A j.7I;;1(P*;B ;; L-IL~

PL,; 1.3 V~- O-/ ry i l I,J* #H J1;J ~tJ l e g.lilS ^*- J1s=ES1 )LI Sst 9L &..6j isJ= LIes AI? LY

j IJlt>i l I *c-t. ;jU>SI Z ,jLA L, IiW .c9L; Jji

.1 LLYI Z. I l-Ji I Y _21L I vS,

+t L-j I et V4J I cLDl l , z L l J.11 21 I jX-. t j *l -X d I Liz Lg- L.:*.' IF

c LJ J (l<-$2 j ^ L LSIJ I1 Ze,_l I I1;15 ^vJ ^-1.J

Ou.A 95 i)? v,. [ a L!:I I Lai I Il t.;e I L ,U&,Yi W WJ i" I 4.A--I

iLU YJI 1 ; (? I JI 17,z U.1 IJ 'L. WIj IS ZJ Ok I a, J_~ Iu .jJ ,1-

j-V -I,UI j4L- ;,!W 1 - L.>--... _5.I1 +j &,L .Y-/ 11 ct -1 -°i A° L di 1 ClM

; u > .JIJIYS;; ; ;;- Jl ,.Vc, -/1g ."-.115 11 iJUIolil o I

cL'J£I ;1JliLL;Y ;S Li Li JJI (IjI)QJIluJI Y

M.11LYLPS ri Jsv- ,- j.sAAA -- 64 Z-., -*XI 4:1 -01^ t 5

LL;j 1 ,7 :L U I QL d-i .Cus ,L-.J ;j= se ~,;I ISk &!-. atayi

-,.LL11 ;' il 1" l Ji 6- I L1:r 1o 1 i llilYlo;w - "Sf- 1 b;i i1L;Y

.iil I e .. CL-il W-JollL-ilA1-j e. \s L,1 11 J*.. 1-- oL;I VY OJ-jA

1D= I C-li; I.A .; -rU-j Z+-,I QY \L-,A1 Vl 1 J U j L u-I i. 1!- ^L-j. tA KJA ,aD tiait i y s> .ihi ts2

Iy j' I~ I,,, I:t1 * -jlDn i

4i ZtI:l id-l S1KL

Lynn Bennett and Mike Goid- &. ?L#i J-J Q6=|loit-,L L,-i 7=11 j6L:6-)I J.berg L c 6 i , ,1J1Sc ; -11 a:tl jJII JEj e

v~_ I Z.iLj I-> 1 ilU I :, L-3 oL -I adA -

Jfb5 ~i LJS L+ I1 4:I w JLMII -_.L ti. -;L I .LL I Zl "4i L - IU c,ll .- A

L- lI U;;... IJ5t I Y--1 l L._41 1 M 1 tE,3 1 1.

U. ,L, ',l I ;.,-Ll ., , : I a, UL ** I & :iu,aJ1s411 i g11 ............... I+1 ,Ij L'^1 iJ L -x -g 1 I 'L,-sS .- ,L

Z1521 Z4jil , .............. .c I uE t -: I o L - 1 - vi

V2 -tSL L,' t!i *Z.iiLj d -U^ -- e Lvi- c* oL,

L<Z J S 1J- ;it) I yI/JL' I, ; L- Jaid L.--I1 jtEI z L Ce*LjY

II F]LlIXI -iL Yl Li-1a !A^ ;LiL5; 3-7AY *SIGl and~ I eqG- 1-411 J_qLt

(4L-A IlY fiaL)JUll<ll.'iiI eitJI 3 li <tL,i:I

u=I si-LL - A - VjU-Jji.L4 J La

YJ *;L 1I tJ, dl fl...±1 LJ.; l* 14n .l *M .iU o0 tI jI J Li cgk I .:LLJI vaff

~~,k V 9I ,I J4 ( i2L •,L*.L ,LL.. *{ : ,1) J.It.U I VI eUX Au~If~ Ul LJ .4 VLiL

.4 L tS jlil 1. YJI AI .S), L o * ; ; V , .ii jo :- j.C 1- v JI

) .;CLII r tul iL -,IaV- ; * .4-- ZL.II J

.l jLIJ ;,[-Al JL.-- b1.;1. C .k ,lIVl L 3LLJ I . L

Y I ;JLJ U

- ~ ~~I ~ Jl& l. 3 dl JL. Lila olLS

Benett -I Lils :1GX , L,LWI LrLI J5 ;11

Besley and, Wk.Goldberg, and Hunte j*i.V I I

Rashid - uppi and Feder., v^ c Coate l] ,,ti.*Afl v .i a L-' 1 ;.iiN and Townsend .(,iUL

w i.JLII sL.Y4I i - V -L * IL1 I Li. -- L J .

,5(6 Li I) -,."I,SO-LL** 11v vg

VL." qr toiltl,ia s,L aj'-UL LW- LIjl di L::-Ft) WsL. LvtoZ zt2 UK;: ct"=,L_ L-; *(2-Lj.:j I iIfzi LA

. JIj9 -a .y cLIoyll ,Lli& O J#iV , L4- ,,,kg ,I ,Lj - 41 L;I.-,

tij 4-iL; .11 ;iJi

Bennett, J 855o .Pederson -^ Li, 9.LI :J L-,- I;IJ-v v1-Il 5

J*l 5A J ,L J;; ,DX 11 5J i1 v L S 1 ;Ls ilL; . JL 4!L@l

Lj-9 -- J- L,:J Izl.611 &,jL _.61I C-? Ji-,1 kL6L I S L l _P1 J;6" -Jze l- ' ;-JU9l Oi-J'l J

J-"1 I f-j L.; -Y I Jl+~ SI J NPLW coL UL_ _,UV I Q6kUMjI *1jl..iVl cL_ LS1 1 JUi :1

LH-r-;YI a.1A I ji 1_;; JL ;I *.! Lt L? I ZLkl lUIWi3 1,*5al 1Z A J;2l IL^ O,

-_ oI il .juz11 _',~ JL=YI mil ,;Lj,,l Wl- Yl L11 L;I ra

*;;II 4"__ J jo Ie 5Y1 - J)L-;I L.-i l 4 tt< S .IW ,L jq- sJ 9CI ,i 1.6ML

i;ULJiI Z- JUlij ahl 119-; 1 v jJ Jw Si (SmartCard) z1..........., u.Qj z ;,;X- ,L- ZIp tMW1>S- L1 JIJ I =1 jY-

U ;L.:11, J5:.J t-.I ;i -- :; ;:%S, I; gz . l L J I JA I j,@ Ig z'V_

&L~~~> _i 4J11 , O;L16ZZU_ ;-XSIi OLi- U _ J--- j1 J- -14 L- . ..

.McLean and Gamser _,,, .;a Li I J I .tulss j i ;

e.L sO jWl A -2 ; U3 L,-,U~ W,.16 JU ;JI! .

iJw- lii ;L wi * ^-~ L.,W tL ,zj i6Yl tL.31 fLI -- JL k_, ><1 I ' YI; ,. i

L_J.lIt V f. i zL@al Lv. '.4-a u I -J~ c.,;Ua 1 ClS 1 &t i>;l5 9_%l tLi-.~ L l L fIi

L,Z.,1Jl. lx i1;vlY 1,.it§>0 I * _ .' f I U__ Z-11 D>1 eij V1 LS .JI

-, -&5 &I Zi! -;[L~ L., -, ,1 l1II JI C - zj L i 4_1M LA.L_&I t L..jl 3 ;.i

:i L--t 1 J,I4C ULl L:Jl a1 fBI. I . LL IJ I 0 I ... L --- 82A .

CO1~~~4: 1 ;L3. I1@I1J- -S

c 1 .91 = LL VOUI ;,.t_ ja~j plj' zJ" q;Jl-:Y ;L' V I YI5^l L'L ;,, 5; Vi

-;_4 U" J; Lj LV;-.1I .J L= IL .13 SII Ll1 I::SLL+ ,.,ZJ

AJi J , (NAI*o) Krahnen and Schmidt .- s ^ ;^Lsill v = .I Zoj s -o K-

* & ,; 4A'AIut4l Jf I1 .o.:VO21 .on Pischke) °S v 1^- 1

'SsL I i ;te I^ LY..I Li ^J-!-, ,9 .SI v^ S sS i LJ W I Ju I

:>LI wJ 11 J-Ia t ,si 1 saluJI a-a I: 1w yJ dll

.o1 cy- 1 Ir &uG 1Z - I rJ Ij L:; I,. J&i J* (j L Y-A'l cLllj~inLl

/ ;I,,- 4i;l,llLL- ^§j l

Z. 1-, ,1 !a. * .;- Lit5L r ,/ OL6 I II -LUll I11 CJ,a0 o14U . Z.,L ,3 I

'r-v J"I Z-ii) l;U--- ,z~ A-p oLJf * 1.31 ul AiL .;1, slji 2 YJg g1 tY

JA| J5.A J-....... Ir0 vJ-> L -- X ^, iL;j,>l a;;

_jW1*S ZL I 1,,L ,L ajl ;.4v l*S lo/i ts4~-*-

tiolti ;6Z 4 uil 1 I LL Z................L'Y --V J#;l 1iUIo V

.J. °1 V J " I U i,I-4J LH Ld; L Zq L i J Id J,-

Y I ~~~~ -6u.1 U j Y IJ i.L l"l JZL=V ;L 5 I %T-A Ln >4 U.II

;A.LJ 11 jgll 5-i-4if f- Z, bi nll =jAlS

oLvld LIY Li=; 6lil -1;Y :\Y-- LpLlYII-"

J 1 .1 v LJo tl J1.. I *iSL J I ; ou I .LZ *Ua,10 IJ11

.Alky) McNaughton - LS4, -z-,j ;'Y:.IIV°

LiY*Jlezl *L- 61 - C7.... [ OtA Y 1 >]-4iD I(Y j-,M .JIYS1.,A1t9

-v L4 - L 1 j~tI lj 1 V ; L-. t ;A li d ;jJ I a9 I .ll I z- i-A,ll I

uJ I - I I Ul - -L -U

U U i .* V° *s i1 i.JI jL _l L, ,1-_4 I

59y* - - - s ' -LYI u5 J Y4- L I - I i ,!V I t 1 I L-I I

Z:fiJ,I tJLA jA vv4L eLjo 611-:ELSv " lJl ;LLZ;

LbC A - Aj- ;-.j : ~ Z(St -; It i.;y vIi jlI J y i ,1 , -1 U..... 1 ;I S-L Aa IE L t I 6 z

.ZLLI vSL L _L i LiJ $3 i YL I .X LiI ,ll ,,4 Ll;Il

;<V=...;VO =/jAT = 7.= - ;/8-X £

t. * + (Xi *) N. + (YX N.) \*w * */ iD lJ

>t Yaron :,-

ZJLll>1UI 111..eL ;°5 1 , Ji .t^-i Ofi5 EL li,/

Z"i eLa UI iLl 1........... Ia L lD 4I , ...... 'J I1 "iJUI o 1 1 1 L a L -)4-.

a J.(I I a Sh d * ** ai.,1 .LLAiI 7U1li .UII 'I' ;L] W.A eL Ji J- *Ul iJlUI ;lII I&U

JV Lw6il I b LYLj 1 l I Qt bLelglLi;U :1jl>LL bJ]

EJ,yll L>I 1s Z. 13{4 l Uul . -,~ 3 LL~~ 1UI 1 .-b,121iig

;UI a L);-,- ,,1 .11.::,L,.t > lAl 3,L^ 1-1L .- ,UII

a d- ;-Lj1 I dLUI I ;L-~lI LL QDVLlFJ IIH1 1-Y J

,21~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~Ok J -^ t Qs, -. ,a. Es,Krahnen and Schmidt) j .............. t|, t

' -I6 -1= l L> ;bL- J; V U ll L L_1 J lv liA Lju

/^j ; ? V I^ IV Ô *-JLSE lY

~.It V;Ij~ ;;- L&j- : £-A ,ILYI

(S;l;laI AJ1 L..JV) i.yj11 J½ O LI aSS; V1 ; * V .A,l ~ J1Zi y ;1z V .I.IL±,VI ,..Krahnen and) L..i"I, L:';I aIL:Li . * . L.

