Upload
others
View
4
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Fundedby:
Women’sEmpowermentinNutritionIndex(WENI):Measuringnutritionalempowermenttobetterlink
agriculturetonutrition
ErinLentz,UTAustin,USAJuly13,2017KathmanduInnovativeMetricsandMethodsfor
AgricultureandNutritionActions
ResearchTeam• ErinLentz,UniversityofTexas,Austin,USA• Sudha Narayanan,IndiraGandhiInstituteforDevelopmentResearch,Mumbai,India
• Marzia Fontana,IndependentResearcher,UK• CollaborativeResearchandDissemination,NewDelhi,India
• Bharati KulkarniNationalInstituteofNutrition,Hyderabad,India
• Sabarmatee,IndependentResearcher,India• withKrushna Ranaware,Ankita Mondal,UdayanRathore,Nirali Bakhla,andothers
• Civilsocietypartners
Women’sNutritionalEmpowerment
• Thecapacityforawoman,andnotjust herchildren,tobewellfedandhealthy;tohaveameaningfulsayinhouseholdnutritionalpractices;andtoreceivesupportinimplementingthem.– OurstartingpointisKabeer’s (1999)conceptualizationofempowerment:resources,agency,andachievements
Approach• Formativeresearchon“overlooked”factors– Reviewofliterature,surveys,andongoingquantitativework
– Communitybasedresearch(Paprocki andCons2014)toidentifyfactorsthatmayinfluencenutritionalempowerment
• GenerateWENIandvalidateWENI– Examineitsabilitytopredictnutritionalstatusofwomen(andtheirchildren)
Women’sNutritionalEmpowerment
Work
Structuralconditions,support,institutions
Nutritionaloutcomesofwomen(BMI,
Anemia)
Knowledge
Resources
Agency
IntermediateAchievements
DimensionsofEmpowerment Domains
Health(fertility)
Food
Achievements
UltimateAchievements
TBDwithquantitative
work
QuantitativeLiterature:FactorsinfluencingnutritioninSouthAsia
6
• Richliteratureexaminingundernutritionofchildren• ConsistentsetoffactorsinSouthAsia:
– Educationofparents(Headeyetal.2015)– Agriculture(mixed)(Kadiyala etal.2014)– Assetsandorincome(Headeyetal.2015)– Demographicfactors:Childgender(Rajetal.2015);birthintervaland
fertility(Coffey2015);rankwithinhouse(Coffeyetal.2017)– Empowerment(Chowdhuryetal.2013;Malapit etal.2015;
Cunninghametal.2015)– Servicesandinstitutions:(Gillespieetal.2017;Kohli etal.2017;
Nisbett etal.2017)– Sanitation:(CoffeyandSpears2017)– Maternalheight(Headeyetal.2015)– Domesticviolence(Yount etal.2011;Ziaei etal.2012)
Aim:Identify“overlooked”factors
7
• Quantitativeliteraturegetsatseveralissues,butdoesn’tcoverallaspects– Quantitativemodelsexplain~30%ofvarianceinstuntingratesand~50%ofimprovements(Headeyetal.2015)
– Manygoodreasonsforthis
• Arethere“overlooked”factorsthatinfluencenutritionalempowermentthatwomenthemselvesidentifyasimportant?
• Focushereonattributesnotcommonlyincludedinquantitativestudies
Method:CommunityResearch
8
Threesites:– Northern Bangladesh– Odisha,India– Bihar,IndiaNGOpartners:– Nijera Kori– Agragamee– PRADAN– Anwesha– Sambhav– JJSS
Method:CommunityResearch
9
• 4-5daysofresearchtrainingwithcommunityresearchers(seePaprocki andCons2014)– Researchethicsandaudiorecorders– Semi-structuredandopen-endedinterviewtechniquesfocusingonnutritionandsourcesoftensionwithintheirhouseholds
• Bangladesh:Conductedabout135interviewsin2districts
• Odisha:Conductedaround160interviewsin4districts
• Focusedonmarginalizedpopulations
Learnings:Structuralconditions,support,resources
10
• CommonpoolresourcesinOdisha– “IfoneSiali creepergrowsupthenwedestroyittomaketherope...In
thatwaySiali creepershavegraduallybeendepleted....So,wetookadecisionnottocollecttheplantsforthelasttwoyears.Asaresultofthis,thisyearsomewomenabletogetleaf.Lastyear,wewerenotabletoprepareasingleplateduetoshortageofleaves.”