.0(k,ka 'SchmidtL- -J 1ji UUJ UU , * L X l 4-.I LA LLI .I

-1,oIali Vi-i v l -A i v LI v- Ul A

.(+v5v.Bennett, Goldberg and Hunte) t : -J Z 31 * . L-JII

J9-I SLiJi V -,? y AL ) .tL *fL ;UL< * C --- iI :,C zL fOiW IjN

J1 Oly l t; JK~ V) ,4" :, aLA-J. L

JŽ -If ZA 6L) v'-JI JI, .j.&LI

*6>tj<^) lI * Y1;5E)-o ' S' ; > LJ ;.- W -M LJ ,IJY Je (fJY L. yw.Jf.YL ~ ..4Ii 5 ~V; MJ...... .l VCi | ;|: .l OY M (

V° LIUI J- VL QLL Ij ".;JL Y

I 'L;l l Y'i L,-,Z - XLUL I,Y I *JL~ ZL4- l ,

° LV,W. tI. j v ' 41 i.l * ~ ,k ~ ~~J&JIj jl-JLv jl, LWi Jv.- -I

J/ L LY31 VLJ.A' 'iiU * LI ; ). -* .5jJ L,

.L.YIJ al4l,iJ . AJ LL+4_,V sLLl Q1~V k f i-

Z"S OzY I P5d I. J. I1 ZLv Z. ,1-*Ll J/; V

4 5i,,, vdf,I 11 - LLp± i 1 l aLI , I*1V s* Lx

.tJ$1 d ±I JL o .dEL , 4 5v^ I-Z-L.1 ~JAsI , io JflJI r't S-I Roiso-

; ~.W 1)I c 1 11) U L6JI j (L JIJ * UJ 4ViX >1=IV .I i L I I ,+ *Z 1 LI_) I :) L_+!III

AIIj I( ;-J iLI I Q -_.LI QJI I -! 1 9l I I S 1 - S L OL Z05V 'Y * L,; Ij!O YI ,e-] I- a

LJI i{JA a..), 1.,1,, &\I:[L|O ^l.-I;.L

4.'' - J ^ 9 l 1 Lv , l ,-i ,,/-+,,/6S ! L-Li Y / -J- EX

31 I LsMU U 1;

Z, 1 - tU I IJ ) * j ^ JYI 511. -L I1 J+ 1 L 1 11I J1 M Q _4.L Iû (FLl ALJIJ _,I I MlV III 2A Vge)a %2

:IJ- A Y . :l am>s Jl-i.J2 I ' 9i 14 . ?I oS ()-o\£) Robinson j..~~~~~~~~~~;1 slv iY I * iL L:;j oL- 1 1 Ij LssEUIs;lf9ei.t 9

Lt, ,21 ;sLjj U I .1 j U521 ii a a Y1 JI IYI vp6leY .1 : Io.p 'SI) p1L jl

Y ItL7 2C61 I .............. .- J' A 1i J4 U11 L'e,1 -~ 1 Li-S * - A:ij Ul - 1) j4

.1 QLL1 Zv92s-(6 32 -?1 ZAL Zi.& 9l,%9 (v-1-)L.I1 zlLYI) '1

t;&Ll iIU I * 5. N.L f t I ZL2; C."1;* F ;(5 >1 S

;(<Lj ).,,g CLU _,L _4 J I LL JUI

f1 o4il lX 0;Wli -sL Jl-11 ;:~ U oA , I|

, u; ;,1 rv w . if- S i a w L -f V * > 1 i L5 , N Ity y -> k I L -o9

f.=N O il ZK_l i;UIL TV £ Y oi ^ Ly -it LO" I --3LI, 1j.. , 558 iy Iss C1, 1

,51 i t;L i EVoL4:4 *jI 6:!j ; Zr iila.l Ls YVo oSL-P E4-Li NV> Xij -Q - j. X.; a, I;

6111 .v &L J .\3tVi 1i JÛ L¢ A-~ :.1'1 1; i 1£1>x5il>&1IllL Z] L

iLll\tif.... J - ^ #e iL 1 - N1s5st ;i1SiJ=l

(J-1, Y] Trk...JJ L) ,FL VJ£ L I V°b' '' '.;-JE JVP'-S i cL- _

,K ,,LJYS C.S* S Uj fi) lA >> 1iz JU I.N cIAE C L 6 , IJ. U l LD -11 jj I.A Z Cl- il

.{ ;;U I L HZ- 1i Vj eJu* IjI l z VL- .t- U, (L-Ll -9; LI

>j.;UIH5Zll LYJID .41 L'~ li r,i LYIAl Z:if.:lvlrl- I

.i-.l YIO J-j DL> i-) Zi 6a (] ;eLll; Jlm ^ -A

> d1 L:;Yl> l Z'Y !1S .-*-^ YJi*ifb I !L ( ;- i t- NI IJl,3i0 Z=vaaj .Y1

I.-Z L;_LX .cI 1 i .A v| L-4Y;J I iUIDlVio auD 4J.V4

jlql,-:l,l' C litlj_41 LL.CL Ji ;,oL" 1~wj l,= 1 JI1i1;5 iL, -L Dils

L- L.:.Y .t2I oIjY Isi -;L Li I o u i t L ku1 4,Il °l .I1 . 1I;

I;xz-U IO u,Il,l I Zi iLL z~" . 4Lx;I *L I L yS I JJto I .1Y4 JE .S 85

.j Lel d I _-Si? ;-tl JJ; ~ ~ I I U-9 aiil l, olLY

LIsk a ~Iwl iM ;;l U LSi £ i s 1s ° 4L+ ZUI Q9S

. ,i ,r .Bennett andj Goldberg , r Oj,W;]- lvLJ{I

&L9 I ziu I;_U I-" a L, I ; J ~ LjI WL U I 1 L4aI I

Z - IvI I I Y IJ I I kUI ; LI|j Uj) I L1J_ I ZLA j- I A

;J,i ul UW . 1 ; ... 4I. ,1- .LV ,J *U L, J

WP i l ) i jI LfP ' Yi L Jl .. iLi wl.k .. 1lfI

.ll JJAI L11 , & . L I L11 ;I 4,Lj a Z Û. L.. LJJ J " &JZ. a - oa I I ;.,L_-

L.J J L_ I 4 ILA l | d ^ U I I ZLJ I JY A JIIU I I s ̂ *

•Lq. I d5,Lz JL a .L .I YUIA ZI.iV VsJId tt LU1 _ ?- -1 L i.IVJI

Z.i Li 3Y-L=. J ! ,IIj * * ; OScmid I and -L S.I 6L_ VIJ, I . * _-

Li I , .I M i ll, .U I a, UL+- II V1 ..Il Ld J "V, jl (VUI Ze^ I tInd- *j * 1 djl QJIO t Ij4; J&jJ LLI I :L, ,;I ;j

-g 'I vLv 1- s- - I Y I 0 1 S |; ,L * Lgj-' I c L M iS LLJ IJ d,. ao. 11|L4 .

IJ5 r1 91 i.j Z-- u I o-. uJLiLI v- - .a pl I IUU iA 4 1 L. i I - 4. L. *.k L IJ I J,LI 1 V4J

.L .4I ; = Si U.k 1. Iti L:W.I :L..= II : LU La III 1 4

*O1 1 t;j L: IS 1Zs1 9i^ ^ W;L Z * Lyl ;,-.WI JLi

. . .4 M J I ,L )z

>dgMJS U(LI Y 1 11 bIL1,I L_2' L1,

;D L1-.L U.1.. iL J.Z ;tWj dJU :j-, iJU Iw L, L S-I J_l> Z,.+ ;1i

C'L ̂ .i Z v Il &c i :d' .-Ll ZLijlaql Z> . J9li v^ ZiqlU cL- ,J "01 rS 9 lIt

;¢W .:~ L94UI ci] I j1 SA ua*l Z s 'L-3 (1 it u1 - Le *

J_ V4 -. 9~ j I i U I O ...........,.|1 .Lii vl 9 ........... Z,y4J. IL fl (s UA =I ...............;;IJI V';L,1LY LJ 1 IYg1V

i 11il.IAVL, U i;5U I-ZJ ;UI L.................... .<P.,11 a-1 oULVI o,/

Lji -.L,t L;.31 &UL-1 J9.LI -; A v,L Schmidt and J . J1i ,lUIL Z-111 cL _.1..............;

ZL;9L,1 CL ' I .9Jl LUIOI;Z lia V S 5 Y O, -V1 (NIVV) Zeitinger

U Z;J1,s J Lj *d4ld ;Li U.1 11 L I , I jA 31 :,. - 1 JI -;V LLgS A a 14i

JL V;jAl1V1 - 4.L1 4iJ '"'';iv =J

z1-t OLL;lE4 Z,.JI LSU JLA ;iA ,iL S ii ,j JL+!.IEIDM S AClJ- J Vl A L *JlllS 1 JU i lO1- J,

L4 1 Z--z L:-u: I L, -411 u rgvgi aL;u .jj, -

,&9 JLj 1~ ZW1J _9A tj1;1DJAI E1SSl LIA-i ;1j ;-- A /G u"411J l-i

,11 iLJUI cL hL.-ni I1 ;,j* -J,y,i,,W1 L;l aLJ-Z!Ll LJ 9 A UI 11

ZaL. IEtU -.A11,j;:1ult I2 -;=JUI c,L.-ill LI.,

,q q it q.WILi it;U o ;1 ,O

oI_,-I ilil 51 ji t~l listA Ji ;J I.J1X I;> ,l. .[a I Z,- - ILL-=L >.'-,

IL, JLSiJ I v:iY Jk- Io tI¢ S 41J i

ju ILL4el :vo1 JLt Dji-i .* Ja -; ,si C. | ,| o;JIu I Yl~ Di- j9 I

Jy. C f3jl lj: l ELA 6. 1i4- aL.:I 1,l -! L.1s;o,11s,

j;I ZL V5i bS¢, L <l 1 gs;I.IfiI iJ=iJ ,4L- vLAYL

;.L2 ; DJf Jl Li J1 jL i ISiL J.--A i Z!.;1 t.az j L.3 1 v, 2 vX

IoAIL t<- Z- ;vL v- a,- (L; > i :oi I11- L,;', 1 p4:ol-i o 1-AoJJ'

v°D- ;aLS * ,-WI j-VI ll

v Fu1* l^-IJ tJSI9 L'i vLi;ICLa,c( y i,@J .-I 4Atk,

a;. vL . ' ;J-~ I v^°;~^^L:tV iX I L^M-

Sj.4L Y JIv^>1 .°.l ,i 6= j-~ ;-- I - 1_ yl; K 61_41.

,;-J. L ,:IIIH V LYISLJ LL'1*-";lv. X1-, I Lo IJ-

tc >- L4g -j-,LJ; 1 I V L: ;jl.3 40 1 oUA J3 L -L -S i va; ID

.;.2 ,L:Y U L-1 L,6 Lv; Ju'Y L i Dt cY 2

J-.,>Sl -Lil oa-ZA Zd6i -t0SC ai5 -' eUL,: I'U 6b--1 IL A UjL=

*t\,m5 Mo Pischke :,L-i LA; LL SMk iuS _Sl!l-Ile>L-¢) =

L.L rQ ZJL I u.4 Wt,1 LiiaI - JI §5-.)k ~J 'Vb 0 - L- ÛLL ,I'

j~~~d_' +-, -,11; 1) 411 iL _- vAi y :I e............... .(L-A

iaJUI i ..;Il1S tz H*iLi

; ... .. ;Ll d iL#JL 9t1 lj ;Ji .3.a Z *:~. :4w

* 14*3I ji,I I L.~IJ Iii;i idl I ui1 d L.JIj ZLO * LIj JUI LOWi JZ1 * *VI

JL ,+ SJ~ ' . Yaron) ULlJI1 L 4L.Lr

L£) J i4 I 6.L4L - ai i5 i .

j eJ 1-i - zLII .:)L1 4I _) .IJ- .L i . -1 j.

* *~5~Ul j (Sil C6i J1

5L - *5 I e ; #iLSIj ^1 UI d- 1V U>,,

- - GL>, ,.I jULs .~L.L 9L~ t1. 1 vi~i

,-.W i WrI~J s O bj I * ^ Uj ''~~1 3 ~ *:' 1S O v -

~9I 3 -L? .LI &J•.A .,;.U d~.J * :lLv~ 29t LS,fllJ 2

L ~~~~ ~ ~ s; aI -p 14 iI %GUI II I . ......I ;L~ Jt L.S.Ld I L.-.L..

i I j *.- W cJ i ~ Y I I\

L pV 6w

,,o

( L1- UIJLLO) 4acI lj llL-Y t.u

-~~~e -j - - t9111 Ll- L-9 1 Au 1 radAL+ =L ,:II coL--L ;x

. -- *e.ll1 1uX g

Jlj> sQ igl _)l S 1 UUl I a-7 l:aeJ 1>1;g

Ls jlSLl ^ :IJ-41 Z L:l* :;-d*'LI J L1 i ,1

a F-,, aa--LF4 13 L. l I> Ai| -ZL*d -GIl

*V-~~~~~~~~~~~L,4 ,j L;ijlJly LI * r@ iL=L; A ;..Id fi-;l b J

Ij iteJi I J- i J IU laA LsI I ;_ YII9>,L!U I I.t

L i L iU I 41.1 I lut51 l I .! d .Y 1 ., .,,,-.0 l" L~ -~ :~lU a

NV

^ TL

([

4 M

C?CT

L. E t & it. -

[ < [ X'E0

* 1 .CIt

t. fi -F F 1

CT.. C-

4,000 I I AL IdL.1I- I~J iILLO~I

3.000 I--~IjJ J .~I~.I t i I Z.5 L,

3,00- -

2 000 . '. I j| ^ I&. 1, , l J .I J I 4.L

1.000 I - - a Z i ;J I2,000 -_j s d-t ;I 4 1- Cd -i

1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 L.L .I 5i c , LALI d J

.. ) , -, ,&L• OAA 'tM J_j Alk Z UI

kl-1,((5J£1) .0t zL;- J UJ LS- . 'l-. uiS

JL 1 _Ji I L<,ui! ^ t is ,jil-.:-.C ̂ i-i>, --LW

_1l I U i I ZJ. L.1 LI L L II c d L I - -J IiL ji L,_ L5,5 1A OL '-I ' .~ U.7& H1

A, I , s (H L -I &V Z,...... .: I 1L~ Ij Le................ ,1j,) I d, J, - .

E ' L~1 L,Y~'2I ,1 J,5k JI ,: i~ d.j,;II Ia .v ,35 -l - -, L , JII2 I

j9 l (F ) -- L eiJ L I ZLz " i , .J1 I i o . JLl l.,u..S L .L-I (<),[ I, L)2 L-:fL- Iu

*(;U j'3

L-" ZU: ,L,i-,l As I. .- 1_1A, L>4" W')M ;r^..gt t aÂ

. sr ;YILS,It S 't T Lg l i tl] , .1] tL&..i .j,

* D L ¢. a,I G d i Z a- t I ;|L; ;_,J I --dI 1-> 1 i

i5AT 7.>c I L5 I-. SIs I "3U -t1 L,-~Jx

le , A i *Z S L .i LS 5 r);. t i ,v szi*clalL Ic IiI jc

1 I UOqLSr I ccI 1 - L I e 11 ,L; >l I>2 l J.MC,,- I I#

j ,,t-iSL I -% I J i .-lJl .eI dL.-41 ,-i .. L ,LJ.-F;'II L,: J. SLi

Zi L 1 ,= I , L,VS I iL,S1 .1 3 I : * ,IGaL.Jte 1 ,d. ,+, L. ' I |~ 1 * .L- L. .Lr I i L - I } 2DZ

ot 2 I-, L' I tL; L4 Li L; It Li L-.--, -21 I1 iA LL_iIf9 i 1 2> I ,

s.00 u- - "aWI (.) . IJ- YJJI -. I SaI

JI- o --. =IL.:;,I ' - L Ji I L

10.001 I - i( ) 1J -I ...... - :l 1 & o >

840.0D- j- 1

2,000 - ---

1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 199,' AA k, La I .,Ld .... V

dtW EUa I . C: -L,1J Y- -I ;.LjI J I JF

<! { i II ~L~ *Li ,H, dLJ La -J3L=V~1#l l4-;I - ,3Il

Jjjff3L lJU LZ4LSi,.aL.., i V ~'~..

1:;Y I -1 J* ; ' Z I ,JJ IJ f I L I 1 Lo.. l -,1 .e->ii i. LJI

lL, F5 I C II -:Ul; *SI( S : I 1 9Sl.":I i 1 I ,JL;

;L 12 I I \ .)I A 'i dUI LdI 1-,T I L4.j d-l

7- ij *- iL; L&uL -;

*jjI .- 2 II 5 i L, 1_.J& A L#- i 3u;L,4I .LLI c .z r-ivlCL- J2 L l L.- .;Li 6I Z U I;u L,i r

,L<- ¢I i,UI Lst V ,r-Ii .I -.A -U I L LS ,-z Y 33 ;,iil 1 Q -

L-/ J bL,- d.! ' '' ' C 2 * *\A r i

Z:~~ L-z1-9 ~-- . La[-,. I; L -:;- YJ _,:; I a C; L;! ;i a *;w

46-ju; LIJ C Vy L5bl 11.. .............. A,, - L- FI taiLi5 ,s ViDt 4L,XIvj

D a L-.?Yc1 65 * ALi

i-*- -t SJ * 55 LIS J- £ (;ill 1 A LPAiJtI i iLII Z :11 L-l.1 =) e

-- y, . ... .1 Levit JCe I &L e .............. Z*di,AiUI

,59 di~j , s:L;21 vt3:-s 1>v g 1 1~i t~Y J5>y *US

5 C±JI *(,; *aIJ 1 I 1 LI; 1 L.j)

,~~~~~~~~~~~~~~J La l',-'L * L,- Ij-',1<1L....................

3 / - : I 1. L - Lc lU -J

2LJ I ;L5 1SS f ; i u Ie e 1 al

.(, \ ,Yaron) LjL el

C - E'S-,w Y: -. 11j

-' , S L t kAlJ 4i4 I ; L1 F ' -- 9 Ji .'C .i I J

198 1988 198 1 -9999jI2 ; t L L I z LII v oL U

1°92 1993 19 ).lT-- L vW -lt J LI pf1994

ct--; I I 4 ri '. E sl5

'.I•~.j ,zuw i * - - _

~ lL U jl;I F .X5 61 :L vI oL~I 2 - L2,U11 I

* .Z,l *(,,4±I- ,LL^jIIJ

F1 s i l;S- I .:. J ;~- F ,1 I,j ae.L fir) 7LUI vE,-ir V-%1 JLJJ=

'I i-1 , LX i,,. L LI Vk'M ZliL JI~ Z_ ; ~ IL1 - . .. . . . .. 1 JI.-. .1 - . . ...... YI

.~~~~~~ ilk)\ 1 U II :Di rLI l i ilJ v )UI ^ 1 J ai .s--N -ZW - Y s,, idl V>

Sl1 1 .... .. I L=J ,,,(L( 95a £ -iZ . e. - ;,.j ljle J IO L51 L ;liYI

~ ;5L"eUl l / -Lu,l JJ c- V;UI =r SetV )-n;

1 O L g D jla L 13 I -L nJg 5.lL~~~~~ ~ II .oIIr.;*l, 9J

1 - jl 4 o1 5 1 J s o Hl j ~ -~ rLoL xL I 1 5 0 I I~- -i

*vO ali t~~~~1 v50 1,J5GG

I LL1 uL L.; ..... & .F 9 LwL°\s|e 1

JV SV I,100j ; G .4LLI.f;IV 1199. 1ZL

I I -_ ~ . I -, 1 992 1993 ''" '- "

Si1 iL L; I 4 1 , ftel l L LLO ai LL i3L1 Zi U,) - rL; 1s1 laf LAI- = L,'1 ;d.UI 1 & ! a~ ~ - LALJ1 oll21s1 o>

*i; I G G I oU L&i U2 LI ,r- I L j a I L L *rtSI >-;...I1 I• I Lx I 4lL I

L,l±)iII LJL _" -, L1 &L a L;. r14. I 4 ;;1 IJ Il -JJI•k I

JJol 6i JL IIWI *aJ II vl

;Ldl LiUL J.l LJLIII.-Li lLLh J4-1 (1) :49

& Z Ul L@1. U 1;, .o - -jt * -

UZAV Ia &rjh L le4~Jl3 ; :I Lli L*-j- -o l t

-~u J~al L,iuu .L J-; '(La IJA 4,J41 ' I, . -- 'LL ' I I -ZI

-M iVI ,•.U I .:YI i iJI Ji oL.iLIl t I1L.I1Xjl L. 11 .(V-53-,j -- 5,£1j >Lil) Z I J OL.A;II1~4.3,.j-l ",: I JV lIJ.

L4j=,1 )LI 6 1* L;fIJv& LU 4-iH S; *- I L 1 K sDJr. a 11 1 WLJlI DHu

V4VWI L-X 511A JLL~ 3 6qt I C, jL eg I 1JEi v Li a.J I J51 jj I5 li

fLf LLLl;l LLI I 5L 14 Q;.iiJII - by,, JJLL I L 4 JI

o =L3 f; ,wl j (-l v 1 J aA fLZ LJJ1I o iIJl I LLJjl .lVja -Jl I;JA IJI -I aJ:~ 'V4SI¢ J 41 -L L-- 1 . - L L., Il jl -~ .L.VJ <L .A2

3,1.31 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ tl UllLiZL l .lL) Lj.JII lj .l-I *,L:_ L*-I:I So_ l _JI L J I'~ V5 S

avIJYI v J>X -I ta mell iLil6 ;,LLJIl 4-1 Z4 tj 4- LI

cL -a .3Lx1 *1J-41 :Lri- ;LL LiJ JI Ls:i2 J9 ---: L-+;

I J i a lli;i L I 4 L;5 11 1 t 1 L*, J O zA L. -U L< 0c l; j Oi s t; J41_, I !J

JLte]t- ;IotIelu-f<ls

jSa I(.)° -YI*-Ll 1 a I . I< (°')' \I i C.............0IJ li,sia

( I 4i ) - eUJiI tl :V-', JJtl c,hj - 4g 1 ± 'tl & d e1 :n-s . I

/A

-dt - t ,12

/T. . .-

! . ... - , . /. £

I.L Ul JI L-t I

. I 3 IJ LtJI 4J1 \ L= li /SAL

~;/r c

'SM?,L1 tA~ ?Lz :1-A -vei -i at- U:1ZU

5LJ d;id ,VW tlW Cc -s1t14 -s 4Jyiio 1 -1 1-1ZUJ11.I L 1 YI-J , U I I 17.

L IJ - . \WY i,,'42 ...................tIEkd--)> ;$.......,JI.. - 11L 2Z1VI jW Ig92

2:I - - -

L-t- lU d I j L. ; J- ,, l U I Lvi A L; Z-_ 1 , dJ Y - >, ] , ,59

, ~~~LJl sL~ _ vs'l .li S*:I Vl -L-*

; 11 ji~~l.;,-1- Js,AI ilf Z- -, IJ.,.t.[~~~~99 I 99£ 1ai,4.;/ '\

X .(8% .Khandker, Khalily, and Khan) ji 11 J5C ii 1,4I 4;S__ C>I_41I ;I

tJJ s iLLI 4 L<V I9 F I1I :1) i*g

LeUl.yl C'-'l - uz t4 S I i. -Z i .=I :I.

iiv2-@ _0t*l t@ A Y I ; 1 > Z g o

.tilL @ y1 a l - L¢;1 a l , -.tA 4il so0sv eS;1 L~j L-,A1 L, ;-U" As ci Jj; l a.- Z. ;

* 4 L (i) l- e51 Idj i I I ;2 9 : sA )- I 2. j1.

if[CaI 4,i=1.1Y ,ai .S- Jn Lv I "v5 i) ;zUI iLliJ

o( / , - 1 1J11 J p•I o LRhandawa1and Agabin

* ** ).. e .Z, WI)jUI J1) U .I , o 19 .kJi 1

~ZLLI,,i -._.., I1, --J .

5 , t ^Do A 1 > - -ltLL! 61iA17~

'_,5UIL I:Yd ^- 1:jL -l ill1 k 't 6 1 -" .. -..;,lj Lle ,> ?it, Y

L1.J- I iiarL .U 1 S1- 1 IlI5I.l5 1 1 Lr VI -J: Iv2 *j Js1 c;I< LJ1,-a &.:Uu LI ,

~j-5~ J.$ U L-* ¢ 11jl.- rLJ Y XI 4.ij L' ^

tv >7. E1Fi ,!#~ 1 stl> I .(85k1 *Rhandawa and Agabin

.1Llsl .i -J U-Zt1 Vj JL- ;S 4 lJB * 9 I

tl LKL J,c , s085£S ll,l

QL ,dL aa I J-l ,I ^ L d k* . YVVV 2 I * NÂAo-

CJ -_ :-J I a aA ........ ._jXl . l YVYVA at IN , J o,9o. d 0

-a a4; Lw st - ci-IB'.J -' ) 4_-o '<- '4 I t 1'Y ''6 I i

e ~~~~', L~ eL.JI L> -,L & 1 ;, * 5 ^YI** l a.1. 1 o ial

G-1 : @ 4LLi L _...-.