– Womenfacevariableaccess;somewomenrelyonforestresourcesfordietarydiversity,forstitchingleafplates,etc.whilethisresourceisunavailabletoothers
• ArsenicingroundwaterinBangladesh– Apregnantrespondentexplainedthatherfamilyhasatubewell thathas
testedpositiveforarsenic,andhasa“red”tap,toindicateitiscontaminated.Nootheroffersofremediationweremade.Atthetimeoftheinterview,therespondent’sfamilycontinuedtodrinkfromitbecausetheycouldnotaffordtopurchasefiltersortodigadeeperwell,althoughtheyknewitisbadfortheirhealth.
– Optionstoavoidarsenicvarybyhousehold,dependingonneighborsetc.
Learnings:Intrahousehold variation
11
• Healthseekingbehavior– FromOdisha:“Wegiveprioritytothemalemembersofthehouseholdtobetaken
tohospitalbecauseiftheystayfreefromdisease,theywilllookafterus.Whenfemalemembersareill,mostlywestayathomeandtakehomeremediesorprocuremedicineslocally.”
• Foodallocation– FromBangladesh:“Iwouldservefoodfirsttomyhusbandbecausehewasgoing
towork,thentomyfather-in-lawandoldgrandmother-in-law.Then,Iusedtofeedmyyoungchildren.Thereafter,Iwouldtakemymeal.Sometimes,myfather-in-lawwouldcheckthecookingpottoseewhetherImighthavecookedmorerice.Ifhesawsomequantityriceinthepot,hescoldedmethatIhadhiddenriceformyown.Iwouldbearit,cryandremainsilent.”
• Domesticviolence– Already,researchlooksatnutritionoutcomesforchildren(seeYount etal.2011).– Here,womenexplainhowviolenceaffectstheirownnutrition– FromBangladesh:“The[restofthefamily]hadtheprivilegetoeatfirst.Afterall
werefinished,theleftoverpiecesweregiventome.Attimes,Ihadtoreturnmymother’shouseduetohunger....Iaskedmyhusbandtoworkasadaylaborertoearnmoremoneybutherefusedandassaultedme....Mymother-in-lawasked‘Whydoyoutalksomuch?’Ireplied,‘Ineedfoodtolive.’”
ImplicationsforWomen’sEmpowermentinNutrition
• Variationinstructuralconditions/support/resourcesacrosshouseholds– Unpackregionalordistrictfixedeffects– Capturenormsanddeviationsfromthem
• Intrahousehold factorsmeritmoreattention– Seasonalityisoftencapturedatthehouseholdlevel
• Forexample,thecopingstrategiesindex,ameasureoffoodinsecurity,askswhethermealsweremissed
• Weneedtoknowwhomissedthemeal.– Theconsequencesofseasonality,shocks,accesstohealthcare,environmentalchangearedifferentfor(young)womenthanothersinthesamehousehold(seealsoLANSAfindings)
Workahead
• Operationalizethesefindingsinquantitativesurveys– Nutritionaloutcomesofchildrenmaynotbereflectoutcomesforwomen
– Opportunitytoincorporatenormsandperceptions
• ConstructandvalidateWENI
Thankyouforyourtime!Questions?
Approach• Formativeresearchon“overlooked”factors– Reviewofliterature– Communitybasedresearch(Paprocki andCons2014)toidentifyfactorsthatmayinfluencenutritionalempowerment
– Quantitativeresearchtoidentifycandidatecomponents
– Assessingsurveycoverageofourconceptofnutritionalempowerment
• GenerateWENIandvalidateWENI– Examineitsabilitytopredictnutritionalstatusofwomen(andtheirchildren)
ResearchObjective
16
• DevelopaWomen’sEmpowermentinNutritionIndex(WENI)thatreflectsnutritionalempowermentofwomeninruralSouthAsia• BangladeshandIndia(Odisha andBihar),fornow• Ruralcontext,fornow
• Examineitsabilitytopredictnutritionalstatusofwomen(andtheirchildren)
Learnings:Intrahousehold variation
17
• Healthseekingbehavior– FromOdisha:“Wegiveprioritytothemalemembersofthehouseholdtobetakentohospitalbecauseiftheystayfreefromdisease,theywilllookafterus.Whenfemalemembersareill,mostlywestayathomeandtakehomeremediesorprocuremedicineslocally.”
• Foodallocation– FromBangladesh:“Iwouldservefoodfirsttomyhusbandbecausehewasgoingtowork,thentomyfather-in-lawandoldgrandmother-in-law.Then,Iusedtofeedmyyoungchildren.Thereafter,Iwouldtakemymeal.Sometimes,myfather-in-lawwouldcheckthecookingpottoseewhetherImighthavecookedmorerice.Ifhesawsomequantityriceinthepot,hescoldedmethatIhadhiddenriceformyown.Iwouldbearit,cryandremainsilent.”