j -. F'f - S 66-5~ L L 4il I -L L- A cALi 6-- Z_I ,Ji I * L;I IIJ9 &s

*J,,I.l Iv la L-~ :1 =, 6I ?Y IJ Lu1 I- 1f -'f ,l-- I *Z~ -.W - - -1

I *t: --- ; lJj 1a _CJW I J -iaLZg L ;1 I LA_J .Lk 1 J IS Q UJij.41 I LI

~~~~~~_L4I *"_ --;11 5J I zfi L +i >fi c y,l Jf3 a I *- tI L>, i s L-I t 1J1 blwY

Z,j I j <) I J-J I tl ;L L,6OD WllJ J4_,i cL;jWil 45 lJ ZJU1 d, Ai LB ;tlIP

f TU I L' 01- . (LS-I I Li>) Q1 s-I *~ *- t~ql y ILs t-A E1^- O-i I ^;v

., s.L ai 1 Aj J>L I.J i-ld; I,X Aoi iJIU I *J i: Lr JAIll Iv -l>F

,=zI JSw(s &. L O1'' JL z 1 1 A L, L.+l ZM -- a

¢1~~~ ~ ii ll;cl>t; oiId J] L a1 jl ;.u t' ]tJ *A s L;a .11 ,i l -. t jJ;zSill

-o-I aiij * #X L- -)Li *I.L.- m M Y ,JUIL - Yl-J Ne ~ .YJj, L9I

jieL Ue1J;V-0 4;5{JWi LAA, V ; ;l.& (LSV :; IM ; YJ

,-,A L,=J;o tl q2,l ,I ji, Il ,LiI - I V°- & ;1 I fJ Zzl . .tlSa.,

5-1 1 1* IJ ;. e,-2 Ij ; 1 z,V L _.21 S YJ -Z_ - 4a1 ELi JII L'i Li I J1v I

(o-,/ L- 5)

.,A) U- WV oo_, j' LSX;JPuL>

VIA -.,V YCYY To>A ctZoljUS

._)*A .r JX @-I4IJ

vvkSt.acay

,JIjJWl giJlt"AI .'%

;.iII 1 ,, i ; L.a) /' Aj 'A,I ;-yI J_ J4,1

L .,p L L .Y

1:1 (L n,Y AJLi Si A V°ll a- J13 1

Y i i v/r i L 0 l O ,;.Jo ZJ) /'-.. _,I -JI ,L1 7 lj-

V l4.Jl LJl 1-II ,;*YII

; (I ,SJI I -

Liovi LAk -o 1i,(4--

Wi (L 4 J. i~. L) 0; y (L.LLL st ZtL) es Y *1~J il jJt I t1L si V < Y °l J,-il La1I

I' iLilol il

I-JI t; ri L+e SL' I L1z

lii;4; iIL; :AA

A\.At,. A\~,A VVJ\-

N ,Sa *ay ,I RhnLaw, and Agabn I

Vl ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Scy Rhndwa and Agabin|d-, j E4i Jill l:

I__L 'j'd- AV 14,~l e.L,

zi:- -Ui.0r, I1 ;.1iL bu I ! - I

La JrZ lU 1 Ij L;U L:zIJ 41_IJI dJ ;: 5 250

b>LaJi ;1 , 5 .k v 1I L~~~1

,,1 &,-' e 200

Sacay,) \4A' ovL , 150

J,,L-. LI; F . ( .Rhandawa, and Agabin3, A. ZIIe L ul I ; . .;L I S I ,0

I.6 -. b; 91J I- Li, 50 A

I~S t 1 ,j1 I LJ! 1 'iILi , - l C ;oi, ,k°-. ZwLU

LI.'I LSS 4L:D 198 819

1992 1993 1

I J.31 I L J , I S , yl L•I * L

I~'

.b-l I L'111= I$ Jzl &.3 ^LzaI .,J 4I *+~ 4 ; L L L,:S7,~ I -;,II sLI -11 JI zIJp ; 1

I sS L-5Y 1 xI z1-"u LIJ ct tL - YJ 1 "v.3YdW I c, .3 ̂ ..,J I U L,.; L-JO1dI

XSl~ it LS .e1 I :J I zi vsS .k ,j ZY L-eLJ ,#O4IJ 1J1 I IÂ xi IH (L II

;1LJ cL4 U6ZI I -J L)WL: 141 LulS L;*l

I -l j.4L.- - 1 I:, L,Le i$iI

,0145 1 @L,!ZIlj Y : 11d= DlAj I aU, V 9J G VJ

-i;- J5 LA G j - *. LLO,14 ; 'LU 41 L.1 I

LL -"= (8fiLA S a ;V-I 4:;_L ZE UJe .I Li Z-- J) ',2 U- ;I Li v~ It > L

J-11 o 5 i 4tL V t!LG 5j U jl I LIL L5;iI , 1 C -F J <C

X P xill L ' i V I jlYI ,,l 'i-, Y.) i\# I,L; jL IO2 ;

(I- I -t J- LAT LA 1 u11 ML

Z- 4-~ Iaa Sl-,t 'i .I,-

-~ L59 t;1 Z -J joY I A 1 t

-:L,-+-J I. L-i 'k i-Nl i JI - t~ L &i. o i sL L3 U I J9 IT, 111J~> A;-T1-

*tCcl i LJ 1 L LYI v)1 1 .LUI

,, i:,1 *,L, .7j I 4 9| w4

&va,L-;, b 1; &aA . .4l .l1 20 - .-

.y1 ,WIcl>lJ& iYI1 '>19 1990 99

;t119 1994,

-UA Li 411 ;UUI ZL-_. ..I1

L 1 .,ji - Is Lli LA.3 L.IU 131

CI *167,Va3 A Ji L< i .1.1 &I<VLYl S iv a f

.. 4 ,L,. ,59 ,;eL a1 M l ;!' L., 1 1 6i-&I :l .................... = l JU I _1.- ,JsUI c -s Z,9 . I

c,:1LC IGj ;91 -I_JIJ -;LlL_. Iz aL;JIj L1 ;.a. i' bl * ;IJ 4 ii JY .4 sil

Z Z *2 J LJ OL JIIJsi; A - LiJi vI 5 5J L4 d11v7iiO

vs j,7 1J1 1x LI 4z-jil I Leb x.J >>Ij Lr I I -' r1UZ,) ;IL L- Z=LE4 VI c

--W- ^1=V-

e L, LiJU i-I . cZ J l R1-~ J1. L-.e OI v51L H 19JV 5 ze - '- H

,Ju -~- Ivl (t -i&) -'- 1.:L J" s-].oi* 1*1> j Y i

ZJU ( .L1J ;.L! Ul01 i j >Jj> i

Z. L- C5-?1CS .............. L_ L - .L U ....... 4 J*::S,~~SE I~.II

fx,,> I -1 :t1 h1 1-- jI I J IA.L Z-Dl LIL cL..: L..;-' J4-_q 5 F ;I sJ; K1 ,

&.;I !YILL , 11 j ,'y La U.L,JI ;.iS'I JA_*J 6sl01>&M~-A1LCIt1

Ln 4 Y l V v L. J JILZ S 4I . M1I 5LdIJjs 1 e e-h

fL iJ I Li * *- *t l I JA- U : 't I Ji . I 4 I 1; 3LL Lu I l Ji ,L; C L

. . LJI 1 I JILL1 ZL ULJ L.K 4 ,W.A I >11I1 LL LUJ JL.i - i ;lL - US

Jl~ *-21 J11 j Y1 LLII Jl. 1 "i 1~*-z.L ijJUI l * zI . , stLUvi J.l L I vJ.,laA f ¢ ,YI 1I .3 a;x-' ^ f >*I "i -,, -. t1 ;J j g V aAg1j (

iIj L>L ) 2L,dI Li.1- 'I t,k l Li s _ lS *, ILIl I t J , i J

Lil tLD ,L 11 I J; J L J JI ."I ;.I VWI -.. BUI ' I L Ii i J i

gi;ULI_6a _ ~ Lt,61J. A ~U 1-tll uL iUllj6L -I ~Li LJI I 1c U L- I Li Vt -,4;L

L : ,, L4 -:1W5I .:L l '1:1., V i YA IJ; LSj iI M -wLl d*.J\t* *

J-;IJ Lrq.11 f. [ 1 VL Yl YI L L'S Jl,)-l IES (W --A .... ;iAiljl J"1 ;l,j 6J;1 ilJl ZI Yl5 .;: I

Jl z9 a. >I; 1 1 4 . v.........C I A .:-);j, I *- L I, I-'L2I \- -AL:a l 'ril l V a - * s5

J.-W UI A- k I J .UI LiJJI o .%M .I t L ,iI iI

U 2-J I jg. .W- I VJ t ~ la - L___U. _I UI ' J. ZU II L',i o

,a6uI ll 2 1 I '.r JI. ;klMeI J I i- Ie ,1 L-_,. t .YI

LQ1LiI'.A% cdjt Ii .- L;Lill j" I *I 1= -l :l J.1.l :0 &-L .Z1

;_J&°- Lil cOji) L; q;5i Zxg IJsY

i ,l*.311J I L.-- I; : L5~Z 11 ULI +a 1 1 ;.L Ls J EcIJ1 aLl 1 aoLI

,LI 31 ,- L. l JlA IL z I;,L; *V J L L;, ,J ij UL~j ~ I LL Y I * -J.s 'is U I -A o

J... 1~ L N l-fl JL,i L.I LsJ I LL.--.1 ............... ij.*,f 11 I alil I J1 V1- . '3 L1. vi UlvSL4Y

,H1, - :."Y1jj, L; :- av o. J.,A=3y 1o,,iLSV L -1w

jl .L l :L aL! ! .1L~ I......... U.1 1 ;LY : S 1V 4YL-S L5E

JL 5 1 W 5 IV4 %lU C'- . 1SOM -UL 't. sLi $'Y

Is Wl-J "JA>JLiff¢1)4 j-SY °);,;i ...1

iiir iiir 15T A. iiA ¶

RJN . ,. ATJ( ,,,s;,,l -*[XltoiL-9-

YI-~ 1>..1I,7, .ZUILi k,A XL 4I Li IjY

,1 ZUI,IJ i.4 JI V1 aL .i;UJ3I h r nJ J;LU 00

~5 5~ .-.1; .dL 3 I eS~ iril al 1 .pI .izI 4z,W 5... UL .I LL 1

Ja Lbts -J, 492 LL I Z-i >d&& lT I ¢ d IJ

J d i. l *41d LL - I o d * JL JJ v . 4j>i i 4 . V. r -4L J 1 4;U I ULi

11- I . i L= II 1 ;2;U OLi1I , L,Si 4 L- LJ JI a & VZU oo LiL1 Jil

L.- ,L .-J ' L- i EA,,.m jI " YI .1~ +-% ILi,ze L- Ll CA-Ll,L.-. , i;UI L~~V

_,.L I'l.- 50 \51 1AO £M LSZ I.a~ Ze4J; :=l R L'H IV RUI Li *J-II ;,9-i ;U I L£. ' JV V I J1J L. ,LJI _;A .~- I "j LJI rL :,. V <-JI :U VLj . _M9 L..S * LI,

Lss ti ilJU I i,3 ,............. ZLL _- Ql al - L lu.1 Zi.111 ZUII , iJt iMr Z tL l j.LLI# Lq a4l l 4 LJll lj-OZ-:Y2 v, ~ LIIL 1U z2M JL - - -L UI iA -4

J--!g *Sa; NJ -k4 oj4.v % J' iA ; L Lra-g Jg-:L;J {LUI i,LS 1 4 GI V L - jv

.(1-9 AxL) I (.I. )zI 9 .1,4 qUI jljJZ t I -J . M

JsJ[ 4. Zl .,U, r

0j\. o A,t. \A-s£<1:" t

VjAA \. A,o i . : L

YYrY£V MSY (N>^f X%J,9I- I5

I,% \A AJYV -ANJ S£-5..; Iil 1 LSAEL*IIi=1

NTAJ\ Z.t .rL\5 S2 L K t1

AT A- 5555 .1 iL2 ; K1

kov 'r%A rr Li*i* ew Ll @ L<-l ZiCz

TA A£ A£ o I55 cte L.V . I J.L

T' s VA \Yk. L I ;-' Il J

"L J -- Us I M

LA, W LLi 7, L-. I -

I1:LA.o J,I bh ;LL=" I C '* . I I L$tJI M Q Li.1.aI L1 J L4J J 3LiLA .1J Lhj LYl

44ZW J-.LI 3>i -• 3J21 IL Iy - U M 1 A A.L-L -I.M 4=:!1

IJj -.lL L.i aq:L L - UL L" b 9o S

Y1 wl S;, ;.11 JL-~ Z5iL ; A ^ ." L,61 .3sUL!aJI Z1131 jok Z,. 1

-Lil JIa 9-wd L ' Iu oL i l *:^- i 1 ^YI BIj JoL- 4.1

c , IJC c tujI d1j VAII (t 1 ) t1 - d1 JJ g , 1 jI

-4 zii 4wJ;t&Id j,Jg1.1iS * -1Z

x _xd ,,i 4.4W zI I , r JU ,JI ;a e Lul L;.1

,L AIj <LiY JLÎ@1S U 1W1#;-'1;1 vI t 1S

;,aJZS4L. /A VR5> /AT

,;yJUI zLjI

4WO ll ,t.,;11l ~-LYl kLL ............ j 1 L 4 L,L -Ia9 I1¢ lI

IL ZiJUli I Z41JI

A_,A

,, '1 r,2(Jll; I jo

vjg -a=a L'. *Gg

£Yi AJOA I,J ;UJ K ;U &Kg Il *L-v

To JI L ITI ,>

A . ( TI) T ,¢ . J-

(6 ±I JJJ I,J.(e - Y,\ Z L"L rJ%

(;),e Yr (aL) ZZWtI ,jJ

(L4a..L ) oVA ;.LrLANV jiA) YI Z.L k E £ Ir (4_.i YY£ ) \ ) TAT - AY ".5W;I zw1

' ;,Lxi

CYA±A , rTAo)."Lr\A..

(%lk c-T\V%T) ITT) --a5. Jud (EIil ".

( vr) K - .. (AnAL Zx,rc (8o-Y v /YT :85O-\Lt I.... Vol ;lJM(;l

JII .ail VETOboI t

Uj %oA) ~~ T \A.,Y,Y

TV:. .. V3 n1 ?J

Y.Y.. jJI lLî) ;lY Y£Yc)

TV. YN aA Y ..o~'.

-t)Li oAYA. aF Ij_ Itr (J^ o);Y c.A TT)A IJj \vv \., rAATAT.

(L tlvv '%j. jyYTAXY N1^^ a NVr) "LYr,otii.1 -

(e)Y £Vc YV. A IIJI ii; ,

co AAA £Y:o AAA lirX: VWA voic;S ;lav

.,; jo . c EA ay TJ I 1 -1

Ilia IL AI - --h

.)£ VVU5 rJ£ VJ1 VJE IYV £ ,>,,LX-Z

aX ,) (oLA- j.J "Al)

W ,, ,I WY >1 i

1EJ. 1YJ. 1.J U£ I.J YAJ L:;L,DI-JI co

AJ, VJr £JN £JSy Y1J 1V (-) - 0) >-4#I'

:, -L-5 1 et-jod

IVJ OJ. lY Vi- LO- IJ " J aUe; -,:I

YYJ - o9A - ,YJ£ I 1 IRIJ.J Ii"

_,XI -J J ,, J-,S.- XA1 LI

VT,y Er yjy '(,I WZ -YW ".9WI1

- .- , iJk , -i LJ.3 ±

(~. JIL .'k ): .;,LI .

*J -E *- - ,I,IiA (IlJ.;;1I

;tJLI LI-i Q -j,

-,r .rJ- .J. £5i~ "AIZ :W,-v L J

Z-.dJVI . 1 oti,

..... -,.7 Y L7JI S6 -L /A 'JO QU 11JY !(41zA;1 t

PJI 4 1 I [] EJ5iv

sA~ - . i 4 1.I

~ALJA

LI&. IJI ,Ijl Z1 - ,&.s y

JIi;ll ;JI

( T .... iJ Yuc~L ' .LL 'J I -Yl,j ;,5: L

&L9 X IJ4LAJI4,SolJL-5L.~ oo Ji) :L,Zg !QAL ,

(A9l JI ,kJ

J iej: JA

L /;o --4I- Qo. J

r L Zu....... J_, ,vL ,&!rLK ,, ,X 1 E l* vi ,1,-- ,Lo J

E 11f1-,1,-IYI A, NL=L

(-- . ) Y 8ojo ,JIl A,r ryJv N(4YI) ;81 ,:J s;ZU1;W JL1

Yr1 ;)4U IL 1

I--j-b~. . . -. ~ -. iJUl

NE IJ ;: NVF ;t vL;L. 1 ,:4 L,! I o-Y I ;LLi I; *;lr(i

' .: 1. - L1 l -, ;LI a LIIt ;ill

(+ ) .LI

(SC JLi i Iu Il y'I 11_ TJl L" I

- -. -Yl ~l ~ I j.l

,L~~~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Ll.5 "i LS ;il Zo1; 1). Z1 L-1 I i;j l-L

:(-. III ;- 14: SJ LL)Y(rJ- J.1I

Viy £;p -;Li L.t<JJ o

£t I W., . ( E .;)(j ; 1;JIII

ZL LS1-I 4;u;L;I>1 l lw*rli .I-i ;I.; 31 <;>LI l.";vil .JLJI : LI - . :Ii r 1J, r t l :c

:(=I- tiS; t J E 6 L)

.. AI Yi * * = S5>. JYp ..4 W\51 >. <X :-I4i .I- £lZL *Y I cl;

* W.'. NMacay, YRhandao ad- bi :AL =ULII i;: l Q ; JI£ JJ UJUI .1;J1J'St £* J I u> -vS I J' MA 6 , d ;.. :;te-l UA:

'irv uma-iC :J LtJ.A

a iII 'I L.I (Js)

;c aL V, i LaL !caL a,L AMVI coIY1

La4.AYVoY t6aL\4A2 ot

-1k Jw ojl I,1v5tUl Aj.W I 1, ao* ui ' k J 11 z A uk,LII j, - (u)

aIa s ,ILI j 4 (.

*ck j.3- ^,7 (Jij L. cbi) t.ZIl cLV 4a cLt 4 # L i 's;l3 (tI) cdaj -L 36I ZaJ1I cI. L - (A

-WY ;; IjA L3 ~l ail c IA iuJ I C-L SJL. j di ;C-dl a M t)

I4fL3

ai- (SL CatAII -jL , L jLIl ua ; ,LIjI cI l 5 LaIIIl a.i--- 0i L L--, 1 9il :Lt3;l1t Jji N ,1 ,- M I .b IiS (- )

*4 'I II 31.1.e111C Jlti L.*Il.ailL Ai,1 (St)

.-.jIM- A LI a; tjD 31 Wa xJill ;^ I C. (_i).ea~~~~~~~?11.ljI at 7Aii ;al:s eS w .1*LZoSJ I.; 31 uaVi C'-9e L9S.$,L 82 t\ JJeJ.ee - (.L)

-dlii ~,EIi .1jY11 ,Jll U 1e L -l a J.Y L ,i o llj I riJ4 1ti (I )- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~.J.1 .', S .. 1111 .a 3 ;v1 .~ LI,i-opIyj.1 ~4 .. l JLulj i L^ CL lil .AbS. ar U JILi H (o)

-Llg. U LLY 1Wv *.LJ ZUI y eLIZ ZO5l ->JL:x L,0slMo*I L' ;NU (

-Jil I:lil js.. j 5t1! l S flJl ,UL.I > i ci.ILL.l . -- I 'Benjarnin (ii)

Misk--lI L-.L-SI-I J'- ILAY.;oWlClI.; el! ZL, (--)

J1;L- 4Lr.1 (ZU ;ii e-j 1'1 ;; t .. J QLjjZC.-P ;jI i ;Avi IU

-(*UW II V, .a . 4 ;11 i (

WV5 ;:. d (;-1--1 ,,a.v1UL ;L LX) S1.i L,,L -,..41 e;II. -S A5o K.Kandlker, Khalily. and iChan (a .)

I

th I u* i WeLO ^ i A

&E ~L.ii ii ;4d llk iJ L LUI u, *i - W) SJ 1. .- Ij cLI Vl t 'Y jl .< UU

_It JIIL~~ UUI CLtLJL. L=ii (Is i t.a V JU,11 J ~~W

.3.]Id ; A W i <.I i J-J Ui L I UI j"wI 7, L,11 *jV -L: ; *11= d * * ll LUJI

_j vLII ;ll L I L ij L ZUI i s:Di LL ) J IIJ L Li kI -1 ,i ._i *vj•I iJ UI

,, " JI (;JiL-. JI JUJ.I U ji ll (I 4 la il Ii -.- i

LLXV Iz L; VU~) {LI ZU 4I IS ELJ LuLl A IE I OL.E dilI ,JI OLLAJ ~, I 451

UUL-4I d . L 4jI d, u LI dL GL I 5U P: ^ 51 L . L . J1 .I Ve4lj .4H~ 4J1 OJ VI VC U A L;LJI u J III IylI; JLAJ a Ji1Zo11 ,L-Yi ;91 *- 1 klO&G V-1 UU 1 'I JLI - 4 -a agi cl 11u L o(

H1lba ZcI _,1. *-;.t| JJ £j1:l (-£. 9 UL I Vi 31-

^,. JI f l < iLrlQ- . KJ I IS 4L<1 4-Z LJl , ze 1_9i UL: v5 LZ,L Zj4- (1 UI

Z:.jI ,UI , L illA IdI ! L4IU L IJ 1 ~~ 1 JU :L-,p~

i .!IA L-iil UL .JUI | ljll L d. -lilI |,c d I * , YI ys -l

iLLii- 2 5 ;,LY L .L CJI L] - ;Ljl d Ul L .uiL L ~i I \. 4-LtI

;-AJ d- Li.b "- d,t IA ds3 * A , L,:j Ip iU I ;- l # 11iaUI d * L = I,;! .- |d l- s

,,1 -;LI (JL. Lf j a-Jl isl1 I Ls;,. -* I S W pia

-LN A- ?;yz s ]1;1 CLSJ I J -- J Y. 1 °U .- iLI I s11

,A H:;V5 PC7JIIVOUd L¢e1 ESS1V6X;, A.;a;JI -c >1LII i

d [Yl | , J III - *i Dt l UjO1j,* *-I &,. LIL C l Lri Li4 iL a lZ: l UUI Z,1_ v l

I UKO ID5 Laa ;:L l ; 1 AA f 1 .;u ULI 1 jj l O + l jc dL -11 a ;^ d-o >i=

Li. la-, Ud * Jj d 3 -tA3 v L l 11 iU °l;a .L- -1| d L-ll ;ILuli iU

L9U L-)LY (.i.f!4 ; LiIZ,=wSUI%I J131 4J l 6al dj UI Li Y %LAji

;,o (JULLI v ,LA - 1 Z OLLl v :I L^ Y L.; :i. z, , I ,i 8 Y L ;;- I eiL.Li I- ;:21 iJ I

, s L JULI O1 ;YIVRUI L,- o .i I jS ; L =JL YI L, i- !L:u I# rL Y '.- L.= I

;LJ Ia J).F U , 1 :1 1iUI d-~ I *-, ULUI JJv it -kaL il D ei ibUI ,g N . SLL~

Lr4i -Li Il ,tjIi J.J .-.1. -jL I LL;) > I ;s Li

vLkii - J L. d11 ) L4 & L. UI - I :, iL.-: -ti Ia4 I uj,: -- I

~jJi .SdI L,, - 1 $4) i AL> * gu u v. -,,, , 5UUI d I

,L I FIJI , pLL*K ,1 | JJ| ~. jU5;VI ;t oi,I U L iil U..iV .L,J J11 Vijll

ti n 1 >; f. F | LLJ l ^ 4 i G * o l Je If.*ill , Z oLj iJUI &I Jl' Ua1 ;4IJ 14 i I J.tAI Ln' tAJJI .j Vi vj c1 Ek U ., J V L LLI 6 * -L 1 I fIj yL ai".- i U41 .YI^

Y . J L * i ^.k jL1UI t 7* Q A Y I ;* vi . )ZiUL ,UI j- JAijl YI a lW I L Li1I L

1,Ij, IL~ ~U L)tJi 1 .j i I

l,.YL.IV c,1I ,q JLlj fI tl . L<J .1 ¢ 1W Ua.l J jcL I Y I LY , I iXU I j; JI t 6 S |- I i U . i

5± WL L sf .Lid ^ 'I o LI ~L I LL eJ Su .;L . -ti I i H 1 iA js~ UW I d

LJ O. 1 ;i eI.L 211 45WI YY *i ~I. EJ.AIl V5 JLY .; 8JJiJ 1.9jL -sL;Y 4ILLV

,JLU .LI I ja V 1 A 1 L S4OJLmUVf V I iJUI m..LJle- U 1 Ja-I jA1 41 R ;,I L JL-II V 1 iL Y l *iL 9j1

; 1- L... -i <L (UI SiJ ol^ l I; .i- 1 J1 f cI =.F- 1 1c.X- L

uis v~4u sj.LI311 Z!Ju L-1Oez oLl:.jiI iM J Z= I 'atl;l ,,iI i4-i 1jLl hl s~l> U6 ZIL Lill s ioLjUI vil~j r6 LjeS1A,d L,- .LJI ;.,! I sa 1- IJi

efv 5 -i (JUI taaff iL- A ol,N i li 1d ol^-j b . ^s Ii2U 1

.e.aA nA_JLc A-1-=L.-JI Us.xf ;il .fi. ..j .i jl iUol-.. ZvlSU :ll=ii W>1 iJUI;~ L - 6 ;aS.11 _,L. L L;t i fCI * I _,.t f-maJU i- I.A;-f 11 >L; 4j vJl - . Il

L51i *t tl iJ z S I Li.L1# t I iiL U I Z:i~ I

ai&.j >i Il #L J aLZcI cl . > I Y La=ov sIi ; L

Z1.L; *-iLJUI L -,99 <-J.L L J -Sdi> d ...................I I .,Jd *-1

tciJl IIA f6m*)X § Ld)gal i I ?,. 1 ̂ ' o -

Z;X1L I J U - ,. L 'J 1... L. d;- I il UI 'V .LU.C................_...... j 21 4 J2|_ ~ -, -rl

_,,II i L41l= LP ILJ 1 L Z4 Lid I L I

(IL.1 ) Ull JII ; iIi tl ;c ~ L oI Ad liL v,k ; II 1 4.e u L v$~I

iLiL G~-~ <Wi LP*I >1 ftl 1:i1; UU I I I

d UId'' - C- y ¶

jL~j ,SI 9,.4 ?.i&iA jial -J1 w1,• -I M 4 ~±

;Xa,9 .ll vP -J; Li I4, - = L A | d > ik lUI ;i L; _

va Ji LLaJ

I -±I -" I L l = (I :Ld.I J S

AS1 US M LJI ^: vl jA;

6t-LUj.S;i1 ELJI-s5 -L^ :- dUUt jq, i~ *-W L;|d - *-j]11 A |

"4 J6-v U1. ~.L I ULUIj,r_ 9 jW t 5 , - dI L,-LM u

~1I~4IIIL! L4L Z~;UJILUJIJI ~5 k ~ ~kl~

li L (JI± LA4lZ.L iL U ..UhL is L,JI L4II = A

,I ,AL-. ajk ^ 1J . ( I JJ) a 1L iLJUI =

- I ,:J IJ ;IU I .YjJ I ai I %. CsI a I

ui:~~I U UISID! J=Tl.

iJUI I1U LiL......4l =1 &• Ei i.j . a L P

22lLI31*--J1 ve ta1v 1) GUI U-;lJ I J-- i Lf:l 1 u 1 ZY tl LJYI = c

1 li&- viYl *LLI idLI 1- L.4Jl L,• , 1 i.I; ;a1 1,,z = SDL

>LiJl .1iJf 1 9, L 1 YI JL. i ( S I Lt 4li l 4L f I Zk Id;K

1^.-1SMill l Lz94-l j.1%. YiLLir^,L ;e4

.)e.LjI li I;L6 ~ IJJI (UvlQs)l+-XL6 i f

i-% 1:;11A 3,l_ijl ,. i;It ;LYI i-L Z.:f U I L -- ;I 1 ^, ̂ d& î (ZJYI;i; Le ;nI J , f

G|~~ ~ ~~ iiU USi I L -j I |1 JI ,J * I - ,-;j ( * J V

a I-I4 1ELIQ *LeI ,,. .3: Z, r I -d

LL 1 I 1,5I Ild ;t? ;L

t * - :- J11) ,>JLY I L - L-l" *<9-J1 vW u4-t)d>lI Zi ......... Il

_~: c a ||d -JlU Li ~ 'Ud L L SDVI S

bL uulG1i--l zzu s* -- 51i 13I U Y I !JLli LP* J l- L , 1 aU; 1l

4zj -L-| I ; L;~ IJ L. 51 I5

-Zs :l ;W UI i---- J ... e1>J2 = SDI

G,. Li_l-41 1 ltg :J -L L= ;aul uUt; L. .. . | I ,-, |.- I JS1 j

* 5Li i p ; 1d ZJ Ie L, - 4cJL

I

W.W. Rostow **4 * 5i1, cs9l tlrAll w v (I)lil!&,1-1OY 8

IIjL.IM L;i ,l l ;lI ,.JI 41 tiS 6iU. (WW) Rashid and Town-) L;I ; iUi3,V11 U I.Fi.*

cd -vI (Ne -) Prebisch 5 5iI1 .S -(0k .send

qLL1S -- J l <5ts,:p 1JI.*Q ,,,P1f;L^L -#L 11 X.1a1 e;.sL

. i-s .... b C 31elb _4 L-i tizjA .; 1i0

Hoff and Stiglitz ,L.i (JiJ ,"I Jl 6_ , (A) L,i 1GI ..U ; _ JIL * --1. . _; 5.± Li M_*LL

laiU aiJlJ ;.II,;1W; "i Le Y I 'J L;-Yl , (MTs) v ;1 v1 t 1v.Y

<i 4., vj LI ,11 i,1ILI ,II J,._31I _IV. OJI JLJ Y Gonzalez-Vega 1d3 (r)

YiI l -L. &j6 -,U 1 vI ,L YI Credit Ration- Zi y1 ,un ,w ..........V ,

li,; Z wL,V1;YI'L J UIL,S i LZ ing Behavior of Agricultural Lenders: The Iron Law

J L o o-zldo>iL[ JLe * 'L - Ct-Lj t 1i .,i ill l,ii of Interest Rate Restrictions"

LA_UiI Z.ULI _ii =I I LiLj JcLvy_I - .Adams, Graham, and Von Pischke

_i L sLII , LisI ,&A Z l U JI v ,l ., rJ 1iI -II , 11I U1 . JlI oY I - (£ )

. I,!" @ c.-11 L E jLL1 _,,- L4 I>l u.. SIL ;I L j eA S c jlJ I:W L *

;-,WI ,W-'A L,,) ~,= L .jI i ~-J ZU' J-:iI Z,-JXLtj ~ ~ Ut.. Y_;.L.~t A ... j_

.l;LII 1 ,k , JI VL ; _U I V JI3. V UL. OLiL. 'LU tt f

V° I;LWI Li Z-I < I 1UI Jti JS; A:ij JL-I . i__jIj .~I aLLL_J I ai tl ZIJ 1 C, -;-,I I Z.

U'oD oIL- *-1S C J.L±ll ly 4e( YL IY) GU-;i Lvi;IL ~.-L.L .;L.II ~3.1;91; 3, ;':U jI..j 3I4U'O U'&= LI WA ::L U'

1 i,.. JAJi b4 -A I .LI C I,y JI *.LL.I jU I Jul !., .. 4. Y

LLkYI~ U~ 1 ,. vLai FiIL6 .J ilI ji. U' I. .., qlUI 4 JJjrLxWl>JYI 5 :1O

oSI~~L; LH 5^......S >D(LLI) 1ijII Z,LG lY ojll ,:L ,i. -qt;l ,&I,; ,l;ll ,5-i .U

,¢E~~~~~~~~ uk IsDli ,1tMS 1va- jA f.; J L kC- UI1, .

ol- U.11.J[I: i5 <o>;il JeL.L>) Lci :"i LA 1 1 il- .J ,kLI .L 31

~.J v °oI I1 S1 I1 ;-,I I O' i1 6_,Lp, _j LJ1 IU sIl

LLLie2 4e St9(I9 ; 19 I EF 11513 LII ,1_J .6 kIy :J -Ud' Z," loligv-

I o 1i Uj C ;I Lo_Y I Li ;S_ LoI +J;I L u>1 -::4 Ai I

z Phelan ul.i +J j ILIII ,,i ,1I (I AE) Townsend t JIJl , I L ;iL ol ,..il *iJ

.3iL;D,-) C:LI ~ Ik; Ll -ik C= EaA; JY (Zy L9; ;L;(11 yJjl^;l JJL-I tiJLU

.(iL I ArI LLI; I ,p ,J I -1- IIrj*!T A ':S U \\

.(8wrY)Sen 3 i(Vs5.)Besley and Kanbur ,i,S, .s .r ; ... f) I L <JI cLL -

Subba- ,,11 ,1,.u 1- k Lz t )iW JY 5I11J s

.( 1) rao, Ahmed, and Teklu * , G , L iLI (\ )

i11 Jl ' ;20 uly-- 41.3- 6Uk jS UL 1 L'i Zs1 j!( - V(Ij rC@ jt ;J 'I t^& 1;s 14 L IeLlLL

aul !mE Ramey and Ramey) .,Js ., -UI -- L ,; - SF -f.;L ;j VH V- 3LdI J

L..~IVI ~ oL ,J1 ;loI v* ,, dL li .(8ao IDB Giovennini and de,, f(IA) Bencivenga and Smith

JIjLiI ; 1 3. 1 ,1L4l Id 1Ui , Y u.i .(v4A'r) King and Levine, !()4AT) Melo

L. -~ I ,...;. I .. -1;s1- LA L-;1 a I L-a I (%£

S 2 Fs-s[ ,pX u ̂-Y~~~~L l 1|" A L.;IJ ;;K1. Y- )c otl-a ;dlv. i - jloA I

ZL-Zl1A a S L,Ji 1..1 -oit -- l

Isham and Kaufmann LJ^1Ij.,2Wi, (Tx) -Jv s .III

'o;' '1 ' VL;.1 Vl V°J 'fiLS>(\°

tjjJ- ) L JI . L I Z. I i _ (vr) L+ .. JII 4f II L,,&... I

.SW1~~j3- 1;I JU;I LlJ 0,: IL *ia tLl I Z,. (YY)j .clY I= tkQill<A Ui ,-tl r-> 6, 6-OL

Goldin and Knudsen j!mr .Bautista and Valdes 'fIA'kl I " o LA; 4 i 3 sJ 3 I Ui 4oLJiw OLiI .

v Jl JL I Ji oL Ii - La=il Li ( I 1 i Ls jlJl v .oiII Lil l ,.i ae11

UK-Y -AiI JL " L3 I 1 L. L iaiI i G 1 °4Ii- M A I; cil IM Li v

>.e~~Z.= 1 LIO,.434lINJUl L J i li l dL= ltS Lil E i 4 e-

,,j(II .Chaves and Sanchez A.S c ,Mul jl)

.4 LS l 4-*)IJ± w : 4 : #, I,t .1•S1 tU u~1 Lll ZMLJ 'LI 4? -- gt o• ILi .L.A i 4 \

Binswanger, !I5v .Berry and Cline) L,4 Z _-l J 0 , I a L ;j I o L.JI V4 J I

.Binswanger, and Thirtle !tr.Deninger and Feder i.i;1L.iI 495I 1;!I ILI3 i - II YI

II- ,k JLun.I ,L. Phelan and Townsend dia v-Lt , 4 %I-1 (VN)

L- 1i L1i * .1 ..i1i:,II j (Yr) L..Ld l * vW ..1 1,l I OLY,II .v

J.,kj L. . oY Ij I {,L.41:XY I ) I L J L J o ,,1 > U. 4-.i d 4 .:I

o3 IliSll ISLli e oLI Yi Li . LlJ I L,11 Phelan d 3 I L.Ls V 7aLdJI !A , .J*;4L

L,i L-= I 0 lI LLtiiJIl - - L.t..il sI,4{ o.L"iI e lii-j cs. 1 .wiiand Townsend

0-;.L.U Ilt.j I R,ah id a i d4J L.L -lil vI L".a

* Wi' Rashid and .Jl'I ,~L G LA niJ .J1i v

*l;1Jol A' JI v vi I

dl,.6l :Y" t~liil '1 C .1 5: 1>11 A j-Vi JI <-M .?,11 K1Jl t- I I La -1Ii-a 4ei.Y; 5 ;LA - 9J(o

.i.iL; II L'I ,n.,1: I Thomas and Nash 4 JI ,,1 , ,L

.(%AAoj NATY) Hazell 4- L. p .... 1i A IzI.A l,I (Tx) .Qi5A8)

r Vll SE i ZVLL _.I ('rv) e r L bis fiil, J LJI* si. (VN)

L I.j I -, t I I .rL.J I u L5 -J .I1 .; i , UM eyw*ov i Lj I- I *YI cL4n l.4 LL (iV) I l J 1 I IoLjLlI ,1~ "o,k el,1 LS 4-e5 ZLSA C,I ,> ecJ-s-1 . i-*illJl

A iA51l all,55 lL I LL,II

.(V .Roberts and Dick) _1 t- VA ' IjU VA (LUI _5 N*Y JL !XLl LA .i , raZ£ U:eji Z !L'A

.T) .L2 iAii Li• ,1LJ VUiLI ; L(I -; 1 ,jUVI ;Ir .fJ -JI J,'I Yl *it1

;, -U. 4 I JU.,I pZ L- j bi ,iI ta-l L.:?J .4ii _L 1 .JJ ,I JL

.(~T) ariro an Mcaugto , WA)Moud i&~ ~ii..L Ll ,1LILa JZ..j J,. (aT Sen _Jji .UILk(T

ZL.J* J ( i'1 L oL, V. 'LgVI ;k Y*.tl ) 'i;UI =I.)

_J4L V L-II S L-I Z1 j L , S ..l LI 1 J JA .i li ( r £) 3LsiV ,ia .yl JI - * jll / ,,tj l 1) vt,..1 UL M: n L, ,l1 -.1 ii , I.LI ctL.Heywood FleisigA jIl uliI (YY)

.(VNANi Heywood,,^,jK s A ?,5ey>;l _ id. oll II Y ,1 l

(r;1 1 JIo) Le A5 ,L; L" (rO i v1:tv 5*Nu ria de la Pena, Fliei si g

V°L;j i ZliaUIo;,LI t51^L JLI ,J- ?." . J11 vL; 'lI~ d HL ".-O1 IjlA L,.i Z?t oI LYI iit5 iOA

J-g _,- W I Z L'? L ;I.if ;Llv ,SoY ;LLJD JUI E11.1 L-L;I 3_-L v (YA)

lLll~1 k6 ;!L;I j" i ;iL6. L_L.: >.W Li C.!- VI L;_,"JJ i I 5 L-.L I L1 UL^;IfI J. o,RA

.( N Y .Ya ron) S d Lj 1x .- 1,;1 JLA 6 1 I L . i4z-;U I L sIi -1.1 a,5:- I v1 J 1 .6 J l

-s1° -I L+t 49. dl 1 *L YI jAcUSc 'I JAL, puI clr 1. i@ N.)

5)~~~~~~~sl ;LSII . -- i U Lo] ci L A.Ia 11 A1 &UIJ=IOjAA(J l.o5Z1 A

E Lojl_,LLI ,i :Ljl ilJUI iLL,lI AI;#4l LAL-I vi:lial ; -. 1LW Z LL.oj.4 &U .l>Iee

LIIU LciiLlI Lfl~ &L Z1 l ' eJ[-* L-¢!* 8

- LL,*(i Nki 8s£) Y aro n ; I_JJ jjt - l 1 ;A ? | (Irv)i A L.4lI -,;J I i,. J1* , J

. ilI U L-S9A I 1 v_~ oU I IA ajA- LL , I LL ;..Li 6..':

. 5)Barltrop and McNaughton J .( Nlkl) Mouid _; ,iL i La5 j. ( 10Sn i*-S Y

D2 , i A raj uJA (rA) Z- U s JI I~W t L;oY I Ll Il -Uy- {Lx laA

I Va9 L-4ii-l ;j Li-A U--_ UJlI ,,X 1 4i| 1 Z,. aa * L.: I DL il . I - I L,. i .J

; ¢^LWI Z I .!A;l.±j ll J VI; J;K , L A'A A 14a iA 1i- -j I

-LJS tt- Lsi C:L i:l L1 'i *-j _l ZK-L (T5) *RJI t ;Zl1 I

Z,1 U i t'-YL i ,J] LL i2U vL)1 Z- A JiL- ;,-iAl J:i I j.1 sIL (r *)

v zt;! IA eLL Li J_U^; y-:i i- L 31 LUj1 A-P i l -ilg jaL 1 L,: & Ldf r L < 1CLY (JULII

QB1;1 i), zX- LJ I yiOL '' 1i bA . I J YLIii SL:l -iA 911'885T¢S Y W 1, Nl 'N i- 134 ~1 VA09

jj iU MJ o;) .uLill - 4e Bennett, Goldberg, and Chit nj *-Aderon'I' J?i

L i11 ufÎII c l- .ia.L ..................... 1~ .(D1 Sacay Rhadaar andI vAgabIin l , J;

*MS;J~ULI 1+1----1i.I . J L~ Bi-UD)l;li (S.)?Sle2 L- >?ylJi4tyl54 .±J.....................>I&U 1

Graee1Bnk:1~)* 4 J1ji --;J e Y &1B1 ;vlt IjJ LI .ijI L L JJ l ,LI i asS uiJ 4g

handke J,. 6alL (o) Prolrm a,nd SusIinablityI *:lt >1o,Ij1 JI -1 ,J1

; u I "i4 * 1_. I L" I I, ui 1j, ; , K.hBn,net, Gold) Garoneer ,g, .(r ss

* Alill J s vi l iUJ .(0;a) aIt a Khnte

aJl-- ii ,, _A ,1 6 , 9I o 1 UlA s.l• I 11 a L. t_I IJ l.; I. 1Lji M JU 1 r(L

4I ,U 4 y;ll . jl . LU Saay Rana, and, ) 1ol1 LfL;IJ L; 11 Y

-LS," A - J - ,.! - L.L L.~- wu I vv.4 YarJ n 4 L, 3 -1f ;.L ~J-lI Iak ?.Ij1I (fLvi

IZJ I_jI oLj. l; II_JI 1.L- L4:I; 111I L (oI ) *(I 5j)Sacay, Rhandawar, and Agabinvj

L;jI ~L~I '~- It', U,itL4i Z- 1iI L.LI_U JLI .J t~ ~lUI~ riV~(

_;1LltJ CL;0-hj L,- LF;i ,I Lrj- ;RF rAL; 15, *XTll:I 4A *j]1 _&s _l (££

.;JIUI C JW AJi L3U I L f L._,* (B R 1 -U D) L I (Ljji) 0l -i*i;Y I * -- * 41

Grameen Bank:., W11i1 > (° Y) Jl OASJI I;I,II ¢ i,,l>a

rtjI .j,V~ k.J Ji ,1 La,.! jU_V L ?,) ~>

Khandker, Khalily,) .Performance and Sustainability O '% 85o),JI 'L1

,L 1.I J.1 .:; L-. ( J1 .iU1LVIand Khan '8 Y " -

;l .JUI L.-"-, LjIJ YJL.II V LVI -- ;l ll Khandker, j (85Or) Grameen Bank , -(JLW) sons

L-A jla ?.1 ,,_ -Ju LA. l :A ; YI laA Je * 0 .Khalily, and Khan

L[._ L :. <LLdV,;YUDI QI*j! JlA i Y tlj L M>JLJI 4L- , .IJ I c.OL;fII4;lCIj * 1 1 I r[,: l JILY' (£n)

J1_ A, ;- J JUI,1 ,j. HI U_.J1w VA X1- .>? ,4 1 4,JI 1 UI- LA' )I 4-6 5JI Je u ,)L.

BJI Li ILY- dl; l I (5; Q1,1 L OL,e;, 1g ,LI Sacay, Rhandawar, and) U_v_1 J3L =U;I L'J I, 1.

,51 LA , -1l LI Jl ZYI Z,.Jl ^-(%1 4;w1 A (5 .gabin

.,L;1Ij UA L L;LJJ Ij ,,;11~, Jl I JL. : L J UI L,S7 -, .i;UI L' r. 1a L_L ,LI:L M, (V

J,S L5_ L S - u I Lri >7 Z_JI 6S Ik J-" 1J L ;*;I 2-41 1-JD L.-l RIFI EAMlYIi-IL= I

v U,Jl o:Il ii.All -e~v*.Ufel Sacay, Rhan- I; LiLf: cEl6UI ,i Y 4 ;,IaYI ,L F., vl

SUIJIJ L Z6L ejI '1.JLlavl-ll Lsl .(8smt . dawae, and Agabin

Is 'I Yl J 1 ;1 LS -I 'L"lv JJ; EL A qL 1U JLl;t I ji__ J bUI oilJ UYI oijl.SiI~ f (£A)

.&"IYB s ,L- :uL Jul L>7DMi *JUI KJ :iL$ l ---L jYI ee A IA vfil .LiXs4

a v U 1 3.Jl.9............ 9- LA >l Iy ?.=......JY I :85 8-e e.Ll t........... )° jJY ........ -- tl .1

~.malI rL JU LZ-Y I LI.i 1 e5 ; .?11I LkJL Ukli I r_L uLl 4 )Y ._~ I TV -A 1

U iJ*L- Liet1 JJZ .1i5 1J." LS L-11 ?."I vLi) Js \8

ak S'11 - f1uI Li L Z,- *( 1L;YI Ja -1 S 7

JLY Li!2 &U I-a JuYZ;lil ez-l > oi a ° $-

al-Jul 1_l L'i 3_j l L Y I 1J ' JI V .....................i i Y :8 °.

-A 4

~ 3Z ii.

.) -

,, * - >-

3 ,-

I

j

I

ii

I

I

t?1L

Adams, Dale W., Douglas Graham, and J. D. Von Bell, Clive. 1988. "Credit Markets and Interlinked

Pischke. 1984. Undermining Rural Development Transactions." In Hollis Chenery and T. N.

withl Cheap Credit. Boulder, Colo.: Westview Srinivasan, eds., Handbook of Development Eco-

Press. nomics. Amnsterdam: North Holland.

Akerlof, George. 1984. An Economic 7heorist's Book Bencivenga, Valerie, and Bruce D. Smith. 1991.

of Tales: Essays That Entertain the Consequences of "Financial Intermediation and Endogenous

New Assurmptions in Economic Theory. New York- Growth." Reviewv of Economic Studies 58 (April):

Cambridge University Press. 195-209.

Aryeetey, Ernest, Hemamala Hettige, Machiko Benjamin, McDonald P., Jr. 1994. "Credit Schemes

Nissanke, and William F. Steel. 1997. Financial for Microenterprises: Motivation, Design and

Market Fragmnentation and Reformns in Sub-Saharan Viability." Ph.D. dissertation. Georgetown Uni-

Africa. World Bank Technical Paper 356. Wash- versity, Department of Economics, Washing-

ington, D.C. ton, D.C.

BAAC (Bank for Agriculture and Agricultural Co- Bennett, Lynn, and Mike Goldberg. 1993. Provid-

operatives). 1994. "Annual Report 1993." Bang- i7g Enterprise Devcelopment and Financial Seroices

kok, Thailand. to Women: A Decade of Bank Experience in Asia.

. 1995. "Annual Report 1994." Bangkok, World Bank Technical Paper 236. Washington,

Thailand. D.C.

Baer, Herbert, and Gerard Caprio. 1995. "Bank Bennett, Lynn, Mike Goldberg, and Pamela

Recapitalization: If and When." DEC Policy Hunte. 1996. "Ownership and Sustainability:

Review Note 2. World Bank, Policy Research Lessons on Group-Based Financial Services

Department, Finance and Private Sector Devel- from Five NGO's in South Asia." World Bank,

opment Division, Washington, D.C. Asia Technical Department, Human Resources

Baritrop, Chris, and Diana McNaughton. 1992. and Social Development Division, Washington,

Banking Institutions in Developing Markets. Vol.2, D.C.

Interpreting Financial Statemenits. Washington, Benoit, Phillipe. 1996. "Mitigating Project Risks-

D.C.: World Bank. World Bank Support for Govermment Guaran-

Barro, Robert J., and David B. Gordon. 1985. tees." Viewpoint 79, May.

"Rules, Discretion and Reputation in a Model of Berry, R. A., and W. R. Cline. 1979. Agrarian Struc-

Monetary Policy." NBER Working Paper 1079. tture and Productivity in Developing Countries.

National Bureau of Economic Research, Cam- Geneva: International Labour Office.

bridge, Mass. Besley, Timothy. 1994. "How Do Market Failures

Bautista, Rorneo, and Alberto Valdes. 1993. The Justifv Interventions in Rural Credit Markets?"

Bias against Agriculture: Trade and Macroeconomic World Bank Research Observer 9:27-48.

Policies in Developing CouLntries. San Francisco, Besley, Timothy, and Stephen Coate. 1995.

Cal: Intemational Center for Economnic Growth. "Group Lending, Repayment Incentives and

Social Collateral." Journal of Development Eco- Analysis of Successful Microfinance Pro-

nomics 46 (February): 1-18. grams." USAID Program and Operations

Beslev, Timothy, and Ravi Kanbur. 1990. "The Prin- Assessment Report 10. United States Agency

ciples of Targeting." Policy Research Working for International Development, Washington,

Paper No. 385. World Bank, Office of the Re- D.C.search Administrator, Washington, D.C. Corden, Max. 1989. "Macroeconomnic Adjustment

Binswanger, Hans, and Mark Rosenzweig. 1989. in Developing Countries." World Bank Research

"Wealth, Weather, Risk, and the Composition Observer 4 (1): 51-64.

of Agricultural Credit Investments." World Cuevas, Carlos E., and Douglas H. Graham. 1984.

Bank, Latin America and Caribbean Countrv "Agricultural Lending Costs in Honduras." In

Department, Agriculture Operations Division, Adams, Graham, and Von Pischke, eds., Under-

Washington, D.C. mining Rural Development with Cheap Credit.

Binswanger, Hans, Klaus Deininger, and Gershon Boulder, Colo.: Westview Press.

Feder. 1993. "Power, Distortions, Revolt, and Dale, Richard. 1982. "Issues in Bank Supervision

Reforrn in Agricultural Land Relations." Policv around the World." The World of Banking (Sep-

Research Working Paper 1164. World Bank, tember-October): 14-24.Latin America and the Caribbean Technical De- David, Cristina, and Richard Meyer. 1984. "Meas-

partment and Agriculture and Rural Develop- uring the Farm-Level Impact of Agricultural

ment Department. Washington, D.C. Loans." In J.D. Von Pischke, Dale Adams, and

Binswanger, Hans, and Shahidur Khandker. 1995. Gordon Donald, eds., Rural Financial Markets in

"The Impact of Formal Finance on the Rural Developing Countries. Baltimore, Md.: Johns

Economy of India." Journal of Developmnent Stud- Hopkins University Press.

ies 32 (2): 234-62. Demirguic-Kunt, Ashi, and Vojislav Maksimovic.

Branch, Brian, and David Richardson. 1995. "Re- 1996. "Financial Constraints, Uses of Funds,

tooling Credit Unions in Guatemala." Paper on and Firm Growth: An International Compari-

a World Council of Credit Unions project pre- son." Policy Research Working Paper 1671.

sented at the Sustainable Banking with the Poor World Bank, Policy Research Department, Fi-

Seminar Series, October 19, World Bank, Wash- nance and Private Sector Development Divi-

ington, D.C. sion, Washington, D.C.Caprio, Gerard, Izak Atiyas, and James Hansen. Edgcomb, Elaine L., and James Cawley. 1994. "The

1994. Financial Reform: Tiheory and Experience. Process of Institutional Development: Assisting

New York: Cambridge Universitv Press. Small Enterprise Institutions to Become More

Chaves, Rodrigo, and Caudio Gonzalez-Vega. Effective." In Maria Otero and Elisabeth Rhvne,

1994. "Principles of Regulation and Prudential eds., The New World of Microenterprise Finance.

Supervision and Their Relevance for Microen- West Hartford, Conn.: Kumarian Press.

terprise Finance Organizations." In Maria Otero T7e Economist. 1995. "A Matter of Title." December 9.

and Elisabeth Rhyne, eds., The NI;ew World of _. 1996. "South African Finance: Not a For-

Microenterprise Finaance. West Hartford, Conn.: mality." January 13.

Kumarian Press. EBRD (European Bank for Reconstruction and De-

- . 1996. "The Design of Successful Rural Fi- velopment). 1995. Transition Report. London.

nancial Intermediaries: Evidence from Indone- Farah, Douglas. 1996. "Satellites Solve Salvadoran

sia." World DevGelopmnent 24: 65-78. Farm Disputes." Washington Post. July 14.

Chaves, Rodrigo, and Susanna Sanchez. 1995. Fleisig, Heywood, and Nuria de la Pefia. 1996.

"Mexico: Rural Financial Markets." Report "Creating a Legal and Regulatory Framework

14599-ME. World Bank, Latin America and the to Promote Access to Rural Credit." Center for

Caribbean, Country Departnent II, Natural Re- the Economic Analysis of Law, Washington,

sources and Rural Poverty Division, Washing- D.C.ton, D.C. FAO (Food and Agriculture Organization of the

Christen, Robert, Elisabeth Rhyne, Robert Vogel, United Nations). 1992. Crop Insurance Comzpen-

and Cressida McKean. 1995. "Maximizing the diumz 1991. Rome: Agricultural Services Divi-

Outreach of Microenterprise Finance: An sion, Marketing and Credit Service.

Giovanrnini, Alberto, and Martha de Melo. 1993. lMvfF (Intemational Monetarv Fund). 1993. In terna-

"Government Revenue from Financial Repres- tional Capital Markets: Systcnmic Issues in Internta-

sion." American Economic Re-view 83: 953-63. tional Finance. Washington, D.C.

Gibbons, David S. 1992. The Grameen Reader. Isham, Jonathan, and Daniel Kauffmann. 1995.

Dhaka, Bangladesh. "The Forgotten Rationale for Policy Reform: The

Goldin, Ian, and Odin Knudsen. 1990. Agricultural Productivity of Investnent Projects." Policy

Trade Liberalizationi: Implications for Developing Research Working Paper 1549. World Bank, Euro-

Countries. Paris: Organisation for Economic Co- pean and Central Asaran Country Department IV,

operation and Development. Regional Mission in Kiev, Washington, D.C.

Gonzalez-Vega, Claudio. 1984. "Credit-Rationing Jaramillo, Fidel, Fabio Schiantarelli, and An-

Behavior of Agricultural Lenders: The Iron Law drew Weiss. 1993. "The Effect of Financial

of Interest Rate Restrictions." In Adams, Gra- Liberalization on the Allocation of Credit:

ham, and Von Pischke, eds., Undermining Rural Panel Data Evidence for Ecuador." Policy Re-

Development witl Cheap Credit. search Working Paper 1092. World Bank,

Grameen Bank. 1993. Annual Report for 1993. Country Economics Department, Washing-

Dhaka, Bangladesh. ton, D.C.

Greenwald, Bruce, and Joseph Stiglitz. 1986. Ex- Khan, Azizur Rahmah. 1977. Poverty and Landless-

temalities in Economies with Imperfect Infor- ness in Rural Asia. Geneva: The International

mation and Incomplete Markets." Quarterly Labour Office.

Journal of Economics Cl (2): 229-64. Khan, Mohsin, and Malcolm Knight. 1982. "Some

Guasch, J. Luis, and Thomas Glaessner. 1992. Theoretical and Empirical Issues Relating to

"Auctioning Credit." Vol. I, Conceptual Issues. Economic Stabilization in Developing Coun-

Regional Studies Program Report 15. World tries." World Developmnent 10: 709-30.

Bank, Latin America and the Caribbean Techni- Khandker, Shahidur, Baqui Khalily, and Zahed

cal Department, Washington, D.C. Khan. 1995. Grameen Bank: Perforfrance and Sus-

Gurand, Marc, Glenn Pederson, and Jacob Yaron. tainability. World Bank Discussion Paper 306.

1994. Outreach and Sustainability of Six Rural Fi- Washington, D.C.

nance Institutions in Sub-Saharan Africa. World King, Robert, and Ross Levine. 1993. "Finance and

Bank Discussion Paper 248. Washington, D.C. Growth: Schumpeter Might Be Right." Quar-

Hazell, Peter. 1992. "The Appropriate Role of Ag- terly Journal of Economics 108: 717-37.

ricultural Insurance in Developing Countries." Knudsen, Odin, and John Nash. 1990. Redefining

Joutnral of International De-.elopment 4(6): 567-81. the Role of Government in Agriculture for the 1990s.

. 1995. "Managing Default Risks in Rural World Bank Discussion Paper 105. Washington,

Finance: The Experience with Credit Insurance D.C.

Programs." Paper presented at the Workshop Krahnen, J. P., and Reinhard H. Schmnidt. 1995.

on Finance against Poverty, March 27-28, Read- Development and Finance as Institution Butilding:

ing University, United Kingdom. A New Approach to Poverty-Oriented Banking.

Hoff, Karla, and Joseph Stiglitz. 1993. "Theorv of Boulder, Colo.: Westview Press.

Imperfect Competition in Rural CreditMarkets in Ladman, Jerrv, and Ronald Tinnermeier. 1984.

Developing Countries." Institute for Policv Re- "The Political Economv of Agricultural Credit

form, Working Paper Series 49. Washington, D.C. The Case of Bolivia." In Adams, Graham, and

Hulme, David, and Paul Mosley. 1996. Finance Von Pischke, eds., Undermining R10n17 Develop-

against Poverty. London: Routledge. ment with Cheap Credit.

Huppi, Monica, and Gershon Feder. 1990. "The Levine, Ross. 1994. "Does the Financial Svstem

Role of Groups and Credit Cooperatives in Ru- Matter?" World Bank, Policy Research Depart-

ral Lending." World Bank Research Obser-ver 5 ment, Finance andPrivate Sector Development

(July): 187-204. Division, Washington, D.C.

IDB (Inter-American Development Bank). 1995. Levitsky, Jacob, and Ranga Prasad. 1989. Credit

Economic and Social Progress in Latin A77erica2: Guearantee Schemes for Small and Medi1m77 Enter-

Ov ercoming Volatility. Baltimore, Md.: Johns prises. World Bank Technical Paper 5S. Wash-

Hopkins University Press. ington, D.C.

Mahajan, Vijay, and Bharti Gupta Ramola. 1996. Urited Nations Department of Economnic Af-"Financial Services for the Rural Poor and fairs, Economic Conmmission on Latin America.Women in India: Access and Sustainabilitv." Ramey, Garey, and Valerie Ramey. 1994. "Cross-Jountal of International Development 8(2): 211-24. Country Evidence on the Link between Volatil-

McLean, Douglas, and Matthew Gamser. 1995. itv and Growth." NBER Working Paper 3755."Hi-Tech at the Frontier: Reducing the Transac- National Bureau of Economic Research, Cam-tion Cost of Lending in Swaziland with the bridge, Mass.SmartCard." Presentation delivered at the Sus- Ramola, Bharti, and Vijay Mahajan. 1996. "Finan-tainable Banking with the Poor Seminar Series, cial Services for the Rural Poor and Women inOctober 11, Washington, D.C., World Bank. India: Policy Issues on Access and Sustainabil-

McNaughton, Diana. 1992. "Banking Institutions itv." Sustainable Banking with the Poor Occa-in Developing Markets." Vol. I, Building Strong sional Paper 6. World Bank, Washington, D.C.Management and Responding to Change. World Rashid, Mansoora, and Robert Townsend. 1994.Bank, Washington, D.C. "Targeting, Credit and Insurance: Efficiency,

Meyer, Richard, and Geetha Nagarajan. 1996. Mechanism Design and Program Evaluation.""Credit Guarantee Schemes for Developing ESP Discussion Paper 47. World Bank. Wash-Countries: Theory, Design, and Evaluation." ington, D.C.United States Agency for Intemational Develop- Rav, Anandarup. 1995. "Directed Credit." DECment, Office of Economic and Institutional Re- Policy Review Note 1. World Bank, Develop-form, Center for Economic Growth, Washington, ment Economnics Vice Presidency, Washington,D.C. D.C.

Mills, Cadman Atta, and Raj NalLari. 1992 Analytical Rees, Ray. 1985a. "The Theory of Principal andApproaches to Stabilization and Adjustment Pro- Agent, Part 1." Bulletin of Economic Research 37grams. Economic Development Institute Semni- (1): 3-26.nar Paper 44. Washington, D.C.: World Bank . 1985b. "The Theory of Principal and

Mould, M. C. 1991. Financial Information for Man- Agent, Part 2." Bulletin of Economic Researchagement of a Development Finance Institution. 37(2): 175-95.World Bank Technical Paper 63, Industry and Roberts, Richard, and W. J. A. Dick, eds. 1991.Finance Series. Washington, D.C. Strategies for Crop Insurance Planning. Rome:

Pederson, Glenn. 1997. The State of the Art in Mi- Food and Agriculture Organization of thecrofiniaince: A Summary of Theory and Practice. United Nations.Washington, D.C.: World Bank. Robinson, Marguerite S.1994. "Savings Mobiliza-

Philips, Louis. 1988. Thze Economics of Imperfect In- tion and Microenterprise Finance: The Indone-formation. New York: Cambridge Universitv sian Experience." In Maria Otero and ElisabethPress. Rhvne, eds., The New World of Microenterprise

Platteau, Jean-Philippe, and Anita Abraham. 1987. Finance. West Hartford, Conn.: Kumarian Press."An Inquiry into Quasi-Credit Contracts: The Rostow, W. W. 1963. The Economics of Take-Off intoRole of Reciprocal Credit and Interlinked Deals Sustained Growth; Proceedings of a Conference Heldin Small-Scale Fishing Communities." Journal of by the International Economic Association. Lon-De-velopment Studies 23:461-90. don: Macmillan.

Polizatto, Vincent. 1991. "Prudential Regulation Sacay, Orlando, Bikki Rhandawa, and Melizaand Banking Supervision: Building an Insti- Agabin. 1996. "The BAAC Success Story: A Spe-tutional Framework for Banks." In Philippe cialized Agricultural Bank under GovernmentCallier, ed., Financial 5ystems and De-elop- Ownership." World Bank, Financial Sector De-ment in Africa: Collected Papers from an EDI velopment Department, Washington, D.C.Policti Seminar held inz airobi, Kenya,from Janu- Schiff, Maurice, and Alberto Valdes. 1992. Theary 29 to Februany 1, 1990. Washington, D.C.: Plundering ofAgriculture in Developing Countries.World Bank. Washington, D.C.: World Bank.

Posner, Richard. 1981. Tlhe Eco;iomics of Justice. Schmidt, Reinhard H., artd Claus-Peter Zeitinger.Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press. 1996. "Prospects, Problems, and Potential of

Prebisch, Rauil. 1950. Thze Economic Developrment of Credit-Granting NGOs." Journal of IntemnationalLat!n America and Its Prinicipal Problems. New York. Development 8(2): 241-58.

xOr T-1

Schwvarz, Anna. 1992. "Effectiveness of Directed ture." World Bank, Agriculture and Natural

Credit Policies in the U.S.: A Survey of the Lit- Resources Department, Washington, D.C.

erature." WIorld Bank, Policy Research Depart- Varian, Hal. 1990. "Morntoring Agents with Other

ment, Finance and Private Sector Development Agents." Journal of International and Tiheoretical

Division, Washington, D.C. Economics 146 (1): 153-74.

Sen, Amartva. 1984. Resources, Values, and Develop- Virmani, Arvind. 1982. The Nature of Credit Markets

ment. Oxford: Blackwell. in Developing Countries: A Framnezvorkfor Policy

1992- "The Political Economy of Targeting." Analysis. World Bank Staff Working Paper 524.

Paper presented at the World Bank Conference on Washington, D.C.

Public Expenditures and the Poor: Incidence and Vogel, Robert. 1984. "Savings Mobili7ation: The

Targeting, June 17-19, Washington, D.C. Forgotten Half of Rural Finance." In Adams,

Squire, Lvn. 1995. "What We Expect from a Bank Graham, and Von Pischke, eds., Undermining

Project: The Rural Finance Context." Seminar Rural Development with Cheap Credit.

presentation at the World Bank, December 8, Von Pischke, J. D. 1991. Finance at the Frontier: Debt

Washington, D.C. Capacity and the Role of Credit in the Private Econ-

Steams, Katherine. 1993. Leverage or Loss: Guaran- omy. Washington, D.C.: World Bank.

tee Funds and Microenterprise. Washington, D.C.: Von Pischke, J. D., and Dale W. Adams. 1980.

ACCION Intemational. "Fungibility and the Design and Evaluation of

Stiglitz, Joseph. 1993. "The Role of the State in Agricultural Credit Projects." American Journal

Financial Markets." Proceedings of World Bank of Agricultural Economics 62(4): 719-26.

Annual Conference on Development Economics. WWB (Women's World Banking). 1995. "The

Washington, D.C. Missing Links: Financial Systems That Work

Stiglitz, Joseph, and Andrea Weiss. 1981. "Credit for the Majority." Report on Women's World

Rationing in Markets with Imperfect Informa- Banking Global Policy Forum, April, New

tion." American Economic Review 71(3): 393- York.

410. World Bank. 1989. World Development Report 1989:

-. 1983. "Incentive Effects of Terminations: Financial Systems and Development. New York:

Applications to the Credit and Labour Mar- Oxford University Press.

kets." American Economic Review 73(5): 912-27. . 1990. World Devoelopment Report 1990: Pov-

Subbarao, Kalaniidhi, Akhter Ahnmed, and Tesfaye erty. New York: Oxford University Press.

Teklu. 1996. Selected Social Safety Net Programs in . 1991. World Development Report 1991: The

the Philippines: Targeting, Cost-Effectiveness and Challenge of Development. New York: Oxford

Optionssfor Reform. World Bank Discussion Pa- University Press.

per 317. Washington, D.C. . 1992. "Effective Implementation: Key to

Thomas, Vinod, and John Nash, with Sebastian Development Impact." Report of the Portfolio

Edwards, Thomas Hutcheson, Donald Keesing, Management Task Force. Washington, D.C.

Kazi Matin, Garry Pursell and Alexander Yeats. . 1994a. World Deoelopment Report 1994: In-

Best Practices in Trade Policy Reform. 1991. New frastructure and Development. New York: Oxford

York: Oxford Universitv Press. 'University Press.

Tuck, Laura, and Jacob Yaron. 1996. "Rural Fi- . 1994b. "Management Response to OED:

nance in the Transition Economies of Central A Review of Bank Lending for Agricultural

and Eastern Europe." Paper presented at the Credit and Rural Finance." The Secretarv, Joint

Annual Meeting of the American Agricultural Audit Committee, January 5, Washington,

Econormics Association, ran Antonio, Tex. D.C.

Udrv, Christopher. 1990. "Credit Markets in _ 1994c. "Mexico: Agricultural Sector Memo-

Northern Nigeria: Credit as Insuranceina Rural randum." Latin America and the Carib-

Economy." The World BamzkEconomicReview4(3): bean, Countrv Department II, Natural Re-

251-69. sources and Rural Povertv Division, Washington,

van Zvl, Johan, Hans Binswanger, and Colin D.C.

Thir.le. 1994. "The Relationship between Farm - . 1994d. Global Economic Prospects and the

Size and Efficiencv in South African Agricul- Developing Countries 2994. Washington, D.C.

_ 1995a. Assessing Development Effectiveness: . 1995. "Performance Audit Report-

Evaluation in the World Bank and tze International Indonesia: BRI/Kupedes Small Credit ProjectFinance Corporation. Washington, D.C. (Loan 2800-nd)." Report 14511. Washington, D.C.

. 1995b. "The Use of Sectoral and Project Yarbrough, Beth, and Robert Yarbrough. 1991. The

Performance Indicators in Bank-Financial Sec- World Economy: Trade and Finantce. Chicago: Dry-tor Operations." Financial Sector Development den Press.Department, Washington, D.C. Yaron, Jacob. 1992a. Assessing Development Finance

. 1996a. "World Bank Collaboration with Institutions: A Public Interest Analysis. WorldNGOs." Gendernet 2(1). Bank Discussion Paper 174. Washington, D.C.

World Bank, Operations Evaluation Department. .1992b. Successful Rural Finance Institutions.1976. "Agricultural Credit Programs." Report World Bank Discussion Paper 150. Washington,1357. Washington, D.C. D.C.

. 1981. "Agricultural Credit Projects: A Re- . 1992c. "Rural Finance in Developingview of Recent Experience in India." Report Countries." Policy Research Working Paper3415. Washington, D.C. 875. World Bank, Agriculture and Natural Re-

- . 1983. "Annual Review of Project Perform- sources Department, Washington, D.C.ance Audit Results," Vol. 2, para. 5.150, Report . 1994a. "What Makes Rural Finance Insti-4720, September 16. Washington, D.C. tutions Successful?" World Bank Research Ob-

1993. "A Review of Bank Lending for server9(1):49-70.Agricultural Credit and Rural Finance (1948- . 1994b. "The Assessment and Measure-1992)." Report 12143. Washington, D.C. ment of Loan Collections and Loan Recovery."

. 1994. "An Overview of Monitoring and World Bank, Agriculture and Natural Re-

Evaluation in the Bank" Report 13247. sources Department, Washington, D.C.

I81S II St,.ct. NAV\\ ishingleton, D)C( 20>43311

TC10f011o: 202-4771-1234

Facsinillc: 202-477-6391

IdcIc: NMCI 64145 NVORLDIANH\Nk

\1(1 248423 \VORLI)I4ANK

WVorld Wid. W\.http:!/wwX8-.x orldh, ld.W-h

( aC)lCo() cIctl-(,ico: hooksw norldha,,k.norl

1 4 4 7 6ISBN 0-8213-4476-5

Documents

World Bank Document · SBP Sustainable Banking with the Poor vi,lJ LIi 5 -l JW i I 1.1I SDI subsidy dependence index #1 ,,L > - SECAL sectoral adjustment loan SLA savings and loan